Skip to main content
Loading video...

Small City - 4p - The Discussion

Transcript 17:49

Derek wins 82. Yep. 47, 45, amazing teacher. I had to try to grief you. Yeah, no, apparently. Well done, Derek. Yeah, yeah. If the game gives you points. Right. So, what do y'all think? Um so, I I'll start with my card. Yeah. Um I picked it up cuz I was like, "Oh, of course I'll get three three factories." And then the second I I looked at my thing, I went "How did you do that?" I like legitimately couldn't figure out how you fit three three-like things that still touch Yeah. That and this is literally Uh the reason why that's a level 18 is because three three factories is the most three factories That's all you can do.

that any person could do. You can't I don't think you can do more than this. Well, I would argue you could do a fourth with a Yes. Or Yes. that. So, theoretically, you could do five. No, no, no, no, no, cuz this doesn't break the rules. You still have to follow the rules. Fair. This is the only one that lets you break the rules. Yeah, yeah. So, okay, sure. But it's hard. It's a lot. It's harder harder than I thought. I was like, "Oh, they can't do a fire park." And I was like, "Oh, that's And I was like, okay, we'll find a different way. Uh well, it's also my 12 was get all of your dudes. Yeah. And I was like, "I think that's easier." Yeah. Now, I don't know. Like all all? 22, which I think is all of them.

Yeah, it is all of them. Yeah, that's really hard. My 18 was make $17 and I was like, "Wow, it doesn't seem like money's really easy to do in this game." But I saw you guys actually able to sell stuff, so I think money you could possibly You could. I mean, it's giving you a direction, but my question is, like on mine, I went into it like, "Oh." But then I forgot, "Oh, wait, you're still losing points because of" So, really, that means your your pollution, if you nail it, is it 23. So, you're losing five points. So, scoring your end game scoring and losing the best you could do is lose five points. Like this this one right here. So, I don't know if like it feels counterintuitive and I don't know that losing five points for getting that.

Right. Right? So, maybe I should have gone for a six-pointer that was a guarantee and try and keep this stupid low. So, so this one right here or was already giving me less scoring, so I was I was getting less negative at the end just by doing this. Right. So, if even if I didn't do it, I still would get like maybe like 20 or 30 points knocked off the score just by trying. I mean, I still though like I also went heavy on parks. Um It's important. It is important. But I'm saying I ended with 30, James ended with 33, and that's with us with a lot of parks. Right. ended with what? I ended up with 58, but really um minus 18 on it, but but if y'all met yours, then it's not minus 18, right? So, I don't know. I just I I always thought like that just seems like it doesn't work. I wanted to try it cuz I I played avoiding that one before and I was like, "I got dealt it. Let me try it." I can certainly see why the park variant is popular. Yeah, so too easy to buy parks and just take a nap. So, okay, the parks variant, for those that don't know, is it's now forbidden to build size two and size three park tiles uh during the building phase. So, only size one can be built.

Uh during the moving phase, you can place a citizen on a P1 and that's how they grow into a two or three. Similarly, Exactly. Yep. So, a lot more That would make this a lot harder. It would make that probably impossible. Right, yeah. And a one uh P1 cannot double upgrade to a P3 in the same turn. They have to stay there for the remainder of the round. And it just this way you can't just buy them. It requires work. And that is the recommended way to play it, but I thought, "You know what? It's been a Let's not mess But it's sort of like I mean, that's a big part of the tourists is forcing that pollution on people. Right. If they just have a sheet on of parks, then they're like, "Whatever. Yeah." It definitely I think it makes the game better. That's That's pretty much what me and Greg Greg did. Yeah, who wanted to visit the park the place with all the parks.

That's one of the two official variants that people recommend. And the other is the peaceful mayor mayor that says choose the first player as normal the beginning of the game. Uh they take them meeple mayor and place it in front of them. Uh it's not placed in the city. No blocking. Uh at the end of the first round, if no player's chosen the special mayor, the mayor meeple's passed to the player to the left who should host the mayor as follows. If possible, the mayor meeple must be placed in city hall where it means it occupies two speed two spaces. It's not allowed to move and organizes citizen meeples from previous round that are waiting in city hall. If you don't have two vertical or two horizontal spaces in city hall, you cannot host the mayor.

