I Review 5 "OLD" Games | Keep or Sell?
Transcript
So, one of the things that is problematic about having a board game collection is that they're margins too many. And we have games that go back way far back and they have been sitting on a shelf for years and we haven't played them. So, one of the things we decided to do this summer, my husband and I, um we decided to kind of go through our collection and try to play as many of those games as possible. games that we used to play maybe quite a bit and are returning to. Uh in this case, we pulled down five games from the shelf thinking, I don't know if I want to sell this. I don't know if I want to keep this. And so the idea was, are we going to essentially callull this game, or are we going to keep it? Andor there's this middle ground of play again, but with a different player count. So, I'm going to go through these five games as fast as I can, giving you a couple statistics along the way. So randomly starting with uh first one, this is Porttoello Market.
So Portoella Market is a game for two to four players and takes about half an hour to 40 minutes to play. Um was designed in 2007. And on BG its ranking is a 6.4 out of 10. That's its score. And its complexity rating is a 2 out of five. So with this you've got an abstract strategy area majority game. Now generally I'm going to say no on the first one. I don't want abstract abstract strategy game and uh no on the second count to area majority is not my favorite mechanic. However, I played this in a two-player game. Every single one of these games will be played in a two-player game. My husband and I again were just trying these games out saying, "Okay, I don't remember this.
Let's all read the rules and we're going to teach each other these games and play as many as we can. So, with this one, I really liked it. I en essentially enjoyed playing down um you have action tokens that will give you a certain amount of actions on your turn. I really enjoy that feature. And there's a way to um essentially get a new action token once you have grabbed a particular region. So, there's even going to be some trading out of tokens as long as players take advantage of that scoring opportunity. But the way this works is fascinating, and I really enjoyed the street scoring. I enjoyed the kind of back and forth of players. I see Lewis doing something and I can play my four actions on my turn, or I can play my two. two is not as good as four, but is this the time to play it low and slow and then kick in um in uh you know maybe the next turn or two? Really fascinating. And there's also a multiplication feature to this where you build your particular um marketplaces is based on who is on either end of your street. And so there are different colored figures that you can draw from the bag. I think this game was really fun. and I had a great time with it and my husband wants to play this with more players. BGG also says it's best with four. So, I'm excited to revisit Porttoello Market with four players in the near future. All right, moving on
randomly to the next one. We pulled out The Minds of Zavendor. Now, The Minds of Zavendor is not as old as some of these other games. And when I say old, 2007 is nearly 20 years old. These games are 15 to 20 years old with the exception of Minds of Zavendor. Um, this is Oh, no. 2010, so 15 years old. So, pretty old. I think it was only um Alexander Fister's second design. Uh, is a rank of 6.6 out of 10. That's uh how much people enjoy it. And it has a 2.61 complexity rating out of five. And the major mechanics are auction, tech trees, and trading. So, I don't like blind auctions. I don't like them at all. Uh, again, not one of my favorite features or mechanics. I do like tech trees. I do like that a lot.
Um, not the biggest fan of trading. This kind of reminds me of our trading from um, Settlers of Katan kind of trading where you sit with people and you kind of do want to trade because it's better to trade with each other than to trade with the bank. But every time you give someone something, then they probably can make a really dynamite turn with it or a dynamite move. And so it kind of feels bad. So in a slower amount of players in this game, you actually don't get to play with as many of the mines. There are four and they associate with four different colors. So you're playing with fewer with two players. You're playing with three and three players and you're playing with four or four players. So this one's another one that is, as BGG says, best with four. Um, so I don't know. I don't know. I had a really rough time with this because it definitely has an engine building to it.
And so if you don't get your engine built and you're not winning the auctions or bids because the player who has the first player turn order breaks ties and you're just missing out on things, every time somebody gets something over you in an earlier turn, uh you are essentially behind. And there is no catch-up mechanism. There is a way to keep your cards if you're not uh essentially, you know, you bid them. You don't lose them in a blind bid, but you're not getting to do anything with them and grabbing a card. That's really a great upgrade that round. You have to wait till next round and then you might not even win that card. So, this has a little bit of a runaway feature to it. Not my favorite. Really enjoy Alexander Fister in general. Um, but my husband wants to play this with four. I am still on the fence with this guy. Okay, next one. Um, this is Michael Stroganov.
Stroggonov, Michael Stroggo. Um, I was thinking of this. This game is the the most recent. This is a 2017 title. So, just uh, you know, under 10 years old, 1 to five player. Uh, this is from Dere Games. And so, this guy is the 6.7 out of 10 uh, for favorability. And it's uh, uh, complexity levels of 2.1 out of five. It's got dice uh, hand Gosh, does it have dice? And dice is a big critique of mine in this game. Hand management, push your luck, race, semi-ooperative. I mean, there's so many things in here that I really like. Like, when you talk about this game on paper, this was the one I was most interested in revisiting. This one was the one I was like, "This sounds really great. I love race. I love press your luck. I love some some hand management." Not the biggest fan of any semi co-op because one person always has to essentially do something for the benefit of other people.
But um the dice here are definitely problematic. Um it's just so swingy and so like you lucky. So players can activate cards by essentially rolling dice and and getting that number and you could like roll the whole game and never get your number. I mean it's just it's very possible. And so you just don't get the things that you've invested in because you do get to invest in things. And there's also a chance for you as you press your way down this path um to be blinded and left for dead, which I think happens quite often. It happened to both my husband and me. And when that happens, then um you kind of have a permanent scar. And that permanent scar can be pretty debilitating. Now, this is a race to get to the end, and you have to essentially press your luck by fighting off um a certain number of cards at the end. And really the only way you do that is by having health or energy. If you have a lot of health or energy, you can use those to kind of like mitigate. Um, but you can also bust. And every time I had the chance to bust at a very low risk, I always did.
