Episode 96 - BGA vs TTS - Is Online Gaming A Good Thing?
Transcript
you're listening to the broken me show a podcast that speaks passionately about board games for the benefit of those who play them my name's Luke Hector best known for the broken meele YouTube channel and I'm an everyday gamer just like you and I'll be talking about reviews top 10 and just about anything that connects me to board games as long as I have a tea or coffee in hand that is so grab a cup relax and enjoy and remember it's only a game hi everyone this is Luke Hector on the what's this the 5th of July 24 recording episode 96 and yeah it is a little bit early that I'm recording this because you'll notice that that's a Friday not a Sunday well on this occasion I needed to get the podcast done early because I'm going home to visit my parents for my dad's birthday this weekend so I'd have no time to do the podcast on the weekend and I wouldn't be free until at least probably middle of next week to record it then so rather than do it late I'm doing it early so that it can be ready to upload pretty much on the what one hour spare I get on Sunday and then at least I haven't got to worry about recording it but to be honest there's not a huge amount to do in this episode so this might be a bit of a shorter one than most I think it's time to ask the patreons for some more ideas I think for the uh podcast but yeah generally update wise um not too bad healthwise uh you know certainly the fro thing never resurfaced uh the summer has actually quietened down a little bit we had that one day of a heat wave but then the
weather's been reasonably warm but not too warm and lately we've just had a couple of days of rain including today and it's cooled down a bit to the point where it's like hovering around that 20° Mark maybe just slightly below but there's a bit more of a wind and obviously when the rain comes it cools down a bit in the UK anyway so actually I've been kind of liking it I know a lot of people are like oh I want a nice hot hot Blue Sky summer well for me I just want to be able to get my house so it doesn't like incinerate me every time I get out of bed or go into bed from ly and it's been doable it's been doable to actually cool the house down so what we in now the start of July well we still got the rest of July and August yet so there's still plenty of time for the weather to uh throw me a spanner in the works but we'll see how things go and then I'll just have to cool down in the Autumn when I go to Weston for Germany and when I go to the Arctic Circle in December because that is still on the cards um in terms of the blog itself not bad lately actually we're all up to 23687 so we're uh hurtling along towards the 25,000 Milestone that I'm aiming for at the moment but mainly there's not been a huge amount of video content because frankly there's not been a lot of review I mean I have got the peacemakers horrors of War review to edit but I've only just got to the point where I can kind of get that ready because I still need to double check when the Embargo for talking about it is they kind of said don't do it until about latest July so I'm going to touch base and find out when I can put that out but what I have done though is I did a halfe overview where just like last
year I basically look at the first six months of 20 in this case 24 and just give my impressions of surprises disappointments anticipated you know just like how's the year gone so far and look at that 11,000 views I wish I could get that on every single video but uh yeah know not going to knock it 411 likes 13 people who just can't who just like to troll me and that video is doing well and still going strong so thank you everybody who's watching it and the other one is that I have just started a new series called best and worst I came up the idea on I think the half year overview maybe a video before and what it basically is is it's kind of a different take on top 10 not to say that I'm going to stop doing top 10 but I think top 10 are going to be a bit less frequent now not you know not because I don't enjoy them although they do take a while to edit much like these ones do but the thing is I did a little kind of little survey as somebody on U one of my comments mentioned that top 10 were starting to get stale not my personally top 10s just top 10 in general like people are starting to get a little bit you know bored with seeing the same like oh here's 10 here's 10 games of which we don't care about the bottom five and then the top five are worth talking about and I asked the question on a couple of other things like the gaming rules slack Channel and and the like to sort of go is that actually the case are top 10s actually getting somewhat you know are they getting stale are we actually now at a point where we don't particularly like top 10 list and it's like okay I'm curious about that and so
far the feedback has been kind of mixed you know some say yeah you know what I'm starting to not really watch top 10 anymore and others are like no I still like watching them every now and again so and to be honest I find myself not watching a lot of them at the moment not because I don't like them but because you know some of the people that I used to watch top 10s for just don't do top 10s anymore so there's nothing there but also even the dice tower top 10s you know I don't really watch them anymore usually because as said the you had the original Trio and then you had the trio with you know Z Tom and deliso and those trios worked great on screen great chemistry I'm sorry but you know there hasn't been any Trio of good chemistry that has brought me into the top 10 since Mike sort of left and went further up North but also the topic ideas are just getting a little bit weird I mean the last one they did was a was it games beginning with a as if anybody cares why would why would that be interesting what is the what is the point of caring whether the games be begin with a certain letter or not and that's not what I want to do I don't want to do top 10 that are you know that are topics that aren't of any use to anybody so but then I'm also running out of you know potential top 10 ideas so what the whole point of this series was was to go well okay well what if I talk about my favorites and worst from specific things I would normally do on a top 10 list cuz doing top 10 of a publisher or designer is quite tricky when you haven't either played 10 games that they've done or maybe they haven't even released 10 games games that they've done you know they might not even have that many games and also you might just end up going through their entire catalog anyway so
the idea was that in order to not have to do a top 10 for those ones I do this best and worst which is where I talk about two maybe three I think at the moment it's being three but it'll fluctuate depending on the topic where I just talk about my two or three worst examples of what they've done and my two or three best examples of what they've done so I did recently uh the stonem one here the best and worst of stonem six ,700 and still climbing I mean and I expected this to be a lot lower on the uh likes and dislikes cuz there's a lot of Stow Mar Fanboys out there but even the ones who disagree with what I had to say are still liking the video and talking about it which is fantastic you know so this has already gone down well maybe not quite up to the caliber of some of my earlier top 10s but it's still doing pretty good and I've got another one that I'm hoping to release today actually you know I when did this one come out this came out on June the 30th so I've got one that I'm almost done editing I just need to finish off of the music and render it and then I will get it uploaded tonight um and that is the best and worst of OU Rosenberg so that one should have already released for a couple of days by the time you listen to this podcast and the idea is that I think Publishers and designers will be good topics for these occasionally mechanics like best and worst of area control or something like that for example and then what could happen is that my top 10 could be on more esoteric ideas not silly things like you know 10 games beginning with a letter t or something but you know maybe like for example I want to do a top 10 list on top 10 tips for uh running a
game club you know because i' I used to run a game club I used to run the Portsmouth one I kind of co-run uh the Southampton Club along with my mate Russell so you know I mean we don't technically have a hierarchy system but it's really us two that kind of like do a lot of the stuff and you know the idea is is that you know I have been to these two clubs I have run essentially half of these you know one of these clubs and half of the other and I've been to other clubs as well and I've seen good and bad stuff arise particularly in my Portsmouth one you know where I used to yeah that used to be run by someone else then I took over running it uh then uh two of us co- ran it and then I just didn't have the time and I wasn't liking the way the club was going and I just basically gave the you know the the running to the other person and yeah the that club has fluctuated up and down in terms of what I think works and what doesn't work and I think that's going to be a useful top 10 but that's the idea top 10s are going to be on more of those sort of topics rather than just top 10 oua Rosenberg games yeah the best and worst I think is just a little bit more palatable and then people can get not only stuff I'm going to talk praise about but given I do like to speak my mind I would like to talk about games I don't like as well so talking about my worst examples also does well and people can discuss and debate so so far the series is going good we'll see how the uie Rosenberg one does and by all means let me know your feedback as I do each video uh as to whether you're enjoying the series or not and we know we'll see what other ideas I can get on there I mean they will predominantly I think be
publisher and designer occasionally they might do a mechanic one but I think publisher and designer Works quite well uh I wouldn't mind doing a check game editions one that would be good for the next publisher one a designer maybe Vladimir sui we've played a bunch of his game so that might be a good potential one so yeah there's plenty of ones to do down the line but yeah there're the only two videos I did since the last podcast because there just hasn't been a lot of videos I mean look at this June 23rd June 27th June 30th I mean I haven't had a lot of time because work has been really really tough the summer for me is very difficult for work because a lot of the stuff that normally I would have to do in December to file like tax returns gets done in the summer because that's when the audit team does a lot of those accounts but they all have deadlines and I have other they know other things to do at work and so the summer becomes fraught with work I mean I've done a lot of extra hours in the last few weeks and those extra hours suck into time that I could be doing stuff with the blog so it is a a hit and miss Affair but as I say as the year goes on there's going to be more stuff to review you know I've got dog park with the expansion there will still be two videos on those coming out once I've uh given the game a bit more beans and played the solo mode a little bit peacemakers as I say will be another video to do but yeah there's only so much extra content and there's been nothing to review lately I mean nothing has released in the UK for I think the last month at least in terms of releases maybe month and a half like no game was
released that I've got any interest in I mean I even bought a copy of uh sand from uh de games um I've got the pronunciation whatever but you know dvir and you know I bought that one but I just can't find myself wanting to play it I mean you know I it was mainly just as a kind of whim I needed to you know buy like 50 quids worth of stuff and I just thought yeah for in you know mate of mine said that he tried it wanted to try it more I'm sure we'll get to play it at some point but I've read the rules to it and I look at it and it's just like this looks like a pretty boring pickup and deliver game but we'll see if it's any good and it's just not appealing to me and there's just not a lot of games that are being released at the moment that are appealing we're in the dry driest part of the year and until Gen Con comes around we're not going to see anything particularly new released and even then we need to get closer to essm so yeah so sorry that there's not been a ton of content but hopefully you're enjoying the best and worst videos and of course uh I'll get more content out as we go along so fair enough on that right let's talk about free games that I have played and two of these are going to be pretty short because there's not much to say about them and one of them is a bit more interesting let's talk about uh let's talk about the weirdest one first a friend of mine who I normally play now context here I normally play Heavy Euros with this person okay all right we tend to play you know they like some lighter games and one of them I'm actually going to talk about a little later in this episode but yeah we we do play some lighter games but for the most part we play the the heavier euros and to see
this game in his ham worried me slightly because oink games don't tend to do a lot of games that are you know very heavy in nature because they're all tiny boxes and this is a game called Dro poter Dro poter I don't know where dro polter the actual name comes from um but it's uh this was like a weird little party game and I thought okay this is really strange to see him with an oint game but okay I'll bite let's see it looks short this and I kid you not this is what the game is right you have a hand of five items a red plastic cube a blue wooden key uh a yellow what looks like a bit like a rice cracker um a white like silver clamshell and something and a ring a plastic ring like you would get out of like a juicy pop or whatever those one those like fun pops or something that you used to get as kids back in the 90s but you know you've got these items in your hand and then these these little metal bells that you can have which could end up there eventually the idea is is that each round someone flips the top card of a deck and the idea is is that whatever is pictured on the card you have to drop out of your hand but nothing else and if you have the bells which are victory points if you win around you get a bell in your hand you also have to not drop the bells otherwise you lose those victory points and that's pretty much the game you just have rounds after rounds going through the deck of cards where this card for example tells you to drop all four of these items and you have to somehow drop them at your hand but you only get to use the hand there
