The Walking Dead: All Out War Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About The Walking Dead: All Out War
Reviewers see The Walking Dead: All Out War from Mantic Games as a miniatures game with two faces. Its competitive identity is the one most people know, and the Watch Review notes that the game is "mostly known as a head-to-head skirmish game." That same video argues the official cooperative variant is where the game really shines, turning the table into a zombie horror movie in which survivors sneak through walker-infested streets to grab supplies and complete story missions.
The Tabletop Minions channel approaches the game from a different angle. In a discussion of single player wargames, the walker rules are the reason it can be played alone, since the zombies follow a fixed set of rules so that no one has to run them. In a separate Tabletop Minions video about gateway games, the channel frames the game as a bridge for fans of the comic and TV show, pulling people who came for the zombies into the wider hobby of tabletop wargaming.
Core Mechanics That Define The Walking Dead: All Out War
AI-Driven Walker Threat
The walkers are the system that drives the cooperative game. Reviewers describe them as controlled by AI, which removes the need for a player to run the undead side of the table. The Watch Review explains that "the further you get into these missions, the higher the threat becomes, increasing the walker count." Despite their slow, lumbering speed, the walkers still feel like a huge threat, and that gap between how slowly they move and how dangerous they feel is what makes the game unsettling. The Tabletop Minions channel adds that a fixed set of rules for the zombies is what makes solo play workable, a design approach it describes as AI in the same shorthand used for video game opponents.
Stealth Through Sound and Quiet Movement
The cooperative missions reward careful movement over open combat. The Watch Review describes the game as "mostly built around sound," with players trying to "stay quiet while also killing or avoiding zombies depending on what the mission requires and how great the threat is." Rather than running and blasting, survivors peek around corners, hide behind cover, and pick their fights. Terrain matters here too, since the game uses barricades, abandoned cars, and other pieces to block walker routes and shape how a team can slip past danger.
The Walking Dead: All Out War Experience
Dread That Builds Across the Campaign
Reviewers describe an arc that moves from caution to panic. Early on, players move slowly and hide, but as missions escalate the mood changes. The Watch Review captures the shift: "by the end you're just like dashing to save your life and hoping that you're just faster than the friend that's running beside you." That tension comes from the walkers themselves, not from a single dramatic moment, and it keeps the team on edge long after the first mission.
Comic-Faithful Scenarios That Feel Like a Movie
The scenarios borrow directly from the comics, and reviewers find that the setting gives the game its flavor. The Watch Review imagines heading into Atlanta for new guns or reopening Hershel's barn despite knowing better, a pull that fits the game's horror-movie pacing. The Tabletop Minions channel notes that the comic and TV show are "a little interchangeable" for many fans, which means the source material gives players a familiar starting point even when they know the story only from the show.
What Makes The Walking Dead: All Out War Stand Out
A Cooperative Variant That Changes the Game
The most consistent praise is for the cooperative mode, which reviewers prefer over the head-to-head game. The Watch Review says the group chooses "the official cooperative variant that makes this feel more like a fantastic zombie horror movie," and credits the fear of the walkers as the reason the game works as a Halloween pick. Because the threat comes from AI-run walkers rather than an opposing player, the team faces the same danger together rather than fighting over the table.
A Gateway From Zombie Fandom Into Wargaming
The Tabletop Minions channel argues the game sits between a board game and a miniatures game, which makes it approachable for people who are not yet wargamers. The host describes the game as one that "starts to straddle the fence a little bit more on the miniature game side." The models are a major draw, and many of them come as one-piece sculpts. As the channel puts it, "a quick prime and some quick paint is a very doable thing for someone you know interested in these games."
Potential Drawbacks
The Skirmish Identity Can Overshadow the Co-op Experience
The game's competitive roots remain visible. The Watch Review notes that the game is "mostly known as a head-to-head skirmish game," which means players looking for the cooperative horror experience need to seek out the variant on purpose. Players who expect a standard skirmish may find the co-op mission structure is not what they signed up for.
Terrain and Painting Requirements
Setup is not turnkey. The Tabletop Minions channel points out that the box does not include a proper playing surface: "there's nothing particularly in here that looks like an actual board to play on." Players need terrain that looks like a field or a city street. The models also arrive in similar gray tones, which makes it harder to tell the zombies from the survivors, so the channel recommends at least some paint to differentiate them, noting that "it's a little bit harder to see the difference between the zombies and the non zombies."
If You Enjoy The Walking Dead: All Out War
- Zombicide: The Tabletop Minions channel notes that cooperative games like Zombicide can be played alone, and the Tabletop Minions channel credits it with teaching players to think about positioning and line of sight in a board game format. It is a natural next step for fans who want zombie cooperation with a lighter footprint.
- Frostgrave: The Tabletop Minions channel describes Rangers of Shadow Deep as carrying Frostgrave's chops, with a leader and a small band of henchmen, scenario-driven missions, and a cooperative option that also works solo. Players who like the small-warband feel of The Walking Dead: All Out War should find a familiar rhythm there.
- Dark Souls: The Board Game: The Tabletop Minions channel calls it a micro skirmish with big, detailed miniatures played on a board, and it appeals to video game fans in the same way the zombie license appeals to comic and TV fans. Axis and Allies makes a useful contrast, since it is a board game with miniature-looking pieces rather than a true skirmish game.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"Now this game is mostly known as a head-to-head skirmish game, but we prefer to play the official cooperative variant that makes this feel more like a fantastic zombie horror movie."
— Watch Review
"It can be played with the the the zombies have a set of rules that they follow so that no player has to play the zombies."
— Tabletop Minions
"This starts to straddle the fence a little bit more on the miniature game side in my opinion."
— Tabletop Minions