Martian Chess Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Martian Chess
Reviewers respond to Martian Chess with curiosity first and then divide over whether the play lives up to the premise. The Chairman of the Board channel ranks it fourth among five recently played titles and describes it as one of the weirdest games the host has played in some time. The host notes that calling it chess is a bit of a reach, because the goal is not checkmate but scoring points by capturing pieces. That novelty earns real praise, yet the same review concludes that the gameplay felt lackluster, with the design failing to push players toward decisive action.
Adam Porter, host of Adam in Wales - Board Game Design, approaches the game as a case study in abstract design rather than a full verdict. Adam uses it to illustrate how pieces can change control during play and how capture scoring can be tied to piece size, placing it in a survey of abstract strategy games where the highest score at the end wins. The third video, from the Chairman of the Board channel, is a UK Games Expo haul in which the host bought a copy from the bring and buy for very little money and admitted not remembering how it played. Taken together, the discussion agrees that the ownership concept is distinctive and that the game is unusual, while the strongest critical opinion centers on how the game ends.
Core Mechanics That Define Martian Chess
Territorial Piece Ownership
The defining rule is that no piece belongs to a player permanently. According to the Chairman of the Board channel, a piece belongs to a player only while it sits on that player's side of the board. Adam Porter describes the same rule from the other direction: you control the playing pieces in your own half, and when a piece crosses into the opponent's half, the opponent takes control of it. Because a capture places the captured piece on the capturer's side, the victim of a capture is handed to the opponent. The Chairman likens this to Onitama, where a player uses an ability and then gives it to the opponent, and the result is that every capture is also a gift that can come back into play.
Size-Based Movement and Piece Merging
Pieces come in three sizes, and each size moves differently, much as the pieces in chess do. Reviewers describe the rules a little differently, which itself signals how unfamiliar the game feels. The Chairman recalls that the smallest pieces move one space diagonally, the medium pieces can jump one or two spaces forward, and the large pieces can travel as far as they like in any direction, while Adam Porter describes the smallest pyramids as moving one space horizontally or vertically and the largest pyramids as queens. Adam highlights a feature the Chairman did not mention: two small pieces can merge into a medium piece, and a small piece merged with a medium piece becomes a queen. Scoring follows from size, since each captured piece is worth one, two or three victory points depending on how large it is, and the highest total at the end of the game wins.
The Martian Chess Experience
Tension That Settles Into Avoidance
The early game produces real interest. The Chairman of the Board channel describes starting to play and finding the sacrifice element genuinely engaging, since every capture hands material to the opponent and the decision to trade carries weight. As pieces come off the board, however, the feeling changes. The host reports that the game seemed to draw to a grinding halt because there comes a point where few moves remain, so both players settle into staying out of each other's way. The tension that made the opening compelling gives way to a standoff that the reviewer felt ruined the experience.
Abstract Intrigue and Unfamiliar Logic
Martian Chess feels strange in a way that rewards curiosity. Reviewers describe a game that does not follow the familiar patterns of chess or other head-to-head abstracts, and that makes players think about control and ownership in a fresh way. Adam Porter argues more broadly that abstract strategy games are at their best when complexity comes from the direct interaction between opponents rather than from layers of overlapping systems, a quality that suits players who enjoy working out a new idea. That same unfamiliarity is also why some reviewers approach it cautiously, since the logic needs time to settle before its strengths become apparent.
What Makes Martian Chess Stand Out
The Ownership Concept
The clearest point of agreement is the ownership system. The Chairman of the Board channel calls the idea that a piece is yours only while it stays on your side of the board super creative, and says the host loved it despite criticisms of the gameplay. Adam Porter presents the same rule as a clear example of how an abstract game can change control of its pieces during play, which is why the design stands out among games where pieces stay with their owner for the whole match.
Merging Pieces Into Stronger Units
Adam Porter calls the ability to upgrade pieces one of the unique features of the game. A small piece that moves onto a matching small piece forms a medium piece, and that medium piece can join with another small piece to form a queen. This gives players a way to build value on the board rather than only trading it, and it links the size-based movement rules to a clear plan that a player can pursue across the game.
Potential Drawbacks
Stalemate and Grinding Halt
The most serious criticism comes from the Chairman of the Board channel, which finds that the endgame stalls. The host says the game seemed to draw to a grinding halt, and notes that the rulebook allows players to agree to stop when the game reaches a stalemate. The host considered that a bit of a copout, arguing that the design should pressure players to finish and force them to make moves they would prefer to avoid. In this reviewer's view, the game does not do that, leaving the final stage feeling lackluster.
Too Little Pressure to Engage
The second concern is that the game does not encourage aggressive play. The Chairman of the Board channel describes missed opportunities to give players encouragement and a nudge to be more aggressive. When players can keep their distance from each other without penalty, the most engaging element of the system, the exchange of captured pieces, becomes optional, and the reviewer felt that the design needed a stronger incentive to confront the opponent.
If You Enjoy Martian Chess
Players drawn to the ownership twist may enjoy Onitama, which the Chairman of the Board channel invokes as a point of comparison. In Onitama, the movement cards you use are passed to the opponent, so using a move makes it available to them later, and Adam Porter describes it as a hybrid that blends the classic gameplay of chess and checkers with a drafting system. Players who appreciate the psychological hook of giving something away to the opponent may also appreciate Quarto, which Adam Porter names as a personal favorite. In Quarto, the opponent chooses the piece you must place, and Adam calls that central mechanism one of the best hooks in modern tabletop games, combining intuitive play with a strong sense of interaction. Both games offer a tighter sense of direction than Martian Chess, which makes them a natural next step for anyone who likes the idea of the game but wants more momentum.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"I love the idea as a piece is yours as long as it's on your side of the board. That's super creative and I loved it."
— Chairman of the Board
"The smallest pyramids can only move one space horizontally or vertically, the middle-sized pyramids can move one or two spaces again horizontally or vertically, but the largest pyramids are queens and they can move as far as they like horizontally vertically or diagonally. One unique feature of this game is the ability to upgrade your pieces if you move one of your own small pyramids into the same space as another of your small pyramids they can merge to become a medium pyramid."
— Adam Porter, Adam in Wales - Board Game Design
"The game seemed to draw to a bit of a kind of a grinding halt really because there comes a point in the game where there aren't that many moves to be made, meaning that people just play this game of kind of avoiding each other and staying each out of each each other's way. And it kind of becomes a bit of a stalemate really. And I thought that really ruined the experience."
— Chairman of the Board