Top Best Heavy Strategy Board Games of All Time: Tournament!
Transcript
And welcome back, board game fans, to another exciting tournament bout between the greatest heavy strategy games of all time. We're your hosts, Mike and Mikey. Rather than give you yet another boring top 10 list, we took 16 of the best heavyweight strategy board games and pitted them against one another in the ultimate showdown. We divided these games into the respective divisions. Here we have the thematic west. This league is the pinnacle of heavyweight thematic brilliance. This is the type of league you enjoy while having a drink and dunking on your friends, be it verbally or in game. And the winner of that league will be facing the winner of the Euro East. These contemplative egghehead games pack a serious strategic punch and will challenge your brain as you try to solve their puzzle just before you get hit in the head with a mele by a friend for taking too long on your turn. I did that one time and now I just never hear the end of it. Let's just get started and jump to the first match of the night. For our first battle, we have two of the most brutal games in the respective field. War of the Ring and Robinson Caruso. One game demanding you hit your opponent in the face on every turn, and the other begging you to hold their hand as you starve, get bitten, and sleep in the snow together till your inevitable death. War of the Ring is obviously one of the most brilliant two-player war games that have that has ever existed.
War of the Ring is heralded as the quintessential Lord of the Rings board game, and for a very good reason. This thematic juggernaut pits two individuals against one another, battling for their respective objectives. The shadow looking to conquer the free people in their lands while the free people seeking to destroy the one ring and send the shadows back to where they came from. The theme it just oozes through every action a player takes and each turn is so beautifully agonizing because you'll you'll never feel like you truly decide on the perfect move for your turn. And I just I find something like that just so exciting. But more importantly, I think War of the Ring is able to do something that Robinson can't. And that's that's empowered players to feel clever. There is some great card play happening in War of the Ring. And when you pull off that perfect turn, you you genuinely feel clever. So, it's not just that these cards highlight the theme of the game like in Robinson, but these cards actually have a deeper strategic depth that provide players an amazing and satisfying feeling when you make the perfect move. Robinson Cruso, on the other hand, features turns that are certainly not as complex, but certainly far more enjoyable in a larger group setting. Robinson Caruso is a one to four player cooperative worker placement game that plays in about two hours. Players take on the role of scrappy survivor with their own unique power doing their best to accomplish a variety of missions on a foreign island.
Seeking shelter, hunting local animals, building and discovering new tools and just do whatever you can to avoid the painful death at the hands of the bone chilling cold or meeting some hungry cannibals. Robinson is just it's great fun and it's one of the few cooperative games where you really do feel like you're working together to overcome something bigger. You know, it emulates the feeling of survival and adventure so perfectly and it effortlessly tells an amazing story every single time you play it. Robinson is the type of game where you look back and say like, "Remember that time?" Like, you remember the time you went forging only to end up with a snake bite on your ass and instead of, you know, treating it, you put the card back in the deck only to have it come back and poison you? Wasn't that wasn't that hilarious? Robinson, like War of the Ring, just provides such a great thematic experience. It really does feel like you're you're you're on some survival adventure in this game. And not just because Robinson is one of the the most brutal and punishing cooperative games you'll ever play, but because you're generally working together and picking tasks that everyone is good at, like some horrific episode of Survivor.
