The Game Makers – An Honest Review in 3 Minutes #boardgames
Transcript
The Game Makers is an engine builder where players will use resources to manufacture board games or upgrade their factory. For example, this wooden meeple can be put into the production of Friedrich or it can become a worker in my own factory. This plastic can become a component in River Valley Glassworks or it can upgrade my factory to grant me a new scoring objective. In this way at every turn of the game, players must decide which of the two purposes every resource provides. But the real ingenuity of this game is how the resources are acquired. Simultaneous worker placement on a brilliantly crafted rondel. Simultaneously, players will advance their forklift to the sector of their choosing. Farther the move, the more valuable the resource, but the forklift is not retrieved until the steering wheel rotates up to that forklift. The game ends after a player makes their 12th contract for a game, but a combination of tableau building, track advancement, tile placement, objectives, and worker placement all contribute to a multi-faceted score sheet. to say, this is a smart game. Three things that it does fantastically well. First, the simultaneous action rondel, brilliant.
Second, the decision space. Deciding whether you want to use a resource to construct a game, as a component for a game, or to expand your factory. Has to be one or the other, can't be both, and you must decide immediately. That's awesome. But thirdly, this probably impresses me most of all, the way that the game implements mechanics from all of these other games. This one game has worker placement, tile placement, tableau building, engine building, objectives, track advancement. So much going on, it really feels like it's paying tribute to all of the games that you find inside of it. For those reasons, I would love to be able to tell you that this is the best game of the year. But, I can't do that because the game play itself really fell flat for me. Two reasons that I can summarize.
One, the lack of interaction. This really is six-player solitaire. You're playing simultaneously. It doesn't really matter what your opponents are doing. Very few elements of interaction at all. One, there is a race condition. It's the first to 12 contracts. And two, there are some scoring mechanics that are influencing other players. But aside from that, this is I mean, you are isolated. If you like that, you might love this game. Second reason, for an engine builder worth $200, it just isn't doing anything that another 30 or $40 engine builder can't do. For those reasons, while I have to admire the game for its brilliance, uh I don't think this one is a keeper for me. But that's just my take on it.
You can vote for it on the perfectboardgame.com. Or if you like showcasing board games, you can showcase your own board games. Just check out the perfectboardgame.com or check the link in the description.