Skip to main content
Loading video...

My biggest Solo Board Gaming Disappointments and Pleasant Surprises of 2023!

Transcript 34:26

hello everyone welcome I'm Robert and today I want to list my biggest disappointments as well as most pleasant surprises as far as solo board games go for the year of 2023 so some of these games I don't own any longer so I'm not going to use a camera for this video I'm just going to keep it Audio Only and uh I also want to go ahead and start with um my biggest disappointments so that I can end on a positive note uh with my biggest pleasant surprises so without further Ado let's get started all right first we have Skyrim the adventure game and this is one of the first games that I reviewed on my channel I do have a full video review for it so I'll leave a link if you're interested uh and yeah this game was a gigantic let down it it really really um did not make me um it really did not make me feel positive things at all uh through throughout the whole experience honestly uh pretty much uh uh there are a couple good things about it but uh all of the negative aspects really just were overwhelming so you know so feel free to watch the video for a more in-depth uh explanation of everything but gosh where do I start I mean like the the most obvious thing the most glaring issue with the game is the rule book uh so uh the rule book is just one of those uh cases where it makes you go through so much work

learning it and there's just no reward I did not feel rewarded going through the trouble of learning this game uh it it really just once you start playing it uh rules questions are you know start arising immediately and the rule book just does nothing to address them it's just poorly organized uh it's just a poor learning experience to begin with and then you start playing it and all of these things start happening and you're like okay what am I supposed to do here and there's no answer in in the rulebook and even when you go to the polishers website and I check occasionally by the way because it it still shocks me in the state in which they left this game right so you go to the polisher website and uh the the FAQ section is pretty much almost B basically the same as as it was uh like when I shot that video which is nuts um uh I I don't know how they could leave the game in that state uh I don't know uh now I'll say though um there is another game from this publisher that I started playing recently uh which I will definitely be making a video on soon and I I do I did have a much better experience uh so uh you'll see that you know if you're one of my Subs one of my subscribers you'll see that video soon but I so yeah um in in this case though with this game um it's just one of those cases where it's it's just a very poor use of the IP uh you know if if I was tasked with making something based on on

that IP it would you know I would do everything in my power for it to be Immaculate and just you know there's so many issues with this game the the the rule book is atrocious The Learning Experience is atrocious the the price point is absurd the the price point is absurd for this game what you get for that price is is not even the the value is just uh abysmal for what you get the fact that uh they left uh a couple of the races out from the base game for you to choose uh the tiny tokens it's just bizarre uh what you know like if I don't know what the thesa is doing with the way that they're handling their IP U but whatever uh so uh the the short the the short of it is if you want a a broken game at launch experience uh I still stand by that sentence if you want a broken at launch video game experience Bethesda style uh they translated that in board game form and I don't know why anybody would do that such a cool beloved IP and this is what the people get uh I really don't understand uh but uh I still have not managed to trade the game I I've wanted to trade it for a while U still haven't still haven't gotten any takers but uh and I was hoping since I haven't traded it yet that maybe they would do like a overhaul of the rule book hasn't happened yet uh it's been a year and as of the recording of This hasn't happen but you know maybe they will and I'll

give it another shot but yeah uh just so all the all the work that you go through learning this game with its unclear and poorly organized rule books it just doesn't pay off but you know if you're enjoying it you know I'm happy for you go for it just wasn't for me just just many more adventuring games I'd rather play so that's uh that's Skyrim the adventuring game uh definite pass and yeah uh and I stopped playing it uh like into the first week of the year and yeah not the great not the greatest way to start the year as far as solo board games go but uh yeah so that's Skyrim The Adventure again next we have Assassin's Creed Brotherhood of Venice which I started playing just a few weeks after the disappointment that was Skyrim so there's another board game based on a video game IP and I'm not coming I didn't come to it from a huge Assassin's Creed fan perspective I've played a few Assassin's Creed games and I enjoy them all right but I'm not a super fan or anything I haven't even finish an Assassin's Creed game but um you know I did want to give another one of these board Gam game video game adaptations a try right so it's not that Skyrim turned me off from them completely so I got the retail I saw it on sale for a huge discount uh reason I got it uh and uh so I got the retail version which comes with standies for the most part uh so the only mines you

