Cathedral Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Cathedral
Cathedral, the 1979 abstract territory game in which two players fit interlocking buildings around a central cathedral, earns a consistently favorable reception from the reviewers who cover it. Most describe it as a compact strategy game that rewards careful planning on a shared board. Adam Porter of Adam in Wales placed it in the A tier of a 50-game ranking built around table presence and personal enjoyment, and described it as a very simple polyomino game with an appealing sense of building a city. The Secret Cabal Gaming Podcast calls it a well designed, quick game that suits a relaxed afternoon, while Foster the Meeple praises its complete lack of luck.
The points of disagreement are narrower. Foster the Meeple notes that some players have found a way to win every game as one side, which the channel regards as a flaw that undercuts the fun. Adam Porter observes that the game shares its core idea with Blokus, and that the sculpted pieces are what set its atmosphere apart. Across these reviews, the consensus is that Cathedral is a sharp, tactile puzzle whose appeal lies in clean rules and strong tabletop presence.
Core Mechanics That Define Cathedral
Polyomino Placement
Cathedral is built on polyomino tiles, the multi-square shapes familiar from Tetris. Foster the Meeple describes the pieces as "almost like Tetris shapes" that each player must fit onto a shared grid, with the aim of getting all of their pieces onto the board before the other player does. Adam Porter explains that the winner is the player who fits more buildings on the board, and that the scoring punishes any building left in hand: players lose points at game end equal to the number of spaces their unplaced buildings would have covered. The Secret Cabal Gaming Podcast notes that the game ends as soon as one player cannot place a building, so which building to play first matters as much as where it goes.
Area Control Through Walls
The second defining mechanic is territory control created by walls. Jamie of The Secret Cabal Gaming Podcast explains that players try to wall off sections of the board using their own buildings and the outer edges, and a sealed section becomes unavailable to the opponent. The walling has a second consequence: if a sealed area contains only one of the opponent's buildings, that building must be removed from the board. Foster the Meeple adds a key detail, that buildings connect only orthogonally, so diagonal contact never forms a wall. The designer Bob Moore, who drew the idea from the interlocking buildings seen from the air above Christchurch while flying for the Royal New Zealand Air Force, built the game around this kind of spatial control.
The Cathedral Experience
Quiet Spatial Tension
Play feels like a slow contest of foresight. Each placement can close off a region for the opponent or leave a gap that the opponent can exploit, and the tension comes from the board itself rather than from cards or dice. Foster the Meeple describes the game as "100% strategy," in which the task is to optimize placement while blocking the other player, and that focus gives each turn its weight. The result is a calm, concentrated atmosphere with moments of sharp satisfaction when a well-timed wall shuts an opponent out.
A City Growing on the Table
The second experience is the pleasure of watching a miniature city take shape. Adam Porter says that the sculpted pieces make the player feel like they are creating a city full of buildings while playing, and The Secret Cabal Gaming Podcast describes the set as a beautiful wooden production with chunky pieces. Because the completed layout resembles a skyline, the game rewards both the thinking during play and the admiring look at the table afterward.
What Makes Cathedral Stand Out
Pure Strategy With No Luck
Foster the Meeple singles out the absence of randomness as the game's central appeal. In their words, "it's no luck it's 100% strategy," and the only task is to make the best placement while constraining the other player. That purity is why the channel places Cathedral first among its suggestions for players who enjoy chess, a game that similarly rewards calculation over chance.
A Game Worth Keeping on the Shelf
Several reviewers return to the physical presence of the game. The Secret Cabal Gaming Podcast includes Cathedral among its heirloom-quality games, praising the wood construction, the chunky blocks, and the board with walls and spires on its corners. Adam Porter credits the sculpted pieces with turning a simple polyomino game into something that feels like building a city, which gives the game a second life as a display piece between sessions.
Potential Drawbacks
A Winning Exploit
Foster the Meeple reports that some players have discovered a way to always win as one side. The channel's advice is blunt: players should avoid it, because the exploit undermines the contest that the game depends on for its fun.
Close Kinship With Blokus
Adam Porter describes Cathedral as a simple polyomino game that is very similar to Blokus. For players who already own Blokus, the core decisions feel familiar, so the case for owning Cathedral rests more on its presentation and its walled-off territory play. That is a fair concern for a game that has to justify a place alongside its close relative.
If You Enjoy Cathedral
Players who enjoy Cathedral's tight tile fitting will find similar satisfaction in Blokus, which Adam Porter names as the closest relative because both games require each new piece to touch the player's own pieces only at corners while shutting out the opponent.
Players who enjoy Cathedral's penalty for unplaced pieces will find a familiar tension in Patchwork. Adam Porter notes that filling as much of the grid as possible is key to winning at Patchwork, because unfilled spaces are worth negative points at game end.
Players who appreciate Cathedral's sense of a city taking shape will find a related pleasure in Baron Park, where completing a grid earns a statue and covering icons opens new tiles for the animal park. Adam Porter highlights it as a polyomino game that rewards this kind of planning.
For a more showpiece-oriented take on the game, Foster the Meeple recommends Cathedral World, which the channel prefers for its beauty. Players who want a quicker, purely abstract alternative should consider Wall, which Foster the Meeple compares directly to Cathedral because both can be left set up for a fast match.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"It's no luck, it's 100% strategy. You are just trying to optimize the placement of your pieces and trying to block the other person so that they cannot do the same."
— Foster the Meeple
"One of the big strategies of the game is that you're trying to wall off certain sections of the board with your pieces, or the outside walls. If you make a section that's completely walled off with your pieces, the opponent can't place in that section anymore."
— Jamie, The Secret Cabal Gaming Podcast
"It's essentially a very simple polyomino game. It's an abstract game where you're trying to fill out the grid and block off the other player from being able to place their pieces. But it's got these amazing sculpted plastic pieces that means that it really does feel like you're creating this city full of these buildings as you're playing the game."
— Adam Porter, Adam in Wales