Skip to main content
Loading video...

Q&A: Charles Ward - Free Print & Plays and Beyond!

Transcript 36:51

hey everybody Edo here and I am super excited because I have Charles Ward on the line say hello Charles hi how's it going uh it's going well how's it with you you're out in Japan right yeah uh and it just started snowing today so we have a lot of shoveling to do what part are you in Hokkaido or where are you in Japan I'm in central uh Japan and the prefecture called the Nagano they had the Winter Olympics back in 98. I have I have snowboarded in Nagano awesome yeah it was probably 15 years ago but it was uh it was a whole lot of fun well so this is an interesting call because I've played a number of your games um which I've reviewed and I'll link them Hayes island rockomon sky Towers tours towers and part of it is that you make these print and play games um and um and so it's been really interesting to check them out and play them and I know you've put them into contests um but to start can you give us a sense of like how you got into game design how you got into print and play because I think you've really established like your big print on print and play and I'm very curious to sort of how you you enter that scene well my uh sort of as a gamer uh I do come to quite late in life instead of playing a lot of games like uh throughout I don't know my life for me it's been like a later thing

and I'm a teacher here in Japan and I teach kids and games were a way for me to try and get the students to imagine themselves in a world of English in which they could exercise and practice all the things that we were learning actually what it should have been it should have been role-playing games but I thought maybe board games would have been a way to do it so I started designing games to try and meet that sort of need and the games were way more interesting than the English that we were learning and educational games I I they're not really a thing in our space because a board game is very much its own thing and educational games are a different thing they're both games but uh I really find it interesting the uh sort of modern day board game design space it's just fantastic so I went into that rabbit hole started to make games discovered Board Game Geek and I've never looked backed really well and so okay and so your initial games you made were were specifically for your class and the and the kids you were teaching or did you start on your own independently from there I was teaching independently as a teacher and I could do whatever I wanted with the kids so um I don't plan as much as I should so I improvise a lot and things just lead in one way or another on the other and it's usually the kids expressing an interest and that's kind of what we do which is that's the way I like to teach uh

so I could try things out with my students and I had a lot of students and it was it was really good but I wasn't really getting I mean I was new making games I've been illustrating and doing graphic design before that so producing them isn't so difficult getting the idea to work and to gel as a game is the hard challenge sure sure and so going back to getting onto BGG like how did you you I mean I mean most folks are seeing these videos and knows what BGG is but how did you enter it as a new designer like can you take us a little through like lots of folks are interested in figuring out how they can get in and start making games and some people get caught up in sort of pitching and sort of trying to get Publishers to dive in but it sounds like you found a a different entry point can you talk sort of back how that process went it's definitely out of necessity because I am in a place here in Japan fairly rural part of Japan where there aren't a lot of foreigners that you can play with or a lot of Japanese people who play board games it's not as big as it is over there in the states some really out of options for trying out and play testing games that are games not like educational you know things that I can't test with my students things that require language and what have you so having Board Game Geek as a place where you can develop games in a like open environment where the threads the work in progress threads of the design forums are just a really

nice Community where you can say hey I'll test your game and let you know what you let you know what I think about it and hopefully you'll do the same and you can play test each other's games and improve on them and before tabletop simulator you put a print and play file and they will then print it cut it up and play it and tell you what they think and this is uh and this is great but on top of that there's a contest there's a whole community of contests that are happening and you can enter with very specific sort of limitations maybe a nine card game or an 18 card game right uh just just playing cards or all different sort of limitations with that it's basically a design exercise that you can sort of go into and try and put a game out share your ideas and let people see you know what you can come up with but also look at other people's ideas and give feedback that really does make you better as a designer because you're having to see you know the struggles that other people make and you you feel better that you also have them too like it's not uh you're not alone when you're designing but it was really out of necessity that I don't have anyone really around me to test and play the games as much as I'd like to so it was uh it was a absolutely crucial for me to move from you know English to board games oh very cool yeah and and actually you know our if if I'm just and I can link it to

