Skip to main content
Loading video...

How to Review Board Games, and Why a Traditional Rating System isn't for us

Transcript 22:43

hello and welcome to board stupid my name is Wayne and I'm mad and have you ever tried to review a board game it's hard isn't it turns out turns out it's pretty hard and there are loads of different ways to review board games Matt yes and in this video we really want to dig into that process a little bit Yeah because we've had a lot of conversations recently about how we do it yeah we did cuz um um so far we had um very much um uh a way of reviewing games uh that we're going to speak about it in a second and uh but we are probably going to move to something else to make it a little bit more uh modern or um or or adjusted to the present day and what this channel is becoming a little bit absolutely yeah we're definitely going to be doing that so we're going to talk about how to review a board game and how we're going to review a board game and the problems that we actually find with some of the other different rating systems um and why they don't necessarily work for us I think absolutely so um if you want to stick around and listen to that conversation a good thing that you should probably do is hit the Subscribe button first of all first of all hit that subscribe button cuz really help us as as a channel and you so you can get a notification every time we get you a new video and every time we create content for you yeah and uh also just to remind you that if you click the into the link down in description you get 10% discount on top of any other discount

for some amazing graphic te and some very nice outdoor wearing and yes is they got a lot of very good stuff to check their website um cuz he's very good so you can treat yourself reignite your wardrobe with our special link Now Matt let's talk about ball game review yeah let's start this episode let's do it

okay let's start um talking a little bit of um how we did review so far for the games uh so way since we started the channel even before starting the channel we had this uh one to five rating uh for reviewing Bard games and uh there's always been like how EOS our mot that um we love games and uh the point was like we only want to play awesome games that's it that was the always the ethos was like we're going to play awesome games and talk about yes exactly that's it um so that's why all the videos that you can find on the um on our playlist on the channels they always has been like about games that we love that we love that we think that they're really good so um every top five or top 10 selection or um every recommended or or even the reviews it's always been like games that we love and we want to talk to you about it absolutely so however yeah however so with that fivepoint scale Matt we kind of got to a point where we're never using the entirety of scale it's always yeah the worst the worst is three I can't remember which one we we we called like 3.5 that is do you should we go through our our ideas so starting from the let's go five out of five and and scaling down yeah so

five out of five in the original scale is uh we recommend you buy this game it's a recommendation to buy it's a game that you should have you should definitely you should have the game um a four out of five game was a game you should play game try and also you'd ask you'd ask to play it you might not buy it yeah exactly you might not want it in your collection but a four out of five is a game that every time is going to be on the table you'll be super happy to play or you're going to ask can we play that game can we play that game if you don't own it you might yeah exactly but three out of five I think we said was um you wouldn't buy it and you wouldn't necessarily ask to play it if it's there you give it a go give it a go and you play it if someone really wants to play it but do you know what I'm happy or it's one of those games that you want to play every now and then you still got to have fun playing it but it's not entirely for you might be because the gener is not it's not for you might be the theme is not for you but they're still solid good gamees exactly ex a solid game I think we said solid game solid game uh a two I think we described as a game that you would only play in certain situations it might have lots of flaws you might not even NE like it that much but you would play it under certain scenarios yeah it's like if you forc me to play it I'll play it I would not leave I would not leave the party but yeah it's it's one of those all all talking about parties is going to be long I don't know one of those party games that you know you you're not going

to ask to play it but in a party mood you might have a lot of fun playing it but in general it's not going to be your pick outside of that you'd never recommend it you'd never ask for it yeah exactly and at one we basically just put the words have you got anything else yes it is literally like I don't want to play that oh Wayne let's play this so Wayne's going to be like have you have something else right yeah but for that to be a one for us the idea was the game is so bad in terms of like I don't know rules or it's messy or unfun unfun cuz there are games that are unfun unfortunately unfortunately bled games aren fun yeah absolutely so again this was our general view of the game this 54 3 2 1 but again since we started this channel we always uh started doing okay well let's talk about root root we both love it of course he a five out of five let's talk about heat heat we both love it of course it's out five out of five um luckily thanks to you guys yeah uh the channel went from last October November 2023 to today uh August 24 from 2000 from zero to almost 2,000 um subscriber that's how it happen thank

you thank you so much um and we started being approached by more than one uh publisher or designer to start reviewing their games um we had so far a lot of like publisher or designer that we absolutely adore and we were more than happy to to work with and all just to get a review copy again we do not take any money out of it we that's that's how we do it we but we've been very happy to play their games and to review their games um but in the last few months due to this like the growth of the channel and people started recognizing my ugly face or or the beautiful face Wayne um we we we started getting approached by publisher that we were not familiar with yeah or we've been started asking to be to to review games that we didn't really had on our radar hadn't heard of at all in some cases and uh some of them are good yeah some of them are not for us precisely that and it's got to a point now where we think we should probably start covering more games that just aren't for us um because we've already spent the effort in that way playing the games yes right and so the additional input of um then doing a a video review for you uh I think is is is more useful than not we always were

