Is Atiwa BETTER Than Agricola? - Board Game Review
Transcript
g'day everybody my name is Danny and I'm from board game sanctuary I'm an Australian board gamer who enjoys sharing this hobby with my friends family and you today we're going to talk all things orange orange Euros in fact by a clean board game designer uve Rosenberg one of his most famous games has you building your own Farm where you're going to be feeding some farm animals harvesting your crops all at the cost of destroying the local environment for victory points on the flip side his other hero is a game set in Ghana a place when the destruction of forests is currently a significant issue there the fupa is incredibly important because they're responsible for the dispersal of seeds and the seeds that they disperse each of the growth of new trees new plants and potentially new forests in the future in this video we're going to be seeing whether Ottawa is better than a gricola wait you told me this video is gonna have oranges in it okay so it says here in the rulebook that you place an orange from your playboard and put it in your tree
Danny where'd you go foreign rosenberg's early worker placement games it's a classic farming game where the constrictions of the game feel really tight but they open up as you progress throughout the game it's really characteristic in terms of uve rosenberg's designs is the fact that he gives you a lot of different choices and options in Agricola the main board where you take your resources and get your workers and get your produce is going to be quite limited but as the rounds progress the options open up wider and wider and become more powerful this kind of leads to progression in the game where you feel like your starting Farm is very limited things get a little bit stressful but as the game progresses that kind of opens up and frees up what you can do and then you'll see that the turns it have towards the end of the game are much more powerful more impactful and larger than at the beginning of the game the other thing that Agricola provides is the puzzle of space the space to manage your farm plowing your Fields having space to put your little enclosures to feed your animals and reproducing those animals over time and also starting your own family those all really nice thematic touches that fit into this idea of building your own Homestead the other
thing that's really cool about this game is this game comes with a plethora of different card options you've got mine Improvement cards which allow you to give you small stepping stones for you to step across to try and increase the flexibility of how you build your farm then you've got major improvements which gives you really cool conversion abilities and then you've got occupations people who work on your farm and kind of fine tune how you're going to be scoring a lot of your points Agricola is a well-crafted game it is a game where you feel like the pressure of building your farm really weighs heavily on you and whilst the options are quite plentiful now whilst I hadn't often seen I eye to eye with the gricola Adderall is a game that actually really captured my attention so how does a game of Ottawa actually work well this game is probably best understood when you've wrapped your head around the theme and the theme of the game is basically the idea that the homes that these fruit bats live in have been cut down for mining but also the way that people use the land these fruit bats are so important for transporting the seeds that they eat from different fruit right across the land to distances so far away that they can help promote the development of new forests there's a cycle to Nature the idea that whatever we take should be restored and these fruit buds are actually catalysts for helping the Regeneration of forests to occur and the more trees that we cut down their numbers are going to dwindle so there's a huge conservation effort
that's immersion that helps to protect the population of these fruit bats the game really centers around this player board where you're given four resources and the interesting Twist of this game is that these are the resources that you're going to have for the entire game these resources when they're spent are going to come back to your board when you deploy them out onto your cards you're going to put them out into free spaces and everything here is recycled the only thing that is unlimited is gold and also the number of bats and you'll see that basically what you're doing is moving all of these resources out onto your terrain cards and your settlement cards to open up the spaces to give you bonuses and whatever Open Spaces you have at the end of the game are going to be your victory points you're also really going to try and maximize the number of bats that you have in your Tableau every bat that you have over 10 at the end of the game is going to be worth one Victory point the other thing that's going to really factor into this game is the fact that some of your families are going to be trained or untrained an untrained family is going to invite pollution into your Tableau which essentially blocks out spaces for you to put out your resources and whenever a space is kind of blocked out it means your resources are stuck on your playboard limiting what you can do there's a really cool twist that the bats have that kind of helps you churn your engine a little bit longer at the end of every turn and you have three turns per round you'll be able to transfer three bats to these three by three card and if you do you pay one orange
and then what you'll be able to do is place that one tree from your board onto your Tableau that has a consequential effect at the end of the round and everything in this game is connected if I do something in my playboard or if I put out a resource that's going to have a consequential effect on the amount of space that I have if that space fills up that's going to have a flow on effect on whether my bats are going to be able to live in this little Conservation Area that I've established and that is a beautiful element to this game dude I was just doing some inventory on this game and it says there should be 96 bat pieces in this box but I think there's quite a few missing have you seen them
