Skip to main content
Loading video...

5 Games with a PERFECT Theme Score

Transcript 17:46

here's a question for you I'm going to show you three board games which one do you think is the most thematic there's gloomhaven Twilight Struggle or food chain magnet now if you're familiar with all three games maybe an answer jumps out at you or you might not be familiar with any of these games in any case in this video we're going to be taking an in-depth look at theme in board games yeah I can actually think of five possible definitions for theme so depending on what you're looking for when you're looking for thematic games you may or may not think that something that I think is thematic is as thematic in your own eyes the very first thing we have to understand if we're going to be rating games thematically is what are we talking about when we say theme now the whole reason I rate theme in the first place is because my web app the perfectboard game.com is designed to pair people with board games that they will like best So to that end I've rated every game on theme as well as four other attributes and if this is something you want to take a look at you can take the perfect board game formula quiz which by the way is free and doesn't even require an email address to participate in you can just take the

quiz and get your results immediately I will leave links in the description there are five different definitions for theme the first two of these I would argue are not truly thematic so we'll start with those the first I would label it as a pasted on theme these are games where theme is used to justify the mechanics but done so in a way where it feels like the theme was added to fit the game rather than the other way around some examples of this would include Azul Carcassonne Dominion Sagrada many more when I'm thinking about playing these games the thing is the driver of those games is not the game's theme but rather it's the game's mechanic you don't play Sagrada for example placing Dice and thinking about your objective to make a stained glass window you're not thinking about stained glass windows at all you're thinking about dice now the fact that they use the stained glass window theme to color the dice to motivate a lot of the power cards that are available during the course of the game make the game more enjoyable but they aren't driving the game now whenever I'm rating this I'll usually give more points if I see more analogies to the theme for example Sagrada has more done thematically to fit the stained glass window theme than does a game like Splendor when I'm rating Splendor which is little more than just

taking tokens to buy Cards in order to build an engine to buy more tokens and cards I gave a game like that a theme rating of a one whereas with Sagrada I might give it a two or a three but the thing that defines games like these is that they are being driven by their mechanics the next four definitions of theme all motivate the gameplay and the next one while I don't think it's authentically thematic is a little bit more controversial and most people who disagree with me on this channel disagree with how I stand with respect to the next definition which I'm going to call the Thematic World these are games that invite players into a thematic world and there's no better example than flamecraft this is a book about the board game flamecraft and the book documents the creation of that world all of the dragons in it settings the artwork flamecraft is a game that is so beautiful that it invites players in not through its gameplay but because of its artwork and it is a very engrossing game in that sense the quality of of effort and love that was put into

this game to create this world is truly admirable however I don't think it makes a thematic game I think in order to make a thematic game the gameplay itself has to be driven by the theme so oftentimes my most common response to people who ask me what I mean when I give flamecraft a theme rating of two is I say that I give games a High theme score when I can use the theme to justify the rules of the game when the gameplay is more intuitive because a player has an understanding of the underlying theme that is a thematic game flamecraft is an example where the gameplay is very much separate from the world everdel is another example of such a game and wingspan is a another example those are three of my most controversial videos but this definition of theme is the reason why we have differing opinions so those two definitions I would argue are not authentically thematic the next three are and it happens to be the case that the next three types of thematic games are embodied in the three games that I showed you at the beginning of this video let's talk first about the gloomhaven type games these are story driven games games that are designed in such a way to uh have a

series of events that makes the game unfold examples of these games are gloomhaven Star Wars rebellion Cloud Spire Legends of Andor but there's one more thing that all of these games have in common at least with respect to me and that is that these are not the kinds of thematic games that I personally uh pursue playing all of those games that I've listed I haven't played a single one I can recognize that these are thematic games especially when it comes to IP games like Star Wars rebellion and credit where credits do their thematic games but they are not the kind of games that I play so generally in this channel when people uh ask me questions about these games or they make recommendations for me to play some new Star Wars game or something I just kind of say you know these IP games that's not really my scene I sort of have my specialty on Euro and family style games I'm gonna stick with what I know so thematic yes my expertise no I'll leave it at that let's go to the next definition the next definition for theme is games that are figuratively thematic these are games where the actions in the game are not

necessarily analogous to things you would do in real life yet the feeling they suggest feels like something in real life now I'm not talking about the ones that are paced on games like I mentioned earlier these are games that thematically have a weight to them and they very much feel thematic so the first example of this is Twilight Struggle Twilight Struggle is a recreation of the Cold War and it's a card game so if you think about the cold war is is the Cold War a card game no of course not but every card played in Twilight Struggle represents a real event something that happened during the Cold War and the way that this game is played is very much a struggle because you can't play a single card without conceding something to your opponent so the whole game is about trying to extract the greatest Advantage you can from a single card while mitigating the damages you cause Yourself by conceding some benefit to your opponent it's a fantastic game there is a space race element to the game there's a world map which players are going to be influencing throughout the game and has a ton of tension embodied in it and then you've got the constant threat of nuclear war this game feels very thematic even though the card is not a

literal translation of what the cold war is about another example is the game Imperial which may very well be my favorite game ever now in Imperial the mechanic is a rondelle and players are using the rondelle to take their turns to move armies around on a Mappy of Europe in order to spread out influence and tax within those governing countries but the objective of the game is to play as an investor who is buying Bonds in whichever com country has the greatest uh wealth at the end of the game so in this game players are not the countries they are simply the investors and during the course of the game whoever owns the most Bonds in the country controls the country so while the game is played by countries it's the players who play the countries as the uh investment in those countries shifts throughout the games that means that a person can be controlling Italy for one round and then in another round control can be passed over to another player while that player resumes or assumes control of France it's a very Dynamic game but what it really succeeds is doing is man does it give you an idea of what's at stake at War when your objective is to make money this

game is all about war profiteering and diplomacy and it is so intriguing to me how that comes together in a board game which is why I think this game is so brilliant I've got one more game in this category and that's the game fog of Love fog of Love is a game that simulates a relationship and it does this by presenting both players it's only a two-player game with scenarios and players have to secretly make a choice for what they want the outcome of that scenario to be now the game is designed so that different uh effects will happen whether the characters agree whether they disagree whether they make one choice or another choice and this is affecting their own individual character over the course of the game now at the end a player can win or lose based on whether or not they've satisfied their own purse personal objective because it's a game about relationships though sometimes the personal objective can be to stay together or it can be to break up which means this game could be both Cooperative or competitive depending on the player's secret objective it's a fantastic figurative analogy for a real relationship the game fog of love so if definition 4 was figuratively thematic definition five is games that are literally thematic these are games that simulate something in real life and

there are many examples of this as well however there is one characteristic of all these games which is to the extent at which the simulation is accurate is the extent at which the game becomes more complex some of the games in this category I'm thinking about war games are so accurate in the simulation that they are on a plane of complexity that I have never approached but there are also several games that are accessible to a general audience and are still richly thematic the first example is the game food chain magnate this is a Cutthroat game between all players is a neighborhood and in this neighborhood there are different houses which represent families now during the course of the game families can be advertised to in order to develop their appetite for fast food and at the end of every round families that have been marketed or the target of marketing will go out and buy food at restaurants and of course these restaurants belong to players so the game is played with players beginning every round placing their corporate hierarchy their corporate art hierarchy is full of everything from managers to Cooks to waitresses to delivery trucks everything has to fit within their corporate hierarchy and then the action round takes place as players go through the

roles of all of their cards and execute their cards action so for example a marketing person will will do a marketing campaign and a real estate specialist will help find a new location for a restaurant on the on the general map it is a game that has so many roles and every bit of this game just has a very true analogy to real life Cutthroat competitive business it is an expensive game though I'll give you another alternative the game stronghold stronghold is a two-player asymmetric game where one player represents uh marauding Orcs And monsters and the other player represents the uh the king of a castle that they're trying to defend and during the course of the game the Marauders are going to advance their troops to the castle walls whereas the castle is going to be sending out different soldiers to defend and building up uh reinforcements to protect from these Marauders the currency that's being spent in this game is time which is so fascinating see you can build more defenses but the more defenses you build the more time it takes and if it's going to be taking more time at the end of the round of all of your preparations you

give the time that you used to your opponent and then based on how much time your opponent has they will invade you this is fascinating see you can you can build very simple self-defenses in very short amount of time and then give your opponent very little to do with the time that they have what an interesting interesting mechanic I really love how fully this embodies its theme it's just an excellent game about what it's supposed to be now I called this video five games with a perfect team score but I'm gonna give you two more because the designer Albin viard is someone you definitely want to look at if you are interested in thematic games this designer is fanatic about it I mean he's got two games clinic and small City both games are a little too complex for me to describe in this video but every aspect is Thoroughly fleshed out not to the degree of some war games out there which are still more thematic than even these but they create for excellent very puzzling games so if you want to learn more about small City or clinic rather than talk about them in this video I will leave some links and you can check those out in another video so that is theme according to how I see it but here's the thing on the perfect board

game it's not just my ratings this is a website that is open to the public you can actually just create an account you or rather log in using Google and as soon as you do after you've reviewed one game you will have the credibility to start upvoting or down voting any of the five attributes so if you go on there and you disagree with my interpretation of Theme by all means go on there and rate it according to your interpretation of theme it's not so much a website for me as it is a tool for the community of board gamers I hope you enjoyed this video thank you for watching and participating in this conversation about theme I will be doing a video on each of the five components or attributes so you can look for those coming in the near future thank you I'll see you next time bye

Progress saved