You keep the mayor in front of you. And during the voting phase, the mayor is making a speech from city hall in front of the six squares that surround that half of city hall. The player host that gets one vote point for each citizen meeple that's listening to him. Oh. Oh, okay. Pivots a little. Slows you down a little with your population cycle, but potentially a bunch of points and a cute little guy. Yeah, so. There you go. Those are the two official variants. And then there are expansions that we didn't even I I don't know what they do, I'll be honest. I knew this. It's more like municipal tiles to make the city feel more like a full city instead of just houses and commerce and also this one district we don't talk about. Honestly, I've I've seen the box before and I've heard people talk about this game saying they really liked it.

When I was reading through the rules, I was like, "Oh, this looks a little SimCity, a little Princes of Florence." There's like some elements of the tiles and how you kind of get in each other's way. I love Clinic. It's one of my favorite games. So, that's uh it has a I I can feel it a lot when I'm playing this, but I do like Clinic's tightness a little bit more than I than This is really I really really enjoyed this and I have to play it a few more times, but I do like the the the the sharpness that that that Clinic has that this this is not has, but also there's a way that I seem like I was able to negate it on the first try. Okay, that's fair. And I'm not I'm not like trying to dissuade you on that, but I would like to point out this is the advanced board.

Okay. Um so, the options here Oh, I like yep. Okay, are that you draw four pro promise cards. Keep one. Draw three, draw two, draw one, keep one. Or negative. Uh-huh. It is in fact uh that is that is the case. Now, in addition to that Yeah, yeah. There is a There's a So, if you're playing the advanced variant that there's that, right? Go all the way in. So, this is our board. Uh Oh, I see. It makes it way harder do that industrial off to one side and keeping it out. So, the game certainly can ramp up difficulty-wise.

This is This is like um I like to play with the This is my first Small City is the version we played. Yeah. Uh yeah, this is like playing Clinic, but with the 3x3 instead of Right. And I mean, it makes sense that it's an urban game, right? Uh no, I I love Clinic. I like this game, too. Um VR, my friend at one point was trying to get us to like constantly play heavy games and he had a weekend where all we did was play uh VR games. And yeah, we played Clinic. And as soon as we're done with that, we started playing Small City. Um yeah, that fried everybody. Spring. That was a lot. Yeah, doing this twice in one day, I'm cooked. Yeah. The puzzle is rough. I mean, I knew it was going to be rough, but it's rough.

Rough and it like break that down. What do you mean? Uh well, I mean, the spatial challenge of cramming everything in so that things have their influence, but I think another level I didn't appreciate is you know, that as they expand, you only have certain shapes. And so, not only how you start matters, how you expand matters. And I could never I could never turn my residence into a five because I narrow it in not realizing that it it has to grow wide and then up. It can't grow up and then wide. staring at the next spaces just so I could figure out where it was going to go. a three turns into a four and then the four either gets fat or gets longer. goes into one of those two, right?

turn that four into that five. Sure you can. You're you're missing this. Like what what No, so I can just do that? No, I can't because I did it backwards. Oh, OKAY. I CAN'T HELP you if you DID IT BACKWARDS. NO, THIS NO, THAT turns into that pretty easily as long as you don't do that. Okay, yeah. No, now now we understand what your problem is. You're like, "But you can't do that." We're like We're like What if you do it upside down? That's my point is getting it in there is a challenge, getting it to upgrade the plan. I spent the whole game just trying to make the five with five guys on it.

Yeah, cuz that seemed like the best thing in the game to do. That's a very good thing to do. When when when we play this again, I'm I'm actually kind of excited because I mean, I have a lot of energy. I could actually play it again right now. But but this is what I do. Late night euros are my thing. I love heavy euros at night. Um Cocaine also is is zero caffeine. Right, I know. That's amazing. No, no, that's crazy. But anyway, continue. No, no, no, I'm just saying that I I really like to play with the other side and then I can truly be able to kind of feel what it's And with the variants um because I think the variants actually make the game better. They really do. being able to do all this me me being me me having to grow over time that that definitely would have been And then you're work you're like, "Ah, I don't want to use a worker on it." But God, I need those. And you don't have that much workers. Also you getting that four like by round what? Three?

