Banish the Snakes: A Game of St. Patrick in Ireland Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Banish the Snakes: A Game of St. Patrick in Ireland
Reviewers across multiple channels describe Banish the Snakes as a compelling cooperative experience that captures a unique historical moment with thematic elegance. The game is frequently compared to Pandemic, but reviewers emphasize that the medieval Irish setting and Christian conversion theme create a distinctly different feel and narrative. Western Civilization educators have adopted it as a teaching tool, noting that students consistently enjoy the cooperative mechanics and appreciate the historical context. Reviewers praise the game for being straightforward to teach yet mechanically rich, offering both accessible entry points and deeper strategic layers that reward multiple plays.
Core Mechanics That Define Banish the Snakes: A Game of St. Patrick in Ireland
Resource Management and Zeal
At the heart of Banish the Snakes lies a zeal system that governs both player health and available actions. Zeal functions as a dual-purpose resource: players lose zeal when conversion attempts fail (when their die roll falls below the target number), and zeal directly determines how many action points they have each turn. Reviewers note this creates meaningful tension, as struggling to convert the Irish populace directly weakens your team's capacity to act. Players typically have four actions per turn to spend on movement, conversion attempts, church construction, or special saint abilities. The scarcity of actions forces difficult prioritization choices, ensuring that no turn feels like rote execution. Church construction offers a long-term investment that gradually increases conversion success rates in a region, rewarding patience and forward planning.
Events and Escalating Pressure
The event system drives the game's narrative arc and escalating difficulty. Each round, a card is drawn that introduces challenges, opportunities, or historical figures tied to the period. Reviewers highlight the elegance of how the card drawn determines severity for the next card, ensuring no two games play identically. As play progresses, events grow more punishing, mirroring the historical collapse of Roman civilization in Britain and the mounting pressure on Ireland from external forces. This escalation creates mounting tension without feeling arbitrary, as each new threat emerges from the deck's predetermined sequence rather than pure randomness. The educational value resonates with reviewers who teach history, as the game's mechanical pressure directly echoes the historical urgency of the conversion effort.
The Banish the Snakes: A Game of St. Patrick in Ireland Experience
Cooperative Tension and Methodical Gameplay
Playing Banish the Snakes feels methodical and deliberate rather than frenetic. Reviewers describe the experience as calming yet strategically engaging, with an emphasis on shared decision-making. Each player turn unfolds through clear, sequential steps: draw a card, take actions based on available zeal, resolve outcomes. The absence of hidden information among players means the team can openly discuss the best approach to each challenge, fostering cooperative problem-solving rather than cutthroat competition. One reviewer noted that the game's methodical pace appeals to solo players in particular, allowing time for careful consideration of each move. The difficulty level consistently registers as high, with reviewers noting that the combination of die roll outcomes and escalating events creates situations where the team can find themselves outmatched. This tension makes victories feel genuinely earned rather than foregone conclusions.
Historical Immersion and Thematic Integration
The 5th-century Irish setting permeates every mechanic. Players represent Saints (Patrick and others) working as a team to convert the Irish populace before barbarians overrun Britain and sever Ireland from the wider Christian world. The conversion process mirrors real historical hierarchy: individual people have a base conversion difficulty, but their resistance is increased by the presence of druids, chiefs, kings, and ultimately the High King at Tara. Each leader represents a level of spiritual and political resistance to Christianity, and converting them reduces the resistance of those they influence. Reviewers consistently note how thematic this hierarchy feels, grounding the mechanical difficulty in historical narrative rather than arbitrary rule systems. The board depicts Ireland's four provinces, and the beautiful medieval Dark Age artwork creates an aesthetic that reviewers describe as distinctive and immersive. One reviewer brought the game to their Western Civilization classes specifically because students immediately grasped the historical premise and engaged with the period through play.
What Makes Banish the Snakes: A Game of St. Patrick in Ireland Stand Out
Straightforward Rules with Mechanical Depth
Despite bearing the GMT Games label (typically associated with complex, multi-hour rule books), Banish the Snakes features a remarkably accessible ruleset. The 14-page rulebook contains only 7 pages of actual gameplay rules, presented with clear illustrations and large fonts that invite quick reference during play. Reviewers repeatedly note surprise at how easy the game is to teach, calling it one of GMT's most approachable titles. This accessibility does not come at the expense of strategic depth; the game includes mechanisms to mitigate randomness (church levels that improve conversion odds, die roll modifiers for various influences, dolmanan chips that penalize failed conversions). Players can spend additional action points to improve their odds before rolling, trading flexibility for certainty. This mitigation system allows experienced players to plan several turns ahead while still respecting the tension that die rolls introduce.
Solitaire Excellence and Educational Utility
Multiple reviewers identify Banish the Snakes as an exceptional solo experience, possibly stronger in solo play than multiplayer. The game's cooperative nature removes the need to manage player interaction, allowing solo players to optimize strategy without table talk. The predetermined event sequence makes the game fully deterministic once players commit to their decisions, eliminating the awkwardness of hidden information in solo mode. Beyond solo appeal, the game has proven valuable in educational settings. Reviewers who teach history bring Banish the Snakes to their Western Civilization courses specifically because it delivers both historical context and engaging mechanics. Students report enjoying the cooperative teamwork, the challenge of strategic resource allocation, and the concrete visualization of 5th-century Ireland's political and religious landscape. The game becomes a vehicle for embodying historical concepts rather than simply reading about them.
Potential Drawbacks
Randomness and Setup Complexity
While reviewers praise the die roll mitigation systems, some note that randomness can still determine games. One reviewer explicitly raised the concern that Pandemic players accustomed to deterministic action resolution may find the dice rolls frustrating; unlike Pandemic's automatic success, Banish the Snakes requires meeting a target number or accepting consequences. This introduces an element beyond pure strategy that some find inelegant. Additionally, the sticker setup process is substantial: players must spend one to one and a half hours carefully applying stickers to wooden blocks, matching front and back combinations to colored pieces before the first play. Reviewers describe this as a potential deterrent for players who dislike assembly, though some view the meditative process as acceptable if done once at acquisition.
Difficulty Scaling and Two-Player Experience
Reviewers note that Banish the Snakes plays at two players but the experience differs noticeably from higher player counts. With fewer players, each participant controls fewer saints and has fewer opportunities per round, which can amplify the sting of failed conversions. The game scales up to six players (based on the six individual player boards in the box), and reviewers suggest the cooperative tension and resource distribution may feel more balanced at higher counts. Some players also report that the game's high difficulty can be punishing for newer teams; a few poor die rolls early can spiral into an unrecoverable deficit as zeal depletes and the event deck grows more threatening. This is by design (the difficulty is celebrated as a feature), but players seeking a more forgiving cooperative experience should be aware that Banish the Snakes regularly defeats unprepared teams.
If You Enjoy Banish the Snakes: A Game of St. Patrick in Ireland
If Banish the Snakes resonates with you, reviewers recommend starting with Pandemic and its variants. Pandemic: Star Wars The Clone Wars and Pandemic: World of Warcraft apply similar escalating threat mechanics to licensed themes, offering familiar cooperative structure with different aesthetic appeal. Conquest of Paradise, also designed by Kevin McFarland, appeals to players who love Banish the Snakes' historical settings and educational potential. While Conquest of Paradise is a wargame rather than a cooperative conversion game, reviewers who explored both McFarland titles found the designer's sensibility consistent across both works, blending historical authenticity with engaging mechanics. Players drawn to the solitaire experience might explore other GMT titles marketed for solo suitability, as Banish the Snakes represents the publisher's more accessible end of the complexity spectrum. Those who value thematic integration of mechanics (where the rules reinforce the narrative) should note reviewers' emphasis on how the hierarchy of religious resistance and the zeal system mirror 5th-century Irish history rather than simply abstracting it.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"It's basically Pandemic. I mean, it, it follows a similar DNA to Pandemic, but it applies a paint that I think I enjoy more, which is like a war-themed, you know, St. Patrick's fifth-century Christian aesthetic. Effectively, it's vibes - it's vibes, and very, very, very difficult, and there's some randomness to it and some asymmetry, which is really cool."
— Foster the Meeple
"The students always enjoy it. They always love the cooperative nature of the game. They love working together and trying to convert the local leaders and the kings and the high king and then trying to get to all the people."
— The Discriminating Gamer
"It's got die rolls, but it's got these wonderful mechanisms to mitigate the die rolls throughout the game. Really enjoy it. This, like I say, it's a good cooperative game. I think it's probably more fun, at least for me, as a solo game, but I love my students how much they enjoy it as they play it cooperatively."
— The Discriminating Gamer