Lost Cities: Rivals Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Lost Cities: Rivals
Reviewers generally treat Lost Cities: Rivals as a distinct game that happens to share a name and a designer with the original, rather than as a simple upgrade. Designed by Reiner Knizia and published by Cosmos, the game keeps the idea of building ascending expeditions from the 2-player card game Lost Cities, but replaces the turn structure with an auction. Rodney Smith of Watch It Played introduces it as a title that "introduces new ideas" while still rooted in the classic, and that framing recurs across the reviews.
The consensus is warm but measured. Marlar of Pair of Dice Paradise calls it a game worth a second look for anyone who passed on it the first time around, citing its "simple but really fun" auction and set collection system. Drive Thru Games is the most enthusiastic voice, saying the game grew on the reviewer over repeated plays, though early appreciation dipped before recovering once the reviewer's family group began arguing over the same cards. Tom Vasel of The Dice Tower is the most reserved. Tom enjoys the game but places it below the original, a judgment that reflects the difference in feel rather than a verdict on quality. Watch It Played's Q&A segment also addresses the game's two to four player design, with host Matthew noting that it is a player-count expansion of Lost Cities rather than a two-player version, which reinforces how reviewers separate it from its predecessor.
Core Mechanics That Define Lost Cities: Rivals
Auction
The auction is the engine of the game. On a turn, a player either reveals the top card of the current draw pile or starts an auction over the cards on display. Bidding moves clockwise, each bid must be higher than the last, and no one may bid more coins than they hold. Players who pass drop out and recover their coins, while the winner pays the bid into the central gold supply and then takes as many display cards as they want. As Rodney Smith explains, the winner may also leave cards behind or remove one card from the game entirely, which gives every auction a second layer of choice beyond price.
Reviewers focus on how the bidding behaves over time rather than on its rules. Drive Thru Games describes a pattern in which bidding first stalls, then gradually warms up as players realize the coins they spend will be redistributed. Because the gold in the supply is split evenly among players at the end of each draw pile, a player who overpays is not entirely punished, and that encourages looser bidding as a deck runs low. Tom Vasel likens the dynamic to a game of nerve, where the first player to commit is often the one who loses ground.
Set Collection in Expeditions
The second core system is the expedition, the set collection element carried over from the original Lost Cities. Each player builds up to five expeditions, one per color, and every card added to an existing expedition must match or exceed the value of the card beneath it. Wager cards, which multiply an expedition's score, can only be played before any number cards enter that column. Points come from footprint symbols on each card, multiplied by the wagers, with a flat bonus of 8 points for any expedition holding four or more number cards. Remaining gold adds one point per coin at the end.
Drive Thru Games points out how this constraint shapes decisions during an auction. Taking a low card early can lock a player out of higher cards in that color, so a player must weigh each acquisition against what it blocks. That tension between taking cards for scoring and keeping future options open is what makes the set collection feel more strategic than the rules suggest.
The Lost Cities: Rivals Experience
A Tense Standoff at the Auction Table
Reviewers consistently describe the mood of the game as a slow-building standoff. Each draw pile has a rising tension as the cards thin out and players begin to gamble more freely, knowing that much of their spending will return to them. Tom Vasel's comparison to a chicken-style game captures the feeling: no one wants to commit first, yet waiting too long can cost a valuable card. Drive Thru Games describes the closing stretch of each pile as a moment of anticipation, with players scrambling to secure a high-value card at a premium price once the final reveals approach.
Quick, Light, and Surprising Fun
Despite the tension, the game is consistently described as light and quick. Rodney Smith gives a typical playtime of about half an hour once the rules are familiar, and reviewers enjoy the way the flip of a single card can change the whole table's plans. The alternation between a simple reveal and a sudden bidding war gives the game a casual, almost playful energy. Drive Thru Games sums up the appeal as a straightforward flip-and-auction design that still produces a lot of surprise and fun.
What Makes Lost Cities: Rivals Stand Out
A Metagame That Shifts With Each Group
Drive Thru Games stresses that the game's character depends heavily on how a particular table learns to play it. What began as a simple auction became more interesting once the reviewer's family group started to read each other's bidding habits, deciding which ice world cards to fight over and which high cards to leave alone. Because the display and the bids are always changing, the game rewards groups that spend time together and develop shared expectations, which gives it staying power beyond its short rules.
Flexible Player Counts and a Short Session
The game supports two to four players, and reviewers note that its short length makes it easy to repeat. Tom Vasel finds that it works well with two players, describing the duel as a sharp back-and-forth. Drive Thru Games, by contrast, says the reviewer would not choose it for two players and prefers the three and four player tables. That split is itself useful information for buyers: the game scales well in larger groups, while two player fans should try it before committing.
Potential Drawbacks
Less Depth Than Ra and Medici
Several reviewers feel the game is simpler than the auction games it resembles. Drive Thru Games describes it as arguably simpler than Ra, since the only goal is to collect sets within expeditions, with none of the more layered tile and disaster systems that Ra offers. The reviewer admits that this simplicity caused the reviewer's enthusiasm to dip after the first few plays. Tom Vasel also places it below the original Lost Cities, calling it a different experience that is still pretty cool but not as strong overall. Players looking for the deeper combinations of Ra or Medici may find Lost Cities: Rivals lighter than expected.
No Official Tiebreaker
Drive Thru Games criticizes the rulebook for offering no tiebreaker, so tied players share the victory. The reviewer discussed an alternative with the family, proposing that the player with fewer different expeditions should win the tie because that reflects more efficient exploration. The reviewer acknowledges that the idea is not official, but the criticism points to a real gap for competitive groups who want a clear winner at the end of a close game.
If You Enjoy Lost Cities: Rivals
Reviewers repeatedly link Lost Cities: Rivals to Ra and Medici. Drive Thru Games compares its core loop of flipping a card or calling an auction directly to the bidding in Ra, and it is the most natural next stop for anyone who likes the auction. Players who enjoy the game's bidding tension will find a similar satisfaction in Ra, where auction pressure and set building share the same table. Players who value the expedition scoring and the sense of building toward a multiplier will recognize the same appeal in Medici, another Knizia design that rewards careful collection. Finally, fans who like the ascending card building that started it all should return to the original Lost Cities, which Tom Vasel recommends as the foundation for understanding this newer design.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"Each of those quarter decks of cards has a sort of crescendo of everybody kind of scratching their nails and taking a really creepy time up the up the down the deck. And then at the end it's like, boom, 50 bucks, I'll spend whatever on this one card to get, and that kind of thing."
— Drive Thru Games
"It's almost more of a chicken style game, like who's going to be the first to do it. It's a very different feeling of Lost Cities. It's not as good as Lost Cities, but it's still a pretty cool game."
— Tom Vasel, The Dice Tower
"The game features a simple but really fun auction and set collection system so it's a game that is definitely worth a second look if you missed it the first time around."
— Marlar, Pair of Dice Paradise