Skip to main content
Loading video...

'GOOD LUCK' (in board games)

Transcript 35:00

You know that moment? You just spent the past 3 hours building the perfect engine. Every cube in its right place. Your tableau was a masterpiece of efficiency. Your strategy flawless. And then you roll a one. A measly one. And just like that, your master plan transforms into your own personal waterlue. The table erupts into shot and Freud laughter. and your carefully constructed economy crumbles like a house of cards built on a shaky washing machine. All because of a bad roll. And we've all been there, right? That moment when the dice gods forsake you or when you draw exactly the wrong card at exactly the wrong time. When a six-sided cube of plastic decided that today was your villain origin story. And the reality is that luck in board games is a cursed blade. In the hands of a skilled designer, it creates these incredibly galaxy moments of tension and release. It allows for more people to enjoy a game, and it creates ways of implementing offbeat strategies while providing a cushion between player scale. But badly designed randomness just manages to stab whatever fun might exist directly in the heart. And I've been playing tons of the re-release of Quacks of Quedlinberg. And let me tell you, pulling boomberry after boomberry after boomberry from that miserable bag has me thinking deeply about just how

much our enjoyment hinges on luck. That fine line between thrill and uncertainty and why am I even making decisions if they don't matter. So today I want to explore what makes good luck in board game design versus the kind that makes us want to roll a natural d20 into the trash. Because it's one thing to talk about RNG and dice rolls and random card draws, but I think that's missing the point of why luck is such a crucial component of so many games. So, what I really want to explore is the relationship between randomness and something much more important, player agency. That feeling that your decisions genuinely matter in determining the outcome of the game. Okay, so first we're going to clarify what randomness and luck actually are because they're not necessarily the same thing. Then I want to introduce a vibe based math equation for measuring player agency in games with randomness. We'll dive deep into analyzing popular games across the spectrum and we'll draw some conclusions about what makes good luck in game design. Finally, I want to share some practical takeaways and my final thoughts. So yeah, thank you for joining me and let's discover exactly what kind of luck makes for good luck. Defining our terms. First, let's get the terminology straight so we're all speaking the same language. Randomness, RNG, is any method that creates uncertainty through chance. While RNG technically stands for random number generation, what we're really talking

about is generated randomness from physical components. This could be dice tumbling across a table, cards being shuffled and drawn, chits being pulled from a bag, a spinner whirling around, a random token flip. It's important to understand that randomness itself is neutral. It has no agenda, no preference for who wins or loses. It's just math and probability in a physical form. Now, game designers often talk about two flavors of randomness, which I think is a useful distinction, but not the end- all beall. Input randomness happens before you make decisions. Think of drawing your hand in a card game. The randomness comes first, then you decide what to do with those cards. Input randomness creates puzzles for you to solve with the tools you've been randomly assigned. On the other hand, output randomness happens after you make decisions, like when you decide to attack in a game and then roll a bunch of dice to see what you hit. Output randomness creates tension around whether your chosen actions will actually work. And let's take a quick look and see how these play together in a real game. In Arcs, you draw a hand of cards at the start of each round. Those cards are all randomly given to each player and act as the major source of input randomness for the round. Now, when a player uses one of those cards to actually attack someone and then they roll a bunch of combat dice, those dice are now the output randomness from decisions based on input randomness.

Many, many games use both types. And one player's output randomness often becomes another player's input randomness. If I rolled terribly in combat against you, my output randomness, the dice I just rolled, just became your input randomness, as you now have to decide what to do with this new situation. But here's where things get interesting. Randomness is just mathematical probability. What makes us curse the dice gods or praise lady luck is something entirely different. Luck is the perceived positive or negative consequence of a random event. It's subjective, context dependent, and carries emotional weight. When you roll a six, that's just randomness. When you roll a six exactly when you need to win the game, that's some good luck. When you roll a six when you need anything other than that, that's bad luck, my dude. Luck requires an observer, specifically someone with goals and intentions, to actually interpret the random outcome in relation to those goals. The same random event can be good luck for one player and terrible luck for another. Think of it this way.

