10 Board Games Ranked - Episode 23
Transcript
hey everybody today I've got another 10 new board games to talk about and rank uh before I get started on these 10 games I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor keyienda dot Co dot UK who are by far the best online retailer here in the UK and if you use my link in the show notes all the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order but let's get cracking with the games at number 10 I have fallout shelter now this is a game where you're kind of collecting resources and building these new rooms in a bunker you're racing to build a certain amount of rooms but every now and then these monsters kind of become an attack you you've got to go fight them off off because they block certain worker placement spots essentially I thought the game was a little bit basic for my own personal tastes and there was a clear imbalance in the quality of the weapons and cards you could build because they don't cost the same amount but some of these weapons were immensely powerful where you could roll pretty much anything and beat a bad guy and some of them were not so good and I just so happen to um kind of buy a card at the right time when a really powerful weapon was out there and it pretty much helped me sell through the rest of the game so yeah not quite what I'm looking for I'm not a fan of Fallout anyway I'm not I'm not not a fan I've just never played the game so I don't know anything about the IP and that maybe took away a point or two as well so yeah not a fan of this one that was full out shelter I at number nine I have anomia which is a pretty chaotic kind of word association game as your drawing cards one player after another um with these different kind of categories on them as soon as there's a
matching symbol on two of these cars then those players have to try and read out the answer to the other player's card as quickly as possible now I actually tend to enjoy games like this and I did enjoy this one so kind of you know to be transparent these next bunch of games are pretty much in the same ballpark as to how much I enjoyed them it's really quick and again it is quite chaotic and it's sometimes hard to you know distribute who gets the points because you read out the answers at the same time but it's so silly and so good so manic that it doesn't really matter and it's just a nice way to end a game tonight for you know a five or ten minute game so yeah simple stuff you know you've probably seen games like this before but it's a good example of you know of what it does so that is anomia at number nine at number eight I have codex naturalis which is a puzzly little card game as you are building out this display of cards by overlapping them on the corners but on those corners of each card you have kind of resources which are used to are used as prerequisites to build other cars which will give you kind of points or they'll give you points based on other symbols on display you have some public objectives to have different different things completed like if every player of these symbols you'll get x amount of points for every orientation of these colored cards you'll get x amount of points so it's all stuff we've seen before it's not a bad example of a game like that and it certainly has a really strong visual appeal to it I love the way you know the cards look in this game and it comes in a nice little compact tin but I did feel like within a matter of a few turns you it was very easy to get all the symbols you needed out there and then it was
kind of a paint by numbers and there wasn't really that taxing puzzle how to min max and how to you know optimize each turn it just felt pretty simple and pretty much on the rails and it was kind of over before you began so it wasn't bad but it didn't inspire me either and if I wanted a game like this I'll probably lean towards something like Nova Luna at number seven I have beer and bread which was a pretty popular game from last year now this is the first of I think three two player only games on this particular video and this is kind of like a resource management and multi-use card game as you are playing these cars through game resources and then you're also using those cars to complete contracts in two different categories beer and bread and only the lowest score in each of those categories will be your final score but you can also use those cards to tuck them under your player board and get ongoing engine benefits so I thought the actual use of the multi-use card was was quite clever and well implemented there's also some other really clever little design design um choices here where if you gain too many resources and not having the capacity to store them those resources will go to your opponent and they can use them against you or to complete their own contracts and I also have this relatively interesting phase structure where some rounds would be quite fruitful and you get loads of resources available and some will be a lot more restrictive and not have too many resources available in the pool and it meant that you could kind of pick up cars that you previously played and then use them again to complete contracts um check out my review of this one if I've not uploaded it yet I will
