Bonus Episode: The Resurgence of TCGs
Transcript
Have you ever been sitting around your gaming table? We could really use some atmospheric music and some sound effects right now. Well, have I got a solution for you. Table Tone. Table Tone is a mobile tabletop audio app that makes it easy to create highquality immersive soundscapes for your gaming sessions. You can blend music, ambient sounds, and sound effects in real time to match any scenario from a tranquil tavern scene to epic boss battles, all at the touch of a button. This app uses an adaptive audio engine and an ever growing sound library that is 100% human-made audio. That means no generative AI. I've used this app in my gaming sessions and it is great. We can be walking through spooky woods hearing some eerie sounds and then when combat starts with a click of a button, the tension grows with a heartbeating soundtrack and sound effects to go with it. And the best thing is Table Tone is free to download on the iOS and Android so that you can try it for yourself. It comes with full functionality and a starter content pack so you can begin right away. But if you want to add more sounds and content, then you can use code tone 20 to get 20% off your order in the store app. So take your gaming sessions to the next level with Table Tone.
Craft Mac and Cheese is better than '90s hiphop. We'll remind you of your childhood without making you feel incredibly old. Craft mac and cheese. Best thing ever. Hello and welcome to a special bonus episode of Rolling Dice and Taking Names. My name is Marty. Typically, you would hear Tony say, "I'm Tony." But Tony was not able to make this session because at last minute he's at some restaurant and said, "Yeah, service is slow." That's Tony. Um, and I hate going to miss it because I'm excited about this discussion that we're going to be having tonight. So, for those who've listened to the show for a while know our our history in that we got into tabletop gaming through collectible card games, CCGs. And it happened almost 25 years ago when we got into Lord of the Rings CCG from the cipher. We started in there and then basically just branched out to other CCGs, other tabletop games.
And it's because of that why you're hearing me today basically. And so be a big fan of CCGs there during that time there was a huge growth a huge spurt in the number of CCGs that were coming out. Well, what what we're seeing now is another resurgence of CCGs. And I want to talk about, you know, why why is there a resurgence? Are we in a bubble? What's going to happen in the future? And I thought, well, I'm not smart enough to have this conversation. So, I have two very special guests. Uh, first up, I've got Dan Green. You may know as Main Deck Dan, who is a content creator and CCG caster. And I've also got the owner of my favorite local game store, Mike Benson, and the name of the store is To the Table. Guys, thank you for joining the show.
Happy to be here.
Yeah, thank you. Thanks for having me.
All right, just to kind of kick things off, let let's go ahead and set a a foundation of of where you guys are coming from and your gaming history with CCGs, your knowledge of the the topic and everything like that. And I want to hear what your favorite CCG is of all time. So Dan, we'll start with you.
Sure. Uh yeah. Hey everyone. I'm Dan. Main Deck Dan. Uh YouTube channel is Main Deck obviously. Um I am a massive TCG fan. Um uh by the way, also my voice I I'm still recovering from an illness. So I apologize if uh if you're used to watching me and are not hearing my full voice right now. Um I started uh I'm 36 years old and I started playing TCGs when I was nine. So it's been a long ride. Um a lot of TCGs. I I began actually with the uh Star Wars Decipher TCG. So, like you Marty, a Decipher TCG. Uh but this was the Star Wars customizable card game. And um I've I've got some uncut sheets and stuff, collectibles from that that I uh used to have up in one of my previous spaces. Um but uh over the years, I have played and judged and uh just about everything. And I've hit kind of every level of the TCG industry as well. even had a stint doing play testing and development for a couple of the card games under uh Panini Games as well. Um who who had made a small splash in 2014 when they brought back the Dragon Ball Z card game which was very uh good bit of nostalgia for uh a lot of people from my era as well. Um these days I am pretty hyperfocused on the Grand Archive TCG and the Star Wars Unlimited uh TCG. Those are uh two of my personal favorites. And um I hate when anybody puts a gun to my head and forces me to pick my favorite TCG because uh I
work closely with both uh companies and so I will just say they are both equally my favorite TCGs right now.
So in the history of everything those two are your current favorite basically.
Uh in the history of everything I I actually do think so. Um because I think we the TCG industry a lot like the board game industry stands on the shoulders of giants and uh I think in general design of games has improved by learning from the previous designs of the past. It's not that there aren't things I I appreciate and love about games going all the way back to decipher uh Star Wars CCG, but um I think today we just have some of the best games on the market u in general.
Okay. and Mike, your story.
Yeah, so I started playing the Star Wars actually I think another decipher game I played the Star Trek uh TCG when it first came out and uh that got me into magic actually. I started playing Magic in what 90 94 95 right around there. So you know my mom would pick up packs at the local comic shop and bring them home to me. we just beg him offer. And uh I played basically TCG's forever and then it took a long break um [clears throat] I think in uh starting in 2017. So I I played all the way up through there and uh came back for the Star Wars card game actually. I played it at PAX unplugged um when they were demoing it there and was like felt that itch again and then came back um and actually that's what inevitably led to me opening the store, but you know, we talk about that more later. But uh yeah, Star Wars is pretty good. And then I think out of all of them, I think um I I'll cop out answer. I kind of like Dan did, but I I think uh mechanically I think Star Wars is the most sort of distilled out of all of them. I think it's like learned from the mistakes of the past, right? And it it makes a a lot of very smart decisions.
Um, you know, not all of them leading to the success of the game, but I think like it's made a lot of great design decisions. So, I really like playing it and I think like Magic will just be in my bones. I I've played it for so long that it'll never go away. So,
Sure. So, again, for a quick history, and you guys can correct me if I'm wrong. So, Magic started in the mid early 90s and then all of a sudden there was this new business model and it's like, "Oh, wait. So, we can have these booster packs that you can open. They're randomized and from these cards you can build decks and play games." And everybody said, "Well, that sounds good. Magic's doing well. I want to jump in on that, too." And then from the early 90s, late 90s, early 2000s, you had a huge amount of CCGs. I went back and looked on a Wikipedia page of of a list and it's like 15 to 20 new ones were just spawning up every single year. Most of them obviously did not make it [snorts] and they had they grabbed every IP they could at that time trying to make a successful CCG. Some made it, some didn't. And it seemed to be that because of that there was kind of like everybody just fatigued. I'm I'm done. And it seemed like 2008, 2009, 2010, the CCG market kind of started spinning down.
And me personally, that's kind of when I was like, I'm I'm kind of tired of this. Which is about the time that Fantasy Flight introduced the living card game. I went, "Oh, that's cool. No randomized boosters anymore. I know exactly what I'm getting. I'm going to play." And I was into LCGs for quite a while. Unfortunately, that format's not very good for competitive play cuz you lose a lot of the stuff like the the sealed events, draft events that that made the game fun. So, it's like, all right, well, obviously we've still got the main three. You got Magic, Pokemon, Ugio, they're just going to be main stays, the evergreens. But then I noticed back in 2019, 2020, this other game popped up, Flesh and Blood, and it was like, oh wow, a lot of people are talking about this game. And then it just seems like they started dropping. Lorcana was announced. Star Wars Unlimited was announced. Um I'm probably missing some other big I mean just recently we had Riftbound that came out. You had One Piece that really came you know storming through. So we've got this huge resurgence. So my first thing to you guys is why do you think all of a sudden the markets like just blew up again?