Randomness is the mathematical engine that produces unpredictability, while luck is how that unpredictability interacts with our plans and desires in the game. So if randomness is just probabilities and luck is how we feel about it, how do good games stop us from feeling perpetually unlucky? The mitigation factor. Let me walk you through a little thought experiment. Imagine chess. It's pure strategy. Now, imagine you could only move the piece you draw from a deck of cards. You have a king, rook, and pawn in your hand. Well, that's just tough luck if your queen had checkmate all lined up. It sounds miserable because it would be completely draw dependent. Your brilliant strategy only works if you get the right cards. Grand Masters would be at the mercy of the shuffle and the skill ceiling plummets dramatically. So why does this concept sound miserable for chess? But when a game like Arcs uses a similar action card system, it ends up as my game of the year. The answer is mitigation. The tools and mechanisms games provide to help players manage, manipulate, or work around randomness. Good games don't just throw randomness at you and say live with it.

They give you ways to work around with it or through it. Think of mitigation as your defense against pure chaos, your weapons for taming the beasts of randomness. And some common forms of mitigation in games include resource management, like saving up things to create a buffer, which can then be used to address bad randomness. Multiple paths to victory. If one strategy gets blocked by randomness, you can pivot to another successfully. Catchup mechanisms. tools that help players who've had bad luck stay in the game. Statistical planning. If there are enough random events, they eventually average out into something more predictable. Skill-based manipulation. Some skilled players can directly improve their odds, like counting cards or knowing how many dice need to be rolled for a good shot of winning a particular combat. Diplomacy and teamwork. By pulling together and dividing bad situations, you can overcome randomness together. Think about katan. Those dice rolls feel totally random. Someone always parks on the six or eight ore in weight space and vacuums up all the resources. But you fight back. You diversify your numbers.

You heel like your life depends on it. And you build around a new win condition. That's all a form of mitigation. Fighting the tide of the random dice. The more tools you have to mitigate bad luck, the more player agency you maintain. Even in highly random games. the player agency formula. Okay, so I wanted to put all of this together in a formula and I should preface I'm no mathematician. I think I peaked somewhere around calculus 2 over a decade ago. So please let me know of improvements. I see this more of a thought experiment and a simple vibe based approach to measuring something a bit enigmatic like player agency. So let's take a look. PA is equal to 1 - R * 1 - M where PA equals player agency, R equals randomness and M equals mitigation. In plain English, you start with full agency, then subtract however much randomness affects you after the mitigation tools have done their work.

And let's break it down into components. Randomness. The R variable measures how much do chance elements have impact in the game. A zero R is no randomness whatsoever. 0.5 it's moderate in the middle. And one is a maximum randomness game. M the mitigation measures how effectively the game lets you manage randomness. If there's a zero mitigation, there's no tools at all. 0.5 you have some meaningful options. And if it's a one, that means you have complete mitigation over randomness. Then we calculate how much of the randomness actually gets through your mitigation defenses with the r * 1 - m. If you have perfect mitigation where m equals 1, then no randomness affects your agency.

If you have no mitigation m equals z, then all the randomness directly reduces your player agency. At the absolute extremes, for example, in chess where randomness is zero, mitigation is zero, player agency is one. In Candyland though, randomness equals 1 and mitigation is zero and player agency is zero because it's just pure random. Now, is this a purely perfect mathematical model? Of course not. The reality is that the randomness variable and mitigation variable are completely based on my own perception of each game. And I would love to hear your own opinions and ideas of improvements or how to better make this formula work. That said, I still find this method, it still works for the purpose of exploring the concept of player agency. And let's give it a quick test. Let's see how it actually works with real board games and see what we find out. Game analysis. Trouble.

Let's start off with a childhood classic to appreciate just how far game design has come. in trouble. You're racing around the board trying to get all of your pegs into the finish zone. Now, that iconic popomatic bubble might be satisfying to press, but everything depends on what you roll. You need a six even to get started, which means there's an 83% chance you'll do absolutely nothing on your first turn except sit there and actively suffer. You move exactly the number of spaces shown on the die. No more, no less. and you want to capture an opponent, you better hope that you rolled exactly the right number. Randomness equals one. For the mitigation side of things, well, you can choose which peg to move, and that's about it. There's virtually no way to work around the bad roles or build a meaningful strategy. Sometimes you might have a choice between one move and another, but often the optimal move is painfully obvious. Yes, there exists a choice, but it never really mitigates the randomness. it's more reactive to it. And if I squint really hard, I I'll give mitigation a 0.05. Plug in these values into our formula, you can see that there's a pathetic 5% player agency. Trouble is essentially just watching the dice happen to you for 30 minutes. The game plays itself with you as a witness rather than a participant.

