Wyrmspan vs Wingspan - Friendly Ties Podcast
Transcript
hey guys it's Anastasia before we dive into this episode I wanted to jump on here real quick from the future because we are in the middle of editing this episode and we're realizing that this episode is going to come out a couple of days before the golden geek nominations close on Board Game Geek so if you are listening to this sometime before April 21st 2024 at midnight is Central Time then if you've been enjoying this podcast and you would feel so inclined mind if you could go click on the link in the show notes of this episode there's a link there that will take you to nominate friendly ties for best podcast on board gek while you're there you can also vote for a bunch of different games all sorts of things it's a really cool thing the board game geek does every year it would be so awesome if we could get nominated I always say don't we don't need to win I I have no illusions of grandeur here on winning but it would be super fun to get nominated so if you guys have a couple seconds you could do that that would be awesome now back to the episode hey everybody welcome back to the friendly ties podcast we usually talk about one game but today the podcast is going to span two games from the worms to the wings we're comparing worms span and wingspan
today so there's this new game that just came out it's kind of about old fake Birds worms dragons worms span kind of surprised me when it was first announced uh a few months ago and it's it's kind of like a reimplementation sort of of uh wingspan super popular game we've all played it a bunch and we've played worm span a few times as well yeah and the I think one of the fascinating things uh here is that we are talking about two games in the same not universe but something with the same core system but there are two different designers too yeah like saying that like oh you know you're playing a worker placement or something like now you're playing a span Style game span game yeah exactly there's two of them yeah so I got wingspan back in 2019 when that first came out uh I played it looks like about 3ish times I I sold my copy I kind of figured I was good with wingspan I thought I liked it it was fine uh and then surprise here's worms ban and The more I've read about it the more interested I got in to play it and I did get to play it I've actually played it three times now and the say you played it twice Nick's played it once and we felt like we had a lot of things to say in fact we just finished uh Nick's first play like two hours ago and I think there's just a lot of thoughts brimming around yeah I've played wingspan a really large number of times um obviously this is only the one for worms span so it's more like Impressions that
you're going to hear from me on this I do want to add uh this will be the one episode where I have to make a caveat uh rather than John making a caveat for being connected cuz I actually know am in friendly with both the designers they they are in the same area that I live in and I've been to both of their houses so fair caveat there why don't we treat this episode a little bit like we treated the last one maybe we just do like a quick overview of kind of the central core mechanic that is present that are present kind of in both games like what should the viewers at home expect right that makes sense between the two these are games with big decks of cards uh which is kind of popular these days I think you know a large draw deck I think it's like 160 cards in worms span seeing just a ton of variety in the cards in your hand and trying to weave something together uh in both these games you play these cards into a tableau in front of you and you kind of run the Tableau like a row just kind of like going bird to Dragon to bird to dragon and uh both of these games are kind of structured in a way that you are building up an engine of sorts as you are playing it so you are weak at the beginning and hypothetically very strong and kind of gassed out at the end there's a lot more Nuance going on but realistically it's about hand management between all these winged beasts that you have here yeah so interesting to me that you call it hand management that would not be the top five things I would mention about this game yeah I want to hear I want to hear Nick's version of
this so I would call I would call the core mechanism the action selection and basically in both the games it's got you have three rows the rows corresponding to the action that you're taking um which is usually get one type of resource get another type of resource get a third type of resource and that resources are like actual like stuff that you pay or cards um and then depending on the game maybe eggs or something like that and then there's a fourth action depending on the game there there are eggs there yeah but like there's not a row that's dedicated towards eggs which is I think very significant true um there's there's the a fourth action of you can play out new Birds uh but in worms span there's a fifth action that you can play out new caves which are required to do new dragons so it's something like a two-step process but really it's it's the same sort of idea of like you are playing things into these rows the rows then become Superior as John mentioned you know your your setting up your system or your engine um and and running through those rows so the more you play into the rows the better you are at doing that action that is true it's interesting that I immediately gravitated towards the variety of the cards versus the actually functionally using them and they're both kind of two two different ends of the uh the system I guess to a certain extent yeah I think it's really interesting too though
because I've always thought of it more as a not even actually I like how you explained it Nick like as an action selection game and I I actually agree with you John like I like how you explained it like yeah there is this massive deck of cards that gives you all this variability with the creatures that you are bringing but I've always thought of it more as a tableau game um you know just the like leaning a little bit to what you were saying John of like the engine that you're kind of creating but more so like what you have this player mat in front of you and the things that you're adding to it you are not only are you putting things down that could potentially become a little bit of an engine give you different things but you're also collecting things on them and collecting different points both on the cards and with the things you can put on the cards and then there are end of round scoring goals and so you're you're trying to put things on your Tableau that meet those goals and then meet the you know give you more points as you're playing the game and so it it's funny that between the three of us you can kind of see like everyone looks at the game just a little bit differently and then also how many layers are kind of like at play with this system which is is is tweaked between the two games but is very much present it's it's a very cool system that is present in both games yeah and the the first I guess real Divergence is what Nick said already instead of just putting a bird down into the wetlands or whatever you have to actually dig out a cave to then put the dragon inside of it and that is
uh an extra thing that you could do in it's an an extra lever and it definitely changed the feel of the game a lot more than I expected when I first you know heard about this new version like okay you need a cave too well whatever but the it really allowed the game to have a lot of variety injected into it with the stuff that you can get specifically with the the cave excavation you're not just digging a hole you're you're realistically getting a bonus like every time you put one down there's just a huge variety of stuff that you get it's a really interesting design Choice CU what it's essentially saying is we're we're slowing down the ramping up the building up your engine your row your power because you have to take two actions instead of one but what we've given you instead with these excavations they give you a one-time bonus so essentially it says hey here's another way to get resources that isn't taking kind of the primary row actions uh which does not really exist in a wingspan in wingspan it's it's really just kind of those like core actions in worms span there's a lot of different ways to get resources and it's it's funny I think if you look at the rule book I wouldn't say that worms span comes across as terribly heavier than wingspan but when you play the game it does because I think there's a lot of different places that you can get those inputs from whereas in wingspan it's like you want food you go to the food row and that's about it yeah seriously when when we sat down to play wingspan uh last week right after we' played warm span same day I think
