Skip to main content
Loading video...

Justin Gary of Stone Blade Entertainment debuts Lord of the Rings: Ascension - TCbH Interview

Transcript 34:19

Hello and welcome to the Cardboard Herald podcast where we talk with creative gamers and game creators. My name is Eric joined right now by Justin Gary uh designer who I've brought up a number of times on the podcast uh designer of Ascension as well Ashards of Infinity, Soulforge Fusion and other games as well. Uh welcome in to the podcast. How are you doing today? Doing fantastic. Very excited to be here. Always love talking about games.

Yeah, so happy to have you on here and uh especially this month uh for TC BH we're doing expansion month in case you have missed it. I know that it's at the end of expansion month when this video is released. So, you have a lot of content to catch up on. Um but uh you're coming in uh with a lot of experience with uh designing expansions for board games. Um but before we get to that, I kind of want to start off just talking about a game that has caused uh great strife in my marriage. Uh is probably the game that my wife and I played the the most of uh and she definitely plays the most of cuz she will just play it on her phone in bed and beat a bot named Eric over and over again. Uh and that is Ascension. Uh it's been about 15 years since Ascension was first published and an additional 2 years from when you first actually started working on the game. So, uh obviously right now it's a massive hit.

Uh it is still selling pretty well. I still see it brought up a lot. We just had a number of you had the 10-year anniversary edition come out and there's uh Ascension Legends on the way. Um what is it about this game that you think helped it catch on? Yeah, so it's always hard to predict, right? I never launch a game and think this one's not going to be successful. Of course, I don't think all the games are going to be successful. And ironically when I first started working on Ascension, I was not trying to make a super successful game. I was making the game that I wanted to play with my friends, right? Obviously I I come from for those who know I come from a magic playing background. I was a US national champion when I was 17, went around and play uh in tournaments around the world and won a world team championships several years later. Like I was just, you know, deep in the weeds on that and and loved that space. And then when I saw uh Dominion, which was, you know, the kind of first deck building game concept which put the idea of a trading card game into a board game, right? So, you have the whole experience of building a deck and getting that joy without having to buy packs of cards and keep up with collections and all the things that come with, you know, I love trading card games but there's obviously a lot that comes with that. So, I love that idea and then there were just and I played a ton of it. So, huge kudos uh to that game. But I saw so many things that I wanted that it didn't do, right? And there were things that I I felt were like slowing the game process down and got in the way of the fun. And so, I just kind of for myself and for my friends, I just made a new version of it

that I thought would be really good and I kept refining and refining and the and the and the core innovation of the of the of Ascension and we'll get into this I think more as we talk about the concept of how you make expansions. But one of my philosophies on game design is you need to have you need to know what your core tension is. And what that means is there's one fundamental thing that ties your mechanics, your theme, your emotional impact to the player that's that differentiates you from everything that's come before. Mhm. And so, the idea whereas in Dominion, what you would at the beginning of the game set up the 12 different piles of like what created the market and there was a bunch of other fixed cards for the market. And that's like once that's set up, then you're just buying things and running through that process. And Ascension took the idea that like that's very static and once I played it a bunch of kind of got a little bit boring and I said, "What if we just created more variety throughout play?" So, we created the center row.

And that was the idea there's a centralized deck of cards that you deal out six cards at random and whenever you buy a card a new card shows up to replace it. Nobody had ever done that before. And that core [snorts] tension around what you wanted to have access to what's in the center row, but your opponent also has access to that same set of cards and maybe they'll get the cards you want before you and you're reacting to what they're doing. That That's the heart of Ascension and the fun that comes from that variety. I liken it to those that are familiar with trading card games, the two major ways to play are what's called constructed where you build a deck and you bring it to the to the game and then what's typically called limited where you at the event get a series of cards. So, maybe you draft the cards or open up a sealed pack and build your deck at the thing. And there's they're both fun, but the the the the joy of discovery and uncertainty of like drafting your cards at the event and the feeling that you're all on an even playing field, Ascension really captures that the heart of that better than any other game in a in a boxed, you know, traditional tabletop game experience. So, I think that while I was, you know, the philosophically the idea that I was making a game for me and my friends and it literally was just like my friends were like, "Dude, you have to make this.

