Great Western Trail: A Buyer's Guide...Which Trail Should You Travel?
Transcript
hello everyone I'm tally this is farell and we are barded of it and Welcome to our buyer guide for the Great Western Trail Trilogy have you heard good things about the original Great Western traal and you're wondering if it's for you maybe you already own that game and you're thinking about whether Argentina or New Zealand is also worth your time or maybe you just want to hear some more about the differences between all three games in this series well worry not we've got you covered with our GWT buyers guide if you haven't seen one of our buyer guides before we keep it mostly factual to inform you of what you should know before buying and then at the end we're going to go through our opinions so more of a review format if you will where we share what we actually think but we're going to take you through the history of Great Western Trail how to play Great Western Trail and then the differences between all the Great Western Trails between the first and the second edition of the original game then between differences of the original game and the two sequels in the trilogy and we'll also talk a little bit about the expansion rails to North for the first game so all of this is going to be timestamped so feel free to jump to the sections that are relevant for you and just know that it would really be appreciated if you subscribed because you subscribing makes us more attractive to Publishers and designers than they want to work with us and it really helps us make these buyas guides particularly when it's a buyers guide with a lot of content
because it's nice to leaz and it makes things a bit easier for us cuz it's very effort intensive but we hope you enjoy it and let's get to the history of Grey Western Trail the original great Weston Trail for two to four players was designed by Alexander Fister and published by egot Spiel in 2016 it has been regarded as one of the best best Euros of all time and it has been pretty happily sat in the top 20 best board games of all time on Board Game Geek for a couple of years now and this is quite surprising given its very dry theme of hering cattle from Texas to Kansas City but it does have the mechanisms to back that rating up which blend together quite well with the theme to have a game which is amazing to go back to and play time and time again Great Western Trail had one expansion rails to the north which was released in 2018 and it was thought that was all for Great Western Trail until egit Spiel surprised everyone in 2021 by announcing that Great Western Trail would not only get a second edition but would be the first game in a Trilogy of Great Western Trail games this then saw the release of the second edition later in 2021 along with a second edition of the expansion rails to the north followed by
Great Western Trail Argentina in 2022 and Great Western Trail New Zealand in 2023 so for this section we're going to show you a brief rules overview from our GWT review because the core rules don't really change across the trilogy this will give you a solid foundation so that in the upcoming sections we can discuss the differences or what's been added to the various additions and versions in Great Western trial you'll start with a standard deck of cows mainly low value the long-term goal is to reach the end of the trail on this board with firstly a hand of all different cows and ideally most are all of them as high value as possible each turn you'll move your cowboy up to three spaces ending on a tile then you can do both actions on that tile in either order some of these actions will allow you to discard a cow from your hand thus building up a better hand for when you get to Kansas City when you do get to Kansas City you'll present your hand then you'll receive money equal to the value of unique cows in your hand you'll also take a disc from your player board and place it in a city with an equal or lower value this will usually get you victory points at the end of the game as well as instantly upgrading an element of your player board maybe now you can move further hold more cards or unlock new actions but that's not the whole game oh no along the way on these tiles are
multiple systems to interact with and to use to your advantage to get more points maybe you go to the cattle market and buy cows of a higher value meaning you can then deliver them further to earn more points but not only that the cow cars themselves are worth VPS alternatively maybe you'll become a property developer building tiles along the trail the only you can use or maybe you think the train man from Matrix Revolutions is the coolest character of all time and you really want to be him you can also do that here you'll focus on pushing your train up the track leaving your discs in the stations as you go upgrading your player board as you earn VPS so you'll do multiple Loops of the board and each time you do you'll add new workers to the available workers section these are fellas that you can hire that are all about increasing your power in the aformentioned systems having more Craftsmen will allow you to build better buildings for example as you add more workers to to the board this token will be continuously pushed down until it falls off the end of the board signaling the end of the game then you'll count up the VPS and declare the