that's right we played them the same day yeah yeah I remember looking at the board and being like oh okay then it's just like you want eggs go to the egg row you want food go to the food row you want Birds go to the bird row like it's not these kind of like multi-step or multi-layered or kind of like o this triggers this and then I get this and then I get this and then I get that so this I think worms span if I was going to make a kind of a summation but you know as we're kind of starting to get dive in and go deeper into the Mechanics for me worms span feels like more of a gamer's game like if it took the wi span elements it just it added in a lot a lot of more gamer heavy I'm not going to say heavy but like midweight gaming elements elements that you know we're seeing a lot of those chains the combos the things some of which are present in wingspan but it really it it does kind of take it add in just enough other elements to kind of have a lot more different things happen you know immediately or later or this or that yeah I was just going to say I think that's that's one of the cuties of wingspan and I think why it's been successful um is because the actions you know they're interwoven with each other like if you want to get food you have to go to the food row you want to get cards you got to go to the card row you want to get eggs you got to go to the egg row and all of these things kind of like require or like diagonally require you to like do things in other places and the birds that people point to in in wingspan is being like imbalanced they destroy that ecosystem of like having to do this and then this and then this
whereas in worms ban exactly as you're saying Anastasia because you've got these like different places you can get things from a little bit more of a gamer's game because you can say okay I can do this it's not a to B to C it's like I could do a and then kind of like steal this over here and put that together and Cobble together my next action for this which will then let me like snowball a little bit more uh and so I think that's why worms span feels like like the the heavier more of the like gamer like efficiency game yeah there's just so many more options available to you like that really hit me over the head when we played wingspan later on in the same day we played worms span it's like oh this is just the not that it's a like a dumber game to play through like there's still a lot to think about there but I feel like there's like twice as many blinking lights demanding my attention to potentially combo in in worms span so one kind of subtle but really impactful difference between these two games is is how you run those rows like you said in wingspan you have the draw cards row you have the get food row and you have the make eggs row and you can put Birds into those rows and looking at the deck at a high level it seems like most of the birds activate when you activate that row like you put a bird into the the draw cards row that bird likely has some sort of an effect that lets you draw cards in some way not all the time but like there's a heavy Reliance on that kind of connection and when you run those rows in wingspan you do the base action but you do it better with more
Birds it's just you do you know if if you you take one food early and if there's a couple Birds now you take two food immediately but in worms span it spreads out the Bas actions across multiple birds and allows the I said Birds across multiple beasts and allows the actual the dragons in this case to be a lot more varied when you activate the rose in worm span you are still going from one end to the other it's left to right instead of right to left but it seems like so many of the dragons in worm span don't activate actually when you have your little Explorer walk across it they give you victory points for doing this and that the other thing they give you one shot effects as soon as you put it down and those exist in wingspan but playing the game of wingspan it felt like 80% of the cards were all about activating something when you activate that row but worm span has so many more baked in things you like do a base action then you potentially do the dragon then another thing on the board then Dragon then board than Dragon then board than dragon and it allows the design space to have a lot of those dragons not actually do anything you just kind of skip by them because that Dragon did something when you played it and then you move on okay the board's going to give you something beneficial now and it made me feel like there was a it allowed the design space to have a lot more different things on the Dragon cards if that made sense like we were playing earlier and Nick played a card the first dragon he played and this was my third play and I was like wait what does that do I looked over and it it activated based off what the person to his left was doing and that was was the first Dragonite scene that had anything
to do with the person on your left and this is my third play it's like okay that it felt like this stuff was just a lot more varied um in that big deck yeah I think one of the things that you mentioned in there about it feels like fewer of the dragons have that sort of like when you run this row kind of like system and I think that that's it feels like it's an intentional choice I think that it is a reflection of the fact that the core rows are just fundamentally stronger like it takes longer for the core action in wingspan to get better than it does in worm span and in wingspan you really you really want those like brown when you activate this row Birds to be in the rows that you're going to be running and ideally you know you're playing those like one-off bonuses into rows that you're not running quite as often that's true in worm span but the rewards for those like one-off bonuses are spicy enough that you could throw it in a row that you're planning on running a number of times and the Row's core strength itself is already good enough that you can get away with doing that and not feel like I think as punished Maybe by like not having sort of the right sequence of of birds sitting in or dragons sitting in a row I think there's something though that I want to pull back on here as we're talking about these rows because one thing I did notice in wingspan was that the birds that came out and and some of this helps because wingspan is about Birds right and even if you're not
an ornithologist most of us still know a a good number of birds right like if nothing else is like okay cool like I you know what a hawk is you might not know what like 14 different varieties of hawks are but like you have a you sort of have a sense of there's grounding there yeah with your yeah there's a grounding an eagle a blue jay you know whatever and in addition to that we have a sense of like there are birds that you just like kind of know or by the art you're like oh yeah that's a Wetlands Bird right or that's a prairie bird and like I think that there is something incredibly thematic that ties in to feeling like when you're going to select a bird in wingspan there's there's this element of being like Oh yeah that's a Wetlands bird like you either it's it's telling you that or you might notice that or whatever but there's a thematic pull towards this is going to go on the bottom and I understand that the actions for each row like it they're obviously reusing it here to tie it in more to the mechanics of the game and probably to help balance the game and how different things work together again to create that efficiency to create that engine but I do think that there's a thematic loss here and also just a little bit of like me feeling like oh I'm not looking at a dragon and being like where does why why why does that need to go on the top or why does that need to go it doesn't it's it makes me think more like oh because of the that's how the game works rather than oh this is a Wetlands bird this is a forest bird you know that kind of thing yeah I'm going to agree with you and it's makes me sad to say that because I'm I love dragons and I
