Skip to main content
Loading video...

Harmonies vs Cascadia - Which is Best? Cardboard Kombat!

Transcript 20:20

Hello and welcome to Board Stupid. My name is Wayne

and I'm Matt.

And we've got an exciting new format for you today.

Yeah. Insert your coin, press start.

Get over here.

Round one, fight.

So, Matt, this is our brand new format. We are talking cardboard combat. Two specific games in similar genres and we're going to try and figure out which one is best cuz the people are asking what do I get? What do I play?

We ask the same things every time. Just say, "Oh, should we play Cascadia or should we play?" So,

why do you want to play this? Why do you want to play that?

Uh, we're going to have a little chat about both of them and uh let's find out who wins.

Absolutely. Let's do it. So, Matt, why have we chosen these two games to enter the arena? Well, uh, they're both in the same space of this like a new cozy nature tile placementish.

Yeah, quite different between each other, but the mechanics is kind of like the same. You got like a pool to select your your things in the middle where everybody uh picks up their ties and then you you're building your um your natural habitat. In case of Cascadia, you got the North American parks while in Arm it's a little bit more abstract but it's still like putting putting animals and putting t and both the ways you need to put tiles in a certain way to score. So that that's why they are quite similar. They

are quite similar. And also another similarity, they both have variable scoring cards. Exactly.

With Cascadia having a fixed card that you'll score against and harmonies having a slightly more dynamic system, but still with cards that you're scoring.

Exactly. With this drafting system where you draft the the animals that you want to that you want to score. Now, uh, Cascadia is is slightly older, but not that much. Just But, um, Cascadia did broke the market in terms of like like sales and everything when it came out. It's one of the most beloved game all around the world at the moment.

It won as well.

Yeah, exactly. Um, well, and it's 2021, so it's 5 years old. So, um, that in today's market is a long

old. Well, Armanies came out at the end of 2024 if I remember correctly and um I was surprised that the other well surprised to a certain level when the other day I was like oh it did made the BG top 100 and I was just like oh wow

people like this is becoming a little bit of an evergreen much like Cascadia is very much become an evergreen but to the point where I'm always surprised Cascadia came out in 2021

I feel like he's always been Exactly. It's that kind of game.

So this number 20 57 at the moment. So Arman is just scroll up in in basically a year and something to not being a thing to the number 57 overall on BG. That means number 58 is Cascadia. I didn't I didn't know. Well, we just saw it. Oh wow. So very similar game.

They're right next to each other.

Very very love to each other. Um, but which one you should pick? Or you should you pick both or more of this, more that one?

Absolutely. Let's talk about the pros and cons for each of these games.

Okay, Matt, let's talk about the pros. The arguments for Cascadia first. I think the easiest one is just the pure accessibility of this game. You can teach this to basically anybody.

Anybody

in 10 minutes or less? Yes,

it is very accessible, very easy to learn and play.

It's uh it's one of those things. It's one of those games that um I I can teach my mom and and I did and

and we played together. Actually, Faith taught it, my mom. So, my mom doesn't speak English. So, I had Faith explaining the game in English to my mom, Italian, and she understood the game and she explained the game. So, it it's it's that simple. Um, at the same times is uh it's very it's it's got that solitire feelings about all right this is what I can get from the market. I'm going to pick this one up. I'm going to build my own uh my own beautiful landscape.

It's perfect for like you said for people that aren't really gamers or for families. You can play like you said you can even teach your mom. Exactly. Yeah, the other very good things is all the different scoring cards because again that goes with the accessibility growing up because you got different sets of um of animal cards that you can use throughout your game. H and they are from the simple set A and they can get like more difficult, a little bit more complex like thinking about the placement of the animals and how you building your your landscape. Um, and especially we're not talking about the the um the expansion of Cascadia, but with the expansion you got more even more,

but we're talking about core boxes at the moment.

You've also got in Cascadia very forgiving game play. Um, because you have the nature tokens, the pine cone tokens. You can really mitigate any bad luck by swapping things out.

There's not really any restriction either around where you place things. The game will encourage you via the scoring to place things in certain ways, but you don't get punished. You can go as wide or as big with your nature park as you want. Right. It's a very forgiving gameplay loop. It It's forgiving of mistakes. Feel bad.

Yes. That's why again very very beginner friendly. Uh the con of of Cascadia or at least what what a con for me personally is that I played it so many times that it's getting a little bit uh kind of like saying same same all the time.

Okay. Okay. Like the same gameplay loop repeating. It's kind of like I do like it to play it now and then, but

I don't know that that sometimes I feel like they're playing it. It it it gives me like the loop of the game is is getting a little bit

Let's let's dig into the reason why that might be. And I think for me at least I mean I love Cascadia, but there's very much a kind of lack of tension in the game, right? And I think that having

a sense of tension I think makes me want to come back to games quite a lot sometimes. But I think this is a different vibe. uh where it's going to be a relaxed vibe, but you can't really expect there to be like a tense competitive finish that's gonna make you go a play again.

