Agricola vs. Grand Austria Hotel: Which Is Better?
Transcript
hi everyone I'm tally this is Farrell and we are Bor of it and today we're going to be doing something a little bit different we're going to be having a debate and that debate is which is better agrica or grand Austria hotel and this is because these are both older games that we've only discovered or started playing in the last like month or two yeah and we're both incredibly en numbered with them me more with a tell more with grand Austria Hotel so because there is a reasonable amount of similarities between them we thought it'd be good debate and we would argue about which is better and then you can vote down in the comments below oh I didn't know that was a part of it and say who is correct because someone is correct it's me no agria is way better so spoiler alert to this debate well we both know who which side we're on but yeah we're just thinking you know they're both a bit older games they both kind of feel older in a lot of ways uh and they both have some similarities where with agria it's it's a very straightforward worker placement game that is kind of altered each time you play by different cards so you have worker cards and you have Improvement cards and these will really shake up how each game plays and how the game feels and what you do whereas while Grand
industrial hotel isn't a work placement game you are kind of taking Dice and it's similar in a way where you know you're taking dice to do specific actions which is kind of the inverse of putting a worker on a space so it feels similar in some ways and importantly there are cards as well that will really alter how you play the game so they do have some very similar Vibes they're actually I think both kind of very close together on the Board Game Geek top 100 so we will just get into it and debate so why don't you start by just saying a little bit about what Grand Austria hotel is and the theme yes so you are guess running a hotel and you have some very prestigious guests in your hotel in your hotel Cafe and you have some staff members which are the cards that you are referring to which are going to kind of give you little bonuses and help you along the way you're basically turnto turn if you have space which you have three spaces for guests in your Cafe take a guest which when you complete their order by sending them was it strudel cake wine coffee uh you will kind of complete their order they come out of your Cafe and give you a little bonus and then they will go to one of your very lovely rooms in your hotel and then that room is then occupied so it's all about you know going up there like an emperor track uh getting little bonuses along the way obviously the more hotel rooms that you occupy the better
that's going to be for scoring but you're going to be kind of scoring along the way the guests whose order you feel are going to give you points as well and so yeah that's basically the gist of it and uh should I say why I really like it now let's go into so I'll just explain a little bit about griin theme so in a grica as I said is a work placement game pretty straightforward uh and what you're doing is you're a 17th century sustenance farmer so you start with two workers and kind of an empty player board and the gold game is to build up and basically everything you could do gets you points and if you haven't done it it usually will cost you a point so you can build pastures and keep animals in them there's different type of animals so you want you know at least one of every type of animal ideally more cuz generally the more you have something the more you score you can plow fields and plant grains and vegetables again the more you have the more points you get and if you don't have them you get Negative you can upgrade your house to make it more valuable you can build more rooms which allow you to get more people and more workers and yeah the the one of the the core things is that you have these improvements and you have occupations and both of these give you ways to manipulate the game like every time you go to this space get this or you know as a onetime thing get this stuff and
there's a lot of these different types of cards and they're kind of you know randomly dealt out and you can draft if you want that variant but they really do shake up how you play because you have to carve out a niche for yourself with these cards because if you don't lean into them then you're playing a very tough game by just kind of taking the work placement space is straight y so yeah so why didn't you start with what you like about Grand Austria Hotel yeah okay I guess important to preference that we both really like both games like I really do like agrica but I just have a preference for Grand Austria Hotel so I think for me I just think the theme is more fun than 17th century sorry I knowe I know that you love 17th century sustenance farming it's all I've heard about for the since we started playing it hotelier is boring boring thing no I really like it maybe because it's reminiscent of grand B pest hotel that's the number one thing one of my favorite films although yeah I think uh people have recommended it based on that but you know it's not really anything to do with it it's just I guess has some kind of Link um but yeah I think for me I prefer it because it's more open I think there's more options within the game personally there's so many guest cards each one's giving like some different bonuses or different combinations of bonuses every time so Define what you mean by open uh I I felt like when I
