1 Star Reviews of Our Favorite Board Games of All Time
Transcript
People have been hating on our favorite board games of all time. They know nothing. Maybe they know more than us. Let's find out. The premise is very simple. We're going to look at our favorite board games of all time. Top five for you, top five for me, and then read some mean comments. One star ratings. We're starting out with your top five game. And I have found a few comments for you. Yes, people have been rating this as a one-star. What's wrong with them? Let's find out. Dune Imperium is a deck building worker placement game where you play one of the powerful houses in the universe of Dune and try to get 10 treatment. Yeah, you just take your little workers, send them somewhere, get resources back, and then use those resources to win military fight. Let's see why people hate on it. The deck building is dull, the resource conversion is dull. The worker placement is worker placement. Obviously, the bidding battles could be more exciting.
It's just a mish mash of stuff. The best part is worker placement is worker placement. This game isn't hugely known for deck building, right? It's it's fine there. It's a tiny bit of it. I think this is one of those comments where he just didn't like the game. Is there some truth to it? Is it fair enough? Or is it just old man yelling at clouds? I think it's old man yelling clouds because worker placement is work placement. Of course, I would know. Found this game to be extremely unforgiving with broken mechanics. Lose an early war, lose the game. rewards for winning are so unbalanced that if you lose once, you're basically out of the game. He said the same thing twice. That's how badly he probably lost because he lost the first war. This feels like a person who played it once and got into a situation where he lost a war and then couldn't get back.
You have to lose wars. You can't win all the wars. So, you have to pick and choose your battles. I can see this happening after one bad game. Yeah, this like this one bad experience. I don't think this player has played it more than once. Maybe twice. Get good. In other words, overrated. Too luck based. Easy to teach and play. Not that long. One star. For those who don't know, the rating is from 10 to one. Like one is the worst thing you can do. So this is the worst game ever created. But it's easy to teach and play and not that long. Two ratings in one. So if we read just the bottom sentence, easy to teach and play, not that long. One star. It's It's a good good comment, right? Yeah. I don't not going to write this. It's not serious. It's not a serious comment. Moving on to the next game, which is Spirit Island. It's one of your top games of all time. So, Spirit Island is a gay cooperative game where you try to save the island. You are the spirits that have magical powers and you try to get stronger and stronger by getting new cards and destroying everything. I mean, saving everything by destroying the bad guys. It's like someone took Pandemic and thought, "Hey, how can I turn this game inside out and make it the most overly complicated play possible?" Fair enough.
I mean I mean or in other words how can we take pandemic and make it good cuz they did it's really good perhaps more fun than worry boarding but debatable but debatable so maybe not more fun more be waterboarding maybe he was playing like as the intruder like you can I don't know maybe he played it cuz he can definitely play some cards that could be similar to like water boating or something. Okay. Yeah. But no, it's just old man yelling a pound. Yeah, a funny comment. Not clue what he really didn't like about it, but I guess not that game for him. Way too much bookkeeping. 75% more streamlined would be appreciated. I love how the math has been done. It's exactly 75% streamlining. Not 100%, not 50%, 75%.
This definitely is a difficult game. Well, actually, once you get into it, there's not that much bookkeeping. Maybe they didn't get the rules in the first time. Definitely might be a little like stingy. All right. All right. So, uh, yelling at clouds. Yelling at clouds, definitely. Oh, so this one, this one goes for you. Ruin wars. Ruin wars is an epic fantasy game. Essentially, if you heard of Twilight Imperium in space, this is the same thing in uh fantasy universe where each player takes the role of this epic nation, elves, humans, and tries to control runes. And you play out order cards, you create armies, you have heroes. It's like anything you can imagine in a fantasy world. It has. Yes, it has dragons. Routing equals pile of garbage. One of the most depressing, boring mechanics in all board games. Lay down for the year. Just to give a bit of perspective, when armies are fighting, you can route other players uh units.