Like you've got it." Like we just kept they kept wanting to play it over and over again, which is what I always look for. And then mechanically and like why it was the right thing at the right time is that, you know, the deck building genre had been discovered. We were the second deck building game on the market and we brought this major innovation that that core tension was a was something that people were hungry for beyond just me and my friends. Yeah, I mean obviously I thank you to your friends for pushing you to continue going with it. Uh it it absolutely is I think, you know, very wildly popular. I think the joy of the discovery and then the joy of just like trying to figure out how to make the your deck work based on what you have available is uh you know, it's so great. I I think that it really gets to a lot of core of what gamers are looking for in games. Um At what point did you realize that Ascension was going to get an expansion let alone multiple expansions?

Well, I you know, because I was just you know, so just again a little bit more backstory here. So, prior to working on Ascension, I was working at um Upper Deck uh this company in Southern California and I designed uh for the Versus System trading card game. I was the lead designer of the uh Infinite Crisis expansion and worked on a bunch of projects for several years. I then created the World of Warcraft miniatures game and I had built a uh you know, an entire you know, game with multiple expansions there. So, everything I'd worked on as a designer prior to Ascension was something that had a ton of expansions, was pre-planned to have a bunch of expansions. And so, when I quit that job to start my own company, I didn't really know what I was doing, but I was working on a variety of things. Ascension was one of them. And I had actually just built in my head 3 years worth of storyline and expansion content. And just kind of not fully designed, but like kind of ready, you know, in my head ready to go. And and and I And one of the things that I also teach designers and I really it was really important to my ethos is like you really want to be as elegant as you can be when you're building a a core game experience, right? When I when I talked in the last answer about your core tension, right? You need to know what your core tension is. And then everything that gets in the way of that core tension or distraction that core tension needs to be cut from your game.

And then those mechanics that you cut, they don't you don't have to think of them as being dead. They're really great fodder for expansions and for future content. And so, there were several mechanics that were in the base game of Ascension that I ended up cutting and they were sort of put into the expansion shelf. So, in terms of like design and concept, I had several years in my head uh you know, before we even, you know, got super serious about producing the game. Now, that I didn't do because I thought we were really going to make 3 years worth of content. That's crazy. There's no way that's going to happen. But instead I but I did it because it helped me kind of just structure my own thinking about how this game should live and how it should exist and what world it should like build the world building around Ascension was really cool for me at the time, too. Um so, I did all that stuff kind of uh again, mostly for fun, but I had a structure. And then, you know, I showed the game off uh at first at the at GAMA, which was a a trade show like an industry trade show and the response was really really positive. Like like, you know, distributors and retailers, everybody was like, "We want this, you know." And so, then I made what what was a a little bit of a risky financial decision. I basically put all my life savings into printing the first print run of Ascension, right? It's just like I don't really generally recommend people do, but I had gotten so much positive feedback. I'm like, "Okay, whatever." But then going to Gen Con where it's like our first opportunity to show it off and I'm like, "Wow, if this doesn't work, I'm going to have to build my house out of Ascension boxes." I literally like that's that's really much what's going to happen. So, you know, but then Gen Con it's one of the most magical experiences I've ever

had. Like it was just like not only we had a little booth in entrepreneurs' alley, you know, just a little little 10 by 10 and I I'd earned an extra 10 by 10 from submitting marketing plans as a scrappy young designer. And then when we would demo the game to people, they would then take the game, open it up and sit at a nearby table and just start demoing it to other people because they loved it so much. They would just like expand and I would like throughout the halls I would see the floors fill up with people playing it.

You know, it's just like one of those moments that was just so magical. I've had it like two or three times in my career. Uh but this was the first time it had ever happened and it was such an incredible moment. And then from there like we sold out of our entire print run before it hit the full run had hit. Like we air shipped copies in for Gen Con, sold out of everything we had at Gen Con. The rest of stuff was on a boat and it was already pre-sold before it even arrived. And so, that point it's like, "Okay, well, we're definitely doing an expansion." You know, and and [clears throat] you know, in retrospect it took a little longer than it should have. Like I should have probably had more of that ready to go, but it was so I just had so much on my plate. I'm starting a new company and trying to get this all done and I'd never done any of this stuff before. So like it took a while to like spool up and get the expansion out the door, but it was obviously at that point like okay, we've got a hit on our hands clearly.

