Skip to main content
Loading video...

Ranking EVERY Root Faction from BEST to WORST

Transcript 1:16:32

Hello and welcome back. Thank you for being here. This is the only, and I mean only board game channel you will find on the internet that is dedicated to thorough classic, sophisticated

taste testing.

Taste testing. We are going to not only be listing, reviewing, and ranking all of the root factions with the new factions that I have yet to play, but I have

included. We are also going to be along the way taste testing in the most professional manner possible. I have my pallet cleaner.

Pallet cleanser.

I won't spit it,

but it will give me a good reset between the flavors. One of the interesting things that most people don't realize, one of the things that actually brought Patrick Leer from Leader Games to fame with the original printing of Vast

was a individual coating of various flavors, sweetened

paint

on each one of the characters he released. single use. Single use.

They stopped doing it after the first printing until this last wave of root. The reason being choking hazard. Luckily, if you look on the back of your root box,

I think it's less choking hazards. And uh people were complaining about sticky fingers.

No, no, no. It all if if you if you if you sucked effectively,

stickiness was completely reduced after the first use.

I am good at sucking effectively.

So, it it could be a problem. But that was not actually the the loudest complaint was from parents across Facebook saying it was a choking hazard. Their teenage sons were putting meeples in their mouth.

Meeples in their mouth.

The most recent printing of root, this last wave to arrive. If you have the most updated version, will not only have a thorough choking hazard listing in the fourth page of the rule book, I think two paragraphs down, but also the back of the box does denote

single use only.

Base game needed choking hazard.

Yep. In that order.

Yeah, it does. The age range has also increased. I think these are they're 14.

I think they're 14 now. Yeah. Europe restrictions. There are some weird restrictions. Caterary eggs faced the same problem back in the day, I believe. So, yeah, we're going to be ranking and reviewing every single one of the root factions based on our own personal preference and their distinct flavor.

Yes.

Where are we starting, Wes? Uh well I think we should start with the corvid because uh the corvid you know it the question is yeah

is it grape

or is it some sort of other berry like cough syrup grape?

Sure. I I have heard many people think it's more like an artificial grape

as opposed to like a blackberry or or something that would be a richer more organic flavor. So I

is my favorite faction

as far as I know and as this review will probably display.

This is this is tends to be my number one. The flavor may adjust this though. So rankings could go anywhere.

It's Are we Are we ranking our favorite

uh taste or are we ranking our favorite or do we do both?

I think both things need to be included. I think both things need to be included. I think the final listing we have,

except for some except for some very brutal exceptions

due to just poor flavor choice,

poor flavor choice,

will be our favorite factions in rank.

Okay,

top to bottom. Best top. All of them.

All of them. Best factions of the game.

Well, you guys are in for a treat. So are we cuz these taste good.

However, if they've messed up the flavoring.

Yeah,

factions may be adjusted on the list.

It's true. We could

correspondingly

we could punish them. It's true. I'm likely to

y

this is,

by the way, a proposed video series for Retin Link if they're uh interested at all. So, [sighs]

a hint of blackberry.

I am concerned though that it's going to be more scent than flavor.

Is it currant or is it blackberry? Cuz those are those can be confused.

I don't have currant on it. [snorts]

I'm going for it. I'm popping it in.

Okay, let's do it.

M. You going to go roll around?

Mm-m. M. No. No. Well, it's a very synthetic. Very synthetic, but a great flavor to me. Not quite Robbitas.

Honestly, I'm not even sure that I've finished. I've I've I've cycled the first use. There might still be half use of left.

Yeah. Yeah.

I'm not I love the Faction. I'm not that into the flavor.

Yeah. I I I definitely feel it it leaned heavier Robbitasen than true fruit flavor.

As an advocate for the Corvette, I'll explain very quickly why I love the faction. so much.

Yeah,

I like the fact that they just breed chaos on the board. I love I love the stressful moments of unflipped little is that a bomb? Is that a trap? Is is he sneaking up on me or does he just want to have some coins so he can go shopping a little bit more? You don't have to be violent and you can get 15 points in a turn if people have just ignored you long enough.

If they've ignored you long enough.

I love that. I love the gamble of it. It's It's one of those that really just you can sink your teeth into. I say we go for a relatively uncommon flavor.

The Duchy.

The Duchy.

The Duchy is supposed to be a peach.

Supposed to be a peach.

Yeah. Modeled after they flavor choice is hard on this one cuz it's mostly skin color.

Yeah.

They went they went off of one of uh Cole Worley's favorite books, James the Giant Peach.

James and the Giant Peach.

And the peach skin does have a little bit of a rump shape to it. Duch like if you imagine the duchy just kind of walking along.

Yeah.

Big old but

big old big old butchies.

Pop it in palette cleanser first.

Oh yes. Absolutely. We don't want any of that tussen

peach. M.

Wow.

That is a surprising flavor.

Really just like

Mhm.

Mhm.

Well, that that's nice.

I'd go for seconds. In fact, I might do one per game so that I've got a I've got a fresh

You just pop one in.

I've got a fresh taste every time I play for the next 30 or 40. Nice thing about the Duchy. Good flavor for a faction that has so many meuples.

So many meuples.

You didn't want a bad flavor on this one.

That's true. And their underground ability to be able to move around and then just pop up random places with a bajillion meuples on the table

really does uh

surprising, refreshing, clean. I like this a lot.

Where does Dunie Duche sit in rankings for you? Are you putting them? And where did where did Corvette sit in rankings? Like what's your list looking like? Cuz right now it looks like they're it's the favorite for both of us.

It's definitely Corvette is definitely not my favorite because one of the things that that I dislike about Corvid is while they yes can do 15 points in one turn, they also can do zero points in one turn

or zero points in most the game.

Yeah. Uh everything that you've prepared for all of a sudden gets blown up because you can't do the one thing that that uh card tells you you have to do. Uh and really kind of screws you up. So that that for me I I do put them still in the top five. So I'm going to temporarily put them in my number five space. But they could make sure you camera here. So you're I mean you're at the very edge of camera. That's why I adjusted you already once.

Already once.

Yeah. So that's okay. Well,

yeah. Good.

Uh I'm putting Duchy as my number two. I love playing the Duchy.

I truly love playing Duchy. They are a very interesting faction for me. They do frustrate the heck out of me, but pretty much all factions do.

They have too much girth for me personally.

Really,

I can't handle it all.

It does. Uh, they are girthy and fleshcoled, so there's that.

I like playing against the duchy. They add stress to the game. They can pop up almost anywhere.

Almost. Yep.

Because I like I tend to play smaller, more nimble factions.

I can kite the Duchy pretty well.

Fair. But the Duchy verse another big faction is something to behold. I don't want to play Marque vers Duchy. I don't want to play Erie vers Duchy. Both of those have organic systems that need to maintain order. Correct.

And Duchy are good at disrupting. They're good at breaking a single link in a chain that can crumble someone's entire game. I have seen it happen. The Duchy didn't win,

but they did ruin someone else.

They had a great time. And sometimes that's really all you need.

They're going to be middle of the pack right now for me.

H. This is up number one. I think it's staying there to be honest.

Yeah,

that's surprising to me.

So, my my one through five is going to be important and interesting. My number two certainly interesting. I haven't even decided yet.

Oh, okay.

Flavor is going to impact that a lot.

Yeah,

but Duchy, I think they might be in the five or six zone. They're definitely up there.

I'm not sure where they set. Who are we going for next?

Oh, we are 100% going for a hirling in this one.

Hierirling. Not one that needs to be added to the list.

No. No. This is just because it's a

This is just I'm concerned about this one though.

Banana flavor's never been my preference. I've heard a reference towards Laffy Taffy. I have to say if that is what this is, I will be left disappointed.

Yeah. I'm hoping for more of that uh that instead of that uh that true banana-y flavor when it's kind of overripe, I want more of that underripe slightly green banana. The problem with the true banana flavor like Laffy Taffy style is that those bananas actually went extinct so long ago that we don't have them in our current flavor profile as a species anymore.

That's very true.

So the bananas that we experience are no longer I heard Laffy Happy banana flavor closer to original banana than you would assume.

Yeah. And we don't want them to go so far the other direction that they hit plantain because no one likes plantains unless they're fried.

I like fried plantains. I will stand with you on that one. But raw plantains, which I have tried, Very gross.

Good.

Tuberous almost.

Very very potato-like. Starchy beyond a responsible measure.

Leak.

Nope. Oh, wow. Wow.

Nope.

Wow.

Nope. Really bitter. Honestly,

that that hit me in a way I was not expecting.

Yeah. Well, that I can't even finish that.

Like right on the front of the tongue. It just was straight the contrast between the lovely uh peach mole.

