Skip to main content
Loading video...

Above and Below: Haunted - Discussion

Transcript 29:24

Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.

Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked. And Brad and I are doing a discussion over Above and Below Haunted, the newest expansion to Above and Below. Uh coming in hot 10 years later. You know, the people were really clamoring for the Above and Below expansion. Um, no. This one, uh, actually thought was kind of a nice welcome, too, because it's like clearly he doesn't he probably doesn't want to do another Sleeping Gods. So, he's like, "Okay." But it's weird that it's above and below and not anything extra for the other two,

right?

Um, but it's a standalone expansion. Not even I I don't I can't even really call it an expansion because it's literally just

it's a rethe of Yeah. of Above and Below in a kind of Feudal Japan. Not really like a It It gives very Feudal Japan vibes with the with a mystic element added to it. But if you go check out our Above and Below uh discussion or if you just have played Above and Below before, a lot of the stuff is it's pretty much the exact same game with a few minor tweaks. Some things that completely fix are earlier complaints for Above and Below and some things that they added that are puzzling uh that I don't really like and I don't know why it it was even added. So Brad, what do you think of Above and Below Haunted? I didn't mind it. Like I said, I mean, it it it felt like above and below.

Yeah.

Um

especially when you're playing back toback, you're just like, "Oh, it's the exact same game."

Some of the modular stuff that they not modular, I guess, but some of the additions that they added were good and some of them were bad.

Yeah.

Um the boat things were kind of interesting.

Yeah.

Gave you a little bit more variation. Um having the extra the two levels of exploration decks was kind of cool.

Yeah. Ramp it up, you know. Everything was everything that they added seemed to kind of it almost feels like they were trying to fix maybe previous complaints where it's like oh when you're exploring you literally have to rely on a die roll to try and succeed. Well, the boats come in and um and completely rectify that. You like, oh, doesn't really matter on die rolls. They're sixes.

And depending on what kind of game you're looking to get out of this though, they you could say that they overcorrected

a little bit. Thank you. No, I completely agree

because like now everything's you're almost getting too much stuff and it's too easy to pass.

Yeah.

You know, cuz when you get these boats and you know, you get some of these characters like I had that were three successes, you just spin a boat. I mean, you just you can just ramp up and you're never going to fail.

Yeah. No, I I comp I was having that exact same thought. I was like, "Okay, so why even do anything when you're just handed everything the entire time? You don't have to struggle for money. Um, you don't have to struggle for resources. Um, your advancement track wraps up and just gives you a you have to you don't have to struggle for reputation. Not really struggle, but reputation is the easiest thing in the world to get and lose. We'll get to that. But harvesting is super easy because I like the fact that they combined that action or labor. But now it's like, oh, lucky me. I I happen to get the squid first. So that's an extra four points cuz I harvested it first. So, you're naturally just going to be constantly doing better. But in a game like this, I feel like with original Above and Below, the the I guess swings of of it was kind of part of the adventure when you're always getting like, oh, explore seven, easy. I'll just get 15.

Well, an example of this, you know, cuz we did play above and below a little bit before this, right?

I felt like I did so much better in the original game.

Mhm.

Than I did this game.

Yeah.

As far as succeeding and building out what I wanted.

Mhm.

But I scored 30 more points in this game. I scored 46 in that first one and 76 in this one.

No. No. Yeah. Exactly.

That just tells you like I felt like I did worse in this one, but I scored 30 more points. That kind of goes with what we're saying.

Yeah. No, that's it's so it's so wild cuz I was um it's kind of like whenever I played unconscious mind, I was like, "Well, I'm constantly getting everything I ever want, so I don't really have to strategize or work for it when it's all handed to you." Um maybe this is for the Gen Z crowd. Am I right? No. Uh yeah, like my final score in this one, we were closer even though the first game of above we played was was also close. I think this was what a five point swing, six point, whatever it was.

We were six points in the last game.

Oh, were we?

It was 52 to 46.

Oh, that's so funny.

And this was I had 76, you had 806 or whatever it was. Um,

it's gone. Uh, but yeah, so the po the point spread was was completely identical, but I agree. I felt like I earned what I worked for in the last one or I had to kind of meticulously strategize on my money. I But here it's like, oh, what's that? Uh that that card over there 17. I have like I have two 16 or I have 16 and a 17 cost card and that is like I got those later because I just wanted to do other stuff, but that is completely doable way early on.