I love Robinson. I really do. But sadly, the enjoyable cooperative nightmare can't really hold a candle to the intense and deeply strategic juggernaut that is War of the Ring. War of the Ring takes this one. But before we head over to the Euro East, let's go to Kim Kimberly in the locker room. Thanks, Mike. I'm here today in the Playo's locker room with Robinson Crusoe. Robinson, I think everyone at home really wants to know what went wrong tonight. Well, you know, I gave it my best, and my best just wasn't good enough. I was certain after my new collector's edition run, I'd be able to take it all. I didn't think anyone could resist my wooden bananas. Here we have a duel between the beautiful and the ugly. Who would disagree when looking at the components of brass that you are witnessing true art? Meanwhile, in the other corner, food chain magnet looks like I asked my drunk uncle to provide art for a game. And so, he went online the night before and just started downloading clip art images and just like slapping them all together and paint. Food Chain Magnet is a two to five player game that plays in roughly 3 to four hours. Players do their best to build a fast food franchise as they advertise their product, open new stores, hire endless streams of employees, and just do their best to run their friends franchise into the ground until they leave game night hating you and hating their own life. But this isn't a beauty pageant. It's a death match. And food chain is an absolute beast of a game mechanically, featuring some brutal player interaction that far outdoes the passive aggressive interaction featured in Brass. Taking that barrel someone was going to use doesn't it doesn't hit quite as hard as
corning the market on pizza and making sure your opponent doesn't sell a damn thing. Completely destroying their business and all hopes of winning. Food Chain is downright a brawler when it comes to aggressive interaction. And if that's something you want on your game night, the food chain is the only game you need. And it's the game that you're going to want to destroy those lovely friendships. But Brass Birmingham is by no means a slouch in the interaction department. Brass Birmingham is an economic strategy game that plays in two hours for two to four players. In it, players must develop, build, and establish their industries and network them all in an effort to exploit the demands of the market and potentially their friends. it it's certainly not as aggressive, but it generally feels enjoyable to utilize your opponent's resources to your advantage, and it creates it creates a good level of interaction that goes beyond the typical Euro game by providing you some really interesting decisions. You know, do you utilize the iron of your neighbor, you know, benefiting him, or do you build your own resource network, which may cost you more turns and and precious cards to establish? It's a beautifully layered game in regards to its depth and its tightly constrained card use is a big reason for that. This is easily one of Martin Wallace's best games. But let's have a closer look at the designer, Martin Wallace. Today's designer of the week, Martin Wallace.
Wallace is one of the most prolific designers in the industry today. While his designs, they may not always hit, when they do, they hit hard. Nobody makes a train game like Wallace. And when it comes to lighter war games, he is the absolute king. He is truly a designer that cannot be pigeonholed. Well, except for his love of trains. He He really likes trains. I think Brass takes this. The depth of strategy in Brass just completely outshines Food Chain. Don't get me wrong, Food Chain is very strategic. I mean, it's it's in my top 100 games of all time for a very good reason. But there's just something far more satisfying and taxing mentally when I'm choosing from my small hand of cards to perform than than deciding, you know, which employees in the chain I'll hire. And and unlike food chain, brass very rarely feels like I'm doing the same thing between
turns. And shifting back into the west, we have the best dudes on a map game versus the best dungeon crawler trading game. Game of Thrones the board game versus Nemesis. two games that perfectly capture the theme of their inspirations. Much like Twilight Imperium, Game of Thrones requires six players to be fully functional and enjoyable. Game of Thrones perfectly captures its source material in its 6-hour play time, featuring up to six players, duking it out across Westeros, forging alliances, battling neighbors, ruining friendships, and vice for control over the land to hold as many strongholds as possible to win the game. And that that's kind of a shame because it really is the best dudes on a map risk replacement that features some of the most fun mechanics imaginable. For example, every round you lay your action tokens face down in various regions on the board. So you might tell uh your friend that you're going to support the Lannisters and their their war against the Baratheonss, but that tile that you laid down, well, it turns out to be a support order. And when you flip it up, you get to see the look on their face when they find out that you're a filthy liar. And that's just good gameplay. But let's have a closer look at the publisher responsible for this amazing game, Fantasy Flight.
Fantasy Flight has been in the business since 1995 with the first ever board game being released, Twilight Imperium. Let's take a closer look at the top three games not competing in tonight's tournament with this week's plays of the week. At number three, we have Cosmic Encounter, a brilliant negotiation game that always brings laughter. And at number two, it's Eldidge Horror with its cooperative adventuring across the globe. Who doesn't love reading endless amounts of cards? And of course, at number one is Game of Thrones: The CCG, the best collectible card game that has ever existed. But while Game of Thrones might hit hard in the tension department, Nemesis provides the perfect counter because this game genuinely feels like the first Alien movie. Nemesis is a survival horror game that plays in 4 hours. Five players do their best to survive the inevitable alien attack as they rush around the ship fixing issues, killing aliens, saving friends, and possibly killing their friends as well. It's not just some silly hacken slash dungeon crawler where you're, you know, mowing down bad guys and leveling up. Nemesis has a slow and tense buildup until things hit the fan.