don't care about birds but I pay attention to the bird cards and like I like you know where it like shows me what their like ranging is I like the little bird facts that are on them and the dragon art is really pretty but beyond that the card doesn't have the personality for me no it's all about what the card does yeah yeah yeah it's it's definitely more mechanical experience in that way yeah the first time I played it I remember distinctly saying like I this was the bird one and I don't I don't really care about birds either but yeah I think that is a big thematic loss between the two it just felt a little bit more generic you know it's like oh I have a angry I think I had a rocky Rock biter and then I have an angry am fit theater and then that doesn't mean anything to you like when you see the the names of these but it doesn't mean anything in an entertaining way either like a lot of bird names don't make anything mean anything in particular but they're hilarious there was one Dragon tonight where I was like like I was like oh I know what that is that's from Harry Potter like it's not not not actually but the type of dragon was this dragon that I recognize the funny thing is that I I do actually know for a fact that Connie considered what the dragon types were and like did actual like Dragon lore research to like figure it out so actually there is a thematic thing but there's none of that exists and like the cultural anything and like I'm someone who like plays Dungeons and dragons and I don't know the things yeah well I will admit I saw some
of that like I said like I I knew I did recognize some dragon names and it does feel like the theme is there I'm not going to sit here and say that theme is pasted on because the element of the caves and putting the dragons out and their hatchlings and all the things that we're going to start talking about it's there it's just not tied in I think as as well as the way that the birds were tied into the habitats and all of the elements that WI span but so speaking of the rows and if we're going to talk about this the mechanics of these rows I do want to kind of just take a moment to talk about the the major way the actions function in wingspan versus worm span because we've talked about how like in wingspan basically you go and you run there basically there's four actions you're either going to play a bird or you're going to run each of those three rows that we talked about and in worms span on the side of your player board the make it really clear that there's there's there's technically there's five actions but they've actually kind of pulled those out on the side so it's like the first one is you can go excavate which is put caves down and that's what Nick was referring to earlier with the twep process of you're going to you need to make room for your dragons before you can put them out the second one is just like in wingspan it's play dragons just like in wingspan play Birds and the last one is explore and so what they've done is kind of kind of pulled that action away from the concept of the you know the row itself is an
action space and so you still you're still going it's it's functionally exactly the same you you basically say I'm going to take the explore action and then you go pick a row and then you can run one of the three rows MH but it for me there's just something about that that just works better for my brain I don't know why but I just I never quite clicked with wings span I it always took me too long to like Gro every time I played it no matter how many times I've played it it always takes me like around to be like wait wait I'm going to select this and then run the row and then do my birds like I I never quite got that and functionally again it's it's basically the same here but you also have a little Explorer token you move that person that Explorer along the track and and it also helps to kind of be like to just kind of pull just changes slightly the thinking which speaking of theme actually for me works really well here it's like you actually instead of just being like I'm running a row you're like cool I've got I'm going to go explore and going to move my Explorer along this track and it's going to do lots of different things as he kind of moves along yeah I think the I think you hit the nail in the head with there's something about it being very kinetic with the the picking up the guy and moving it to the various places the action of the excavate and the entice uh you know aren written out detailed on the left side of the board or you can like you know that could be like where you toss your coins so you can track your actions whereas in wingspan in order to like take that
build- a bird action it it like goes in this like tiny little row at the top of the board like an Excel sheet where they forgot to like expand the the I mean I think that kind of comes back to a point I was making a little bit earlier like in wingspan it it feels like most of the decision space is what road do I run on my turn it's my turn what roow do I run oh I could put a bird down whereas in worms span I feel like it's kind of the opposite like it's almost like I'm putting off running rows because you get so much you do so much when you put dragons down like so many dragons give you an immediate effect and every cave gives you an immediate effect so when you start the game you have six actions that you could do in the first out of four rounds you could go many actions without touching any of the rows because you kind of want to make the rows better before you actually run them because you have a limit number of actions and you could just go deeper you could just do so much more because you play a cave that gives you a meat and a gold well cool now you don't have to run your resources row that is is really weak at the beginning of the game it's only going to give you one resource but I put this cave down and suddenly it gives me two like that's even better it just it made the running of the rows almost feel like a special thing like okay now it's time to explore the cave whereas in wingspan it felt like almost every turn it was like okay what row you know it it really shifted that kind of I don't know where my brain was with it and and one way they also shifted it is they limit it in in worms span yeah in wingspan you can activate a row as many
times as you have actions for but in worms span you can't activate a row more than three times in a round and in fact the second time you activate it it costs you an egg which is a victory point and the third time you activate it it costs you two eggs so it really feels like from an incentives perspective the game is is trying to say you know go back into that cave if it makes sense for you but I don't know you're starting to spend a lot of points to actually do that maybe you should f on something else which did feel surprisingly different uh for from a head space perspective yeah and it's not as easy because there's no egg row in in worms span there's no like it's not so easy to get eggs once you get deeper into the cave and you've have more dragons and you've explored more sure you can make lots of eggs but until then you're you're you're going to have a lot harder time finding eggs and I do think that is one Element too at the end of every round you actually do just get an egg which I think is probably something to kind of help kind of keep keep the game moving along in that way yeah yeah since we're talking about the egg row that I think is a really good segue and so I think to me the biggest difference between these two games from a strategic perspective so in wingspan you know it's pretty common that at the end of the game you're like great I'm going to take the egg grow action a whole bunch of times because that's where victory points are having extra resources is having extra cards like those aren't victory points at the end of the game there are some exceptions but mostly you know at the end it's like eggs eggs eggs eggs eggs game over mhm um and as you guys are already mentioning in this game
an egg shows up near to the end of every row and then at the end of every row there's some way to convert that Row's resources into victory points so the food row says all right throw that food on dragons that's victory points the cards row says throw those cards underneath dragons that's victory points the caves row says pitch those caves get some eggs those are victory points so it's essentially set up that if you complete any one of these rows you can jam it at the end of the game for points um but as John said you are limited to only doing it up to three times in the final round of the game and so I think that's a really interesting and clearly deliberate choice to say look you kind of you're not going to be able to just do one thing over and over again so acknowledge that that's going to be part of your game plan but also really no matter what you choose your game plan to be you're going to be rewarded for it later whereas you know you might build a really sick food you know engine in uh wingspan and get to the end of the game be like oh my food engine is dumb I need to do something else well and I think it's really interesting in this game because I actually did I I sort of tried to do the wingspan strategy in the game we play tonight of worms span I filled up my c r and then I had this really cool what I thought was really cool kind of engine going I was running my cave row and at the end of the cave row it's get rid of
caves extra excess get rid of the excess caves that I had in my hand and and make lots of eggs and I was like oh my God I'm going to have so many points and eggs because of course wingspan points and eggs right but apparently dragons don't lay quite as many eggs as birds so I did not have enough room to hold all of the eggs that I was capable of making and I've never had that experience at the end of wingspan I've always felt like oh my gosh you you know to your point Nick just run the egg row eggs eggs eggs but in this game I realized like oh I didn't do enough to create space to be able to do this and it required just as you're going to kind of hear over and over with this game just a little bit more thinking of like oh I need needed to have dragons that had space for that and also because there is actually baby dragons hatchlings they're baby dragons in this game and those hatchlings speaking what John was saying earlier where every C does different things and kind of changes and and has these elements hatchlings play just a little bit differently than the adult dragons and they don't lay eggs because they're babies they eat an egg well they take an egg so exactly so there's a a different element at play yeah actually you know we were talking a little bit uh down about the Thematic integration earlier with the names and everything but there is some pretty fun thematic connections and those hatchlings the game we just played last night
hatchlings were incentivized in the second round you got some last night it's already been a whole night he says two hours well for for me it actually is last night yes and uh so we all had a lot of hatchlings and this is my third play the previous two plays one of them didn't put a single hatchling down the second game I think I had one and I didn't really focus on it this game all three of us really focus on hatchlings in a big way and they actually kind of you feed them so your your Explorer goes into the cave and they kind of wander through the cave they say hey to all the dragons and they give you stuff but every time your Explorer meets a hatchling the hatchling says please feed me meat or please feed me milk and if you feed the hatchling it then it's going to give you a bonus and it's just another way to kind of run your overall engine whilea getting that tie in and when you feed the third thing to the hatchling it thematically grows up and it gives you a a really big bonus like one of my hatchlings let me excavate a card from my hand for free when I gave it its third piece of meat and that was a really impactful play because it meant I didn't have to spend some eggs and whatnot getting back to the mechanics but I thought it was kind of fun like I almost envisioned the Explorer like you know padding the little hatchlings on their head as he like treed through the the the cavern it's like oh I made sure to bring some meat for this one and I made sure to bring some milk for that one yeah the hatchlings are a thematic slam dunk for sure absolutely mechanically they're they're pretty interesting I think there there's definitely some discussion online about like how good they are I'm very curious
I'll have to play more to like get my own sense but you know they allow you to convert your food into points right by putting them on the hashling that they're points and then as you said they they give you like a little thing back so they kind of they they basically filter points they kind of they do have things like that in wingspan I don't think it optically operates the same but I think I think functionally right like putting a resource in you get a point for doing that and then maybe you get some other reward that exists in wingspan too um so the hatchlings are different but they're not as different as i' I think as I've seen people talking about them um except for the growing up part which is which is just a cute little bonus I love yeah yeah and it makes it it does I must admit make the idea at first when you look at a hatchling you're like why would I want to put the time and energy I remember at the beginning because we had a reward for hatchling and hatchlings in this game I think it was at the end of the second round and I was like Nick and John were taking them was like I don't want to be a mom like let's move on I don't want to raise them I don't want to I don't want to give them eggs or milk or deal with them right like because they they need things right like they need it you they don't need it but you know you want to put you want to every time you want your run your row you want want to give them their meat or their milk or whatever it is they want because then they grow up and then they give you this really great bonus and I think that's super fun um and I don't think I even realized until I started to take a few I was like oh they they they take this thing and then as John said they give you something back immediately
so I I remember I was running I was like I was like okay I give you a milk and then you give me a milk back oh okay like there just it was like too much yeah yeah I'm I'm with you like it they they seem kind of like us at first blush cuz you're like do I really want to be paying resources into you right now like that doesn't seem great but they're they are the way to you know if you have the right hatchling it lets you get a resource that you would normally get from a different row right and then convert it yes there's there's a nice little like system there so like I think I think it makes a lot of sense to to build a game plan around what your hatchling situation looks like yeah in this game we just played I I didn't touch the excavate on the bottom until like my second to last action of the entire game and I did that because at the very beginning of the game I put two hatchlings into my draw dragons row then those hatchlings let me get cave cards so right from the very beginning significantly more so than you would ever see in wingspan I customized my draw dragons row to be a draw dragons and draw caves row and I explored that that so many times in this game to the point where it's like I don't even need to go down below to the the get caves row because I have a a cave and dragon row already and and that was just kind of cool to like you know customize these things around and and also there are some themes I I noticed mechanically between the dragons like the dragons that activate in the middle row which is draw dragons like there's some some of them kind of seem like they match up together but there are also a few
dragons and caves that let you swap dragons on your board so that means you can really do some interesting combinations of things like you play a dragon to the middle row cuz that's where it has to go and then you swap it to the top row so suddenly you run your top row and you get some resources and you also get some dragons and then you get some resources and just there's so many little and mediumsized levers all over the place that you can pull to kind of customize this little pop off thing that you're putting together all of the things that we're saying if you've played Wings band like you're going to hear that and you be like oh yeah isn't there that bird that does that kind of like jumps between robes or does this like it takes it takes all of these little cool mechanics that were from wingspan but then does kind of just change them just subtly enough and tweak them into this system where it's like it's not just about oh this bird kind of moves here and here it's just kind of like cranking that up and being like yeah but now you can really like change the way you're constructing the engine that you're creating at the top and the bottom and just kind of I think there's a lot of potential here to really be able to look at the game and be like oh I can really work with with what's in front of me um and have a lot of fun with how that's going to play out mechanically in the game mhm one thing that uh I didn't expect to feel so different was the way actions are actually handled between these two games you know in wingspan if I remember correctly I think you start in the first round you get eight actions to use and it's use it or lose it got to use them the second round it's seven then six then five so as you go deeper into the game you you just there's less things
you can do within that overall round but hypothetically those actions are more impactful because you put Birds down into your rows Etc in worms span it just throws that idea out the window of like de-escalating the number of actions you have every round in the four round game you get six action coins that you can spend and there's a ton of ways to get extra actions uh I I've seen multiple rounds where people take like 9 10 11 12 actions in a single round even though they started with like six or seven because you can get so many more through various different ways and I thought that was kind of interesting design departure you know with the first game like specifically saying near the end of the game your actions are going to be good so you get less of them and here it's just like go wild you know six every single round lot more control and you can pass you can you can pass and just save them and then have 10 actions in a round if you want to you you just have a lot more control over how it's how you use them yeah exactly and it makes the game a bit longer I mean I don't think we're getting there's any getting around that like you just take more actions I actually I haven't done the math going 8765 versus 6666 but it just feels like you do so many more I guess because there's a lot of ways to get bonus well you can get more yeah where wingan it's a fixed amount yeah exactly exactly yeah this is probably my least favorite part about worms span yeah yeah so so first of all I I know that I know the reason that this exists the like 666 versus 8765 is that the
8765 is like a point of complaint for other folks um like they don't like that they get why do I get fewer actions as the game goes on I like it I like that it says like hey you're better at stuff so make it work like I I enjoy that um and I also think that it's really really important that that board games do not get to a state where you have everything fully assembled to me a board game that gets to a state where everything is fully assembled and you are allowed to run your maximum engine more than like one or two times is a game that goes on for way too long and becomes boring and I think most game designers know this and most game players don't know this um another really great example of this is like teram mytica which if you've listen to other podcast game that I really love but people are like w six turns I don't get to like get everything out it's like once you have everything out there is no game left to play so just like it is about the Journey of building up to that and the challenge of like that push and pull I think the same is true um for for the the span Style game games in worms span the fact that it's it's not the fact that it's 666 like I I like that it's 8765 so that was the first my first point of Defense in worms ban the 666 thing is fine the part that I don't like is that you can get the extra turns by getting the coins or saving things and so the downtime of
like some of these rounds yeah becomes I I think to the point of being painful at points like you know if what happened in this like game that we played tonight is that John had more actions in the second round of the game than Anastasia and I did and then Anastasia and I had more games more actions than John down the third round and it was like he literally got up left the game for like for over five minutes no I actually came back and missed nothing I I it was 20 minutes between between me passing and me me finally like okay the you came back and we weren't done yeah yeah it's because I personally I checked it I had taken 12 actions not six in the third round right and it and there's nothing that that that like component of like The Irregular turns between players is is a little too much in this game for me I think that it just it creates these these situations where folks can like really slow down and uh the downtime thing is is already a problem in wingspan and worm span for me like it's not that the games are too long it's just that like because the games are on the multiplayer solitire side and I'm I'm just saying that as a fact not as a burn um they there's not a ton for me to do on other people's turns and and speaking of the downtime it's not just from oh there's a lot of turns like we've talked a lot about running rows and again Anastasia and I played worms span and wingspan in
the same day and I was almost shocked when we played wingspan later on that day at how fast you run those bird rows so fast there's birds on there that do things as you go down it might be like draw two cards and then discard one or you know get an extra food or everybody gets a food from the bird feeder but it was pretty Breezy to get through these and frequently once you get your cave even to the halfway point are on there's so many steps you do so many things I remember in my very first play of this one uh my friend Dave it felt like he had done 10 things and he had gone two steps in his cave because this is a very combo game way way way more than wingspan like he went onto a thing that let him uh draw an an excavate a cave from the top of the deck that card that he drew just happened to let him activate the placement bonus of a dragon he had already put down okay now he has to look at all his dragons oh this placement lets me draw and excavate a card from the top of the deck so he does that again and it just went on and on and at one point I was just like are you really not done he's like oh I've got like five more things to do and that was one one turn right that was one coin that was one one single turn exactly like there's all these like tangential combo blowups that you can do which is fun when you're the person doing it well fun with a side of uh guilt like it almost like sorry sorry everybody I just gonna do this this and'll take a food you know I'll figure out what the food is later sorry then I'm going to go here I'm going to draw a dragon I'm just going to draw a random so I don't have to look at like because
you almost feel guilty the amount of time that you're taking like I'm not even going to look at the face up dragons I'll just draw random to so that you know I could get through this process so that next person can likely do the same exact thing you know in the mid to late stages of the game well when you think about it it's what you said Nick it's like you it's it is multiplayer solitire but where the the the interaction is is in the cards that are available the caves that are available and the dragons that are available so you can only plot so much because sure maybe I'm going to draw three caves you know when I run my bottom row but I can't figure that out until John's taking his turn and Nick's taking his turn and now now I can run my row well the caves could have changed you know while I was wait so there so you start doing this and I remember multiple times this evening I was like okay so I'm going to need to take three caves but actually in the middle I have to discard a cave and so I was like looking at the cave around I was like okay wait so I got to figure out the cave now because I don't want to take the cave I want I have to take a cave I don't want because I'm going to have to discard that cave because discarding that cave is going to have me move on the dragon Guild and then I'll get to draw another cave and then so I need to make sure the cave that I want is still there like it's you can't even condense it down and I get three caves I have to get rid of one because the the order of these things actually does matter and so it it does create these really lengthy chains and you know it's like a lot of Euros these days if you're used to playing games where you have these big comboy pop off turns and you're like
waiting for people to do all their stuff you're you know this is going to feel familiar in that way mhm yeah I think that for me the ideal would be someone figuring out a way to make this style of game allow players to play simultaneously like yeah it's it doesn't work because there's a public card row that you can draw from and that's that's the thing that really mitigates it but like in our last round of this game we were like all right well we're not drawing more dragons all of us have our caves all in play so no one's drawing more caves and it was just like you run your row you run your row you run your row you run your row you run your row there was there wasn't the same like navigation of what do I pick up what do I put down um and then in wingspan the problem is they have like a couple birds that interact with people just enough birds that interact with people in between turns that like you can't just kind of like overlap turns with each other and someone needs to figure out a way to make this system let everybody play at the same time because if we could play this game in 35 minutes that would be amazing yeah before we move off off of what do we going to call this the the action coin the number of actions that you get per round the that that action count yeah the action count yeah I do want to say a little something kind of in defense of it um because I I hear you Nick and I hear what you're saying about you know having all those actions and then being able to get more of them and and and the thing is like there is something really satisfying and fun