get for the most part are the Assassin minutes the Assassin character player minis but pretty much everything else is uh standies and the the at the beginning the game did uh it did give me a positive vibes right so I was enjoying it at the beginning it's one of those big campaign uh games all right with you know tons of scenarios and progression so it's a campaign Legacy game uh and uh at the beginning was okay so it introduces the rules to you slowly but one of the things that bothered me from the beginning was the fact that um the dice tutorial was poorly implemented because uh the box came with a code that uh that didn't really do anything like I don't know because I don't use the dice app a whole lot so uh I wasted my time using the code because it didn't do anything in the app when I downloaded it and like it it didn't literally didn't do anything it wasn't the tutorial wasn't working properly on mobile so it was just giving me issues so I just went on a computer instead of the uh my phone and it worked properly on the browser and without me having to use the code so what was the point of the code and then I go and the tutorial assumes that you have the kickstarter uh copy and there's some differences between the retail and the kickstarter copy uh that made it a bit confusing learning through dice uh

so well the reason I bring that up is because this game is confusing to learn already and that ticked me off I already kind of hated having to waste my time with the dice app code and then going when I finally get to use it there's differences when you see the tutorial versus the retail version that um made it more confusing so that's one thing then uh one another thing that I uh greatly disliked was the fact that the rule book didn't use Pages page numbers it used this format where it's like rules points so you go to you check the index and you go to a rules points but there's no proper page per se so it was a very unconventionally formatted rule book because I have never in my life I'm sure that there's another board game that has done this but I have not read a rule book that is structured like this and I don't know why they decided to do it it was just confusing and annoying um so yeah so it made the experience The Learning Experience even more annoying that it needed to be and it was a translation rule book so it it it felt like a translation rule book because there were certain things that felt unclear so it it the fact that it was a translation rule book came across so it's one of these games where it asks you to put all of this work right and initially it's like okay I'm having fun this is cool but then as it introduced you as it introduces the rules later on uh at the beginning the Cadence is is fine it it's slowly walking you through

the rules one by one with the scenarios which some board games do this like jws of the lion each scenario each scen iio will introduce you the rules meal piece and that was working great at the beginning but then if I remember correctly by the four or fifth scenario like he just added a bunch of rules like out of nowhere right so instead of you know keeping this nice slow meal peac meal Pace with the rules it all of a sudden just vomits a bunch of rules and it just made it so confusing and even when I got over that then later the the uh failing upwards mechanic I hate it in this game because uh instead of just play if you if you fail in this game if you if you fail a mission you stop playing with your assass your assassin your proper assassin character you you you're not supposed to a use your proper assassin that you've been using the whole time they assign you these apprentices right so you're not using your proper assassin character you while you heal quote unquote you get to retry the mission with apprentices and if you failed the mission again then you just have to move forward right but I hated that I'm sorry I hated that why don't you just let me keep using my assassin now I know that I could house rule it and I know sometimes people say that but that that's not my job I'm sorry like I don't know from like the designer perspective that just doesn't sound fun to me just let me play with my character because I feel like

I'm like I'm doing something I'm not supposed to do like game says you're supposed to play with an apprentice like I'm sure probably there's a reason for that so I don't want to mess around with that so that's what the game says right but that just sounded so unfun to me like why are you making me play with these uh apprentices which are inferior uh they they are inferior to your assassin character they have less capabilities so uh so I hated that and then then uh one thing that started bothering me and it is a common complaint of the game um you know one once you lose your uh stealth status like if the alarm goes off the the mission just goes to hell pretty much like really quick um and it can happen really early on if you're just unlucky with the dice roll and you just alert the bad guys you know it it the stealth aspect just goes out the window like and it can happen in the first turn and it did happen a couple times and it's really it was really annoying so uh you know so all that work through learning the the game with you know this translation rule book that was just miserable to learn that wasn't formatted uh conventionally uh and also you know the it compounded with the uh you know the fact that it just it it tossed out the window the nice spacing of introducing the rules uh and the fact that it you know

if you fail ad Mission you don't play with your uh main character anymore all of that stuff added up and I just gave up on the game it's like not I'm not doing this anymore so I just I just I just uh packaged it and I put it up for trade and eventually I traded it so it was a huge disappointment and again it's just one of those games which it it really live left a really bad taste in my mouth because it it makes you go through all that work and it did not feel rewarding at all so it was just as bad as Skyrim in that regard U so Skyrim made me go through all that work did I I did not feel rewarded in the slightest uh so uh same thing happened with this game and and this game appears to be uh some of people's favorite games I can see I can see how someone could like it um I just you know my experience was just not great unfortunately um so yeah uh and and I I do I do like the idea of the use of stealth it can be fun but that whole part of where like the the stealth aspect can just be over in the first turn if you get a bad role it's it's just yeah I I can't can't deal with that but yeah another disappointment this year so that's Assassin's Creed Brotherhood of Venice all right I'm moving on to my last big disappointment this year is uh tiny epic Dungeons and I did make a video on this where I explained why I ended up calling it I still haven't been able to trade it