have played AG gri I I maybe this is just me and maybe it's why I don't win but I found myself going through the same motions a little bit this is interesting because this is literally the exact reverse of how I feel but I think AG Grio like I think AG Grio is more different and interesting on a given play than Grand Austria hotel is cuz I feel like Grand Austria hotel is always like I mean the main point of interest is the staff cards which really shake up what you can do and bonuses you get uh so I think those are great but generally playing it's like you need to be going up the emperor track because otherwise you get Negative penalties you need to go towards the goals of which there isn't that many you need to fill the rooms and it kind of goes into a rhythm that's similar each time but how you do that I think is quite different so the emper track you could do that by filling up and occupying all of the yellow rooms and give yourself like a boost and move forward on the emper track cuz basically if you're not familiar uh it's three times in the game kind of every other round when it gets to the end of the game right well it's like third fifth seven and there seven rounds um the emperor will come and evaluate I guess and if you haven't made it uh far enough up the track then you'll get bumped back down and you won't get the emperor bonus and you might even get something negative happened to you but there's just various
ways for me that you can go up that track so yeah by filling up the yellow rooms and occupying them you could go down the route of using a staff member who maybe every time you do action a will give you you know an option to go up the track you could use the guest cards as well so for me I think it just gives a bit more options you're doing the same thing every time but how you do it I think is quite different whereas for me in Agricola I don't find the uh occupation cards like that different from each other I think they're all I don't know doing yeah of course the way what's written on them is is different but I think it's just because you're trying to fill up the farm all of the time there's only like limited ways to do that it's like build a pasture build fields I think for me it's just because it's quite tight so I feel like I go through the same motions because I don't have the breathing room to expand out and maybe like try different things this is why we're having this debate you're not right I can have my own now you're looking at me um yeah I just think um I with grand Austria Hotel you obviously score much bigger you're like always getting points as well yeah oh my God you're so annoying um you got so salty the other day when I was winning this and you said that you never wanted to play it again so like don't even test me that is true um but you didn't love me yeah that's a Fleek you said you got
lucky um put me off now I'm enraged thinking about the game that we played earlier today it was very annoying and maybe I was going to change my mind and this video wouldn't happen I hate this game so annoying well um but yeah I just find it uh more satisfying to kind of be getting points as you go along whereas with agrica you just score up at the end um and it's obviously like much lower scoring and like the difference between the points I think is like less games a game because some things might only give you like one or two points at the end of the game that we played today I was weighing up do I do this or this it's like okay that's going to get me one point that's going to get me two points it's just like smaller to me uh which is why I like to yeah I just think Grand Austria hotel is my preference because it's just more open and flowing in my opinion one thing so yeah I guess youve talking about I really like agria because I I really like I mean we both do like mean tyght games and AG gria is is a bit mean it's very tight and I really like the element of it where even though it's work placement you know you are you kind of at minimum you have battle for space mhm and I think that's very interesting and very tight where are they going to go what are they doing can they do their space can I leave it till later uh and I I really I think it's one of the best examples of worker placement what I also
find really interesting really like about arria is it does so much for like an older game relatively that you don't really see that much like I'm surprised not like it's not things on AP it more like having the spaces where the resources stack up until you take them having new spaces revealed every single round and expanding the options available I think those are really interesting things you don't often see and they really they make it actually feel quite novel coming to it now than everything else that's doing the same thing over and over yeah one thing okay what about this as a question as which is better M don't you find that gria is much more it is much smoother and much better at providing you information than Grand Austria hotel is like we play Grand Australia Hotel seven times and the iconography is such that we often still have to check in the rule book what the staff cards do what the guest cards do because there's such a variety for the symbologies not quite there whereas in agrica because it's like text and because symbology is much better we don't have to reference the rules almost ever then you think that's Superior in agrica no I like in Grand D
Hotel it doesn't really bother me to have to check the rules I prefer that there's more options right like again because there's like so much variety that's why we haven't maybe got to grips with it yet and for me that's why I like it because I just think there's like more it's like in agrica the cards might be get one wood oh get one clay it's the same I think I think you're severely underselling what the cards do yeah maybe I think you really I think the cards are incredibly interesting okay that's really s yeah no I disagree but I think I'm not saying they're not interesting but I just think they're all much of a muchness in a way I think one thing I prefer and this is like a small thing it's not really happened except maybe once in Grand Austria hotel but what I like in agria is that all the cards are generally focused on carving out your Niche and finding a way to gain the system and kind of hammer that in whereas in Grand austri Hotel you can get endgame scoring cards and cards that help you in the game and I mean if you do the drafting variant then it's probably like less bad but in our first couple of games we were just dealing them out and one of the issues can be because it's random you can get a hand of cards that's almost entirely endgame scoring cards yeah and then you had disadvantage because you need those non-end game scoring cards to carve out a little Gap in a similar way to agria yeah I just F yeah I just find like the