winner as popular as it was GWT was played a lot as with many board games there was lots of debates and arguments about strategy focusing on specific areas and after years of feedback several tweaks to the game playay were made for the second addition mainly focusing on balancing and also introducing elements from the rails to the north expansion into the core gam playay EG exchange tokens and buildings there's also a new type of cow the cemental which could be used as a mini expansion the gimmick there was that if that cow got taken to Market it increased in value making it really quite powerful in the mid to end game oh and there's also now a solo mode as well as the gameplay changes there are also numerous aesthetic changes too such as the Native Americans which constituted hazards in the old game now being changed to Bandits and the workers are generally more diverse as opposed to the crustiest old white guys that you've ever seen as well as some general improvements to artwork and components dual layered player boards y'all there are less differences between the expansion fwt Rous to the north and Rous to the North Second Edition to keep it in line the the artwork and components have been updated but the main addition is a new breed of cow otherwise a few tweaks have been made to the expansion board but really nothing
major everything rails to the north ads stems from a new auxiliary action the placing a branchlet that action will allow you to place a little house somewhere on this new board which attaches to the top of the old board and what these houses are can do is either give you Rewards or let you connect to new cities so you have new options on where to send out your diss however you have to work outwards connecting each City and town to the previous one so it's something you do have to work towards but it does expand the decisions and the options available to the players now the original version of rail of the north included exchange tokens but as these are now included in the second edition of Grey West Trail the second edition of rails to the north doesn't have them it actually instead has a new breed of
cow in DWT you were driving cattle to Kansas City and in GWT Argentina you're driving cattle to buas Aries and that's about it that's a joke as in reality Argentina is DWT with about 40% more mechanisms packed in you now have a fourth type of worker which is a farmer these now make up the hazard tiles which were the Native Americans or the bandits depending on which version of the original you had and you have to pay them to cross their lands alternatively you can recruit them by agreeing to help them plow their fields to do this you spend sides either from your player board or from your cows or combination of both but the more cows you use the more exhaustion cards you take which just clug up your hand and give you negative points however the farmers can be crucial to providing grain a new type of resource in Argentina when you deliver the cows they get loaded onto ships which then travel to Europe now for this long journey you need to provide grain and if you don't have it you'll have to buy it which is quite expensive and can quickly eat into your profits the player discs are now also added to ships which set sale at different times when they reach the port cities you can also spend grain part of the market action to put them onto the bonus spaces however this time you cannot pay with money these spaces are going to be where you get some of the big points in the game but you do have to be prepared the Cowboys the builders
and the engineers have their equivalent workers here and they all work in the same way although of course you have different buildings to build and different cows to buy the way trains work is also a little bit different because rather than your train having to be at a certain point point or you lose money on your delivery now you can actually leave the trail early you don't have to go along the full Trail to get to the market but how early you can cut out is based on how far along your train is and this is something you're going to have an incentive to do because as the game goes on more farmers are going to fill up the last stretch of the trail and obviously other player buildings as well meaning that it's going to get more tedious and more costly to kind of go the long way around you could say so you probably will start cutting out a bit early if your train has got that far ahead so what you have is a gry won Trail which adds more complexity more mechanisms but is more mean it has tighter resources there's more resource scarcity and this means that it's probably the most complex but also the most brutal of the three the big difference between Great Western Trail New Zealand and Great Western Trail is there are no cows only sheep the Sheep work for the most part the same way as the cows did you take them
to in this case Wellington you reveal a hand a different sheep and you get to send a disc out and you get some money but now the Sheep also have a secondary value on them they have a wool value and there are specific actions on building tiles which will allow you to share the Sheep to generate profit so there's a new worker in the game a fourth worker type called the Sheep sharer and for every sheep sharer you have when you take this shearing action you can discard a sheep card from your hand to get money equal to its wool value so three sheep sharers you can uh discard three different types of sheep get a bunch of money and similar to how deliveries worked with the main city and the market if you generate enough wool value by doing this you can also deliver discs out to other spaces the second biggest change to Great Western Trail New Zealand is to the deck building aspect and this is because now it's far more robust there are far more sheeps to recruit than there ever were cows and some sheeps you can't just buy at the Sheep Market you have to get them through other ways and these are special and only possible to get those ways there's also a number of cards which are non- cheap cards that you can add to your deck so you do get a real deck building sense of achievement here however there is also far less opportunity to remove cards from your