What what made the market the right time for TCGs to make a comeback? Uh yeah, I I'm actually really excited to hear uh Mike's thoughts as an LGS owner as well. I I also work in an LGS uh I didn't during that time I was uh I was in clinical research for about a decade of my life. Um but now with everything I've been doing, I'm I'm back in that space. So I'm a lot more attuned again to kind of what's going on uh with the retailers behind the scenes. But I know that at the time, you know, you mentioned flesh and blood, Marty. And uh so there there there are it's basically a confluence from my understanding, a confluence of elements that led to a sort of a perfect breeding ground for these TCGs to come up. Um the the one of them that uh it's maybe actually not the most important one, but it led to the success of games like Flesh and Blood, which then paved the way for a lot of other of these games to be tried, was that Magic the Gathering began to shift its focus very heavily. Um games like Flesh and Blood came in with a sort of a specific goal in mind. It was to offer competitive Magic players the experience that Wizards of the Coast was leaving by the wayside as they moved to focusing multiplayer commander uh format focused casual focus um for their product lines for their design um that kind of thing.
It's not to say that they don't support competitive play, but they did things in around 2018 I think it was. They dropped the DCI number system uh or maybe that's 2022. I think I mixed these up. 2022 they dropped that. By 2018 though, they had uh sort of completely gutted the uh PTQ, PPTQ system, whatever they had at the time. Um they started to make it harder for players to find an inroad to be competitive with the game. Um and started to reward players less for doing so. Um, and a lot of players were just missing the, uh, elements of the game that they fell in love with in the first place, uh, from a competitive standpoint. And that Flesh and Blood came and they, and if you look at Flesh and Blood system, even today, it's like a carbon copy of what Magic the Gathering's competitive system was in the 20 uh, 2010 to 2015 2016 era. Um, it's almost identical to that. Um, so that was one element where games found an opening because magic was no longer the de facto ruler of uh all of those things. And then the big thing that you have to mention is that uh the pandemic um caused a huge shift in how a lot of industries were where the cash flow was, what was going on. And especially the big one is collectibles and cryp and like crypto and stuff kind of popping off at the time led to Pokemon cards becoming highly soughta by people who had a bunch of extra disposable money
now. And that created sort of a a gigantic advertising impact on the TCG industry where now a lot of games started to started to crop up suddenly saying, "Wow, there's people here who want to put money into card games. This is a great opportunity." Um, and it uh overall actually created a bigger and more robust market for TCGs than we ever seen. And that's why even still in 2025. We have a we have more people who want to buy than ever. And so games keep coming out and they are not dying off quite as quickly. Although there's a lot that do that are like the Kickstarter random like whatever. But uh the bigger ones are lasting a little longer now. Sorry I talked for a long time. I'd love to hear Mike's thoughts too.
No, I mean I I think you nailed it. I think that Magic always I think early on lived by the idea that you could buy a deck of cards and learn how to play it and suddenly be a professional Magic player. And if you look like in all that the print advertising and stuff that they did during those years, they pushed that super hard, super hard. I mean, it was on ESPN. I I specifically played in a nationals that was in um at Disney Wild of Sports and it was nationally televised. It was on ESPN. I mean, it was huge. And so that was always the dream, right? Is like anybody could just like pick up a card, you know, a deck of cards, learn how to play Magic, and then suddenly you're on the Pro Tour and you're making your living playing Magic. And like that's not realistic, but that was the idea, right? And that's they built sort of that whole funnel from Friday Night Magic at your local store to, you know, a regional qualifier that called PTQs back in the day to Grand Prix and up through that. And then I think what happened is slowly over time I think that the Hasbro acquisition was huge, right? And it it leads to them looking for like who who do we make money off of? Like where where does the money come from? And I I was actually I think the MPL started in 2019. That was the big shift in in Magic the Gatherings organized play. And it I was at the PAX where they started or not the PACs the U GDC where they announced that they were going to do that. And so, weirdly
enough, it was also at the same GDC that they announced Google Stadia. So, really, really humdinger humdinger announcements here. All going well and crushing. And so, um, but, uh, yeah, I mean, I I was there when that guy got on stage and said, you know, I don't the Google CEO said like, I don't play a lot of games and I don't really know why people buy them, but my daughter really likes them. And that's how he opened his talk. And I was just like, oh boy. Okay. But anyway, so so I remember talking to them at that panel and and having a conversation with them and trying to understand like because they they basically made an influencer league. They were like, "Look, like what we want is very few people and we'll take the highest ranked Magic players, but we're going to base it off of current pro tour." So you had to like um there was no rating system anymore, so you had to, you know, get Pro Tour points and participate and do well in those events. And [snorts] uh so they they compressed it very tight, right?
Where now the dream wasn't quite the dream anymore, right? And I think that that shift was very concerted where they said, "Well, we can't make money off of these people, so like let's have a little exhibition, you know, Savannah Bananas like style. These are the good players that play." and then everybody else is casual because I think they found my guess is they did a bunch of market research and realized like multiplayer because during that time was about the same time they started making commander products, right? And commander was a format that started at a store that I used to play at in Tampa. Um, and the guy that made it Sheldon Meny who was like a heavy judge there. Um he would play with his buddies, his kind of old old dude buddies and you know a bunch of big bearded dudes like look like me but much grayer hair and would sit in the back and they would play five player multiplayer Magic, right? And uh that became over time it became Commander. It was so popular it was called Elder Dragon Highlander. It became the multiplayer format for Magic, the deacto one. And they literally were like well this is huge. Like we have to make products for it. And so the first they started making products for it and they blew up, right?
And so you see those two things like sort of overlap is they realize, oh well like here's where the money is like these people buy anything we put out and we don't even need to rotate it. We just print stuff, right? And so and then you see the shift away from their organized play. So immediately all those organized players, you know, those competitive players, they got to go somewhere. And so they they tried everything. They tried Lorana. I mean, you see the or you've been in the shop. The guys that play the competitive games, they'll play any they don't care what it is. They they're going to chase. They want competitive play. They want to play for prizes in an environment that is, you know, cutthroat and that's what they want to do. But those aren't the people that buy Magic cards anymore. People buy Magic cards are multiplayer casual commander players. So, that's what I think you see that divergence, right? is like Wizards very clearly said like this is where the money is but we have to our roots are this now they've tried to like recapture a little bit of that to middling success I think but they're they're trying right they're making an effort so it's interesting
well so that's interesting so both of y'all felt like the part of this resurgence was the fact that uh Wizards created a vacuum that everybody else started trying to fill itself now I I've heard that before Dan about flesh and blood I know a lot of former Magic players it's like ah this is what magic used to feel like. And and I guess like I said, everybody else kind of saw and the pandemic I think is a good point, too. Um because I was actually going to bring up just just the economic environment. I I I assume that it's probably easier to it's cheaper to make cards than it is boards and dice and wooden pieces and miniatures. And if you can develop a solid game, you can run that game for years. where tabletop board game publishers are, hey, this game, let's try this one. Ah, okay.