later but if you're just going to BGG and you want to look at some of that Designer space and the contests and stuff presumably if I just had to guess is that going into the forums like what area of BGG is that community in it's definitely in the Forum section and there is a sub Forum I suppose it's called of game Design Within which there are maybe two or three threads are important one is the contests and they're all on one section then you have the work in progress uh which is your sort of baby that you put out there in the world you put it in that sub forum and the other one is game design and that's the general Chit Chat that you get most threads popping up in and there's some really amazing feedback if you want to learn about probability there's something specifically for that and there are some really clever people out there answering these questions I'm like wow this is such a great resource and it's really active and that's the cool thing uh since then there have been maybe one or two places on Facebook that have a similar sort of energy to them one is the board game design labs and another one tabletop designers Guild maybe I'm not sure um so it's kind of like spreading out and it's amazing that the board game design space has such a cool sort of forum and public sort of space to develop and discuss games where I've started looking into role-playing game design and there's nothing quite like like the Anna energy and the amount of people that's interesting yeah I

couldn't find an equivalent even you know I know this board game geek has a spin-off RPG geek but it's just not quite the same level of bubbliness that's interesting yeah and actually I I I just thinking before I forget I don't know if you've seen my q a with uh ayako uh taranishi but it's all about the Japanese Indie board game scene it's crazy huh yeah and so I don't know I don't know in your area might be a little lower but but in in Rural and but in there in a number of the Cities there's a very vibrant board game scene in Japan for sure in the cities yeah yeah so I have my crew of uh uh local board game Fanatics some of which are designers some of which are Cafe owners and we have a little team and we go to Tokyo game Market oh there we go awesome yeah we I've done that show maybe 10 times now and uh it's great because every time we get a little bit better we get a little bit bigger and I know what I'm doing and my my Japanese is getting better and but it's always like uh you're disorganized chaos for me and go in there it's it's crazy it's very short uh the duration is very short and there's a lot of people and it's just like it clogs up like nothing moves at one point in the day where everyone's just standing still waiting for space to be able to just keep moving forwards it's crazy that is crazy okay so so back to the story you're getting all this feedback you're you're you're

you're entering these challenges you're getting those you know barriers the boundaries to work in design from that'll help you know helps settle you know your options and and focus your efforts what was your first recognition how did you you know what was the was it Haze Island what was the game that sort of got on the map it was Hayes islands and uh you know it had been one game and design and morphed into another game I think it was Hayes City before it was Hayes Island sure Hayes Islands just seemed to fit the game and it was a game that um you know I worked on as well not my first game uh the first game I worked on for like a year on a daily basis and by the time that year it elapsed it completely morphed into something else that was unrecognizable and the insurance sure sure and then that happened again and again and finally I got a bit better at this and Hayes Islands came up and it won a few uh print and play contests it won the survival contest by uh thundercliff games and it was nominated for a golden geek for the print and play category so I was super chuffed at that and that awesome that was exciting I thought okay well maybe this is it you know maybe you figured it out now have you ever so I mean I know that you continue to print in place have you ever and uh looked into or considered other publishing routes or or kickstarters as well or has it really just been

exclusively in the print and play space no I'm I'm very I was very sort of uh holding back uh not wanting to commit to I don't know putting a game out there that wasn't quite ready so the development sort of field that principle has is perfect for me because I never think A Game's finished you can always improve it a little bit and you know after a year you play it review it you want to change it a little bit more so it's kind of agile in that format right but once you print you put your name on it and then you know you have sort of repercussions of people like it or not and your your reputation starts to either go up or down um interesting interesting it was it was it was tricky and I didn't think I wasn't ready for a Kickstarter because I think if you're going to do a Kickstarter you need to have all the building blocks that go after that in place whether it's shipping whether it's a a website to collect sales after to the kickstarter whether it's a mailing list and all of these things you need a ton of stuff before you think yeah Kickstarter it's a kick Ender really it should be sort of towards the end of the process um so how many print and play is also uh not only agile but it's a way to give back to the community who helped me design these games because it isn't just one person right it's like feedback and there's illustrates oh sure I like to work with artists and you know go back and forth and direct and sort of get the game to look as good as I can make it it's not the best game in the world but for me it's like yeah this is great well