And not only are you scared for your life that an alien is going to murder you when you turn a corner, but you're you're you're pooping your pants in fear because your crew mate uh who you had hardly any trust from the start might be trying to blast you out into space in an airlock while you're just trying to make sure your ship isn't heading straight to the towards the sun. The game, it just oozes tension and atmosphere. And here's the thing. While Nemesis can't touch Game of Thrones in terms of depth of strategy, Game of Thrones is a game that I know some people are not going to enjoy while playing. Someone is going to get their heads beaten every single time. When this happens, I know that they're going to be sitting there and just fuing for like 3 hours straight because there's nothing they can do and there's no way they can catch up. But Nemesis, Nemesis just offers a more fun player experience. And while I think this is a very close one, I I think Nemesis ultimately takes
it. Our next battle in the Euro East features a rookie in the league versus one of the most veteran players you'll find in Euro East. Arknova versus Kais. Old man Kais may appear to be no longer relevant in this league, but do not underestimate him. He might show the rookie a thing or two. Kais is one of the original worker placement games where players attempt to build the city into something great to gain the king's favor. Each turn, players place their workers on various buildings to perform actions such as gathering resources, build the castle, construct buildings, and as many points as possible to win. Kais is a great example of how amazingly cutthroat and interactive European style strategy games used to be. You could completely ruin someone with the movement of the provos. And so it's so it's so satisfying when you do. Now I find a lot of interaction for a lot of these heavier strategy games is nothing more than sort of passive aggressive hate drafting. And that lack of interaction is one of Arknova's few flaws. Arknova is a game that dominated our minds in this household for months on end. Ark Nova is a three-hour game that plays one to four players that sees players running their own zoo, constructing new enclosures, settling animals, releasing animals, hiring staff, and just constantly getting upset that you didn't draw the cards you wanted. Where the hell are the other bear cards in this deck? We didn't want to play any other game but Ark Nova. And and for a really good reason. The card action selection mechanic, it's just so brilliant that I'm just blown away that I haven't seen this replicated in other games. If you're unfamiliar, you can select any card from the board to
perform an action, but the cards get more powerful the further they move along the path. Even with just that mechanic, the game provides you an immense amount of options on any given turn, despite only having like five basic actions. Both of these games are in our collection, and I'll never get rid of Kais. He's old, yeah, but you know, he still likes to come out from time to time and remind everyone who plays that he is still one of the kings of worker placement. But he can't go toe-to-toe with Arknoba. An unfair first matchup for the old king. I'm I'm I'm afraid he's going to have to lose this bout, but we all know he will be here next season.
I'm once again in the playos locker room looking for thoughts on what went wrong during this match against these two amazing games. Listen, I did my best. I went out there and I gave it my all. I just I just got to get ready for the next year. Arnova put up a good fight and he deserves it. But I'm the OG worker placement game. You can't keep these old boats down. What a tenacious spirit from this veteran player. Back to you, Mike. Up next, we have an exciting bout in the west between the game that gets worse the more players you add and the game that gets worse the more players you take away. Mage Knight versus Route. Mage Knight is one of the most interesting, intense deck builders ever made. Mage Knight is a deck builder for 1 to four players that plays in about four to 5 hours and sees players traveling and exploring the land to conquer monsters and dungeons, raid cities, recruit new powerful allies, mess with your friends, and essentially recreate Heroes of Might and Magic on your table. It it is absolutely fascinating to play regardless of how much of a time constraint it is. Usually your choice in a deck builder on your turn is not it's not really that complex because you're limited to the cards you have in your hand. But there is just so many ways to use those cards in Mage Knight that even something as simple as just moving around the board becomes this like super exciting puzzle to be solved. What's funny about Mage Knight is that even when I'm playing and and having fun, I know I'm playing a game that is absolutely sloppy in its design.
Like, it's it's a mess. And yet, I I don't care because it's just so damn thoughtprovoking and challenging. I tolerate the massive tome of of rules because it gives me so much to work with on any given turn. Vlad Vlad has produced hits every single time. Vlad is one of the most unique board game designers in the industry today. This guy will one day put out some crazy real-time ship building game where you're just constantly getting blown up by asteroids and aliens and then the next he's designing one of the most famous party games that has ever existed. He may not have as many games as others under his belt. But not a single designer in the industry has the creativity and breath of genre that this man has. But Vlatas game is up against a formidable opponent. Route is a two to four player war game that sees players take control of one of the many unique wilderness factions to complete their own personal objectives all while doing their best to foil the plans of their rivals. Root has become this insane game that people just obsess over. I have a funny feeling that there are shrines built to the designer in some people's homes. And Root is, in my opinion, it's his best game. It takes uh what can be a fairly complex genre like the coin series and sort of distills the mechanics into something super fun and accessible and yet pretty difficult to master, allowing a lot of room for dedicated players to really engage with the game. I feel as though Root is the big reason we have this like giant shift towards asymmetric powers these days.
Yeah, it can be a pain to learn and teach, but the variability just it just offers so much more fun and makes you feel as if you're playing a new game every single time. We are going to get some hate here for this one, but Mage Knight, I think Mage Knight takes it. I can find games that feel similar kind of to what Root provides, but I can't find anything even remotely close to Mage Knight. Weight matters, and Mage Knight is just it's a heavier and stronger fighter. And moving back into the east, we have the greatest civilization game ever made, Through the Ages, versus one of the coolest and most stylish worker placement games you'll ever find. Both games showcasing mankind going through time, except only one of them has mechs.
There is no other board game that I can think of that best captures the essence of building up a civilization from scratch in a more enjoyable manner than Through the Ages. Through the Ages is an epic civilization game for two to four players that plays in roughly four hours. Players build their civilization through time, researching new technologies, building and upgrading structures, constructing massive wonders, invading rivals, and fostering powerful figures in human history such as Bill Gates. What is this It's one of those games where you want to do everything, but you can't. And that fact is both agonizing and surprisingly fun. It's this wonderful exercise in efficiency where you're doing your best with your your limited actions to draft the right cards to create the perfect scoring engine while also being leerary of those sitting beside you who are amassing an army of tanks while you're still, you know, fielding spearmen.
While anacrony lacks the interaction that through the ages has, it just provides a very deep strategic and thematic experience. The world of anacrony is on the brink of extinction, and you need to gather as much as you can from the planet before leaving. You'll suit up your workers and giant mechs to brave the dying planet to gather as many resources as you can, hire new workers, make scientific discoveries, and build amazing structures like time machines, all to gain as many victory points as possible. The game has this this awesome thematic mechanic, which generally is nothing more than a that alone, and yet somehow feels so cool when you accomplish it. You can provide yourself resources with the expectation that at some point you'll need to build a time machine in order to pay those resources back or risk destroying the the fabric of reality. Like I said, it is mechanically just a loan. But if you run with it, I I promise you, you'll you'll enjoy it.
Anacrony is a great game, but it's up against a game that never misses a shot. Through the Ages provides me an immense and wonderful strategic experience every single time I play it. Our final western match is between Twilight Imperium, a game you're lucky to play maybe once a year, versus Gloom Haven, a game that demands custom plays weekly to really get the full experience. Twilight Perium is a game of Galactic Conquest for three to six players that plays in more hours than there is in the day. Players choose a faction which offers unique play experience to explore the galaxy while exploiting the newly found planets for resources. All while developing new and exciting technologies and defending all this through shrewd politics and likely even allout warfare. Twilight Pirim is a kitchen sink style board game that throws just everything at you and demands that you do balance things like politics, war, exploration, and your resources throughout the entire game.