I mean, if you really want, you can hate draft,

but it's a very forgiving, very relaxing, low low tension game. And there is the other element of that which goes along with it again uh to to the arguments against Cascadia. It's very much multiplayer solitaire. Yes,

you like you said, you have some hate drafting, but most of it is accidental anyway. Oh, you took that. Who cares? I'll spend a pine cone and get

and get refresh. I'll get whatever I like. So, that's kind of there as well. In terms of the final thing that I would say is like although Cascadia is a very beautiful game, I think it can look a little bit flat when you look at other games in the genre.

Yes. Um, again, this was cozy before the cozy

before the cozy vibe. Um, so I I think with the new version that's come with Alpine Lake, the 3D version that again, we're not talking especially about that, but they are trying to revisit that as well and going into this 3D coming up

like in harmonies.

So harmonies instead. Harmonies looks like a kids game, but it's not. So that's the first things that I that I want to say that Cascadia looks more serious, harmonies looks more more playful.

Yes.

But I'm feeling the level of complexity I'm going to say is higher than than Cascadia.

I agree. And I think that's one of the positives of this game. If you want something that has a higher crunch factor, I think Harmonies does give you more crunch than Cascadia does arguably partly because you have a limited board. There's no go as wide as you want. No, you know, no issues, no restrictions. You are restricted. So, you do need to think through your decisions way more than you would do in Cascader, I feel like. And related to that, you don't have, you know, just creating width against you are restricted, but you do have a 3D spatial going up.

Exactly. So, you do have to think about height and how you're putting your tiles on your board. And I think that is a really fascinating puzzle in this game.

Yes. And on top of that, instead of having a fixed um scoring card that everybody is scoring, you're drafting the cards that you're going to score. So the during your turn after you pick up the tiles from the from the central market uh you can pick one of the animal tiles. The animal tiles will tell you uh if you go a blue next to a green next to a to a brown you you score in that card. Score that card for three four times then you put it on the side is is end scoring at the end of the game. you can have four of them um um cards at the same time, but it's is a it's a scoring me it's a dynamic scoring mechanism. That is the other big difference with uh with Cascadia that is that it's got like

it's a positive as well. It gives you constantly uh keeps you on your toes having to make new decisions when they're new come out or trying to think ahead how can I make the most of this new scoring card and opportunity.

However, I've got one more thing I want to say.

Yeah. score production wise.

I think it's

it's beautiful.

It's really nice.

It's It's really Cascadia is It looks It looks beautiful once you set it up and you got your big card, but Armon is is is a notch. I think I think I think Yeah. All the artwork. Um and again, it threw me off at the start when it looked like very much um a kids game, especially because he's from Liberal. Leoo had had done I' done a few games that are more like uh family kids friendly. Um so I remember when I I I I got this one I'm just like I'm not really sure about it and then started playing and and we were hooked from like the first second. Look the artwork that Beth Soil did in Cascadia isn't bad. It's beautiful. It's but in terms of like 3D production this the harmonies really pops on the table. It's really I like games that that go up.

Yeah. And and it's quite like very beautiful to see especially when you finish your um the game and your your board is all built up and down different colors. Uh it's it's very it's very pretty to look at. Yeah.

So let's talk about the arguments against harmonies now.

Um so my first things is going to be uh the scoring card. Uh it's a little bit of a lack of a draw. So while in Cascadia you're building your um your park to score a certain point. So you can almost kind of like having your strategy having your knowing where you want to go and how you want to do it. Of course you got the market you don't know what is coming out but fair enough. Um in armonies um you start placing your your towels having your board that is uh smaller and quite confined. you can't really you can't go out of it. Um, as soon as you put something on the board, that's very much stays what it is. And if you don't have a space for a blue tile and all the scoring cards needs blue tile, that's it. Good luck. You can't Yeah, you're not. And on the other side of that, exactly the same luck of the draw wise, you might just pull a card that you've already scored and you could just get very lucky in that way.

Yeah. And just automatically automatically score the cards and making a bunch of points. It's rare, but it does it does happen. And it goes into the into the things. All right, I'm building like this. If I can get a card similar to that, I'm going to draft it. Um but yes and again the draft thing is um it's quite is quite based on luck because again the the cards are coming out. So months before you get the cards that you wanted to score there's going to be another cards coming out. God knows what it is and it might be that it's a million points all together for you without really doing anything. Or it could be like you cannot score any of the cards in the market and you need to keep waiting for it.

Harmonies is also a more restrictive game than Cascadia. So if you like the freedom of being able to kind of do what you want, you don't get that here. It is a very fixed width. So and a very fixed height. So if you it might feel a little bit restrictive, a little bit um more punishing because if you do make a mistake, you can't just

top that's it. It's that bit is blocked off. You're done. You're cooked. Yes. So there is that as well. Um the other things is harmonies is more complicated in your head in terms of like in terms of like how are you scoring and when you you when you're taking a card okay you need to understand the pattern that you need to score how the to build the pattern um at the start of the game especially with people that are not used to this kind of game can be a little bit more complicated to explain it to them because certain type of tiles can go on top of each others cannot. not like the the river, the blue one, you can't put anything on top of that. Um the brown the the the the trees you can stack up to to two and then put a green on top.