I think I think what you're saying about a print and play Never being finished but a package game being done is super interesting professionally I make video games and a lot of them are mobile or online and they have all this extended live operations period where you can yeah where you continue to change and update them and add content fix bugs whatever it is interesting that that's something you can't really do in board games if you have a reprint you can do it you can do expansions obviously like it exists a relative but it's not cool yeah yeah but like it I never thought of this is the first time everyone is anyone has ever described a print and play to me as more of a living game living document than than just a single Edition do you ever get like a how do you capture that do you like is it a version number like how do you let people know that you've like changed it or updated I wish I was that organized but yeah that would be the right way to do it thanks you'll just update the files and and next time person downloads it to get the newer version uh yeah I'm a bit sporadic on how my systems are sort of organized but yeah that's that's the ideal situation I usually put the date on it if it's updated that is a good way to do it that would be good because then I know when it came out as well that helps but also putting these games out for free it's it's amazing the amount of volunteers that come and say hey by the way I've translated your game into Italian if you want to you know use it please let other people you know play it so because it's

free it's I don't feel bad about getting someone to translate the game for free and then use that to then make the game available to even more people so uh it's a great way to give back to this board game Community well and in terms of this I mean I is it fair to say that um you know and I'm not to I think it's a it isn't meant to be loaded but like presumably since you're making print and plays and making them available free you you you're not making money this is just a hobby you're enjoying um so uh I started self-publishing the hard way which means without funding uh get a set of copies and take them to game market and see what happens I had an online store live for a couple of years and I was selling them through there and it was great uh so we have printed copies oh look at that you do oh of every game that I think is worthwhile and I have them but I gotta now factor in to uh send them to reviewers and all of that there's a blood unfortune which is my first mistake beautiful mistake uh rockomon is in a box too there you go oh yeah and uh Kika is maybe a game that you don't know about it's a no so this is a Thailand game with the various combinations of rules that you can add to it remember the four uh was it 404 the freedom yeah sure yeah yeah

that gigantic I remember that game this is kind of on the same thing it's got 972 possible ways to recombine the rule cards that come in the game and that gives you different styles of play but essentially it's not that they're not that different it's a tiling and presumably if I remember my my conversation about the Japanese Indie scene like you're able to that is something you were able to purchase purchase type the purchase manufacture within Japan right there's services or did you do it there are but I did it through China okay and so are but then are you shipping from Japan to folks or do you have are you using other services right now uh we don't print like large runs I think kick out was 500 Hayes Island was a thousand uh rocomon was a thousand and they come in in a big box and I have them just there and I pack them and ship them as the orders come in uh when my shop was live it's kind of offline now because I'm dealing with Kickstarter um well you are doing it is something live now or you're just figuring it out oh uh I've successfully funded my Third campaign so we've got a lot of great okay it's been a while okay so you okay so hold on a second then let's just tie this back into the story so you're doing it independently you're making it for free you start going to Tokyo you start going to the Indie uh whatever uh the game show token it's a Tokyo game market and and at some point you're like hey I'm gonna go do this the hard way I start printing your own you have a web store you're selling it yeah so then at what point were you like I'm gonna go to the kickstarter route

well uh I made something which uh well I ended up making something which I thought I really want to make this my my my uh Flagship product and it's not a game but it's game related it's coin science this is uh a spinning diced it's like a metal coin which acts like a top you spin it you put your finger on it and it tells you the number of the value of the dice that you rolled uh I've seen dice Spinners before but this one managed to design managed to forge all six of the role-playing polyhedral dice so your D4 D6 d8 d10 D12 D20 into one coin so on either side of the coin there are different combinations of numbers and when you spin it and stop it it'll tell you what you rolled basically every single die you know in a coin yeah uh and this is the first well the first was coincides well coin size classic now I suppose and then this last last year we did Cthulhu coincides and that added extra dice into the coin and next year will be this year now we're going to do cyber coincides a different design coincide just coin and then size if you look up there the Kickstart is a tell you very well like what the product's all about