We need to keep this moving and that was very exciting. Yeah, and I mean you've continued to design expansions for this game. Just a very quick loop backwards a little bit. Um was your process designing expansions for Ascension at the start different than your process when you were designing expansions for Versus just as like your starting point? Um yes, they're very different it's a very different thing to design an expansion for a TCG than it is to design an expansion for a uh a normal tabletop game um for one. Uh for two with the trading card game with Versus stuff it's it's a you know, it's a comic book characters battling thing. So it's very much a a top-down like start with the story. Okay, like what does Superman do in this situation? Like what is what is it like if Wolverine and Batman get into a fight which is by the way like 14-year-old me was like totally high-fiving you know, whatever 34-year-old me or whatever at the time.

Um uh so so the process there uh is a little bit different. You know, you're designing many many hundreds of cards. They have to fit in a different way like when you're building a TCG not only does it have to fit cohesively as a set on its own, but the cards have to support and iterate things from the past in very specific ways. You're designing for rarities uh and and you're having how you're opening up packs and chasing packs and there's a a lot of different like you actually want cards that are like better and worse and have a large you know, decent range so people have that joy of discovery or niche things that only work with certain cool side strategies. When you're building something like a deck-building game uh it's a little different. You have to you know, everything kind of has to work cohesively on its own. And to be perfectly honest, the idea of building it when I started the whole idea was each year of content two sets would be a cohesive like thing that's played together. So the original Ascension and and uh Return of the Fallen and then it was you know, Storm of Souls and Darkness Unleashed and or uh uh uh that's not the right name of that one. Anyway, the basics of the names all blur together now, but uh this idea that um uh that the ones would would come together and then uh uh Immortal Heroes, thank you. Storm of Souls and Immortal Heroes. I know I got there eventually. Um uh that those would play together and then most you would ever shuffle those two decks and then and so those those were designed to be synergistic and stand-alone.

I never imagined that people would be building and playing all of the decks together which because physically it's very inconvenient. It's very impractical. Then once we released the digital app, of course, it's just clicking a few buttons and the crazy [snorts] wild mode of all the sets mashing together and playing is actually quite quite a bit of fun. So uh so that that changed how I designed and developed sets going forward once I saw uh you know, what the app play experience was like and how that how that morphed. Um so there's a lot of different ways we could approach that that topic um but uh but in terms of like differentiations between expansions for a trading card game or collectible game versus a tabletop game, those are just kind of some of the different principles. Yeah, and uh as mentioned previously, you're still actually working on expansions uh at the time that this is being recorded. Uh we know that Ascension Legends is on the way um but by the time this is being posted, you've just made a big announcement uh for our viewers about Ascension. Do you want to talk about uh the big announcement?

Yeah, you're basically the first person I'm actually talking to about this outside of my company. So this is really cool because nobody knows about this at the moment we're having this conversation. So um Ascension, right? I've been working on it for you know, we have we have our 15-year anniversary this year uh which started at Gen Con last year and it'll go through Gen Con this year. And I wanted to make sure it was a really big year that we celebrated. For the 10th anniversary, we celebrated it by launching Ascension Tactics uh which was a miniatures-based, you know, tactical you know, tactical board game tied into the deck-building experience which nobody had done before. It was a great way to call back my personal background of having worked on miniatures games as well as TCGs and card games. So for 15th, we did a 15th anniversary district campaign which launched last summer. We did of course Ascension Legends which as you mentioned is fulfilling soon and we wanted but we wanted to do something special.

Something that we'd never done before. Something that would really transform what it means to play Ascension. And so what we've done is we have created the first ever licensed Ascension game. Woah.

license That's correct. And we didn't want to just pick any old license. You know, we're going to go we're going to have a licensed game for the first time. Let's go big. And so for the first time ever we're going to talk about The Lord of the Rings Ascension. Oh my goodness. I don't know if the audience can tell from my reaction. I am actually hearing about this live right now. That's amazing. Oh, that sounds so cool.