Let's try this game. No, let's try this game. You know, sort of deal. So, if you find that one thing that you're good at, you can kind of run on it for years. So, I wonder if the publisher said, well, maybe instead of making 15 games a year, if we could Fantasy Flight, knew it was like, man, we're doing all these board games and stuff like that, but if we just focus on this one card game, could we make it on that? And it seems like Fantasy Flight's pretty much living off unlimited Arkham Marvel Champions right now.
Yeah, I I think that it's I would just be careful about reducing it too much because there are there's a there's a crazy amount of costs that go into a TCG that a board game doesn't always share to the same degree. Um, you know, you think about a lot of TCGs these days are releasing sets that are somewhere between two to 300 cards, each of which has a unique piece of art, uh, hopefully done by a human. I have my own opinions about a couple of the games in the industry as well. Um, but, uh, you know, humanmade artwork is expensive. Then you have your organized play costs which are a basically a super inflated marketing budget that you need to have uh that you need to have much much higher ultimately than you do for a lot of board games even just to try and take off with any you know if you a lot of I'm sure a lot of board game publishers are just trying to figure out what's the next katon what's the next you know uh ticket to ride what can I what can I really get to be my sort of breadandbut game that we can ride on for a while so we can develop until we find the next one um and some amount of marketing absolutely goes into that and you're trying to show it off at every con you can and everything, but I think uh off the top of my head, I assume that the budget for most card games who are trying to do competitive play at a serious level is going to be going to dwarf I think what a lot of those marketing budgets would go go for for those uh TCGs as well. So there there are a bunch of steps and a bunch of follow through and a bunch of consistent design. You have to come up with three to four sets a year or if you're magic I think it's 16 or 17
sets a year at this point. I seriously it's seven weeks between sets right now. I do our event schedule at the shop and it's break neck and I can't handle it. Um I I don't know who can but um these you know most sets most games these days are three to four sets a year with maybe one or two kind of supplementary little products that'll come out a gift set near the holiday season that kind of stuff. Um, and that is that means like your 1,00 to,200 pieces of art per year compared to a board game which is going to have if it has a lot of cards in it, 40 to 60 pieces of art maybe and that's it and then you just kind of publish it from there. Um, so the the cost can definitely balloon. Um, but that said, you know, Marty, I want to hit on one thing you talked about. Uh, you talked about the economic climate. Um and and you know we related it to the pandemic and everything and I think that really led a to a lot of the ballooning that we saw happen uh to that's leading to kind of this current golden age so to speak that we're in. Um and you mentioned it was around 2008 910 that the last one seemed to die off and it's really easy to notice that that is exactly when the economic recession in the United States hit um in the first place. you know, the most the most recent one in that era was uh soon after that, a lot of these luxury hobbies were just not really something that people were ready to invest in anymore. And then you saw
companies scramble to find, well, what are our new ways we can have pay we can pay less and have people pay less and everyone's happy. like the LCG model um was perfect for just trying to give people an experience that was similar, that was lower cost to the company because they don't have to make 300 pieces of artwork. They can get away with just the bare minimum to get the decks out uh for people to play with. And then everybody just had to buy the one release. And it was a model that really fit well in a an economic climate um that was very, you know, just very appropriate for it. Um, and board gaming took off a lot then, too. A lot of us who were TCG players swapped over to board gaming for a while. I I have shelves of board games cuz I was a serious board gamer for that kind of whole chunk of time. Um, and uh I I think it's really hard to deny that there had to be some sort of impact from that um both on both ends, the the ending of that last era and the beginning of the new one.
Yeah. I mean, I think we talk about organized play, but nobody plays Pokemon, and Pokemon is the driver of I I would say is actually the driver all of this. Like, I would say, you know, nine out of 10 people that buy Pokemon cards don't play it. They have no idea how to play Pokemon. They've never played organized Pokemon play. So, um, it's interesting. I think, yeah, I mean, I think you're dead on. I think the co like Pokemon boom during co It was huge, right? It was just like the the hottest thing imaginable. you know, people were literally running entire Amazon businesses based on arbitrageing Pokemon cards from like a Target to Amazon and it was just like, you know, it's just insanity. And I think that that has carried over a lot, too, um, into the casual market. So,
well, that I was going to bring this up later, but I guess I'm going to tangent because it's kind of a good little side note. H, how has Pokemon maintained this momentum to where people just like, I'm not doing it anymore, and then all of a sudden it just tanks? How is it just not tanked after all these years? Is that the demand still that high for these cards? I guess
you know what's crazy is if we go back to the era when Magic the Gathering was the most competitive and the biggest game in the market, our local stores, I'm in Fargo, North Dakota, just for context. I'm not in a big city. I'm in a I'm in a rel, you know, it's an okay city, but it's not big. Um, we had a store with 60 player Friday Night Magics in Fargo, North Dakota during the 20 2013 14 era especially. Um, I remember the release of Zendicar. I remember people playing on the floor cuz we had at midnight 115 120 players in there just to play the new set. Uh, the return of Fetchlands, the exciting stuff. Back at that era, our Pokemon sales and I worked at an LGS then as well. Our Pokemon sales were nothing compared to our Magic sales. Magic was the game. It was the driver. And it's that, you know, it's just this timing of everything where Magic gives up its position as the primary competitive game and then COVID hits and the Pokemon collectors just come out of the woodwork. And it's like a nostalgia thing, too. It's a bunch of people hit the age now where they're like, I remember Pokémon when I was a kid and the government just sent me $2,000. I'm going to buy some of these.
Um, and we got from that this like complete swap where Pokemon went from being just, you know, a thing that you could buy and collect and cards of that era are just more rare now because of it, which is kind of interesting. But now, now they have to they can't print enough Pokemon. It's crazy. We just have created this culture of collecting now over the last 5 years that has really I mean I don't know how it's maintained as well. We are starting to see a little bit of falloff on some cards but other ones are still you know holding pretty firm and people are just kind of deciding what they want to collect I guess and uh laying a line in the sand somewhere. But um yeah like you said Mike it's 100% now Pokemon is nine out of 10 collectors. Uh, it's just a it's a very different swap though from from that period where magic was king when your shop had to have magic or you weren't going to make it. Now your shop better be getting Pokemon from as many distributors as you can cuz that's going to get you your uh your bills paid.