so I really want to draw your attention if it's playable because at the end of every round once everyone's placed their workers out players are going to be going through an upkeeping phase basically players are going to be collecting income they're going to be uh producing and then they're also going to be returning their bats on that night card out onto their Tableau and as well as that they're going to be feeding their people what's really cool is that as you uncover this top row of wild animals the production gives you one tree so as you uncover those wild animals they kind of eat food or eat plants and then they go and do poo out somewhere in the field and that's going to lead to the production of a tree which allows you to take the next treat off this next row and it creates an interesting Synergy between each row once I take the next year of the next row that's going to uncover more fruit and because it uncovers more fruit I can then take that number of fruit off the fruit row which then uncovers and attracts more bats to your tableau and that's going to create a cool spatial puzzle that Cascades as you play the game the wild animals are simply there to help you feed your people because at the end of every round you're gonna have to take the numbered value from the family row and subtract it from the numbered value from the goat row you breed your own goats they kind of produce milk so one goat can kind of feed one person but actually if you sacrifice that goat it can feed three people the trees are really cool because the more you plant trees the more spaces
you'll have for placing and growing your oranges and oranges are super important not only do they give you vitamin C and avoid you from getting scurvy but they help to attract those fruit bats and as I said before those fruit bats are going to score you so many points you want lots of fruit bats in your Tableau because it's going to really make your conservation efforts feel validated do you mind I'm trying to film a review here but this game just sounds so juicy now there's also an extra twist the more families that you put out and you can only place families out onto spaces that have the family symbol on them once you've kind of trained them they can flip over to their bat side and basically you can each family that has the bat symbol on it yes sounds like I'm talking about a DC Comic here but you can actually house a single bat in each person's home so the main board is the primary location where you're gonna get all of your starting resources things are going to help you to expand your area and ways to kind of start that engine going you've got this top row here which is a deck of about 36 different terrain cards that are centered around different environmental themes you've got a plantation card which is really good for growing lots of trees you've got a mangrove forest that gives you extra space but also houses bats wild animals and plants and then you've also got Farm cards and pastures
that are more centered around the agriculture around down which your village thrives upon the other thing that I really like about this game is every single round that you play these action spaces are going to slide across this main board providing different combinations um that pair up each and every game and as they slide you'll see that the combo of the resources and the abilities that you get will become quite different so at the beginning of the game you might like to go for this combo which allows you to train a family gain a bat but also a wild animal so that trained family that you've just flipped over that could be a really cool place to place that bat that you've just invited into your home as these tiles slide across they reveal production goals each and every round you're going to try and buy for these goals you're going to try and have that amount on your Tableau so that at the end of the round you can gain a bonus for each of those that kind of just gives you that little extra push to help you get those extra resources in the game which is really important when it comes to not only balancing the conservation efforts but feeding the people that are investing their time and effort into conservation as well there is another cool element here where if you get lots of terrain cards they have this cool Plant symbol on them and if you have more terrain cards in them they kind of act as a multiplier so if you
place your work on this space here depending on the number of plant card symbols that you have in your Tableau that's how many gold you get now my mum always says that I should eat a balanced diet or instead of having a balanced meal okay I think I should probably stop dabbling in all those confectionary having a balance to a Euro game like this is super important the way that everything feels interconnected and every action feeling like it has a flown effect on not only the environmental impact in your game but also the resourcing in your game is such a cool thing to see the puzzle here is really interesting because you're building not only this physical environment in front of you but the resources are helping you to fill in those spaces I really liken the feeling of this game to filling in a cool crossword puzzle the idea that you've got all these uh different pieces and these different um components and you're trying to squeeze and fit them in in every nook and cranny that you can find and then once you kind of Hit the ceiling effect on feeling like everything is filled up you're always searching for other avenues and other ways to expand having played games like agricular where the worker placement is super tight I felt that the Open Spaces in this game were quite uncompetitive I mean at a foreplay account the spaces do become a lot more contested upon but at the lower play accounts it does feel like there's a lot of freedom to move and evolve the constriction does happen in your player
