Skip to main content
Loading video...

Sea Scroll, Sea Shells & French Toast Reviews - 3 Charming Small Box Games

Transcript 12:42

Hey, I'm Alex Raffle from Board Gameco and today I'm reviewing three separate games. Sea Scrolls from Renegade, French Toast from AllPlay, and Sea Shells from KTBG. All of these games are perfect for what I normally call my six smallbox game reviews. But honestly, all of these games have just enough something that I didn't want them relegated to a six smallbox board game reviews. Although, the truth is here and there I do I do throw some hidden gems into there. But also, I don't know if I if I feel the need to give these their own individual video for each of them. So, I guess starting off the bat, you know that I think there's enough here to talk about that I wanted them to be a bit more important. And so, we have three Ouch, that hurt. So, we have three small box games to cover today. Let's go ahead and start with French Toast from All Play. We'll go into all these time stamps, everything down below. French Toast is a party game designed by Peter Hayward in which players are going to be Let's try to zoom in and drop more on the camera.

We don't need to uh be that far out. Players are trying to figure out a war. The problem is the wars are almost completely random. There's a timed variant as well as a ninetime variant. Highly recommend the nine time variant to start, but then after that, do whatever fits your group. So, we have a word here. Okay, this is the word. I'm going to look at the word. It's that. Got it. Okay, there's advanced words and basic words. The advanced words do not start with. Then, we have a little bit of a number line over here. Not really a number line, a hint line. This is going to be used to give the players clues because what's effectively happening in this game is the game is called French Toast for a reason. We're going to grab a hint. And the hint is going to be, let's find a hint card. The hint is going to be how much is this thing a vegetable? It is not a vegetable. Okay, it's going to go all the way at the end. It is not a vegetable. And then we start then we start the process over here of trying to figure out what the ward is.

Now again, you could take turns in the turnbased variant or you could play the timer variant. We have 30 seconds per round. You will have six rounds to figure out what this ward is. What are your hints? Your hint so far is that it's not a vegetable. But then you go ahead and you guess. And so you say if it's not a vegetable, uh it's a a pipe. A pipe. And now I have to think, is this word, whatever it is, is it closer to a vegetable or is it closer to a pipe? Not vegetable. It's close to French toast or a pipe. I'm going to say it's closer to a pipe, I guess. I guess a pipe. Sure. Okay. Then you'll say board game. And I'm like, a pipe? A pipe, I guess. I don't know. You say bird. I'm like, bird. It's closer to a bird. It's closer to a bird. And you're like, okay, well, owl. I'm like, bird. And you're like, uh, raptor. And I'm like, not raptor. Uh, what's it called? A vulture. Vulture. And I'm like, uh, vulture, vulture. And you sit there and you d dance around trying to figure out what airborne animal it is until eventually you realize that it's not necessarily an airborne animal because I just said it's closer to a bird than it was to a pipe or to any of those other things. It doesn't mean it's an airborne animal, even though you got fixated on that. The timer runs out. We grab another clue. Next clue pops in and we have, is it old? And I'm like, it's kind of it's kind of not. It's kind of like middle old as far as it goes.

doesn't really help you that much, but I guess you're not going to go with Leviathan or anything like that. But you sit there and you finally realize that maybe it's not a bird and animal. So you say whale and I say raptor. And you say elephant. And I'm like elephant. Closer to elephant. And you slowly work your way closer to the word until eventually you figure out that it is indeed a tiger. That's what this word was. Seems impossible. And yet I would say my win rate for this game is probably around 75%. Although I will also say most of those plays have been with the uh the basic cards. I played it like two or three times with the advanced cards. I guess the truth is I got it two times, so it's 66% with the advanced cards. Uh, it is it is one of those games that doesn't feel like it should work. How do you work your way closer to a completely random thing? Always going with what is it closer to? Is it closer to French toast or whatever the last thing that it's closer to? You're always comparing between the new thing and the old thing, and you work your way closer to eventual common understanding. It is bizarre. It should not work. It's It's a crazy funny little party game that somehow manages to actually end up with people getting their way closer to actually figuring it out. I will say playing it at two players is not my favorite experience because two players you get too stuck in like because one player knows one player's guessing and when you only have a single player guessing they are too stuck in what they are guessing on. It's a little hard to break free. I find sometimes having even a even a third player is enough to have that breaking free aspect. I'm fixated on birds and someone else goes like mammoth and you start to work your way closer because the other person is trying to think outside the box. Having multiple minds I play definitely helps. So even though it works at two players, I would say that