Yeah. I mean, I think like Pokemon died for quite a while. It was just literally just trash. Like nobody wanted it. It basically crashed like sports cards did, right? Um, and I think it came back because of I mean I I could make the argument, but I think Tik Tok released in 2016 and then Pokemon immediately got huge. So like you've got a younger audience that suddenly, you know, is consuming social media content. They're,
you know, maybe haven't been fed like that that dopamine drip of opening a pack and like here's literally, if you think about it, like Pokemon is just gambling for kids. That's all it is, right? Like so you're you're just saying like here's a if you've ever given a kid a a iPhone or iOS game that has loot boxes in it and cut them loose and had your credit card attached to it, you'll instantly understand like what a dangerous proposition that is. And I think Pokemon was essentially that. Like you you have people you know you have kids like consuming Tik Tok content and they see Pokemon cards and they see people opening Pokemon cards and immediately like it boomed, right? And then again, just like you said, co happens. They're consuming more social media content. I mean, it's it's crazy.
We have kids. We have people come into the shop all the time and purchase cards and go in the back. They will sit at a table. They will hold a phone over top while they open the cards. I mean, it is you don't see that with any other game. Like, nobody else does that. You see it with I mean, there is content creators that do that with Magic, but not like Pokemon. um the whole community, all of it is just sitting there opening packs. Um which makes sense because Pokemon holds a sealed premium unlike any other game, right? And and what I mean by that is the e like the estimated value of like what a Pokemon card is worth. Um like all the cards in the booster pack versus what the booster pack is worth, it is so low for Pokemon. I mean, you will literally you'll have booster packs on the shelf that'll be seven $8 market and they'll have a$150 worth of cards on average in them and they do not care.
They will still buy them. So,
it's funny you said cuz I was going to bring up this anecdote I saw the other day. So, um we're recording this right after Thanksgiving and on Black Friday there is a game store that was about 45 minutes from my house. It's a retro video game store. They have a 25% off sale and I collect retro video games. So I went there, but they also also sell a ton of Pokémon. And so I asked the owner, I said, "Did you have a big line this morning?" "Oh yeah, long line." He said, "All of them were here for the discount on the Pokemon." And so in the back of the store, they have a play area. And I saw a guy doing what you were talking about, Mike. Had a camera sitting there opening up packs and stuff. But what made me sick to my stomach is after he went through a pack, he just took them and threw them right in the trash can. And it it bothered me so much. I'm like, how how does the store owner or somebody or, you know, somebody say, "Look, give those to a kid, you know, save those and just let people have them. Kids may want to play the game. Get them into this hobby." And stuff like that. So, it just sickened me. The guy just went through a box of cards and was just trashing almost everything he opened.
Yeah. Because the value is opening the pack. Yeah. That's that's that's what I I always try to explain like why people like Pokemon cards and why they're so expensive is because they're not opened. That's that's the only reason they're worth anything, right? Because if you want to play Pokemon, right, the game itself, which there are people that do play it, um it's the best time ever to be playing the game because the cards are incredibly cheap and you can get them for next to nothing because once they're open, the value is gone. outside of like the crazy speculative market around, you know, slabbing the Pokemon cards and like trying to, you know, they'll open a card that's worth $8 and they're like, "But if I get a gem mint 10, it's worth $800." And which is, you know, value produced from nowhere. But, uh, it is it is wild.
Uh, for those who are listening who aren't into the the hobby, slabbing means you go get it graded. And obviously a higher graded car is going to be worth a lot more. Dan, you want to say something? Yeah, I just wanted to add that like Pokemon is Pokemon is such a unique part of the industry right now. Um, and one thing that I see a lot is players from other card games who are looking at other card games, judging other card games. Um, I see far too often people looking at a smaller card game, you know, and smaller means anything right now, but I mean like a much smaller card game. um and saying, "Well, I you know, this is crazy. Why is this game so expensive to play? Why does it cost so much to build a deck for this game when I could just go to Pokemon and pay $25 and get the deck that just won Worlds? It's so easy. It's it's so cheap." And uh Pokemon is the only game in the market that can pull that off because like Mike said, nine out of 10 people are not playing the game. open the cards, they throw away the coffins or sometimes more than that or whatever.
But there's just they flood the market with tons of the playable cards because the playable cards are not the card the single card in the set that on release is going for $700, $800 or whatever. It's not the gold mega Lucario EX or whatever. It's the, you know, it's just the regular version of Lucario EX who is $150 or I don't know. I don't know what the current price is, but $5, whatever. It doesn't matter. It's not expensive, right? Um, so your deck is going to have like eight cards in it that are maybe worth a dollar to $3 or something and then a bunch of commons and uncommons and stuff that just doesn't doesn't have a price tag on it because people just open so much product on TikTok or whatever and just fill TCG Player with every single card uh that you could need. and every other card game would if they could sell as much sealed product as Pokemon did, then maybe they would start to have prices like that. But it's just not a fair comparison. Um, I think people still truly don't understand the difference between the magnitude of sales Pokemon has and the magnitude of production Pokemon has and most other TCGs on the market.
Yeah, you almost have to treat them totally differently. They're they're completely different beasts. Um, people talk about them in the same breath, but Pokemon is it's a it's like gold. Um, so so um, [clears throat] so we're kind of in this like a real resurgence. So there's a lot of new games out there. So I wanted to ask you uh each of you some games that you feel like that are doing it right. uh whether it be from game play, competitive play, organized play, which games do you feel like, okay, these guys know what they're doing and they're probably going to be here for a while? And I'll give you a chance to think on that because I want to let people uh know. I actually have pulled up uh from Q3 of 2025, what the top product lines were, the bestselling trading card games for Q3 by total dollar values of all sales. This includes singles and sealed. Here are the top 10 from Q3. Magic, Pokemon, U-IO, One Piece, Gundam, which was new, uh, Disney Lana, Pokemon Japan, Digimon, Star Wars Unlimited, Flesh and Blood.
All right, so that's kind of where where we're standing. So, I'll start with you, Mike. What What is a game or games you feel like, you know, these guys know what they're doing and this is going to be a successful product?
Uh, Riftbound. I mean, I think Riftbound like has done literally every single thing correct uh from a retailer perspective outside of like being able to meet demand, but you can't no TCG meets demand if it actually is good. Like Star Wars had the same problem. Every TCG when it releases can't print to demand and but Riftbound actively had organized play before it started. They actively sent stores promotional material before it launched. um they they just did all the little things that matter. You know, they sent us promotional material. We have like calendars that counted down to release and and they send us promos on time. They, you know, there there's a lot of things. I mean, that's just from a small scale, you know, out of the smaller games. I think from a gameplay perspective, I think Riftbound does some really interesting things with multiplayer that is very interesting where it it does not exclude a player at any point unlike Magic and some other games where you know I think Magic it's Commander is huge but someone inevitably dies in a Commander game and then they have to sit there for like 45 minutes waiting for the game to end and that's not very popular, right? whereas that never happens in Riftbound um due to the way it's you're counting up and so nobody ever actually dies in Riftbound.