All while fearing the giant mass of ships that seems to be conveniently stockpiling on areas near your planets. This is one of the few games that I feel completely justifies its play time. It's fun from beginning to end, and I just I love the experience. You put the day aside, invite some friends, and engage in so much strategy that you may want to detox after the game for about a week. Gloom Haven was one of the few campaign games that actually they actually kind of impressed me. Gloom Haven is a 1 to four player dungeon crawler campaign game that sees players explore an adventure in a persistent world, taking on the role of wandering adventures with their own special skills to explore forgotten ruins and menacing dungeons. You'll do this over and over again, each time forgetting this entire plot of the game between sessions. Typically with a lot of campaign Kickstarter games, you get a lot of nonsense and and that just doesn't it doesn't mean anything like miniatures with mechanics that are so tired and repetitive which you've seen in every other dungeon crawler board game to date. The combat in Bloom Haven, however, was actually it was actually good. Like finding new ways to manipulate your characters on the battlefield, like using uh Craig Cart to throws terrain objects at enemies. It just it's so damn fun. And it was an actual world that the designer created that has that was unique and not just another generic fantasy game. But Twilight Imperium has its own unique world as well. I mean, what other science fiction uh has space lines and and space turtles? We interrupt tonight's tournament with breaking news.
Both Twilight Imperium and Gloom Haven have just announced another addition, thereby making the hundreds of dollars spent on a single game completely wasted. Now, you'll forever worry that every single time you play, you're not playing the best version of the game possible. But don't worry, both publishers have issued public statements concerning the new addition that are in complete unison. They say, "Don't ask questions, just consume product and get excited for next product." Back to you, Mike. Twilight Imperium is a game that will be in my collection forever. No, it hasn't played in a long time, but it will be eventually, and when it gets played, it will be glorious. Gloom A on the other hand, as amazing as I think the game is, is likely not something we'll return to. So, I I think I have to give this one to Twilight Imperium. It was a It was a tough battle, but Space Kitties will always beat muscular
Rockmen. And finally, we'll be finishing the first stage of our tournament in the East in an exciting match between Brothers. Two of the best Lerta games, duking it out to see who is the father's favorite child. On Mars versus the gallerist. There can be only one. The Gallerist is a one to four player worker placement game that sees players taking on the role of art dealers in a museum, enticing new visitors to the gallery, exhibiting works of art, investing in new artists, and doing their best to increase the reputation of the museum to win the game. The Gallerist is such a wonderful worker placement game where there is almost this sort of pseudo cooperative nature to it because you are better served in the game if you're promoting an artist with someone else. And even when you take an action, you actually give your opponent benefits when you replace them with your worker.
I really enjoy stuff like that. I just it just makes me feel like I'm actually playing with other people at the table because games like these can often feel very solitary. The gallerist is anything but. And the puzzle that it asks you to solve on its own is very interesting and it's engaging. But if you want a puzzle that offers far more depth, look no further than On Mars, which demands you balance so many different plates all at the same time. On Mars is a 1 to four player game that plays in roughly 2 to three hours that sees players establishing a self-sustaining colony on Mars. During the game, players will try to complete missions, build shelters for colonists, grow plants, and do whatever they can to create the best damn colony on the red planet. It's it's a deeper and more complex game than the gallerous. And yet, somehow, through some form of magic, it runs smoother and is easier to understand after your first game. Each of your moves impacts so many different areas in the game, and it's on you as the the big brain thinker that you are to be on top of every single impact before you make every decision.
And while that may intimidate some players, I I see that as like peak fun. I love both games, but the the win has to go to On Mars. It just offers so much more than The Galler. It's a game that demands your full attention at every moment at when it's not your turn, and I just I love that. So, to kick off the next round, we have Mage Knight versus War of the Ring. Two very different games providing one hell of an epic experience. I think the versatility and variability that Mage Knight offers over War of the Ring is is staggering. While War of the Ring is easily one of the best two-player games in on the market, Mage Knight cannot be beat in providing players a completely different game every single time. And that difference it far extends beyond tactically adjusting based on your opponents. There are moments in War of the Ring where you feel you've been there before. Whereas with Mage Knight, it's just constantly allowing you see new things and demanding you solve a new puzzle with every playthrough through a different map construction monster decks and and so many other variables and even your own deck. Managing that deck of cards every turn is some of the most fun I've ever had in a board game. But where Mage Knight can be a bit messy, it can feel unfair and not balanced, War of the Ring is an incredibly tight experience that offers a fascinating dice action mechanic that is a joy to puzzle over every single turn. While Mage is a series of skirmishes, war is is of course providing a war. The feeling is always epic and it's always tense. There
are no runaway leaders in War of the Ring. every turn feels like you're on the the brink of losing and you're also so close to victory that it's just it's a hell of a feeling. War of the Ring is a game you get not just when you want to dip your toes into wargaming, but when you want a deeply thoughtprovoking two-player experience that cannot be rivaled by any other game available. Both of these games are ones I exclusively play at two players despite the box suggesting that plays, you know, upwards of four. And because of that, when I want the best possible two-player experience, I'm not looking beyond War of the Rake. This one, this one kind of hurts the most. Seeing Major League take even the slightest L will keep me up at night. But let's go to the locker room and get a word from the winner. Bro, we're going all the way on this one.