Yeah, that which was actually quite pleasant.

Okay. I like I like the hierlings. It's a good expansion. I like mixing it in. Add some chaos. Keep the flavors to the core game.

Yeah, absolutely. We should not be experimenting with uh with outside abilities like that.

Where we going? Who who next?

Okay. Lizards. Lizard faction. We definitely need to do the green apple. I want it to be Granny Smith, not Jolly Roger. If it is sour enough, it could change the rankings for these because I don't like the lizards. This could actually start to redefine my relationship with them. Okay.

I'm very open. Let's get the bitterness out.

Yes, definitely.

Okay. [snorts]

A promising promising promising nose.

Sweet at the front.

Yeah. Yeah. We just need that tartness because it's very important. Otherwise, we go too far. I'm I'm actually hopeful because the overpowering sweetness at the front indicates there might be some tartness. It's harder to get that tart in the in the nasal gland.

Yeah. Without the tongue.

Yeah. Without the powder. Yeah. All right. I'm going in. Oh. [clears throat]

It's not what I was expecting.

I don't not like it, though.

Mhm. It's like, you know, it's somewhere in between. It's not as sweet as a Jolly Ranch.

Not as sweet as the smell either.

No. It's almost like a like a Fuji apple, right? It's not quite Granny Smith tart.

I mean, full in, though. There's a hint of tart there. There is. It doesn't last long.

Yeah. It It's a It's a little bite, but not fully. But not fully. Not as not as tart as you would expect from a granny.

I find the lizards very hard to wield. I don't like the lack of movement. I don't like the constricted play style. They fall into the same camp with with some of the others. And I have to admit, the Corvid can sometimes be lumped into this grouping. True. They breed chaos by being disruptive by burning everything to the ground. The Woodland Alliance is very similar in this. The The Lord of the Hundreds is very similar in this in some ways.

They want to just wreck an entire clear. They want to convert it to their own methodology.

It's the conversion part that probably gets me. I I feel like

I find they frustrate the people I'm playing with and they're hard for me to play.

Yeah. it. The restriction of getting meles out on the board really does put them at a disadvantage I think for most people because they are a much more complex faction.

What do you think about the discard discard pile mechanic though? They add an interesting way that people have to adjust their play style

if they want to try to control what the Lord of the hundred are doing.

Mhm.

No, not Lord of the 100. What?

The Lizards.

What the lizards are doing.

Yeah. Because because as you play and you if you're paying attention to what's the hated faction, if you're paying attention to like what is what is declared death.

Sure.

You got to not bury too many of the cards that you you know from a clearing that you need to keep yourself at.

Yeah. No, I agree with you.

I do find that unless someone's pretty deep in the game though, they don't pay attention to the graveyard mechanic

very often. It'll sneak up on people and that is a frustrating part cuz you're like, I didn't even know.

Yeah.

I just played three foxes, man. I didn't even know you could do that.

Mhm. And now my clearing doesn't exist.

They're going towards the bottom for you.

They are going to the bottom for me as well.

The flavor might actually adjust them by I think a score of two.

Yeah. I I think I mean how many do we have? They're they're definitely towards the bottom. I would say in that like seven or eight range. Yeah. [clears throat] Yeah. I think this where they have to be.

Start with a baseline

palette cleanser.

Let's start with a baseline. Marquita Cat Classic.

Classic original core box.

I have actually tried before. Mhm.

before they started adding flavors.

Yeah.

I gave this one a good swirl. It tasted very

woody. Yeah.

So, I'm looking forward to actually an improvement on something that I've experienced in the past.

No, obviously.

It's like it's like wine.

Correct.

Before it was wine. It was like grape juice that's now turned into something aged, more refined.

Sure.

Sprayed with a chemical solution that awakens a lively uh neurological reaction in your brain. Now, do we hope for Valencia orange or do we want mandarin orange or blood orange? Because you never know. I mean, orange is such a a an odd flavoring opportunity.

Yeah. I What's the brand of Japanese oranges that are like $5 a piece? Those are my favorite by far. I I actually hope more for a tangerine flavor. I think a core tangerine would be better than an orange here. I don't expect it, but I hope for it.

Okay. What do they call those things in in England? Aren't they something different? They're not tangerines. They call them some other weird name.

I don't remember. Let us know in the comments if you know. If you know, you know. I'm not getting a strong orange scent.

And I'm even trying a little bit of a scratch and stiff here.

Are you sure that you didn't grab some of the original meeples from one of your other boxes?

No, these this is all from the new printing.

All from the new printing. Okay. H

I'm wrong. This is wood.

Yeah,

this has no no orange on it at all. That is already pre-lit. I did try a few of these before getting into the cycle.

That could be a thing.

There's no orange on that at all.

Yeah, I didn't I didn't get anything other than

So, where does the faction land though?

You know, I think everyone has that nostalgia for

must be from the old box. I'm I'm sorry about that.

That's okay. That's okay. I I think I think a lot of people

get the other faction or we're just going to keep going with this

because fairly

people have tried this one. If they've tried any of them, they've tried this one

because it's so original.

Well, it's classic.

Yeah. And you've got that nostalgic effect.

But I but I already really enjoy it.

You already know the orange flavor. If you're watching this, you already know what this So, you can determine the flavor. We're going to rank the We'll rank the faction.

We'll rank the faction.

Please ignore uh my lapse in judgment for the flavor here.

It's okay. The the nostalgia effect, I think, is going to put this higher on most people's charts. But let's be real, they're one of the factions that you have to play a lot because they are one of the bigger factions. So there to make that math work for bringing in the faction that you really love, somebody has to play them.

Yeah.

And that's where I think it fails.

Watch this.

Mhm.

Going right up here.

I'll tell you why. I'll tell you why. They're clean, straightforward to play. I can either reliably teach them to someone or here's here's what you're saying. You're saying someone has to play them.

Yep.

I'm always the person and I never mind.

I'm always I always am happy to play play if if someone has to play Marquita Cat. I want to watch other people experience a new faction and I want to set the tone of the game and have a stable functioning woodland society.

But see, I don't I disagree with that.

You don't have to. That's that's why I volunteer and you play you play new chaos.

Yes. Agreed. Cuz that's my favorite. But for me, I think they're in the top five. They might be top three. Not because they're good, but because they're reliable,

but does reliability like Okay. Does I mean, if does reliability actually equal fun playability?

I don't think so.

I think they are fun to play. I think they set I think setting the standard for the game, setting the baseline for the game is a fun experience, especially when instructing new people.

If you're talking about from a clerical standpoint of ex instructing new players, yes, I agree with you. They're the best for that. But for me, that means that they're the easiest to play. They're the most simple. They're the most straightforward. And nobody wants to play them anymore.

That's wrong. I volunteer to play them all the time. I volunteer to play them all the time. Not because I have to, but because I think they're a reliable, good faction, and because I have to. It's both.

I am also one of those people though who happen to still have very fond feelings towards things like the White Lion, which you fight 50 times in Kingdom Death Monster. Everyone gets tired of, everyone wants to replace him. We put in a Gorm, wants to put in a frog dog. Not me. I like things that are just good, clean, straightforward. They set my introduction to the experience and that introduction has nostalgia and that nostalgia has value. I like stories just like you like Malort,

right?

Oh, wait. No. Um, you just want to rip the lion's dick off.

I do like punching it in the throat.

Mhm. Uh, no. I disagree. And that's okay. We have different opinions.

My list right now is Corvid Marquee moles and lizards. I'm putting them behind the lizards

because I do not want to play them. I I don't dislike them necessarily, but I've been forced to play them so many times I don't want to play them anymore. So therefore, that makes me less

I enjoy them less.

Makes you a

a jerk. That's okay. I always make somebody else play the big faction and then I can have fun with them.

You like how you like how like even with all the jokes and humor and back and forth and Yeah. Yeah, I still couldn't quite bring myself to even suggest that you were a bad fan. Like I was like, I don't like this joke. This isn't the joke I want to make. I couldn't think of something to replace it, so I still mumbled it. But

yeah, no, that's totally fair.

The stuttering beforehand.

Those of you out there who are like, wait, he likes the moles so much and he's their big fashion. Yeah. Okay, but moles are new, so you know, get over it.

Screw you, George.

Yeah, George in the comments. George,

what's the next one?

Uh, why did I pick the Oh, no. You picked the cats, didn't you? Yeah. Okay, we are going to go over another of the core box.

Okay,

we are pulling out our good friends, the Woodland Alliance.

Mhm.

The little piece of toast.

The little piece of toast.

They didn't They had an opportunity here to spice it like toast.

They did. They didn't go for toast.

They did not go for toast. I'm concerned because I I worried that this is more lettuce than it is anything else.