Um I think they're doing everything right. I think uh they've done a good job. Um Star Wars from a gameplay perspective is fantastic and I think plays extremely well. Um I do think that they have problems on the retail side like massively. I don't think you can effectively support a game long term where its sealed product is at cost or below two weeks after it releases. Um, I think sealed boxes of Secrets of Power were $71 on TCG Player a week and a half after the pre-release. So, I mean, when your cost I think our cost on Secrets of Power is like $69 a box, you know? So, like you're talking after TCG player fees, you are literally losing money on every box of, you know, I I think Marty, I sold boxes in my store for $50 a box or something like that. Um, so it it Star Wars has problems from like a product like getting people to carry it.
Um, and I think the people doing it wrong, um, I mean, Magic is t it's tough, you know, it's hard. Like, it it it really, um, they just release sets too fast. like you can't release sets of the clip that they are. And you know, they told people last year that they were going to slow it down, that this year was like a, you know, an aberration and they they had licensing agreements that they had to fit and all of these reasons and don't worry, next year it'll be fine, right? And then they come out and they say, "Oh, actually next year we've got one one more set than this year." Which is crazy. It's just crazy. And uh people can't keep up, right? But again, I think that goes back to commander players where they know commander players purchase every set that comes out regardless. And it never rotates, so they feel confident buying it. And uh yeah, Magic, it's tough. I mean, it's selling, but uh I think the last two sets have really struggled uh as a result. I mean, we've sold them. They've been fine, but they're not what the previous sets were. And I think if they let them breathe, they would have done a lot better. So, I I think Mike, your point about Riftbound is is really good. I think it is a I think it's a game that is doing a lot of things correct. Um, I think one of the things that surprised me the most about Riftbound, um, and just for like some context, I guess, uh, our the store I work for was
I don't know where we are on the list, but we're we were one of the highest, um, sales stores, uh, online stores for Riftbound in the country. Um definitely we're up there um from our discussions with our distributors and we uh we had a lot of issues with the allocations as a lot of people did. Um so we went I had a summer it was I'm going to be honest it was one of the most stressful summers of my life. um trying to work with distributors and uh even talking to folks at Riot and UVS games directly um working to figure out how to meet allocations or to meet beat meet the demand that we had or the the pre-sales that we had based on the allocations that were coming out. But one of the most incredible things that resulted uh after we learned that there were going to be at least one more wave uh and now we have the confirmation of a third wave coming here soon of product. But uh I the earliest I knew I knew that there was going to be a wave two within about a month of release. And wave two released within a week of release uh within days actually of release. They managed to get a full wave of I had we had to card in more product than I've ever seen in my life in one spot. Um, but uh the amount of product that Riot managed to fasttrack uh and UVS games managed to fasttrack is is remarkable. And that to me that was the big point where it was like okay like a lot of games I look Marty you were there for Star Wars right? You
remember when Spark of Rebellion sold out and then they said, "Don't worry, we have more Spark of Rebellion coming before the holiday." And it was like September or something.
It was March. It was March.
Oh, yeah. True. March. You're right. Oh my god. Yeah. My timelines are
Yeah. Star War Rebellion released in March and they were like, "Yeah, we'll have more product to you by the the holidays." And I was like,
"The holiday?" Yeah.
Excuse me. What? What's going on?
It was I think I think you're right. set three had released at the point when the the reprint finally hit and it was um just far too late. Uh where Riot did something I've never seen before and managed to get a gigantic second wave out. Um and there are still players who are trying to get products. So, I'm very sympathetic to that as well. It's still impossible to find, but the amount they added really is going to help sustain that momentum that the game needs to really take off. So, if there's any game you're, you know, if you can find product for it or you're looking forward to pre-orders for Spirit Forge or something, that's that's one of the games right now where um I definitely think it's it's poise. It's positioning itself well uh to really become a serious contender for those top three spots in the coming years.
Yeah. And so, uh for those who are like, "Well, Marty, you didn't mention Riftbound on the list." That's because Riftbound was a Q4 release. That's Q3. Guaranteed Riftbound will be top four, top three easily in Q4, I would assume. I guess it depends on how much product they had to sell. So
I think Riftbound has a little bit of a they've got a little bit of a head start, too, because they it it came out in China first, right? So they
the game existed there and they didn't plan on releasing it here and then it did so well that they were like, "Oh, maybe we'll let's see if uh maybe we'll put this here, right?" and immediately, you know, huge amounts of of demand. So, like I think that's what led to them being able to deliver product-wise um was like, you know, they were already printing them, right? So, they'd already done the thing.
Riftbound not deciding not to do a global release initially is still to me the craziest thing that I've heard this year.
I I just I mean, they they started planning the global release before the Chinese release as well. China released about a month before we did. So, a lot of this stuff was already done. It was just as soon as they revealed the game out, they were absolutely inundated with people all around the world saying, "Great, I can't wait to get this in English." And they were like, "Well, uh, I guess we should plan on doing that then." Which I don't, it's League of Legends. I don't get how
I don't understand it either. It's so wild. Yeah.
Uh, I I do want to throw one more thing out here, though. I think I think that um there are a lot of games uh on the list like especially the list you gave Marty that are games that we can expect to be around for a long time. It's pretty easy you know companies like Bandai who's the publisher of uh Digimon One Piece uh Dragon Ball Super both Dragon Ball Supers um and now Gundam as well. Like that's a company where uh I personally I have a pile of my own concerns, but I work in an LGS and when you work in an LGS, your opinion on Bandai usually shifts a little bit. Um
a 1,000 I'm you can see me tight lipped like not saying anything because I'm like
I'm I'm only here so I don't get fined. You know, like that kind of energy.
It's a free space. I mean, if you got stuff to say, let's hear it. I'm not sponsored by Bandai. So,
I mean, I don't I don't carry I I do not sell Bandai in my store. I do not. I carry it and immediately flip it on TG Player. I will not stock it. I will not. We We had
My one experience with Bandai was I pre-ordered $30,000 of Gundam, right? And I was like, "This is going to be our game. This is going to be our game. We're going to do it." Right? And then we, you know, I people are like, "Are you going to take pre-orders for Gundam?" I'm like, "I don't know, man. It's Bandai. I'm going to wait. I'm going to wait till we get actual allocations." Right? And they pushed them back, pushed them back, and pushed them back. And it was Monday before the stuff was supposed to release. And I got calls from one after another from every single distributor like, "Hey, hey, let's talk about Gundam real quick." And I was like, "Yeah, what are we getting?" Nothing. I said, "Well, nothing." Like, like one box, you know? I'm thinking like, "Oh, it's nothing, but it's like a case or two cases, right? And we're just going to build up." No, zero. Nothing. And I asked why, and they said, "Well, you haven't run Bandai events before."
