Skip to main content
Loading video...

BGG.con Game Impressions Part 1

Transcript 15:56

welcome to John gits games today I'm excited to talk about my initial Impressions on 24 different games that I played at board game geekcon last weekend now that is way too many for one video so I've split it up into eight games in three videos and I kind of scattered the ones I liked and the ones I disliked throughout all three videos so let's jump right into it the first game just going to get it out of the way was mysterium by Portal Games this was probably the hit of the convention it it sold out relatively early before I was able to get a copy unfortunately and it is phenomen it's a Cooperative game which I'm not normally crazy into but there is no way that anybody can take over this game and tell other people what to do because okay so one player plays a ghost and every other player plays a psychic who was in a haunted house and the psychics are all connected with one person who died in that house and the ghost is trying to lead the psychics to figuring out who they're connected with so they can solve this uh age this long ago murder and the way that works is all the players get dreams in the middle of the night which are these cards that the ghost player gives out they are really surrealistic if you've ever played Dixit they're a lot like that where there's all sorts of unconnected beautiful stuff going on in each card and they're going to give a couple of them to each player and the player needs to figure out the connections between these really weird cards and the reality of the situation they're trying to figure out so first they need to figure out who is the person I'm connected with and they could look down in a car and see oh there's a picture of a race car driver in a metal and and it's a guy with mustache okay

that is probably a race car driver and here's a guy there's Barber shears and a little Top Hat okay maybe that guy was um a hair cutter and then you get these cards in and you're think oh my goodness what does these two cards have in connection with more of with one than any of the others that are out in front of you and you're all talking about it so it's this awesome group deduction thing while the ghost is sitting on the other side of the table can't say anything because you know the dreams are done and now everyone has woken up in the morning and they're interpreting and it's really really cool I enjoyed it a lot I'm definitely going to be grabbing it because I love deduction and I hate the only reason I don't like Cooperative games is because somebody takes over and there's no way to do it because the answer is not set in stone and there's all sorts of awesome moments when you get it right and and really perplexing moments when you think I can't believe I got that wrong it was so obvious you sure it wasn't that location Ghost and the Ghost says no guess I gave him the wrong cards and of course the ghost has a very set number of cards they don't have every option ever so they might just give you a card because the predominant color on that card is blue and the location is kind of bluish so there's just so many different ways to take it really really cool game game two was actually a prototype and this is something I did not expect to be able to play at the convention and that was seaall by Rob davio which is his Euro Legacy game uh if you're not familiar with Legacy games the idea of those is that the game permanently changes as the game goes on like you play one game and then the next time you play the board has changed because you're putting stickers down and uh you might be tearing things up you're doing all sorts of very permanent things to create a unique gaming experience and this one is

kind of a 4xy Euro game I'm not going to commit to the 4X bit and I'm not even going to say too much about the game but it was really good and we got to try a version of the game that had some new mechanics like it was very a very new uh some new changes that Rob davio had put in there and some of them worked really well some of them need a little bit of fine tuning but it's got ships you're putting stickers down I enjoyed it and I cannot wait until the real version of it comes out game three is The Witcher and this is a game that my friend Matt and I demoed at the Fantasy Flight games booth and we were intrigued enough that we went out of our way and rented it from the game library and played a short two Quest full version of the game with three players and and I enjoyed it it did some pretty interesting things that I'm not used to in adventure games where like right from the very beginning of the game on your first turn you can spend an action and start developing you can get a new skill just for just for spending the action or you might get a new axe or various upgrad type things that sometimes you have to kill a bunch of monsters first to get experience to do this not in this game you just get it right away uh you're going to be moving around this board going from City to City getting clues and once you get enough Clues you turn those in for I don't know a realization token or something like that and you spend those to complete quests to get victory points and at the end of the game you want to have the most victory points It's relatively multiplayer soliter there's a little bit of things you can do where you could help somebody else with their Quest whether they want it or not and you get more points than they do for the most part you're running around the board doing your own thing and turns are very very quick you only have two actions which is kind of good because it means that it's going to be your turn