Uh the mountains it

it takes a little bit longer to understand how to

It is nowhere near as accessible as Cascadia is. Like it is significantly less accessible.

Yes. Yes. It's still an accessible game, but I think for non-gamers, this is

I would not take it out with Yeah. If no one on my table with three people that never played a game, I'll definitely go for Cascadia um rather than than Armonies. But maybe between us, we will pick Armonies.

Maybe. Yeah. Yeah.

Boom. Let's discuss about it.

Let's do it.

So, Wayne, um we're toward the end of this conversation, so um let's wrap it up. What are our recommendations? So, both of these games come in at a very similar price point. Harmonies is slightly cheaper. You can find this under the 30 mark. Uh Cascadia you'll find just over the 30 mark,

but we're talking about

within5. So, between5 to£10 each uh of each other. Um, in general, if you prefer much less uh conflict, if you want more space, if you want a more forgiving, accessible game to play with family, maybe non- gamers, if you're playing with new gamers, uh, and you want the more classical feel, Cascadia, I think, is the obvious recommendation. If you are more of a board gamer and you want something that is going to give you more of a spatial puzzle, give you more restrictions, give you potentially slightly more punishing play, I think Harmonies has got to be the one that you would pick.

Yeah. So, if you want to play with your mom, Cascadia. Uh or if you want to have a relaxing evening where you having your cup of tea or or a or a hot chocolate, um definitely Cascadia. harmonies is is for the for the next for the next level in terms of complexity. But again, then it depends on the uh on the mood of the night because it's sometimes I don't want to play harmonies because

uh I don't want to be there like

crunch crunching my brain to think about patterns and

maximizing efficiency. I just want to have a nice time.

Yeah, exactly. So I do think that they both have um space in the collection. That's why they're both in the collection.

Yeah.

Um,

but I want to just add the note that Cascadia wheat landmarks probably for me goes a little bit higher than Ammon itself.

There we go. So that's with a little bit of extra spice on there coming in at the end with a flying kick just there like

Yeah, exactly. But that's my favorite my personal flavor. But what's which one would you pick instead of uh

Well, Matt, let's do this. I'm going to put these up and on three

on the count of three, we're going to point to the one that we would pick on game nights if we were

on game on a on a random game night. Okay.

Okay. Ready? One, two, three.

That was

That was easy.

Easy.

But with landmarks,

but with Matt with landmarks.

Oh, if if if it's just the core box, I'll go like this.

Okay. Fair enough. Fair enough. Now, let me explain my reasoning. Um, I think Harmonies is fantastic and I'm surprised how well it's done honestly. Uh, it's flying up like the people's favorite game. It's becoming again a bit of an evergreen. People saying it's literally a replacement in some way.

Yeah, in some way. In some way it is.

In some ways it is. But I still think Cascadasia has this classical evergreen feeling. It's a game that feels like it's always been around. And I think that is

it has a certain eternal quality.

Yes, it does. It does. um which I don't think Harmonies quite has in the same way despite it being an excellent game.

Yeah. Um so for me is the argument is Cascadia on its own. Uh I played it too many times.

That's totally fair.

Uh Cascadia with landmarks without those a couple of like extra rules that make the games a little bit more crunchier. Uh with the different scoring um cars then is a little bit more crunchier again. Uh, I I will go for that. But core box to core box at the moment, Armonist gives me a little bit more little bit more depth.

A little bit more that a little bit more of um uh funkiness.

So, this is the debut episode of Cardboard Combat.

Interesting one it was.

Yeah.

Get over here. Uh but we would love to know from you which one would you pick as your winner

for your game night for for this episode

between Harmonies and Cascadia. Do let us know in the comments below and the reason why you would pick one over the other.

Yeah.

Uh but more importantly, man.

Yeah. I want to know which one is going to be the next match. You decide. You tell us which are the next two contenders that you want to on board game combat.

Yeah, absolutely. pick two games, same January or or same that you you guys think are up similar and we'll have a discussion about them.

Absolutely. Uh if you'd like to hear more from B stupid combat or not, then please do check out the Patreon page. Uh we've got so much exclusive stuff on there just for patrons, including a monthly giveaway just for patrons of all the games that we get from uh from publishers. Uh also access to our super secret WhatsApp group. the WhatsApp group. That is fantastic. Just the best. Hello, WhatsApp fam. Uh you make my days wonderful. It's so super nice.

And I can check the chat during very boring meetings. Very boring. Really makes my day. Absolutely. It really does. Uh and so much more, Matt, including a monthly exclusive podcast and industry interviews and a monthly update. So much.

Yeah, exactly. It's a lot of price.

Yeah, exactly. Otherwise, if you've done that or you don't want to do that, it's really really good for us as well if you just hit the subscribe button.

No combat required.

No. And maybe that's going to make Wayne's voice coming back.

Sorry.

Uh I've been sick.

But yeah, tell us what you think about this episode of this first episode of the the ball game combat.

Absolutely. Car combat. Ding the bell. Check out the rest of our videos. We'll see you on the next one.

Ciao. What's the pink game we'll use for you and me? What's the pink? Here's what you should play and see.

Progress saved