And I said, "Well, my store just opened 6 months ago, right? So, I can't run Bandai. I haven't." Because you, people also don't know this is Bandai makes you pre-order all of their games 6 months in advance. So, you have to order,
you're essentially on the hook for three sets before you ever receive your first order. So, if you're like, "Oo, I'm going to order Gundam." and you're going to you're going to support Gundam and really be into it, uh you are on the hook for essentially three sets of Gundam and if it comes out and it just tanks and no one wants to buy it, guess what? You're buying two more sets of it and or else your distributors because I don't know, I work on the OP like with my distributor I think and most people do if they're surviving the TCU business. You take what you ordered. You don't go back like cuz the last thing you want your distributor to be is mad at you, right? because you didn't take your your full allocation. And so you are swinging in the wind if it doesn't go well, right? And so it's wild to me that Bandai would not fulfill set one because they essentially made it so that I wouldn't order any of it. And the that is the only time I have ever not taken allocations for a game is I said I will not take any more gun. I will not b purchase it because you gave me zero at the beginning. Um and I think other people have similar stories which is crazy.
Yeah. Um, and and you know what you said is spot on about how early you have to have everything ordered. So, you can imagine how well Battle Spirits Saga went for uh for stores when that came out and that was Bandai's hot new hot game where they were pushing a million dollar, you know, prize circuit or whatever. And [snorts] the set one boxes within a month of release were down to $25 a box.
Yeah. um the game just absolutely crashed and retailers that they crashed before set two came out and set three was already ordered at that point as well. Um Bandai also requires that you uh not just have your orders all set up that far in advance, but you have to have your events scheduled like your pre-release events have to be scheduled on that time frame as well. So, if you want to start getting Bandai products for the first time, you will be able to have, I think, basic weekly promos in about two or 3 months and then start doing pre-releases four to 6 months later. Um, and it's it's a ridiculous time scale that is totally, in my opinion, totally unnecessary given uh the our communication methods today and how quickly we're able to manage everything.
Um, it is not every company needs to do it that way, which is all the evidence I need to know that that's not how it needs to be done for Bandai as well. But, uh, it is what it is. And also, just to add to Mike's story, if you, uh, even if you do run Bandai events, if you missed the short window to register for Gundam's launch events, you also didn't get anything. Even if you are the premier Bandai store in your entire region who runs events for every other game, and I may sound like I'm speaking from experience, and it's because I am, but the Gundam launch was uh not a fun one for us either. And now set two is very plentiful, and I'm not I'm not sure where things are going for there. I the point I ultimately wanted to make was that despite the misgivings and the issues that we have, Bandai has one thing going for it, which is their IPs are unmatched. Um, other than I guess League of Legends now,
but um, the IPs are incredible and the car and the cards look really nice and so they get a lot of players who are consistent and I look at a game like One Piece and One Piece isn't going anywhere anytime soon. It's it's doing just fine. It's going to continue doing just fine no matter how Bandai wants to run the other sides of things. Um so it's uh yeah you're going to basically sorry that was a tangent but I think a fun one. Um but Bandai games are going to be ones you can always invest in but there are games on the market that are more like the flesh and blood era that I also think uh era flesh and blood you know experience that you get. are I al I think they're also games that you would feel comfortable investing in even though they're not the games that are selling insane amounts of boxes like Riftbound or One Piece or anything. Um and I I am going to take just a moment to shill Grand Archive as well. Um because this is one of the card this is the only get card game to survive Kickstarter and not ultimately uh flop.
It has uh only grown since then. I just got back from the biggest tournament yet, which is 700 player tournament in Japan. It's a it's gathered a huge following in Taiwan, Singapore, Malaysia, and has a ton of North American, US players, Canadian players as well. Um, and the reason that I talk about this is because Mike, Marty, you said, "What games are doing things right?" Um, I agree there are issues with Star Wars Unlimited, even though I love playing that game. I could play that game literally all day. I would never get bored of it. Um, but there are games like Grand Archive who are growing and are small, but you look at what they do and everything is so focused on the experience, the players, the community, the product. Um, Grand Archive has foils that don't curl. They don't they don't curl and every other company will tell you
Yeah. They'll tell you that's not possible and they're actually just wrong. Um, Grand Archive has has competitive circuits with cash. It has an it has a it has its own uh tournament software that isn't cardio, which cardio is the worst thing in the world. That's sorry that's the one misstep Riftbound has so far, but hopefully they're just making their own right now. Um they have tournament software that works and tracks player rankings and they send out player rewards every season just like Old Magic. Um, and I there there are games that that you can find, smaller games that are going to do those things. And you it's just about finding the ones where you you can tell that I think the passion and the drive is there and it's not just a uh oh try trying to make money off of people, but trying to actually build something.
All right, so we've talked about the resurgence, some of the games are doing it well and stuff. Let's let's uh try to pull out the crystal ball right here. Uh are we in a bubble? Is the bubble going to pop? What do you think the future looks like for the TCG market?
I want to hear from Mike first. Uh, yeah, we're in a bubble. I mean, it but I think we're in a a bubble. [sighs] I don't know that it's the classic like, you know, this stuff is too expensive and inflated. I think it's um more of a like manufactured FOMO kind of thing, right? Because games that are available, right, like Star Wars, I think it's you're looking at sort of modern retail, right? Like it's it's problems with modern retail where Star Wars is fine. It it plays well. It's a good game, right? But uh nobody is frothing in the mouth to buy hundreds of boxes of Star Wars, right?
Which means it's worthless, right? And that's kind of like the two your game is either the hottest thing imaginable and you cannot get it right and it it blows out immediately or it's worthless and and the boxes crater immediately because L LGs's are on this cycle because you're operating on such low margins that you're ordering 20,000 30,000 $40,000 worth of a card game even if you're small, right? And so you're ordering all of this product and if it's at all slow, if it's at all sluggish, you just can't afford to have that capital tied up in that game. So what you immediately do and you're you're operating in a world where click of a button all of it's gone. Now you may not get what you want out of it, but it's at least 80% 70% or whatever you know MSRP you could get.