be uploading it soon it was a solid game and I can certainly see why people would like it and I don't really have too much negative to say about it it just didn't really you know it didn't really inspire me and I didn't really kind of give me that urge to come back and explore it much further it was quite pedestrian but a good example of what it does if that makes sense so nothing wrong with it but nothing truly great about it either so that is beer and bread at number six I have caverna so I've been wanting to play caverna for many years and finally had a chance to do so and you know what I was left pretty impressed um by this one it's certainly a well-designed game loads of things you can do by you know increasing your farm and you know getting animals breeding those animals increasing your own personal cage give you special rooms and things a good urgency to get to the worker placement spots that you want I actually really like the way that new worker placement spots were drip fed throughout the game so it's not so overwhelming and not so front loaded um if that makes sense um yeah actually I thought this game was was really well done if you like work replacement games I think this is a really good option to go for because it has so many things going on but it's still relatively digestible I was pleasantly surprised with how restrictive it was um I was kind of worried that the feeding your workers was going to be paralyzing I think it was just about all the money for me it's still difficult to feed them but it didn't occupy your whole strategy and he wasn't always hand strung by collecting resources just so you don't lose points but yeah I think this is probably maybe my favorite big
box Eva Rosenberg game now maybe matching with newsford um but yeah I can certainly see why this is a lot of people's favorite game these kind of worker placement Resource Management games aren't my forte I don't always lean towards them first but I would play this one again because it is a strong example of its genre so that is caverna at number six at number five I had a lofiton so lofiton is another two player only game and essentially this is a kind of a tug of war Style game actually competing over these different scoring cards by collecting these good tiles generally speaking if you have the majority of those good or certain type of guitars you'll score the most amount of points but they do all kind of score in slightly different ways but the key concept of this game is how you collect those tiles in the first place because you're gonna have a small hand of cards only three cards um they have to stay in a fixed order in your hand so you have the left card the right card and the middle card the left card is going to rotate this kind of fleetboard round anti-clockwise the right one will do the same but clockwise and the middle card will load in a new contract for you to collect the matching type of tile and it's all about how to min max those card plays to not waste any movement and to beat your opponent to the punch to get the tires you want and hopefully win that particular category it's actually pretty clever um I do kind of feel it's a one-trick Pony um I'm not quite sure or sold on the longevity of this one but that Central kind of fleetboard gimmick did hook me at least for a while and I would
recommend you cast your eye over it if um if that unique mechanism appeals to you and there are different ways you can play the game there are kind of very basic modules or Advanced modules I would encourage you to go straight in to those more advanced modules because they just take it a notch above being basic so um keeps it a little bit more interesting and makes the game feel a little bit more Dynamic and adds a wrinkle or two when it comes to decision making but yeah maybe a near Miss for me I'm not quite sure if it will stick around much longer but still it's nice to see a two-player game that feels different to other stuff out there at number four I have Hannah mckoji geisha's Rose so I've been eagerly anticipating getting this game to the table after being such a huge fan of the original Hannah makoji for many many years as you know it's been one of my favorite two-player games and to be one of one of my favorite games ever um this one shares a lot of similarities to the original in terms of that core action selection system and the ice split you choose Dynamic um but this one does add a few more things into the mix um in terms of this almost like a rondelle obesations that go around and around allows you to collect these points scoring tiles and also allows you to increase the yield or points you get from these cases but to be completely honest I don't think this game did anything better than the original does so I have recorded a review of this one and I suppose the the takeaway point of that review was that I feel that if the original game didn't
exist this one would be fantastic and I would definitely have it my collection because of the original one existing I didn't feel this game even has a space or a niche to explore or a niche to take up on my shelf because everything this game does the original game does better you know it's quicker it has a smaller um a smaller footprint easy to pack away easier to set up um and just less fiddly so yeah ultimately the decision space was roughly the same but it just had too much stuff bolted on so yeah despite me really liking this one in isolation I cannot Advocate it over the original and you know it's a weird game to review because you know this is my fourth favorite game out of all these 10 and I still can't recommend it because of that reason so that is Hannah makoji geisha Road at number three I have Royal realm so this game I'm sure you guys wouldn't have heard of because it was sent to me directly by the designer but this is a kind of a bidding and set collection card game that reminds me a lot of rhino canitzia's High Society so in this game you have a predetermined set of cards which are your bidding cars you're going to use those cars to acquire these gem cards which will score you based on different patterns you build if you have a bunch of the same color in a run you'll get points if you have a bunch of the same number but in different suits you'll get points and so on I love and I love the way that you can use cars to score on multiple different patterns so you can actually build a bit of a network and utilize certain cards in multiple ways this game also has some cool twists to
