Enthrone VS Scales Of Fate - BUY THIS, NOT THAT (surprising...)
Transcript
We're comparing two games that are very similar. Enthroned and Scales of Fate. Both are recently released two-player deduction games where you're secretly controlling pieces on a shared board. Both cost 40 bucks and both promise strategic depth without eating your entire evening. But after playing both extensively, one of these is a keeper and the other is going to collect dust after your 10th play.
And I'm saying upfront, we disagree on which one wins. I know where you're going with this and I think you're dead wrong.
Of course you do. Let's start with basics. Enthroned has eight sculpted fantasy character busts. King, priestess, knight, jester, all the classics, and you secretly control one. Your goal is either to get your chosen character to the throne in the center, eliminate your opponent's chosen character, or knock out three specific target characters your identity card tells you to hunt. There's also this fourth win condition where if your opponent eliminates four characters without winning, you automatically win.
And that sounds great on paper, but here's what actually happens. The action track has eight positions, and only pawns in the top five positions can move. The top three can enter the throne space, and the top two can actually attack and eliminate other pawns. The bottom three are completely locked. When you move a pawn, its tile slides to the bottom, and everything shifts up. So, you're constantly managing this priority queue, which is clever initially, but it becomes this deterministic puzzle where you're just calculating which pawns will be available three turns from now instead of making actual strategic choices.
But that's the point. It's a positional puzzle with hidden information layered on top. You're trying to deduce which character your opponent controls while simultaneously positioning your own pieces. That action track creates tension because you can't always move the piece you want to move. except that constraint stops feeling like tension and starts feeling like the game is playing you. And the replayability issue is real. When we first played it, we loved how it looked and how tight it felt. But over time, we started to notice there are no variable player powers, no events, nothing that changes up the game. It's the exact same structure every single time. We had serious concerns about whether would hold up over 10, 15, 20 plays. In our experience, games with those kinds of longevity concerns usually don't stick around.
Fair criticism. The board setup is identical every game. But let's pivot to Scales of Fate. Scales of Fate has nine demigods, and each player secretly controls two of them. Not one, but two. Your goal is to manipulate the renown track so that your two demigods score the most points. Points are calculated as the difference between your two demigods positions on the renown track. If they're on different spaces, you score the numerical gap. If they're on the same space, that space's value is your score. At the end, you guess your opponent's two demigods. Three points for correctly identifying both. Lose one point if you don't identify at least one, and you lose one point for each god power you used once. And this is where Scales of Fate demolishes Enthroned. First off, it's pure skill. Zero randomness once play begins. Every decision is fully in the player's hands. No dice rolls, no surprise card draws. The game doesn't challenge you to memorize optimal strategies. It challenges your cognitive reasoning abilities every session. And the dual identity deduction is exponentially more complex than Enthron's single identity system. You're trying to identify two demigods out of nine while concealing your own two. I'll give you that the zero randomness design is elegant and the dual identity deduction is more complex, but here's my issue. It's trying to do too much.
You've got the renown track, the abyss mechanic where you can send demigods to score positive or negative points, the quest tokens that trigger when demigods are placed in their line of sight, the servant tokens that affect entire rows and columns based on border color matching. the age cards that change the board setup three times per game and the god powers you can use once each for a onepoint penalty. That's a lot of systems. But those systems interact in fascinating ways. When you place a servant token, it affects all demigods and action spaces along that row or column whose borders match the servants's color. That creates cascading effects where a single servant placement shifts the renown of multiple demigods simultaneously. And the three age structure means the board resets twice.
New quest layouts, new action tile positions, new strategic considerations. No two games felt identical to us because of that variability.
Except we also found that the mechanical transparency makes it too easy to deduce which demigods your opponent controls. It feels less social deduction and more crunchy deduction because the scoring system incentivizes consistent behavior. If you're trying to maximize the renown of two specific demigods over three ages, your actions reveal a pattern.
That's only true if you're playing against someone who's not actively trying to misdirect you. The game really shines when both players are engaged in trying to outwit each other. The better you know your opponent, the trickier the psychological battle becomes. You start recognizing how they bluff, when they hesitate, what their usual strategies are, which means you have to constantly switch things up. In our experience, that's where the mastery potential really kicks in.
But the publisher lists the play time at around 30 minutes, which is actually similar to In Thrones 15 to 30. When we play Enthron, some sessions finish in under 15 once you know what you're doing. That quick run time means we can play it three or four times in an evening, rapidly iterating on strategies. Scales of Fate runs closer to that 30 minute mark once you're experienced, though our learning games definitely push toward 45. Either way, you're getting fewer plays per session compared to In Thrones's fastest games,
but the 30inut experience in Scales of Fate is more substantive. For a deduction game with this much strategic depth, you need time for the psychological warfare to develop, for the board state to evolve meaningfully across three ages, and for the deduction element to actually matter. When some of our enthrone sessions ended in 10 minutes, that often wasn't enough time for sophisticated strategies to really take shape. Let's talk about mechanical constraints in Enthrown versus Freedom in Scales of Fate. In Enthrone, the action track constrains you. Only five pawns are available to move, and only specific positions can attack or claim the throne. In Scales of Fate, you can place any demigod on any open action space. You can place servants to affect entire rows and columns. You can choose when to use your god powers. You're navigating a rich decision space where multiple paths lead to victory.