by the way but yeah I decided for for good that I just don't ever want to play that game again uh so if you haven't seen the video I'll leave a link but let me just kind of summarize and tell you why here uh so first I want to talk about you know my bit of a history with the tiny epic Series so uh my first tiny epic game was um tiny epic galaxies I still hugely enjoy that game to this day um and I've tried others in the series Like Pirates enjoyed it don't feel like I want to play it again so it's up on my trade file and then I have have tiny epic Defenders which I don't think I'll ever ever trade it's another one that's pretty sweet it's a great little tower defense game and I also have Quest um and yeah Quest I don't know that I'll ever play again but it's it's all right I mean it's innocent game um don't really see much wrong with it just a lot of lots of other games I'd rather play but it's okay now uh so those are all the others I had played until now right so then I get um tiny epic dungeons a lot of lots of people raving it super successful successful Kickstarter and uh I eventually got it and I get it to the table and well first uh the rule book like I don't know like what happened with the the the scope of these tiny epic games is just kind of gotten out of control uh like I I kind of I in in on paper it sounds

great like you want to put a lot of you want to put all of this stuff in a tiny box and make feel like a great game but in this case and I kind of feel like the same way with um tin epic Pirates you kind of sacrifice the the Elegance or or like the ease of getting it into a table sure it occupies less room in your shelf but gosh like the the the drawback of the drawback of of that is because you you're constraining yourself with all with the component you're having to do these gymnastics with the rules that I think that they should go through a bit more uh they should go through a bit more editing to make them a bit easier to get on the table I did enjoy tiny epic Pirates but I just don't want to ever relearn it like relearning it was miserable and learning tiny epic um uh dungeons was absolutely miserable uh I did not feel uh this issue with uh G galaxies which I love to this day and Defenders which I still love to this day I could play that it's a great little tower defense game now with tiny epic dungeons it's just confusing it's just confusing the dice tutorial did help I'll say that uh the dice tutorial is well done in this case unlike the the Assassin's Creed uh tutorial which it wasn't unnecessarily confusing because of the differences of

the kickstarter version and the retail version a tiny epic uh the tiny epic dungeons dice tutorial very well done I'll give them that it did ease the pain a bit but it's still a bit of a confusing game to learn uh and even when you do uh so again see a pattern here of of of of games that end up being disappointments for me you put all that work right because you you have to decipher this this hyperdense rule book is that is that tiny rule book that you know it's shoed in the box in there but it's is it's incredibly dense and incred L danc rule book so super tough to learn and you know you go through all of that and then you get just get your ass handed to you by the dungeon right and then you play again same thing happens you get destroyed and then I go and check the rule book and there's no way to adjust difficulty and it's like am I doing something wrong and no I'm not I'm I I check the rules I read them again no I'm not doing anything wrong I'm just playing and I'm just I'm just not even close to seeing the boss I just keep getting destroy and and and I'm like what is this what is this why is this game so difficult why um it it doesn't this these tiny epic games are not known for that so it's like this unnecessarily difficult game for no reason uh and and there's no way to adjust the difficulty and it makes you go through all that work and it's like not even you know you're

not free to export the dungeon in any capacity you have to like make all of these perfectly calculated moves to maybe even get a chance to see the boss and I'm not crazy because you can go on Board Game Geek and you'll read the same uh anecdote from a lot of people many people don't even get to see the boss this game just was incredibly brutal and I asked why why does it have to be so brutal I I really don't I really did not it really just oh it did not compute for me why does this game have to be so brutal and why can't why isn't there an official way to adjust the difficulty and there there's you know you can go on borging g and there's people that will concoct this methods for adjusting difficulty with the torch gosh that torch the the dang torch with the with the the way that it puts all of that pressure on you and and it's just too Brut too brutal too brutal for no reason tough to learn and I was just not having fun it's just that simple I was just not having fun with that game and uh to add insult to injury is the whole symbol thing the hieroglyphics of the game where you're supposed to interpret this um textless uh symbols and you know the fact that they didn't include the symbol reference in the Box oh gosh folks that that that just that just didn't rob me the wrong way like if if you you need that like you can't you shouldn't it shouldn't be a thing that you have to go and print separately it should be included in the