deck so this means that throughout the game you're going to end up with quite a large deck if you're getting a lot of cards but the good news is that the non- che cards they're not going to clog up your hand which you might be worried about if you're a regular player of gry Austin Trail and this is because the way they work is they let you take their action and then immediately draw a card back up so it means that you're not going to be stuck with three action cards and two sheep in your hand you'll always draw up until basically you have a handful of sheep and then take your normal turn you so now have a sailor instead of an engineer no train just boat you have a separate board where you can move your little boat around some different routes some of the stops will at like the train stations in the previous two gwts where you can pay some money place a disc and get some points and maybe swap out a worker for a Harbor Master tile other stops allowed you to build storehouses from your player map and once you've built enough you'll unlock some bonuses not to mention they also allow you to make foreign deliveries and send your discs there when going to Market or selling wool you also have a revamp of the worker market now theel that are of a type of worker the cheaper they will get and it's now also divorced from the countdown to the end of the game as there's now a whole secondary Market of bonus tiles these can be purchased and will provide you with bonuses and it's this tile Market
that will trigger the end of the game however one is also added to the market each time you go to the Sheep market so there'll always be the same number of visits to the market each game depending on the player count grey Western Trail is one of the alltime modern Euro greats we both had it in our top 10 games of all time and it's just such an enjoyable experience to play because it gives you all these options but not enough resources to do all of them so you have to make these important decisions about which routes to go down and just mechanically and in terms of Engagement it's a joy to play through it's one that is a delight even when you lose just because you experienced it and the kind of mechanistic nature of it going through it it's always enjoyable to go down these different routes and part of that is how replayable it is because the random kind of assortment of the neutral building tiles will give you different challenges each game and the way the work has come out that will also change up what options are available to you what routes you go down and there's a lot of different strategies you could take on now you might ask should I maybe try and get a secondhand copy of the first edition which you see here or should I just buy the bullet and buy a
new version of the second edition and honestly I mean there's nothing wrong with if you can get a cheap version of the first edition but if you if you don't have any great Wesson Trail and you want to get into it then you might as well just just by the second edition it's got updated components it looks nicer it's got kind of gameplay changes it's got mini expansions so there's not a lot of reason not to get it if you're kind of new to it but there's also nothing wrong with just getting a cheap version of the first edition that's up to you for us we actually are keeping our first edition because the next question might be should we upgrade if we already have the first edition and we're not going to do it just because the gameplay changes are so small and we already have rails to the north so then we'd have to buy both the second edition and the second edition of rails to the north so that if you want to do that or not is really up to you and if you want all the boxes to match I guess how much that will annoy you yeah that is a little bit Jaren not going to lie it's true but the rails to the north expansion is a really good one but it's not a necessary one unless you really want to expand the decision space like Farrell said Great Western tra second edition contains a lot of the elements from R to the North like the exchange tokens so it could be considered even more of a luxury than it once was that said the really great thing is it fits in seamlessly and there are minimal new rules to accommodate if you're a big fan of the base game then we'd always recommend it but it's probably not going
to be something that's really going to alter your opinion or improve your experience substantially as many other expansions will do and then obviously to further complicate things you have the comparison between GWT Argentina and GWT New Zealand so just starting with Argentina like we said before this is GWT for people who love GWT because there's about 40 to 50% more mechanisms so that means it is more complex so you have a lot more to consider resources are generally a lot tighter it's harder to kind of deliver cows and get victory points because you have this whole like wheat system to think about there a fourth type of worker and how they play into your whole strategy and thinking about when your discs will get kind of shipped to the ports in Europe as well and the timings of that it is just generally more complex yeah I think like you touched upon there's often another layer between things like with getting the discs out sure you put them on ships but then if you want to get victory points from them now you have to pay grain to put them out yeah so it's another layer and then you have a fourth type of worker which which pulls you in the farmers which pulls you in a different direction because it's kind of more like which way should I go so I think it's it's a game for as we said people who do love grey Western Trail and really this is only I would say Argentina is only for two types of people the first is you love