Um so yeah, I feel like you kind of again it depends on what game you're wanting. Would you rather have complete control over the entire game the entire time? Well, then you're going to like this one more. But that kind of coincides with some of the other changes that are completely new that I don't really like in this game. And I want to I want to make this very very clear. This adventure deck I love in co-op games. Um this is like almost ripped straight from like Sleeping Gods is this kind of unique deck of stuff you can get through an adventure. I really love that. But it sucks ass whenever I have to look over and be like, "Oh, lucky you. You got [ __ ] a free worker, a free thing, and I'm over here." It's like, "Oh, I'll do my own adventure. Cool. I got a coin and a rep,

right?

Where's my [ __ ] adventure card?" Like, and it because it sour it whenever it's competitive.

Like it versus like, oh man, you got some resource that I I didn't get. That that's just part of it. But like it feels even like a bigger disadvantage or it swings the game wildly whenever I'm not getting special abilities,

you know?

Yeah.

Like, and that has nothing to do with strategy. It's not like I guess I'll explore every single time and really hope I get the a cool adventure card,

but yeah, this works so much better. And like, oh man, you got a special ability in a cooperative game, right? So, I don't know what I mean, you got to benefit from it the entire fine. I mean, you know, that one was kind of neat that had a quest. So, like you kind of do So, I don't know how many of those would be in there, but like

you have quests and then I have these deals where I didn't have to spend a worker when I build a building, but I still have to pay the cost. So, you know, it's still it just gives you a little bit more. And then this one was

you could pay one fewer coin when hiring a villager or gain plus one lantern when exploring. Yes. So there they just added some variation. But yeah, I could definitely see how it would be a different a different thing, you know,

seven, eight, but

eight of them.

But um and we're going to we're going to slowly gradually move into this next point, but this is a game that I don't want to have player interaction in.

Yes. And that and it's almost and then there's an aspect that we're going to talk about that has like forced player interaction.

Yeah. So

care for it.

Yeah. it. So, the hard negative because I mean these just kind of feel bad um whenever you're not getting any and everyone else is and it's like it it these are just so much better than any type of other thing of like because in this game you ramp up in reputation like that that it's like okay so if I get a rep in a story who gives a [ __ ]

um woo I got three rep oh it's actually wasted so I didn't gain anything huh that sucks. Oh, you have eight quests over there that you get to do. How fun. So, the hard negative is the stupid ghosts and they're so this is this that type of element in any game just ruins it. Um, so in this game, whenever you hire a uh or you recruit a villager or I mean through some story events, you gain a ghost and the ghosts go on one of your buildings and who it doesn't really matter. But there's a new action called banish that you remove all ghosts from your thing but one. And then you take that one ghost and you put it on someone else's building and you gain something for depending on the building. If it doesn't have a bed, you get two rep and two coins. If it does have a bed, you get three coins and a and a juice. Uh, also this is an improvement just having one token for instead of cider and and a potion. uh and you get a a mystic juice or if it's an out uh outpost, you get a boat and and a thing.

So, the reason why these suck is because at the end of a round, you lose a reputation for every single ghost that you have. So, it's entirely possible in a multiplayer game for people to just swarm you with ghosts. And all it does is it makes sure that you just bank a [ __ ] quill person the entire time and you just wait it out. Yep.

And you're like, "Okay, um, like player order becomes it's usually inconsequential, but now it's like, okay, you have that many people. You have that many people. Okay, you don't have any quills. And my final action is to dick you over at the very end. I get rewarded. Yay me." And you're losing reputation. I mean, the reason why I won this game is that difference. That was a 10-point swing. Because I mean how much reputation you lost over the course of the game ended up not really mattering. You still were super high. But this is the [ __ ] troll thing in Champions of Midgard. This is the shitty ass military and transgalactic.

I don't know. I just don't understand why people think that that's a good design mechanism. Hey, in a game that like just play indirect player interaction is fine. You took a building I wanted. Damn, that sucks. Mhm. That's that's perfectly fine. But like, hm, what if we make everyone a piece of [ __ ]

Well, it could be just simply fixed by not you do the banish act banish action.

Mhm.

Something different than this. Like you don't put it on somebody else's.

Exactly.