He he is putting that early and often, right? If if you're doing well. is this is all this is everything I was trying to do. This was just ancillary to because we needed to get money. So it was like this was my whole plan the whole game from the when we started playing. I was like, "I'm going to put that there." So which is tighter, this or clinic? Clinic, I think. Yeah, clinic definitely. Well, I haven't played the other board, so. Okay, fair enough. Well, so clinic has a lot more of restrictions on a lot more restrictions on what you can build. And depending on what modules you're using. Well, see, hold on. Let me ask James. Which do you think because you I I haven't played clinic in too long. Okay, fair enough. See, to me clinic the 3D aspect of it is what's difficult for me to visualize. But I feel like this is harder than clinic. But a different kind of spatial because that is you're looking in 3D as opposed to 2D here. In 2D I can handle, so it doesn't it's this feels more difficult because I feel like this is more limiting in a sense that again looking at it from the advanced version of this, it is just so constricted. And it is so difficult to be able to do what you want. It's a really good puzzle, but it's a lot of work in a good way.

And I enjoy this more than clinic. But I enjoy clinic as well. Because I I had only played clinic. So I played clinic like seven times. I haven't played it enough. I I would love to play it a lot more because the modules seem like they really change game play so much. And playing this is going to be the same, but seems like there's more things to do. Like you're trying to like maneuver more things than in clinic you're like, "I have this, this, and this." These are the three or four things I have to worry about. On this it seemed like there was a lot of other ancillary things that I was kind of worrying about. Like these specific buildings or like you getting that before I get that or there's some other things that were going on where clinic is only like three special buildings or four special buildings that are limited. The rest of it you're kind of doing what you're doing. Well, I mean all this all this limited in some way.

Yeah, true. Like the doctors and The the thing is if I want to build a new hospital or or clinic, whatever, doctor version thing in clinic. It's not just Yeah, specialty. I forgot I forgot what the It's not just oh, I need to make sure I I can get it before someone else. I need to make sure I have room for it, the two beds, a closet. And also there's stuff below it. And how are you moving around the hospital? And see, I you're not wrong. I agree with you. But then I look at James's board and No, no. I'm not being mean, but that exact situation you're like, "Well, should have planned for that."

And this requires more or equal foresight to be able to figure it out. And again, when we're talking about this, look how you have a 6 by 7 to start. And these are all really big pieces. Here's the thing. I'll put I'll most of the seven that is on my industry. I would just put that right at the bottom. And I'll start here with city hall. And then no points for you. I had a really small engine over here with lots of So it's going to be interesting how that lays out. Also I'm realizing the only reason I did three factories is because of this. Yes. Were I not trying to do this, there's no reason I would do more than Yeah, cuz you can use other people's.

That was a big thing, too. I think I used my own factory. realize how important that was until halfway through the game where James was I mean, he's on his death march obviously. He's literally sending out his guys hoping they died. And I didn't realize that until he broke over there. I Well, and the thing is like I don't know what all the I don't have them committed to memory. It's been too long since I played. But um so it sounds like everybody's down to uh play this more. Yeah. Absolutely. known the OG box, which I will say the nice thing is the box size is way better in the deluxe version. The other one is like an age of steam almost size. It's flat and big. Yeah, it's just it's just more it's just bigger. Yeah, for no other reason. It's mostly just flat cardboard. Yeah, it really is.

There's and there's I mean, the component quality is fine. The colors I think are good because they're different. It's easy to see. It's all very clear. Great color. I know I I like that it's a different it's olive. So so actually this is Crayola gold. Or olive. Yeah, not that Crayola gold. It's wasn't that color. So

I know gold has has that green tint to it, but it has I we we can talk about it later. So uh tomorrow night I'm back with John from Dad's on a Map. He and I are going to have cocktails for an hour so and and shoot the breeze. So if you are unfamiliar with it, well, that'll give you an opportunity. Uh if y'all enjoyed it, please like and subscribe. That was a long night tonight. Appreciate y'all sticking with us. Consider supporting the show patreon.com/hthq. Uh yeah, I think that's it. Y'all got anything else? I am, too. Wendy's. Arby's? No, that's way too far to drive. No. Wendy's though. Wendy's is worth it. Edward. Edward, great. James, y'all have a good night. Later, y'all.

I appreciate that y'all made it this far. Thanks for watching the video. While you're here, like the video before you leave and subscribe to the channel. It really really does help. Certainly appreciate. And you know, you could always check out some more videos there if you want. It's a thing you could do.

Progress saved