And so you're seeing more and more of that happening where you know I think Avatar had happened right I think Avatar was more Avatar the Last Airbender was the last magic set right and Avatar was very strong at the beginning and sold very well and I think still continues to sell well actually and uh but it is not sold out therefore boxes have cratered they're almost right at cost, right? Like they're they're so cheap and it is a good set. I don't think anybody would tell you looking at Avatar that it's bad, right? Because it plays very well. The cards are are good. Uh people enjoy it. Um it's a popular property. It's a good IP. Um people like it. But um you're going to see this polarization I think more and more where sets are either the hottest thing imaginable and the product goes to the moon or it's worthless. And I think you see that with board games as well because you board games are either impossible to get and you cannot get them because, you know, Shut Up and Sit Down did a video review of them and that made them, you know, it's the hottest game imaginable and everybody wants it or it sits on your shelf forever and you're blowing it out at, you know, 50% or 60% of of cost, right? And so, um, it's I think that you will you will see this happen more and more, I think, over the next year. I think especially with, you know, I'm
very slanted toward Magic because I think most stores their revenue is very tied up in Magic and I think like you are essentially forced to take huge allocations of magic because you need it, right? You're you're trapped onto a treadmill with magic where once you're in, you can't go down. You can't buy less. you have to buy more and more and more and more, right? And that leads to people having tons of product that they have to liquidate. So, I think next year more sets equals two to three of those sets are just not going to blow out and they're going to be dirt cheap. We were selling boxes of Spider-Man in my store for $80 a box on Black Friday. 80 bucks. And like honestly, we didn't sell many of them, right? We I mean we sold tons of certain ones, but not Spider-Man. And like I think it's only going to take a couple of those sets next year for that bubble to pop hard. And I, you know, I think I I mentioned this to Marty. I think this is this was the year I think you said earlier, Dan, that this was like the most stressful summer ever. I think every LGS that was open was just like, oh my god, the money's raining from the sky. Everybody's crazy to buy things. And I think we've cooled a little bit toward the end of the year here. And I don't expect I think there'll be bursts of super hot, you know, they'll want to set it'll sell out immediately, but I do think you're going to see a lot of stores that can't handle those swings have a lot of trouble next year because they that bubble is going to pop, I
think. So, yeah, I I agree. Um I mean, it's impossible to look at the current market and think that it's just going to go forever. I mean, I guess you could do it, but that's I think pretty naive. Um, there's obviously something is going to happen at some point because you simply it doesn't make sense to continue to add new giant IP, new the Cyberpunk TCG was just teased last week. That's another one coming out now. So, anyone who's a fan of the CD Project Red game or the source material orever for Cyberpunk is now going to have to look at that game. Um, it's impossible to just continue to add on game and game and game and game and players have limited, increasingly limited, I would even say right now budgets u to be able to spend on games and Magic is trying to get them to buy 32 sets a year and uh and that's not accounting the secret layers that you were going to want to buy because you got to play your Dwight K.
Shroo commander deck. Um, but
he holds serious. Yes, there's an office secret layer set for magic. So, anyway, go ahead.
I made I made a joke when we opened the shop that I said by the end of 2025, you'll be able to equip Aunt May with a buster sword and attack and I I'm correct. It it you can do it right now in a game of Magic, which is silly, but you know,
yeah.
Yeah. No, that's that's fine. It's um yeah, Magic's in an interesting time, but uh every company is competing already for everybody's wallets. Um there are great smaller games. There are IPs you love. There are games that your friends are playing and so you want to play them, too. And then there's new IPs and new games and new Kickstarters and new whatever coming out. And it just you just can't keep you just can't keep adding those on and have that market continue to support every single game that's in it. Now I want to also sort of balance that with something I mentioned earlier which is that this is the biggest market of TCG buyers we've ever had in the industry period. So the one piece of wisdom that we have heard going back to that era you talked about Marty the 2008 era was that uh card games will go for one to three years and die. if they make it past three years then well actually five three to five is sometimes said as well but um eventually you know every TCG is going to die um and that's and sort of like 99% of them are within three years right um and I I actually will well okay I'll say that that's true if you count 99% as the Kickstarter that Kickstarters that come out because 99% of Kickstarters that come out are someone who had an idea and drew it in MS Paint and it's you know it's not a serious like effort at adding to the TC industry is just trying to create a
something that they're happy with or whatever and they want to find like-minded people. Um, but a lot of TCGs that come out now do have what it takes if they do things correctly to last a longer amount of time. And it's easy to look at the market and look at games that have been going on forever. Some of them I don't know how, but games like Universes, Dragon Ball Super, um, I mean like there's a pile of games. Force of Will is actually still in print technically from what I understand, which is also kind of wild. But um the there are games that are able to kind of take it the distance and go for a pretty long period of time and sometimes even thrive for a pretty long period of time and Flesh and Blood really proved that that's possible even when you don't have a gigantic IP on your back if you can hit the right timing, do things right.
Um, so I do think the bubble's going to burst and I do think some of those games, even some of the ones that are doing well, might end up having to uh make some concessions at some point um and may even end up uh collapsing on themselves. But I don't I also don't think it's entirely doom and gloom. And I I think that um it really just comes down to how these companies manage the games.
Cool. Cool. Well, guys, you got any last comments or anything that you want to show? [sighs]
Tony shows up at the last last minute, y'all.
So, so let's rehash. I'm kidding.
Wow.
I am so sorry. I I just jumped in there hoping it had been ended, but [sighs] how hard is it to get a dinner out of spaghetti? That's all I'm asking. I've I mean, come on.
So unprofessional. [snorts]
Don't even go there with me. I It was I had it all timed out. Life was good.
No, I forgot my train of thought. So anyway, so all right, we just talked about the future of the TCG market. Uh where everybody feels it's like, yeah, it's probably not going to maintain the momentum. Like like you said, Dan, I hope that we don't have what happened in 2008 or so where the it feels like in 2008 TCG players said, "I'm just I'm done with TCGs." I hope we don't experience that again. I hope that
I don't think we're going there.
Okay.
No, I I just think like we're going to go out of this insane world where people pre-order things at 50% up markup over MSRP. I think like you'll get back to the world where you can buy boxes at a reasonable, you know, discount over cost and like, you know, collector boosters will be somewhat expensive, but like especially for Magic, this boom is like very recent. Like it's it's kind of started with Final Fantasy and it kind of brought the Pokemon speculators over, but I don't think we're we're there forever. I I also think like none of these games are going anywhere. I think they're they're what they're doing right now is they're accumulating huge number of players which is great right like I think if the prices go down I mean I think even Star Wars like which I would say is maybe the game that I'm the you know the most bearish on I think like um it's super cheap to play it like it's incredibly cheap to be a Star Wars player. You buy like three boxes a week or two after release and you're spending like 150 bucks. That's awesome. That's great for players and and cards are cheap. Like I think Luke I s we sold a Luke on TG Player the other day and it was like $17. I remember when Luke was like 70 bucks
and so I mean it's a huge change. So the games are cheaper which hopefully brings more players. I think they just need to survive. They need to figure out a way to make it work for retail.
Um but I don't think they're going anywhere.
A lot of games just need to carve out their niche and perform their niche very well. Some of those games are like the Bandai games where their niche is just does it have a picture of Monkey Duffy on it, then it's really good. So, good job. Um, and some games need to fight a little harder. And I think Star Wars is is a game that does it does need to fight a little harder. Star Wars as an IP just isn't quite as salient in 2025 as it was in the late '9s. Um, but it's also got a lot of people now viewing shows on Disney Plus and uh, you know, there's like there's plenty of fans out there of the IP. Um, it's just that they they kind of for some reason they have they have so many demons that they're fighting from the past as well. So, they really need to continue to do uh, great things with their product line, which I think could use a little bit of a little bit of a rework. Um, and uh, and make sure their organized play is hitting and everything. But we saw at Galactics this year, there were 2,000 people there. I mean like it's not that the players aren't there.