Mage Knight and their crappy minis, they didn't stand a chance, bro. But don't people actually complain about evil men as well? This interview is over, bro. And next we move to Arknova and On Mars. Two late blooming engine builders that provide brilliant strategy decisions with very tightly constrained mechanics. I have never been a fan of polyominal games, but there's just something about building those little enclosures and doing my best to cover up certain benefit spots or just trying to fulfill my personal objectives and just building the perfect little enclosures for animals. It just it just makes me want to keep on playing. It just feels good. And beyond that, it's just another layer that this game provides where your first layer is that sort of brilliant rotating car row. And then once you do select an action, even something as simple as building enclosures, you are met with even more decisions you have to make.
And it's it's that space that makes you feel challenged and and truly engaged. But let's get a better understanding of the strategy in this game and head on over to Strategy Corner. Michael, take it away. Welcome back, board game players, to Strategy Corner. Sponsors are the bread and butter of Ark Nova, and they can make or break your game. Here are the best S tier sponsors that you should draft in every single game. The best one, in my opinion, is side entrance. It adds way too much versatility to ever be ignored. The others, Technology Institute, Federal Grants, Science Lab, Talented Communicator, Cable Cars, Explorer, and of course, Native Farm Animals. These are the best in the game. Back to you, Mike. But I think on Mars is just able to do what Ark Nova can't. On Mars provides players a feeling of autonomy where you never feel like you're being screwed by lady luck because you can't draw this card or that card like those damn bear cards. In On Mars, you're in control. And that feeling, that feeling is amazing. In the game, there's a shuttle system that dictates the actions you can take as a shuttle flies between the colony you're establishing and space stations. And you know, you get to choose when you want to travel, which means you could put yourself in a position where you could be up against and competing against nobody for the spots that you want. And I love the game for providing those moments where you get to feel like you're outthinking your opponents. I think in gaming, that's really important. As strange as that may sound, as much as I enjoy the low brilliance of On Mars, there is just something so incredibly charming about building a zoo that I don't think On Mars can match. Take that feeling and and combine that with a very rich action
selection system and a deck of cards that likely took an entire tree to print, and you can easily see that Ark Nova is the clear winner of this match. Back in the West, we have two games that have more backstabbing than your average Care Bear might be comfortable with. Twilight Imperium versus Nemesis. Twilight is a fairly old game designed back in the late '9s. The game's age acts as this like great advantage in this match because there are there are now four additions and each new addition does its damnedest to build on the brilliance of the previous iteration. Almost like almost like cutting and refining a diamond over time. This super dense and engaging game really only centers around picking one action card on your turn and then everyone around the table gets to perform the secondary action of that card. It's just a great way to encourage interaction beyond the various other ways the game engages players with one another. And I think it's I think its subtlety gets lost on how cool that mechanic is because Twilight is a game that demands you constantly engage with those at the table with you. And that's why it really is an event game. Now, before we move on to Nemesis, let's take a look at tonight's weather. Over to you, Michael. We interrupt tonight's tournament for a special weather bulletin. Tonight's forecast calls for rain caused by a sea of tears moving in from the east as you take control of Murk Rex. But be careful because a gust of war suns has been starting to move in from the west and it may just ruin your day. Back to you, Mike. In Nemesis,
you're cooperating, you know, working together to rumage through the ruins of a ship. Deeply afraid that the slightest noise you create may bring aliens that will absolutely ruin you. It's the complete opposite of Twilight in its scale. here. It's far more intimate and and for boating, and that's what makes it so enjoyable. And unlike Twilight, you're mostly working together, and that can be that can be a really fun experience. Some of my favorite gaming memories happened in this game. having to go back to different rooms to, you know, to rescue a teammate who was just going to about to die from an alien only to have the same teammate toss me out in space from the airlock because he was a traitor is certainly not something I enjoyed at the time, but it's something that I can look back now on and and and laugh. But I mean, mostly I mean I still hate you, Andrew. I I still hate you, but but I can laugh about it. I guess this one has to go to Twilight Imperial.