in so I can't drop them out of I can't use any other means of getting them out of my hand you have to kind of just jiggle your hand around move the fingers do some crafty like you know dexterity with your fingers in order to drop the particular items now it's stupidly easy when there's only one item typically and even then that tends to be random as to who wins that because it really does depend but you effectively have to shake the items in your hand between two hands first and then clinch the Fist and then open the Fist and start trying to draw them where the items end up in your hand after doing that will dictate your chances of winning it basically so it is just a silly little party game but yeah this is weird this is just weird I mean I don't know who came up with the concept of this game you know whether he was like a little bit high at the time but the fact that my friend had this I mean a guy who plays heavy Euro games pretty much never plays party games and for some reason bought this like he saw it being demonstrated or he saw it on the thing and just thought this sounds ridiculously silly let's just have a laugh with it and oink games aren't cheap so it really did shock me that he had this do I hate it no it is what it is it's a silly little party game the the problems I had with it was I won the game by kind of cheesing it a little bit because you're meant to get to five Bells that's the automatic winner but when you get to three bells in your hand it becomes insanely difficult to separate the Bells from all the other pieces and if you drop a bell you lose the Bell permanently and have to get it back again so there's no incentive to get to five I got to four by fluke a
card came out only wanted one item and it was at the top of my hand I was able to drop it easily so I got to four Bells right if I tried to drop any if I tried to do any of the other cards since that point I would have lost Bells because there's no way I could have done it to get to five items you have to be a dexterity master in order to do it it's too hard and to the fact that because your hand gets sticky and clammmy as the game goes on all the items made out of plastic in that basically stick to your hand so you know you're trying to dislodge the red que but you can't because it's partially wedged between two fingers and it's sticking to your fingers which means you can't physically dislodge it so you know that becomes a bit of a problem as the game goes on so I ended up winning it by literally just not really trying whilst I got four bells in my hand because I knew nobody else around the table was going to get to four Bells because they were constantly trying to usurp them M themselves or so you her brothers and surpass themselves and every time they tried they just ended up dropping their Bells so it it's kind of a weird little game it can be a bit cheesed but it is what it is it's a simple little party game that is a Bonkers idea I think somebody literally just had a bunch of random pieces in a sock draw or something and just decided how can we make a game out of this and so they did but it's another one that it does what it does I don't really care about it I'm not seeking it out or whatever you want something that's a little bit funny to play with your kids than by all means grab this but serious Gamers aren't going to play this that often although the four of us are serious Gamers and we ended up playing it so it wasn't exactly the first thing I expected him to pull out on game night but it's quick it's
fast I wouldn't say it was cheap because it's oink games it is what it is what what do I need to say it's a silly little dexterity game and I don't go mad for dexterity games but this exists so give it a look if you want something to entertain your kids I think right let's take a swig of green tea M and that's green tea mixed with some white marble honey uh one of my viewers um um very kindly sends me a lot of honey jars and in big bulk from Greece because I love honey you know in all shapes and sizes I mean I love Meade you know Meade is pretty much on par with cider now as like the two main drinks I love but in terms of alcohol but yeah I love honey so he sends me very kindly a bunch of honey from Gree and they come from a mixture of the stores but also from various people he knows who run their own beehives so I got jar as one of them which had no label on it no label at all it just literally had nothing on the label and it was just solid honey and we're talking solid like you have to carve into it in order to do it it is not runny honey but it was apparently called White marble honey and apparently it's a delicacy in grease but it tastes quite nice and it's still stirs into my tea so I got a little bit in there but all these other Honeys a mixture of hard and runny Honeys I mean it's as presents and Gifts go it's amazing so I love it when he does send me them you know thank you very much but um it's it's just like you know all this honey that I've got that I can just eat as I go along and trying all these different ones is really nice but yeah
it just kind of seemed weird anyway um getting off topic let's move on to the second game um as much as I can say look it's a harmless little dexterity game with a bunch of little pieces out your sock draw it is what it is this one though I don't know what it's trying to be I mean this one I think won some award or got nominated for some award in Australia that's what I heard I thought I read it somewhere that it did has Australia got a low bar for games because I'm a little bit concerned now this is called aamon collect I saw it at the UK games Expo didn't like willingly grab it I think I just got given one and it's basically I mean it I feel like Pokemon is going to sue somebody at this point because it basically is Pokemon the card game and all you do in this game and I kid you not this is the game right these cards which basically look like they've got Pokemon in fact some of these creatures look pretty much like ripoffs of Pokemon I mean look at this one matcha here I'm pretty certain in Pokémon there is a Firefox of some description and that looks Mighty similar to it and anything with a green like forest spider in it U you know deserves nothing but you know this is literally just a small box bunch of these cards a few little artifacts facts that give you like a once per game ability and the rules are written on cards so you don't even get a rule book They're written on cards that you have to keep an order and flip over I mean that's already a little bit of a oh Christ but all you do in this game and I kid you not this is all you do they lay down a grid you have this character
model in the middle and then you move the character model as far as you like in a row and pick up the card okay and the cards basically come in various different suits and they're worth one two or three points and you're basically trying to collect set you can play at Co-op where you have to like do you have to kind of like go through the Tableau and get so many cards you know without going bust but then you've also got the competitive mode which is you're trying to get sets and that's literally it I mean here's the typical setup so I could move this guy to the left take this uh langana or whatever that is over there then somebody else moves it south and takes this torto over here then somebody else moves over there takes this Raider and then basically just keep going like a rook in chess and collect cards for sets 15 20 minutes and that's a game that's it that literally is the entire game okay um am I missing something here I mean it's weight 1.0 on board gting in fact is that actually got anybody voting on it three people have voted on whether this is a light game and of course it's a light game so three people have voted on this that makes it wait one out of five like literally one out of five but this game is boring there's nothing in this game it's two to four players and you basically just move this thing around and collect cards for sets the competitive mode is just outright dull the co-ops a little better but I couldn't really entertain people for more than about five minutes of playing