under the original ethos or we don't want to do it because it's additional energy on things that we don't want to spend energy on right again we're not doing this as a as a job this is a um um a side usle for us uh we take away time from uh from our partners we take away time from from doing from doing playes together playing games but um this this we really like doing it so of course we put we put time in it and um we always found that it's like oh do we really need to spend now like an hour setting up and recording and uh editing a video about a game that with didn't like yeah before has always been like no no before is always been like no I don't I think it's a it's a waste of everybody's time yeah um but again we are not even close to Big a channel as channels that we always watch like yeah we're not like sharp and sit down or but if you guys are watching it hey love you guys an autograph yeah or or the dice game hangover yeah or average like you got you got so many big channels we're not even close to that however we started seeing that we might need to review how we review in board games because if we're being sensed off by Publishers under the faith that we might look at that stuff we should probably look at that stuff and do something

right and if we like it or not it would be useful information for you who come to our channel in good faith looking for guidance on what games to potentially put your money in yeah and if you put money in games that we think probably aren't for us um and we had the chance to tell you that uh the potential flaws and we didn't I think I'd feel pretty bad about that no yeah exactly I think it's a it's more like a a service that we do yeah uh to the to the B game community and again change of an ethos a little bit and again it's going to be our opinion and that is we all get wonky opinions but uh we we we played few ball games at this point in our lives so we got we got an idea of what kind of works and what not all the the games we always try to play at different play accounts we got our we're lucky enough their out Partners as well they both loves play uh ball gam we do a lot of like four player games so we we got a good idea and sometimes games are not good for for a group and we've got a good diverse group folks in our in our crew that like and so if if if no one likes it then that's probably something that you should know uh and I think it would be useful for you as a viewer to know that so let's talk about all of the different ways that we could review games and why we've chosen to move away from our fivepoint category because we could have just kept at the fivepoint category yeah but let's have a chat

about it about that so Matt there are lots of different ways that we could have gone right we could have with like a 10-point scale which is quite common yeah um we could have gone with uh reviewing and scoring games section by section game play production this this and that and giving like a fun factor or whatever I don't know score out of a 100 or something 100 Point score or something like that or a letter grading or something like that and I think for me at least Matt I don't want to get lost in granularity I think I wanted I think when we had this discussion we wanted if anything it was a long discussion yeah a long discussion more simplification because what's the overall aim the overall aim I think is just to provide good information yeah it's it's going to be at the end uh we want you to watch a an enjoyable review of the game when we talk about it and at the end of the day we tell you this is for us this is not for us or this is for everyone yeah that's essent that's essentially it and we basically settled on those three broad categories um because when I was having a chat with Matt and the rest of the guys uh at board stupid HQ um a lot of the games that I own would be basically um a six or seven or eight and I'd recommend those games all the time yeah of course swise you you would have not it's very rare nowadays that we buy a game that don't know anything about it we have extent research about the games

we know what the designer are what the what the game looks like then you buy the game it's very rare that you buy a game that you done research and then it's like this is rubbish absolutely sometimes happen it it does happen it certainly does and those games I would wrate somewhere like a one through five and would I recommend someone play a one through five like one if I score if I had a 10-point scale would I recommend someone play a game that I scored a 1 2 3 four five no no no I wouldn't I'd recommend you play a six seven or eight yeah and if I scored a game on a 9 or 10 I'd probably say you should buy that yeah so that is basically basically that's basically the idea giving a a a seal of approval that um if we finish the design should appear here yeah this is the board stupid seal of Excellence y so this is for games it's like a '90s St do you remember this Nintendo seal qu I love it I loved it do you remember the '90s Nintendo Nintendo G if you're around 40s Mark like us you will remember and that's this this is the Seal of quality our seal of excellence and these games we recommend this was like our old 5 out five yes but more this is more than that this is those are the games that we tell you you should go out right now and buy a copy yeah we think that they represent just great examples of the genre um that they have amazing production values and they must have