game we played today for instance I didn't have anything to do in the end cuz I'd filled up the farm the pastures were full of animals and then had nothing else I could do that was meaningful like I said I could get maybe one more Point by doing a major Improvement or something okay I don't know it's like it's less interesting to be weighing up a decision do I get one point or two points or like but isn't that a bit the same it can be in the final of grand UST hotel where if you're not going to take cuz any guest say you haven't putting your rooms at the end of the game are negative so and a lot of the drive is kind of getting the resources to feed and water the guests before putting them in their rooms so it can be you know in the last round where if you're not going to take someone cuz you know you can't build them then you're just like okay well like you're just kind of similar yeah I suppose so I think sometimes it can and sometimes it can't in both games I think it's just the consistent progression maybe that's the wrong way to say it but because you're always getting these little bonuses is in Grand Austria Hotel whereas yeah gria just is more tight and it all comes down to like the final scoring which usually I like to be fair usually we like games where you don't know how the other person's doing and then you score up at the end and it's a bit more of a surprise but I think you can have more epic turns maybe
and obviously you don't get that in agricol because it is all about like building everything up and then you score it at the end no I do agree that there is you do if you like comboing Grand Austria hotel is much better you know you can have three guests which is maximum you can have and maybe like two runs when you start your turn and then you're like okay well I complete this guest flip him get some points he lets me build a room for free so now I have a room so now I can put this like red person in that red room I just buil and then that gives me some money so now I can take this action and you do have these really interesting turns where you kind of explode out and do from a basic turn is picking a single die and uh just doing the action which might be like get some food right into like a really big turn where you're doing a lot so that's quite interesting exactly um do you think that with grand Austria Hotel the how do you feel about the turn order thing I think that's one of the negatives for me that Agricola is back and forth you take your turn you move on whereas Grand Austria hotel has a yeah in a two-play game the first player goes then the second player goes twice then the first player goes again yeah and what it means in principle is because sometimes you do have to think quite a bit about what you can do and how you can kind of make
those combos we said it can be that the first player goes and then the second player is just like there for about 5 to 10 minutes like doing both of their turns back to back and then you come back to yours and that's a bit and this is why actually so it's not the biggest problem but I think in a Fourplay game the first player actually goes first and last so that's one of the things why people say it's one of the games that's best at two players because if you're playing with four your downtime can be enormous if you like first that's fair enough yeah I don't I've never even thought about that I think it's interesting I think it's more interesting than anything as the first player to think about the optimal order to do things knowing that the other player is going to get two turns um and then equally the player who goes second and then third back to back you obviously don't get to go first but then you get that obviously bonus of doing things back to back and then you get more space again to start comboing different things okay I'll do this in my second term because that means I can do that in the third term I think particularly annoyed me today with ag gria you have to go you have to waste a worker to get the first player marker because it doesn't go back and well you also get to put an occupation down yeah but I don't think that's if youve only got two workers every round for probably the first half of the game I don't think
that's worth it and I I wanted to go first a lot but I just didn't have the room to go to that space yeah and then you just went first the entire game so I don't know it's a bit annoying I much prefer the mechanism Grand Austria hotel where it's like back and forth so you get a chance to go like equally yeah I mean I kind of agree but at the same time I think you do get to put down an occupation which is one of these cards so if you have like a good one to put down it's kind of like a bonus to get the first player marker yeah someone could just take it back uh next turn and then next round at least yeah whereas obviously it's just a consistent way of doing it in Grand austri hotel which is yeah yeah I just prefer that I think yeah to be fair I think it's a weird one with G industrial Hotel because I actually think I prefer the the second and third turns being together because you know that the other player can't interfere so you can really look at what there and be like I can do this and do that like you said was I think it's actually more annoying to be first because it's very rare that being like going first matters so much because you know a place might have two or three Di and you can always paay to kind of boost the number and it only really matters say if there's like one die there yeah so it doesn't matter but then you have to like wait and I find that more annoying actually so that's quite interesting