this game before they got bored you know this I get that there's a market for these tiny little simil games and that but then why wouldn't you play something like love letter I'd rather play Love Letter if you want like a little micro game that's super quick and has some interesting choices in it at least has an element of bluffing a little bit of deduction in it this one is literally just move a piece you know up down left and right and collect cards for sets you the other detail on the card is meaningless it doesn't matter what the name of the animal is it they don't have special abilities or anything you got these little artifacts that give you a once per game ability but even they're not particularly interesting it's just it just doesn't do anything there like this is this is kind of like your typical thing that you sometimes find at UK games Expo a small game done by you know Indie people which fair enough you know they they put their heart and soul into a game and I suppose it's a you know partially a dick move for me to be talking bad about it but uh I say it how it is I just didn't get any enjoyment out of this I mean this is on par with something like a gentle rain yeah I said it I'm getting sick and tired of a gentle rain being talked about all the time on solo things but I'm sorry but this gentle rain game is boring and tedious and I don't like this one either I mean most of your ability to win this game is based on random draw so where is the puzzle where is the fun but nobody people on the solo Facebook groups just won't shut up about this game I've done a review of IT ages ago in lockdown when I had horrible hair and beard at that point and yeah I wasn't kind to the game you might want to watch that before you get hype sucked into this hype of a
gentle rain just because I think it got released at Target or something but uh a Gess a foron collect I mean it's nice artwork but that's it and I'm surprised that Pokemon aren't going to have a go at you so uh yeah it exists but I haven't heard anybody say it's a great game and if I was reading it right that it had some award nomination in Australia Australia you have something to answer for you really do all right well let's talk about something a little bit more um interesting and that is Tanto cure is it cure cure I know I'm just going to call it Tanto and the idea is is that this is a game that I'd wanted to play for a little bit because a friend of mine has a game called heart of crown which is similar in terms of this anime style theming and the idea is is that it's a deck builder that plays very much like Dominion um this is hard to Crown by the way so you you play it pretty much like a Dominion game except that there's a bit more variety with the cards and you have these princesses that give you some really cool Power once you get to a point in the game when you can get one all right Tanto is the is kind of like a spin-off or something that's fairly similar to it I think it's done by the same people as well and it's got this typical artwork for anime Stars however you might just have to bear a little bit with the theme because the theme is is is basically anime Maids yeah that basically all the cards are girl Maids you know female Maids of typical Japanese anime style portraits
so you know think of the the slightly over-the-top sexualized version of these things I mean they don't hold back um I mean there's no like man massive nudity in the game as far as I'm aware but the um you know they are definitely it is that artwork you know what Japanese artwork is like for this kind of thing but the idea is is that you have a bunch of these laid out which are you know chamber M so these have special abilities and they allow you to do things like you're doing Dominion like draw cards and get extra buys and uh have more currency I mean it's it is basically a deck builder but the with the expansions that come out you got all these different Maids that you can pick from and the slight twist is that depending on which expansion you use you know you might have one expansion that lets you do things like you know discard a bunch of cards up to a value of whatever to get points and these bonuses but the first set we played I think had us uh similar to the heart of crown game it basically had us doing oh what was it that I can't remember what they were called but they were like super Maids they were basically like really powerful maids and you were able to basically uh acquire these and these had special powers but they they changed as the game went on like there was a deck of them and you could go right through them I'm not seeing much in the way of gameplay from these images more just people dressed up as Maids at conventions kind of want to see the kind of an image of the board so yeah you would just have these decks out they come in small boxes you buy these love cards because you're effectively showing love to these Maids okay interesting and they're one two and
three much like the silver bronze and gold in Dominion so as you can say there's a lot of similarities but that's pretty much the game it is a deck builder so you buy these Main you have to you have these under maze that you can get out of your deck but in order to do so you need a certain like resource to do it you can buy these different maze they all got special abilities and you play it like a kind of pseudo Dominion game and honestly it's fine yeah I like it I mean you get past that whole weird sort of setting that the game is and to be fair I watch enough animes and I've seen enough of this over sexualized stuff in anime I mean I'm a big fan of fairy tale and which I'm looking forward to the um 100 years Quest series that's coming out in a couple of days but yeah if you've watch Fairy Tale and a couple of others yeah they go a little bit over the top with the way that they personify women in it but I mean that's anime for you it's something we're just used to and let's face it all the guys are depicted as like you know whiny pretty boys all the time so it's not like it's a one-sided argument but you know this game is fine it's a very quick game we we played it the same group that was playing Dro polter and that and it's yeah it's amusing what the what the names of these Maids are and the Flor text of them you know it certainly leads to a few innuendo jokes and uh some in gags but the game is a straightforward Deck Builder and with the different maids and expansions that you have you can create some cool Combos and different like settings for the game but it's not quite as varied as something like heart of crown so this one is a little bit more linear in how it does uh although they have released quite a lot of sets for it so I suppose that helps