You get rid of them at a cost maybe or like maybe something you have to pay to get rid of the ghosts so that you don't aren't losing the reply. or or like I mean well because none of the cards really have abilities because I was gonna say or you don't get anything from the card. Um but that would be that that would be a little bit more complex of like

card flips face down and can't be

it can't be used. Again, there's like so many that just don't really do any. I guess they all kind of do something, but yeah, like something else that means that you have to go out of their way to banish them and they're just gone or hell each like cuz one of them was you get three points for each ghost you have. Um, but again, if you're trying to make that worth it, like, oh, I have 10 ghosts on here,

you'd be a negative seven rep.

Yeah, but I guess 10 ghosts would be 30 points, so it'd be still a 23 point swing. Yeah.

Um, so again, that's just I don't know. I do not understand why they thought it was a good idea. This completely just doesn't need to exist cuz one, it floods you with money. Therefore, you can buy any building you'll ever want. It floods you with rep. You're maxed out on rep all the time. So even then, against the it's not necessarily the reputation lost. just go all you have to do is to send it back to someone

and then you gain that rep back.

I just I find it like such a just questionable design design decision. Um and it might just be like oh well I mean what's the actual complaint if it really doesn't do anything? It's the principle. It's the the act of now in a game that originally had no player interaction. I am now just kind of doing something to be a dick.

Yeah.

And I don't want to do that. That's my only real hard negative on the game. Uh cuz I mean otherwise if we were complaining about everything else, we wouldn't like Above and Below.

Now the best improvement in my opinion, we kind of touched on a little bit is the adventures. Is there are two different decks, one dangerous and one uh that's not. And I like how they give you a range. Hey, like the regular ones are a range of 2 to six. That's what you'll need. And then 5 to 11.

That reminds me of Kingsburg where you know if it was like the range of the the invaders each round, it would tell you kind of range.

And what they added in this one, which is uh I believe pulled from maybe near and far, but I know now or never, is you get rewarded extra stuff for going over cuz in regular above and below it didn't matter. If you had a five and you got 10, it didn't matter.

Um, but now it's like, oh, you needed a five and you got I think it might always have been just two above. Now that I think about it, I think it's as if you always did at least two above. So, this was a base five. I got seven. I'm going to get a bonus. That's nice. I'm glad that's in here. But then our major complaint with original Above and Below was after you read the initial blurb, depending on your choice and all that, it would just tell you what you got now, which we were hoping that they were going to do, you actually get an extra story element,

right? Even if it's just a line.

Yeah. Even if it's just a line, you get you get the results of your decision, which just adds even more immersion. Um, and that's just, you know, clear just design or designer improvement over the years, right? Especially with the experience he's had with Sleeping Gods and stuff. Uh, I appreciate that significantly. Um, because it's exciting. It adds a little bit more story stuff, which is to me the the best part of the game. Um, and and also the crux. That's how you get really anything, honestly. money and all that, but um

I I'm I'm very happy that that was included cuz I would have been significantly disappointed if it was just the exact same stuff just hey now there's a little ghost theme, you know? So, I don't know. It's weird because they they clearly made improvements like it but at the same time made some weird decisions to the game that it's like do you if someone's like hey should I get above and below um I see there's two of them which should I get I can't be like oh haunted's way better like oh man makes original above and below obsolete

there I would have you know what I would have rather had another just theme to the the base game like what they did with the desert and labyrinth.

Just do that.

Yeah,

cuz now I'm sitting here with really just two copies of Above and Below, but one does gameplay a little bit better and one does story um a lot better. It's weird. It's kind of It's almost a little bit like, well, why was this made? This didn't really need to be made. Money. Money. Dude, you got your money. Make another Sleeping Gods.

Yeah,

that's what you had to do. This theme would be amazing in a Sleeping Gods world for me anyway. I know you hate it, but

I never played it, so

Yeah. Oh, you mean that the

the actual like feudal Japan mystical Japan?

This wasn't too bad. I mean, it didn't really come out that much and everything. So,

but I would have loved this kind of thing in an actual sprawling sleeping sleeping sleeping godsesque world. Um, so yeah, it's these these are always interesting, especially I don't know. I I feel like when games that are so old come out with an expansion, it's always worse. It's like really trying to trying to bring that back, huh? I mean, why didn't you just re I guess it is kind of like an above and below 2.0. It's a 10th anniversary release. So, I'm wondering if he's got plans to do 10th anniversary for like near and far.