Exactly. That freedom creates actual strategic depth. In Thron's action track is a straight jacket. You're not making choices. You're solving a queue management puzzle that becomes predictable once you've internalized the timing. Scales of Fate gives you freedom within structure. The cascading interactions when you place a servant that triggers quests along a row create emergent complexity. In Thrones mechanics, in our plays, don't interact in interesting ways. The action track is just a cue. Eliminations just remove pieces. There's no synergy, no combo potential.
But that elegance is the appeal. Enthrone doesn't need cascading systems because the core mechanism is tight and self-contained. The action track creates meaningful decisions within a constrained space. It's like chess. The rules are simple, but strategic depth comes from the interactions between simple elements. Scales of Fates multiple systems often felt more like feature bloat than integrated design to me. They create the variable setup that for us ensured replayability. In Thrones, fixed board and starting configuration mean the early game is identical across plays. You've got eight identity cards, so there are combinations, but once we played through those a few times, we felt like we'd seen everything the game structurally offers. Scales of Fate has three age card variants per age, randomized quest tokens, variable action tile placement, and 36 possible demigod pairings per player.
I'll concede the variability advantage, but the scoring system in Scales of Fate creates this high-risk, highreward dynamic where you can play conservatively by keeping your two demigods close together on the renown track for a guaranteed moderate score. or you can take risks by spreading them far apart for a potentially massive score differential. That tension is really compelling. It's probably the best mechanical element in the game.
Agreed. And that's where the psychological warfare lives. If you're obviously boosting two specific demigods and tanking the others, your opponent figures you out. But if you're spreading your manipulations across multiple demigods to create misdirection, you sacrifice optimal scoring for better concealment. That trade-off between winning the points game and winning the deduction game is where the skill ceiling lives. In our experience, that high-risk, highreward dynamic is the best part tension-wise.
But Enthrone integrates its deduction more tightly into core gameplay. There's no separate guessing phase. You act on your deductions by trying to eliminate your opponent's chosen character or blocking their path to the throne. If you guess wrong, you've wasted actions. The deduction is woven into every decision. Scales of Fate has that formal guessing phase at the end that to me feels tacked on.
That endgame guessing added explicit stakes in our plays that rewarded all the deduction work we've been doing across three ages. The fact that you lose a point if you can't identify at least one demigod means you're constantly gathering information throughout the game. It's the payoff for sustained observation.
Let's talk value proposition. Both games are strictly two-player only. Both cost $39.99 for the standard edition. You're paying the same amount for a game that only plays two. Which one justifies that investment better?
Scales of Fate justifies it because of mastery potential. This is a game we can see ourselves playing dozens and dozens of times with the same opponent and still discovering new strategic wrinkles. The zero randomness design means the more skilled player will usually win. Your win rate reflects actual skill development. Compare that to Enthrone, where we both started to worry about the game feeling sy around 10 plays for a $40 purchase. That gave us pause. But we also found there's some nuanced layering of learning new strategies, and that the game is very satisfying right now. The concern about longevity for us is future-looking, not about the first handful of plays. And the 15-minute session length means even if it does get stale, you've probably gotten a lot of value out of it by that point. But we both know from our shelves that games with that kind of fixed setup and limited variability often don't stick around. Once we start to see that lack of variability, they get rotated out. And the insert issue is real. In our copy, the insert was actively frustrating. Getting everything in and out cleanly for setup and tearown was a pain. And over multiple plays, that kind of friction adds up. Fair, the insert is bad, but both games invest heavily in production. Enthrone has eight finely sculpted 3in tall fantasy busts and a fourpiece illustrated stained glass puzzle board. It looks absolutely stunning on the table. Scales of Fate has thick wooden components, a dual
layered board, and premium production.
But for us, in Thrones production matches its gameplay weight. It looks like a premium abstract strategy game and plays like one with Scales of Fate. We sometimes felt the production exceeded the strategic depth. There were moments where it felt a bit narrow for this level of gargantuan opulence. And we both commented that you could probably scale it down to 75% of the size and it would still work just fine. That's not exactly a glowing endorsement of how tightly the production and gameplay are aligned.