again relatively soon but on the flip side it means you often times don't feel like you did anything on your turn you just move to a location and then maybe rest and then your turn's over but it'll come back again to you relatively quickly so that's not a problem you're going to be fighting a lot of monsters often times it feels like you don't really get much for those monsters especially the lowlevel ones but you get victory points for the higher ones in general I enjoyed playing it I hope to play it again at some point but I'm not necessarily going to rush out try and buy it game four is Johari now this is a game I was not initially interested in I heard lukewarm opinions of it that it might be kind of boring and dry but then I saw an interesting video of it online I decided to give it a shot we played a three-player game and we ended up enjoying it the basic idea of this game is you have a hand of um some number of cards action cards like seven or so and everyone simultaneously picks one and puts it down it has a cost associated with it you all flip it over and you evaluate it in turn order in kind of a Stefon Feld style where you have um turnor pieces and the ones on top go in order and you pay the cost for the card and you do the thing which is usually purchasing gems from various different spots on a board uh then you all pick from your ex um the cards you have left to do the second spot you flip that over and we do that again in the specific player order which has probably changed because that's based on the amount of gold you have in the second slot it's there's a discount to playing the card and then we'll all do that a third time and in this slot every card is free but at this point all the good stuff has been taken now the interesting parts of this game are first of all you're trying to get sets it's a set collection game that you're buying these gems from markets you're trying to turn that either a lot of them in uh a wide

variety of them in or just one of them in if you do just one you want a lot of it but you can't turn it in for points unless somebody else has some of them some of that gem as well you need to have more of them which sounds kind of convoluted and weird but in reality it means you're really paying attention to what your other players are doing if you have eight uh rubies and neither of them have any you can't turn those in for points and they're not going to want to take rubies because they they see you have eight rubies every is Open Face in this game so they're not going to take them so you you definitely have interesting decisions to make based on what other people do this is not a multiplayer solitary game at all uh and then when you do diversity you're going to get less points but it's not associated with what other players have also many of the gems are counterfeit and whenever somebody sells gems either a variety or a singularity everyone else has to discard one of their counterfeit gems because the inspector goes around when there's a sale so there are ways to protect yourself around this but you definitely are interacting with what other people have if you have lots of counterfeit gems it's going to affect how you play versus what you think your opponents are going to do so that you can protect them I found it really enjoyable there's a little bit of engine building you get these cards that can buff the cards in your hand so you always have the same cards in your hand you you pull the three back up and you do it all over again but you might get a card that says okay every now you every time you do this one card it costs you less or it's a little bit more powerful very solid game uh we felt it was a bit long it was a 12 turn game and it kind of felt like maybe this game should have been like eight or nine turns I think I might end up getting this and if I do I

doubt I will ever play it to 12 turns again and the game went well over an hour and a half and I felt like it wanted to be about an hour hour 15 so I'll tweak around with that that's really easy to change because you just have a deck of 12 cards and once you go through all 12 it's done so you could just put less cards in that deck and I think the game will work very well in that way so I liked it game five is a word game called PRX I didn't expect to play any word games at this convention because it's not a kind of game that I like in general as a genre mostly because my brain just locks down with trying to figure out what word I can make with these letters because usually you only have those letters to work with in many word games also there's usually a timing element of like a sand Tim or just your friends getting really frustrated at you for taking too long of a turn and this game kind of fixes a lot of those things uh the way it works is you have a board with eight different uh letters on it and you just could say any word you want you are only going to get scored for the letters that match up with the ones on the board so you want to have a word that uses as many of them as you can but at the end of the day you're not overly restricted you feel relatively free to just go with something and if you're not coming up with any good you just say something that's not that great get a couple of points and be a little bummed about your turn but not worry about it too much now there is a little bit of a timing element in that your opponents can jump in on your turn and say a word instead of you they can interrupt but they get a negative Point uh penalty for doing that and they also get to they have to cross out one of the previous words so if they had a crappy word then they're probably going to want to interrupt you but it seems relatively balanced to the point where they're not just going to be

saying any word they're only going to interrupt you if they really come up with something better than you so there is a bit of a timing stress there but the game was so light and that you you have that feeling that you could jump in on somebody else's if they jump in on you and squander your turn that it seems to bounce out really well I was very pleasantly surprised by this I could see myself owning it and I look forward to playing it again game six is Istanbul uh now this game got a lot of hype because it won the SPI auris this year and I I read about it I looked into it and I didn't really think it was necessarily going to be my thing but when I had the opportunity to play it at the convention I decided to jump in just give it a shot and see what all the buzz was about and ultimately I liked it about as much as I thought I was going to which is I didn't hate the time I spent playing it but it really didn't engage me very much and there's a few reasons for that largely you it has this mechanism where you have a stack of of workers essentially and you just move to an adjacent spot on the board and you lay a worker down and then you do the action and then at some point you run out of workers because you stack it smaller and smaller at which point you have to either start re retracing your steps or you just start losing turns until you can go back and start retracing your STS your steps unfortunately that means that I felt like the whole game I was doing everything twice because I would do a path and then I would undo that path and I felt very restricted by that I know there are probably other ways you can go and I'm sure I was playing but I didn't I didn't like feeling like I was just going back and forward doing the same actions you know I feel I felt

