DVONN, Isle of Trains, Babel, Stripes, Caesar & Cleopatra Ranked and Reviewed
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to another chairman of the board ranking video this is where I take a look at the last five new to me board games that I've played and I rank them from my least favorite up to my most favorite just to share some initial thoughts on those games now before I get started on these five pretty good games actually so good um good standard this episode and I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor kendra. co.uk who are my go-to online retailer and if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order at number five I have Caesar and clear Patra so this is a two-player only game from the cosmos line it goes all the way back to 1997 and to be honest all in all I think the game has aged quite well but there are certain aspects of the game that I feel are a little bit outdated so this is one of those tug of war style games you are playing cards from your hand to try and have the highest majority um assigned to these particular kind of Senator cards at each round a certain Senator is going to score and if you got the majority of the highest value then that card is going to come to you you're going to score points based on every single card you've collected as well as having majorities and on top of that if you have exclusive ownership of one or many of these Senators then you'll score some bonus points as well now there's also some kind hidden scoring aside at the start of the game which does have a bearing on you know who's going to win uh or not now I tend to like games like
this and this one does have some pretty cool twists and turns especially through the use of these P cards that are shuffled in your deck now when you play those P cards the actual scoring is going to flip on its head because it's going to no longer score based on who's got the highest the value but but it's going to change to who's got the lowest value and because in this game you can either play cards face up or face down you can of course try to get into the head of your opponent try to mislead them you know are you playing High cards are you playing that P card and so on so some good interaction there as well uh the way the scoring work is fairly interesting as each round you're going to reveal a card which will show which particular Center is going to score and every so often when a particular card is revealed those CS will be reshuffled so sometimes the same Senator can score you know back to back but sometimes if that reshuffle card is right at the bottom of the stack then you're going to know with some pretty you know certainty that each Senator is going to score so you can use a little bit of deduction here to help you or help guide you where to focus your efforts now all of that part of the game I liked I thought it was well done now the part of the game that I did not like unfortunately were these bonus action cards that you could draw from from a separate deck for me they felt a little bit heavy-handed they didn't quite gel with the rest of the feeling of the game cuz it's quite a uh a carefully balanced kind of a hand
management style game but when you introduce those action cards they just feel a bit too amerit trashy a bit to you know smash your opponents take cards from their hand that kind of stuff it didn't quite feel like a a well jelled game for me so if I wanted a game like that or to play a game like this in general I probably lean towards something like Lost Cities maybe battle line this one I feel is not quite there and not quite as refined of a product as those other games I mentioned but it's a shame because it's a near Miss for me but I would have liked to seen those acting cars be a tweaked to be a little bit more a little bit more nuanced a little bit more delicately balanced rather than being so in your face so that is Caesar and Cleopatra at number five at number four I have stripes so this is a rather Charming little game as you have seven cards in front of you in a row and these cards will have a bunch of different stripes on them in different colors now the goal of the game is quite cool and nice and clear that you are trying to get one particular colored stripe along your whole board by shifting these cards uh up and down now the way the game works is pretty simple where you'll be choosing an action from the ones available in the center these might let you kind of flip your tiles or your cards upside down they might let you swap them with other people swap them with ones from the deck kind of um you swap cards around all these different things you'd imagine with manipulating your kind of a tableau State and that's pretty much what the game entails it's all about taking the
right action at the right time and you kind of want to sneak under the radar in this one I know each time I played this that seems to be the way that the winner is resolved because somebody looks really close to winning the game and you know that they want a particular action so you go out of your way to restrict them from having that action where in the background somebody has the action available to them which gives them that magic move to finish the game so you do have to be quite alert and quite vigilant on about how people are doing here which best action to take not only to help yourself but to put obstacles in the way of your opponents now I don't want this to sound like it's a terribly strategic game with tons of decision space because it's not generally what you'll do is you'll find a color that needs the least movement in order to complete it and stick to a certain game plan because doing anything else is going to take too much work essentially so you know decisions are fairly obvious about what you're going to choose B on the available options to you but as the game does draw to an end as I said you do need to consider what other people are doing in order to hate draft them not only to you know to help you but also to slow them down so that you might have a chance of winning but I liked it it is quite Charming I'm not sure if it has the legs for repeated plays to keep playing again and again but I did like that fresh idea and that fresh winning condition of trying to line up those cards in a perfect line so that is stripes at number four at number three I have Isle of trains All Aboard now this