um but yeah I know I see your point with the with yeah the back and forth of a always being first but I think yeah I I just really like how the action spaces expand over time and you have like more options and that that bite point of you have the spaces that accumulate resources and it is one of these things where it's like I don't want to go there now because there's only two clay I can't do anything with two clay the next turn has three clay now you can do something with that and then it's like oh should I go there now should I wait and then if like tally goes it's like oh no well I'm not doing clay now I have to figure out something else yeah I find that really interesting as back and forth yeah it is is pretty brutal actually cuz it is so yeah so tight okay so why don't we wrap up by saying something that we like about the other game okay really apprciate I like the little pigs I mean about gang specific uh I like no like you said before we do we appreciate mean mean type games and obviously it is interesting to try and figure out and pivot all the time what you're having to do because you are so dependent on the worker placement spaces and where where the other person goes so
obviously that is an interesting challenge where you can have a plan in your mind but then you just go take the space and you've got to you got to Pivot so I think it's an interesting challenge because it is so tip for me with Grand austrial Hotel I really like I mean the main thing I really like is this uh combination of the staff cards and the guest cards because the staff cards kind of give you maybe like bonus actions or improve actions or things like that and the the guest cards give you little bonus bonuses when you complete them usually or I think almost always but the the power of the bonus is kind of if they also give you victory points related to that and I I just really enjoy the combination of both those and getting your staff in play and then being like okay I'm really good at getting food now so let's look out for guests that get food and then you're like okay I can do this guest and then they give me this good bonus and linking these bonuses and like extra actions together and I think that's really cool uh yeah but as we say we both enjoy very much both games a lot I think they're terrific just agria is better no Grand Hotel is better I think I could win this one in the comments let's name g is Og man so Grand austrial Hotel famously I think no I think it's actually not that old well OG doesn't mean
Old Well it can't be it can't be game is that what it means yes then yes it's the OG yes no but it can't be OG if it's only like 3 years old 5 years all I think I disagree but there we have it we can agree to disagree unfortunately but the good thing is that we enjoy playing both of them yes so so yeah just I think just do a little summary so agria it's if you like work placement I think prob clearly it's one of the best that's why it has longevity and popularity I I think it's brilliant with some of the stuff it does and I'm surprised that more games now don't ha what it does you know the expanding spaces the brutality of the worker placement the fact that you kind of build up something and you you grow from nothing into like a really populated little area and you can look look back and be proud of all that you've done yeah yeah I just think it's it's it's really great and it it's one of these games that is like simplistic to play but very mean but also a lot of weighty decisions Grand Austria hotel has a far superior theme that's more fun than sustenance farming none sustenance farming is the ultimate thing it is a game that maybe you like if you kind of like to get that buzz it reminds me a little bit similar not as brutal but like Prager or something like that you're always getting the little bonuses
you're always moving tracks I mean your classic Euro things really uh but like you said I think where it shines is really the comboing of your staff cards and the bonuses that you get from your guests to really move your little like kind of engine forward in a way and yeah it just for me very satisfying to work out how to best combo it and to be always getting the little bonuses and I do think the emper track even though it's sometimes a bit annoying it always have to consider it it is it is quite interesting it's it's more spicy there's a little bit of spice thrown in because you could you know get a negative if you don't go up it so you always got to consider okay I'm just want to serve my guests get the points out from them but I do need to be going up on the emperor track and I think it's quite nice maybe a little bit like the mean Sandra mechanism in um cban EV which we really love I think it would be a bit too nicey nice without it uh so yeah I think that's also quite fun so vote for Grand Austria Hotel well in agrica no no no no no you finished I'm just saying it's a game where you can be excited about getting an asparagus Fork you were excited I was so excited about my asparagus for yeah that is true yeah but we've got strudel come on strudel so that was the end of our debate review argument and bickering bickering so we're just preparing for marriage basically so that was our video
please obviously comment down below which is a better game please let us know what your favorite expansion is for either game well I think there's only one but if you recommend it I guess then we' really appreciate it if you're not already if you could subscribe it really helps us grow the channel and it means a lot to us and finally we're just happy to answer any questions you might have about the games Y and we'll see you next time I think for a normal review yes so thank lot for watching see you bye