He is just too strong of a contender. This game has been in the league for decades, and he always ends up in people's list for best games of all time. Nemesis is just too new and green around the edges to compete against this this seasoned juggernaut. In the East, we have a battle between two games made much better in their second editions, Through the Ages and Brass Birmingham. With all the popularity of asymmetric games, I I really love this this battle because it's between two games that have no game start powers or factions. In both of these games, it's incumbent upon you as a player to build your own identity through your actions. Maybe you've got the perfect spots for for iron and coal that everyone needs. You know, maybe you're the cake master. Maybe you run the entire east side of Birmingham. It's it's always more pleasurable to forge your own path than it is to be given guide rails to follow, like those yellow lines that appear in video games sometimes. And what's fun is that you're creating this identity in an incredibly fierce competitive game where you're constantly worried someone is going to build in your areas or want to take that resource that you really need. A lot of worker placement games try to emulate that tension through an almost passive interaction, but brass maintains that tension throughout the entire game. and someone taking your card in the car row and through the ages just it doesn't have that same impact and excitement.
But if tension and unique player controlled powers is what you seek in board games, Through the Ages cannot be beat. Like Brass, everyone starts exactly the same in Through the Ages. And as the game progresses, you take more and more cards from that card row, building a sort of unique infrastructure, establishing special leaders that nobody else can have but yourself. You feel like you're building your own civilization and determining if you will be, you know, the sort of military powerhouse terrorizing your neighbors or this economic juggernaut building wonders quickly or or maybe becoming a a scientific marvel researching every new tech that appears on the card. Every game feels immensely different. And that tension from this game comes from so many different areas that brass just can't compete against.
You know, seeing your neighbor amass an army or researching the latest military tech is genuinely frightening because now you have to sort of like pivot your strategy and adapt to his potential aggression. And that's it's just a hell of a lot of fun and a cool decision space to be in. The winner here is is just clear as night and day. And Board Game Geek couldn't be any more wrong. Through the Ages is a better game than Brass. There, I said it. The scope and uniqueness of Through the Ages is just worlds beyond brass. It's just it's staggering.
For our final stage of the West, we have a bout between two games that have a fanatic following. No matter who wins tonight, there is going to be a substantial amount of fans going home in tears when Twilight Imperium faces off against War of the Ring. Taking and occupying areas is something both games have deeply in common. However, unlike War of the Ring, in Twilight Imperium, there is a beautiful element of exploration intrinsically linked to the game, especially in fourth edition. Now you can flip an explore deck corresponding to traits found on the planet and gain new improvements for the planet or bonuses for your faction. It adds this sort of like epic feeling that War of the Ring can't really replicate. Middle Earth is largely stagnant where as you here you're you're building a new galaxy every single time. And part of the thrill of the game is not just seeing what unfolds within the galaxy through war and conquest, but seeing what new planets will develop and and how these newly explored pieces of space may completely change the flow of the game. But if Twilight Imperium is a choose your own adventure novel, War of the Ring is a meticulously crafted novel. It somehow allows both the the the control and impact of the players while still managing to tell a coherent and always exciting epic story. And that story involves two sides that are insanely different. This isn't like Twilight Imperium where one side gets a plus one to something. No, the wind condition of the free people and the shadow are vastly different. It makes you feel as a player like you're playing an almost completely different game than your opponent and yet you're both doing your absolute best to poke and punch your opponent to prevent them from getting what they want. It is deeply