And no wonder it's even boring for four-year-olds. And this ultra low agency is exactly why so many of us have negative emotions towards games like Trouble or Candyland. They taught us that board games were exercises in futility rather than something you actually have influence over. Thanks for teaching us the myth of Sisphus Milton Bradley. Dune Imperium Uprising. Now, let's jump onto something more substantial. Dune Imperium Uprising. Some people think this game has too much randomness, and it's a game I play a lot of, so let's talk about it. Randomness is a significant part here. You draw five random cards each round from your deck, which dictates most of your available actions. The Imperium Row offers random cards to purchase.

Conflict cards reveal somewhat random rewards, and those intrigue cards can sometimes swing things dramatically with special powers or endgame points. add in modules like the tiles and starter car. And even there's a little bit more through random powers that can be factored in. Still, it's not only dice rolls, though. So, randomness gets a 0.65. But mitigation, oh boy, it's everywhere. The entire deck building aspect exists to mitigate hand randomness. You strategically buy cards, thin out junk, create combos, and improve your draws over time. Your agent placement choices are deliberate and often planned several turns ahead. Clever resource management actually gives you flexibility to address different strategies. And spies give you access to draw more cards and also get you to spaces you might not otherwise be able to. Even the multi-use cards of Dune Imperium give a buffer against random drawn because even if it's not useful for your agent turn, it might prove valuable for that reveal turn. And the game encourages opening up multiple pathways to victory, whether it's through deck building, conflicts, or faction tracks. Dune Imperium Uprising is fundamentally about turning the chaos of your initial weak deck into a finely tuned engine over time. Even when you get a bad hand, you still have a meaningful choice about how to make the most of it. So yeah, it's really high mitigation at 0.75. Plugging this all in to the formula, you can see there's a

strong 84% player agency. Despite the constant presence of randomness, Dune Imperium Uprising gives you so many tools that you can still manage it and make skilled play, which consistently rises above luck. This makes sense because in tournaments and repeated plays, you tend to see the same skilled players rise to the top. They're better at mitigating the randomness through superior strategic planning and tactical adaptations. When players complain about unfair RNG, they're often focusing on dramatic moments like a perfect entry card for an opponent while missing the larger picture on how much control they actually have over their long-term trajectory in the game. Arcs base game.

What about the hottest game of 2024? How much agency does the base game of Arks really offer? Arcs has dice combat that can whiff or obliterate. Sometimes your fleet just misses horribly entirely, and you get decimated by unlucky roles. You draw action cards every round with no deck building to mitigate bad draws. And then there's the court offering randomly drawn guild cards that can dramatically change power levels, or those vox cards that can instantly flip a board state. While these cards are both randomly drawn from a court deck, there is an auction system at play before you can actually secure them. It feels like you're constantly trying to snipe and outbid other players. Like it's 1999 and there's a rare Furby on eBay that you really want. It's definitely got randomness. So R equals 0.78. But ARCs is all about cleverly working around randomness. The pivot, copy, surpass systems really turns bad hands into puzzles. You can copy another player's card. You can pivot to use a new card entirely or try to surpass for maximum use. Of course, seasoned initiative is also a method to gain control over bad luck. Of course, with a cost attached. I just have to say the trick taken is actually a really clever way of making you realize that a bad hand is just a puzzle you haven't solved yet. Likewise, resource management and use of your prelude actions will provide ample flexibility for the core card

actions like stockpiling fuel before a combat turn. And while combat uses dice, experienced players learn to plan around expected outcomes over many conflicts rather than just betting everything on a single roll. So yeah, I give it pretty high mitigation as well at 0.65. Let's plug this all into our formula. And that's a solid 73% player agency. Arcs still maintains high player expression despite significant randomness by giving you tools to work around limitations. The randomness creates dramatic moments and forces adaptation, but it never removes your ability to influence the outcome through clever play. It really is a tactical experience of learning to make the most out of whatever randomness comes your way. Of course, I should note the base game and leaders and lore are relatively similar with regards to player agency, although I would argue to increase it a little bit once you add in leaders and lore. But the blighted reach, that campaign would likely warrant an entirely different analysis and calculation. It leans much more into randomness with some new mitigation tools dependent on your fate. So, let me know in the comments what you think the agency level might be for that monstrosity. Quack and its expansions.