with the variety aspect I'm not sure how many different Maids are in a particular expansion set I mean we play with a lot of them like you know 10 different maids in every game we played we played two separate games but I don't know if there's like 20 maids in the box or whether you do just get the 10 Maids it's I'm not entirely certain but yeah the game played fine it was a fine deck builder you know race a race to get to the uh the you know to end the game and see who's got the most points uh games are close um there's definitely close scoring and I'm seeing a lot of cards that I don't recognize here in terms of um abilities and that so I just wonder how many sets has been released to this I mean maybe some of these are fan expansions I don't know uh my version oh right okay take a drink yeah so some of these are fan versions but I can imagine fans are making some interesting stuff with this but yeah I enjoyed it it's not something that I would go hunt out and buy um I think there are better deck builders and I'm not sure how many people I would be able to entice into this theme and if I'm going to play something like this why not just play Dominion I guess or maybe even the heart of crown Frank frankly and certainly some of these do have rather small text on the card so that make it quite hard to read but if I find a cheap set and I just want to fit it into a space on the Shelf maybe I would grab a copy it's you know it's just a harmless little deck builder I don't know what this motto Tanto core reimplementation is but you this is the one that I see these like big flashy Little Boxes but yeah the game art is in the Japanese anime style and uses the theme of maids commonly
seen in anime all of the cards fit yeah with dividers and stuff like that it's just a simple game you know I'm curious as to you know how much buzz it gets these days I mean you know I mean this is uh yeah Tanto cor BL me the last video that was done by this was done by Starlet Citadel this was a YouTube pair that they were ages ago could blame me they haven't done anything in yeah 13 years ago I mean this is old school stuff I mean this was this was actually yeah a pair of female uh content creators before the whole thing went out of control since 2020 or something you know so this was actually you know ahead of its time but it's a fun little game fun little game no you know nothing groundbreaking there are better deck builders but I enjoyed it it's a bit of a laugh and I'm just glad that I finally got to uh play it you know because it had been on the bucket list for a while cuz I'd seen it on the shop shelves and my mates had I'd seen my mates playing it I just thought yeah let's give it a try you know I like anime and so this kind of resonates with me just from the anime theming but yeah it's uh definitely an interesting style to put it that way right well let's get on to the topic for this video which is um not hopefully going to take up too much time but it's unrelated to everything that I've kind of said but basically we have various online means of playing uh board games so we have board game arena we have tabletop simulator and we have um what you call it uh tabletopia now I'm
not really going to talk much about tabletopia because when it comes to the fre platforms I've just mentioned tabletopia is easily my worst one by country mile mainly because not because it doesn't look nice it is nice to look at but the interface and the controls for it are absolute garbage absolute chronic garbage you know it may look pretty but it's clear that whoever designed this software knows a fair bit about software design doesn't understand about usability or gaming so it just it's too clunky and too horrible to control and let's face it I don't hear of anybody looking at table too anymore hell even Publishers they don't seem to make a big deal about tabletop anymore so I'm just going to ignore that so we really have tabletop simulator and uh board game arena now question is can I actually get on here without having to uh sign into my thing well I might as well sign into it fine password's blocked you can't tell it is so the idea is is that come on let me in let me in there there we go so and tabletop simulator I think we'll just have to go on their homepage but let's let's talk about tabletop Simulator for the moment so this is basically like a 3D engine like machine thing so most of the time you would use it to do 3D models of various stuff but at the moment it's used a lot to play games and of course
you had the old stuff like you know Checkers and chess and all that lot and there you like bgam in here but the idea is is that on Steam people have now taken to making board games on there and Publishers do this a lot they make uh you know lots of different board games for tabletop simulator and they're basically bats where all the stuff is freedy rendered on the screen and you use the mouse and keyboard to you know to move the camera around and manipulate cards shuffle them you know flip the deck that kind of thing and it's done mostly by users so yes the publisher might hire somebody to make the TTS mod for them but some of these mods might just be done by individuals around the world and they create a decent mod using the imagery from the various cards and stuff uh board game arena on the other hand is basically a kind of like an online I don't I don't want to say JavaScript because I'm not a Computing expert but I forget what the Computing sort of language is but this is basically like where you can play a bunch of games on a slightly quicker version than playing it in real life because I can't really maybe I can browse a game actually so let me take one for example let's take uh let's take L of arnac here right okay so move that one now can I I should be able to browse a game if I click on yeah if I get into the actual games here we go so they got a lot of games on here and they keep adding more games they have some in beta as well now some of these I've never heard of Circle of Life power vacuum and all this stuff but you know they have a
lot of stuff that you'll recognize here I mean you look at this picture here race for the Galaxy is old tiet a ride guy project Sky Team sea Sal paper uh bunny Kingdom know hadara Ark no wingspan tery Mars Katan they've got a lot of them on here so why don't we load up my favorite Arc NOA okay so I should be able to here we go yeah so I can watch a game in progress this might actually help to illustrate my points let's go into a most people played as two players uh progression does anybody actually progress why all say 0% that just seems weird um I don't know let's have a look and see if they've actually done anything here who here we go hopefully that's coming out on the screen fine if you're listening to this there's only so much I can tell you but have they actually all right so they are actually getting stuff done they're just basically starting off um I'm just probably going to turn the sound down though because I don't want the sound to come actually no let's just leave the sound if you hear the card shuffling then sorry but basically yeah this allows you to do the platform and so you've got all your stats on the right you know I can see what uh card symbols I've got tags for tells you the victory points people are are and tells you whose go it is with the spinning hourglass and stuff and then the rest of the game is basically represented on the screen um by various you know card imagery and so every time you click on stuff it will guide you at the top to allow you to say right confirm this what card right I'm going to select this card which card do you want okay it is your
turn what actions do you want to doing and you basically point and click and so the the idea is is that this allows you to play these big games in a much shorter space of time um I'm going to come out of this because that noise is starting to get annoying but come on come out and so now these the idea is that yeah you can play these games a lot quicker and you certainly can I mean AR NOA takes like a good three plus hours in real life Arc NOA can be played in about 60 Minutes on here with a two-player game you know I'm here it says 53 minutes and it could even be less than that if you've got some really fast players but you know it it it does have you know small games and light games as well and the idea is is that some of these that you can play them ranked or unranked so you have like this weird El ELO score I forget what it's cool but basically it's like a star point you get every time you win games and like you could be ranked in the world and who gives a monkey stars I mean seriously I do not care about ranking myself in the world on games I don't play any game enough to warrant ranking anything and it as soon as you start playing for a Competitive Edge to try and be the best suddenly the game stops being enjoyable because somebody has taking it far too seriously so these are the two platforms that we have uh you know effectively you know these are the two main ones yes I know others are available but they're less common they're more Niche they might only cater to one or two games these are the two big ones that is like that you can't deny that so the question is kind of