It It is the coolest thing of all time. And so I'm going to speak about this on a couple levels. So one, if anybody else is excited about this as we are, by the time this goes live, uh we'll be live on Game Found. Uh you can opt open follower pages. The campaign itself will not be launching until July, but the follower pages open and if you follow early, there's free goodies and you get early previews and all all that stuff. But what was so cool about this for me is you know, one of the reasons I loved working on Ascension and we built our own world, we built our own lore, we built our you know, the storyline is actually something I'm really proud of and it's a really cool thing that we've done and we haven't done a licensed game as Stoneblade Entertainment as my company Stoneblade though I worked on many many licenses outside of Stoneblade. Uh and so when I'm working on a new expansion and this was I think it'll tie into the topic of your thing, right? It's like what how why do I keep doing this, right? I have plenty of other games I could make. I have plenty of other things I could work on. What keeps when I'm working on expansion 17, 18, 19 of a game?

I need to be entertained. I need to care. Like I need to be excited about it. And so I will shift gears and do a lot of other stuff. We did two years of pirate sets that are like super wacky and like you move pirate ships around the board and do all this stuff. You know why? Cuz I like pirates and that sounded really fun to me as a design challenge. Sounded super cool. Actually it was a real pain in the ass. We still have yet to get those sets into the app because they're so hard to do. So like from a business decision maybe it wasn't the best choice, but it was really cool. And so what I did with this last set is I just on my own without the license, without anything, I just said okay, what if what if we brought Ascension we did Ascension Lord of the Rings. And I would just designed it for fun for me and my friends to play kind of just like the original version of Ascension. And I said worst case scenario, if I don't you know, I could just I could use the the ideas in this and make a variant that's in the Ascension universe. And so I did it. I started created this idea of a corruption track and this like powerful artifact that you would use and like that players would vie over and the control of it would move you up and you'd be tempted to gain corruption and that would give you more power but would cost you honor and you and there's and you're actually Sauron is showing up and this villain is showing up throughout play and influencing the game as it's going on and it was so much fun and it was so cool and my I just iterated on so fast and I was like and then I I was like I wonder if I could actually do this. And I literally just posted on my social media like hey who has the Lord of the Rings like how would I Does anybody know who I can get in touch with to get the Lord of the Rings license? Asking for a friend. And uh and they they did and I got in touch with the right people and then I was able to pitch the game to

them and they they loved it and the you know, it's really cool because the the company on Middle-earth Enterprises that that controls all this stuff, they really do care about their their their brand, about The Lord of the Rings, about the world, about being true to the world and about supporting you know, small companies like me, right? Like I'm not a big not a a big giant company. I'm it's me and you know, like 11 other people or whatever that that do that that are all of our games. And so to be able to like work with us and entrust us with something that for me was like such a huge part of my childhood and such a huge part of like just the coolest thing of all time. And we're doing three different expansions. We're going to do the Fellowship of the Ring set, a Two Towers set and a Return of the King set. They all tie together. There's going to be a collector's edition that has all of them, you know, in the full kind of saga that you get from The Lord of the Rings.

It's like the coolest thing I've ever worked on probably you know, and and so it's a it's really fun to finally be get to be able to talk about it. Um yeah, that sounds that sounds amazing. I'm really excited to be talking with you about it and getting to hear about it first hand. Um with this expansion, so the main mechanic is going to be a corruption track. Um Uh yeah. Yeah.

Yeah, I'll speak to it a little bit. So so there is there are several different mechanics that are all going to play through.

