Trick Shot (Second Edition) Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Trick Shot
Reviewers tend to describe Trick Shot (Second Edition) as a sports board game that actually works. In a full review, BoardGameBollocks called it a delightful ice hockey game that is simple enough to teach once players know the actions, and the reviewer gave it a strong recommendation. A later top 10 list from the same channel placed it among the best sports games that channel had played, and a separate top 100 video described it as one of the reviewers' favorite sports games of all time. Ryan of Rolls in the Family went further, calling it the best sports game Ryan has ever played, while brother Daniel described it as a must own.
Luke Hector of The Broken Meeple was more measured. Luke Hector had heard little about the game before its second edition appeared, and judged the price harder. The pre-painted edition under review was around 89 euro, and shipping pushed a typical order toward 110 to 120 euro, which felt like a little over the top. Luke Hector still found the concept unusual, noting that sports games rarely translate well to the tabletop and that a push your luck mechanism built around ice hockey had not really been done before.
Core Mechanics That Define Trick Shot
Push Your Luck Dice and Stamina
The central system is a push your luck dice pool, which Ryan of Rolls in the Family explained in detail. The first action of a turn uses a single die, and each die carries only one X icon, so the opening action usually succeeds. Every later action adds another die to the pool, and the chance of an X appearing rises with each addition. After a failure, a player can spend a line change token to flip the dice that show icons and reroll them, but the tokens are finite. If a failure occurs with no token available, the turn ends and the line change stays exhausted into the next turn. Ending an action successfully lets a player refresh the line instead of pressing on, which creates a real choice between chasing a shot and handing over the puck.
BoardGameBollocks describes the same tension through the stamina system, noting that the more actions a player takes in a turn, the harder each one becomes, which the reviewers read as a thematic reflection of fatigue. Failed passes and shots also carry a puck icon count that shows how far the puck overshot its target, which can leave it loose for an opponent to collect and run with.
Skater Roles and Arena Powers
Each side fields a defenseman, a winger, a center, and a goalie. Each skater has a player power on a card that comes with the arena card chosen for the match. BoardGameBollocks gives concrete examples: a center may move one square after an opposing puck carrier performs a move action, a winger carrying the puck may change one arrow into a blank when activated, and an aggressive defenseman may move one square in any direction before attempting a hit. Ryan of Rolls in the Family said these powers make each team feel asymmetrical and open up strategic thinking about how to build a play.
The arena card also sets a home rule that applies to everyone. In the Edmonton arena that Rolls in the Family tried, hits became a regular action that could be rerolled with a line change, so players slammed into each other far more freely. Ryan said the same teams in a different arena would have felt completely different.
The Trick Shot Experience
Edge-of-the-Seat Tension
Reviewers consistently describe the push your luck structure as the feature that keeps the tension high. Each added die makes the next action riskier, so every turn becomes a judgment about whether a chance on goal is worth the possibility of busting. BoardGameBollocks noted that this kind of decision is rare in sports games, and Ryan of Rolls in the Family framed it as a question of how much risk a player will accept, since hockey is about shots and real scoring chances are scarce.
The Unpredictability of Real Hockey
Rolls in the Family praised the way Trick Shot captures the randomness of the sport without bogging down. Ryan and Daniel observed that many sports board games either become too much of a simulation and grind to a halt, or keep the speed of play but lose all resemblance to the real sport. They felt Trick Shot found a middle path, with failed passes and shots that can leave the puck loose and create sudden turnovers. Daniel said that no other board game came to mind that simulated the feeling of pushing forward for a goal so well. BoardGameBollocks made a similar point in its 2024 top 10 video, describing the push your luck flow as mirroring the way an ice hockey game moves.
What Makes Trick Shot Stand Out
Table-Ready Production
Nearly every reviewer raised the visual impact of the game. BoardGameBollocks in its full review called it one of the best looking sports games it had come across, and treated the painted miniatures as the main reason to choose the more expensive edition. A later video described the component quality as exceptional and the fully painted miniatures as a real stunner on the table. Luke Hector of The Broken Meeple agreed that the pre-painted version is worth the premium because it reinforces the hockey theme on the table.
Variety From Arena Cards
The arena cards and player powers combine to make each match feel different. BoardGameBollocks pointed to the large number of player cards, most of which differ from one another, as the reason the game changes from one play to the next. Rolls in the Family showed that the arena choice alone can change the character of a match, since a home arena rule can turn a defensive contest into a much more aggressive one.
Potential Drawbacks
Defense Can Feel Helpless
The most frequent criticism concerns reactions. In its full review, BoardGameBollocks explained that a defending player's reaction only lets a skater move one space after an action resolves, so it can feel as though the defense cannot influence an attacker who is rolling well. The reviewer described attackers skating past a large defense and scoring straight away, with nothing the defending side could do about it. The same reviewer acknowledged that the dice can work against the attacker just as easily, but the frustration was still noted as a real limitation.
A Large Board and a Sparse Feel
Two reviewers pointed to the physical footprint. BoardGameBollocks felt the main board could have been shrunk to a more manageable size, since much of it sat unused on the table, and it also noted that the scoreboard lies flat with no stand, so it is hard to check the score at a glance. A later top 100 video described the board as massive and said the game can feel a little empty, because only a few skaters occupy the rink at any moment. Luke Hector of The Broken Meeple raised cost as a separate concern, since the pre-painted edition and shipping together make the purchase expensive.
If You Enjoy Trick Shot
Power Boats is the closest match for players who enjoy Trick Shot's dice pressure. In its 2025 top 100 video, BoardGameBollocks ranked Power Boats among its all-time favorites and praised the thrill of committing to a route before rolling its free-sided dice, then predicting the result. The reviewers did not draw a direct comparison between the two games, but both reward a player who accepts risk in exchange for a chance at a big result.
AG Warp Gate is a useful pick for fans who want to explore the designer's earlier work. Luke Hector of The Broken Meeple linked the Trick Shot designers to AG Warp Gate, a space game recalled as a relatively quick title with a cool card system. Luke Hector noted that the second edition's streamlined rules suggested the team had been fixing issues from the first release.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"But it uses this really clever push your luck dice mechanism where your first action on your turn you're just rolling one dice and each die only has one X on it, which is kind of what would end your turn if you get that, and so it's very likely your first action is going to succeed."
— Rolls in the Family
"I like the idea that this is a unique theme because we don't have a lot of sport games, because they usually don't translate well to a board game, but a push-up mechanism, ice hockey, it's not really been represented before."
— Luke Hector, The Broken Meeple
"The push your luck element in this game works really, really well, and it just keeps you on the edge of your plastic seat. It gives you a nice little feeling of squeaky bum time when you're playing this game."
— BoardGameBollocks