Skip to main content
Loading video...

Everdell - Ranking the Expansions and Complete Collection | with Jason

Transcript 23:29

yo my peoples what's up welcome to the One Stop Co-op shop Jason here and today I am ranking expansions for everdel everdel is a worker placement and Tableau building Style game in which you are playing the cutest of Woodland creatures and trying to build the biggest most attractive Village in the land you can be placing those workers and Gathering resources you're going to be using those resources to acquire cards Critters and constructions that work together you're here for the combos if you can execute those card combos the best then you'll get the most prestige and win the game I love this game solo and I love this game multiplayer it is the perfect weight for me uh it's not light it's not heavy it is right in the middle just like Goldilocks everdale is one of those games that is probably going to be in my collection for a very very long time as I've recorded this in 2022 there are five big box expansions available as well as additional content and I'm going to go ahead and describe them all and rank them here in this video I like all the expansions so why am I ranking them because we see what you want here in the OneStop Co-op shop audience you like Marie rank stuff so here you go a ranking video of everdale with all the expansions let's get to it disclaimer I've worked with Starling games and tabletop Tycoon for a number of years and I've gotten expansions of everdel as review copies throughout that time including all these expansions that I'm about to present

my number six expansion for Evadale is New Leaf this is for the gamer who felt constrained or had those little points of frustration with the basic game you were going for a certain combo but the other card of that combo didn't show up you had your eye on a special event and other players ninjaed the second card that you needed to get that pair New Leaf says no problem and adds multiple paths to Victory so this might be of most interest to a lot of Gamers who wanted more Village cards you get a ton of New Village cards and the way they work is that they don't pair just one to another they go with any so that you get something and then any uh unique would be able to get you that for free the greenhouse you'd be able to summon any green card so that's not unlimited you only get three opportunities at that but these golden occupy tokens but that's plenty you should be able to do anything that you need to do production wise with the improved New Leaf cards you want more abundance New Leaf has it for you this is an expanded Meadow called the station where you'll get a card and you'll be able to get an extra resource along with that card and there's plenty more of these train car tokens where that came from you have these visitor cards which are like special events so if you miss out on the base game special events you got plenty more for you you also have these tokens which allow you to reserve a card and then another point during the season you could play the card into your city at a resource

discount you have these tickets which two times per game allow you to move meatballs kind of a train that lets you go all around the city if you're shot out of one path that new Leaf gives you many many tools to go another way now my personal preference is to have those constraints and maximize what I have so the new Leaf play style isn't quite resonant with what I'm used to but there are other Gamers out there that might Delight in having so many options it's my number six expansion but it might be higher for you my number five is the Belfair expansion this is the board that I've attached to the top of the main board so more Pathways to points an abundance Paradigm not as much as new Leaf but that's the direction in which you're going so a little bit of competitiveness here in the Garland Festival you get points for first and second another basic event this one I like because there's trading you place your worker here you get the thing and if you place your worker there a second time on a future turn you can trade the thing for points and random resources to get a little bit of exchange there this is a nice little wrinkle doesn't add too much overhead folds into any game Belfair also added a couple of really cool miniature modules that I think fold into any game uh first of all you get the different special events which are a little bit more General when you have a nice fat deck where you can't get the combos that you're looking for for the

more constrained special events you want these more general ones the other thing you get and at this point this is kind of a thing that is included in all later expansions but Belfair started it player Powers so you trade your meeple that you get in spring for a power that you can do and so it's a little bit of a mixed bag because it's a work replacement game you want to be able to place that additional worker but the trade is that you can focus a little bit more so if you are focused on production the snails might be for you the Stokes allow you to discard cars to get stuff so if you notice your game is leading a certain way and you can coordinate that with your power it feels really good player powers are excellent in my opinion