is the card game version of Isle of trains uh this one is a very cool multi-use card game as you are trying to basically constantly buff or improve your train that you have in front of you by increasing its um kind of pulling power so you can put more of these kind of wagons on them which will let you kind of um load goods and then send those goods off to different regions and at the same time you're trying to deliver these passengers off to certain locations to get bonuses um again really cool use of the multi-use card system as again you can use them for resources you can use them for the the cart themselves and you can use them to pay for other cards and so on and you know multi-use card systems are one of my favorite mechanisms I think it's very cool when they're done to a high standard this game certainly does that you are pushed and pulled in different directions and I even really love this idea of interacting with the other players in this game because not only are you trying to load your own trains with your own Goods to try and complete these contracts but you are actually rewarded by loading other players trains with the goods that they want because you get quite a nice powerful bonus if you do that but of course you're giving them a a Kickstart on their next delivery so I love that tradeoff you know is it really worth me loading up their um their wagons in order for me to get this bonus you know maybe get a whole big influx of cards maybe give me you know a bunch of points Etc so um the game also moves at a very brisk Pace I actually played this one at two players the other day and we
played um until the point where it was supposed to be a higher player count game and it and it still felt short so um yeah I played it longer than I should have done and it still felt shorter than than it actually was supposed to be which is definitely a rarity and it just has a nice flow very Breezy but still has some good decisions I have to that again that opportunity cost that you need with a multi-use card system really does shine here you know have to give up this in order to do this um not leaving yourself into a corner where you don't have any CS to play with and so on so all in all um definitely way better than I was expecting it to be I had heard some good things wanted to try it for myself thought you know maybe this is going to be okay but it's definitely better than okay and I'm looking forward to see if this holds up to multiple plays and everybody does handle that stress test of um you know playing under different scenarios and different circumstances so that is Isle of trains at number three okay so let's get into the top two games here and this is where my commendations are going to begin and to be honest the minute before I started recording this video I thought I was going to put my number one as number two and number two is number one so these two are very close in how I grade them and but at number two I have Devon now Devon is from the GIF series of abstract strategy two player only games um in this one you are essentially trying to create the tallest stack of discs of your color so all you can do is you can
pick up one of these stacks and move it a number of spaces equal to the height of that stack so if it's just one disc you can move it at one spaces if it's three you can move it exactly three and hopefully land on somebody and take their piece now this game has some twists where um there are three red pieces on the board and you can only can stay on the board with your pieces as long as you can somewhat chain back to those red pieces and as you can imagine um if you end up hijacking those red pieces and moving those away from your opponents you can actually eliminate a whole chunk of your opponent's pieces from the board in a single move so you have to be hyper Vigilant in this game making sure that you're not making mistakes it's pretty I wouldn't say Cutthroat but the the potential for big kind of catastrophic moves are definitely there if you are not care for so um it kind of strikes that really cool balance of being thinky um you know definitely AP prone but still lighthearted at the core um which I really do like it definitely struck that balance very well not a big deal in order to you know just rack and go again if you do make a mistake so the stakes don't feel terribly high but it still does feel like you're making meaningful meaningful decisions from the get-go and my only slight bug bear with this game is the setup because you are populating the board as part of the game and there are quite a few pieces here um and you know because there are so many variables it just feels like you're doing it just just to go through a process rather than making anything you know making any
decision based on what you're going to play during the game you're just going to be reacting to what your opponent does um so I'm not sure if there should have been a recommended setup or something I'm not sure um but still the game play is so elegant it's so smooth um and you know before you know it all those pieces have dried up from the board and um you're ready to go but I think definitely it's one of those games where the best player will win and I I tend to like that with these styles of games so that is Devon definitely a modern classic and I'm very much looking forward to trying other games in the series because of my plays of Devon so that is Devon at number two and finally at number one I have Babel so another two-player only game going back to the year 2000 so it's an older one but for me this one still feels very fresh now believe it or not this is an uve Rosenberg game and I don't normally like Rosenberg games he's normally known for kind of eurocentric resource management farming style games this one is the furthest thing from that because this is a sharpen your claws head-to-head battle very mean-spirited very confrontational so you need to be prepared to offer something different if you see rosenberg's name on the box but it's a card driven game as you are playing these cards in order to to move around to these different locations and build these pyramids is going to be a race to get to a certain value of pyramids essentially um but these cards come if with different uses because not only are
they useful to move around the map but if you play three troop types of the same type in sequence then you will get access to a particular ability which will let you do things such as steal your opponent's pyramids or tear their pyramid down convert their troops into your troops Etc so you can imagine you are definitely smashing your opponent you are stealing their stuff from the get-go here so be prepared for that but despite that it still is a very fun game with some clever card plays some good choices um and I do like the way that you can shift things around and you know move troops from one spot to another knowing when to leave regions defend for themselves um and so on so definitely an optimization puzzle at the same time as a head-to-head Bor um but yeah this one feels distinct it feels fresh despite being an older game and I can't really think anything to directly compare it to but at the same time it does feel like it's a it feels like it's from that classic line of two-player games with games like um games like lost city you know games like Kahuna this one feels like it shares some DNA or the same feeling of those absolute Classics so very impressed by this one the more I'm playing it the more I'm liking it uh that is Babel at number one so there we have it that concludes the video hopefully you have enjoyed it and discovered a game or two if you have enjoyed it please be sure to hit like And subscribe to the channel and check out my other content too but for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye