90-81: A Decade of Game Design Wisdom
Transcript
this video is sponsored by launch tabletop a fullscale board game manufacturer with a print on demand prototyping service launch lab hang on until the end of the video for more information and a discount code so welcome back this is my second video in myund lessons that I've learned about board game design in the board game industry after a decade working as a freelance board game designer I'm Adam Porter I design games I have eight published games more on the way I like to talk about my processes and experiences on this channel with a real focus on product design so if you like what I do please subscribe share the video and uh and comment uh I really like to hear your thoughts on these topics so we're today looking at numbers where are we at 90 to 81 so first up I've got my my deck of cards here pre- shuffled so let's have a little look what have we got keep your day job this is not an industry where you're going to make an awful lot of money you could it's possible right I I I have friends who have managed to do it I I mean I said I mean they're not millionaires do you know what I mean they're making really good money really good money an annual salary but after years and years of making very very little and you can look at it and think there's some sort of big overnight success there but actually you're missing out on all the work that's gone on before so that success can come but it comes for very very few people the majority make a relatively modest amount okay got eight
games that have been published and you know none of them have been I haven't had a single year where I could even possibly think about like that's my income for the year every year it's been enough for you know a holiday um or a little bit of a contribution to some savings or something like that it's not a massive amount of money that's coming in because you only get paid very small amounts of royalties uh on each individual sale and it might be as low as you know 20 P or 20 cents um per copy sold for a really small game or or maybe maybe a dollar or a euro per copy on on a really really big game now that doesn't Mount up very quickly if you're only going to sell 5,000 10,000 copies maybe 20,000 if you've got a game that's really successful then that's not going to be a huge amount of money even if you sell 50,000 100,000 copies well that's that game might have a fairly short shelf life right these games tend to disappear after a couple of years and so you might have a nice little pot of money but it's not going to sustain so the only way you can really give up your day job is if you have uh one Evergreen game that's Mega successful right we're talking wingspan ticket toide something like that where it's going to just continue to generate Revenue uh royalties for year after year after year and even if it doesn't you've already made your fortune right or to have uh a bunch of sort of of games that are coming out frequently almost in a sort
of magazine subscription style things like the exit the game series or the adventure gamees series or uh the echo series from Ravensburger games where you know there's going to be new episodes that are produced frequently which are almost guaranteed and they sell really well and so that's how a lot of the designers who are full-time have managed to do it because the games just keep on coming it's a different story if you're self-publishing you can build uh a career around that if you're going to take total control of everything and if you're really really good at it if you're bad at it then you're going to lose money frankly uh but keep your day job um don't don't risk your livelihood on this stuff it is not easier to design a simple game nor is it harder it's commonly said by designers that it is more difficult to design a simple game than it is to design a hard game and you know I design very very simple games and I will get G designers who have designed really complex games saying to me oh you know I wish I could design something so simple um and you look at somebody like um Bez shariar and her games are so simple so streamlined so you know there's so little going on in the game and it's a real achievement to get into that mindset and to be able to produce that stuff but it's not harder than creating a complex game I I couldn't
create a massive Euro game I don't have the skill set just like the people who are creating those games don't have the skill set to create the little party games and children's games and family games that I create it isn't easier to do one thing or the other you play to your skills right so I think sometimes we talk in these cliches but I don't believe that they're true there are too many of us I'm talking about game designers there's too many of us I'm talking about Publishers there's too many of us the industry cannot sustain it and it means that we're all vulnerable we're all in a vulnerable unstable State it's another reason not to give up your day job right don't give up your day job this is an unstable career right we are in this massive hesitate to call it a bubble cuz hopefully it just keeps on growing okay but at some point it could burst and even if it doesn't Publishers go under all the time okay you see kickstarters failing frequently this is not a stable business to be in there's too many of us so enjoy it enjoy it have fun with it try and Rise Above the Rest of the noise but I you know this is not stable okay you you you're going to have to ride the waves downtime kills a game aim for quick or simultaneous quick turns right
you don't want to be sitting there for ages thinking about your next turn if everyone's doing that that is so that that that just absolutely kills the flow of a game it's um it destroys the whole experience I dread the play test nights when and our play test group when somebody will have produced a game and you know they they tell us maybe it's going to take 45 minutes to play or an hour to play and you think okay that's quite a long perod of time for an untested game a game where I'm not quite sure what I'm getting into maybe this designer is completely new to us and then they start laying it out and you start to see the complexity and the dread is starting to build but we can't stop them now and then you start playing and everybody is sat there for ages and it becomes very clear this is going to be the whole evening now was playing this one game that is going to be a slow trudge through the evening I dread those experiences downtime kills a game keep everybody involved make your turns as quick as possible if there's eight different things that you might want to do on your turn well why not do them over eight turns okay so everybody gets to do one thing on their turn and then over eight turns they can achieve lots of stuff don't give us loads and loads of things to do on our turn because it means everybody's waiting yeah downtime kills a game try and keep it quick simultaneous play is great although simultaneous play interferes with interaction and possibilities there right in the second person to sound Dynamic so I'm talking there about not only writing your rules but also card text now what I mean by second person is
don't write on their turn the player rolls the die right on your turn roll the die make it Dynamic the players score points for this and this and this no you score points for this and this and this okay everything should be written as if it's directly speaking to the player okay conversational as if you're teaching the game at the table it makes things so much more Dynamic so much easier to read so much easier to kind of grasp because someone's got to sit down and read this stuff so it's got to be engaging and dynamic nobody is going to steal your unpublished idea okay oh I'm almost dreading this card because this is a whole Topic in itself and I've made a video about it where I probably I don't know how long I talked for I can't remember maybe half an hour 40 minutes I could go on and on about this topic and people do it's such a frequently Asked question in the board game industry from new designers how do I protect myself against people stealing my game idea the truth is you can't do an awful lot about it okay there is no you know you automatically have copyright on your game you can't patent it really I mean you might be able to if you went to extraordinary lengths but it would be a complete waste of time you can only really get copyright on on uh the text and the artwork not on the ideas right the me mechanisms can't be copyrighted so anybody can use them legally ethically they can't and that's where your protection comes in is that if people do stuff that's unethical they
get called out for it and this is quite a small community the global Community the board game Community is quite protective of this stuff they don't like it if they see somebody being ripped off so they tend to dive in there you've got so much to gain by showing your game to loads and loads of people getting their their their feedback both Publishers and play testers so don't be protective about it okay ideally You' be working on multiple games so in the very very unlikely event that somebody stole part of your idea you can adapt you can you can um move on there's not enough money to be made in this this business to really be thinking about stealing people's ideas the one area where you do sometimes see it is people getting their idea stolen when it's a when it's been published right you've got a published game and then someone else rips off the published game right not the unpublished idea you don't it's not it's not the publisher you're pitching this stuff to it's somewhere else it's some shop some I I get very disappointed with some like High Street stores in the UK where I go in there and I see ripoff versions of popular games and some of these are mass Market games where I mean what does Hasbro care if uh there's I probably do care frankly very much but if there's you know ripoff copies of Connect 4 or guess who floating around everybody knows the original everyone really wants to play the original they're probably making plenty of money any anyway it's still not right but when I see I remember seeing a a ripoff version of um um rhino hero in a in a mass Market
store and I thought what you know what a shame because that is a game that's come out of it's not out of the hobby market it's because Harbor is big in Germany I don't know I don't like it I don't like seeing these things being ripped off but it does happen and there's not much you can do about it and there's not much Publishers can do about it but no one's going to steal your unpublished idea don't worry about it and watch my video if you want more more detailed coherent thoughts on that submission forms suck personal addresses rule talking about email addresses there this is what I find when I'm trying to arrange meetings pitch meetings before a convention I hate using the online submission forms I never get a response if I have a form where I fill out some brief information about the game it might ask me to send some photos maybe the rules of the game occasionally ask for a sell sheet usually it doesn't very rarely does it ask me for a video and I don't get to really put in anything very personal as an introduction I don't learn the name or the email address of anybody who works in the industry it's cold it's impersonal and I can see why it might work for a publisher because ultimately they don't want to be swayed by your personality right they've got to look at the game because that's what they've got to show to distribute tributors and and retailers and purchasers you're not in the box right so they they quite like the in uh the the very formal um nature of it you know the impersonal nature of