Really?

Yeah. I've I've heard broccoli. I've heard it's very vegetable focused.

Yeah. But they went for strawberry.

They went strawberry, which is also a problem because it's not red. So, does that visually, unless you're color blind, does that visually make a difference?

For me, it doesn't because they went they had such a harsh red up here

flavor-wise. They could have gone watermelon.

They could have.

They went strawberry. I think the green tops denote enough on its own. The fact that you're saying that it leans more vegetative than strawberry. Strawberry are vegetative in flavor. They are, but only when you pick them up at like the very early parts where the where the bottoms are still very white.

I was looking forward to this. I'm concerned that they've gone too natural on the strawberry flavor. It's actually not. Cuz you always think strawberry is sweeter than it is.

It's very tart. It's very tart for the original strawberries.

And without the seeds, is it really strawberry without that like seed that gets stuck in your teeth? You know, we'll see. I don't know. We will see. I just I can't get past when someone says broccoli. It's like licking the top of a broccoli stalk. It

It's It's a less ripe strawberry.

A very less ripe strawberry.

It's a less rice ripe strawberry.

Yeah.

Which is disappointing because strawberry could be a a pretty good flavor.

It could be. It could be a great

I do find most people disappointed with a strawberry though.

So this is just gonna be another one of those.

Yeah. How how do you rank them?

The decision I have to make

Yeah.

is are these behind or above the lizards?

I don't like either of them.

Yeah.

The question is, do I like the thematic overtones of the Lizards? The cult.

Yeah. The cult aspect.

Does that overpower the lack of movement and the frustration way that they play? or do I like the infection that is the classic spreading of the Woodland Alliance, the rally to arms and convert people to your cause? I think they have to go above the lizards for me,

but I would never willingly choose to play either of them. I'm happy to play against them, although less than happy usually,

right?

But I am happy to play against them if someone really wants to play them. Yeah,

they're never in my list of what I want to have on the table.

I am in a a complete agreement with you. And perhaps that's because it's Core Box again and we're going back to some of those original ones and like do I really like this one or do I not really like this one? Um I have not been forced to play this one numerous times. So I I think I've only played them a handful of times at best. They're not my favorite faction for that for the exact reason that you mentioned is that again there's all that heavy restriction on what you put out, what you do with them. Um

they are able to blow up. They're able to destroy everything when they do which sometimes is very frustrating for other players. But the precision you need to get to the point where they can explode,

yeah,

is a lot. And the ability for other players to counteract their spreading

early on in the game can really destabilize the balance quite substantially. You kind of have to ignore them knowing that you're setting your own doom and let the clock play out as it will.

And and which I think has gotten worse when you as the newer factions come in, they have more and more tricks in their bag to break up the alliance. I'm going to put them very

Lizards were one of the strongest factions back in the old days of Shut up and sit down review the funnest or the highest ranked on my list of what to play

strategically. I think new factions have been introduced to start disrupting what they bring to the table because both of them were very strong originally. Yep.

And so that has al also kind of made them worse like you're saying like they're not they weren't the funnest but they weren't some of the toughest. So you might play them because you're going to be you want to compete kind of you want to try to win.

Yeah.

And now the new factions are both funner

and breaking them up more effectively.

It is interesting though if you look at the review right now Corvid is still the top for me.

Yeah.

And Corvid is mechanically thematically very similar to these two factions.

But the restrictions are different.

I know the restrictions are very different. Corvette are open.

Yeah.

But the way that they are laying, the way that they are blowing up, the way they are scoring off of a sequence of things. I need four tokens revealed to score my 15 points in a single flip.

Yeah,

that is the same strategic, precise, slowm moving infection that these two represent. And yet the freedom of movement, the lack of restriction here, and the beauty of stressing other people out without always being cruel to them. These guys are always mean when they blow up. I don't have to be. I can be I can be

You're like, it's just what the cards said I had to do.

But the I don't always have to have a bomb.

Just a coin purse.

Just a coin purse. Just just shopping.

Mhm.

Or these if they flip.

You're done.

You're done.

Yeah, you're done.

It the heavy guys right now are right behind. They're, you know, they're right here in the middle. But yeah,

the contrast between the two for me is pretty steep. I think a lot of people that like these factions probably also like Corvett. Yeah, but it it that's like comparing Niagara Falls to a leaky faucet.

I like both.

I only like the falls.

I've spent hours entertained by either west. Hours I don't know

entertained by either.

Where we go next?

Long-awaited.

Oh, the frog's new line.

Long aaited. Brand new. This is actually what prompted the new flavors being added back into the leader games line.

Yeah.

Kind of a surprising move.

Yeah.

To bring flavors back alongside Skunks and Frogs.

Yeah. Do you think pea soup was the way to go though?

I think it is reminiscent of the classic Thanksgiving sodas and Christmas sodas that I used to buy as a teenager. I think there's some nostalgia to it.

Okay.

I didn't like those, but I did always enjoy buying them. Same thing with like bag of jelly beans from the Harry Potter universe, right?

Granted, this isn't branded.

Bean Boozled.

Bean Boozled. Yeah. I I did always enjoy the experience not only of trying myself but also then like sharing with grandpa you know who always for some reason took a sip like I liked that

this is calling back to a yester year and I appreciate Patrick for doing that.

Yeah.

Do I think this is going to be good?

No,

not a bit. Do I kind of want it to be bad?

I mean it's like licking you shouldn't lick frogs in in a real time. The interesting thing, they didn't include this in the rule book,

but in a interview about 7 months ago or so,

they did hint that one of the original,

you know, lose the game rule, like one of the fun little things they were thinking about including

Yeah.

as a punishment for the losers, you have to lick the toad.

Oh,

they thought it was a little bit too adjacent to hallucinogenics. They thought they didn't want to get into the drug culture of it. So, they didn't include it in the rule book. It would have probably risen the age level restriction of the game.

But, it's in the era. It it's it's in an interview.

It's in an interview

talking like like

which basically is that might as well be the erotic

you know I I saw at one point they mentioned that

if you lose the game while playing against the frogs

just that

you give the toad a lick.

Does he turn into a princess? Do you start seeing wild things? Does it just taste like bad pea soup?

Who knows?

You will soon.

We're about to find out. Cleanse that palette.

All right.

Are you even giving this one a whiff?

I don't think so. I think you have to go right into it. Do you smell the frog before you lick it? No,

absolutely not. You just lick it. [sighs]

Oh, the snazberries taste like snazberries.

It's I mean it's

It might be soup. It might be frog.

It might be frog. I don't know.

Yeah, you never know.

Like I haven't eat a lot of toads in my life.

That's true.

But I I have had a few bowls of pea soup.

That definitely has a flavor that's familiar in some ways.

I But I don't want to go back.

No, definitely. I'm going to leave I'm going to leave the front unlicked, I think.

Yeah, same here. I lick the back, too.

Uh-huh.

Yeah, definitely don't lick the front. Who knows what happens there?

Wow. Okay, you

mechanically, how do these play?

Okay, so the mechanically these guys are very peaceful in theory. The key with these guys is that they do change your clearings. They add a frog clearing whenever they put their little frog things out. So now that clearing is both fox and frog or bunny and frog. everyone's game because Well, no.

But not yet.

You're about to tell why.

I'm about to tell why. Because as soon as you attack anyone of their their people inside, you attack a frog inside of a clearing that has a frog element on it, that frog ele clearing becomes an angered element and it goes over top.

Everyone's game.

Everyone. And it's not just that one clearing.

It's relying on that clearing for things like crafting, for things like movement, FOR ALL OF YOUR MECHANICS are tied to clearing mechanics.

Yes. And it's so frustrating because not only is it the one clearing where you had the fight, it's also every other clearing that has your mele in it. So, if you're in a whole bunch of areas like you do with the with the Duchy or or with the Lord of Hundreds or others, you could have it end up being flipping all of these over. The the discount though for the frogs and the and probably the bad part about it for them is that they score points at the end based on the the clearings that they're in that are peaceful. So if they discard a rabbit card, all the peaceful clearings they score points for. So they have the potential to score three points every round.

So they want to remain peaceful and yet the way they establish and shut down and control is by being angry but also

kind of denaturing their ability to score points. And the other nice thing about them is they introduce a second uh draw pile into the game because they have a lily pad. So all the cards that are frog cards go into the lily pad and instead of drawing from the the top of the deck, you can draw directly from the face up pile that's there. So you see what card that is and you can decide whether or not to take it. So there are I think there's a lot of really great things about the frogs and they sneak up on you. They they start a little slow, but man, all of a sudden there's everything everywhere and you can't deal with it and you've now just let them

become very close to winning cuz I still won.