cool I'm working while you're talking uh and this was this is like a surprise for me because it was actually intended to be a design for the one player Guild every year they make a commemorative coin and they thought well you know we can make it spin and put a dice on it and I entered into the competition to design the coin for them but for some uh luck of for some lucky accident I was out voted by another design so I got to keep my design and make a a very successful sort of product out of it so that was kind of fortuitous and so and so the kickstarters you have done are for these coins have you done a board game Kickstarter yet or uh that's the next challenge uh mainly this is quite small and easy to ship it almost it fits through your letterbox even if it's packed so it was designed for that to be shippable however covert came and ruined all the shipping plans that we'd made so uh not good but uh my second Kickstarter was for a role-playing product it's a magazine so it was entered into the zine Quest oh cool pretty simple black and white um role-playing games and this is my first one uh my first step into the role-playing scene which is kind of like what am I doing but it's really fun the story of this is It's I'm gonna keep it short but basically I play with my son in the car we play an adventure where I I guide the story and he makes decisions and we just

roll to see what happens and we've got to keep it very simple so this simple system of rolling dice which I call any um worked so well for us that I thought well I'd just publish it you know I'll just put it in a book I know how to graphic design I know how to write I know how to write the rules or spend some time on this and put a Kickstarter for uh Zine Quest it's a very low threshold very easy to sort of you know yeah no I I've not been part of it but I remember seeing it yeah yeah super easy way into Kickstart if you want to learn to do a Kickstarter choose either that project or the make 100 project and it'll give you a little boost so so let's just yeah so just that for those who aren't aware who have done kickstarters you can always do a Kickstarter but Kickstarter has these sort of like events promotional event things where they're like hey we want a bunch of campaigns where you will only make 100 of what you're selling or we're doing this thing which is all about little magazines if you do your own campaign but it's part of this event and then they'll promote you and do other things and I would say the make 100 is better because if you choose to be part of a dedicated or focused uh campaign like Zine Quest is very much for role-playing games now you are swimming with a lot of other big fish an old big fish catch the fish and the little the little guys like the new guys like me like well yeah this wasn't such a good idea um but okay it was fun but on the other hand they make 100 it's a much broader spectrum of things so you you're likely

to be maybe more successful doing that sure so role-playing stuff or board game stuff in the make 100 space that's probably a better recommendation right so you did the Zen one and did it I presume it funded yeah so coin size one was funded uh Annie my uh role-playing game was funded and then Cthulhu coincides was funded so we did okay and so I mean but presumably I mean is and but you're still teaching this is still a hobby it's just starting to make a little money or are you with the with the with Corona being what it is I lost a lot of my classes so it helped me to to spend doing the kickstarter stuff for coin sides and get good at Kickstarter so I can put my games on there when the time's right and this is also new new new games that I'm designing uh games that I've published already that I want to improve for example Hayes islands is great but the components in it are really substandard for like most of the modern day board games I'd like to have minis in there if I just do a Kickstarter for The Minis then you can the game's already made you know and I got plenty of them so uh um so that's it I'm very ambitious with my like print runs and then I think well yeah I should figure out a way to sell these and not just have them in the house and go into games well you know you could build walls and forts I mean all sorts of fun stuff you can do with boxes yeah yeah boxes oh man I got I got a fetish for boxes I think too many boxes too many boxes

inside them I mean I think it's a really interesting story of entering the space in this very robust Community Learning engaging building up your skills building up your Renown and then moving through onto Kickstarter one of the things I mean the reason we're not the reason we've actually interacted a lot but you had reached out about a couple games that you're working on that are for conventions and you said hey I've got I think um hold on hold on uh mismatch and you win and you know I was sort of like well I'm not really attending any conventions soon and so I'm like I don't know if I'm gonna be able to play this and then like why don't we just get on a call and you can talk about how you got to it and what it is so like you know especially in this world where you're like I mean was it for the the Tokyo market like like what how did why were you like I live in rural Japan I'm gonna make a convention game like how did that come about I don't know uh I wake up every day and my brain says yeah today we're gonna do this and then we we do that and then we we do something else and whatever whatever's sort of tickling or sort of rattling inside there sort of like yeah that'd be really cool if I made that and then I'd just go and make it and sometimes it takes like half an hour and sometimes it takes eight years but I'll work on it whenever like I get that buzz like oh you know I should be I should be doing that now and it's just the way I am and instead of you know

