Tales of the Arthurian Knights: Discussion
Transcript
Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.
Hey everyone, welcome back to More Games Unlocked. Today I'm doing a discussion over the Tales of the Arthuran Knights, which if you're not familiar with this kind of game, is a rethemed version of an older game that I believe came out in like 2010 or something uh called Tales of the Arabian Knights. And this game has been I feel like talked about for many, many years. I'm looking up 2009 is when the Tales of the Arabian Knights came out. Um, and this one came out in 2024, but if I remember right, there was like talk for a long time of a rethemed uh, version of that game. Um, and here it finally is. So, I have had the Tales of the Arabian Knights in my collection since I basically got into the hobby. It is a game that's definitely not for everyone, but certainly holds a special place in my heart just because of the sheer chaos of the game. Like, if you can even really call it that. There's very much just a sense of we had to put some mechanics in here uh to make it not just reading to each other, but that's essentially what it is.
and the the amount of variety that is in uh that game, you know, almost is is one of the more special kinds of narrative games that because there's just every type of encounter that you can have is just you have so many decisions of how you want to interact with that. So, fast forward from 20 2009 to 2024 and this game comes out. And so, how does this compare to a game of of that? And I mean, honestly, it's pretty much that just in the Arthurian setting with King Arthur and way more streamlined. Like, it is I mean, for all intents and purposes, a better game. Um, I personally love this setting a lot more. This is more in my wheelhouse of the Knights of the Round Table, the mystical enchantment that it wasn't just, you know, the story of King Arthur and and the search for the Holy Grail or the Camelot, the war in Great Britain. It's not just that. There's also mystical elements and it's pretty much that but again just in a much more streamlined sense. A good example is in the Tales of the Arabian Knights. They made you do this arbitrary setup on trying to figure out, you know,
how much Destiny points you wanted or how much of I can't even remember what the other thing was, but you had to secretly choose, hey, I want to get this much of this score and this much of this score. And once I finally meet that number, I need to make it back to Arabia. They completely scrap that here. And it's literally just whoever has the most destiny points, like however many of these tokens you have uh by the end. And there's some end of age scoring based off of your own renown plus if you end up being in Camelop at the end um based off your ranks of your your sheets uh or your skills. It's just such a better streamlined process. Um, one of my favorite things that is that you know about this game is the fact that every single encounter that you come across uh basically has so many different options. Like I mean a simple example is you know if you go to a location and you just draw a card that's like hey you come across the queen and if it's a person then you just take this card and you draw a feature and it's like oh okay you've come across a wise queen which is going to be story uh section 1112.
But this queen could be sorrowful. She could be enchanted. She could be blessed. She could be desperate. Each, you know, there are 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10. There are 10 different features that this queen um could be. And that's going to take you to a completely different section in this massive book of tales. And not only that, but almost every single section that you come across out of these 10 choices gives you a a choice on how you want to react. Um, like, hey, you come across a mad queen. Do you want to try and uh I mean, mad could mean many things. She could actually literally be mad or she could be insane. Let's say she's insane. Do you choose to end her suffering or try and absolve her of her madness? And you just, it doesn't even tell you. It just says, do you want to do one of these two things? And when you pick one, that takes you to another section that will then tell you, okay, you can try and do this with with a skill you may have or renown you may have, uh, or not a renown, uh, a renowned score. And if you're like, okay, I'll try and absolve her of her madness. [snorts] And that might tell you, okay, you need a divinity of this level or a particular skill. If you don't have either of those, then you fail. So each choice you
make also has a success or failure option, and that's usually the end of it. But some of them might even open up more opportunities to do something later on. Um, but the great thing about either, you know, either of those is it seems to be less harsh. Tales of the Arabian Knights was brutal. Like there were ch there were an entire possibility that you could be imprisoned from from the get-go and just fail to get out for a long time. It could just be I mean, if you're going in with the the right mindset, that could be just hilarious or it could just be incredibly infuriating. this so far seems to be less punishing. Um but but yeah, like that's just one of my and that's just one example of one of the encounter cards that's just the queen. That's just a a person you could come across. You know, they call it a whatever the word is. Um, it's basically like uh the one of a more mystical or or historical thing, just a vague kind of description like the one I just drew is um harrowing battlefield.