Now, for the game that really made me want to talk about luck in the first place, Quacks of Quendlinburgg, or I guess it just goes by Quacks now. I guess Quax just gets better search results. And we all know you got to optimize for that algorithm even when brewing questionable medieval potions. And I can talk about the art change all day, but let's just focus on randomness for a moment. And randomness doesn't get much more in your face than blindly pulling chips from a bag, praying you don't draw another bombberry. It's literally the core mechanism. Every pull is a brief moment of tension and relief. And there's this beautiful addictiveness to reaching in and wondering, will it be a valuable ingredient or yet another boomberry to blow up my potion? The fortune teller cards add even more variability between rounds. And of course, there is the bonus die roll, which just gives out nice goodies. Plus, if you're playing with either expansion, both the witches and the alchemist require drawn random witch abilities or patience to cure, which can also dramatically randomize the game state.

There's no getting around it. The game at its core is randomness. It's a randomness factory. R equals 0.90 for the base game, and there's even slightly more RNG when you add in the expansion at R equals 0.93, but Quacks gives you a way to fight back against the chaos. You strategically build your bag after each round, buying better chips and diluting that boomberry pool over time. Certain ingredients have powers that directly mitigate bad pulls, like the bookmark one yellow mandrekes, which remove a boomberry from your potion. Your flask also lets you toss one boomberry back as an emergency button from an unlucky draw. While those rat tails are a catch-up mechanism who help players who've had terrible luck stay competitive. Now the expansion content, while it adds even more randomness, it also provides even more mechanisms to find strategic mitigation like returning boomberries or shopping more or having an improved start and bag, which can all create strategic decisions to balance the added randomness. Perhaps most importantly, knowing when to stop pulling is a skill in itself. Push your luck mechanics give you agency through risk assessment. Do you keep drawn after that 10th chip, or do you play it safe?

Player skill is really expressed through self-control and gain a good feel for what's actually left in your bag. So, yeah, there's a decent chunk of mitigation, especially when playing with these expansions. I'm going to give mitigation a 0.28 when you play the base game and a 0.4 four when you play with both expansions. Plugging it all in the base game and with both expansions. So yeah, with just the base game, I think 35% player agency feels right. And when you add on to those two expansions, which is the way I've been playing most often, you can definitely feel like there are more decision points to mitigate the additional randomness, which actually creates a lot of player agency. So yeah, 44% agency. It feels right with Quacks and both expansions. Yes, at its heart you're just gambling with vaguely gummy bearesque tokens, but the choices around building your bag, knowing when to stop, and using those supplementary powers, that's where the skill sneaks in. In essence, the high randomness keeps you on the edge. But there's enough mitigation that exists that meaningful and thoughtful players consistently outperform reckless ones.

It's the sweet spot where strategy meets delightful chaos. And I know Quack isn't the most competitive game in the world, but when you lose, it more often than not feels like you've pushed your luck too far rather than the game being fundamentally unfair. There are layers of strategy that can really sway the game in your favor. But there's also enough randomness to make any player of any skill level feel like they have a good shot through apicious fortunes alone. Simply put, this is a gold standard of well-designed, family-friendly player agency. Clever players feel properly rewarded, but everyone else feels like they still have a good shot, even if they have no overarching plans. I have a lot more thoughts about the game, so I might do a full review of Quacks in the future. Let me know if that deeper dive might interest you. Monopoly. Let's tackle everyone's favorite family fight starter, Monopoly. The randomness absolutely massive. Since dice control movement entirely, you can't decide to visit Park Place instead of Baltic Avenue. Chance and community chess cards create even more random events that can drain your bank count or fill it. Even getting out of jail relies on dice rather than strategy. It's the ultimate roll and move toppled with even more RNG through random decks. R equals 0.95.