three plus is my recommended player count. Overall, as far as review on this one, French is charming. It works when it shouldn't. It's a fun party game. It is very much a onetrick pony. I find that the the best part about this is doing it with people and then having it actually work and watching their minds get blown. They're like, "How does that work? How how did we figure out a completely random random word with hints that are barely helpful if at all? They're a little helpful, but the hints are honestly barely helpful. You work your way towards a common understanding, and it kind of works. It's a party trick of a game. It's a party game, don't get me wrong, but it's also a party trick of a game. Overall though, rating wise, I'm coming in at a 3.5 out of five. It's fun. It's a lot It's a very charming to pull out and do the whole thing with. It's great to show it to new players. I do find that I prefer party games with a bit more structure. So I so it feels more interesting connecting things. This feels like just like 20 questions without having 20 questions and instead having a timer. And it's not even really a timer because it's not really ask no questions. It's a variant. It's a variant of 20 questions is what this is, but it's a variant that works from there. Let's go into seashells.

Seashells is from KTVG. This is their newest game. This is a game by Bruno Fidi and it's a game of collecting various seaells. What you're going to do, I'm not going to fully set up on the board over here, but I'll show you at least so you can uh see the basics over here. Uh you have this board over here. This is the board where all the seashells are going to go. And for the sake of this example, I'm going to throw a bunch of seashells on the board just so you can uh see how it plays out. We have our bucket. That's important. We have a bunch of various spots on the board. And this is going to be a midame setup because every single one of these 64 spots is going to be filled when the game begins. But what you're trying to do in the game is you're trying to move the bucket and trying to collect various shells. So, let's pretend this is the board stay right now and the bucket's over here. On their turn, a player can move the bucket to its row or column, collecting that thing. Sometimes it's a shell, sometimes it's not. So, for example, over here, maybe we'll move it over here and we'll collect that star, placing it onto our playerboard.

Obviously, we'd have a bunch more things on our playerboard because we're playing Midame over here. The next player can get again go row or column, collect that thing, putting onto the playerboard. So, all you're doing is you're wandering around this beach over here collecting various things. Collections of fishbones will be worth three points if you get a head and a tail. Sand dollars are worth a simple point. These bottles give you an extra turn, so you can take two turns in a row, which can be very helpful. But then the shells are the main thing. The shells are the way you score because at the end of the game, for each color and for each type of shell, whoever has the most will get points. And then the second place points as well. You can get three points for having the most, one point for having the second most. There's a whole tie structure. There's only one of each type. There's only one of each type. So effectively, you're playing a collecting game. game. It's a fairly straightforward collecting game as you try to gather resources based on how you're going to try to score. There's also like a hidden card aspect where you have one hidden shell other players can't see. Uh overall, this is this is a fun, charming, very kid-friendly, very approachable uh game from KTVG. I do find rating KTVG games or kids games in general always a challenge because there's my personal enjoyment and then there's my desire to play it with my kids, how I feel it works as a family game. Personal enjoyment wise, this is a three out of five. It's a good game. It's fun. It's simple. I've enjoyed playing it. I've enjoyed playing it multiple times. It's straightforward as far as what the game is doing and how it operates. It's a good game. But as far as a kids game, it's a great kids game. I'm still going to leave the rating at a three because again, I have a hard time. My own rating system has a meaning. It doesn't really work as well with kids games. Uh what I'll say is that this is it's an easytoplay kids game that is very it has

enough strategy as a hardcore gamer that you're at least intrigued by what you're doing. you're trying to play to optimize to an extent while also not trying to destroy your kids. Uh it's a it's a game that the kids can play by themselves. My kids have already played this by themselves as well. And it's again it's very easy to dive into once you play a single game. The overall rule structure I mean age is always a tricky game. But I would say that a six six or seven that was unintentional. I'm sorry. A six or sevenyear-old plus can uh can can probably dive into this game pretty easily. Uh the only thing you have to really wonder about is the mathing and the optimization aspect. But it's very charming, very fun. Uh, if you like games like oh my gosh, what's their vegetable game? The sliced vegetables, chopped chopped veggies, whatever it is. Chopped dice veggies, chopped dice. I'm forgetting the name of their game, but the chopping vegetable dice. If you like games like that, this is very much that kind of vibe. It's another solid game from KTBG. And then lastly, we have Sea Scrolls. If you liked Hannah Makoji, that's not true. If you liked Arboritum, that's the game I was going to say. If you liked Arboritum, Sea Scrolls is doing the same thing, but completely different. Meaning, it's not going to it's not the exact same as Arboritum.