Now, again, what's awesome about this is these have uh six numbers on it that you then take the age that you're in, and there's three ages you can play, and you just line it up, and depending on which section, like what type of terrain you're on, that's going to give you a different um a different section in the book to go to. So, if you happen to come across a Harrowing Battlefield on the sea, that's going to take you to 2271 in age one. But, and if you're in age three, then it takes you to 2471. And again, like the the the people, you're going to come across something and have a decision on what to make. Like I for a lot of my channel, I have a s I have series, I have campaigns going on. A lot of my top 10s or top 100s, a lot of these games are narrative driven campaign games. But what Tales of the Arabian Knights and what Tales of the Orthora Knights do so well is capture that narrative driven element without having to commit to a 20 plus scenario campaign. uh you get to sit down and feel like you're a character making decisions, having things happen to you um and you know develop a character in you know a few hours and then by the time you're done you're like cool here are my destiny
points. Here are my quests I've completed. Here's my status cards that I have. I've essentially had a story be developed based off the choices that I made and we get to pack it up. Don't me wrong. I love me my campaign games, but there is still, you know, a love that I have for gaming where I don't have to sit here and almost feel like it's work to to to finish a campaign to be like, "Okay, we have so much left of this game to complete depending on how much I'm enjoying the campaign or not." But it's so nice to be like, "Man, that was epic. That was awesome. That was fun." And we're done. and we get to pack it up and still feel fulfilled. I made the same exact comment whenever I did my re-review of like Eldrich Horror um or my review of Twilight Imperium. You just get these epic experiences in hours and not years, you know. So, and I understand this game is definitely not for everyone. There's virtually not a lot of game here. your your game is is this is the book of tales is literally if you don't have someone who's a strong reader or you're not someone who likes to sit down and have a bunch of read to you, you're probably not going to have a good time with this one. And I get that. Like I mean honestly I've made complaints with campaign games on there needs to be an app, you know, that reads
things to you and I do agree um with that for campaign games. I would love it for this. Like I mean it would be amazing. I don't know if that exists. I highly doubt it, but it would be awesome if there was like a a app that basically just took you just put in the um the code and they easily could like oh hey the mad queen that is uh 11 1107 and you just type in 1107 and it plays and it reads it to you. I haven't looked, but I just highly doubt Whiz Kids is going to shell out the money to have something like that developed. Um, but that is has always just been one of my absolute favorite things. I mean, and those are only two of the three types of encounters you can come across. The fact the third one is um cities, and there's a certain number that you only put in, so they're a lot more rare for you to have an encounter.
But yeah uh so so the the question then comes down if the game is if the game is this if the game is the book of tales then how how's the writing? Um I think the writing is very very well done. Uh, in this last game we played, we had we actually had two instances of uh like fighting, like combat, and they're actually pretty lengthy sections, a lot more than I remember coming across in Tales of the Arabian Knights. Uh, and both of them were very descriptive. They they encapsulated the feel or the the epicness of being a knight in in this uh in this encounter.
Like a good example is my girlfriend uh came across a manticor that she chose to attack cuz it was it took over a city and it was describing how she could have used hunting to try and hunt it like an animal or mounting. Um and she she had mounted. So that's what she did. And upon her success, it was basically describing how she whistled for her horse in the citadel and it came charging in and she rode on it and beared her lance down upon it. And as it it like the manticor shot porcupine quills out of it that she put her shield in front of her and her horse to to uh protect it, then pierced the lance, threw the manticor's wings, knocking it down to the ground as she leapt off the the horse to slice its tail off at the base. And while it was crying in agony, she beheaded it.
And that's literally, you know, that was just it was worded so well that that's just in my memory of, you know, it did a great job. My character had a similar experience uh with a success of of overcoming a um like a base of operations from a like a like a a rogue chieftain. and they they just do a really good job of being extremely descriptive and having different characters that you're encountering have different personalities. It's really really well done. The only not necessarily criticism um that I have. It could just be because again there's thousands of pages uh of not thousands of pages, thousands of uh entries you can come across. So maybe we in in this last game uh you know we just didn't come across a lot of them. But I feel like this game like the tales of the earth knights is not as wacky. Uh cuz tales of the Arabian Knights had very strange instances. It was really really like almost whimsical of some things you can come across. Like there were serious moments but then there was also just completely weird moments. And I think the reason there's a couple reasons.
One, the way that the story is being told to you is you basically you see your encounter, Mad Queen. We'll just keep using that. You go to the section, reads what you come across, and then you're given choices immediately. In Tales of the Arabian Knights, it would basically give you a matrix. uh like on your on your board it would say matrix uh N or whatever and you would look at matrix N and that would tell you how you could interact with that and sometimes it would just be really weird stuff like the the matrixes of options of keywords that you could pick just didn't quite immediately make sense for what you were encountering and years ago show I'm really going to show showcase when that the golden era of board game reviewers.
Um, shut up and sit down. I know they're still around and doing stuff, but Shut Up and Sit Down. I think it was um Quill and Paul, I was going to say Peter, uh, they did a review of Tales of the Arabian Knights. And one example that they they gave was like you come across a lion and you can enter it, you know, things like that. like based off the matrix it would give you a you know a section of words and you would be like wait I come across a line yeah of course I can attack it I could wait I can speak [snorts] to it let's do that you know I can enter it how am I entering this line and that would take you to a really weird section that you would come across um so I I mean I really love having both of the games because well my version is actually the Zman copy [snorts] um I know there's a 40th anniversary edition of it coming out at some point, but so I don't know if they've changed anything with that version. Um, but in my version, they have those weird entrances and I and it it's it's a different kind of storytelling.
This one again seems to be more serious. It's limiting in a way. I mean, it makes more narrative sense. Hey, here's where you come across as a night of the round table. You could still do you could be a villain. You could attack someone when there's not prompted to. You can do this sometime. I mean it's not always two options. There's they can give you multiple choices. Um but not all of them are going to make sense to what you are coming across. So it makes a more cohesive narrative story versus the tales of the Arabian Knights which never felt like it was truly interconnected. you were just I mean from my understanding of the tales of the Arabian Knights is the thousand1 knights or thousand1 tales. Uh so a lot of them could just be wacky and and you know willy and silly and stupid and that makes for a more humorous experience whereas I feel like this one might actually make for a more epic experience if that makes any sense. Um and I'm not quite sure which one I prefer. I think I think this this version does kind of come off more gamelike more narrative driven cam not campaign game more narrative driven game and that one came off as more of a beer and pretzels element where you're you're coming in and it's just let's just see what happens and make the best of it and just have have a good time. Not that this isn't, you know, having a good time, but yeah, it's it's strange. I I do kind of
miss coming across something, giving a choice of keywords to pick, looking at those options, and being like, "This one makes absolutely no sense. Let's see what happens." Um, and you I mean, you can easily do that here, too. You're just limited again on the options. Uh, but between the two, um, not that the Tales of Arabian Nights, not that the writing for that one wasn't wasn't good. Uh this this is clearly just better. It's it's more cohesive, more streamlined, more structured, uh more detailed. It it is better writing. Um now the other great thing about this game is the fact that they have provided each player just with a a again streamline version of your skills and your statuses. Everyone has their own status deck that they they just keep on them. They have an easier way to keep track on when you get rid of them.
They're kind of timebased now. So, at the beginning of each each of your turns, you'll move a track down and once the thing falls off, it goes away. Um, that's clean. Uh, they have new ways on keeping track of your skills. It's not just blanket skills that you just have now. That's either a plus one or plus two. Now, you actually kind of have a level up system with your skills. Um, there's four different types, uh, marshall, spiritual, courtly, and wilderness. And each time you gain one, like, hey, okay, if I gain I start with sword and shield. If I gain that, then it just moves up to a plus two. If I gain it again, plus three, four, five, and but you're limited on how high these can go. So, you can only ever get one skill to a six.
But from that point, it's just so much easier to go across an encounter and it's like, "Hey, you can use mounted." And you're like, "Cool, my mounted is sitting at a three. I'm just going to get a plus three." And it's always just been a die roll. And you roll. Cool. I got a three, so that's six. and the person reading it. The way I've always done it is I have never told people what they're um what they need to get. Uh because the game is so storytelling based, I always found it more enjoyable to see what they get and just read what happens and leave it at that. Um and the rule book actually says says to do that as well. You know, it keeps them in suspense on like, oh, what what do I need? What what happens? It's like, "Oh, well, you're about to see what happens because it's like, unfortunately, you needed an eight." Uh, then you only got a six, but because like I said, even if you fail, it's still it's just like you still get something for it. It's just you could get something even better. Um, but I like this system. Again, I think it is a much cleaner experience. It's so much easier to just sit here and be like, "Cool, I gain mounted again. Boom.
Now it's just at my plus three. Two. I get it again. Three. Eventually, I'll just get in. Might just be a plus six." Or every time mounted shows up, I'm an expert, you know, horseman person. Uh cavalry. I'm I'm an expert cavalry knight. That's just based off what's happened to me. This is what the skills that I have gained. Um, also quests are just way easier to manage. Uh, everyone has a starting quest, which is nice. It kind of gives them a direction because in both of the games, there's nothing necessarily stopping you from you could just have a quest and be like, eh, I don't really feel like doing that. I want to go all the way down here and just start dealing with random stuff. But for going after the quest is just going to because you're going to have random encounters anyway, you might as well just try and complete the quests. So, everyone has a starting quest and then there's a deck of of quests that you get to draw.