thank you my number four are the assorted extras from the collector's edition of the base game so promos you can get of all sorts of different places if you want to go to the BHD store sometimes different cons they always have inventive little packs that you can add into flavor up that Village deck these two pieces come with the collector's edition of the base game I understand that everybody has a collector's edition and there is a separate pack you can get called the glimmer gold pack I think well maybe you can get it like with a lot of these things availability is uh kind of iffy you might be stuck with getting the Collector's Edition in order to get these two pieces but if you can swing it then I think it's worth it these are extra cards that add complexity kind of like the how the promo cards work you add them in and they flavor up your game this is the main star though that I'm referring to which is the legendaries so legendaries will interact with basic cards in the game so you have your queen which can be upgraded and to amila glissendu and then you have uh you know the teacher and different cards in terms of the critters the constructions like the Clock Tower and the dungeon can get upgraded to dark key prison I think that's awesome anything that adds extra flavor and it definitely does that by making your village particular and extra mechanisms these are more powerful versions of those other cards sign me up love the legendaries

thank you my number three expansion for everdel is Pearl Brook so you have decide what that goes here on the left side of the board and you also get the very cute frog Ambassador meatballs one Perfection the way it works is that the space is only open when you meet the preconditions in your city this is a hoity toity faction that needs you to have some kind of reputation before you visit Three production two Wanderers Etc so then when you have it you can visit and then they reveal an ability to pay some of your resources to get pearls pearls are extremely valuable more valuable than any resource in the game they allow you to fire off your adornment which is a one-time power this is very very powerful personal thing you can do the pearls are also good to get these improved wonders which replace the basic events so then you can go for that hope watch gate get some points there or you can shoot the moon gather a whole bunch of resources throughout the course of the game and get that star falls flame now some Gamers will find this frustrating because you have to gather a lot of resources it's easy to miss certain parts so like if you go for this then you might not have the city that you want you really have the strength being together however my phrase for this is puzzled to pay off if you can solve the puzzle and get everything that you need getting that 25 Point score or even a 20-point score can be really satisfying nothing else in everdale gives you that shot of point just at the end of the game so for that experiential thing Pearl book is my number three

all right foreign expansion for everdel is the Spire Crest expansion so you get these cute little walking rabbit meeples one Perfection you don't interact with this board during your main worker placement and card play phases it kicks in during the prepare for season so then when you do so you're gonna travel the path you're gonna get one of these Travelers tokens to add to your personal row you're gonna have access to improved powers spider Crest tends to be the kind of expansion that I like because it adds Challenge and it also adds good stuff the challenge is a twofold one you have to contend with weather so then this is a bad thing uh Forest occasion may not be visited during the winter it's winter uh spring summer fall also have additional challenges also as you gather more of these as you travel through the path at the end game you need to be able to satisfy all these conditions in order to get the full effect if you satisfy this one but not this one then you don't get anything past that a nice thing to balance there but you also get good stuff along the way you can purchase these improved powers or improved worker spaces or my favorite thing which definitely traps me you see that there are some cars that have the big Critter you put a saddle on them and then an improved worker thematically mechanically I love what spider Crest does

thank you my number one expansion by far for Emmerdale is the Mist wood expansion now I'm a solo player this is a Solo Channel so that is a length to which I am making this assessment the base game of everdale had a bot the rugwort which provided this kind of static Wall of Resistance it was okay kind of felt like you were playing Evadale on your own which was fine for the time the Knight we've bought is much more Dynamic the workers are plentiful and they're going to spaces where you want to be there's an automa deck which is very easy to implement you play a card and you just do what it says and it goes to different places depending on what you want to do you want to gather resources too bad they're there you want to get a special event or a rush towards finishing your city too bad it's there the night we've bought does it all in a pretty intelligent way and you also have nightweave herself yes welcome to my Lair do you accept the challenge if you want you can play with nightweave and the workers in any game of everdale including the bigger expansions you just have the ottoman deck I find that the best way to experience this spot in its fullness is to take out all the expansions and play with the personality cards so if they don't fold into the other stuff for various reasons but when you open this up you have personality for the big night weave meepa herself she enters the metal and does something bad to you she will present turned by a season by season ploys long term plots