rule book and I I get the angle of it being easier to translate right uh more cost effective I respect that but if you're going to do that I really would have appreciated if they at least included it in the rule book so again you go to all that work and this is what you get I would just rather play so many other games at this so yeah in the TR trade pile it went and I mean if you enjoy it good for you but there's so many other better better dungeon cross than this um and yeah like I just I really want would I really wish for like this tiny epic titles to kind of going back to like the the Simplicity of um tiny epic galaxies or tiny epic Defenders these games are just becoming increasingly tough to get on the table um none of after this um I I haven't really looked at any other of the new ones and the reason for that is they just look complicated they just look complicated and I I think that in the case of tiny epic um dungeons it really needed a bit more time in the oven uh it really needed a bit more play testing uh and just a way just a bit more time in the oven to make the rule book a bit more palatable um maybe this onee cycle for these games is not doing in any favors maybe they should do twoyear gaps in between each so that they stay a bit more in the oven and you know people will get a better experience but what do I know all right right so

yeah so that's a tiny epic uh Dungeons and those were all my disappointments this year now I want to get to the biggest uh pleasant surprises uh that I had uh this year all right so let's move on to that all right so my first biggest uh surprise this year was after the virus which I already discussed in my top 20 solo war games of all time which it made it to my top 20 this year and the reason why it was such a pleasant surprise is because um you know I avoided it for such a long time because of the art which was a huge deterrent for me and you know it's not just a game that I opened it and I played it a few times and then I moved on I uh addictively and obsessively played it for a few weeks and it's just one of the best uh solo deck builders of all time uh that that I've played and it's you know the art it even grew on me to some extent I still think that the cover doesn't do it any favors as I explained in the uh in my top 20 video but uh it's just such a wonderful tight uh little deck builder and I was just not expecting to like it this much uh so uh yeah so that's uh after the virus I really and it's uh what made me introduce the dopamine Awards love that little bit um I love that little bit I'll definit definely be doing that um into the next year if if

there's a game that makes me react the way that game did that makes me play it obsessively I'll I'll keep handing out I'll hand out that award if it if it make me makes me feel like that game did but yeah so that's uh after the virus hugely recommended I do talk a bit more in detail in my top 20 videos so if you haven't watched it I recommend that you do I'll leave a link to that uh but yeah that's after the virus great little surprise of the that uh arrived on my collection this year and made it to my top 20 so great little game moving on we have shadows of Brimstone and I made a full length video on this game earlier this year uh so I'll leave a link to that if you're interested this game which I played for the first time this year it also made it to my top 20 it's um the I think it's the best Dungeon Crawler that I've played so as far as dungeon pure Dungeon Crawlers go in my collection is the top rated one for my money okay and uh so I discuss it also in my top 20 video but this game it just took me by storm this year the uh it's just one of those lifestyle games that I um as I mentioned in my uh full length video about it um I used to I did get um in I did get introduced to the Hobby the miniature painting hobby aspect through Warhammer uh many years ago but it's been dormant

for the most part I've played the occasional I've painted the occasional miniature since for solo War gaming but you know I didn't really extensively do it until this game arrived because one huge aspect that I enjoyed about the hobby is the the building aspect the um you know the it's not just the painting and lots of lots of uh board games just come with um uh sculpts with uh resin sculpts that are already pre-assembled and you just paint them and you know in general just those sculps are not as high quality and detailed as Spruce and I enjoy the sprew aspect of it you know assembling the miniature I enjoy that too uh and the upsite that you get from it from The increased quality and this game offers that so it has these beautiful Miniatures that are not overly detailed right CU a lot a lot of what happens with modern Miniatures is is that they're excessively detailed so some of that elegance and some that some of that readability from Far uh not that I'm not that I'm an expert on it okay but some of that readability uh on the table it kind of gets lost when when it's so um busy and so noisy with detail and there's a reason why uh there's those uh old Warhammer those old Warhammer Miniatures are so beloved those um you know the the green bases back in the day

um the goblin Green base era Warhammer Miniatures they're so beloved and remember nostalgically and it's just CU they're just so much they're just so much simpler and Charming right and this uh these Shadows of Brimstone Miniatures have that property uh if you haven't uh you know you can read an interview about uh the guy who work on it I think is Jason C Hill uh and you know he worked for a Games Workshop so he checks out that he he has that pedigree uh and yeah so I really love this game because of the types of Miniatures that it offers but it's not just the Miniatures the uh it's just a great dungeon crawling experience and the way that it generates Maps is just absolutely nuts uh the the the procedural generation aspect of this game is insane and it's it's it feels balanced because it's really hard to balance those things when something is so just so procedurally generated and the guy just has a way of keeping you know adjusting the values of your characters and the way that it scales uh this guy just has a some uh black sorcery black magic with his design skills where he he he has very tightly adjusted the uh the way that you scale so that you know the world scales around you as well as you as you generate Maps now I have heard that in late game it can become a bit trivial you know if your