Keeping track of these is so much easier. It still has some player interaction where some people some some players get to put your quest markers somewhere. Um, but in all honesty, this game has never had player interaction. This one or Tales of the Arabian Knights. There's literally you can't fight each other. You can't That's like That's it. Hey, have someone else place your quest marker somewhere. That's literally it. Um, hence why it makes sense that people on BG would say this is best at at like two. And I would very much agree. Um, again, not that it's bad with more, it's just going to be longer, more reading. If everyone wants to read, then you're passing it along. Otherwise, you're kind of designating that one person to do it, which is typically me, which is I actually would prefer cuz man, there's I just can't stand when people are reading aloud and they're like, you come across an empty field and in that field you see a knight whose hair is flowing in the it's like, dude, can never mind. Just give it to me. like I don't like I'll read my own thing and and make it way more entertaining.
Um but yeah, like I I love the structure. They also have something really nice uh in that you can decide how long you want your game to be in that if you want it to be a quick game, you do one age. Um intermediate game, two ages, long game, like the full game is all three ages. And each of those will have different elements of kind of destiny scoring. And then by the end of the game, there's like a bigger a larger way of gaining more destiny based off your renown, based off your skills. And it literally just comes down to who has the most destiny. And uh and that and they're the winner. There's no secret like, haha, I put these tokens underneath my board so you couldn't see what I was trying to get. I made it. That was just always weird. Um yeah, they also have uh something I mentioned the quest. They have a variant you can play called the grand quest which allows for everyone to kind of contribute to this more board uh like this board quest that's going on that as long as you have contributed to it, you get the the grand quest rewards.
So, that's pretty cool if you want a more involved epic game. They also have treasures you can get that are really powerful and help out a lot. Those are really cool. But honestly, yeah, I mean, it's a it's a relatively small footprint game that I I enjoy. I mean, I've done a 3D insert for it, but it it's so much better. [clears throat] It's so much more streamlined. My only complaint between this one compared to the Arabian Knights is the fact that Arabian Knights just had a more wacky, whimsical, silly vibe to it. I'm glad they both exist. Uh, but yeah, it just depends on what mood you're in. If you want to feel more like an epic knight set in the Arthuran night setting, then this is going to be the game for you. If you want the more Arabian setting that is just, you know, you know, beer and pretzels, then play that one. Now, if you don't own either and you're like, "This is this seems like the kind of game that I would enjoy," I would just I'd say just get this one because it's it's just going to it's a better game overall. Uh, now how this one will compare to the 40th anniversary or whatever it was called.
Uh, because I just looked it up on game found. 40th anniversary. Damn. Um, yeah. H how's it going to compare to that version? I don't know because the 40th anniversary is done by Play to Z. I have no idea what that is. God, that game originally came out in 1985. Holy Yeah, my version's the 2009 version. Um, and yes, I don't think they they have the 40th anniversary out yet. So, so not sure. I mean, it could just be basically that that game just now more streamlined like this one, but this is done by Whiz Kids and that one's done by someone else. So, who knows how they're gonna implement that version, but comparing this one to the 2009 Zman version, uh, yeah, this one just has has a lot more has a lot more going on, uh, and is cleaner. Um, and that's really the the major difference. So yeah, I mean it it was almost a blast to the past because I haven't played the Arabian Knights in a long time, but I could never bring myself to getting rid of it from my collection because it's just hey, this was one of the first and I just have so many good memories from playing this. Um that I'm actually happy that this still
captured that feel just in a more gamer gamey game, which is still very little. Like I mean I'm not going out and saying, "Oh man, they really improved upon it." It's like no, it's still the same. Just just a different system. Uh and I do like the writing a lot. So on a scale of 1 to 10, what am I giving Tales of the Arthurian Knights? I'll give an eight. I really like this game. Which is funny enough how I have Tales of the Arabian Knights. Uh so they're they're virtually the exact same. Like both have like the similar pros. And even my issues with the writing is not that it's bad. It's just different different storytelling uh uh what's the word avenues that that they both have. But in terms of actually my enjoyment of the game, yeah, they both get an eight for me. I I absolutely love them. [clears throat] And yeah, I remember a lot of people this this is kind of one of those games that people have that stupid argument of like it's more of an activity. It's like, sure, whatever you need to feel superior. But I I think these games are an absolute blast. And if you just want a chill, you know, epic session of feeling like you've made decisions and see your character, you know, grow and and be like, "Oh, I remember how I became beloved and I remember how I became betrothed because of this story, because I chose to do this." You get to feel that without again having to commit
to a 40 plus hour campaign. You get to do this in an hour if you choose a quick game and you still feel fulfilled. It's like boom. Okay, cool. We're done. But let's do an epic game. Let's see how much what all can happen and you can choose to do that as well. Anyway, that's it everyone. That's my thoughts on the Tales of the Arthorian Knights. Let me know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.