It's not like, "Oh, yeah, read, you don't need this." But if you like that kind of game puzzle, that's what this game is offering. So, we're going to have a whole bunch of cards over here. You're going to have a deck. Let's go ahead and put a bunch of cards. Uh players are going to start by having their own two cards in their hand. So, you're going to have two cards in your hand that are your cards. Happen to get two nines over here. Maybe I didn't shuffle from the last game. Don't remember. Then, you're going to have a uh a set of cards over here that are going to be in the middle. This is the reef. It's equal to number of players plus one. You have these cards in the reef. Players can take at any point. But on your turn, you're going to take two cards from the deck. You're going to add them to your hand and then you're going to figure out one one of these cards to discard. So you have your starting cards and I'm for example, I'm going to discard this 10 because I'm eyeing the seven in the reef and I don't want no people that have it. And because it's a new number is going to create a new school in the reef. Basically what you're doing is you're trying to get sets of cards. There are seven sevens, there are nine nines, there are six sixes. So there's a degree of mathing it out. Not all cards are in the game every single time you play those. So it's not perfect information. And what happens is at the end of the game when everything's all said and done, you're going to reveal your hand. And then whoever has the most of each number is going to score that many points and the other players are going to lose that many points for having that that number in their hand versus the other players who have anything except for the most. Most are tied for the most is going to give you uh the points. So I have the most sevens, I'll get sevens. If I don't have the most sevens, if I have one or three or whatever it is, if I don't have the most though, then I'm going to lose points equal to that value. I would lose seven points, which means this is a game where as you play, you're trying to basically either score or not have it at all. So, for example, if at any point I think I'm no longer getting the sevens, then next time I draw two cards, maybe I

intentionally discard the sevens to the middle. That's part of the game. The other hook of it is that three times per game, you can pull from the middle to put them up in front of you. You kick all the cards of that type from the middle, putting them in front of you, and players will know what's in front of you, but you have that ability where you're kind of constantly discarding to the middle, and then occasionally pulling from the middle to put them in front of you as you go. The overall puzzle is extremely satisfying as trying to figure out exactly how far to push it. It gives me very strong vibes of arboritum. Again, if you've played Arboritum, it has that kind of vibe of like, okay, well, I'm trying to go for this thing. Am I actually going to score it or am I wasting my time in it? I can't go too broad because I won't get anything. I'll just get a whole lot of lost points. But if I specifically focus in the right areas, I can optimize around it. Two players is a highly strategic game because you can kind of optimize to a degree. Like, hey, if there's seven sevens, if I get four of them, I'm I'm set. I'm I'm guaranteed to score sevens with four of them. When you're playing at a higher player counts, that math gets fuzzier because sure, you're still guaranteed to score the sevens if you get four of them, but do you really want to get four sevens when there's a bunch of players and you know, Tom might have one. There's one might be not be in play. How many do you really want to double down on as you go through it? The game is overall a tight balance of making decisions as to what to go for and to when to pull from the center reef. And then to mix it up, because I love games that mix it up, there's a whole bunch of rule variants that you can add rule variants to the game that change up the gameplay. So you can introduce those those that give you small modifications to the way the game works. I love rules variants because they take a game that otherwise you can solve as you go through it and they make it uh more engaging for longer. So that's Cools over here. It's a fun, challenging optimization, hand

management game. Overall rating wise, I'm going to give this a four out of five. A very solid pull. Build your hand. The variants add to the scores. Variants add to the replayability and enjoyment as well. That's going to be Sea Scroll from Renegade Games, who I think did they make the newest Arboritum? They may have made the new Arburedum, by the way. That's that's a tangent. That's just this this game just makes me feel like Arboritum. Anyways, that is going to be a review of these three games. We have Seashells, Sea Shells, which is a three out of five. But again, it's a it's a hard it's hard to give ratings on kids games because of my own enjoyment versus what I think they do. I do think it's a very solid uh children family game. French Toast, which is a fun party game that definitely has a very unique hook, but it's a party trick of a it's a party trick of a party game. Uh it works, it's charming, but I prefer other party games overall. And then Sea Scroll, definitely a very challenging hand management scoring puzzle that is very satisfying with high replay-ability. In any case, and until next time, I'm Alex Radical from Board Game Co. I hope you found these reviews helpful.

Progress saved