Mhm. And the other thing is as I previously mentioned when I designed expansions in the past, we have done largely the expansions are designed to be stand-alone. Maybe they pair with one other set. But with this one we knew because we're going to do the whole trilogy that the mechanics and the sets have to all flow together. And so while corruption is a theme that runs through all of them, there are additional themes like the fellowship working together. There's themes like the you know, there's a really fun theme where you're trying to like kill more monsters than other people kind of like Legolas and and Gimli when they're battling and keeping their count of how many monsters they killed and there's rewards for that. And then there's other things that get introduced as you play through seasons and seasons. But at the heart of it, there's this idea of like you know, fellowship and uniting a you know, people that are facing insurmountable odds and there's the the corruption and the temptation of the ring and what power it offers and what price you're willing to pay for it. And that when I when again we talk about the core tension of the game, right? From within the core of what Ascension provides, the the we knew that the ring and the corruption and the temptation of the ring had to be at the heart of all of these three expansions and all of how this represents. So, that's at the heart of the that mechanically and emotionally. Well, awesome. I'm really excited to check out the Game Found page and I since this will be launching this video will be going up live after that is launched. I'll make sure to link to that in the description down below. Um that sounds like a great celebration for your 15th anniversary of Ascension.

Again, congratulations on 15 years. Uh

Thank you. To loop back to your 10-year announcement, Ascension Tactics as you said is is a combination of your love for miniature games and obviously bring deck building into that. Um how much fun was it to design with these mechanics that you love and bringing them together? Yeah, so it's an interesting this is another sort of thing is like you're doing this now as long as I have, right? So, it's been whatever more than 20 years I've been designing, you know, a professional game designer and almost, yeah, more than 25 or so I've been making a living at games. When I was thinking about doing Ascension Tactics, originally my vision for it was actually to kind of re-bring back the mechanic that I loved from the Lord of the Rings oh sorry the now I got Lord of the Rings the break the World of Warcraft miniatures game I had done where there was a time there's a timeline system and kind of I it was a really cool way that like each character evolved and moved through the things. I really wanted to bring that game back to life in a new format in the Ascension universe. And it was actually you know, members of my team that convinced me that that was not the right choice because there's an opportunity here because Ascension obviously it's a deck building game like can we make a miniatures game that fits with a deck building as at the core of its engine.

And and I Ryan Sutherland was the one who co-designed this one with me and so he really he gets a lot of credit for like the vision that was obviously correct once we saw it, right? Uh to be able to make a a core Ascension experience that fits with a tactical miniatures game. And so, it was really really fun and really cool and it's a really unique thing. You know, we talked about we talked earlier about what why was Ascension a big hit at the time, right? And what was what what made it succeed? And it's you know, there's a lot of that is just like the right thing at the right time. If I had tried to make something like Ascension Tactics back when Ascension was launched or even within the first 5 years of Ascension, I guarantee it would have been a flop because it was so new. There's so much going on. Like deck building was still like being understood and explored. But 10 years in to Ascension, deck building is just a it's a it's a fundamental building block of games. I mean, there's there's I was going to say hundreds but probably even thousands of deck building games that exist at this point. There's it's used as a puzzle piece in a lot of other components. And so, being able to take that puzzle piece where if you know about deck building games or if you know about Ascension specifically, I can teach you how to play Ascension Tactics in less than 5 minutes. And it's a in the terms of depth of gameplay, I would go so far to say there's no game I've ever made and I would challenge almost any game anywhere that there's more depth of gameplay out of a box of Ascension Tactics. Like we have a solo mode and a co-op mode and a bunch of different scenarios and the amount of strategy that comes in from like the what controlling space and scenarios and

increasing your squad and attaching constructs and weapons to your guys. Like how much skill and variety of play emerges from that game is incredible and not you know, not to toot my own horn my team gets a ton it was a massive massive lift. My team gets a ton of credit for it. Um and and so it was very it's something I'm really really proud of and again it just like kind of moved the conversation forward. It's something I'm always trying to do in my work is like we all stand on the shoulders of giants, right? I give credit to you know, without Richard Garfield and the innovations he made in Magic I I don't exist. Like I'm probably just a lawyer somewhere, you know, and miserable in life. Right? I have if it's if it's not for you know, the the Dominion as a as a core innovation I openly admit we stood on their on you know, on their shoulders as well to make what we made. And and then I want to be I have other people many of other people have adopted the Ascension center row and that's more I think more common than other forms of running deck building games. And I had you know, the creators of Slay the Spire on my podcast and they credited Ascension with some of the stuff that led to the deck building rogue like genre thing. And so, we are all like supporting each other and kind of taking the next step and I think that Ascension Tactics was a really cool next step in what's possible um in how you can take the deck building genre and really bring something new to the table quite literally and figuratively. Yes.