basically a are these any good uh do they ruin the industry you know are they a detriment to the industry to have these available and are they you know just generally are they worth it well let's start with the easy one are they ruining the industry no not really at least not in well it would have an impact but I don't think it's ruining the industry because the thing with these like settings here is that you know this allows you to test games before you probably want to buy them and some of these games you're going to want in physical condition you're going to want the box and all those pieces to move around because as much as you have the ability to 3D render them on tabletop simulator or you know or to have the games represented on the screen here it doesn't compare to the tactile feeling of grabbing all the pieces and manipulating them and holding the cards and especially with some of these games that are pretty component heavy you know I mean I get for a card game it's not particularly amazing but you Great Western Trail Gia project ter mystica you know a bunch of these you know these core Gamers distilled uh Seasons with those big chunky dice that you see me roll for comedy value do you really want to play seasons on here all the time and never get to roll those dice Obsession all those different Meats Feast of Odin all those pieces Through the Ages I mean there's a lot of stuff where you might want the Tactical experience so people are still going to have the physical board game what this does though is that allows you a very good way to test the game first before you buy it you know I'm I might hear about a game that's
like no I've never really heard of this uh well let's I mean power vacuum what the hell is it a trick-taking game okay so all right so it's a trick taking game that would interest me at first I've never heard of it I don't know if it's any good but I could basically watch the game in progress or I could literally just go you know what learn the rules very quickly and just play a game unranked who cares if you win or lose it's unranked and then I can basically see if it's any good to play but then it could also be for a game that's already been out for a while I mean let's say you you are tempted by uh wingspan you've never played wingspan you just hear everyone talking about it well come on here you can learn the rules I mean the rules are in PDFs or somebody could hopefully teach you and you could just play a game of wingspan and see if it's exciting for you if the game play is good yeah you won't be able to see all the artwork in the game and you certainly won't well you'd see a decent amount of it and you obviously won't be able to get the tactile pieces and see the component quality but you'll be able to get a game done pretty quickly and this also has the advantage AG of allowing you to be able to play with other people that you don't see at a game club you know it's all right saying oh well you know I could take wingspan to the game night and play Four you know I could play four things sorry four with four people there but what if your friends are over in America and you live in the United Kingdom what if you're you know what if you're going to play with your family and your family is overseas what if you're you know what if you're at home and you haven't got anybody to play with and you're stuck alone you don't want to play a solo game you want to play with people then you would use something like this in order to do it in board game arena you don't even have to
know the person I mean you can certainly build up a friends list but you can simply just go and play with randoms now that does have a a positive and a negative on that front and you know positive like I say you can play these games whenever you like you can always get them played they'll always be somebody in the world who's going to play it with you so that's not a problem but the negative is you don't know that person if you play it with friends it's not so bad but the thing is this doesn't have as far as I'm aware detect a a specified talk system on it so even with tabletop simulator it's similar you need to use something like Discord which is what I tend to use but the thing is Discord is typically more common on tabletop simulator CU you will play this with your friends on tabletop simulator rather than randoms because there's no matchmaking system for tabletop simulator so this is something you kind of pre-organize in advance therefore you would have a Discord server you would set up you would get it people in the room and every time me and the mates play on tabletop simulator when we haven't got the means to host for the night then we use uh microphones and that's fine here though there isn't a talk system as far as I'm aware so you are not actually directly talking with the people around the game there is a chat box but it's not really that great and let's face it you've only got so much time in the game because the the the game is handling all the stuff so quickly around the screen if you don't pay attention you're going to lose what the hell's going on especially with something like um you know arnova or particularly Earth Earth on here could blind me you know you think there's a lot to deal with in terms of the cubes and the and that well the system handles it all for you granted it's not the
perfect impementation I think they could tweak a couple of things to make it smoother but um I I like it fine but yeah you are kind of rushed off your feet with this and also I really don't like the ranking system on this this whole ELO thing I hate it it's not of interest to me I mean does it even tell me mine while I'm on here it's on my favorites yeah here we go there ranking there's 10 people and there's some guy called song who's apparently in the best in the world from China and then there's somebody from Antarctica how the hell do you how the hell do you play a bunch of games around Target or what and then United States of America Sweden again I just don't care I honestly don't I'm not interested about being the best at the game I want to play it to enjoy it so why would I care and you do get a lot of I've suffice to say mean people on here yeah this isn't a setup where I think the random players are particularly nice in terms of the community I mean look at this we got real time slow etiquette as a topic idea for forums here which basically is that people get sick and tired of players being slow in this game it's Arc NOA it's not something where you can do a turn in less than 10 seconds it takes time to think about your turn so you have to accept that there's a little bit of a slowness but people just don't really talk to you I mean I go on here to play a game of art over somebody might turn up I'll say GG you know the internet slang for a good game and I get no response back nothing at all and they
