Skip to main content
Loading video...

Wingspan, Just One, LAMA & Spiel Des Jahres 2019

Transcript 14:13

hi I'm Adam Porter and this is my board gaming vlog and today we're going to talk about the spirit as Yara's Awards because the nominees were announced for 2019 the spirit is Yaris is the most prestigious award and this week is one of the most fascinating weeks in the boardgame calendar really when those builders Yara's awards the nominees are announced the winner is also an exciting and exciting time when that gets announced but there are three levels to this award there's the family level award which is the spilled as Yara's itself there's the kinder spiel the children's game awards and then the kennerspiel which is the gamers that sort of the experienced players award now I never really know the kinder spiel games I'm not usually familiar with them so I won't cover them in too much detail but it was nice to see games like magic maze kids getting a mention and concept kids getting a mention these kids versions of the sort of games I've got all around me really getting some sort of Nod and actually a seal of quality there so that's nice to see the spiel dis Yara's Awards themselves were the nominees were just won and Lama and we're words now none of those games is an obvious sort of breakout hit not something that leaps out as being you know absolute builders Yara's quality but then I don't know what else was from last year um but actually once we start looking at them I think it's interesting to go back over the years of this field as urs and think about you know has it has it represented over those years the

way that our hobby has evolved and all the various different landmarks in that time I mean we've seen deck builders represented with Dominion we've seen you know lots of tile laying games with Carcassonne and Tikal and things in the early earlier years of - builders Yara's we've seen all the worker placement games when they came out then Kahless and Agricola were getting awards from the spiros ers jury cooperative gaming matt leacock kept missing out with things like forbidden island and pandemic you've lost out to Dominion I mean what a year that was Dominion versus pandemic but then later he gets his award for the special award last year for for pandemic legacy season two and so legacy games get a knot when that micro game fad was going on over about three two or three years there were loads of micro games coming out with very few components and that was around the time that a Nabi came in now a Nabi wasn't quite a micro game but it was very very small for a spear as euros game so what's left I mean what are the remaining sort of genres which haven't been represented in spirit as Yara's and I would say one of them is social deduction and this is where where words comes in where words is the first time as far as I'm aware that a spill does Yara's nominee has been a social deduction game so I think it stands a chance I think the closest we had was spiteful getting recommended a few years ago what about app based games in the kennerspiel category we've got the game

detective a very complex long app based sort of deduction sort of style game which I don't think we've seen the like of in spirit as Yaris before it or who's seen anything with that hybrid of technology and and sort of tabletop gaming so I think Detective stands a real chance because of the innovation there I mean the spirit of Yaris does recognise innovation we saw the exit games winning the kennerspiel last year so the obvious winners the ones which I think I don't know leap out are just one for this field as Yara's award and just because it's so accessible and so colorful and just billed as euros has given lots of awards for party games in the past but maybe where words with its slightly sort of crunchy a rule set might sneak in there now I can't really wear worse because I haven't got a copy of it and in fact I haven't played it although I have played the very similar game The Insider but I can tell you just one is far simpler than where words far more accessible and I know that because it's pretty much the simplest most accessible came over ever seen just one is a cooperative party game where all players work together to get the best score the group have given a mystery word which everyone sees except for one player who will be the guesser all players each write one word down on their plastic easel except for the guesser and the guesser closes their eyes then all are revealed any words which been duplicated are canceled by tipping ezel over and the guesser then opens their

eyes and looks at the remaining clues they then try to guess the mystery word this is repeated 13 times with players taking turns as guesser and the group scores one point for each success a score of 7 to 8 is considered average 11 to 13 is considered pretty awesome according to the manual now if we take a game like just one with its simple simple rule say I mean there's barely any rules to it let's compare that to a game that normally would be about as simple as it gets I I can't believe that a game like llama has been nominated for the Spirit Awards it's so simple but well I say that it's still about five six times as complicated as just one in llama each player has a hand of cards which are numbered between one to six or have a llama on them which is essentially a seven on a player's turn they may place one of their cards on the discard pile it must be equal to the card currently showing or one higher alarma is one higher than a six but it wraps around so that a one could be played on top of a llama if a player cannot discard a suitable card they must draw a card from the top of the deck or drop out of the round and the aim of the game is to get rid of all your cards before the other players now if you drop out you score the cards that you have remaining and points are bad in this game each card type is scored only once for the player and at face value so a six is worth six points but three sixes is also worth six points a llama is

worth ten points points are represented by tokens in denominations of 1 and 10 and if you get rid of all your cards then you may give up a token either a 1 or attend us losing points and when one player hits 40 points then the game ends and the lowest score wins now llama came out of left field with regards to this award I mean this is a uno variant it's a good one it's it's very very quick playing it's quite funny to play it's actually more fun and more funny than it looks in that in that overview to actually play the game it's just all these nice moments where you can sort of laugh at the other players bad luck or enjoy your own good luck or enjoy your own bad luck and although the game really only has one decision which is when to bow out when to think you know this is as good as it's going to get and then you lock down your score it is a delicious decision it's a really really neat one and very satisfying decision to make I think the other interesting sort of dichotomy sort of dilemma for the Spooner's ers jury is putting up carpe diem against wingspan now these could not be more of a sort of contrast we have carpe diem that came out with relatively little hype especially for a Stephan failed game a few years ago a Stefan Feld design game would have been everywhere everybody hyped about it everybody talking about it but now they just sort of sneaked out there and this with it's very low-key