When my husband went, he went high risk and never busted. So there's the press. Your luck can be pretty swingy. I don't know if I want to return to this game. U BG says that this is best with one player. This is the only one that says is best with one player. So maybe this game needs to just be Louiswis's my husband's solo game. I can let he can have it. He can have Michael Stroggo off. Okay. Um next one. Uh this is a Queen game. This is a Castelli from Days of Yore 2011. Right. These again are pretty pretty uh old. So uh Castelli is a 5.6 6 out of 10 and a complexity of 2.33 out of five. And it's essentially tile placement. Um, this game really really rubbed me the wrong way in a variety of ways and it made me feel like I have seen implementation of these features, this kind of tile placement done much better.
There's just a lot of things that have been fixed. This made me feel like this is an old game. And I didn't realize that old games felt like this until I played it. So, here are a couple critiques. First thing is there's a chance to draw cards. And if you draw cards, you don't know what you're going to get. And you could grab all the cards that don't necessarily help you. There's a victory point card in there that's worth either three, four, or five, and they have them all mixed in. I draw from the deck, get the five victory point. You draw from the deck, you get the three. That's it. you just you just did the same action I did and you just randomly got two fewer points. And in this game, the win came down to one point difference. And so I feel like just to like luck into getting a five over the three is kind of ridiculous.
It's really silly. Um the way that the tiles turn is really fascinating. You place a tile down into a player area board and then each different side um um uh correlates with one of the player colors and then that player gets to have those things. And so you're essentially gaining power control in three different areas and then spending those to place down your castellis which are your castles and your castles are what score you points. So it's a really straightforward get this stuff out here and then you turn it in for castles here. cards are really cool, but again they're super swingy. And then the last thing is there is not equal turns with three players and that was like not in my opinion I I never like a game that doesn't give players equal chance to play or some kind of makeup for that.
Some kind of like here because you went second or third you get to start with this thing or you all get to play equal turns and when you play last you still get to do this thing. So didn't like that at all at all. Um, this game is not going to be played again, no matter how many players it says is best with. BGG says four. This is the one game that my husband and I both said this goes. This goes. I don't care where it goes, but it's going out of the house. Okay, last one. Uh, another queen game. This is called Maharani Mos Mosaic Palace. And, uh, this guy is from 2012 and has a 6.6 out of 10. and has about a two out of a five complexity. Uh, and then this, what is this one too? A 40minute game. The Castelli is about a 45minute game. All of these games are about 45 to 60 minutes. Um, to be honest. And then Maharani is abstract strategy. Uh-oh. Not my favorite.
Pattern building, yes. Set collection, sure. Tile placement. Yeah, all of those things. So, I can maybe make do with the abstract strategy as long as everything is making sense here. There's a cool feature in this game, which is that this center space spins for every player, which means the tiles that they get are facing a different direction. And if you face your tiles with the arrow pointing essentially in your direction, you get to do bonus things. And you also get to have a wheel where you spend an extra bonus turn to exhaust it to play another tile um and or play it into a different space. And I think that's cool. It's really cool. Um this game had a kind of fizzle ending for me. Uh essentially, if you've been focusing on particular areas, then you may not have the right tiles to place in these spaces that you have remaining. And so I feel like your early game and middle game really dictates how your end game is going to be. And multiple plays of Mosaic or Maharani Mosaic Palace benefits players because it's hard to see that strategy from the start. They say this is best with four. I think so as well. Um when you play with two, you have to play with two player colors and things start getting a little goofy up here. And it was a little challenging for me. I had the hardest time getting into this game.
I could not wrap my brain around this game. And by the end, I still was like, "Wait, what?" So, I think I'd like to play this with four because there are some really, really cool features here. And I think the game would be so much more dynamic with four players playing on all four sides of the board. But this is cool. It's interesting. I think I'm going to play again with four. I think my husband wants to as well, but this will be the queen game of the two that I actually want to keep and play again. So to wrap things up, we're probably going to get rid of Castelli. We might be getting rid of the Michael Strogoff mines and Porttoello um after playing with four or more or like three or four. And I think perhaps, oddly enough, Maharani might be the game we keep. I think it's the most replayable. I think it's really interesting. And um maybe I can just get my brain around it, maybe not. But the others feel a little swingy. I like Porttoello Market, but my husband didn't like it as a two player. And so I think if it doesn't work as a four, it might be one to go because he won't play it with me. And then I'm not going to be playing it with anybody else. So that's going to be my final take. And again, I'll give Lewis Michael Stroggo as a solo game. So we might be keeping two of these, maybe three of these, but then the others will go. It was really, really interesting to revisit what I call older games. games that are 15 to 20 years old that to me we've made so
many leaps and bounds and different mechanics and things that I really enjoy now as a gamer that I don't necessarily enjoy and didn't enjoy when I first started gaming that were kind of like the staples or the mainstay, the kinds of mechanics that um just rub me the wrong way andor make me feel like I don't have a chance in the game. And so I really do appreciate some of the other mechanics. If you want to know what some of those mechanics are, I've got a top five of my favorite game mechanics on my channel. You can check that out and some examples of games that really just kind of like click for me that really just light a fire in me because there are some fantastic mechanics and a lot of the ones that were not present necessarily here in these games, which is why maybe they're a little bit more of a miss for me. So, that's going to be it for my five games I revisited and are they going to stay in my collection or not? All right, everybody. Let me know what you think in the comments below. I really want to know what your take is.
Best with like game size games that you're like, "No, really, you got to give this one a second chance. Don't give up on it this early." Or, "Yeah, you're totally right. This game is not working for XYZ." All right, I'll see you next time. Bye.