which get in your way either providing Global effects or buffing the workers or doing something else that's nasty to you this is my absolute favorite way to play everdel I love the game in its entirety I love the bigger expansions but if I'm just gonna throw down with one single game of evidel it's going to be with the Knight we've bought with the plots ploys and personality my favorite and that's not all when it comes to the overall missed wood expansion it adds a lot of things that I've mentioned previously that I like as well it adds extra cards in this particular case improved forms you swap out the boring Farms that you get and you have a different upgraded Farms we see that a more complicated text I like that that's pretty cool it adds more legendary cards I like the legendary expansion and you get a few more of those Miss Wood it to me is a no-brainer for a solo player finally a little bonus here this is not an expansion there's a little piece I'm calling a commitment to cuteness every single expansion adds more animals and it adds six of each of the Meatballs I'm only showing the pears because quite frankly they don't fit on my screen if I lay them all out but you get a whole pile at the end and you have all sorts of lovely animals snails and bees and I think these are foxes bats butterflies uh the commitment to an adorable presentation an inviting presentation is just unmatched fantastic everything that I've shown in this video so far has come from the everdale collectors edition as well as all the expansions that are all available in retail so then as you can see everything

that I own for this game fits in these two boxes what you are looking at is gameplay all in so about the children's collectors edition but I wanted to point out that if that's all you're interested in then these two packages that you can get at retail will serve you just fine and so here is the everdel complete collection so you might have seen this on Kickstarter raised a whole bunch of money for it once again this has all the gameplay that you need it fits in these two boxes but if you want that Deluxe experience and I'll open the box in just a second then the complete collection is there for you just for a sense of scale look at my box of gloomhaven it's even bigger than that holy moly so taking a look inside first thing you see is this nice package laying out exactly that you get everything that has to do with Emmerdale including all the expansions and where to store it so then more games should definitely do this and you know constructing the tree and the different wonders uh really guides you through so the first thing is this box of adornments and wonders which allows you to maintain their construction if they're in the two boxes you got to kind of take them apart and put it back together not everybody favorite that's there for you so then this piece right here is the tree which if you're like me you don't play with the tree because this thing is super inconvenient to put together and it gets in the way but uh you can just kind of put it in here you have it in case you want to make a nice looking one that is all good all right so uh this is

where all of the animals are and as you can see I have them stickered up this took a super long time to do because you're stickering all the animals all the critters you can get the stickers separately you don't have to get the complete collection in order to get all these nice stickers but it's a nice bonus there for you and a good solution for the animals so then next up you actually have this grooved in here for the rule book sometimes big boxes will come and they don't give you space for the rule but kind of throwing it on top nope this is molded so that you can just fit the rulebook big thick rule book lots of card explanations in there next up is all the little bits once again you have a carry case that accommodates everything so this is really cool for storage I find it inconvenient in terms of actual play on the table that's something I would want is like little things to put them in guess what they sell that separately as well all right getting a little bit further in now we get to actually I'll talk about this for us to talk about the cards so uh nothing too uh exciting or fancy here uh all the cards promos that come with uh the the through every season from I think it's a Mist wood uh the extra extra cars that come in the legendary set everything uh comes together including uh now this is a little bonus that I believe is only available here and elsewhere

uh these are alternative Farms so uh some years ago everdale got in a little bit of trouble when people observed that there was only options for a husband and a wife in terms of like a spousal connection so that was uh came from the designers James and Clarissa Wilson they wanted to kind of put themselves in there as an Easter egg here's a design you can do whatever you want and they took that ass as kind of heartwarming thing but there was a controversy where well there's a husband and a wife why can't there be a husband and a husband a wife and a wife same-sex marriage different alternative means of getting together so you know there was a conversation about that and how the designers and Publishers um kind of navigated that was that they first of all they changed future printings and is now no longer the husband and wife it is the Harvester and The Gatherer a lot of the cars have been changed for them and now you have the opportunity to personalize your experience so so these are blank you can write yours in and have your own husband and wife combo and so many different you see piles and piles of cards so that one little thing that people had an issue with everdel they managed to turn into I guess it was about the best solution that they could so I'm glad that they're listening and finally we have the board so we have one custom insert these are the player boards as well as the missile expansion you have your score uh the bag for New Leaf right there and I never even thought of this this is

kind of we're about the bottom right here uh I'll open this up and we have the board so you're looking at the Belfair board right now and then the different boards are in there for the base game uh and everything else this right here is felt so I was like wow this is the thing that kind of gets in there you know the components whatever whatever but this can get kind of scratched up pretty easily if you put them in and out but you have like a felt border here to preserve uh the Integrity of the boards they thought of everything so I am definitely not a deluxe person as a matter of fact I'll be completely honest I got this as a review copy from uh tabletop Tycoon because I covered evidence over the years I was perfectly happy and will still be perfectly happy with the uh those two boxes full of game however if you can swing the deluxe version whether you uh got it on the kickstarter or Amazon eBay or whatever other um this will be sold I really think you're getting your money's worth and a lot of thought went to this so that is the complete collector's edition of everdel so now I'm going to go ahead and address a question which comes up frequently which is can you play all those expansions together in one big massive game of everdale so a couple of reasons for that number one the product model all those sideboards fit around the beam board to make this one big Mega everdel

which barely fits on my table as you can see from that picture but really let's be honest it's just you and me here when I read that question on forums more often not it comes from a spirit of I don't want to be bothered shuffling and unshuffling and you know combining the sets and looking out to all those little icons and I just want to be able to shuffle it all together and throw it on the table it's the path release resistance and it also takes advantage of all the money we spend uh people want to know that they're getting their money's worth it doesn't feel right to spend 30 40 bucks on an expansion and you have to go through all the rig and roll to play it and you could probably only play it once because really uh we have so many games how often really am I going to play this am I going to get my money's worth from the expansion and is it going to be user friendly for me as a gamer I understand all that uh but I have to say the big Mega expansion of everdel wasn't that fun I did try it and a couple of things happen first of all um the designer is open about saying this has not been play tested at all I can feel that you know we played the game and it was fine you know it you know scores happened uh but there could be something lurking in all the the admixture that just breaks the game makes it collapse so that's number one from an experiential perspective the way that expansions are constructed is that you kind of have to go for whatever is there in order to truly take advantage you know due to Pearl Brook you got to either get a bunch of pearls and get

those wonders or ignore uh what's going on there if you're doing spider Crest you gotta you know make sure that you complete that path which might mean you focus a little bit and ignore what's going on there so why have everything shuffled together and set up if you're gonna ignore big parts of what you've already presented now I can see the counter argument it's there for me if I choose that's okay but the thing is I chose and if I want to you know play differently than I play differently the next game it's there for me to explore hey it is your game you do what you want for me and for answering that question of whether it is truly worth it to play all those big expansions together and keep them all shuffled together it made me appreciate more just having the one expansion Pearl brook or spider crust or whatever module and throw in kind of modular pieces here and there like player powers or legendary cards for that um mixing of the experience that's my favorite way to play everdel not necessarily that big bloated expanded thing and so that is my coverage for all things everdale at least at the present time according to the designer publisher this is it uh for this iteration of everdel will we get a new iteration in five years ten years from 10th anniversary edition whereas new content who knows uh or is it going to be a Donald X factorino situation where it's like oh you know what this is the last Dominion set and then a couple years later boom Another Dominion set who

knows uh all I know is that there is enough um different play Styles uh different ways of approaching it uh and just depth of gameplay to last year a very very long time if you decide to go all in either on the gameplay package or the complete collection it's a game that is going to be in my collection for a very very long time this Jason with the One-Stop Co-op shop reminding that we will see you at the next stop

Progress saved