That's a fair point. And those units will just lay down and they're going to be laid down for the whole big turn. And I can see how that's not very exciting, but that's just one teeny part of the whole game. Much too long. Play Lord of Hells instead. No, do not. Lot of hells is still like what? Four, five hours. Okay, this is going to be eight for your first game, maybe less. Yeah. Yeah, it's a different experience for sure. For sure. Different experience, but uh I guess I could see where he's coming. Yeah, it's similar like area control type of thing, but I like this better than L. A lot of fair points uh for commentators. Time for some cloud yelling. All right, let's get to one of your faves. Terrifying Mars. What is it? So Mars is a game where you play out cards in front of you making up the blow of different engines. Yeah. And then you try to terraform Mars, building houses there, cities there, and using the oceans and waters there to build the best civilization on Mars.
All right, we'll start off with the quite obvious one. $75. One star. Was it like $1 too much? It's It's fair. It is $75. And uh do you think it was $1 too many to be at least two rating? What a slo. Have never understood the high acclaim. applauding Eurogame engine builder whose engines take way too long to build and whose resources, convention, and card play is large, bananel, and not particularly novel. Well, I think it's pretty original how the cards combine. At least I haven't found any other game that's so easy to get to the table and the combos work. So, it's definitely old man yelling at clouds. Hey, Germany, this one goes for you. It's actually my favorite board game of all time according to last year's top, but it was also in your top five. So you go. Hegemany is a giant game where you control four different parts of the country. The government, working class, middle class, and the capitalism. And all of these parts are connected. One creates jobs. The other sends workers to work at those jobs.
It's just so much. But yet the game is fairly quick. Does not work as a game. Maybe as an experiment. Didn't he see victory points? That's that's how you know it's a game. Doesn't have dice. works as a game. I have you played. It works pretty well as a game. Pretty awesome. All right. Another asmatic game where everybody's too tired to look at the other boards, too exhausted to talk, so nothing interesting happens. Okay. Uh if you timed this really bad, especially like late, don't don't play this game. There is a lot of things happening and you have to keep track of everyone's doing. But if you're tired to do any of that, doesn't mean the game's bad. Yeah. Yeah, cuz definitely it depends also on the people who are teaching you the rules or the way how you learn the rules cuz you definitely can have a bad experience where you just if somebody just All right, let's sit down and for 2 hours I'm going to explain everything in details and so on. So it depends. It definitely depends. Uh it might be really really difficult uh to get into and play. Oh my god. Fair enough. Can we French edition?
Can we get a fair enough in here? Yeah. I mean would you be able to play a French edition? No. It's essentially unplayable. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Well, they with French uh language. I'm really sorry for your tram. Moving on to the next one, which is Nemesis here. I'm taking this one. Yes. This is well both of our top games of all time. Nemesis is a semi-ooperative game where you are survivors on a spaceship and you each have tasks and some of you will have bad tasks, some good ones depending on your own choices and then you try to survive, right? Yeah. And no one knows except you your task. So, are you a good guy? Are you a bad guy? Probably a bad guy. 5 hours of randomness and bad luck. Great time, huh? Yeah. This game is for everyone who enjoys to be controlled by the game and having no options. Player elimination way too soon. That was my first game. I I got killed 30 minutes in.
There is randomness and bad luck, but I do not agree at all about not having options. Uh, I think yes, you could die from randomness, not by your doing, but uh, also you can set yourself up to put yourself into situations where you give yourself the best chance. And that's what it's all about. Shameless alien ripoff. Maybe the game is good, but the treatment of an IP is simply unacceptable. Unacceptable. Never. I guess I see where he's coming on, but it's really old man yelling at us. Twilight Struggle is my favorite game. second favorite game of all time last year and it is a two-player massive epic game that covers the Cold War. One player plays the USSR, the other player plays the US and you're trying to control countries and it's great. One of the best things is it's a card during game. What that means is we have cards which I can play for the event or use the points on the card for actions. It's great. It's historic. I love it. But I guess these guys don't draw one OP cards and roll one two. I know what he's saying. Ops are operation points. So, the cards have operation points ranging from one to four. So, if you draw a ton of ones, not a lot actions you can do, but I can see why that might not work for Pestly. I'd say it's it's fair enough. Yeah.