vested once I did these three or four actions I was going to have to go back and do them again before I could do something else and you could break off to do other things but now you're stranding pawns which you could say okay those are interesting decisions but it didn't really line up for me also at the end of the day this is a euro game but it's a race it's the first person to get to uh some number of rubies so it also had that realization where like three turns from the end I said I it'll take me five turns exactly to win to to end and I look over to the person next to me because there's pretty much no hidden information and I say it's gonna take him two turns to win so I just gonna kind of phone in my last couple turns because it's not even it's not even a choice it's not even close and uh I don't really like that in gamees so I don't see myself playing Istanbul again but I'm glad it did game seven is lifted and this was a huge surprise to me I had seen a little bit about it on the board game geek stream from Essen but a friend of mine ran over with a copy of it in his hands he say we got to play this we got to play this we got to play this and I said okay and it's a really goofy game more almost more of an experience it's a dexterity game where you strap this little crane to your head and from that there's a string that drops down to a hook and you are manipulating this with your head and you're trying to build these um these structures with these essentially Kitty type toys and very like there's an angle and there's a sphere and there's a cylinder and they got little hookie spots in it you can

pick them up and you're trying to build these towers uh based off of a card that's played down now we didn't actually play the official rules with the time frame on them we just played two uh two teams uh myself and my friend hung versus my friend Matt and Dylan and we just flipped over the card whoever built it first one and we didn't really keep track and it was so much fun oh my gosh we had a blast and people started crowding around the table looking at us and you know laughing along with us uh my friend hung and I at one point we had to get an angular piece in a really hard way so we both hooked our hooks into it so we're both controlling the same piece with our heads and we accidentally knock over the whole Tower and it's it's so silly and it was so much fun I have got to get this when when it becomes available I'm going to acquire it because this is such an amazing Icebreaker I mean as a filler it's brilliant it's just it's just a really fun kind of party game is experience that was a total blast I mean just look up any photos or videos online and I think you're probably going to want to play it too and for the final game of this video number eight we have hyperboria if you've seen my John gets excited videos you might know that I was really excited to play this game I it was one of my number one games to play the convention because it looked gorgeous it had some you're getting technology you're you have this bag of cubes in it and you you can decide which new cubes to put in there and you're pulling them out a bag building thing going on and you're putting them around oh man I was really really excited to play this I played it on my second day of the convention with my friend Matt to

other people and it totally flopped for all of us we were all just sitting there thinking why is this so hyped I don't get it and I'm understanding they I'm like I was so excited about this game why am I not enjoying it and there were a couple reasons for that the first is it was slow uh most mostly because you every time you reset the bag every time you go through your entire bag that's when you get to kind of pull your pieces out of the cities on the map and then you get to use all the pieces on the map again but once they're used you don't get to use them again until you go through that bag which incentivizes you to keep your bag small which is weird in a game that's all about building that bag up so of course and I decided I immediately started getting cubes into the bag of specific colors the ones that would match my Technologies for my race and the one guy who didn't who just said I think I'm just not going to add cubes into my bag at all pretty much he he haded maybe like four in the entire game and he had this amazing ability to pull three out for one blue he just did that every turn for the first three turns of the game he just played every single Cube from his bag um because he had a spot to go on the board to pull another one out then he would spend a blue to pull three more out and then the way the matth worked out he did this like three turns in a row and then uh later on he got a couple cubes to the point where he was resetting every two turns and it felt like what he was doing was the way the game was supposed to be played and all of us were sitting there like Schmucks we're like why we keep putting cubes in our bag it's slowing down the amount of time we have until that we can reset the board on average it took us three to four um turns to be able to unset our dudes and that felt so slow

and just clunky and awkward I would love to be told that I was playing this game incorrectly I don't necessarily think we were but it just really really disappointed all of us we felt very uh disassociated with any theme it just did not work and I I mean if somebody's really excited and they want me to play it with them at some point the future I'll give it a go again maybe to see if we maybe got a little rule wrong here or there but I don't really see that happening which is definitely a bummer but I'm glad I did that before I spent a bunch of money on it and that wraps up this first video if you want to click the link over there or the one down in the description you will go to the next eight games that I'm going to talk about that I played at this convention uh I hope you enjoyed this video please subscribe if you like what you've seen and thanks for watching

Progress saved