about that especially in this game where where there is you know so much popping off and different things you can do it is it is really great to be like cool I I can get another action coin by doing this and then I could I could do a little bit more and so you you it really feels more open and free than it does in wingspan where suddenly you're like okay I only have you know five actions this round so like this is all I can do like I do actually really like that I like that you can do that um obviously it has its downsides here in terms of how many actions different players can get but you know I also like the way that the dragons there are dragons that basically eat those action coins I guess I thematically it's probably you have to spend more time with them training them whatever but it also is a nice way to balance out some of the really powerful dragons and I think that's really cool too especially early on like in our the first game that John and I played he had two dragons in his initial hand that both needed to eat these actions and so he somehow managed to get them both down I'm I'm telling this correctly right yeah got a both down in the first round that's all I did exactly that's all he did he he you know he starts with six actions and he uses you know essentially four of them to get these two dragons out but they were so powerful and they worked so well for him all game but you know he he he ate a lot of action flexibility by doing that and I think I think that that is really interesting um
but the last thing that I'll say on this is that in that first play the coins having the six actions and having that flexibility to pass and then wait for the second round and then build and finally everything kind of came together for me in the third round but being able to kind of save my actions to then have my game play out the way I wanted it to play out in the third and fourth round let me play a game where I was able to build and then kind of get everything to kind of come together and you can't do that in wingspan you don't have that flexibility so that was my very long-winded way of saying that I I really like the the flexibility and the control that having the the the kind of like you're going to get 24 actions in this game we're going to give you six each round and you're going to you can get more you're you're probably definitely going to get more but you get to control how and when you use those 24 actions over the course of these four rounds with obviously the limitation of of only getting refilling six I really like that I think that I think it's I I I really like that and so for me it's an improvement for sure you talked a lot about control in that last session there and there's something that I've kind of been really wanting to bring up as far as comparing these two games and that is Randomness uh we have a big deck of cards in both of these games that's you know functionally similar as far as I can tell but in wingspan you roll dice to get resources as opposed to just getting the resources that you generally want and as you mentioned in wingspan
there are these goals that you start the game with you get two of them you choose one there are birds that you can play that give you more of these hidden goals you can get lucky with those and you can get really unlucky you can play a bird in the middle of the game and get a goal that's going to give you a pile of points or maybe it's just nothing and it was a very this is a very stark contrast for me because the day we played worms Span in the morning and wingspan in the afternoon when we played wingspan I picked up a goal and in the bottom it told me 11% of the cards match this goal it was the the birds that are named after people like you know Anna's Sparrow or something like that and I was like cool 11% of the cards are like this and we proceeded to go the whole game I literally never had a single card that was named after somebody in my hand and I literally never saw one of those cards in the display it became a joke like we're just laughing you know I kept drawing blind and just laughing as I proceeded to never draw these cards you know I probably Drew 30 40 cards and I never you had to a card and you could not see and I think I lost that game to you by a handful of points and I remember feeling like I'm not like beating myself up or about it or even mad at the game but I just remember sitting there thinking like I'm so glad this isn't in worms span you know that kind of that thing where you're just like okay I have a goal and then it just it doesn't you just have to get lucky and and it was just it was almost like a humorous anecdote to really highlight that one particular difference between these games yeah I mean in terms
of the the variance is obviously the bonus cards from wingspan are are very variable just in terms of like how accessible they are and what you can draw to to make that happen um I don't find that I mind the bird feeder die rolling thing as much as other people do in wingspan I think because it's it's very it's like a known quantity like what things are out there and what things are not out there so I kind of it's it it like responds to the game State and like you're required to respond to the game state so I don't think I mind it quite as much as other obviously you can get really hosed by it but the the core variance for both games is what cards you draw off the deck so to me I think that the it feels like they're both equally wild in that way and I'm okay with that because I think it's part of the design yeah I guess my point is just you don't act have a second set of luck on the luck that you have drawing already yeah but also there's also a ton of dragons that give you points at the end of the game and it's very possible to only draw end game dragons that aren't good for you so yeah yeah but they that is a change right like the dragons themselves now provide those endgame points so you get to choose more as you're playing the game and you also might not find them like I I didn't actually in this last play I could barely find any I was like I need to find some of these you know to come out of come out of the deck but you know to touch on that the bird feeder I think there is something again and you know I really want to give credit to both of
these games for the little thematic elements like there is something so fun about like you roll the food Dice and then you're forging for food and it's like what food is available to you right like it's not just like oh I can have anything and it for me in wingspan I think it ties in really well it annoys me because you know you can get really hosed right like you can't get what you need or you know speaking of interaction you know honestly in a way it's some of the the it's a lot more blatant interaction with the bird feeder with the other players than there is even with the card rast I could remember frequent swearing from you every time I took a die from that bird feeder like and you talk about the hate drafting you could do like you have the choice you're like do I take the one with two food or the other one well it doesn't matter to me but it's worth for John I mean like every for us in that one play it was like constantly being like I better take this because the other one's just way better for John so there is even like straight up hate drafting in the ice right like and that's just a component of how the Food Works in wingspan so I I really like seeing it lifted here honestly just because it's fresh like it's it's fun to be like oh I don't I can get any food I want but it also adds some AP like there was quite a bit you know when it's random you take what you can get right and now there is a lot more of like what do I need and the plotting and the thing I mean this last round of the game I remember I had all my action coin Co
laid out you know I had like I think I had seven of them or something I had them all laid out and then under e each one I had laid out the resources I needed with like little gaps for the ones I had to get from the previous resources I mean I literally had like a map of like how I was going to like play this I was like convert this into this and then put it here and here and you know the my ability to do that is because there's no bird feeder there's no there's no random dice rolls of food right like I can know what I'm going to be able to take and and how I'm going to be able to do that and you know for this game I think it works really well yeah yeah can we talk about the dragon Guild yeah right absolutely yeah the board Nick very much like he the dragon Guild and really I I can't believe I'm saying that because it's so basic like the dragon Guild is literally a track that you can advance on all your rows can advance you on it if you have at least one dragon in play and it just gives you a reward and the rewards are like a cycle of it's basically a picture of all the different rewards you can get in the game and you bump into them you make no choices you just bump into it the next one that comes up is there and I think I really like it for two reasons one is the game acknowledges that it's a game about needing to have everything right like it's like yep there's all this stuff here and there's this track and it gives you the stuff that's there you don't get to choose what order you get it in but it's all there so you can get your things here and the reason I really like it is because you're like oh I'm really
good at getting food and I'm really good at drawing cards but I'm crap at getting cave cards and then all of a sudden you're like and the dragon killed it gives me a cave card it solved a problem that I didn't have a way of solving and like that the like the like occasional like dopamine drip of like I have bumped into the thing that I needed is just I just really liked that a lot for a thing that has literally go up this track yeah yeah I it does a lot of heavy lifting for me yeah and this is you know we've been comparing wingspan and worm span a whole bunch this is just totally new like not like to this game yeah like you there's really nothing to compare between them so like when you say oh there's more going on in worms fan I think I I usually see the dragon Guild in my head pop up and I have to agree I I really like it as well it's like you are you exploring the caves and then boom Dragon Guild happens sometimes times it causes the game to go a little longer because it's like oh surprise you get to draw a dragon okay hold on a second I didn't realize I was going to draw a dragon let me take a look at the dragons over there but on top of that every time you reach the halfway point on this circular track you get to put a cube onto a menu of bonuses and there's four different quote unquote menus there's four different guilds in the game uh I think we had the highlands Guild today and there Dragon guilds so yeah and there was Plaines Guild and there's just a bunch of these and I've seen I've actually played with three of the four now and that not only adds um
some variability from one game to the next because they have different ways to score conditional points um but you also getting each other's way like the one that we had tonight there was one spot that said you get a point for every cave that you add onto your board that was essentially The Cave Dragon Guild and I got there first and I got nine points out of it it was great and I remember the stage she was really bummed she was right behind me so it adds also another moment of tension like yeah you're getting all these bennies and then every halfway around it's like oh what can I take to stop other people from taking it I also really like the dragon Guild board for the same reasons you do Nick like having this Dragon Guild is just this like little extra thing that you get to do and it's in every row I think that's an important distinction we were talking this whole episode about how the rows are a little bit different you know every row has its thing so you know and it's it's food dragons caves right but that's the First Column and then the next column is mov move on the dragon Guild so if you just have one Dragon you get to do both of those things you get to do the thing of the row and you get to move on the dragon Guild and then the following one just following column repeats the first one right so it's just this little change that's in every single row but it it it makes a difference because of what we've been talking about the dragon Guild is all sorts of different things sometimes it's a resource sometimes it's a dragon sometimes it's a cave sometimes it's an extra action coin you know so it it it creates just that little little another place of that injection of kind of like
fun and pop off and just kind of a little bit of a difference thing the thing that I'm not as enamored with I will say is the guilds themselves I love the variability of the four guilds what I think that those guilds add though is a decision Point that's really a little bit difficult for me for my brain it's like it it's it's an interesting one it's do you want points or do you want a big action right but you have to stop and EV valate that and there's multiple options and and and the spots are also like it adds in this layer of well do if I don't take it then am I leaving it for John or am I leaving it for Nick and I remember in our two-player game the you know was my first play I sat there for a couple of minutes trying to calculate out whether I should take the six points because there's a like a just a straight victory points which is kind of boring but like it's there and so you're like well should I leave these six points on the table or should I go take this this spot that gives me an extra action token and a couple of other benefits right and I I like I had to sit there and then suddenly my brain went into this whole other space of like trying to calculate the value of of of everything I was like well if I take this action but then I'll have to spend eggs and eggs are points and like you can easily lose yourself in this game and frankly in wingspan but in this game in particular because you have to spend eggs to keep exploring your rows it's very easy to be like to get kind of get lost in that calcul of what am I spending points on and doing points on and what am I giving up and and to have
that added layer here it that that is just like the one AP I didn't need in this game and I'm sure that will get easier as I play it more but that that that part I'm just not quite as uh over the moon on so I'm curious Nick you've played this once once did you like it as we were playing I just I could not figure it out from the tone of voice and stuff yeah no I was really serious when we were playing but I think it's because I it's just it was just my first play and it was it was I was just crunching and trying to like keep up I also uh I'm not good at multiplayer solitire in the sense of like I'm just going to pay attention to myself like I want to see what other people are doing too so I was trying to figure out my stuff while also figuring out what you guys were doing so I think that's a more reflection of my brain Cycles running than than anything else um yeah no I did like it I think I think it's really interesting the the question I want to ask which we can segue into in a minute is if you like wingspan will you like worms span and it I'm I'm really grappling with that because I think worms span is the game that I wish wingspan was when it came out because when w wingspan first came out I was like this game's not for me it's not heavy enough even when I was playing testing I was like I'm happy to play test this but like this isn't a Nick game like I'm not I'm not like
invested in it and the more I've played it the more I've come to like it and in particular I've come to like it for what it is and what it does and who it appeals to um and that's something that I've really come to respect about wingspan it has frankly taught me a lot about what board gamers consume and what what people are into right the fact that that game like absolutely exploded is something really to pay attention to and think about um so worms band is definitely closer to the the style of game that I want to play uh I think though be because wingspan is more buttery smooth on on after first play my instinct is that I like The Buttery smoothness of wingspan a little bit more even though worm span is certainly more satisfying to sink my teeth into um just the the the the like crunch there is obviously nicer um for me so I yeah I liked that and I I liked I liked exploring the changes I'm looking forward to playing worms band some more I'll certainly be playing wingspan some more I think that the thing I'm struggling most with worms span now is I'm asking myself the question of when am I going to choose to play this game um and I think that's more a reflection of like me struggling these days with what does what do medium mediumweight gaming um do like do I want to be playing like I know when I want to play light games and who I want to play light games with and I know when I want to play Heavy games and who I want to play Heavy games with so I'm I'm stuck with this question of like when am I playing