Um with Ascension I mean you're at with with those three expansions at 19 18 expansions for Ascension

Seven 17 17 full scale oh sorry yeah, so it's 17 Ascension core expansions that are full full playable Ascensions as we did two Ascension Tactics expansions, you know, so the base game and and and and Ascension Tactics Inferno. And we have you know, if you're counting like little mini like expansion packs and little add-ons then we've got another like half dozen at least. Um and so if you're just in the Ascension universe, you know, full stand alone games we're at 19 not counting collector's editions not counting expansion pack like little add-on packs or the alliances set or so whatever. So, quite a bit and then Shards of Infinity is the other deck building game that we have which I've done four expansions that we then combine into a brand new Star Saga collection that has even new game modes for it. So, lots lots of expansions.

When you are approaching expansion, is it stuff that you are still figuring out how to work into the game when you release it or is it like you release the game and then immediately think of like oh this is a really cool mechanic that that could be brought in? How do you approach an expansion?

All yeah, so all of the above, right? So, so I mentioned it before like when I first make a game there's always stuff on the cutting room floor that is left aside that is great fodder for for games. Uh for future expansions. Then there's a world where we will have the players when you have the game on the table and players are reacting, their pain will give you opportunities for new designs, right? So, like the pain that I saw in players were like oh man, if only I could have held on to that one card in the center row. If I could have built around that and you took it away. I have no I noticed that pain and then I built the Dreamscape expansion where you actually have a center your own set of reserve cards that are just yours, right? That are you could protect but you also have to get enough insight to play them. And so, that was a pain point relieving. Or with Shards of Infinity was a really interesting one where I I I I finished the game before I held the real physical copy in my hand. And then when I saw that we had these cool like full character cards that were your your shard masters or whatever that they they looked like they should have some kind of unique power. And then the base set they didn't. And so, without seeing that guy in front of you cuz I just played with dice, right? When I was using my prototypes. But once you saw that image of that guy that's like this is me, it felt wrong that they didn't have their own special powers. And so then I did Relics uh of the Future which was a where now each of those guys got unique abilities that you could like level up into a difference. And so, all three of those things like your your cutting room floor, player pain points, and then like

cool opportunities that become inspired by like actually playing the game and seeing it in the world and getting inspired by other games that exist out there are the main systems for for finding new material. Mhm.

[clears throat]

Um with expansion and you know, all the sorry with Ascension and all the expansions it has, do you ever have difficulty designing within that space and making things feel different from one another? Yeah, I would have thought yes but the answer is no. I mean, like there's so much room to grow. The engine is so like robust on its own. There's plenty of room to design and and develop new things. And then you know, and we'll we'll push in different directions, right? So, like sometimes we'll get really crazy and we'll do something like the pirate sets like you know, Curse of the Golden Isles and then that's got a lot going on. And then we'll sometimes we'll bring it back and do something like like Gift of the Elements which is like a much leaner, cleaner version of Ascension that comes back to the core and just cycles on a few of the card mechanics. And I think that our players are willing to come on the ride with us where it may not be every expansion is for you, right? And I I I recognize that but that you'll you'll see what I'm doing with each one and play it and get some joy out of it.

And then the next one if you don't like the last one, the next one's probably going to be much more your speed cuz we're going to swing the pendulum back and forth towards the different you know, some that are higher variance and more crazy and some that are more strategic and some where you're going to be banishing all the cards in your deck and some where you're going to be like trying to build out, you know, mess with some tracks and some external board things. And so, I try to provide enough variety in what's available to the player. And as I mentioned earlier, honestly, I just got to as long as I keep myself entertained and I'm making a game that I want to play, that's been the best North Star for me. And of course, as any game designer developer should, you have to do play testers that have to give you that same feedback. But but really just building like okay, cool. What would I want to do next? And I mean, you know, look Magic has been around for 30 plus years releasing thousands and tens of thousands of cards. They're still able to keep new stuff and keep things fresh. And I can I'm not I'm only halfway there on that timeline. It's