excellent rules yes the rules must be really great and clear and easy to read and learn um that they provide great replayability great value in terms of their production the production should also be excellent um and that they do something either very exciting or otherwise Innovative yeah yeah yeah or all all these things all together again it's not going to be oh this games is better than the other it's like in this gener in this type of things is is an excellent game yes or not it could be a party game yes could be like a very Mega Heavy Euro so that's the big difference um but yeah that's entirely the point Matt you've made an excellent point this could be party games this could be very light games it's just does it do all of these things that we've just talked about if it does and we really need to steer away from we've already talked about it in the weight ratings the discussion that on BGG and other types of sort of board game communities there's a heavy towards heavier games yeah in terms of thinking that they're the greatest things this is going to be an excellent it because for me uh don't know something like just one yes is a is a party game is a very cheap small party game but to me it gets the of Excellence because in his gener in his in his bubble is an amazing game absolutely it does exactly what it tries to do in an amazing way and it does something Innovative and interesting and

exciting so all of that good stuff so that's the top category yeah and that and and to be what we need to add is that games will get a seal of excellent just if both of us agree that should have the Seal of Excellence so it's going to be um um a a unanimous unanimous um um decision that we both needs to really like to have that game to have that a seal of excellent absolutely so those are the rules around seal of Excellence the next broad category is just recommended boad stupid recommended yeah and those games um they might have a Flor or two they could be an issue here or there but otherwise they could be solid good or very good games yeah right any of those in that category and we we during our review videos we will discuss those what level of recommendation is going to be so a strong recommendation or a recommendation recommended games you don't necessarily have to rush out and buy and be the first in que no but you should probably go and play them yeah exactly those games you should certainly go and play why they might be recommended not seal of Excellence it might be that they could be very expensive or over produced for example right U they could be really good games but they might be $200 and we can't recommend you a seal of Excellence on a game like that I don't think I mean they'd have to be really good value for that or it might have a couple of sticky

rules or the game might be unusual or not necessarily for everybody yeah yeah it could be like I don't know a very large um large number of of players game where if you can only play if it's eight of you you can't yeah it's very difficult to get eight players around the table that's why it will not get the most likely not get the might might do I'm thinking about something like Twilight Imperium yes that for me is a of Excellence for example so but yeah again it will it's going to be like a do cases depending on on the games yeah but the recommended is quite a broad category we recommend that you play these games for sure and it might be for you that you end up buying mhm okay y clear good and then our final of bottom category games is quite simply just and we've talked about this a couple of times already on this video I don't know if you've already caught the phrase but we've said it a few times and that is it's just not for us and that's fine yeah it might be for you but these games we think would have maybe some significant flaws man yeah it's uh significant flaws or the rules are very messy uh or I don't know some of them the artwork could be that bad that you don't the production is very production is really bad it could be actually that the game is perfectly sound mechanically it's just very uninspiring yeah it could be so it's going to be that we do not recommend you

to go out and buy the game go find this game or spend time you know but again what we say all the time is and what we try to do we we'll try all the games yeah um then some of them got priority or not so we want to give you our idea on how we putting all those games in kind of like in a in a in a list of which one we want to play first um so yeah again they not recommended doesn't mean that the game is bad it means that it's not a game for us AB that we we found clunky or we found very uninspiring or just not fun in some ways oh it's not fun but then you might find it really fun and having a great time with it so yeah absolutely because I already know that me and way we got games that he would not recommend while I would give a seal of Excellence um and so the there's going to be like yeah this kind of debate but um yeah we'll try there's going to be games where I give a recommended and Way's going to say that he doesn't recommend it so so we will try to have a conversation about why or how I think one things and you think another absolutely and with these three broader categories the one of the eventual and hopeful AES is that um we come at you with a a combined clear voice right so with the broader categories it's more likely that me and Matt are probably going to go this game is not for us as a and this we as a or this is excellent as

air there will of the scenario where exactly so in which case it wouldn't be a not for us it would be a not for me yeah that's correct or not for me exactly and we'll let you know during your reviews if that is the case so that was our discussion on our board game review approach how to review a board game yeah because um we've had deep debates about this over a beer or two yeah exactly and just we just want to make you um include you guys in this conversation and to tell you what's going to happen from from now on when we review games uh so we're going to start probably reviewing more game then in the past there's going to be way more basically yeah and hopefully you're going to enjoy it and you want to hear what we think about it and um yeah just like and you guys you tell us what's your way of reviewing a game of scoring a game yeah how do you approach that do you have like a 10o scale a 100 point scale do you think about games from like segment to segment good ugly or something like that thumbs up thumbs down is it is it even simp thumbs up two it's either yes or no it's one of those it give it the the emperor the julus Cesar the Italian flavor um yeah let how do you rate your Gamers what do you think of our potential thre lay scale and hopefully there's going to be enough Nuance in those three layers that there's going to be plenty of information yeah for you there let us

know in the comments below and if you liked this video you know what to do you need to hit the like button Mt and what else do they need to do hit the Subscribe button of course come on guys let's get those numbers up let's get those numbers do it let's let's raise the room let us know and show us that you care check out the rest of our video videos and we'll catch you again real soon ciao

Progress saved