Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top Board Games that We Don't Agree On! | Sommelier Suggestions with Alex & Liz!

Transcript 10:24

hi everyone due to popular demand liz is back in the chair she's got a new sweater to keep her warm and today we're gonna let you in on a little secret even though we're game partners for life we do not always share the same taste in games it's true so today we're going to talk a little bit about some of the games that we don't always see eye to eye on so if you want to learn more about these games or learn a little bit more about us then might i suggest hi i'm alex and i'm liz from might i suggest a game a channel devoted to helping you find your perfect board game today we're going to be talking about some of the games that we don't really agree on but first we wanted to give a big welcome to all the new subscribers to this channel hi last week we found out that the tim shuen featured us on his list of must-watch creators on youtube okay now for the next two creators they are creators that i have just recently found this next one is called might i suggest the game and they are alex and liz needless to say we were blown away by the love and support that we got in response to this video and now we're so happy to welcome a bunch of new subscribers to this channel so as a tribute to tim's channel we took inspiration for this episode from his new fire and ice discussion series with sam from lord of the board if you've been living under a rock and you don't follow tim or sam or any of the other creators that they mentioned on the must watch creators list like sword and board games thinker themer foster the meeple

or board games with b we'll include the links to all of their channels down below in the comments and while you're there don't forget to hit subscribe and that little bell button so you can get notified when we post new content anyways let's get back to business today like we mentioned before we're going to be talking about games that one of us loves and the other one not so much in a household that plays so many games it's bound to happen that there are titles on the shelf that we don't always see eye to eye on but that's the whole point of this channel we want to give you recommendations no matter what kind of games you're into anyways let's get into it will one of these games be the perfect game for you let's find out shall we the first game that we're going to talk about today is grand austria hotel from lookout games grand austria hotel is a dice drafting contract fulfillment game where players will compete to have the grandest hotel in all of vienna sounds like a lot of fun right liz you know it actually does sound like a fun game but in my experience it doesn't always end up that way but i'm really curious to hear more about why you like it so much all right i'll take the bait personally grand austria hotel has a special place in my collection because it's one of the first middle heavyweight euro games that i ever played i love how many little puzzles there are to solve in the game there always feels like there's one aspect of the game that you can take advantage of because no one's really paying attention to it i love the action economy and i also really like the way this game handles dice mitigation personally i'm not usually a fan of dice games where it's up to the luck of the role but because this game offers a few different solutions for that i think it's the gold standard for those types of games and i mean what could be better than serving up a plate

of coffee and strudel to your guests and making everyone really happy anyways even though i like this game a ton i know that liz isn't a huge fan so liz what is it about this game that you don't love i'm so glad you asked because i know that you know this isn't my favorite game it's nice to have a chance to kind of unpack why so i think first of all i will say i love the theme of this game i remember actually the first time that we played it at the board game store i picked it off the shelf because i loved the idea of like a hotel a travel themed game sounds very fun and it's kind of new like it's not very common i didn't expect it to be a game that ends up taking four hours and is very complex i thought it was going to be a lighter game based on the theme and so for me there's a little bit of cognitive dissonance there like you think you're going on a european vacation getaway but you're actually studying abroad in a school where it's really hard coursework it wasn't quite what i expected the first time i played it the next thing that i sometimes struggle with with this game is just that for me the components and the art style of this game leave a lot to be desired again i think there's so much potential with the theme of hotel with travel with giving guests their coffee and their strudel but it just didn't quite do it for me i don't think my father the inventor of toasters droodle would be too pleased to hear about this i mean the components are just simple wooden cubes when they really could be something much more fun so i think this is a game for me that if they came out with a remake then maybe i would consider it one that elevates the game a

little bit more has more fun art maybe they trim it down to be a little bit quicker it really comes down to the theme is cool but the art and the components and the length of the game don't seem to match the theme for me so you're looking for a slightly less grand austria hotel i'm looking for a casual austrian hotel that's fair that's fair yeah i think there is something to be said for the production quality in this game it released in 2015 and i think the board game industry as a whole has taken some significant strides since then when it comes to the production quality that is expected in a new game it does have those classic cubes on a board euro style look to it and i do agree that you know having upgraded components and things like that would definitely enhance the experience for the game so i guess i guess i agree with some of your points but at the end of the day this comes down to someone who you know likes the puzzle likes the challenge likes the euro game versus someone who prefers something of a little bit lighter and that's okay the two can co-exist and you know we're married so who cares i will say like i do think that the puzzles and the dice mitigation and all the things that you've talked about it's true like i can't argue with that but it's well done in terms of mechanics but for me it's it's more important to have a theme and kind of like a quicker game so anyways the game that i love that i'll have to find some other friends to play with is grand austria hotel from lookout games

okay so the game that i've chosen to talk about today is surprise a lighter party game it's muse from quick simple fun games believe it or not that's a real company muse is a lighter party game where players team up to try to get each other to guess the correct art card using cryptic clues i personally really like this game but i recently called alex trying to get rid of it in a math trade so i know that it's not his favorite busted so today i'm gonna try to convince him why we should keep it in our collection like i said this game is about using cryptic clues and what i mean by that is that instead of using a word to try to get your team to guess this card like you would do in something like code names you're actually prompted by these inspiration cards to use anything from the title of a book that relates to this art card or it might be something like make a sound effect or make a facial expression that represents this card to me that's so fun i love that it can kind of get a little bit silly i love that it's just way more sensory i love the art it's just beautiful if you've ever played something like dixit or mysterium it's very similar to that also if you know me you know that i love a game that you don't really have to keep score and this is definitely one of those games that there is technically a way to score it but it feels like you could just keep playing this for hours and not keep score and it would still be really fun also the thing that i love about it is that in a lot of these games you're trying to pull a clue out of thin air but in this game because you're

given a specific prompt it's a lot more manageable in terms of thinking of a clue to give your team so for me this is just another great party game to keep in our collection it's fun it shakes things up it's a easy one to pull out it's a quick palette cleanser when you're in between games and you just want to play something that's fun and light that gets people thinking outside of the box and i think it's a great game so what's your rebuttal uh well i was a pretty convincing argument to be fair i was just trying to get rid of it in a math trade to make a quick buck or something like that i regret my decision i regret my decision but what i will say about muse and the reason why you know it's not super high on my list is because i don't think it adds enough from the other abstract art card games that are out there for example liz mentioned dixit and mysterium both of those i think dixit is a sort of more pure execution of this game and mysterium has that murder mystery theme that i really enjoy and so when i think about playing an abstract art card game i would more likely pick one of those two than this game the other thing that i don't love so much about this game is that i don't feel like there's enough of that player interaction to really make it feel like a party game for me party games are all about interacting with the people on the table if you've got a lot of people playing all at once and while this one does accommodate up to 12 players i don't really feel like everyone has a reason to pay attention the whole game i wish there was a little bit more influence that the other teams could have on the vote like maybe they could

put in an extra card that would make it a little bit harder for the guesser they do get to add in extra cards to the pile but those cards are randomly drawn so there's not as much strategy as i would have liked at the end of the day muse is still a good game i still would play it but it's maybe not the first one that would get out to my table or that i would pick off the shelf that's fair so can we keep it uh yeah okay okay we can keep it anyway so the party game that i love to keep in the collection that i've now convinced alex to let me keep in the collection is muse from quick simple fun games thanks for sticking around for a more personal episode this time luckily we agree on more games than we disagree on which is one of the reasons why we're still married anyway we'd love to hear what kind of games you and your gaming partner disagree on we're always interested to hear from you guys so don't be shy drop a comment below and if you want to continue this board game discourse you should check out the fire and ice discord started by tim and sam who we mentioned at the beginning of the video so that you could join an awesome community of people that talk about board games all the time anyways thanks so much for all of you who have supported us so far please don't forget to like comment and subscribe so we can keep growing this channel and keep helping you find your perfect board game once again this has been a mighty suggested game production i'm alex and i'm liz your board game sommeliers signing off

Progress saved