uh sort of trying to have a regular job I'm just going to lean into it and and you do that so I do whatever comes to mind and one of the games was how to have a replacement for rock paper scissors that's probably how it started because rock paper scissors is fine but it just kind of feels you know a bit arbitrary sure I wanted to design also designer game I'd seen a game called called what was it coin age yeah it was one of the first kickstarters I backed it was a game on a card an area control game you put coins on it my God this this game was all on like one card and then I thought oh that's cool I'll try and design a game too uh it was like a a game without ties which would quickly resolve and you'd know who'd won and it was basically an arrow on a card right sure one person would hold it the other person would flip it and whichever the direction the arrow pointed in that person would win right that's that's all it was so I made my business card out of it this is my business card or one of many business cards it used to be called uh flip um massive multiplayer card game that was like maybe the version you might see on Board Game Geek was recorded as that but it went through iterations I'm not kidding you it took me eight years to make a one card game because every now and again I'd come back to I think I'm going to give it another crack this year and try and make a game and I've got versions like

stacked up over there of different versions of a one card game that you could play standing up and yeah anyway I finally finished that project and now they and that's that's the one with the QR code right that last one you picked up these these are my business cards uh I'm afraid I'm gonna have to turn the blur off so you can see better but uh this is the first printed you win card this is the face of the card to tell you which way the arrow points and this is the back of the card so this is what you see before you flip it as you can see it doesn't matter which way the card is the instructions are repeated uh upside down just at the bottom so that you don't know which way the arrow is pointing and you put it on your hand and the other person does the same thing so you both need to have these cards to play in this game uh slightly different from my business card which is like a it's just a one flip of a card this is a little bit more engaging because you have a few choices right you can choose how many of car how many of these cars you bid right so the more cars you bid the more cards you are likely to win if you're the winner right two players have the cards on the hand they flip each other's card at the same time and you can flip it either this way or this way and that makes the arrow point in a different direction so you don't really know doesn't matter if you know what their card is because you don't know how they're gonna flip they might it's not really bluffing it's just

random look really so you flip the cards and the arrows indicate who wins uh just to explain that simply both arrows point to you you win if they point to me I win if there's a tie where the arrows Point differently the person who bid the most cards wins that's interesting if that still results in a time which it might be if people are just playing one card then you put those two cards together shuffle them up flip the top one and it's whoever that Arrow points to takes all of those cards that's the you win game and that for me is still a little bit too complicated and messy because it has that tie and I'm like no I've got to make a game without ties God damn it and some nice guy in the uh uh I think it's Greg in the board game uh in the board game geek Community says oh I have a similar idea that I haven't managed to finish off but you can have it and use it in your game because it's essentially like what you're trying to do and that came uh to be mismatched looks similar it looks similar pretty much the same text the only difference is is the resolution on the other side for one there's no arrows so what you do before you play you would say hey you want to play mismatch I've got some cards here so do you let's do it and then you decide who is going to be Miss and who's going to be match right okay let's say I miss and you'll match and then we play the cards right and we flip the cards and there'll be cards on

your hand and cards on my hand if the orientation of the card is the same it's a match it's ah different it's Miss so it's always going to be a 50 50. someone's gonna win that's it there's no uh there's no ties and if you play 10 cards then you can take up to the 10 cards if you played one card you can only win one card so so the more bid the more likely you are to win but it's still 50 50. so have you had an opportunity to actually take this to a place where you play it standing and use it yet or is it just all in your head at this point no uh so when we when we launched the you win game it was in a contest and I I've not had the pleasure of playing it in a massive group of people but I think it'll be fun because I get to uh pull this out every time I meet someone and I have my sort of business card exchange a little uh routine setup right it's it's super funny it's super funny uh and they always win which is great so I get to give them the business card if they lose I have my business is very sneaky you you know the trick it's just it's just banter really but uh at the contest there was a uh another designer who got to play uh you win for the first time in Poland in a group of you know uh 20 or 30 board gamers so it was more of a more of a sort of a party and it worked and it said it went really well I'm like okay good because eight years is a long time you know to be well yeah it's sometimes it's interesting when things are simple I uh you know we've done a lot of games