it but for me it doesn't work I enjoy these personal interactions I like the feedback I like the discussion I like meeting people face to face and so I much prefer going to conventions Gathering business cards asking who I should contact in the future and then building up my own little database of addresses that I'm going to use and updating it each year as people inevitably move on to other jobs sometimes though I have to use submission forms and it always sucks it never gets me anywhere okay so I don't like online submission forms I don't know about your experience I'd be very interested to hear the first play is everything okay first impressions really really count particularly in this industry where there are thousands of games if somebody starts playing your game and they don't like it they're not going to come back and try it again I I mean frequently I see when there are negative reviews and things like that people will argue well you know that's what somebody would say if they'd only played the game once or twice you've got to play this game five times or 10 times before you're really going to start to really enjoy it and understand it nobody's doing that right nobody's got time to be playing a game five or 10 times to to discover whether they enjoy it or not particularly in an industry where there are thousands of other games they could be playing why would they that first play has got to be exciting it doesn't have to show you everything but it's got to show the game you know if not at its best it's got to show the game in a very very good state right you've got to give a good account of
yourself on that very first play lift up other designers don't tear them down now what I mean by this is sometimes in play test groups you get a sense of perhaps the more experienced designers they can be quite brutal with their feedback okay they can be they can really um kind of tear apart uh a designer's protype it's almost like a baptism of fire like there's a there's a kind of bravado in it you know I I play your game I I'll rip it apart some occasionally you see it with Publishers too they like to tell you about you know all their experience and and and and expertise and really you know wear it on their sleeve and and and kind of beat you down and they do it with a almost a sort of supportive like I'm doing this to help you but they're not it's about them and it's about their ego okay lift people up don't tear them down okay tell people about your experiences for sure tell people where they're going wrong for sure but always be humble enough to recognize that you don't know everything and you were in their position once and you wouldn't have liked to have been spoken to like that and even if you did like being spoken to like that doesn't mean that every everybody else does as well all right be kind be generous help people reach out to other people lift them up okay what do I get out of making this channel I say that I okay I'm I get a few quid each month not a huge amount
it's not worth the effort right I get the occasional review copy of a game really really not worth the effort um what I get out of it is helping other people and enjoying the comments and the feedback and seeing people saying you know what this was really really valuable to me um that is what fuels me right lift other people up and they'll do the same for you never debate a rejection Publishers will reject you for all sorts of different reasons sometimes good reasons sometimes bad reasons okay they might reject you because your game doesn't really fit in their catalog they might reject you because it's not going to fit in the right box size that they use they might reject you because they can't afford the sort of components that you're requiring from them they might reject you because of personal taste it's just not the sort of game that they like they might reject you because they think your game's rubbish that's a bit harder to suck up but yeah we've all got to I'm hard on games sometimes why shouldn't a publisher be um and they might reject you for some ludicrous reason that you just know is completely injust okay and and not nonsense never argue with them what a waste of time they've made up their mind they've made up their mind they're not going to change it because you debate with them leave it smile say thank you thank you for your feedback thank you for taking the time to look at my game move on to somebody else there
are plenty of other Publishers out there okay I I at Essence Spiel I met with 30 of them and I could have met with more if I had more hours in the day okay there are a lot of Publishers you don't need to be arguing with one of them and trying to change their mind cuz you're not going to achieve it just get on with your life doesn't matter go back to them with another game in the future or don't give them a black mark doesn't matter don't argue with them don't debate with them be a professional they talk to each other okay if they don't if they're not happy with your approach if they think you're unprofessional it'll feed back to other Publishers so that is my second 10 taking us from number numers 90 to 81 and we're gradually working our way through my 100 lessons I've learned in the board game industry if you enjoyed it please watch some of my other videos subscribe comment and share this one all the best did you know that launch lab has multiple shipping options and shipping this game to the UK costs as low as $7 for a single unit or $25 for 10 if you'd like to produce a professional looking prototype and have it shipped anywhere in the world l on to launtop docomond Wales for a 20% discount