easy money, man. So, I can definitely keep going. Um when you are designing a game, this is kind of just a bit of a callback to your first designing of Ascension and then then going back to the Lord of the Rings expansions that are announced. Um would you recommend designers design for like a specific group of people to have fun? Like cuz you said you designed you know, you were designing and having fun with your friends and if that's all got to you'd be happy with that. Um Do you do you recommend that you always you always need you always need to have a very specific target audience. Like do not try to design a game for everybody because you're really designing a game for nobody, right? And and and and and just try Sometimes you will make a game that everybody loves, but you don't have control over that. What you have control over is to find a very small niche of people that is like and I you know, picture like two of these people. Like who are they? What do they look like? Where do they go? What games do they play now?

What do they love about games? Like really make that mental picture in your head. Ideally to make it easier on yourself, you should be within that group. Right? And I've worked on games that that's just not true, right? When I made a game like for a Bakugan or Redakai or make our games for kids, right? The the games are for kids. So, I want to be able to find joy in them, but they're not for me. I'm not the target audience. I'm making it for somebody else. But if ideally you're making games that you're in the target audience, so you know and your gut instinct and your your own taste is going to matter. And you have a few people that are like your kind of trustworthy. Like this is the this is I know that I could bust this out like for Ascension like being able to bust it out with my friends in between rounds at a magic tournament where I could finish a game in 20 or 30 minutes and they would love it and we would have fun and play. That was my that was my sweet spot. And it's also helpful when it's you and your friends because it makes it a lot easier to find playtesters, right? So, so it's just another There's a lot of reasons to do it that way, especially if you're newer into into your your journey as a as a designer. Uh but I think that uh that it's just knowing your target audience, knowing your core tension, right? What's the core mechanical and emotional tension of your game? And then with each expansion saying, okay, what am I what twist am I providing, but still knowing that my target audience is the same, my core tension is the same, and now I'm either relieving a player pain pain point, providing another contrast to the core tension, or something that was cut from the original game, or because now I've discovered a new aspect to this I didn't see before, and now I'm going to bring that into the game, uh you know, and again it's still serving that core tension. That's pretty much like the recipe for for making new content and

building expansions.

And if you're a game designer listening to this and you somehow haven't heard of Think Like a Game Designer, you should you should go check out for Think Like a Game Designer for more information like that. Um uh last question I have for you. What is your favorite board game expansion? And and kind of just generally what do you look for in a board game expansion as as a consumer of it as opposed to a developer designer of it? Uh dude, that's a hard question, man. That's a hard question. Um I think uh you know, there was a I'm just going to go with the first thing that came to my mind because it was like it was this these impactful I used to play the Talisman. Uh like there was a second edition back in the day and they've revamped it and they've re-brought it back. And it was just this really It's like there's so many things about the game that are not actually like good game design principles that I do but it was like just this immersive fun thing where you just like fell into the characters and you could play the game and you just like go on this kind of classic fantasy adventure. Uh and they had an they had an expansion called the Timescape. And it created a whole other board and like things from the future and like crazy like war machine and Warhammer type characters and like and it would and it would you could teleport back in and out from the board. And it just was like it kind of blew my mind like as a designer. I wasn't a designer when I was a kid, you know, I was like 17, 18, I don't know. And as a as a player that they they could take this like world that I felt so comfortable with and felt understood which just play for hours just kind of was like our

go-to. And then like transform it so fundamentally because the game was so different with this area, but it still felt like the same game. And it still felt like, you know, again they were true to the core of like that experience of me and becoming immersed in this character and going on these crazy adventures. Uh and so that one just it's always had a really big impact on me even though it wouldn't be like the kind of thing I would give like a a game design award to or whatever today. Uh it was something that that has always stuck with me and I I I I can't uh yeah, so that'll be my answer. Well, uh I think that's a great answer. It's a lot of fun.

Um thank you so much for coming on to chat with me. I appreciate your time and obviously I'm really looking forward to Ascension Lord of the Rings all three expansions. Uh Thank you to our audience for tuning in. Thanks for being such an awesome community. I've been Eric with the Cardboard Herald here with Justin Gary.

Progress saved