area and the process of thinking how am I going to Feed My People how am I going to reach those objectives so you're really kind of Shifting your brain into a mode where you're thinking when do I need space how can I maximize my resources and how can I use my Tableau to kind of provide that extra space for this environment and this species to grow hey Danny do you like worker placement board games I love worker placement board games they're like my favorite type of games to play well can you get back to work so you can finally finish so we can play this brand new game that I just got one of the main criticisms that I've had with this game is probably that if you play this game 10 times in a row it might start to feel a little bit samey but you know what the variety of terrain cards that you get and the ways that people can compete for different resources and the fact that these little tiles connect together in different combos is varied enough for me to want to play this game at least once every two to three months I think the theme that uve Rosenberg has really invested in for this game is something that really appeals to me a lot one that gives me great enjoyment not only because I'm a passionate person who really supports the environment and using environmentally friendly resources and generating awareness of um world issues I can bring this game out at a game night and really say look this is the message that we're trying to fight for this is the message that we really want to try and Achieve by the time we get to the end of the game and
yes you're going to have a winner in the game in terms of the victory points but the winner here is planet Earth so before we get to my comparison and thoughts on this game if you like oranges and like the content that you've seen so far please consider liking and subscribing to my channel and heading over to my main page and seeing all my other content so in comparing both games which of these games do I think is stronger well Agricola definitely has the variability the tenseness of this strategy and the immense scope for building that dream farm that you want to build while still maintaining a sense of constriction strategy to the game and an element of Challenge and achievement Agricola is a beast of a farming game because of just how pressured you feel as you try and do the things that you want out of work definitely lacks invariability you don't have uh that feeling that you're creating a different type of Village each time the main goal and objective Remains the Same the little chaining that you do essentially all feels slightly different but actually it's the same each time you play but the environmental message in Ottawa is super strong it's actually something that I actually play and feel you know what this is a chill puzzle this is a chill game where I know that when I finish playing this I'm not only going to have a really fun time but just the theme of the game just feels incredibly satisfying the puzzle is still there it is still a fun deep rich
interesting spatial puzzle of trying to manage your villagers but also manage how many bats you're actually inviting into your area there's that cool chaining effect that you get in the game that makes it feel like you know what I could definitely play a second round straight after this game is finished there's less cognitive load in terms of trying to wrap your head around all the different options but there is a greater cognitive load when it comes to making the right decisions optimally compared to the other players in the game I definitely think Adam will probably uh is better at the three to four player count but whilst I say that the solo mode in this is so cool not only do you play with the three sets of three colored meeples each round you'll be playing out those three meeples and those meeples are gonna sit there for the next two rounds as in the subject sequent route I'm gonna be placing the other color out and then the round I thought you'll be placing your third color and then in the fourth round you're gonna be collecting your first uh color back and then redeploying them only take each of those spaces once every three or four rounds means that you're gonna really have to think about is this the moment that I'm going to use it and in addition to that the rule book also comes with a solo challenge different objectives for you to Vie for I would actually get out of work purely for the solar mode the solo mode in this game is probably a 9 out of 10 for me I just am in love with the solo mode in Ottawa the game itself is so easy to get
around but also the solo challenges just provide the elevated ceiling effect where you've like you know what I beat that first game now what is the next solo Challenge and all of a sudden whoa the ceiling level has increased again I actually think that I prefer Ottawa if I was choosing one of these two games off the shelf mainly because it's more accessible it's more interesting the idea of the chaining and the worker placement is really straightforward yet the strategy is still rich and deep Agricola is a very well designed game I would definitely play agricular with seasoned Gamers people who are more experienced people who are willing to digest the extra rules and variability and tap into really specific strategies I feel like Ottawa is kind of a mid mid-level game and agriculture is more of an advanced game and you know what both of these games uh sit highly in my board game collection my rating for both of them would be an 8 for Agricola just mainly because I've had a lukewarm experience with the gricola I found the learning curve was superbly high when I first dived into it I definitely appreciate its design but otherwise something that I definitely can sink my teeth into and just really go for it thanks friends for joining me for another board game review if you really like the content you've seen so fun found it super helpful and also want to support eating a balanced diet then definitely like And subscribe to this video or head over to my patreon page and support me over there otherwise
I hope your next game is an amazing one and I can't wait to bring you more content soon right here from my very own Lounge room see you later foreign