confrontational at its core and sometimes that's a far more engaging and thrilling experience than being two factions sitting in space on opposite sides of the galaxy and never actually getting to interact with one another. I think as brilliant a war game as War of the Ring is and how wonderful that dice selection mechanic works, there are moments where you feel like you're being railroaded. And while I can enjoy the tight decision space at times, Twilight Game just I think it outshines this game and its ability to truly provide players a sense of agency. Both games are are absolute 10, but only 110 can survive. The final battle of the east goes to Through the Ages and Ark Nova, two of my favorite games of all time. Through the Ages is able to do what Ark Nova can never do, which is perfectly capture the theme that it's trying to convey. In this game, you generally feel like you are this like fledgling civilization doing your best to find some avenue to differentiate yourself from your neighbors and dominate everyone else at the table. And the interesting thing about the game is how condensed the game feels. I I know that seems strange to praise when the when the game takes like five hours to complete, but you really do feel like you you're running through a huge chunk of human history and a limited amount of time. I I think avoiding a a a communal map is the reason for this. Finding a way to perfectly emulate the feeling of a civilization game with nothing more than a hand of cards is an incredible design feat, one in which Arknova wishes it can accomplish. Ark Nova, more so than through the ages, offers this
amazing sense of accomplishment and mastery as you continually play the game. Between each session, you can feel yourself getting better at its intricate systems. You know that if you just play a bit more, you'll improve and start to see more and more strategy the deeper you go into this game. It's the game itself demanding that you adapt to your current situation on every turn. And to me, that's really exciting. I can go into a game with a basic strategy and understanding of which cards are good in which situations, but the amount of pivoting I have to do when I see a specific specialist at the Carro, it's just it's too much fun. It's one of the few non-abstract games that I would liken to chess or go. And that's that's that's a damn good company to be in. In my eyes, you could not ask for a tighter match. On any given day, if you were to ask me my favorite game, you would get either of these games at the top. But today, but today, it's through the ages.
It reigns supreme as the king of the east. The veteran beats the rookie. And we've reached the final battle. Two warriors that are deeply respected and love in both of the respective leagues. And perhaps two games that couldn't be more different. One demanding your absolute focus on the game and its mechanics, while the other demanding you pay close attention to those around you at all times. Two very different playing experiences and two awesome games. Through the Ages versus Twilight Imperium. In Through the Ages, every single turn matters. You want to do as much as you can, but you can't. It's agonizing, but it's exciting. And there is just something about that car row that is just head and shoulders more interesting than many of the things Twilight offers, despite how simple it is. Deciding to grab a card from that row and paying more actions for it either makes you feel like a genius for snagging it early or an idiot for being too impatient. You have to read other players at the table in a way that is far more subtle and fascinating than Twilight. It's the same with military or figuring what cards people have played for endgame scoring objective based on the actions that they taken throughout the game. I think those brilliant subtleties are lost when up against the blunt force of a huge bombastic game like Twilight. And that's a shame because if you're you're avoiding games like Through the Ages because you don't feel they have interaction, you're doing yourself a great disservice because Through the Ages provides some of the most interesting interactions I have ever had with friends at a table surrounding, you know, bits of cardboard
and wood. When people think Twilight Imperium, their first thought is probably huge epic space battles. And one would think that would be the focus of this fight. But looking at Twilight Imperium as just space battles, it's it's wrong. you you could instead focus your resources on making deals with others. Uh maybe asking someone to play their strategic card at a specific point or or playing someone to to attack someone else or or purchasing a planet from someone and then having them abandon it. There are so many ways to interact not just with the mechanics of the game, but the people you play with that you'll never see in a game like Through the Ages. And that moment as a player when you're able to put your energy towards, you know, nudging others to do things in a game adds so much to freedom and agency. Yes, it's complex and it's timeconuming, but that time allows so much more room for interacting with others around you. And after all, isn't that the entire point of gaming?
Yeah, we're all sort of, you know, solving this intricate puzzle made of cardboard. But the reason I'm sitting here down at this table in the first place is because I want the opportunity to connect with my friends in a new and interesting way. And any game that facilitates that experience isn't just a good game on its own. It's a valuable piece of culture. And the grand winner of the heavy strategy board game tournament, taking home the crown for the greatest heavyweight game of all time in human history, is Twilight Imperial. What a hard-fought battle between two of the best contenders within their respective leagues. Twilight Imperium was just it was too massive a juggernaut to ever be taken down. And that about wraps it up for tonight's big tournament. Be sure to like, comment, and subscribe for more silly like this video.