Heroes become too strong but um there are ways of increasing difficulty even more right there's a supplements that you can buy to like get nine M level difficulty um uh you know aspects to the game if you think that it's getting too easy so there's many ways of adjusting the difficulty in the game but it's just it's just a lovely procedural procedurally generated dungeon crawling experience with campaign elements and like a it's like a campaign light it's not like um you know you can just connect scenarios and between the scenarios you visit a town and and you level up your character so it's it's not there's not an overarching narrative it's just gives you something to do in between missions and I love it there's no huge commitment campaign wise it's very easy to get back in the table if you have a decent storage solution uh yeah like I I love the hobby aspect and it it also has a very unique um box that it takes it has it's a western game with the supernatural cthulu element so very unique game in my collection great lifestyle great lifestyle um system if you want to SN hundreds of dollars into it I know I have I love it I absolutely love it I'm not a completionist thank God I'm not a completionist because I would be in trouble thank God I'm not oh Jesus thank God I'm not a comp a completionist um I've I've bought plenty of expansions but I'm you know I'm pretty happy with where I'm at uh I think I've reached a

pretty good spot pretty much the only thing I want at this point is the allies of the Old West expansion which has like little Companions and I think I have I have a great um little sandboxy uh Dungeon Crawler game in my collection with tons of variety with everything that I've bought so far but uh don't get me wrong the uh as I've mentioned before just the coret will keep you busy for hours and hours and hours and hours and that does that does not even include the hobby aspect of it but yeah great lifestyle game folks just you know um not enough good things I can say about it to be honest with you it's just amazing system I'm so happy that I bought it on a whim it was just on sale on Miniature Market and I did my research gave it a shot and wow just amazed that this system love it so much so that's a Shadows of Brom one of the biggest surprises of the Year for me all right and finally for my last biggest surprise this year uh it's uh folklore the Affliction and I made uh just like for Shadows of Brimstone I also made a full length video for this if you want to hear my extended thoughts on it and whether this game is for you or not I'll leave a link to that uh but there is another game that I bought on a whim it was on sale for you can find a copy of the retail version with Miniatures the first edition Miniatures version from eBay instead of the newest standy version for $27 with shipping included and you know for the

amount of content that you got in that box you know I just went for it and it's just one of the best $27 that I've spent in the hobby all right wow what I got for that first being introduced to this system which uh as I've mentioned in other videos of mine uh the uh I have a little bit of a quest of finding a dndd ification of board games all right like DND style board board game ifications got that uh backwards but yeah board game ifications of the ND basically and I've tried plenty till now and this is just the second best one the number one for me is still uh explored uh and not by a not by a large margin but yeah folklore is very close uh very close in that regard uh so it does a great job of offering what feels like an DND experience that is soluable the unfortunate part is this the bookkeeping as I mentioned in my video uh but just the stories that I experienc in that core boox are great uh I have acquired uh the dark tales expansion since it was a bit tough finding uh a way to get the Miniatures to I had to buy the miniatur separate but I got all of that on sale thankfully so I didn't have to pay as much as I nor you normally would have it appears that this um this line of games seems to be kind of up in the air with the publisher kind of having an un

searching future which is unfortunate I think this is just such a great system and I wish it got the kind of support that uh Shadows of rimstone has uh Shadows of rimstone you know they is very well supported and they keep releasing content and updating it every year and they just had a super successful Kickstarter campaign and I just wish that folklore had this type of support because it's just such a wonderful system uh but if you want a great uh if you want a great uh DND experience at hes that's soluable and if you're willing if you don't mind controlling a minimum of three characters uh you know this just is just such a wonderful wonderful wonderful game um and in case that you want to reduce the the bookkeeping there is an app uh which I have not tried but um you know you know if if you're if you're not too opposed to that which I'm I'm not like completely opposed to it but you know I enjoy it being an analog experience but if you're not opposed to it completely you can uh try out the app to kind of Ease on the uh on the uh bookkeeping but yeah as full cor the Affliction which again uh it's just I mean notice a bit of a pattern uh with the games that were such surprises for me I bought them on a whim I didn't really wasn't sure what to expect and ended up absolutely loving them all right so those were my biggest disappointments as well as my biggest pleasant surprises for solo Bo games in the year of 2023 and I want to find out

what games were the most impactful for you this year whether it be great positive surprises or disappointments so let me know in the comments section and I'm really excited to see what 2024 holds for solo War gaming and I want to thank you so much for listening to me today and if you have any other comments questions feedback go ahead and put them in the comment section thank you so much for watching once again and I'll see you in the next

one

Progress saved