I love the introduction

Mhm.

of a second deck of cards.

Yeah.

Love card choice. Love open card choice. I think that's super cool. One of my favorite parts of games is a hand of cards.

Like deck building quite a lot. I love I love the fact that they are choosing whether or not to expand, be violent, frustrate, or

just be peaceful and score.

Yeah.

Leave me alone. Just let me keep going up the ranks. And other people have to also make that choice. Do I piss them off ruining my game?

Yeah.

By attacking them

or do I just let them keep going up three POINTS AT A TIME and I'm watching them climb the ranks. THEY'RE GETTING REALLY FAR AHEAD. I'm putting these guys, even though I have yet to experience them, I am putting these above the Marquee the Cat. This sounds like a faction that is so up my alley. And doubling that up with the fact that it has a very gross pea soup flavor,

which I can and will

Yeah.

based off rules punish other players because who's going to read the rule book to check if it's really there?

Nobody.

I will make other people lick the toad.

Absolutely.

And uh I stand by that. I'm very excited to play the these will be the next faction whenever I have a table that allows me to play a new faction.

Not doing my classic Marquita.

Fair.

I will be playing the frogs. They have the potential. They do overtake the Corv.

I can't do that yet because cuz I haven't played them,

but they have the potential. I'm probably the most excited about the frogs

than I have been about any other faction that's come out since the Corvid.

Yeah. Yeah, you're going to that if you put the corre the lizards since any expansion that's come out the frogs are the most intriguing to me other than the mysterious cloaked bombers and I was right about them. My instinct on those I knew I was going to have fun with them and I did

and they are awesome. Uh yeah, I agree. I actually I love the disruption. It was very frustrating to play against especially when you're trying to put mobs out and you can't roll the dice cuz everything's flipping green. Um so I enjoyed them quite a bit. I think they're definitely going above the core bid for me as well. So, we will see where they end up.

Well, they didn't go above the Corvette for me.

Well,

right behind.

I can change that for you if

Can you tell me your list? Well, yours is a little bit more scrambled than

here. We'll do it this way. Is that Is that better for you?

Well, not for the camera.

Okay. Well, make it better for the camera.

Okay. Thank That's That's how it is.

That's how it is right now.

Top top.

Top bottom.

Don't mind if I do.

What are we trying next?

Uh, you know, we really need to just mellow ourselves out. So, I think we need

We want to just round off base game.

Yeah.

Get the vagabond in here.

Get the vagabond in here and take care of it.

Yeah. Classic flavor.

Chocolate. I've got I've got

regular chocolate. You happen to have white chocolate here.

Flavor is supposed to be very similar. I I don't think they did a big distinct I think the spray that they coated everything with.

Kind of the same.

Kind of the same.

You know, like white chocolate is dark chocolate. It is still chocolate.

Like Skittles are all the same flavor, but the colors change, right?

So, it's the same concept.

Same concept.

Yeah. I don't know if I'm hopeful for chocolate or not. Pallet's cleansed. Let's give it a try. Let's see.

Let's see. We go. A little sweet.

It's very sweet.

I want it to melt.

I I do want to smell it as well.

That's the one thing I'm disappointed in.

The other thing is

it's just the flavor. There's no creamy melting.

I think you gave me one that you've touched a lot because I also I I do taste a little salt to go.

Could be could be almond. Try it again.

Try it again.

Get in your mind. Is that Is there a white chocolate almond?

Is that sea salt? Oh, it is sea salt.

It could be fingers.

I hope I hope it's not fingers.

One of the two.

But but I do I do definitely get I do definitely get that uh that chocolatey flavor.

Yeah.

Which I which I like.

Pleasant. Nice.

The the most dis disconcerting thing about this Yeah.

is instead of a nice lindent, you know, melting creaminess that's here.

Lint. Yes.

Yep. Lindent.

Uh you end up with a hard piece of wood at the end of your chocolate experience. Some people like hard pieces of wood, but others when you're looking for chocolate can still sometimes like hard pieces of wood.

I don't usually like finding it in the midst of my chocolate. I want a little bit creaminess to start with.

Hard piece of wood could come a little bit later.

Yeah.

Uh let's go ahead and set the vagabond down. I am going to do a confident placement. I'm pushing Marquita back. I'm putting the vagabond in overpowered theoretically

massively.

If the board ignores him, and he's easy to ignore cuz he's a single mele. You don't run around him. He just runs around being a hero.

He's just picking stuff up. Hey guys,

he can win all the time. You have to give a warning to your teach that whoever is playing the vagabond should be bullied a little bit.

Yep.

And you have to remind people during the course of the game because they just don't want to do it. They want to be friends, they want to trade, they want to sell, they want to buy,

etc.

Absolutely. However, because of that, and specifically because of the variation in different types of characters to play, starting gear that you can use, what you're going to find as people craft for you, as you craft for yourself,

they're just such a fun character.

Everybody wants to play the vagabond. Don't lie to yourselves. You've always wanted to play the vagabond because it's the most unique character in the game.

Feels like a little RPG.

It does.

I'M JUST THE HERO. I'M JUST DOING STUFF. That's why he goes above the duchy for me.

Yeah, he so far

top of the line.

He is my most favorite.

I need to back off. I didn't even realize. I need to back off a little bit. I need to give you a little bit. 30 seconds.

Why in the world did that just happen? That's insane to me. So,

I'm up there. Yeah,

I'm not there.

The the key for me and and most of you will know that I love take that games. Like, I love it when I'm out there with you and I just destroy everything you've ever wanted to do. So, it doesn't necessarily make sense that the vagabond is where he is for me. But what I love about the vagabond is that bartering element. And you know, we're going to see that in one other faction, but I love the opportunity to be like, "Hey guys, you know, I can help you with that."

And but it's going to cost you, but but I can help.

Yeah.

And then as we're playing, you know, little things happen. I happen to get this. I happen to get that. AND THEN OH, ALMOST. WOW. I'M AT 29 POINTS. How did that happen?

I wasn't even playing THE I'M NOT EVEN PLAYING THE POINT GAME. I WAS JUST I WAS JUST WALKING.

YOU WANT to help?

I just I'm I'm such a helpful guy and that to me is the reason I love I love playing

you you get to be the character more than any of the other characters.

Absolutely. You you get to really lean into the story element of your character and I think it that's the best one to do it with. I truly do. There's there's two other factions that I think you can do that with. I think so. lean in so hard to with this one.

I just love it. Love playing them.

Little bit of silver.

Little bit of silver. I'm a little worried that this might actually be Mercury. [sighs]

I don't think that's what they've established it as, though.

Well, it's not rubbing off on my fingers, so I guess it's safe.

But you never know. It's definitely shiny.

It is very shiny.

You think it's You think it's m You think it's lead paint?

They wouldn't do that. They couldn't sell it. They couldn't sell I mean, you never know what you get out of China these days, but uh

Yeah,

it's probably safe.

Yeah.

Yeah. I mean, I think Chrome was an interesting choice for uh for taste.

It's all right. Here's here's the idea behind it.

Yeah.

And it's a weird idea. I think they might have ran out [clears throat] of some of the flavors that were an option.

The idea is not chrome. I understand. I understand that's what it's listed as,

right? The idea is that it creates a cooling effect. I think I think they could have gone with like menthol or something for what they're looking to do with this.

That probably would have been better. Yeah,

chrome is the color and it does elicit like if you imagine a freshly washed a freshly washed kind of you just spritzed a little bit of alcohol on a nice silver spoon.

You pop that in like just fresh polish that metallic taste that's at the front of that that's cooling.

I I was going to say kind of like licking a 9volt battery. Yeah, that's what they're that's what they're going for.

Okay.

I don't have high hopes.

I I don't know how you're going to make how you how you manufacture that like electric flavor that that true metallic edge to it. But hey, I'm willing to give it a shot.

Oh. Oh, it

right at the front. It loses it immediately.

Yeah. It's like the battery died, but

it immediately

Yeah.

Yeah.

But right at the front, it is there's a taste of coolness like the like a spoon on the top of your tongue.

Yeah. Just a hint. It doesn't last long. Not a strong flavor, honestly.

No. But I mean, yeah.

Disappointing, I think, for what they could have done.

A little. Yeah.

But is a unique flavored item.

It is. And, you know, if you're looking for

Good for them for being experimental as well.

Also true. I think you do need to take some risks in this day

and what do we think about the faction though?

Uh, I'm going to be honest here.

I'm split on this one.

I have absolutely no idea who this is.

You've played against him?

I'm sure I have. This is probably my wife.

Yeah.

Let me Let me answer. Nope. Not my wife. I don't know who it is. So, I'm just gonna hang up because And turn my I answered. So, when I when I open my phone, it answers.