That's the right kind of failing is all I'll say. Like what when people are playing the game, you're doing all right. So
yeah. Yeah. So um as long as these games find their niche, do it well, make themselves stand out in the market. Um you're going to get basically you're just you need to make sure you have people who say I am invested in X because they do Y the way I like it. Um, and once a game no longer has a significant why for people to name, then it's going to start to fade out.
Yeah. Yeah. I I will say this, uh, Mike, if you ever get one any more of those four player Riftbound starter boxes in, hold me one and I'll take one.
This thing's that is like the one gripe I have with them. And again, it's all due to like, you know,
oh no, people want to buy your stuff, right? But like, god, man, print more starters. What are we doing? Like you've
exclusive cards in the starters and like they just disappeared. We got eight of them.
Eight of them. It was like what? How is this ever enough? Right.
It It's so weird. It's like what's the perfect way to try to get Well, just buy the starter set. Great. Yeah, you can't get that. [snorts and laughter]
No, you can't.
The product was one of the best I've ever heard of designed for the market. It's just that they needed to print literally 10 times or more the amount that they printed for it to succeed at what it set out to do.
Yeah. I could have sold hundreds of those no problem. Like every player that wants it.
I did pre-sell hundreds of them, but I didn't get them.
Yeah.
Yeah. All right. Well, uh, amazing discussion, guys. Like I've always been passionate about the TCG games, the TCG space, and Mike, you know, I'm always in there. I like I like hearing what goes on behind the scenes. I like getting to the business stuff. I just think it's super it's just very interesting to me about why a game succeeds, why they don't succeed, who does it right, and you know, why the resurgence and all this, which is why I was excited to have this discussion with you. So before we go, Tony, do you have any one last question you want to ask these guys that that you just been burning your brain even though we may have talked about it?
I'm not going to do that to the audience. I can't wait to listen to this episode. Um because I'm sure I mean you know I know Marty went back to our history and what started this whole freaking podcast that we've had for as many years as we've had and it's just we've seen the demise of many of these games. So we're really pulling for like our the new one Star Wars. We love it and we hope they continue with it because we know what make believe it or not um age and experience do count for something and some of the ones Yeah. You can't knock the jargon off. You can't knock magic off, but figure [snorts] out what failed. I mean, there's plenty examples of that, you know, from I mean, even Dragon Ball and uh Yu-Gi-Oh and those kinds of things just
Wait a minute. You said those those didn't fail.
I know, but what I'm saying those continued, but are they at the same level as they were in the pre
Ugio was the number three selling See, he he missed all this guys. It was a number three selling game in Q3,
which why? There's no comic behind it anymore. There's no, you know,
it's been around for decades.
Doesn't need it. It keeps going, man. Like
I know. Yep.
And what's what's the secret sauce? What's behind that? What makes it the Mac rib? You know,
right now the secret sauce is designing terrible sets that are $30 on the market. I don't I don't know why it works, but it does. designing boxes that come out and are immediately under cost. I think
we got a set in one time. The the first Yu-Gi-Oh set we ordered, we ordered like three cases of it. I was like, I don't know. Let's see. And by the time it came in, it was $5 under cost on TCG Player. And I was like, "Wow, cool. This is great. What a great game." And you know, that's it. We kind of stopped carrying it. But
I I think from Oh, I'm sorry.
No, no, go ahead. Go ahead. Yeah, I the only thing I would say is I think they're so much better now is like from a gameplay perspective, every single game that I play, every one of these new TCGs is miles ahead. I mean, I played Wyvern and Rage and like those games were not good. I mean, I know that the Rage people don't come for me, right? Like I look, I I played Rage. It was fun, but it's not a good game. Like, we we it was terrible. All of the games now, even like the ones that I think are simpler like Lorana and things like that, they're great compared to what they were. So
don't don't worry, Mike. Overpower is back.
Yeah, Overpower. Yeah, good lord. Like why
I have But
yeah, so I I mean I think just the quality of the games are so much better now. They're just so much better.
What's [snorts] the one sitting in your basement, Marty? We commented on during our mini Star Wars tournament. Um the western one, which you and I
Oh, Doomtown. Doomtown.
Yeah, but that that wasn't a CCG. That was that version was an LCG. Now, you're talking about Kickstarters. Uh a year and a half, two years ago, I back I kickstarted the Warlords from the early 2000s. They're re-releasing that. I never played. So, I was like, I totally forgot I backed that. So, I'm going to be getting some of that.
I like that game, actually. That's a pretty good one.
I think so, too. I think that game's good.
All right. So, so what I heard was the quality the quality of the games has gotten better. So, there you go.
Yeah. And if y'all wonder why Tony's mic sounds weird is because he doesn't have his right mic turned on. So, um
I've selected the right mic.
Anyway, he sounds weird. Um All right. So, before we get out of here, uh Dan, where can people find you?
Uh thank you, Marty. Uh Main Deck is uh my channel. I go by Main Deck Games everywhere. So, if you just go to any place and type main deck games, you'll probably find me. Um, and uh, yeah, I'm I tweet a lot. Actually, I tweet a decent amount about card games. So, head over to Twitter or X or whatever you want to call it. Um, and I'm over there as well.
And I need to try Grand Archive. I I don't know anybody around me that plays it, but I think the art I think the graphic design on that game just looks absolutely amazing. I'm a big anime fan, so I like that style. Anyway, so look at that. That's just gorgeous.
You ain't gonna get me on that one.
That's gorgeous. And
everyone's got their own.
Mike, where can we find you? [snorts]
Yeah. So, I run, as Marty said earlier, I run a board game cafe in Charlotte, North Carolina. Um, called to the table, board game cafe. Uh, you can find us at tothetable.game. And, uh, we sell, you know, board games there. You can also find Sigles on Manaool, TG Player. So,
uh, yeah. And it is my now favorite local game store, everybody. It's like uh he has great prices. He says, "Hey, look, I try to stay competitive." And 100% he is. So, I pre-order stuff from there. Play events there. So, it is my go-to store. And I've gotten my In fact, Mike, I had a a friend I've got into Star Wars Unlimited, travel like 35 minutes down to come see you on Black Friday because of the great sales that you were having.
He was super nice. Yeah.
Nice.
We also have beer and wine and that helps a lot. So, That always helps. Well, guys, thank you so much for having me on. I think this was an amazing discussion and maybe we'll follow up in a year or something. It's like, all right, you know, what do we predict that was correct? Maybe what's hot in you right now and just uh I love keeping my pulse on this industry because I think it's super exciting to follow. [snorts]
Yeah. Thanks a lot. Doesn't have to be a year, Marty. Call anytime. Happy to join again.
Nice. All right. Awesome. Thanks, guys.
Hey there, I'm Hugh from Poderation. If you like today's episode, why not check out Dice Wall Roll, the queerest Pathfinder show on the planet. Join a crew of four friends asking the important questions about RPGs, like is it cannibalism to eat a polymorph chicken? From getting four ones to the roll to standing up to the darkest forces in the multiverse, Dice Roll is available wherever you get your podcasts.