Oh, interesting.

I'm saying because this was that's how it was taught like on the game found page when I was on it.

Oh, really? Says, you know, 10th anniversary.

Interesting.

So, maybe near and far will do something.

And that would be fascinating. When was near and far? Was that 20 2017?

Yeah, probably 17 and far. Nailed it, baby. Yep. 2017.

So, I guess I'm a couple years, you know, to

Yeah. So, it's something

now or never would be weird, though, because that near and above and below makes sense going to do a 10th anniversary because that game design wasn't like amazing. I mean, it was, but like

now what? 20.

Oh, now or never.

Now or never. I mean, it's more recent.

It is more recent. We'd be we're we're a ways off from anything of that now. But now or never 2022.

Okay.

Um, but that's the thing is like above and below kind of makes sense if that's how it was touted as a 10th anniversary. Near and far kind of also makes sense.

Near and far haunted. Everything's going to be like Jeffy. Um, but now or never came out in like the golden era of board games where it's like there's nothing really to improve. You know, if if they did a 10th anniversary, maybe a name change,

but have the or crossed out and have like and

that'd be so funny. I I I don't know. I can't necessarily I can't really just be like you go out and buy this um because it's so much better than above and below. If you have original Buff and Blow, throw it away. This improves on everything. One, it barely makes any changes. It kind of adds a little bit more rules and a completely new rethe stories. story improves because it actually gives you your results afterwards of just a narrative element, but other than that, it's the same exact [ __ ] on what you get.

Um, so yeah, I'm I'm kind of a little bit disappointed, but at the same time, I don't really know what I was expecting

with it.

Yeah, I would agree. I wasn't sure, you know, what what they were going to bring in haunted with it and come to find out the only haunted aspect is the ghost

is the ghost and

that's really I mean

that is literally it because even the story

the story stayed with along with what Above and Below was.

Yeah,

cavernous and stuff underneath and it was all mystical.

Yeah.

So I mean that's that's the only change.

That's true.

That's true. Uh and I guess the arts a little bit different. You are you are correct. They only and those these little ghost things are kind of purely ripped from creature caravan. It's they're not specters. They're like fire people, but in terms of actual design. Um cuz the fire people imagine instead of the silver, it's red and they look more like people. That's it. Um yeah, money. I don't know. Like take what we said with, you know, for what it is. Uh, basically if I would say if you don't own either, then just get this one because it's just narratively an improvement. Um, if you already own Above and Below, pass.

Yeah. Yeah. I don't know

cuz you don't have any expectation if you don't own either.

Oh, yeah. Yeah, that's true. Um, but because we we did come from above and below literally just an hour ago, um, we can clearly see what I think is an improvement or a deprovement. I don't think that's a word. But if you have no reference for either, this this is just naturally kind of I would say the better one.

Yeah. I mean, they added enough stuff that I thought it was going to be a great improvement.

Mhm.

But then a lot of the new stuff that was added actually took away. Some of the stuff took away. So that's why I don't I I personally don't think it's better than above and below

just because of that.

Yeah.

But it's it's negl I mean it's close, right?

You know, I mean that's why I'm saying yeah, it could go either way. I mean, it's there's there's some cool things in here that they added that I really thought was, you know, when we were learning it and everything, I was like, "Yeah, that's be really cool to have an adventure deck, have two separates of those." Those those were good.

Yeah.

You know, and the boats seemed like they were going to be neat and all that stuff, but then they brought in the player interaction part that just sunk it. Yeah.

Like and stuff and it's just not

Yeah. I mean, I do I think you're right. Especially cuz it's but again like you said all the improvements that they added or all the new stuff they added just make you feel like you're kind of going with the flow

for about an hour. Never really have to work for it. And to some people that might be what they want. But I don't like games where I just sit here and get everything I want the entire time. I find that boring. So, if I wanted to sit here and go through a story and the the adventures, I'll I'll just play Sleeping Gods the entire time and have a significantly better time.

It's weird. This is Every now and then you get these weird kind of reviews where it's like, huh? What is this? Like, why what's going on? What's going on with that? Um, what do you think on a scale of 1 to 10? Well, I gave above and below seven.

Mhm.

Um because just being a solid, you know, classic.

Yeah.

Um this one, man, it it could easily have been

an eight.

Yeah.

But then I'm taking two points away from the the ghosts in the stuff. Yeah. So, it's going to be six. So, you're at a six.

So, it's still solid. I mean, it's still a good good enough game to buy if you don't if you need to buy one of the two.

Yeah. But to for me the go the ghost thing like this is the type of game the player interaction does not need to be

I know

you know

I know and and again it's not like in Champions of Midgard where it's just the the shame tokens are just really bad at two but as soon as you got in the third person it's negligible. Um this one it's negligible at two. It just makes you have to now kind of be a dick uh for no reason. Right. So, even though the punishment really isn't that bad because all someone has to do is be like, "Hey, I'm sending this over to you. I got my rep and I got my money." Okay, I'm sending it back to you. I got my rep. I got my money. It's a wash.

It's just needless.

Yeah,

it's wast.

Um, funny enough, I gave Above and Below a seven. Like you definitely think it's a Yeah, I kind of agree with a six. Yeah, I I think I am I think I am going to follow you on on a six. I was thinking, does the narrative element that they added improve it from a narrative standpoint? It does, but your results are still the same. So, funny enough, even though I like the additional elements of a story for this kind of game, it actually makes it longer now because you now have to read a little bit more. And when people are adventuring all the time, that adds a de a decent amount of play time when your end result is still coin fish, you know?

So, I kind of might enjoy the way original Above and Below did it because it was just so clean. You still got your nice little element of story and then you got your stuff and you moved on. So looking back because we just reviewed Above and Below it's like oh you know maybe people don't know what they want. I thought I would have wanted

to get story for the result but looking it's like now that we have that I'm like oh actually it's huh maybe maybe in this kind of game it wasn't it wasn't needed. Well, and if you take it as a as an entire thing, all the new things as a whole.

Yeah.

That's where I'm that's why I went down just because there are some really good things that that's nice.

Yeah.

And there's some nice stuff, but just the there's just a couple of things that were puzzling and that was kind of the

that was kind of the back. Like I'm still going to keep it, but I at with the with the final product, I'm kind of like, oh well, like if I ever choose to play Above and Below, I might just play the base game just cuz it's going to be quicker, but I'm still getting the same exact meal. Um, so I would have just rather had this as an actual expansion.

Yeah, modular. I'm going to add the ghosts in this time,

right?

You have to add the ghost this time. because of action now, which I mean I guess you could still

Well, I know how to do it, but

they say Well, I mean, let me double check.

But I mean, some of the adventures give you ghost, so you'd have to like

Where is it? Um, maybe it doesn't actually say. I I thought I thought it said it was a standalone expansion.

It does on the It does project page. It says it's a standalone expansion.

Okay. Uh, but it's not because nothing of this can be integrated into the original game. So, it's not an expansion. It's just another game. And maybe that's what standalone expansion means. I don't think so because the expans

to me standalone expansions you can be played by itself or it can be integrated.

Yeah. And there's nothing in the rules that allows you to integrate this. You because the the card back all the design is completely different. So just the fact that you don't you have two separate decks of adventures. You can't throw that in. So I would have just much rather had more buildings added. You could have kept the theme, the haunted theme, and just throw in new buildings and throw in the exact same deck of uh encounter cards. So, you just increase your option of you a random environment or random encounter. Throw in more uh more workers. You could easily have the boats or whatever. You could have more resources. They could have just added way more stuff to original Above and Below. Um, [ __ ] Since they put in the work for the narration, do a whole new narrative pack. So now you have results um, narrative results to your OG stuff,

right?

Yeah. I think it's a missed opportunity. Honestly, I think this could have been a slam dunk if it was just integrated into the base game, but now we just have this weird box that's going to be around. I don't know. So yeah, I agree. Actually, I talked myself into a six. I've also somehow talked myself into not liking the extra narrative stuff when I was like I was like, man, yeah, that's that's amazing. So, it's a shame, but no, I mean, still a six, I guess, cuz it's still above and below,

right?

All right. You got anything else?

Nope.

Well, that's our thoughts on Above and Below Haunted. Let us know what you think of the expansion in the comments below. Like, comment, share, and subscribe. And have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.

Progress saved