it where if you've spent the least money by the end of the game you'll get bonus points um and you can also stash cards away and whoever's bid the most cards in terms of stashing them away will get um these wild cards which can obviously help you score loads of points by putting them in the right locations so it's kind of like a recipe of games that I tend to like you know I love my little succinct card games that are well balanced and mathematical and I like bidding I like set collection so it's a really nice little package here and yeah I'm quite looking forward to getting my review out and playing it at different play accounts because it's a really solid one that I think is going to fly under the radar simply because it's not put out there by a big publisher but check this one out that is Royal realms okay so let's get into the top two games now and this is where my accommodations are going to begin so at number two I have Mosaic so Mosaic is a very streamlined civilization game that's card driven you're collecting cars in different categories it'll get new technologies increasing your ability to produce resources um and then you're buying more and more cars building your engine um and basically racing to achieve objectives very smooth game now I'm really impressed how this game has no no fittedness it has no convolution it has no rounds no phases it's always just go go with rapid Snappy decisions which keeps everybody engaged everything's been abstracted here but not abstracted to the point where you become disengaged with the game
um and I just it just struck that perfect chord for me in terms of what I was looking for for a civilization game now I have had to must house rule a few things here because of the variation in terms of how long the game can take um due to you have to especially Shuffle these cards into these decks and that will be um kind of the in-game trigger and what I've done is I've made sure that those cards are shuffled higher up in those decks to make sure the game's a bit quicker because you know the first game I played this one we went through so many cars it felt like we were just waiting for the game to end because we had achieved so much whereas in the future games we put those decks much higher those cards much higher in the decks which added a lot more tension and added that kind of haste to want to get things done quicker and because the game could end at any time but yeah really enjoyable game and um yeah I was left very impressed by this one and it would certainly break into my top 10 of 2022 and retrospectively I'll probably do a future list of my um kind of final definitive top 10 games of 2022 and no doubt you will be saying Mosaic on that list so that is Mosaic at number two and finally at number one I have craftwagon by Matthias Kramer so this is a game by Kramer that's certainly not talked about anymore um and it uses that time track system that was made so famous by Matthias Kramer in the legendary Glenmore 2 Chronicles where you can go as far as you want and get the get the action you want but you have to wait for other people to catch up with you before you get another turn now despite this game using that same mechanism the game
itself is completely different as you are building kind of better engines You're Building these new cars and you're putting them up for Market to sell them to customers which have been determined by the players and these customers have different wants and needs some of them might say well I want the car with the best engine some might say I want the most luxurious car or I want the cheapest car and it's all about trying to get things on those limited spaces to make sure you are selling your cars to get money um you're also racing your personal car around this track to get more points you've got a different frontal fight going here to try and try and win the game but it's just a very nice and pleasant game to play that's got interesting decisions very easy to learn it kind of fits that nice niche between a mid-weight Euro and a more Gateway level game so yeah very impressed with this one I'm really into I'm looking forward to playing more of it um two the two-player version of the game isn't very good I would say you're going to need at least three players to play this one but if you have that you know a three four player count the market becomes very Dynamic and it's just an extremely fun game to play so that is craftwagon at number one so there we have it that concludes the video hopefully you've enjoyed it and you've learned a thing or two about these games if you have enjoyed the video please be sure to hit like And subscribe to my channel and check out my other content too and for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye