Royal Realms Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Royal Realms
Royal Realms, a 2023 card game from the UK publisher Hobby Doctor Games, is covered most consistently by the Chairman of the Board channel, which describes it as a bidding and set collection game for two to five players that takes roughly 20 to 30 minutes to play. The reviewers agree that the core design is clever and tightly tuned, and they treat it as a hidden gem that deserves more attention than it has received. Praise is strongest for the scoring and bidding systems, while the rulebook and physical production draw the most reservations. The channel repeatedly notes that the game comes from a first-time designer and a very small publisher, and it presents that as a reason the title has flown under the radar rather than as a knock against the design.
Opinions are positive without being uniform. In the channel's top 10 games of 2023 list, the reviewer calls the game a complete hidden gem and suggests that it will appeal most to fans of bidding and set collection games. In a monthly roundup of recent plays, the same reviewer describes it as a lovely game that is massively overlooked. A later three-player session, covered in another Chairman of the Board video, reaches a more measured verdict: the game is a good and affordable option, but its written rules are not as polished as those of High Society. The consensus is therefore enthusiastic about the design and cautious about how the game is explained.
Core Mechanics That Define Royal Realms
Auction Bidding With Blind Bluffing
Each player begins with an identical deck of bidding cards running from 2 to 36, and each round the next gem card is auctioned face up in turn order. Players can place several bidding cards to outbid rivals, but they cannot take change back from cards already committed, a restriction the channel identifies as a major source of tension. Face-down gem cards add the bluffing layer: they are bid on without knowing what they contain, so the bidder must judge how much a mystery card might be worth. Losing bidders take their cards back into hand, while the winner discards the money spent. The reviewers place this auction close to the bidding in High Society, though they also note that Royal Realms layers its own twists on top.
Money is scored as well as spent. After the first two rounds, the player who has collected the fewest cards must hand money from their hand to the bank, and the penalty grows with the gap between that player and the leader. At the end of the game, the player who spent the least earns 20 points while the player who spent the most loses 20. During the later rounds, each player may secretly stash up to two cards to compete for wild cards, and the largest stash takes the most. Wild cards are bid on simultaneously and in secret, so a player who overspends on them loses ground in the end-game money bonus. The channel describes this conflict between the wild card auction and the money bonus as one of the game's best features.
Set Collection and Grid-Based Combo Scoring
The gem cards are scored by how they fit together, and the reviewers describe the finished layout as a grid of rows and columns. Players build runs of the same gem color in consecutive numbers, and sets of the same number across different suits. A run of two doubles the face value of its cards, and a run of five triples it, while matching sets score 10 points for a pair, 25 for a trio, 40 for four and 60 for all five. Every card can count toward both a run and a set, so a single gem can strengthen several parts of the layout at once. Wild cards can stand in for any gem, which makes them especially valuable for filling gaps. The channel values this design because it lets a card serve several scoring goals, turning the grid into a puzzle that rewards long-term planning.
The Royal Realms Experience
A Crescendo of Speculation and Pressure
The reviewers describe the opening rounds as a period of speculation, when players pick up gem cards at bargain prices because nobody yet knows which pieces their layout will need. As the game moves on and the remaining cards narrow, niche gems that complete a key run suddenly become valuable, and bids that once looked cautious start to ramp up sharply. The channel calls this a natural crescendo that gives the game its momentum, and it is what makes the late auctions feel as tense as the final scoring.
Bluffing Anxiety and the Fear of Falling Behind
Because the fewest-cards penalty punishes players who sit back, the reviewers feel a constant pull to keep bidding. The channel describes the rule as pushing players to get their engine running early, since a player who spends nothing will lose that money anyway. The blind bids on face-down cards and wild cards add a further layer of anxiety, because a player may overpay for a mystery card or lose a valuable stash without ever knowing whether a rival was bluffing. The result feels fast and busy rather than relaxed, with little downtime between rounds and players invested in every bid.
What Makes Royal Realms Stand Out
Wild Cards and the Stash Decision
Reviewers consistently treat the wild cards as the most important element of the game. They can proxy any gem and therefore resolve awkward gaps in a layout, and the secret stash that wins them forces players to choose between spending on wild cards and keeping money for the end-game bonus. The channel describes this as a point where the game's systems interlock, with money decisions made mid-game that only settle their value at the very end.
Fast, Compact, and Flexible Play
The game's compact footprint and short runtime are repeatedly praised. The reviewers note that the four rounds pass quickly, that the small box does not take up much shelf space, and that the game scales from two up to five players. The channel prefers three or more players because the extra bidder keeps the auction lively, but it also says that a two-player game is not the end of the world. Despite its size, the design offers plenty of decisions on every turn, which the reviewers cite as the reason it remains engaging from start to finish.
Potential Drawbacks
Rulebook Clarity and Rule Consistency
The most consistent complaint is that the rulebook could be clearer. The channel observes that players familiar with other card games may assume how things work, only to find that the written instructions take more effort to navigate than they should. The reviewers also question the no-change rule, which applies to face-up auctions but not to face-down cards. The channel argues that a single blanket rule would be easier to remember, and it finds the fewest-cards twist not the most intuitive, even though it is interesting and necessary for the game's pacing.
Production Quality and Box Design
The reviewers view the component quality as a mixed bag. The cards are standard in feel and do not seem premium, although they are bright, clear, and easy to read, and the gem sets are legible when laid out on the table. The channel is less impressed by the tuck box, which it finds hard to repack and somewhat cheap, and it would prefer a sturdier container. The channel also notes that finding a copy outside the UK may be difficult, since the publisher's distribution is limited.
If You Enjoy Royal Realms
High Society is the game reviewers compare Royal Realms to most directly. Both use fixed bidding cards to acquire gems, both reward the player who spends least and penalize the one who spends most, and both make each bid feel meaningful as players pace their money. The Chairman of the Board channel calls the pairing a no-brainer for fans of High Society, while the later Chairman of the Board review argues that High Society is more refined and polished, making Royal Realms the more affordable alternative. Players who want the tension of High Society with added twists such as wild cards and the stash decision will find Royal Realms a natural next step.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"I think the twist after round two where they play who has the fewest cards suffers losing money in relation to the player who's bought the most cards. It's not the most intuitive of rules, but I do think it's pretty interesting and even necessary for the game, because it stops players from being a bit lazy, sitting back and seeing what form is later."
— Chairman of the Board
"I love the way that you can use cards to score on multiple different patterns, so you can actually build a bit of a network and utilize certain cards in multiple ways."
— Chairman of the Board
"I think the rules are very dodgy in it. I mean, it's pretty obvious how it should play, but some of the way it's been written down isn't crystal clear, but you can fill in the gap yourself."
— Chairman of the Board