Great Western Trail and you want more you want to try it you're interested you want more crunch you want more gameplay and the second is kind of the same but maybe if you're someone who has played great Weston Trail but you don't own a copy you've played with friends or a gaming group maybe then Argentina is good for you because you have a separate copy to that gaming group or friends if you've been playing with them uh so you can bring it to the table you can play both and you also get something different and you can experience more great if you've never played it before then we definitely wouldn't recommend starting with this one no it's the one you should go last with if anything y then we have great with and Trail New Zealand yes so this one really brings the deck building aspect to the Forefront it lowers the kind of um complexity I guess in a way although it is still a complex game but it is a little bit easier flows a bit easier um because you have a lot more freedom basically so because you can share the Sheep there now there's a way to get a lot more money than in the other two maybe so you can choose to do that have a lot more money things are less tight so you could um play around with it a little bit more let's say and the kind of boat aspect as well gives you a lot of freedom you can sail around stopping at different ports and I guess the kind of complexity let's say comes in what you choose to do and optimizing everything rather than things being tight also you can have cards in your
deck which are kind of the non- sheep cards which give you kind of bonus actions so it is really about the deck building that's really kind of being elevated in New Zealand and like we said it's a a little bit easier as well yeah so you're going to have more breathing rooms you say there's kind of more routes you can it's a little bit easier to to build your own route because you know you could go for wol and getting the money and investing that in other places or you could go straight for going to Market and how you steer your ship is kind of part of that um you kind of max out workers at a bit less five instead of six now so it's definitely a bit more about a little bit of everything but you want to lean into one or two strategies it's a lot easier to kind of switch out your sheet before you go to the market as well you you can get um less stuck let's say with a with a bad hand before you go to the market than the other two where it's really kind of having to think about curating your hand uh before the market the entire time whereas here you're kind of always discarding cars picking them back up again so a lot more options there as well yeah so I think the one thing I will say about the deck building is that for me when it comes to deck building I am of the opinion that you should be able to get rid of cars from your deck as well as game them and this is probably the hardest game to get rid of them from because now you can only remove cards by discarding two exchange tokens and then you can only get rid of the one sheep uh so you will have a much
bigger deck that you have less control over but like you say you do run through the cards quicker and the new cards you put put them down as soon as you get them the non cheap cards so it's not so much a problem but if you if you like crafting your deck then maybe you might be a bit disappointed like I was by not being able to cut out some of the that that's signature move is uh curating yeah I think one game I had a deck of like eight cards or something of the cows in the original uh so who is this for as we say someone who this you could probably if if you're approaching series for the first time you could probably go for either and maybe you'd lean towards Great Western Trail New Zealand if you're more into deck building if that's something you like and you like the idea of having these different cards and all these different sheap having different elements it's kind of a bit more Breezy because you're able to get money easier so you're always able to do something although still not everything uh so so if that appeals to you then this might be the one for you otherwise reckon that gross and Trail the original is also a great starting point if you kind of want a more classic Euro with less of deck building elements yeah exactly so probably yeah recommend start with um Second Edition G or like we said before if you can get a cheaper copy of the yeah I think I version still lean towards getting the second edition unless money was an issue in consideration yeah for sure um yeah
regarding whether you should have all three if you want all three and you're a fan of the series then absolutely we would recommend it we are not going to be getting rid of any of ours we love them all I actually had uh Argentina as my number one game of 2023 and I had New Zealand as my number two game of 2023 um I thought they both deserved a place in there like separate places rather than bundling them up together so I guess that's Testament from my side how much I love them but if you you need all three like of of course not you could just go for one if you know it's not your all-time favorite game it's not necessary to have all three um and obviously these are heavier euros and the play can be quite long yeah especially when you go up to four players we've had some very very long games with with four people uh so obviously think realistically about whether you're going to have time to play all three yeah I think one element of why we have all three and we'll keep it is that we have friends who are very much into grey Western Trail so they're very much into getting it out as like a classic of our group so then with the new ones they're also interested in that so we actually have got all of these to the table like a fair few times yeah so that is basically our great and trails buyers guide if you have any questions about any of the stuff or the games or the different versions please ask us down below we really appreciate you watching and if this was helpful
please consider subscribing if you're not already because it allows us to work with Publishers and create these bias guides which are a lot of energy and effort from our side and sometimes cost if we have to buy everything ourself and working Publishers and being attractive to them can really help with that as it's help us make ones in the past although for this one we kind of bought it all ourselves uh but most importantly thank you for watching and we hope to see you next time see you bye