Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood of Venice Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood of Venice
Reviewers see Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood of Venice as a stealth-first campaign game that lives or dies by its license. The strongest praise comes from 3 Minute Board Games, which describes the game as the stealth-first core of V-Sabotage blended with the Assassin's Creed universe, and says the blend works "stunningly well." Liz Davidson of Beyond Solitaire approaches it from the design side, pointing out that the game comes from the same team behind V Commandos and applies that team's game system to a new setting.
Agreement is strongest on the theme and the stealth loop, while opinions split on the experience of learning and sustaining the campaign. Liz Davidson is openly enthusiastic in the tutorial episodes, praising how the rules open up gradually. Robert, AzureDeath | Solo Board Gaming was far less forgiving. They eventually traded their retail copy after finding the rulebook and campaign structure frustrating, though they acknowledge that others count it among their favorites. 3 Minute Board Games sits in the middle, calling the rulebook "a bit of a mess" while recommending the game to players who want a full campaign with heavy stealth and planning.
Physical scale is another point of discussion. 3 Minute Board Games warns that the box is large and crowded with miniatures, making it a real financial commitment, although the retail version relies on standees for most of its figures. Robert's retail copy used standees in the same way.
Core Mechanics That Define Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood of Venice
Hidden Movement and Detection
The central system is concealment. Each assassin starts with a base in their player color, and once spotted, that base is replaced with a red one. Every time an assassin enters a square containing enemies, the player makes a detection roll, and the wrong symbol on the red die reveals the assassin. Raising the alarm makes those rolls far more dangerous, spawns more enemies, and turns the whole board against the crew. Liz Davidson explains that an assassin who moves away from every enemy can become concealed again, leaving the red base behind as a marker of where they were last seen, and enemies then head toward those markers. Exposed assassins face a further risk: when one leaves a square containing enemies, half of those enemies, rounded up, hunt them, and the player chooses which half. Concealment is also tied to the body economy, since hiding corpses costs an action and enemies who walk into a hidden body may or may not notice it.
Action Points
Each assassin spends a small budget of action cubes, and reviewers emphasize how much planning those few actions demand. Assassins can act in any order, which lets a player interleave moves across the crew. Liz Davidson notes that a leap of faith costs nothing, that Claudio's hidden blade can eliminate a guard for zero actions once per turn while incognito, and that Daria's special ability lets a player return an unused cube to an assassin who has spent their allotment while staying hidden. A later memory introduces a "save an action" option, where a cube is spent on a special spot on the board to bank a fourth action for an upcoming turn. Costs vary by ability: a parachute takes two cubes to glide between rooftops, while hiding bodies or opening a chest takes one.
The Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood of Venice Experience
Tension When the Alarm Goes Off
Reviewers consistently describe a shift in tempo once the alarm is raised. 3 Minute Board Games says that changing rhythm is one of the game's best features, so players spend early turns trying to get as far as possible before the alarm, and "adjusting your plans for a badly timed alarm is a cornerstone of the game." Liz Davidson describes the same pressure during play, noting that the detection rolls are "a lot more dicey" once guards are on alert. The reinforcement system reinforces the mood, since an alerted board draws enemies from a far more aggressive column of the reinforcement card. The tension is sustained rather than spiky, because the state of the alarm shapes every decision that follows.
Feeling Like an Assassin
The second feeling is thematic fidelity. Reviewers keep returning to small details that echo the video games: hay piles where assassins hide, rooftop escapes, towers where synchronization reveals new map information, and a hidden blade that delivers a satisfying kill. 3 Minute Board Games credits the designers with paying "loving attention" to what made the franchise unique. Liz Davidson's accounts are full of the same delight, from the thrill of a quiet takedown to the fun of hiding a body in the haystack for no cost. Even the miniatures earn praise from Liz Davidson, who admits to never having painted one but still finds these very appealing.
What Makes Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood of Venice Stand Out
A Stealth Engine Built for a Campaign
Reviewers see the stealth loop as the game's clearest strength. 3 Minute Board Games praises the "excellent core stealth first, combat second" gameplay of V-Sabotage and recommends the game to players who want stealth and planning above all. Liz Davidson argues that the same design team's system transfers cleanly into the new setting, and the walkthroughs show a single turn combining climbing, quiet kills, and body disposal. The campaign context gives those choices weight, since objectives, alarm state, and the assassins' progress all carry forward from one memory to the next.
Discovery Through Sealed Envelopes and Rewards
The campaign's secrets are its other major draw. Liz Davidson explains that envelopes are opened by reading a large red card first, and that players are not supposed to look ahead, so reveals keep their impact. Synchronizing at a tower adds new objectives and chests to the map mid-memory, and completed memories earn experience tracked in a Diary of Memories where players place stickers for achievements. 3 Minute Board Games frames the appeal in terms of legacy-style progression that does not require destroying components, suggesting it suits players who like opening new material but dislike tearing things up. Liz Davidson is similarly eager to see what happens as the assassins level up.
Potential Drawbacks
A Rulebook That Demands Patience
The most consistent criticism concerns the learning experience. Robert argues that the rulebook uses numbered rules points rather than conventional page numbers, reads like a translation, and does not answer the questions that arise during play. Robert also describes the scenario pacing breaking down when a batch of new rules arrives around the fourth or fifth scenario, after the gradual introduction had been working. The digital dice tutorial frustrated Robert as well, since a code included in the box did nothing in the app and the tutorial assumed the Kickstarter edition, which differs from the retail version. 3 Minute Board Games agrees the rulebook is messy. Liz Davidson's approach of introducing rules in stages through the opening memories is the most patient answer to the problem, though even Liz Davidson moves back and forth between the rulebook and the campaign booklet to work out setup.
Harsh Failure and Heavy Investment
Once the alarm sounds, the game can turn unforgiving. Robert describes missions collapsing very early, sometimes on the first turn after an unlucky roll. Robert objects most strongly to the apprentice mechanic, in which a failed mission sends players into weaker substitute assassins instead of the character they have been developing. 3 Minute Board Games similarly warns that the game "can get flat out mean" once the alarm is raised, and says stealth players need resilience to cope. Both reviewers point to the investment required: 3 Minute Board Games describes a large box crowded with miniatures, which makes the game a serious commitment in money and shelf space, and the retail edition's standees help control that cost without eliminating it.
If You Enjoy Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood of Venice
V-Sabotage is the clearest next step. 3 Minute Board Games notes that the two games share a similar design, and that Assassin's Creed takes the stealth-first core of V-Sabotage and wraps it in the franchise's universe. Players who want the same mechanical engine in a different setting will find it familiar, and the comparison makes V-Sabotage a natural companion piece.
V Commandos is the other natural pairing. Liz Davidson calls it a game that is really enjoyable and points out that it comes from the same design team, so anyone who appreciates the planning in V Commandos is likely to recognize its DNA here.
For players who want more open combat, 3 Minute Board Games recommends Batman Gotham City Chronicles as the fightier alternative. It suits groups who would rather confront enemies directly than slip past them, making it a useful contrast to the stealth-heavy experience of Brotherhood of Venice.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"The best thing about this game is it really feels like Assassin's Creed. As a thematic experience it pays loving attention to what made Assassin's Creed unique, right down to jumping in those little hay piles."
3 Minute Board Games
"I hated that. Why don't you just let me keep using my assassin? Now I know that I could house rule it and I know sometimes people say that but that that's not my job."
Robert, AzureDeath | Solo Board Gaming
"Once per turn, if I'm being incognito, use my hidden blade for zero actions, and my hidden blade lets me eliminate one guard on my square."
Liz Davidson, Beyond Solitaire