Heat or Flamme Rouge? Comparison Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today I'm going to be comparing two very similar racing games by the same designer and letting you guys know what I think of them and also letting you guys know which which one I would choose uh if I had to now the games I'm talking about are flam Rouge which is a of course a racing game based on the Tour de France and also the heat pedal to the metal which is the newer design of the two very popular at the moment and this is based on the kind of early days of Formula One now before I get into my very informal chat on these games I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor keyienda dot Co dot UK who are my go to online retailer when it comes to purchasing board games here in the UK and if you use my link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order okay so I'm going to talk about these games quite informally there's going to be no order here I'm not going to go into tremendous detail I'm just going to spitball some thoughts on them so let's start with flam Rouge so I actually played flam Rose a long time ago when it originally came out I was very much enamored with the game when it first came out I really did appreciate the Elegance of it how simple those rules were and how clever the game was tied to its thematic ties now this was you know it taught a France Style game and it really did bring to the Forefront that feel of a Tour de France race especially through the use of that slip streaming mechanism where if your cyclist was behind another group of cyclists you can make up the ground as you are not taking some wind resistance you can get a lot of mileage about how you use
these cards and I also love the idea that if you were ever in the front of a pack of psychos or a Peloton then you would take these kind of exhaustion cars to represent that you know you are taking the brunt of that resistance and much like a deck building game you know the more you cycle for these cars the more those exhaustion cards you get the worse you're going to get because they're going to make you slower and slower and slower it also had this great Hill um climbing and kind of um Hill rolling mechanism where if you would spend High cars going uphills then you would not get the maximum benefit from them because you'd get capped at a certain movement level and the other one would be if you're going downhills and used a very low movement card you would get some extra momentum and move faster because of course you are using the gravity and to help you very simple game um some cool ideas by the fact that you would have two pieces in the game so you'd have a roller and a sprinter and you could actually use them to support each other so the roller was generally a bit more well-rounded and the Sprinter had the lower value cars but also had those really high point cards high value cards which would burst forward when you needed to and again I love the way that you could utilize with each other to share the brunt of the wind resistance and you know maybe give each other a bunch or a bunch of slip streaming um benefits Etc really well implemented it's scaled great and you could even choose to play with like a rider each and Skillets like eight players and flow very smoothly and it just did what it did um very well now I think one of the things that made this game feel
different to a lot of other racing games was that you would not be too rewarded or you'd not be rewarded by just going for it you know you have to pace yourself and sometimes you'll be rewarded with patience now you had to really know when it was time to flick the switch and push forward and kind of utilize your deck and know when to start taking that Branch because if you go if you're in the front too much earlier in the race again those exhaustion cards are going to catch up with you so yeah I did like this game a lot I still speak highly of it now I think I did burn myself off on it a bit too quickly early because I played it a lot in short succession that tends to be a bit of a nail in the coffin for me because I tend to like variety um but hey it's still a really solid game a very clean game that's a lot of fun now fast forward to 2022 and heat to pedal to the metal uh comes out so this is of course setting again I think it's like 60s era of Formula One now I'm not a formula one fan at all I'm not a fan of cards I'm not a petrol head if you want to put it that way um but it did share a lot of DNA with flam Rouge and especially through the card cycling system as you'd have a bunch of different cards and different numbers on them and know where to play them now the trick on this one was the fact that rather than having the hills and the multi-slip streaming system you would have to almost like the Formula One race you'd have to time your Corners carefully um not go around them too quickly um Etc now there were certainly more
levels here or more layers 2D gameplay here which I actually initially was quite surprised about because I was very much under the impression that this was a very accessible game of completely family weight and maybe I won't dispute that fully but I was surprised with how much is going on here because again there is a few more mechanisms and more rules that come into play when you go around corners um the slip streaming mechanism there's a few more choices in terms of the phase order you've got using boost cards Etc um but I do feel like the the hand management and the way you use cards is a bit more interesting in heat than it was with flam Rouge because in this one rather than taking exhaustion cards of course you wouldn't because you're you know you're in a car um you would kind of use these Heat this this deck of heat cards and that'll transfer consistently to your deck and back to that that um heat pile of cars so it's a constant flow of the two rather than just stockpiling and filling up your deck and I loved the management of this game in terms of how you manage that heat because they're rubbish because they clog up your hand um but of course you need it at the right time because you might want to take the lead of course it added this layer in in terms of the gear system which if you'd be in lower gears you could choose to eradicate heat from your hand and put it back in the pile ready for you to use it again on a future Corner Maybe but um at the same time it would mean that you could play fewer cars in terms of
