Lost Cities: Roll & Write Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Lost Cities: Roll & Write
Reviewers generally present Lost Cities: Roll & Write as a light, accessible roll-and-write adaptation of the expedition structure from Reiner Knizia's Lost Cities card game, published by Thames & Kosmos. The strongest praise focuses on how quickly the game plays, how little time it takes to teach, and how well it works with more than two players. Dylan of All You Can Board describes it as an approachable first step into the genre, while Ilya and Tyler of Kovray call it fast paced and praise its colorblind-friendly design, which pairs colors with symbols.
The main point of disagreement is whether the game keeps what made the card version appealing. Dylan argues that it keeps the expedition framework and the risk of starting late, but drops the hidden information that Dylan considers the heart of the card game. Ryan and Bethany of Ryan and Bethany Board Game Reviews, previewing the game before release, admit that roll-and-write titles are hit or miss for them and say they are hoping this one lands on the "love it" side. Getting Games approaches it with the most caution, questioning whether dice can match the controlled odds of a card deck. Sir Thecos discusses only the original card game in their monthly ranking, so this version is not covered in that video.
Core Mechanics That Define Lost Cities: Roll & Write
Compound Scoring
Each expedition column is scored by the spot a player reaches rather than by adding up the numbers written in it. Dylan explains that the points listed on the left side of the sheet correspond to the highest box reached, and that a zero placed in the double-point circle doubles that column's total, even when the total is negative. Artifacts and dice are scored separately on the right side of the sheet, with a fully shaded artifact column worth up to 100 points, while a fully exhausted dice column scores zero. Bridge bonuses are added after doubling, so they are never multiplied. Because each category is tallied independently, a player can build a strong total from one column and still lose ground elsewhere.
End Game Bonuses
Each expedition, the artifact track, and the dice track contain a 20-point bridge that is claimed only by the first player to reach its seventh box. Every other player must cross that symbol off, so the bridges reward speed and reading the table. The game ends when all players are exhausted or when every bridge has been crossed, and the bridges can be split between players in any proportion. Kovray describes how the endgame can shift abruptly: in one game, the round ended as soon as the green bridge was crossed, which pushed players to manage their negative columns and try to delay that moment. Ryan and Bethany likewise note that the bridge race makes the ending visible to everyone, which turns the final rounds into a deliberate tactical contest.
The Lost Cities: Roll & Write Experience
Fast, Low-Friction Play
Speed is the most consistent description. Kovray calls the game very fast paced, notes that it takes almost no time to play, and says it is easy to teach. The setup is minimal, with one sheet per player, a pen, and six dice shared at the center of the table. Dylan adds that the game does not slow down much as player counts rise, because nearly every player is choosing from the same remaining dice at the same time. Dylan argues that this makes it a practical choice for groups in a way the two-player card game cannot match.
Racing Against the Table
Kovray emphasizes that inactive players are never idle. Because every player can use the dice the active player leaves behind, the table stays engaged, and players often watch one another while hoping for a specific combination. The bridge race adds a layer of hidden intent: a player may quietly work toward one color and then use a few acceleration arrows to finish it before others notice. The result, in their description, is a game that feels like a short sprint with constant attention on what everyone else is doing.
What Makes Lost Cities: Roll & Write Stand Out
Acceleration Combos
Writing a number in a box with an arrow lets a player copy that number into the next box of a chosen expedition, and if that box also has an arrow, the chain continues. Dylan compares this to the combo-driven design of the Clever series of roll-and-write games, but at a much smaller scale. Kovray notes that a player can secretly build toward one color and then speed through it with a run of arrows, catching opponents off guard. Dylan also points out that a number written into an arrow can start a brand-new column, which gives the chain more flexibility than a simple one-way track.
The Refusal Mechanic
Refusing dice is a central part of the design, and Kovray singles it out as a favorite. Refusing too little costs points, refusing too many leaves a player exhausted and scoring nothing on the dice column, and refusing exactly the right amount can open a useful lead. Kovray observes that late in the game, space on the sheet becomes scarce, so refusing becomes a natural and sometimes necessary choice. That tension gives the game a pressure valve that many players find more interesting than a simple penalty.
Potential Drawbacks
Luck Against the Original Card Game
Dylan concedes that Lost Cities: Roll & Write is much more luck based than the card game because the dice produce results that no deck can fully control. Dylan notes that players still face the same risk assessment about how close the game is to ending and whether to chase a color that may not appear. Getting Games raises the statistical issue directly, explaining that the card game was balanced with a fixed deck of numbers, while in a dice game players can experience strange streaks that were never expected. Kovray adds that a player can pursue a color all game and never roll the right number, a frustration that reviewers see as an inherent part of rolling games.
Reduced Strategic Depth and Theme
Dylan argues that the central strategy of the card game, which comes from holding back cards, reading the opponent's hand, and guessing what remains in the deck, is absent here because the dice are open information. Dylan says that players who valued that aspect of the card game will likely not find the same enjoyment. Ryan and Bethany also observe that the theme is thin, describing the game as primarily about optimizing points, with the adventurer idea mostly present in the title. Reviewers who want a deeper thematic or hidden-information experience may find this version a step back.
If You Enjoy Lost Cities: Roll & Write
Players who enjoy the expedition structure and want to bring the family to the table should consider the Lost Cities card game, which Dylan describes as one of their favorite two-player games because of its hidden information and hand management. The original Lost Cities remains the better choice for two players who want the most strategic depth, while Lost Cities: Roll & Write suits groups of three to five who want the same expedition goals with a shorter, more social game. Dylan recommends it for anyone new to roll-and-write who wants to learn the genre's basic ideas, and suggests that experienced roll-and-write fans may find it too simple. Players who came to the card game for its bluffing and memory will need to adjust their expectations, but those who want a quick, interactive game about racing for expeditions will find a clear reason to play.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"i would say that this is almost a gateway roll and right game if it's if it's um you know a genre that you're in u2 and you want to sort of dip your toes in the water this would be a great place to start as it's very simplistic in its mechanics but it has a couple things that are branching out to teach you"
— Dylan, All You Can Board
"I really like the refusing dice mechanic because if you refuse just a little bit you'll score negative points, and if you refuse too much you score zero. But if you refuse just the right amount, you can actually score a decent chunk of points."
— Ilya and Tyler, Kovray
"lost it is the card game obviously was balanced with a deck of cards to have certain number of uh ones and twos and threes and fours but in a dice game you don't know there's probability but you can always have strange streaks of numbers that you wouldn't have expected"
— John, Getting Games