Yeah, it's fair enough. I've yet to play, but judging by the rules, this promises to be an excellent game. That's why Barry Barry rated it as a one star. Uh, it doesn't make sense. Uh, it's uh uh what? This one goes for me. My second favorite board game of all time according to last year's top. Subscribe to know this year's top. All right. It's coming up uh in December. So Trespass is a massive campaign game with tons of things to do like ship management, like exploring, like building, crafting, things like fighting boss. That's the biggest part. There's lots of things and I bet these comments will talk about all of those things. Overrated, one star. Let's just start off. Is it overrated? I mean, it could be. is my second favorite board game of all time, but I definitely can see that it's not for everyone. Not all people like the same things.
Overrated one star. Well, that's a different issue. I really wanted to like this game as it has so much going on for it yet. But simply, it is just not that fun to play. It's just too much of everything. Too many rules, too many cards, and takes up too much space. Yes. Yes. And yes, I get it. Definitely. Uh I've now have close to 200 hours, I think, in this board game. Have you learned it? No. somewhat and I'm adding house rules to it and trying to manage myself, but it's also the part of the experience that I enjoyed cracking. It's a lot of things, but it is definitely a lot a lot of cards, uh, a lot of everything. So, I totally can get it. It can be overwhelming. Never understood it when people say the game can feel like a chore until I played this game. Can it feel like a chore? It can. It definitely can. It depends on how well you you are with managing things cuz I have my own like set box where I place all the cards so it's easier easier to set up. I have a table where I place the game and then leave it. So if you don't have a dedicated space, this game is a is a is is a chore. It kind of feel a chore definitely. So last one for you, my friend, is here I stand and here you stand.
Here I stand is an epic historic game that covers the war of reformation. If you have no idea what that is. Oh, here we go. I'm not going to explain that in this video. We'll make a separate video. But each player plays country essentially like England, Spain, Ottomans, and tries to control regions, spread their religion, steal stuff from each other. There's a lot of diplomatic like negotiation back and forth. It's many things. Okay, hit me. Does this Oh, that's that's an easy one. Okay, so Ed Beach, the designer of this game, really likes the subject and so he thought that he should create the game around it. That's why this exists. One star more. Yeah. Here I sleep long turns of doing nothing interesting at all. Fair enough. That can happen. You can get locked out and some of the bad dice rolls, card draws, decisions that you make, or just other players ganging up on you can quite, you know, lower your game. We played for 10 hours and didn't finish it. Yeah, there are many games that I played for many hours and didn't finish it. So, if that warrants a one, then that's a fair point. All right, so last game. This one by promise that game.
Yeah, War of the Ring. And this one goes for me. War of the Ring is Lord of the Rings inside a board game blocks where uh two sides fight it out each other. Try to destroy the ring or take over Middle Earth by military force and you just play out cards to do things. Roll dice that gives you some actions. Moving armies, attacking, moving, please. No. That's a good one. Well, that's what Smeaggel said in the end, right? So maybe he's just want to be want wanting to be the thematical bra. No one wants to learn this ducks. I think this is one of the fairest comments. Do you want to learn big games ever? No. No. Fair enough, isn't it? If I could play this without learning it. Yeah, I'm in. Yeah, totally. Monkey these nuts.
I totally agree. I'd rather just know all the games, right, bro? I don't want to learn this. And that's it. Do we agree with these ratings? No. But the comments sometimes, right? Yeah. Yeah. Some are fair, some are way out there. And if you like to find out what I don't like and about War of the Ring, well, check out our Plain to Insane video where I changed and improved all the things that I didn't like and now I love it even more. Except the theme. It's still rings. You couldn't fix that.