the speed you're going now sometimes that could be good because if you're going around a really tight Corner then you want to go in that low gear and only play one card so you don't take too much heat in terms of over spilling but it means that you have to maybe an eternal too you have to keep filtering your way through the gears in order to get to play more cards again so I think it ranges from like um one card up to being four cards played at a time and that's as a whole new record of the game on when to switch gear when to blurt through the gears and go really fast by switching more than one gear at a time and potentially taking more heat yeah a really cool system there initially I was thinking that there's too much going on here for a simple family work game I think I like the the crispness and the more cleaner version of flam Rouge now that was at my first game of heat now after my second game of heat that was completely nullified I did not feel that way anymore and I thought that all the additional wrinkles and the extra elements of gameplay made for a much more rich and a much more interesting game and that's not to downplay flam Rouge because I think that's very clever and I think a big portion of that is because in flam Rouge it would kind of be a bit going through the motions until it was time to again flip that Switch and Go For the Kill whereas I think in heat you are rewarded for playing consistently well if you have managed your hand of um of heat through the first lap of the race really well it means you've got a bit more leeway in your second lap to kind of start flowing around his Corners a bit more recklessly um Etc so I do think that you are more you get
more consistently rewarded for better play rather than just kind of going on a gut reaction and I'm going for the kill like you are in flam Rouge and I also am really appreciative appreciative of the fact that flam root sorry heat managed to maintain that slip stripping mechanism which I think is one of the unique things about this series of games still did it really well you know if you landed on one space behind something you can slip stream right around them and then benefit from that and there's even wrinkles to the game with how you use that and utilize that going around corners because you can get a lot of mileage should you time things and predict the movement of other players so yeah there's some actually some really cool little tactical tricks you could do here that you probably need to play the game to find out how it works now I must say I think that sometimes it feels like heat went on a little bit too long um if you're playing like a short amount you have to pay like three laps um bigger Maps you normally play two I must admit normally three quarters of the way through the race I'm ready for it to finish or maybe even before that but it's it's kind of a double-edged sword because going back to that idea of your first lap really being important for your second lap it means that if you wanted to play just one lap in total you're not going to get that full um you know reward of playing well you can kind of maybe wing it a bit more and it can be a little bit more swingy rather than again being rewarded for playing well consistently which again goes hand in hand with how long the game is so sadly I think you can't have one uh without the other
um and I was also a little bit concerned about this idea of drafting cards at the start of the game because heat actually adds in these modules where you can do this draft pre-race which will give you unique cards for your deck now these unique cards might be things such as being versatile in terms of going really fast all really slow on a certain card you can choose how to use it we want to let you get rid of heat even if you're in a high gear Etc now I thought that might be a bit imbalanced in terms of people who've played the game loads um knowing which cards to go for which are the best and I was another one another example of me being really wrong I think the actual drafting added lows to the gameplay and I thought they were really cool when these cards came into your deck and then once you use them when to hold on to them they went to discard them ready for them to come out again I added another little wrinkle and Nuance to the gameplay so again I was expecting not to like that part and I was I was wrong I'm so yeah I was pleasantly surprised by that and I must admit I actually did like the fact that you only ever have one car in heat because although I like I said massively get the idea of you piggybacking off yourself in terms of slip streaming and flam Rouge by having two races in this one you only have to take ownership of one car which for me it made you feel a little bit more invested and keeps a little bit more simple so so yeah um that's it really I mean again all my concerns about heat after that initial teach were quickly um you know bled away and were alleviated and I
left the game feeling quite a fan of heat actually despite me not thinking I would because generally family weight style games um are what I like though when I enjoy them I find that my enjoyment of them goes pretty quickly now I'm not going to say that he is going to be my favorite game ever but it's definitely one of those games that I can certainly objectively see that this game has been really well thought so very well designed it's simple enough to get into you can edit a few things out if you're playing with maybe people who don't want those successive things or you can just add a little bit extra if you want to play a slightly more complex version of it but again that that the actual choices you make are a bit more consistent and a bit more um I think it gives you a bit more autonomy it makes you take ownership a bit more than flam Rouge does so I actually think these are both fantastic racing games I put them definitely both put them in a top 10 list for example but I actually think and this is much my surprise I think that heat has replaced flam Rouge for me and I was not expecting uh to say that I was quite impressed actually with the way that heat was put together so that's it really it's been a bit of a rambling video I apologize for that but hopefully that's given you a bit of value as to what I think of these games if you have enjoyed the video please be sure to hit like And subscribe to my channel and for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye