Carcassonne VS Land vs Sea - Which Is Better for Two? | Board Game Review
Transcript
are you someone who feels connected with the land or are you someone who enjoys the feeling of being close to the water well if you an avid fan of carcassone land ver is a tall laning board game that has you literally fighting for space as you create your own unique maps in this video we're going to be comparing both games and seeing which of these two TI L games is the best in this board game face off let's go so on my turn I draw a tile from the stack and use it to extend this road I then place my meeple out on it to hopefully score this road later on well on my turn I'm going to place this lanti next to this other lanti scoring two victory points uh that's not exactly how you play this game what you should have done was you should have placed the lanti over here so he could enclose the land and score 12 victory points oh cheee bro I don't know what I'd do without you you'd actually have a lot of difficulty laying tiles of course carcassone is a tle laying board game that is considered an alltime classic carcassone is the candy rapper that advertises the delicious chocolate of modern board gaming encased inside in carcassone players will take it in turns drawing a single tile and placing it out connecting it to the main Game Area extending the landscape as they go it could be extending the road expanding the city or building a monastery players
are then placing Maples out on different Landmark features hoping that when those features are completed they can score it for instance placing a maple on an open road will score when the road is closed and completed they're kind of like those fluo orange safety cones that you see on a construction site players will score points for each segment of a closed road that they've completed and claimed in closed City score two points per tile as well as two points each per code of arms shown in it it's the thanks you get for protecting the monasteries can earn you up to 9 points if you can completely surround it on all sides carass own's famous square tiles Medieval theme simple rule set and geographical strategy has meant that this has been one of the most perfect games to introduce to brand new players let's hold that thought for a sec what if I told you that there is a board game out there that is simple to teach like carcasson and easy to play but introduces a whole new level of geographical strategy and thinkness land vers sea is like casson's muscular younger brother fitter stronger and possibly more attractive in every way just look at how handsome this fine piece of cardboard is in land vers sea one player fights for the land and the other the sea the aim of the game is to place out these land tiles to try and score as many points as possible the land player will score points whenever these land areas are closed up and the C player will score whenever the sea areas are enclosed the first main difference that you'll notice between the two games is is that lver se takes the classic Square shaped carcasson style land tile
and adds two extra sides to it to turn it into this very hexy happy hexagon by adding two extra sides and transforming the tiles itself means that there's an added level of complexity puzzlin and it does reshape the geometry and geography of the game itself plays now in land vers sea can create little sea shapes or little out cloves or even little holes in the game board itself this adds for extra decision- making and complexity to the layers and the choices that you make on your turn throughout the game each player will have two tiles each on their turn they will place one out so that the terrain matches the edges of the existing landscape players then can trigger any bonus actions if they wish a play again tile allows a player to put out their other tile whilst a steel tile allows them to take a tile from another player at the end of the turn players draw back up to two tiles one of the simplest and most genius design choices that is introduced into land vers SE that I really love is the fact that the land tiles are double-sided all of a sudden one side is public knowledge and the other side is private knowledge that only you know about ultimately players are going to be able to have four choices on their turn two which could be a surprise and for me that's a game changer whenever a land area is closed the land player scores points equal to the number of tiles that were used to make up that land area if a SE is ever completed the ca player earns poins in in the same way the game ends when the last tile in the stacks has been placed
Whoever has the most points wins so you might be thinking at this point that all sounds simple enough but Danny where is the strategy and deep thinking that appears in this game well I like to compare it to looking at a fish tank where when you first glance at the fish tank it kind of looks like a living ornament or a living ecosystem it's not until you put your face up against the tank they get to see all the abundance of life and interactions that happen within it when you approach a game of land vers sea you kind of look at it from the out and go H this is a pretty simple TI Lane game it's not until you actually look and put your head up against the glass and see the cornuc copia of choices that the game truly presents to you whenever a player closes either a CA or land area they can score bonus points if there are these plus symbols on them no matter which side you're playing for you'll also notice on the tiles that there are mountains and corals these score whenever you place them adjacent to other mountain or Coral the the beauty of building chains of coral or mountains is that every time you add a new piece to the chain the entire chain rescores again for example if I place this piece of edge Coral here on the map that connects with this piece of edge Coral I get to score two victory points because there's two pieces of coral touching each other later on in the game if I place another piece with coral on it and slide it into the same chain and connected together I get to rescore that entire chain giving me three points the next
time I extend it it's important to note that only the land player can score points for chaining Mountains and the Sea player can score points for chaining reefs so when you're placing your land tile out you got to be really careful that you don't accidentally give points to the opposing player another way to score is to connect ships operated by the C player and Caravans managed by the land player together whenever a player places a ship or Caravan tile next to another ship or Caravan tile that player gets two victory points building a cluster of ships and Caravans together is important for creating a trade route whichever player has the most ships or Caravans in a trade route at the end of the game gets to claim and score that entire route so it is a competition for who can connect the most way points come in these very nautical themed wooden discs oh not this I meant this these get placed out on open terrains on the map that kind of symbolize where players are exploring in this world whichever player completes a Terrain with a waypoint token on it gets a point if a waypoint token is ever surrounded by six hex tiles it also earns that player a point the Waypoint markers are there to help entice the opposing players to help you finish off some of your regions what really impresses me about this game is that as the game plays out the landscape and geography of it changes and evolves because the tiles are hexagonal in shape you can often find yourself in a situation where holes appear wait a sec there's a hole in my
script hey there's holes in these cards oh that's really strange wait a minute there's a hole in this banana I was talking about a gap in the game players can sometimes find themselves in a situation where they're creating these hexagonal shaped holes if the hole ever has six land edges or six ocean edges then the player who placed the final tile that completed the hole gets to gain the power of the volcano and whpo tile what this tile does is it fills in that empty space meaning that player can score in complete particular regions it might be scoring a coral reef gaining bonus points or or completing an area of sea that will swing the game in their favor it's bound to make any board game completionist really happy or maybe a dentist who takes pleasure in filling in people's cavities the tile is literally a masterpiece in whole filling whenever a Whirlpool or a volcano tile is placed if this finishes or completes an area then all of those places score including the terrain bonus points terrain points as well as the coral and Mountain chaining effects this piece is literally the piece D resistance if you can successfully use this piece it can be a gamechanging move throughout this video I've mainly spoken about land vers sea being PR primarily a two-player game it does come with a four-player team variant and a three-player game mode where one player takes on the role of the Cartographer in the three play mode
one person is the Cartographer the rules are essentially the same except there is a particular play order that players need to follow the Cartographer scores chains of corals and mountains placed by any player as well as scoring endgame trade routes that have an equal number of ships and Caravans comparing the strategy that both games have to offer Kasson is all about forward planning and forward thinking as players Place their meeples out on different landforms they're kind of announcing to the other players how they're going to try and score it might be completing a castle completing a really long road or even surrounding a monastery with other tiles this public information means that other players on their turn can place their tiles in a way to try and strategically block that player from scoring a lot of points as well as trying to navigate around that player so that they have to work really hard to try and fill in those geographical gaps in land vers sea all of the ways to score is public information however the tiles that players hold is semi-public information the opponent is only ever going to know 50% of the information because the tiles um are double sided this really provides for some tactical gameplay one player might be trying to complete a really big land region and if the other player knows this they can place a tile down that really opens up that land so that that the land player needs to plug them up really quickly there's a little bit more tactical strategy that appears in land versus CA because of the scope of
how the information is shared between players plays can even combo out in land versus CA by playing a play again tile or a steel tile those little minor actions really reshape the game and give you a little bit of an edge over your opponent and I think that element to it just really appeals to me I also find that in land versus sea each player has four options on their turn whereas in Kasson players only have one tile and they've got to try and fit that tile uh where possible on a board where sometimes the options are quite Limited in this version of the game that is going to really open up the floodgates a little bit and provide players with lots of options on their turn to tactically move around this map which is ever evolving in Dynamic so ultimately I would definitely have to say Land versus sea is better in this category but I do know that there are variants out there with carcassone where you can play with two tiles per turn where you draw two and decide which one you want to place out in terms of scalability Kasson is a relatively balanced game that plays really well from two to five players I really like playing at the high player C CU there's a little bit more social dynamics it's a bit more tactial and uh every piece that you place out really matters whereas in land versus C this primarily plays best at two players where you're playing head to ahead it does have some extra modes but I don't like sharing my role with other people so I tend to like playing for myself so I'm quite competitive in that regard so
I definitely would recommend that if you've only got a significant other or friend that you want to play with and this is a perfect game for you but I definitely have to give the award for scalability to Kasson in comparing the mechanics in both games no one can argue against the classic nature of carcassone it is definitely one of the best Gateway Games to introduce two new plays and in fact it featured at my wedding as a little guest book where all my guests Drew on tiles and the maples and every time we play that version I call it the wedding version of the game uh I really really enjoy it what I really like about land V SE however is that the scoring in here is a lot more Dynamic compared to carasso by chaining and rescoring mountains and coral reefs you'll really using them to create a little combo or engine I really love the trade rout feature that features in land versus SE where if you've got um more ships than the other player then the C player will score for the entire trade route by the end of the game getting those little extra bonus points and completing the regions and sending way point markers back to their owners to get bonus points there's so many layers of Point scoring that really makes your brain really tick over the base game of carcassone really only has the three or four main ways of scoring that I feel like gets a little bit repetitive and is isn't varied enough to make me want to VI for one over the other I might try to complete the castle and try incorporate as many Shields as possible but it doesn't feel as dynamic as L versus C does so in
terms of superior mechanics I would definitely say Land versus sea gets my seal of approval but I still have a place in my heart for carass own so don't let this one go in terms of comparing the theme of both games I feel like both themes definitely work for the actual gaml that they're trying to V for in carcassone you do feel like you're in the Medieval Era and you're building this map and you're building your border Fortress between France and Spain and it definitely has a stronger narrative behind it whereas land ver SE probably is a bit more of a visual aesthetic where you're seeing patterns of sea and land kind of connect together but there isn't really a coherent story line that follows Land versus sea so I would say in terms of theme carcassone differ gets my seal of approval so in considering my final verdict Kasson and L ver SE are both really great tall Lane games and it's worthwhile owning both one or either and you certainly won't be disappointed with either choice however if I were to pick one of the two I would definitely pick land ver C mainly because it's smaller it's more portable and the rules are a little bit more elevated in this game in terms of the strategy the choices that you have uh per turn as well as the different scoring methods that you encounter throughout the game the hexagon shaped tiles really definitely add a new dimension to the game and the puzzly and thinky nature to it thank you once again for join me for another board game sanuy video If you really like this video don't forget to hit the like subscribe and share button as well as leave a
comment in the comment section below as to which of these two board games you would have chosen if you really want to help support this Channel please consider becoming a board game sanctuary and heading over to my patreon page and if you want to stay tuned for the latest news and updates head over to my Facebook page this is Denny s now it's time to decide which of these two board games I'm going to play or maybe I will play both see you soon guys bye