the pencil first games and and there was herbaceous which was very simple and there have been other games since that some people like more such as soliferous depending on your taste yeah and I get asked that all the time and a lot of times I'm like man to make her be to have to be as simple as herbaceous and be fun is like that's I think sometimes even more difficult than when you add in the different systems and the different elements when you when you strip it all away it's like is there enough here to make it work so once uh once uh the in the contest uh it was a a the two 2022 in hand contest okay and uh it got second place on one category that was it and I'm a sucker for winning and if it doesn't do well I'm like uh that's it uh it's not worth mentioning and but I I really do appreciate all the feedback that the people sort of gave uh for like such a small project but for me such a big project and uh it got uh played at a convention in America uh the 2022 uh Great Planes gaming project they have a great planes gaming Festival uh once a year and Cameron the organizer I was sort of just like reaching out to a few conventions to see if this kind of thing exists if this is like a uh possible um and someone said you know what we'll do it and I gave them the files they print entered it at their Staples like not cards yeah yeah no I get it in yeah just business cards and they had a blast

with it and that went well so I'm like okay so I'll take that feedback and I'll try and run it again this year with mismatch as like a simpler quicker version I think you win is the better game for for like whatever a game is right but mismatch uh just seems simpler and lighter and uh saltcon 2023 in Spring is going to be running the first mismatch uh uh sort of event and that's awesome that's partly because I'm sort of interested in that event and wanted to support and sponsor them so I sent them the prizes and the cards as a way for me to also get them printed so that I have my stock of cards to do it all in the same print run and now they have uh I think it's 40 of the beautiful coin signs that you could win if you go to saltcon and you play this game called mismatch super very cool it also gets to have their sort of salt con logo on sure of course so get to they get to keep the cars and possibly if enough of the cards return to the organizers to claim for prizes they can probably run it another time as well with smaller numbers and then smaller numbers because once you give you know there's four thousand cars that have been shipped to America once these go to per attendee so there's two thousand people coming they'll all get two cards it's important that the event is sort of behind there they get two cards with their program and instructions of what to do and what it is and then between games when

they're standing in line or playing or waiting they get to play mismatch they get to collect more cars they might have a stack of cards by the end of the convention and that's how you get the prizes they can Whoever has the most at the end of two days of gaming wins a prize which will probably be a coincides plus something else the game that saltcon has organized but if you don't want to stay for two days if you need to leave early you can take what you have go to reception says what do I get for 20 cards or you get a key ring oh thank you very much but you can also just take the cars home because they're in your pocket right you can maybe want to play with your 20 friends when you have 40 cards or whatever at your next game convert at your next game night with your friends or whatever so and it's a game that you get to keep as well and is this so I know you're doing your I mean you're very entrepreneurial and how you're looking at these different activities is this also a print and play thing or is this all of them mate all of my games are gonna I'm just checking okay I didn't want to so so if somebody was like watching this and I was like oh that's interesting I'll print out 20 or whatever they could just go to BGG and print it out so it's not immediate I put it on my website because and this is we didn't talk about this this is exist game with a one right yeah ex first or ex1st or exist games whatever I'll link it in the in the in the description cool uh I I I'm gonna keep making my games and whether they're like massive titles or whatever the bigger the get the hotter it is for

people to print at the end of the day right so I don't mind putting the games online maybe like a slightly lower resolution or like a slightly uh uh not inferior product but you know I get it easy to print products so that you can try the game because really if people aren't playing it you know they're not talking about it they're not going to go out and buy it that's at the end and also my website now collects your email address which gives you access to the files and that also sort of lets me let you know when I'm doing a Kickstarter once a year or twice a year whatever so it is kind of like a give and take thing now but financially you know there's no money involved it's just the files are there if you want them very cool well you know you took us on on quite a journey I I appreciate all of the information and certainly we've talked about a lot of things I'll drop some of the reviews I've done in the past and then I'll link the website and if folks want to try Miss if they're willing to give up their email they can try uh mismatch or uh you win or any of these games um and that's awesome so so thanks so much for uh taking us through everything you've been doing excellent thanks very much it's always a pleasure to talk to you and I want to say thanks for all the videos that you do oh sure now people like you making stuff available for free for people who me who need to learn things about the industry the details the shipping all of that stuff uh so thanks uh Adu it's been really good knowing you for many years now yeah absolutely man appreciate it okay talk to you later okay bye bye it hey

everybody Edo here and thanks for watching gaming with Edo reviews over here on this playlist league and Insider videos over here on this one subscribe share all that good stuff but most importantly play some great games thanks

Progress saved