Wingspan Vs. Wyrmspan Vs. Finspan: A Buyer's Guide
Transcript
hi everyone I'm tally this is Farrell and we're Bor of it and Welcome to our buyer guide for the wingspan series of games which includes wingspan worms span and finpan maybe you're new to the world of wingspan and you're wondering which game you should start with because you're a bit confused about it all maybe you already own one or two of the games and you're thinking about whether the other ones in the series are worth your time then we've got you covered yep so please note that in this video it will be timestamped so you can jump to whatever section is relevant for you knowing the differences learning about the games it's all there to jump around and also as a disclosure just note that we bought the base game of wingspan ourself but we were provided worms span and finpan as review copies uh from the publisher and also that there is a lot of expansion content for wingspan and we're not going to get into that we actually have a buyer guide just for wingspan that covers all of that expansion content so we recommend you go and watch that video uh we're just going to be talking about the base games in this video and one very final thing before we get into all of these games currently YouTube has changed their algorithm and it's hurting a lot of channels uh we've seen a lot of talk about this and we're experiencing it where essentially videos aren't being pushed to anyone so as you can say a stand our video might be pushed to all
of our subscribers when it's released now across the first week only a third of our subscribers might see it uh so please please if you're a regular viewer consider clicking the notify the Bell icon and being notified when videos come out because a lot of channels are having the videos be dead on arrival and it's a constant problem at the moment thanks for your help and let's get into it
wingspan is a board game published in 2019 by publisher stonem games it was designed by Elizabeth Hargrave with art from Anna Maria Martinez yo Natalia rohas Greg May and Beth soel it was themed or is themed around attracting North American birds to a Wildlife Reserve and its core gameplay components are Tableau and engine building it became an instant success uh for many reasons it's a very accessible gameplay it's vibrant artwork and the things such as it's its wonderful components you know it has this Dice Tower shaped like a bird feeder it has these wonderfully tactile little legs they all helped contribute to its success now it's become so popular that it's even being featured on TV shows and it also is currently ranked the 32nd best board game of all time on Board Game Geek wingspan is played over four rounds with a diminishing number of actions available each round there are four actions that you can take you can play a bird card to your Tableau which will cost you resources and maybe eggs and then the other three actions are all related to the rows on your tableau and allow you to gain food lay eggs or Draw
cards respectively when you take one of the latter three actions after the action you'll move from right to left across the pl Birds within that row activating any when activated Powers allowing you to chain together several actions within one turn most of the birds do have powers and if they are not when activated they could be that you get something when they are played on the Tableau or when another player takes a certain action points come from a variety of sources such as personal objectives bird cards and food and eggs cashed on bird cards there are also end of round goals for players to compete over with points being awarded how well you do in relation to other players to Mark these end of round goals you'll need to lose an action Cube thus the amount of actions is diminishing every round however as the game goes on you'll build up your engine in and you'll be taking more complex turns so this balances out 2024 saw the surprise announcement of worms span the second game in what had now become a series of wingspan games in this game they swapped out the birds for fictional worms EG dragons if you're uh confused and think I'm talking about earthworms as T did when I first told her about this game this was designed by Connie vogelman with a development credit of course to
Elizabeth Hargrave and art by Clementine cardu this is a bit of a Gamers wingspan it has a couple of additional mechanisms it's a bit more complex it's kind of Tighter and crunchier and there's a bit more resource scar scarcity so a lot to like if you're a bit more of a hardcore gamer
first there's the obvious change from birds to dragons but the cards work in the same way I.E to play them you have to pay resources and they provide bonuses what's different about playing Dragons is the introduction of a second type of card cave cards in order to play a dragon into your Tableau of which there are now three rows and four columns there first must be a cave card representing that you've excavated that spot spot in order to make room for the dragon cave cards also provide instant bonuses when they are played interestingly there are now a variable number of actions per round players given a certain amount of coins which are spent to do actions but it is possible to generate more and it's also possible to reduce the number of actions you have in a round by having to spend your coins on Dragon costs one of the bigger changes is to the actions so in wingspan you had four actions and three of which were associated with rows so you took that action and then it kind of activated any when activated powers in that row now you don't have those actions anymore what you have is a single action called explore where you will move your Explorer mle along a row stopping at Explorer spaces uh some are pre-printed on the board and kind of getting further down requires you to have Dragon cards in that row but you may also have Explorer spaces on Dragon