Yes.

And so, they just heard me say, "I'm just going to hang up."

And now everybody's going, "Oh my gosh, Jesse has a flip phone." Yeah. He's from Florida in the 2020s.

I'm pretty cool.

Let me catch my flip phone.

Let me just let guys let me text real quick. Let me send a message and give

4447778212.

But the the only the only issue is as I opened that it answered the call. So I hit the red button quickly and then um

so whoever it was was like hi um

I thought it was my lovely wife. I would have brought her onto the video.

That would have been great.

But it wasn't.

But it wasn't.

Back back to these guys you played again. You played me against them. These are the guys that need to set a triangle and pull something from the center of the map.

They're collecting. It becomes kind of a shield for them. They bring it home. They convert it into points. [sighs]

Yes,

they're a little unwieldy.

Yes,

they're a big faction.

Yes,

they can be strong, but you can't have too many of them at one location cuz they don't like having too much stuff.

I don't mind playing these guys.

Yeah,

I don't. But the Badgers are going to go behind the moles. I would rather play the Moles or play against the Moles than play with the Badgers. If you put them at the bottom of your list cuz you literally haven't you played against them twice, I believe, and can't even remember them.

That might warrant the bottom of your list. I would not fault you for it.

Yeah. And and and mean no disrespect to them, but I I definitely did not remember the look of them, and it might be because I purposefully blocked it out. Um there have been several games I've played against uh his highness over here who just absolutely destroyed me. Keepers in iron is the term you're looking for.

Yeah. Yeah.

Might be might actually be part of the inspiration for the flavor too. The name probably was a little bit

I I'm because of that and even now telling me about it I still like

not excited about it. So premise

I'm just going to put them away.

I feel like they were designed after ideas were running out

and ideas have only ran out now cuz Cole's left. If he

if he had any more ideas he would have stayed. Um, I don't know that I want to put that on him, but I I would say that there's a there's a lot of universe.

Wrap it up, boys. Game's over.

There's a lot of universe there.

Who are we trying next?

Who are we trying next? We are 100% going to the Otter.

Okay,

we have to go to the Otter.

I didn't know. Blue raspberry.

Yeah,

one of my favorite flavor.

Yeah,

one of my favorite flavors.

I'm so excited to try this one. It's been a while. It's been a hot minute. Yeah,

it's been a hot minute. Do we We need to get the chrome out of her mouth. I I'm going to Yeah. But do we dink and sink?

Oh,

do we dink and sink? I think we dink and sink.

We can try to Okay. I'm not really good at the dink and sink, but we'll try. We'll see what we can get.

Okay.

With all that chrome out.

Yeah, that's a lot of lot of lot of chrome.

Dink and sink.

Dink and sink.

I'm tossing to myself. You're tossing yourself. We're not

We're not cross tossing.

We're not Yeah, we don't want to cross the streams

and sink.

OH, YOU MISSED.

I'M NOT GOOD AT THAT. OH, THAT'S REALLY GOOD THOUGH.

WOO.

It's like a like a pie.

Oh, it keeps going.

Yeah.

Man, this is good.

M.

Yeah. A little bit of suction.

Mhm.

This is the most substantial flavor.

Oh, it's so good.

Blue raspberry is an established flavor. Yeah.

Very reminiscent of like an Airhead. A little bit of Jolly Rancher in there.

Yeah.

It's so good.

Just good. I think one of the problems that is so good I just want to suck on a piece while I'm playing the game.

Yeah, I suck so hard I got a little bit of the paint off of mine.

Yeah, you got to be careful about Yeah. No, that's This is This is great.

Otter.

Definitely great.

Otter. Oh man. Okay, I'm going to be quiet cuz I do have things to say, but I think you've got a lot of things.

I have a lot of things to say about the otter. Okay, now there is one thing that I love the most about the otter, and that is leaning into the thematic element, right? These guys are traders. is like, "Hey, the waterway's open, guys. Come on down." You set your pricing structure however you want. And where most people fail at playing the otter is that they set their prices too high cuz nobody wants to pay all that. So, it's super easy if you do it the right way. Set your prices low, make it nice and easy, people start trading with you, and then all of a sudden, again, you find yourself being up in the 20s and everybody's like, "How did that happen?" Because he hasn't done anything except sit on his butt the whole time over here in the sides. The one substantial weakness I agree with everything. My some of my best games of Root have been with a thematic otter player by far.

Player count needs to be high.

It does.

And if the table decides they just don't want to trade cuz they feel you're a threat

100%.

The otter start falling apart and it's so reliant on other people playing with you

that I find them really conditional. They that is one of the big negatives of the otter is if your table decides they're just not going to be with you, then that's going to be tough. And it's the same thing with the vagabon. If the table decides not to mess with you

or not to mess with you, you win.

Well, yeah. To beat you up to beat you up the whole time.

I understand. I think that's true for a lot of the factions, but I think the otter rely on player thematic interaction and mechanic interaction more than any other faction.

If I'm playing any of the factions and everyone groups me, I will lose. That's just how Root works. Everyone leaves me alone, I will win. That's just how Root works. However, here, I have no recourse for people just not interacting with me.

But it's the exact same thing. If they if they fight against you with all these other factions, you're going to lose if they decide not to mess with you.

I understand. But the difference here is they're fighting. You get to roll the dice. You get to play cards. You get to come back. You can always try to scrape your way forward. The otter, if they just don't trade,

it's hard.

What are you going to do?

Yeah.

You don't got anything. you don't you got to start sacrificing your own guys to build a pool big enough to try to make something happen but it's so hard and so the shutdown feels a lot less

it feels a lot less substantial and the opportunity to come back from a shutdown feels a lot less viable. It's my one big criticism of them.

It is a big criticism but I will also

still at the top of your list

get better friends. That's all I'm saying. Get better friends. people who actually want to win a game because you can win faster

two and you're on the list

if you play with uh the otter work on replacing you.

So for me now this may sound surprising cuz I do love my otter but for me

not the top

they're not the top. They go behind the duche

for the exact reason that you just said.

Okay. All right does hold water.

It does hold water because there is an opportunity there for them to get to get completely knocked out. Not completely, but to be heavily knocked out if you're not playing well and if the group decides to play against you because those but anytime that kind of happens, those people suck. You should get better friends.

You're going to be shocked.

Yeah,

mine are going into position three

as well, just like yours. Different lineup here.

Yeah, different lineup.

But position three, not because I want to play as them,

but specifically because I want desperately. My favorite imagined game of Root is a four or five player game of Root

where I have someone like you at the table playing a thematic otter.

Yeah.

Any high player game of Root that doesn't have a thematic otter isn't quite the game I want.

Mhm.

So,

I agree.

They're sitting right there. Not cuz I want them, but because I want them included.

Absolutely.

Let's keep going.

Completely agree. Uh I chose the Otter. Your turn.

I'm curious about these bats.

Curious about these bats. Now, I think it's important, this is one of the new ones, is that you need to look at this guy first, right?

Look at what he looks like.

Tell me that's not a rotten peep.

Like, let let me flip it over so you see the backside.

I mean, it is.

That's a rotten peep.

It is. I kind of I'm kind of disappointed that they went with so many joke flavors or experimental flavor. We got the rotten peep. We've got the uh little metallic tinge from the keepers in iron. Uh we've got the pea soup. The new box really leaned into the we're bringing flavors back and these ones are a little

a little unique,

little gross,

you know, but but with but with Malort and things like that, like it's the new thing on the ticky Takis,

you know, people are just like those weird flavor.

Maybe that's why they did it. Maybe they brought it back with this extra addition.

Yeah.

Like with this weird twist to make people talk about I mean I don't know that we'd be doing this video if it weren't for the fact that Soup was in the mix. Like Lick the Frog

that spawned the idea for this Spawn. Spawn. Yeah, that's good.

So key with the with the bats, just for the record, since it's a new faction. Uh the interesting thing about them is that they have these councils that they put out on the table. They kind of look like circus tents. Uh if the council is closed, again, this very peaceful faction. It's the theming element with this. You have to leave that in your mouth until I'm done talking.

I don't want to.

I don't care. Um, so here's they've got these beautiful tents and as long as the tent is closed, it's the council is closed and it is a okay. Uh, but as soon as that council is open, they flip it up and boom, now you can't put anything in there. You can't put your mobs in there. You can't put any tokens. You can't build a fortress, any of that stuff. It's very frustrating, very restrictive. But you can easily flip it over and you could do that at any time, which sounds great, right? Oh yeah, just flip that over. If you want to put something in there, flip it over. It's fine. What that means is that now they get to put little paratroopers on their board and they could just drop in anywhere they want to go. They're not part of the movement restrictions, which is incredibly incredibly frustrating. The other thing that's really frustrating about them, I don't care. You keep going. The other thing that is really frustrating about them is that they have the ability to just to push. You don't even have to battle them. You don't get to defend. They just push you. But you know what? they still roll both of those dad gum dice. So, they get to take the top number and they push them into another place. And when you're playing someone like Lord of the Hundreds and you've got to have empty clearings with just your stuff in them, yeah, they just push everything around the board. Now, all of a sudden, you haven't scored the nine points you're expecting to score.