just play and they'll play at lightning speed I'll try to keep up sometimes I'm at lightning speed sometimes I can't you know sometimes I slow down a bit because I'm trying to obviously think about my turn and you know I might get distracted doing other things and the thing is is that the you know they get to the end and as soon as you finish the game they you know you don't even get a GG back or well done or anything they just they just Bugg her off that's it they just run off and that's it but even then lately I've seen people on this uh BGA actually actively tank the game before it ends why would you do that because of the stupid ELO ranking system because it apparently doesn't reward the opponent as much or it hurts you less I can't remember which way around it is but there's definitely something that impacts if you concede the game early and also it means that the points do not tally because you might have like high scores or like oh did you get a low score and that and there's I'm sure there's some ranking on here about comparing your highest score and your lowest score but if you concede the game early the opponent doesn't get a winning score so I could be playing AR NOA we could literally be two turns from the end of the game like we're about to finish the game and find out what the points were on either side and then literally on my last term you know last ter before I'm about to trigger the end game and possibly win uh or likely win they can ConEd they concede I don't get to see what my score was because the system automatically just gives me the
game and doesn't do the point tally and in bird culture that's what we call a dick move okay and there's other examples of just people being very like antisocial being very like not violent but you know some verbal abuse is being said by it I mean the community on BGA is not good okay if you want to I do play on BGA every now and again but I must admit I have played I have spurts where I play it constantly and where I don't play it at all and certainly I haven't played it a lot lately um it's just as I say it's the problem is that the community has kind of been sucky and it puts me off plus I just haven't have much time but you there's a bunch of games that I like to play I mean this is like the favorites that I have so I mean I typically end up playing Earth Seven Wonders duel AR NOA as much as I give Forest Shuffle grief this does handle the scoring for you so I would rather play it on here I would like to actually try the uh expansion for this on here actually and I mean that's another thing I don't want to buy Forest Shuffle with the expansion the Alpine expansion I hear it fixes the game so I'll play it on here and find out uh Through the Ages season Splendor yeah there's a bunch of games I do like playing on here and there's obviously others uh dog park I mentioned that earlier I can play that but then there's a few others I mean I would play terraform Mars on here tanaku wingspan Obsession Obsession is pretty good on here so the problem is that I would rather just play with friends on here because knowing that I'm just going to be playing with some soulless random one a lot of the times and sometimes I
get nice people sometimes people are chatty in the chat phase sometimes they'll laugh with you they'll crack jokes and stuff and they'll be you know they'll say good game well done you know you know and I'll do vice versa if I lose but man they just you do get some really nasty people on here sometimes and it is a little bit off-putting so I mean that's board game arena it it's good and I don't it's killing the industry having stuff like this because you you essentially yes okay you might argue well a friendly local gaming store is not going to sell a physical copy of the game if you can just play it online but like I say people like to have the physical copy of the game I mean yes I could play you know one of these online you know a lur game online I could play kban on tabletop simulator but that big game with all the pieces and all that laid out I want it so I don't think it I don't think it really hurts the board game industry that much and I think the Publishers who put their games on here do get some money for it so it's not like it's doing the Publishers any harm but you can argue that maybe some friendly local gaming stores might s um suffer as a result Okay small addendum here everybody uh basically the Wi-Fi cutout in middle of recording and normally when that happens I can usually Salvage it by Bridging the Gap unfortunately I finish talking about board game arena and then start talking about tabletop simulator and it doesn't gel well at all no matter how I try to gel it so basically you're now going to come into a point where I've just said that you know tabletop simulator is based on Steam and that the website
doesn't have much of me to look at and but there is a selection of games that it does showcase on there and then I start continuing to talk about tabletop simulator so sorry about that let's continue but you know H this is all right this is a good list of games on here and this is just an a selection right like DLC games not sure why they're specifically DLC games but the idea is is that on Steam basically a lot of users would created their own games so you know they've got the models they've done it and you know some of them are scripted BGA scripts everything and tabletop simulator doesn't always script things I love it when they do though some game mods where they're scripted so that as soon as you say I'm playing this with four players with this particular map or whatever and it automatically sets everything up for you there is very few things in life that feel as good as that but the the problem with tabletop s simulator is a variety there are some good games popular games on tabletop simulator unfortunately because they're based on the publisher doing it as well as maybe some random user doing it you won't be able to find every single game you like on tabletop simulator they just may not be a mod that's created maybe they just can't physically create a mod for yeah you know I'm not I'm not aware if you can play Frost Punk on tabletop simulator maybe you can but I mean I imagine that takes a lot to render and sort out it's it's you just have to sort of play it by ear but there are some mods that are fantastic I mean there's a brilliant Spirit Island comprehensive mod out there uh there is a great West andril New Zealand mod I found which is
fully scripted and easy to play I mean I've played some solo games I mean I I probably won't play the game solo anymore in person I'll certainly play it with people rather in person but if I want to kick out a solo mode game I'll load up The Script Mod because it takes me like a fraction of the time to move uh you know to use the controls on that especially when it takes I don't have to set the game up and you know actually deal with that side of things and this is an advantage of BGA and TTS in these online platforms that I don't have to set the game up and this is one thing that I don't like doing with board games and that's setting them up because they take far too long sometimes so that takes out that problem uh the downside of TTS on top of the variety is that it's a bit more of a learning curve BGA doesn't take that long to learn the interface and most of the stuff it just involves clicking on a thing on the screen saying confirm or whatever your action is so it's pretty like intuitive and pretty easy to get through it and if you're a bit uncertain about a game just play an unranked teaching game and then it won't matter but TTS involves you having to get used to the interface so you need to learn how to manipulate the cameras you need to know how to like save camera views you need to understand what the how to flip cards and how to rotate cards and which areas the cards are hidden from view of other players you then need to be able to like you know click and manipulate pieces on the board so for example there's a very good mod for hegemony out there which I think is also scripted and I've played some solo games of hemony using that mod because it's quicker than me setting up now although maybe that will change now