Mitigation though, limited. You can't influence dice or choose movement, but you can decide whether to buy properties when you land on them and when to build houses and hotels and to try trade in with other players. But these are mostly reactive to luck, not preventative. Even things like in a jail, it's all just randomness that you have to deal with. The events in Monopoly happen to you rather than be created by you. Now, of course, there exists optimal strategies. You can purchase certain stretches of properties or land. You can use cash management to help you weather bad rolls, but there's only so much that you can really do when the dice send you straight into Boardwalk. So, yeah, mitigation goes low. M equals 0.15. Plugging this all in, we get a 19% low player agency, which confirms most of what we feel. Monopoly is dominated by luck. Your decisions matter somewhat, but are heavily constrained by random movement. There's a reason why this is an exercise in futility and frustration.

Even though many people don't consciously realize it while playing, Monopoly doesn't reward your decisions, and it makes you suffer through it. The game drags on and on and on as luck refuses to deliver that final blow. This low agency is exactly why Monopoly has become the poster child for games people hate but play anyway. It offers the illusion of strategy to unsuspecting families while actually being heavily luck dependent. The property acquisition might feel strategic, but it's largely determined by the luck of where you land. So that low 19% player agency feels about right. Twilight Imperium 4 plus Prophecy of Kings. The epic space opera Twilight Imperium 4 combines grand strategy with sometimes wild swings of fortune. Randomness abounds. Combat dice decide massive battles that can determine the fate of empires. Agenda cards can rewrite the rules of the game or hand out huge advantages. Action cards create tactical surprises, while the public and secret objectives are drawn randomly and set your personal scoring paths. Even the exploration mechanics in the expansion add even more chance events and access to immensely powerful yet randomly drawn relics. R equals 0.85. But TI4 also offers robust mitigation through an incredible array of tools. Fleet composition and size lets you improve your combat odds significantly. Technology upgrades directly boost your capabilities and consistency in all aspects of the game.

Leaders all provide mechanisms of stability and flexibility to each faction while having strong economy gives you even more flexibility and options when planets might be randomly scattered. And most important of all, diplomatic negotiations create the strongest barrier against bad luck. It's an organic solution to a randomly created problem. For example, if an agenda is drawn that would specific players, a unified front can be negotiated to actually weather whatever random storm might be coming. Huge decisions and meaningful progress can be made without a single dice roll in TI4. Also, let's not forget the game's length allows a regression to the mean. Bad luck in one moment can be balanced by good luck later on, and the sheer number of decisions mean that skill has time to shine. So, yeah, there's a lot of mitigation as well. M equals 0.85.

Plugging this all in, there is an impressive 87% player agency. Despite significant randomness, TI4 provides such powerful mitigation tools that skillful players consistently prevail over the long arc of the game. The randomness creates drama and forces adaptation without removing control. This high agency despite high randomness explains why TI4 has such a dedicated following. It manages to create memorable, dramatic moments through this randomness, but still rewards strategic thinking and skill play over the course of its massive runtime. Coup. Last but not least, the minimalist bluffing game coup. Initial randomness is actually quite extreme. You're randomly drawn two character cards that determine your abilities, and there's only 15 cards in the entire deck. This random deal can create a significant power imbalance in starting positions. Plus, you aren't even redrawn cards very often, and you have a hand size of only two. So, yeah, there's actually a lot of initial randomness of 0.95. But here's the twist. Coup's central bluffin mechanic allows you to claim any card at any time. The Duke lets you take three coins. Great. Claim you have it whether you do or not. Someone trying to assassinate you? Just claim you have the Contessa to block regardless of your actual character cards. These actual cards you hold become almost irrelevant compared to your social skills and your ability to read other players, which is

really your bluffing abilities. The immense randomness of those two cards you're handed is almost completely mitigated by the game's core mechanic. So mitigation is 0.95. Plugging this all in for coup, it leads to a staggering 95% player agency. The initial random deal becomes almost meaningless compared to the social game of lion challenging and reading opponents. Your skill at manipulation matters far more than the cards you were dealt. This is why Coup works so well as a quick social deduction game. The randomness creates variety in setups, but your success hinges almost entirely on social gameplay rather than the luck of the draw. What makes good luck? Phew. Okay, we just blew through seven examples. So, on to the main course. So, what makes good luck in board games? To me, it was never about eliminating randomness. Many of the games we love have very significant random elements. Rather, it's about making randomness interactive. When luck is designed properly, players meaningfully engage with chance rather than just suffer through it. And I would argue there's several key principles that emerge from our analysis. One, randomness should create interesting decisions. Look at arcs. That random card draw becomes a strategic puzzle of optimizing each hand. Even though it can seem daunting, when you get those random cards, you really need to find ways to play around it. Compare that to trouble where luck just happens to you and decisions are so

obvious and non-existent. Two, mitigation should be a core part of gameplay. In modern games, mitigating randomness isn't just a side activity. It's often a central component of the game experience. Quacks of Quedlinberg makes the big building exercise a core strategic focus. Compare that to Monopoly, where you just kind of waddle through a renters's hell until you end up bankrupt due to no fault of your own. Even though both are family games, one of them actually uses your decisions and your own behavior as a method of reward in you, while the other is a slow grind into family beckerine. Three, randomness should create moments, not solely determined outcomes. Good luck creates memorable moments and forces adaptation without completely dictating who wins.

The dice combat in Twilight Imperium creates dramatic swings and story moments, but the game gives you so many other levers to pull that one bad battle rarely spells doom. Four, agency should increase over time. Many great games start with high randomness, but gives players tools to reduce it as the game progresses. In deck builders, your star hands are highly random and garbage, but by the end, you've crafted a deck that produces more consistent results. This creates a satisfying arc of increase in power over time. Dune Imperium Uprising is a good example wherein you can really feel like you're more powerful and there's more options and you're more in control as you get a better deck and better cards. Five, the stakes of randomness need to be designed around.

If a single random event can drastically alter the game, players must have powerful ways to influence or respond to it. Conversely, minor random elements can add spice without needing heavy mitigation. Think about coup. If you miss a Contessa bluff, you're done. But the tool exists, and if you've done the work and played everything right, you can still pull off a proper block. And the game rewards you heavily for using all of those mitigation tools. Looking at our analysis, we can see a pattern. The games most beloved by strategy gamers tend to cluster in the 70 to 95% player agency range. They have enough randomness to create variety and excitement, but also enough mitigation that scale consistently matters more than luck. Meanwhile, games in the 30 to 60% range can be fantastic push your luck experiences, or casual games with broad appeal, where randomness and skills form a delicate balance of both feeling fair and lucky simultaneously.

It's only when we dip below 30% that games start feeling frustratingly luck dependent for most adult players. Though these can still be perfect for very casual situations or non-gamers who just want a simple roll and move kind of time. Conclusion. So what have we learned about good luck in board games? Designing and making good luck doesn't eliminate the storm. It gives you a compelling way to sail through it. It transforms randomness from a form of punishment into a puzzle. It's the difference between the dice hate me and now I lose, which is bad luck game design, versus the dice hate me and how can I work with this, which is good luck game design. In both cases, you know that the game might feel like it's rigged against you. But a good game would say, well, here's a tool to change your luck. What can you do with them?

For players, understanding this can help you choose games that match your preferred balance of luck and skill. Recognize and use mitigation tools that games provide. Focus on decisions rather than outcomes. And also appreciate how randomness creates unique scenarios even in strategyheavy games. And lastly, understand that randomness can open games to a wider audience of people. On the game design perspective, I would think of randomness and mitigation as a paired system. And I would design mitigation to be engaging and enjoyable rather than feeling like a hurdle. Lastly, use randomness to create problems for players to solve, not to determine the outcome of the game. In the end, many fantastic games don't try to eliminate luck. They harness that emotion to create engaging experiences where your decisions matter, but unexpected twists keep things fresh and exciting. They use randomness not as a crutch but as a deliberate tool to create memorable moments and makes challenges that you haven't seen before.

Ultimately, good luck isn't about avoiding bad roles. It's about interacting with uncertainty in interesting ways. It's something that designers can craft and players can navigate. So, the next time you find yourself cursing a bad draw or role, take a moment to consider, is this a failure of game design or an opportunity to showcase your skill at navigating uncertainty? A lot of great games make you feel that even when luck is against you, your choices still matter. And that's it. I hope this vibe based framework gives you a new lens to appreciate your favorite games. Let me know in the comments what games you think has the best ratio of mitigation and randomness. And thank you as always for watching. I'll see you next time.

Progress saved