Okay, it was only four, but still, you didn't get all the points that you deserved because they pushed everything into the area with you and you can only fight so much.

I have tears running down my face. Terrible. Yeah. [sighs] So, uh,

rotten peep. I don't know. Rotten certainly.

Yeah.

It's got that

I need I have to taste it.

I don't know why I leaned into the chubby bunny challenge. You mentioned doing it before the video.

OH WOW.

IT'S STRONG. It doesn't last long. So, adding extra does impact the flavor.

Oh my gosh. It's It's more rotten than it's specifically peep, but I don't know that there's a way to distinguish between rotten and

I just licked it. You put them in your mouth.

I like four.

Five.

Wow.

No. Six. I got to six. I gagged three times.

That was rough. That was really bad. That was really bad. I don't know how you did that. That was really bad.

I didn't even listen to what you said about them. I haven't played this faction or played against this faction yet. [snorts] I understand a little bit about what they do.

Mhm. [sighs]

Let me start. They're going in front of everybody else.

What

I want to play them so desperately because if you lean into chaos, that is what they do. I think they're incredibly good for area control, which is what this is. Because of that pushing mechanism, it is so frustrating to play against them. and the aerial element where you they can lock down an entire area with their stupid little circus tent and then they just paratroop into any spot on the board at any time is amazingly frustrating and I only won by one point because I was able to go before they did.

We play a slightly different game or lists displaying that.

Mhm.

Yours,

frogs, frogs and bats are switched for me, switched for you.

Fair. Yeah.

So, I I'm intrigued. I don't mind playing against them. I certainly will play them.

Flavor alone

way bad.

I'm surprised they're up there for you.

That's why it's chaos element,

but I I can't I'm not as excited about them. I've already put one new faction so high up. I certainly am interested, but I'm not interested for myself. I'm interested for the table state.

And there's just no way I can push down some of these other factions. I'm shocked. But because you guys you've experienced them,

I think this is a fair placement.

Yeah. yet an excited placement.

A a very excited placement. I

Where do you think they might settle is the question. Are they staying top of the line or is this a brand new can't wait to play? Can't wait to see like is this going to be your favorite faction? Is it really going to overpower the otter, the moles, the vagabond?

You know,

I'm fine with you leaving it, but I just want to

I honestly

five plays in. Give me five plays in.

Five play. I still think because they are such chaos elements.

That's so cool. And the other thing they can do,

I love that you're sticking with it. That's so cool.

The other thing they can do is block attacks to other things that are there. So like if someone wants to attack pieces, they have to attack you first. So like there's not you first as far as they they can attack other pieces that are there, but they can't take the things off the board, the little cardboard chits without attacking you first.

Okay, let's save let's save the last bad flavor for the end of the video. Let's go with the classic cherry.

Let's get the Lord of the Hundreds in our mouth. I need something to refresh. I had some whiskey on the back of that. I am concerned that the paint's going to start peeling off a little bit because I did put them directly in a pile of whiskey.

That's rough.

Luckily, I'm an artisan and I can repaint them if need be.

You are an artisan who doesn't paint.

Yeah. And I'll be getting a second copy anyway. Exactly.

I can sticker these if I have to.

If you have to.

And none of the others will be licked. So, no worry about paint coming off there.

It's true. Now, I because of that classic flavoring.

You think it's cough syrup? You think it's classic sour cherry?

I am concerned that it's cough syrup. I want I want sour cherry. I don't think I'm going to get it.

I don't think so either. I think you're going to get that like syrupy marishino. I

think it's going to be a cough drop.

Yeah.

Good for my throat, honestly. Yeah.

Not bad on my throat.

It doesn't have a menthol flavor, which I feel like I'm missing right now.

Doesn't have a menthol, but it does have that surface level.

Very much so.

Surface level cough drop cherry without the curative effects.

Yeah. And not like the good um what are those ones that are mixed with the yogurt flavors? Yeah, they're like either the swirly ones like those. I really

Those are mostly candy.

Mostly. Well, that's probably why I like them.

Yeah.

Uh, Lord of the Hund.

Violent.

Very violent.

Compelling.

Yep.

Demanding faction.

Absolutely.

A faction that is the fear of every player at the table. Unless every player determines that they are to be feared and then they are kind of pitting.

Very true. If every player is as scared of them as they should be. Yeah.

Here's the problem with them.

They look scary.

They look like a mob. They're rats. They're ravenous. Whereas some of these other factions that are very powerful, the lizards for instance, they don't look scary. Yep. The moles overpowering, overwhelming, not terrifying. Yep. The weakness of these guys is the fact that instead of being cute, instead of being adorable meles that I want to interact with,

they are violent offenders with a leader

who has a flag as a mast at the front of the pack.

Everything you said is true.

And you want to slaughter them and that makes them hard to play because they're violent, but they like violence is best ignored in Root.

They're fun.

Yeah,

they're fun. I am putting them [sighs and gasps] I'm putting them behind Marquita Cat.

How dare you?

This is This is This is where my my my list has to be.

Behind Marquita Cat

because Marquita Cat, I've already explained my reasoning. Classic, reliable. I will go to Marquita. I will volunteer to play it. I will be happy doing so. Lord of the 100. I'm wary about when I introduce them to the table.

Okay. From that perspective, it's fair because they are violent. They are they can be cumbersome to manage.

They scare the table and the table then responds and that can ruin the game. We played with Dennis.

We did

knocked out cuz both of us we were scared of him.

We were very scared. Yeah. And we kept him we kept him locked down

effectively.

Very effective.

It was a bad game for him.

It was a very bad game for him.

And less fun than he should have.

Yes. Which is okay. Sometimes that's the way Routt goes. I This is my favorite faction. I love playing them. which is stupid when you think about it from a thematic perspective. But here here hear me out.

I did not other than the fact that there is levels of take that with the Lord of the 100 that is not experience. I mean but there's levels of take that with these guys too. These guys are just screw you factions.

Yeah. But they're so is the openfaced no precision necessary raging inferno.

Wow. Yeah,

because there is nothing that feels better than to take four moves with your little your your captain guy and your little flag and you're like,

I'M COMING TO INVADE YOUR AREA. ALL HANDS ON FOUR DECK. And you just run in and you just smash an entire area with with like nine people. And then the ability to put the mobs out that just destroy all the buildings everywhere you go. There is nothing better than feeling so incredibly powerful. And I really feel like this this group, this this wonderful, beautiful faction gives you you the ability to feel like almost superheroesque because it's so painful when you're playing against them. Uh, and I truly enjoy that. But you're right, if you get them locked down, you're going to have a bad game. They It just sucks. But again, you know what I say?

Your opinion is don't don't get locked down.

Get better friends.

Yeah. Well, rip rip people apart.

Rip people apart from the very beginning.

Merch across the land. Yeah. If you're playing them, and this is one of the reasons why I think you like them. My instinct and most people's instinct in route is to pull your punches a little bit.

Make friends, pull back. Here's the problem with them. Because they're already scary.

Pulling your punches

opens the door to other people shutting down your game. Yep. These guys have no negotiation. They have no thematics. You need to precise and strategically destroy from the very beginning

everyone's core mechanic engine possible. You're fighting against the Marquita cat. Break their engine from turn two. You're fighting against the vagabond. Hit him as hard as you can before he even gets a second pair of boots. You're fighting against the otter. Don't create a single thing for them unless they're giving you the thing you need to destroy other people. You're fighting against the toads. Well, I don't know, but I assume you can wreck some havoc when they start flipping some tiles or set yourself up in a position where when you attack them once, you've screwed the whole board cuz they've just covered up all of the locations and everyone else has to deal with it. You're fighting against the Corvid. You're not going to leave a single token on the board for them to flip. You cannot pause.

Yes, this is wide open the entire time. Absolutely. From the very beginning. My other

straight here in the middle. They're straight here in the middle for me. I think if I played them more, I might like them more. I am always playing against them. I'm never playing on them.

Yeah. And and the other thing that's really nasty about them is while everybody else is crafting to get all these XP points, you can just go, "Hey, I'm going to have a battle with you, but I'm not going to hurt you. Isn't that great of me? But I'm going to take that thing." Which then makes me even stronger.

Yeah.

Yeah. And if you're really smart, you only take the one type of item so you don't lock yourself out of all the really great cards.

Yeah.

Yeah. I love playing them. I love playing them. Now, the question is, are you going to love this final flavor?

I'm not going to love this final flavor.

What do you expect charcoal to taste like? I've chewed on pencil lead before. Is are we going in earthy tone here? You know,

they can't get the grit that I'd expect from like a a brick of charcoal.

In theory, charcoal is supposed to make everything taste like nothing, right? Just adds that mineralyesque flavor to things. But I'm worried that we're going to taste that that there's going to be some sort of flavoring left on it in a way that kind of tastes like licking a fire, but afterwards.

Okay. Like smoky. Yeah. Like that's

a little hint of char.

Yeah. And maybe I'm also a little worried that there might be splinters in here because that's what I It feels like licking like, you know, you're licking true charcoal.

Don't chew down.

Don't chew down.

Yeah. I wouldn't take a bite of this one,

but that's part of the fun.

I keep waiting for that like juicy center,

but it hasn't happened yet.

I do love Gushers.

Yeah.

Last one. Let's round it off and we'll talk about the one I think the faction we actually know the least about. So, flavor is going to determine a lot on this one. We can't judge off of

anything. preference. I'm saying preference.

Preference. Sure.

We have flavor preference.

We're going to have to judge off of what it's claiming to be.

It's claiming to be charcoal.

So, let's set up this faction a little bit before we swing into it, though.

Yeah.

This is what are they called? They're called the Night Cage Alliance. What's the actual term?

Nav Deep Wood.

Naves of the Deepwood. The core concept here is that you're sending out skunks.

Mhm.

You're using these skunks to uh infiltrate

Mhm. the landscape. Yep. And bring back

uh victims, prisoners,

things

into the deep wood. The deep wood is composed of like seems like a weasel,

a boar. Yep.

And a goose.

And a goose.

And these guys are kind of incompetent leaders

who send their minions out. They score points by having their minions harbored, but you have a chance, other players. I mean, yeah.

To rescue your companions. It sounds hilarious.

It does sound hilarious.

Sounds really fun.

It does. It sounds kind of unwieldy.

Yeah, it does. I I love the idea of chaos. Chaos is my favorite element in a board game. I I love injecting that weird, spicy, crazy, like what the heck is he doing? Why is he doing that thing? Um, it's almost like Van Helsing, you know, just kind of a weird nut that's going after some guy's a vampire. But

I almost feel these are vagabondesque.

Yeah.

Like they set they set a good story line for the vagabond. The hero that can go rescue some prisoners. M they're almost vagabondesque in the fact that they're like the evil villain to the hero.

Yeah.

Sending out their minions, conducting an orchestra.

I'm I'm very interested to see how they play because I I I haven't seen it yet.

Yeah. So, here's an interesting thing I think is worth addressing here.

Yeah.

They did originally try to go for a skunk flavor.

The issue [clears throat] with the first round of prototypes that arrived back to Leader Game Studio, they actually cleared a couple rooms out for about a day and a half. The skunk flavor wasn't prominent. No one tastes skunk. Instead, the manufacturer did a pretty excellent job at the skunk smell.

Smell. Oh, that does happen.

The whole box was was infested. The other flavors that you really want to be distinct.

Yeah, they all smell like skunk.

They all had that hint of skunk. And so like you you couldn't really get a distinct skunk flavor without the smell imbuing everything. And that was going to ruin the experience of licking the toad. Y

that was going to ruin the experience of going ahead and trying the the rotten rotten peep

the rotten peep.

Yeah, absolutely.

So yeah,

they went with charcoal. I think I think it's

Do you think that was to clear the smell of the skunk from the original that's where the idea came from actually cuz charcoal does tend to absorb. I think though thematically it fits. If you flip him over, you got that little bit of what looks like like a charred rodent.

Yeah.

You know, like the charcoal brick there at the top. Yeah,

I think it works. I would have liked to experience the skunk.

I don't know that I would have.

Yeah, that

without it infusing everything.

Yeah, exactly.

I wish they could have found a chemical solution that would have given you the flavor of skunk.

Like when you lick it,

the airated Yeah, the airrated smell.

That could have been fun.

But I understand why they didn't.

Yeah.

Let's go for it.

Yep.

Okay, here we go. I really don't want to I don't want to taste it. Is that weird that I don't want to taste the charcoal? I feel like I But I'm gonna do it. We're gonna do it together.

Gritty.

Very little smoky. I think you're actually a little bit right on that.

It does have that smoky edge.

Mhm.

But it doesn't It's just It's just dark.

It's kind of bland.

Yeah. Bland. Open though. Here. Yeah.

Circle.

Okay. Okay. That's is That's the thing.

I'm now really a lot of the wood there.

Yeah. campfire.

Mhm.

That's nice.

Almost like a like a It Itarkens back to a s'more.

Here's the thing.

Them watching the video at home, unless they've tried that method, will not actually know that both of us are reacting to a flavor we are experiencing. You have to take one of these. Don't just don't just suck on it. No.

Put it in your mouth. You want to get air going around it.

Yeah. It's very different flavor. Now, I know that's the way it works for wine and things like that, but that irration is quite nice, especially with the smoky flavor.

I'm losing a little bit of on the second wave. The first wave was very pro. I don't know if you experienced the same thing that I did. The first wave had a lot of flavor, though. Those first few gusts.

I'm concerned that the viewer will think that, you know, these aren't flavored meeples. They'll they'll think that we actually aren't reacting to what was a distinct and noticeable quite pleasant flavor for me.

Quite pleasant. Yeah. Uh, surprising

without them trying this at home. They're going to have to do that.

Yeah, you do need to try

because there was a charcoal overtone to it.

This might be one of the more accurate flavors I've had.

I honestly think it's the most accurate.

It really takes me back to camping.

Yeah.

Yeah. And with that, you know, almost think of like the Fourth of July.

I like this a lot.

You're out by the camp.

I like this a lot. I would I would and in fact will uh double up. I will I will give this a one more swig. I want to get the arration early on in the process.

Mhm.

Does it make it even stronger?

Okay. Oh.

Oh, wow. It really It really does something.

It's right there. It loosens after a bit.

Yeah.

But something about the manufacturing process of this that

whatever they've, you know, could be could be that they wood burned these like to cut them out of the original prototype.

That's an And they just didn't clear up. Yeah. Wow. has a lot of that nice smoky char flavor. Where do these set for you? And should I go first or do you want to go first? Cuz they're going top half for me. Just so you know,

they're 100% going top half for me.

They're going top third for me.

I don't know if they're going quite.

Then you set you set first so I can react.

So I I love my thematic element. And I think because of that, I'm going to put them above the otter. And and here's my reason behind it. I think you can lean into crazy when you're playing

and just be like, "Oh, I don't know what's happening here. Oh, we got SOME GUYS. COOL. GO GET THAT GUY." YOU KNOW, AND YOU JUST HAVE A good time playing them. I I I don't again I don't know enough about them to truly say, so I'm not confident to put them higher than that, but I really think that that crazy element is going to make them fun to play.

Otter is right there for us, but I'm going right behind the otter.

Okay.

I want to play them a lot.

Yeah.

But still, I imagine a large player count game.

Yeah. Yeah, I always want the water otter there.

Yep, that's fair.

I don't know for sure. Like, let's go through Let's finish our hierarchy. Let's go through our list so we can round this video off.

We have a side quest.

We have a side quest because we have the goose and we have the weasel and we have the boar. Now, because it's not kosher, I'm going to take this one cuz that's ham.

Okay. I mean, technically the weasel isn't kosher either.

Well, you're not going to think about that. Um, that's okay. So,

this this might be kosher if there was a tradition of eating it. certainly is not kosher. Otter's not kosher. Skunk's not kosher. Little ferret thing's not kosher. The cat's not kosher. The rat's not kosher. The rat's not kosher. Mole's not kosher. The uh otter is definitely not kosher. Mouse isn't kosher. Literally nothing here with the exception of potentially the bird.

Yeah,

we didn't get the eerie.

We've missed the eerie.

Wow. I'm glad you figured that out now because if we went through this whole thing and we forgot the eerie, I'm going to go find the bad. Keep talking.

I'm going to keep talking. So, uh, we do have a side quest because the the Deepwood faction has three leaders, which is part of that chaos element inside of them that I think makes is going to make them quite interesting to play. Um, you have to taste test at least these two.

I realized why we didn't bring the eerie.

Why is that?

In this new printing,

it's not the core. They didn't want to reprint the core eerie.

It is just the hierlings that have the flavor. These are these are these are the eerie hierlings. Yeah,

they're the only ones that actually contain the blueberry that they promised.