that I've got the insert for it but I'd have to compare but the thing is with the gemin is that you've also got to pick up the MEO pieces and put them around you know BGA would have some automatic thing that moves them to a spot on the screen whereas TTS you need to physically pick up the piece as if it was your hand and plunk it somewhere and this involves you having to get used to how the controls work to manipulate the stuff on screen now I've played enough TTS particularly as we played it a lot during lockdown in covid that I'm used to it so you know I know how to use both of these interfaces and TTS in particular I can deal with the camera controls sometimes I need a bit of a refresher you know for how to do like save particular camera shots and that but I'm pretty Speedy on my PC because it's got quite a decent amount of RAM and a good GPU Pro uh GPU um graphics card and table top simulator is not the best optimized engine in the world so you are going to need a pretty not not a stupidly powerful system but the better your graphics card is and the better your RAM is the better because it does require a bit of computation and you are definitely going to hear that fan noise out of your PC because it's going to heat everything up in order to render a lot of the 3D imagery so yeah it's not the most optimized thing in the world so just bear that in mind but the you know tabletop simulator has allowed me to play a bunch of heavy games with people that I know so that we can effectively socialize over Discord and that is the advantage of tabletop simulator you're going to be playing with people that you know and like therefore it's fine Publishers also use this as a way to
kind of demo their game so occasionally for some of us in the press and content creation they've actually said right you know you can come along and we'll arrange a couple of games for you on tabletop simulator and you get a feel of the game you may not necessarily be able to handle the pieces but when it's a prototype who the hell cares you so it has allowed me to get used to games without having to play them but for the most part even you know if I want to play Things solo it can be just quicker to go onto my PC load up a scripted mod um and say yeah I'll just play this you know and I've done it with Spirit Island and you know Sentinal and the Multiverse and actually not so much Sentinal because that's pretty quick to set up in real life but and also tabletop Sim not tblop simulator is a little bit harder to use with card games because you got to do a bit of manipulation with the card cards and stuff like that if it's not too many cards then it tends to work quite well like I say Great Western tra New Zealand's pretty good with that and so was her gmany but there's a lot of other ones Garfield games um you can get quite a lot of theirs on there although those vary couple of their mods are pretty good but ones like way fa farers of the South tigist just do not work and a lot of this comes down to who creates the mod if a publisher creates the mod typically they hire someone really good to do it and they test it and test it and test it but if a random person designs it it's going to have bugs and some issues and sometimes you get lucky and sometimes you don't you know you just have to deal with it but you know I like this as an alternative means to play games so yeah the you know these online things are here to stay I certainly don't think they're killing
the industry I think they allow another means of playing games when you can't otherwise get to a venue to play it and there are going to be people in the world who are in that situation whether they like it or not so you can't say it's destroying the industry because it's like ah people will just play online rather than play in person not really the people who play games in person want to play games in person okay yes I can play hegemony in on you know on my tabletop simulator maybe with other people but maybe just playing it solo with a bunch of 3D rendered stuff but I've got an Raptor UV insert for that game I love hegemony you have all the banter between people that you want to be in person with not over a Discord microphone when playing that kind of game so yes I can play it on TTS but I would much rather to play it in person and that's going to be a lot of the attitudes for a lot of games typically solo games I like to use tabletop simulator and occasionally BGA because it sorts out the setup time you know I mean do you know how long it takes to set up nemman at times the fact that it does it all for you I mean Great Western Trail New Zealand as I mentioned perfect example setting up Great West and Trail New Zealand is an absolute pain in the ass so being able to Simply go uh one player and I'd like to be red and I'll start there please and then it's done you know something that would normally take me 20 25 minutes is done in like 10 seconds so there is certainly advantages so I don't think they're killing the industry I think they're perfectly good platforms I think tabletopia just really didn't work with its interface and as
far as I'm aware that just seems to be dying a slow painful death but but BGA and TTS uh Bard game marinaa and tabletop simulator are here to stay I think they're useful platforms I'm going to continue to use them I'm sure a lot of other people are but I'm pretty sure we'll all still be playing games in the physical world most of the time so yeah that's all for me I'm going to wrap this uh video up I'll probably edit it on uh I suppose will I edit it tonight or will I do it on Sunday I it wouldn't take me too long to I think I'll edit it now and get it sorted and then that way all I got to do is upload it on Sunday that will be easier but yeah hopefully you've enjoyed this podcast with the games I've played in this uh discussion topic I think I'm going to be asking the patreons for some more ideas for the next bunch of episodes because I've uh kind of run out um but by all means put some suggestions in the comments if you really want and hopefully you're enjoying your Summer Wherever You Are uh if you're going to Gen Con by all means enjoy that I won't be there American convention cost a lot to get there maybe in the future we'll find a way to get to an American convention but to be honest I don't think gen con's high on my bucket list it just looks too packed too busy too expensive if I want to go to an American con it would probably be Dice Tower East or packs unplugged I think they're the two that strike me as being a easier to get to and B probably just better in terms of the like how much trade versus how much gaming sometime in the future I would like to but cost is the big problem I mean getting enough Holiday from work is one aspect you know it's a long way to travel just for a game convention but as I say it's cost
cost is a big deal so we'll see but anyway that's it for me I'm going to sign off so hope you're enjoying yourself hope you're enjoying the show let me know your thoughts in the comments uh take care and remember it's only a game love you all and bye for now and enjy enjoy the rest of your weekend