That criticism could be flipped. Maybe in Thrones gorgeous components are overselling a game that's going to feel repetitive after 10 plays. This is the fundamental disagreement. You think Scales of Fate's multiple systems create depth, and I think they create complexity without proportional strategic payoff,
which is exactly why we're doing this episode. So, let's get to the verdict. I'm saying scales of fate. Here's why. The zero randomness design creates a pure skill game where cognitive abilities determine outcomes. The three age structure with variable setup has kept our plays feeling fresh. The dual identity deduction is exponentially more complex than single identity systems. The scoring system creates high stakes tension and the psychological warfare deepens as you and your opponent get more experience. Yes, it has multiple systems that don't integrate perfectly, but I'd rather have ambitious design with minor integration issues than elegant design that feels sy by the 10th play. And I'm saying in throne precisely because of that elegance. The action track mechanism creates dynamic interconnected decisions every turn. The multiple win conditions create tactical variety without rules overhead. The 15 to 30 minute play time enables repeated plays and rapid skill development. The component quality matches the gameplay weight. Yes, we both have a concern about long-term replayability, but that's a future-looking worry for a game that's satisfying right now. I'd rather have 50 amazing plays of a tight, focused game than a hundred plays of a game that's trying to do too much. But when we ourselves started to wonder if Enthrown would hold up over 10, 15, 20 plays and noticed that more often than not in our collection, games with that
profile don't stick around. That wasn't a minor warning. That was us recognizing this game might have a shelf life. Scales of Fate doesn't feel like it has that problem because the variability is built into the structure. The age cards change the board. The quest randomization creates different tactical landscapes,
but you're navigating the same systems every time, and those systems reveal optimal play patterns relatively quickly. The mechanical transparency where the concrete board manipulation leaves out room for too much skull duggery, that's a real problem for a deduction game. If your actions reveal your identity through optimal scoring patterns, the deduction layer loses tension. That noise in Enthrown is just the game artificially restricting your choices, not creating meaningful strategic decisions. The fact that you can't always move the pieces you want because they're locked in the bottom three action track positions, that's frustration, not tension. In our plays, Scales of Fate never artificially restricted our choices in the same way.
Let's talk target audience. I think Enthrone is better for players who want quick iterative two-player sessions. Couples who want something they can pull out repeatedly and play three or four times in an evening. Abstract strategy enthusiasts who appreciate chess-like positional thinking with hidden information. Players who value elegance over feature count.
And I think Scales of Fate is better for players who want a substantial two-player strategic deduction game with room for mastery. couples or dedicated two-player groups who plan to play extensively with the same opponent. Competitive players who want a pure skill game where the better player consistently wins. Players who value variable setup and don't want to play on the same fixed board every game. If you're primarily playing with different opponents every session rather than the same dedicated partner, Enthron's quicker learning curve and shorter session length make it more accessible. In our experience, Scales of Fate's psychological warfare element, where you're learning your opponent's tendencies, works best when you're playing the same person repeatedly.
Fair, but Scales of Fate still has superior strategic depth even with varying opponents. The cognitive challenge of managing the renown track, the abyss, the servant positioning, the age card transitions that exists irregardless of who you're playing against. And honestly, if you're buying a $40 two-playeronly game, you're probably buying it for a dedicated partner, not for rotating game night opponents.
Okay, that's solid. But I'm still not convinced the multiple systems in Scales of Fate create proportional strategic depth. I think they create apparent complexity that looks deeper than it actually plays. The enthrone action track mechanism is brilliant precisely because it's so focused. One core system that creates cascading strategic implications. And I think you're undervaluing the variability those multiple systems create. Yes, in Thrones action track is elegant, but elegance without replayability is just novelty. I'd rather have a game slightly less elegant, but that I can play a hundred times without it feeling sy. Our concerns about Enthron's longevity are serious.
Definitive verdict. Buy Skills of Fate if you want the deeper game with more mastery potential and better long-term replayability. Buy Enthrone if you want the quicker, more elegant game for rapidfire sessions, and you're willing to accept that it might feel sy. But if I'm putting my money down for a $40 two-player deduction game that I want to still be playing a year from now, I'm buying Scales of Fate. And I'm buying in Throne because the elegance and quick session length create more actual table time for me. But the listener gets to decide which argument they find more compelling. Just know that if you buy in Throne and it feels repetitive after your 10th play, we warned you. And if you buy Scales of Fate and it feels like you're managing too many fiddly systems, we also warned you.
Neither one is perfect. Enthrone has a potential replayability problem. Scales of Fate has a complexity to depth ratio problem. The question is which flaw you're more willing to tolerate. And for me, I'd rather have a game that grows with me and my opponent over time, even if it's more complex upfront than a game that hits its strategic ceiling relatively quickly. And for me, I'd rather have 50 amazing plays of something focused than a 100 okay plays of something that's trying too hard. But either way, both games are better than playing another round of whatever mass market game is sitting on your shelf collecting dust. So, pick one, play it extensively, and let us know what you think. That's it for this episode. Thanks for listening and we'll catch you next