cards so then you can kind of much like in the same way as wingspan build up your row of actions and kind of have that engine building element what's interesting about this system is that although each row is associated with the type of resource again like wingspan you have your food your cave cards and Your Dragon cards uh Rose what happens is that the more you you go uh to one row within a round the more expensive it gets so this means that there is a push to be more efficient in your actions and you can't just Hammer your one row where you've built up maybe a good points generating system there's also the addition of the Dragon Guild which is a track players will move around gaining a resource at each step and it also provides VP or Superior bonuses at the mid and end points there are no objective cards in worms band but there is still end of round goals with an improved scoring system although quite similar in design all of these tweaks make worm span a little tighter give it a little bit more depth and certainly a distinct game Flow to wingspan a little less of a surprise finpan arrived in 2025 and is the third game in the wingspan series with a focus on fish and marine life designed by David Gordon and
Michael oconnell with of course a developer credit to Elizabeth Hargrave this has art from Anna Maria Martinez yo and Mesa schuma this represents a streamlining of the wingspan system uh refining uh there is a tighter economy there is a tighter focus and as such it is actually the most approachable of three games and the most familyfriendly even more so than wingspan finpan is the lightest game of the three as it streamlines many of the mechanisms from the previous two here there are only two actions player card or dive player card is pretty self-explanatory and dive is very similar to explore from worms span where you'll choose a column and your diver will move down the column collecting bonuses depending on which regions you've placed your fish cards in and activating any when activated bonuses from fish cards as the diver passes over them now there are only three resources to play around with uh cards young and eggs and what's quite interesting is any fish card you play might ask for one or multiple of these different units uh so it creates quite a nice decision space because on their own eggs and Young are worth points and obviously cards you want to play so if you're sacrificing any of those you're kind of giving up
something fairly important for gameplay so there's a lot of just interesting decisions on what to sacrifice but this also brings what I will term a mini game for lack of a better word because what you're kind of trying to do on the resources you don't spend are hatch eggs into young and then move young around so you have three on one fish and then they turn turn into schools and schools kind of double their points values so you kind of have this spatial puzzle as well it's also a nicer game than its predecessors as at the end of each round you score the objectives based on how well you do against them rather than how well you do versus the other players also many of the fish cards that you play when they have the when activated bonus the other players also get to claim the bonus which is pretty nice honestly there's not too much more to say other than that as it's a pretty condensed game of playing cards boosting your actions and meeting objectives which polishes the wingspan system to a shine in this section we're just going to talk about what we think and yeah like bit of a buyers guide what order you should buy them in should you get all of them that kind of thing and I think just to start I think we' both agree after favorite is worms span yes and this is I think just because as we kind of alluded to throughout uh the rest of the review that worms span is
more of the gamers wingspan and we just like that extra crunch I don't know what you like yeah exactly just a little bit more thinky maybe a little bit more to consider I do really love wingspan though maybe it's just holding a little bit more of nostalgia Factor MH but gaml wise then yeah worms span is the one that we prefer um maybe wingspan gets a little bit more airtime let's say with friends that's also something to consider because it is that little bit lighter yeah but yeah if it's just me and you then we're going to opt for worms span with I think fin span being the least favorite but that's not to say it's a bad game at all really really enjoyed playing it but just out of the three I think it would be the one that I would least opt for yeah I I completely agree fin span's a bit of a weird one because it's come out and actually a lot of people have said it's their favorite wingspan game and I think there's something in that it has this tigh of focus it's a very clean game as we said there's very few resources it's like this very self-contained economy uh it's stripped out a lot of the more uh you say almost competitive elements but like crunchy elements it's just very very polished and stream so I can see why people like that um you absolutely hate the theme I'm very scared of eels struggle to even say the
word so that is uh yeah definitely a negative for me there have been instances where I've flipped over a fish card and it's been one of those things and I have screamed you've screamed multiple times playing fin fan yeah some of the fish are very beautiful though and I like to look at them but just yeah yeah that element for me is a bit tough so in terms of okay so I guess first question do you think that you would need to have them all do you think that you can have two and not the other like how would you play it yeah actually um I think if you started with finpan you would in a way want to like work your way up and maybe have all three yeah but I feel like if you have these two these two I think do different enough things for us that we I mean we're going to have this in our collection as well but these two I think are distinct enough to have both yeah whereas if you start over here this is lighter and easier so do you really want to like go backwards is a bit the wrong word but but I I agree I think that if you I think one of the things is well is that I agree that I think particularly wingspan and worms span do different things yeah in terms of their mechanisms I think this is very approachable and you can play with anyone and everyone enjoys it like generally um that's a bit more you know
gamery so there's something in both of them and they kind of the actions are like different and the powers are different and the resource you know uh but the way W worms span is is kind of Action System is basically the same as finpan yeah so then I think there's also that where it's like these two feel different whereas I think worms span and finpan feel very similar in terms of like the core Action System so then yeah it's like is it a bit much to have both of them yeah but I agree with what you said that I think you might work your way up but you won't work your way down and also I think one thing is that with wingspan there's such a wealth of extra content uh all the expansions you know you have the Oceania expansion which kind of addresses some gameplay concerns from the base game you have the Asia game uh which can be Standalone two-player game you have all the other kind of you know the European expansion which is more cards and objectives and such so there's kind of like a lot of content as you can see from this box uh I think if you like you said really really don't like I mean these are like barely competitive some like Light Elements of interaction like how you can take cards from a central Marketplace for instance but if you really don't like any of that then finpan probably is your best bet because there really is nothing that you can do to yeah greet other players so if that's
more your cup of tea then yeah fins bam would be best yeah I think so moving to if you're look if you don't have any of them and you're looking to get one I I would say definitely start um I'll say for probably the average person I would say start with either fins fan or Wings fan probably just whatever takes your fancy a bit more cuz I mean although we like fin fan the least it is a very good a very kind of polished and clean game um so I think there's not too much in these two uh so I'd say whatever sounds better to you uh if you're more of a gamer then and you're only from one then I would say worms fan I think it has a little bit of edge to it that like more hardcore Gamers will enjoy um but you can't really go wrong with any of them no but yeah I would say start with one of these two and then move up but I wouldn't necessarily say if you start with one of these you'd have to go to the other one no I agree um yeah so any any final thoughts on the trilogy really yeah we really like it as we've mentioned um yeah now that we have all three I think they hold kind of different places in the collection like we just alluded to for different occasions different groups maybe so yeah love the kind of core systems that it
brings it's always very I think like soothing to play these games I agree um maybe just because it's something we've played a lot now but just I don't know the way that you do it and the way that you build up the engines and then get bigger and bigger turns is just something quite satisfying but it's just not something too aggressive or if you just want to kind of focus a little bit more on your own you know Tableau and building that just find them quite soothing to play always calms me when I play any of them yeah apart from the eels surprised you keep saying it I'm actually sweating yeah so uh that is our bias guide for the wings fan series if you have any questions please ask us we're happy to answer any about any of the games uh feel free to check out our wingspan and buyers guide to learn more about all those expansions there is a lot of content for wingspan and we really appreciate you watching and as we said at the beginning of the video please if you're a regular viewer uh click the Bell icon to be notified when our videos come out as currently YouTube is kind of killing the algorithm and is a bad time for a lot of channels we would appreciate it but thanks L for watching and we'll see you next time bye bye