Battles of Westeros Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Battles of Westeros
Battles of Westeros is a two-player Command and Colors game from Fantasy Flight that puts players in command of House Stark or House Lannister as they recreate battles from George R.R. Martin's books or design their own. Reviewers tend to describe it as the Command and Colors system dressed in Game of Thrones trappings, with more depth than its relatives. Board Games UnLocked returned to the game in several videos, and its tone shifts across them. In an early top 100 list the host praised it as a more complex take on the system, calling it a better iteration of Memoir 44 and recommending it to anyone who wants something more involved and set in Westeros. In later videos that enthusiasm cools. The same channel placed the game on a list of titles its host would no longer play, citing assembly and a lack of rules support after the publisher appeared to drop the line. Board Games UnLocked later returned to it with an unboxing of new accessories and said the purchase would likely prompt more play.
The Discriminating Gamer treats the game as an honorable mention in a ranking of favorite Command and Colors titles, noting that its dice-driven approach differs from the card-based entries. Foster the Meeple mentions the game only briefly while sharing a haul, noting that it sits in the same line as Memoir 44 and Battle Lore and that a Game of Thrones version of the system exists.
Core Mechanics That Define Battles of Westeros
Dice That Decide What Moves
Battles of Westeros does not rely on drawing cards to choose which units act. The Discriminating Gamer contrasted it with other entries in the line, recalling that you would roll dice and the dice would inform you which units you could move. Dice resolve attacks, but the player keeps broad control over how the army moves, which Board Games UnLocked described as the host's only real luck, since "you get to control everything you want to." That split between luck in combat and control over positioning is central to how the game plays.
Heroes, Flanking, and Objectives
Beyond the basic activation rules, Board Games UnLocked highlighted the layers stacked on top. Flanking and objective bonuses reward players who think about position, and heroes attached to specific groups of the army carry abilities that can also mitigate die rolls. Leadership proximity matters as well. In a later video the host noted that when a leader or a close unit is nearby, "then they get that bonus," tying the tactical geometry of the board to the characters who command it. The host also pointed to the keyword vocabulary, including terms for guarding, as a step up in technicality from simpler games in the same family.
The Battles of Westeros Experience
Book Faithful Game of Thrones Immersion
Reviewers respond most warmly to the source material. Board Games UnLocked was direct about the appeal, saying the game is "book Game of Thrones not show Game of Thrones," and the host, who identifies as a book reader, valued that the battles draw from George R.R. Martin's novels rather than the television adaptation. The Discriminating Gamer similarly framed the game as drawing on both the show and the books, which gives the battle choices a recognizable Westeros character for fans of the saga.
Swingy Dice Balanced by Strategic Choice
The dice generate real tension, but the experience reads as more strategic than a pure luck test. Board Games UnLocked recounted a session with a family member who nearly won, with the host explaining that the win came from rolling exactly what was needed at the decisive moment. In a later video the same channel described the game as a clear step above Memoir 44 in this regard, saying "it's less swinging" because the player is not tied to one unit or one good roll. When the host unboxed the new expansions in another video, they recalled liking the game a lot and suggested it may have been more strategic than they remembered.
What Makes Battles of Westeros Stand Out
Rules Depth Above Its Command and Colors Cousins
The most consistent praise is that Battles of Westeros carries more rules weight than its family. Board Games UnLocked described it as "basically the commanding colors system in Game of Thrones but it's a lot more in-depth," pointing to the flanking, objective, leader, and keyword layers that set it apart. The host also contrasted it with Memoir 44 in a way that favors the extra structure, since the dice are only one part of a turn rather than the whole engine.
Scenario Range and Premium Components
Board Games UnLocked examined the expansion catalog closely. The host acquired the large Baratheon expansion, which adds a couple hundred soldiers, along with the Tribes of the Vale, and expressed surprise that the line did not extend to other houses such as the Greyjoys or Martells. Later the host bought the premium banner pack and the Lords of the River expansion, adding variety to an already broad scenario library. The plastic banners were called really cool, a clear upgrade over the cardboard versions in the base game.
Potential Drawbacks
Assembly and Setup Friction
Assembly is the complaint that comes up most often. Board Games UnLocked explained that the miniatures must be built and seated in their stands, and that the parts do not always fit neatly, leaving the host reaching for glue to finish the job. In a separate video the host recalled opening the box and remembering the requirement to glue the pieces down, which made the prospect of playing feel like a chore. Setup as a whole was described as heavy, and the host said that kind of setup burden is what keeps a game off the table.
Thin Support and Convoluted Expansions
Reviewers also questioned how well the line was supported over time. Board Games UnLocked said the expansions felt convoluted and that the rules needed clearer support, a gap the host felt the line never closed. The host was surprised the publisher stopped developing the line, suspecting that sales had not been strong enough to justify more releases. The result, in the view of these reviewers, is a strong core system whose later additions never fully matched its early promise.
If You Enjoy Battles of Westeros
- Memoir 44 is the closest sibling, since it shares the Command and Colors structure with dice-driven combat. Opinions split here. Board Games UnLocked called Memoir 44 something that channel despised, while the Discriminating Gamer ranked the Overlord expansion as that channel's favorite Command and Colors experience for its large-scale, eight-player battles. Players who want a simpler, faster scenario game may prefer Memoir 44, while those who want more control and Westeros flavor may prefer Battles of Westeros.
- Napoleonics appeals to players who like the Command and Colors engine with a more mature ruleset. The Discriminating Gamer praised its historically grounded choices, such as infantry forming squares against threatening cavalry, and named it a longtime favorite.
- The Great War brings the system to World War One, with offboard artillery that can disrupt a scenario before the first move. The same reviewer ranked it lowest among the favorites because the unit pieces were prone to falling apart, so it suits players who are comfortable with the assembly and plastic quality that Battles of Westeros also demands.
- Medieval covers Byzantine and Frankish battles and refines some unit dice counts from the Ancients rules. The Discriminating Gamer enjoyed the era and the refinements, though still preferred Ancients, making it a good next step for players who like the medieval setting.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"Battles of Westeros is basically the commanding colors system in Game of Thrones but it's a lot more in-depth."
— Board Games UnLocked
"They're tiny and like they go in their stands and the pieces to either don't fit just right like they're too big or they're too small and half the time I need superglue."
— Board Games UnLocked
"It was a little bit different there, but still was a lot of fun."
— The Discriminating Gamer