art style very old-school sort of beige colorings that alia tends to sort of specialize in I mean this is not a lavish production and it's old-school Europe I'm sure it's very good I have not played it but it's going up against wingspan the darling of the currents on a board game world taking the board game world by storm not because of its in its innovative gameplay but because of its stunning production values it's clever accessible theme it's mega popular trendy sort of publisher brand stone Meyer behind it and actually because although the mechanisms are not hugely innovative they're pieced together in such a satisfying package let's have a look at how wingspan works in wingspan each player starts with some birds and some food and in this video I'm using the lovely wooden food tokens I bought separately from meeple source players are attempting to fill their own personal boards with birds and on a player's turn they may place a bird by feeding it with the required food type and in later spaces by also giving up one or two eggs and the birds must be placed into their favored habitats or the player may take food by selecting one of the visible dice results and taking a corresponding token or a player may lay six up to the allowance indicated on each bird card or they could draw new cards into their hand so they have four actions available and for each action you get an increased benefit if you have

several birds already in that corresponding habitat often when you take an action the special abilities of the birds on your board will activate giving you resources or other game-changing effects after each player has used all their actions then the round ends and bonuses are scored for certain objectives for example having the most Birds or having the most eggs in a certain type of nest and after four rounds the game ends and players reveal whether they've completed any of their secret objective cards these points are added to the point shown on the birds and they also gain one point per egg and then the highest scorer wins now wingspan is a great game i played wingspan a lot mainly a two-player banging out games twenty minutes a game we can play three in an hour and and you know and and it's great as a couple's game it's great once you start to get up to four players it starts to drag a little bit because there's not that much interaction really and so you're sitting there waiting for your turn but as a quick fast very very pretty game it's great it's more complex than the internet would have you believe okay the internet would have you believe this is the next Ticket to Ride or something like that it's not this is definitely a kennerspiel game it's definitely in the right category I've taught people this and found that they they're a bit confused when it when they're newcomers to the Hobby this would not be the first game I've introduced them to despite the super accessible theme but it's not mega complex either it is certainly a next

step after you've got those first few games out of the way and people are getting a feel for what this euro sort of Hobby game thing is so which games do I think you're going to win and the spirit is yours I can't call it to be honest I think probably where words because of that social deduction thing I think it's about time social deduction God and not in terms of is that the best of the games well as I say I haven't played where words although have played insider which is very very similar I think the best game is probably just one does I mean it'll win I don't know it depends whether they pick innovation over over sort of accessibility I suppose and actually to call this one not into in innovative is is doing it a bit of a disservice I mean I myself designed the game doodle rush I can tell you having that simple an idea is is something it has huge value it's it's it's a you know I would be doing myself down if I if I said that you know that was somehow lesser than than something with a little bit more crunch to it I mean when you look at games like double and happy salmon and yogi these are brilliant brilliant games with one very basic idea and so I think just one you know it deserves it um personally I would have gone for silver and gold this didn't even get a nod I mean we talked about hitting this sort of the key sort of fad this one hits two of them we'd be it not yet seen a rolling right game win we had one nominated we had Ganz shown clever nominated for the Kenneth field as

Yara's last year this is a brilliant rollin right game by phil Walker Harding who also made sushi go it's also well it's not quite a polyomino game but a Tetris style game where you're putting together Tetris pieces and writing them off on your board that is another big trend at the moment those Tetris style games are putting together pieces and they've been around for a long time but it's become a fashion I remember years ago I think Arcadia by rüdiger dawn got nominated or recommended or something that was one of the early polyomino games and a very very good one if you want to look that up um so let's go forcefield as yours I'm gonna go for where words as the winner for Kenneth fielder's er s again depends on whether they go for innovation or whether they go for just straightforward good gameplay can't say carpe diem getting it I can't see I haven't played carpe diem maybe it's amazing that's you know I've not heard an enormous buzz around I have not heard as bad I've not heard it's great I've just not heard much about it whereas wingspan of heard everything about it and I can vouch for it being an absolutely fantastic game Detective I would never play that's not to say that it's a bad game it's just not my style at all getting on a computer getting on a phone hours of game play duction style very stark and dark sort of graphics and and theme not really for me so I'm calling it for wingspan in fact I think it would be a bit of a travesty if wingspan didn't win with the amount of hype and support

that's behind it so another fascinating year first frivolous Yaris we'll just have to wait and see won't we I guess it will be revealed I think I can remember this July I think it's revealed this it's a little while we'll be waiting in the meantime maybe I'll try and get a game of carpe diem and wear words in anyway thank you very much for watching this video if you enjoyed it please watch some of my others on my channel Adams boardgame Wales or follow me on Twitter at boardgame Wales on BoardGameGeek I'm Adam 78 thank you very much for watching all of us

Progress saved