So, we'll try those in a moment. Side quest.

Side quest. So, we've got ham

here. Like bores head like truly. And my question is they just said ham

should be rich. Should be fatty. Should be salty.

But is it salty or is it sweet? Is it Virginia ham [sighs] where it's like at that honey glaze?

Think they went that direction, but I think it's probably wrong. I think salt would stand up better. It would. But truly, I want I'm I'm a Virginia boy, so I really want that like true that that really

So, you get the lovely You get the lovely pork.

Yeah.

What is the weasel supposed to be?

Well, you know, when you've like worked in your garden for a really long time

and and you know, you've got that dirt underneath your fingers and you've been, you know, using compost and biting your nails and mulch and all that kind of stuff.

Flavor I'm very familiar with.

Yeah. So, this is that they call it inner tunnel. inner tunnel. Okay.

Inner tunnel. And I'm not sure what inner tunnel that they're talking about. I assume that it's going to be that like dirt tunnel.

Well, for

but the deep wood

for a season for a season of Patrick Leader's life, I believe he actually had a few alternate profiles on well, you know, Discord at least where his name was in her tunnel for a period of time.

It could be.

I'm not sure those still are in use. You could do like internet deep search if you wanted to find them. But

is that that like time machine thing?

You could do Time Machine possibly. It was before it was before Vast even came into the marketplace.

Oh wow. So a while back. Yeah. Okay.

All right. Well, I'm interested to see what Inner Tunnel is. I'm I'm going to put uh Ham in my mouth and see what happens.

The only reason I'm down to do this is because it is a call back to to you know Patrick Leer's younger years and his uh earlier experience on the on the internet.

Oh. Oh, that's good. This takes me to Christmas time. And you get that. It almost has like a clove flavor to it. It's like that sweet Virginia ham with the cloves on top of it. That that like nutmegy flavor as well. Oh,

that's really good.

It's mostly a bitterness. It's a s There's a sour, there's a bitterness to it. I think the compost kind of under the fingernails, the earthy tones are there.

I don't know that it's screaming inner tunnel for me.

Yeah. Um, but I don't know that it's not.

Yeah. Do you want to drink?

No.

No. Okay.

No, I don't know that it's not. It's not kosher.

Yeah. Yeah. That's why I said

I would have if it wasn't, you know.

Yeah. I I definitely think side quest wise those were quite good.

Let's get Let's get the ranked.

Clear cleanse the palette.

Okay.

That's important.

All right, last one. Pallet cleanser went down the wrong pipe. [cough] Okay. Uh, air doesn't help as much on this.

Forward, rich, bright, very blueberry, very sweet, kind of artificial almost.

Yeah.

It's not the least favorite. It's not my most favorite. Very similar to the eerie themselves.

It's a very classic very classic element.

Yeah. Not not the best, not the worst. They are slotting in right here in front of the vagabond. [clears throat] I will play the eerie.

You sound like you're struggling.

I did. It did go down the wrong

too many flavors.

Too many flavors. [clears throat] Um I will play the eerie uh before I'll play the cats. And that's it. I

I put them ahead of the cats for myself, too.

Yeah, but your cats are way high for no reason.

I've got some nostalgia. I don't know. We I need to work through it, I suppose.

I I'm just not there. Yeah.

Let's set our list. So you mean and let's list and the wrong list

very very quickly. Let's talk through them. So top of the list for me, Corvid, your Lord of the Hundreds. Two factions, brand new, both very intrigued to play. Different for both of us, but our alternatives match up pretty close.

Yep.

We've got a vagabond. Very high in the list. An otter close by. Very close actually here. We're matching up when it comes to the deep wood.

We like that chaos.

We like the chaos. Moles are a surprising choice for me, but I understand why you like to play them. I don't play a lot of the Bitcoin factions unless I'm supporting the table. True. Moles are not a table support faction as much as they are chaos.

They are chaos, which is why I like them.

My table support factions come in right now. We've got the Eerie, we've got the cats. I'm a friendly player. I want to facilitate a good game. You want to ruin people's day.

Yes.

Which is fair. Fair fair to play. In between is going to be the vagabond. You've got the deep wood here. Like I said, very close. otter down farther than mine, which is surprising.

It is, but I love the chaos element of the others more than I love the thematic element of the otter.

Sure, your frogs are going to match up with my marquee. Uh, which is curious. I mean, I my frogs are way up there. Um, your marquee are way down there.

I definitely like the idea of the frogs, and I hated playing against them, but they were I I think they're they're not as exciting as the bats were.

Interesting. Another doubling here. You see what I see? Um,

our ones are switched for our third, sixth, eighth position.

Actually, very interesting.

Your eighth favorite is my eighth favorite.

Yeah. Huh.

I thought I think that's very cuz cuz they play so distinctly differently.

Yeah.

That you can tell like what we both enjoy out of Root.

Very true.

Our lists are so opposite and yet I can't say your list is wrong. You can say mine is wrong, I suppose. But

it's one of the things that's so beautiful about this game is how distinct our list can be because there's a there's a faction for everyone to play and have the best game.

That is what makes Root so interesting.

There's not I'm not jealous of the faction you're playing cuz there's a faction that is my favorite that isn't your favorite.

Exactly. As long as the pairings match up, it's great.

Yeah. Uh we have the uh the uh Woodland Alliance here paired with my bats. We've got the Lizards paired with the moles. We've got the Eerie, which are much higher on my list, but still floating [clears throat] in the middle. You know, back end of yours, front end of mine, but paired up with the keepers in iron. I'm surprised actually

by the fact that Keepers and Iron are

ahead of the next two for me. But it makes sense cuz I am more willing to play them. I really never want to play the Woodland Alliance. I really never want to play the Lizards. I don't mind playing against them if someone really wants to try them, but I'd rather they don't.

And really, this is a pity spot for me because I just don't remember. I I just blocked it out. I guess

you like them, but you probably wouldn't like them that much.

Probably not.

Probably. I think they might be ahead of the cats in the eerie for you.

You think so?

Because you haven't played them.

Maybe.

But I think the fact that you've played against them and literally can't recall what they do without me describing it to you says a whole bunch.

Says a lot.

I feel really good about my list.

Yeah, I do as well. I I'm very excited. I I will sit down to a game of Root and play any of them up to about here. I will sit down at a game of root and ask to play here.

Mhm.

I will be willing to play here

and I will begrudgeingly play No, I won't play. I will I will play against here.

Ah,

you know what I mean? Like

Yeah, sure.

Like I'm not if or I will play if asked to play.

Sure.

But I'm if if if someone wants me to play the Moles, I'm going to suggest I play the Cats or the Eerie because they're a base faction that's a little bit more manageable. Someone wants me to play Keepers and Iron for a video or because I want to try them out again.

I don't know. I kind of want to play Lord of the Hundreds. I want to try something new. These I'll never almost universally reject.

Yeah. Yeah. I'm I'm extremely hesitant to play.

You know what we have to do now, though? We need a game where we both play our favorite.

I have a lot of games where I play my favorite. So, maybe I play my second favorite.

Yeah.

We need a game where we both play

our least favorite. I play lizards, you play keepers, [clears throat] and we add in another player or two.

The only reason I'm willing to do this is cuz I just don't remember keeping those. I

know. I know. But it would make for an interesting video.

It would. It would make for an interesting video. Thank you for watching. Thank you for being here. Let us know. Did you flavor taste? Did you taste test along the way with us? What are your opinions? What are your reviews? Where did you set your hierarchy? And

do you think they should have mixed in the the weird flavors with the classic kind of sweet, refreshing flavors? Do you think that was a mistake? You think it's going to lead to some viral like, you know, Tik Toks, some some YouTube shorts and stuff?

Those short videos of them tasting the new ones. Those are going to be

I've seen the office staff videos. I think they did a very good job in those. They're quite They're pretty funny.

They are pretty funny.

Um, but I just don't know if it's going to like kick off in the game industry like they hope it will.

I don't know. Patrick dancing at the same time was unique.

Yeah. Here's the thing. I do believe his dancing was AI. He was a little too graceful and a little too silly. But I'm open to be proven wrong. I have emailed him. I cannot confirm one way or the other. What I can confirm is that all of these flavors are an interesting twist in the board game space. Something we haven't seen since the original Vast published by Leader Games. Again, they're really innovating in this space. I like them pushing the boundaries. I like what they're doing. I don't know that it's the right direction to go, but I like a company that tries.

New things are important.

New things are important.

Thank you for watching. Thank you for being here. Whatever the case though, whatever you do, remember to do the important thing

and taste your meeples.

You got to try your meeples. You never know what they're going to be.

So important.

We'll see you next time.

Progress saved