Medium games I think worms span sits Square in that spot right there that's really interesting I feel very similar to Nick I think on this one I I'm actually just trying to sit here and try to answer the question you're asking if if someone likes wingspan will they like worm span and you know honestly for me I think it really goes down to why do you like wingspan I've never looked at wingspan and thought wow I just I love the mechanics of that game that's why I go play it because that's not why I go play it I think I I do kind of love it for what it is which is a game that you know I want to share with people because of the theme and so for me it was kind of an interesting thing to be like when you guys first brought up worms fan I was like I don't know why I would want to play a re theme of wingspan wingspan is the perfect theme but it's not a rethe of wing Wing band it is it is a different game it is an evolution it's I don't even know if you can say that it's just a reimagining with with the same core concept but done as a gamer's game and that's really fun to me and that was it's been really satisfying to play and I think that's really cool and I think there is room for both and I think it's kind of almost a disservice to both to to place them in direct comparison with each other frankly agreed I think where I've landed is that if you have not somehow not played either of these games and you are a gamer you should probably try wi span yeah and if you haven't played out of these games and you're not a gamer or
you're new to gaming you should play wingspan yeah or you're sharing this with someone who's not a gamer you should still play wingspan don't don't take them worms span yeah I agree I mean Nick you said you know if you like wingspan will you like worms ban my take is if you love wingspan I'm not sure if worm span's going to be for you if you liked wingspan but it didn't really scratch the itch hard enough then I think worm fan could be significantly more likely to to hit I mean that is essentially me and a nutshell I love that statement that's I think that's really I think that's super on like I the first time I played wingspan I was like this is such a cool game and the second time I played wingspan I was like this is fun and then I played it a third time and then I sold it I just I I pretty quickly realized it didn't have the kind of crunch I was looking for and I got to be honest I've really enjoyed all three of my plays of wors fan like way more than I expected because I was going into it from well you know wingspan was it's a very good game but it's not really for me and this one like I don't even generally like pop off games because of the downtime and but I just really like the heads space of piecing together of the Combos and I guess it's hard to really put my finger on it but for me as somebody who enjoys well kind of the gamut of games I I I generally like medium to heavier games on average than lighter games but I I felt just a lot of Joy like I'm just happy when I'm playing this game I'm really happy with the decisions as opposed to being frustrated by the restrictions that the gameer is throwing my way and I think when I think about
myself and wingspan I I want more buttons to press more levers and all that kind of stuff and worms span just adds those in so yeah I mean for me I I would happily not play wingspan ever again I have to be honest like if somebody really wanted to I would we played it last weekend and I was really happy to play it for the comparison point but spent the entire time thinking this is so much less interesting than worms span the whole time I was just like I I would just I would I would definitely rather be playing worms span I'm mostly doing this for research purposes because I hadn't played it in so long but you know that that's again not me sliding the other game that's just purely a preference thing and I think it's cool I think it's cool that there is a span game for me I guess yeah yeah I mean and I think it speaks also to you really have to ask yourself to you know I think we all have to ask ourselves this with this particular h HBY like what does a game mean to you is a game something that you need to have and play 10 times and and and and become an expert in and want to you know how much depth do you need the game to have or is the game something you're going to play a couple of times or is a game that's on your shelf because it is a great game to share it's a great game to that that's why I still own wingspan is because it's just it's it's such a good Gateway game it's it's just such so accessible to so many people right but I'm with John like I'm not looking to go play wingspan a bunch of times because I feel like I've seen everything that the game has to offer as a gamer but I love sharing it with people and I I still love you I've
got all these pieces and I was telling John my copy's all tricked out and I I love it and I should add and I think this is a caveat that I I just personally want to add I have only played with one of the expansions and I have a couple of them and I and this you know this whole episode at least my opinions in it are based on not having explored more of those expansions which I do think add in more elements that that that turn the game into turn wingspan into more of a gamer's game so Anastasia do you like worms fan like you talked about what people might like it but I'm just curious about where you land after two plays I like it quite a bit actually I I don't know if it's a game I need to own I don't know if it's a game because I'm kind of with Nick right now where I don't know where midweight gaming Falls for me anymore um and so it's it's really interesting for me to have only played this twice and and to be sitting here kind of giving our Impressions to everyone I the first play of this I tried to play it like wingspan and it kind of fell on my face a little bit and then it kind of came together but I was sitting there watching JN have these crazy turns and and frankly I mean I was happy for JN but I wasn't really happy for myself it wasn't as fun to watch you know him uh you know do this when when I couldn't seem to get anything to kind of come together which for me makes this a game that is you know it does take a play or two to kind of figure out what the game is and I remember finishing that game and being like okay we need to play this
again because now I understand it now I can see the potential there and then you know we played it uh tonight and I had a lot of fun with it again but now I feel like I see more of it now now it's kind of unfolding I'm actually really curious to see how how it does feel after five or six plays or something cuz I will say in our last play tonight one thing I think Nick you point out something really interesting in our conversation tonight about how you don't like it when a game you can kind of do everything in a game you kind of feel like you know sometimes it's nice to have the game end before you feel like you can maximize it tonight I I had an extra action token and and I didn't I didn't love that you know and I had no more spaces to put things and I so I'm I'm curious to see how this one kind of balances out as I get better at it as the people I'm playing with get better at it as as things happen I'm I'm very curious to see H how this one keeps playing because it's it's had a couple of rough edges in in in in my first two plays but it's also had a lot of really fun things to explore so so yeah so curious well my mom bought a copy and she loves wingspan and is is a gamer so I'm sure I'll be playing this one a bunch more nice well that was uh it was fun these comparison episodes are are are cool to kind of dig into um like going back and forth between various topics like this is something that we haven't really done a lot of and uh it's it feels fresh to me anyway I'm enjoying it
yeah yeah and uh congratulations to whoever puts in the comments how many times we said Birds when we meant dragons and Dragons we Birds yes yeah many many times so yeah that's going to bring this one to a close uh as always we would love to hear what you to say about this uh this game and this episode you can find a link to the YouTube version of this one in the description and you can leave comments over there we love to see that we' love to answer those and yeah thanks for listening by thank you