Skip to main content
Loading video...

3 Forgotten Gems - Saint Malo, Alhambra, Manhattan - Board Game Reviews

Transcript 13:17

hey everyone today we are going back 10 20 and 30 years ago to talk about some forgotten gems now I have done a video like this before and perhaps these games are not quite as obscure as the last ones but who cares these are all really worth still talking about so the games we're talking about are Saint Marlo by Inca and Marcus brand we're going to take a look at Manhattan by Andrea safarth and also Alhambra by Dirk Henn and spoiler alert these are all really good games but before I go into my thoughts on these games I want to give a shout out to the show's sponsor keyienda dot Co dot UK who I might go through online retailer and if you use the link in my show notes or the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order so let's start with the smallest of the three this is Saint Marlo by Inca and Marcus brand this one accommodates two to five players and takes around 45 minutes to play on average now this is actually one of the forefathers of the roll and right genre of games and this one does utilize that Yahtzee star mechanism if you're rolling a big cluster of dice and selecting one of these symbols you do get some re-rolls however you always have to be wary of this crossed sword symbol um because if you end up racking up with too many of those then the game can

fight against you and end up scoring you negative points and I always love that kind of Pusher like mechanism and this one uses that to a really high standard and the other way you can mitigate that by choosing these wall symbols and I'm fortifying your little player sheet here and I'm racking up some defense points but essentially you are trying to fill up your little town square here and you have quite a restricted little grid there and you are collecting resources you're using these resources to build buildings You're Building churches which will score you based on set collection you're collecting these different kind of villagers which will score you points in different ways such as giving you more defense points or points based on different things you've collected or straight up victory points and that's pretty much the gist of the game there are some different things you can aim for by connecting these walls to um by completing a section of wall you can collect these bonuses such as again additional money um some victory points um Etc and again it all comes down to what are you going to draft how are you going to puzzle things out there's a little bit of a special puzzle there and yeah it's just a very nice little concise game kind of a lot of stuff we've seen before but you know bearing in mind this game does go back 10 years I think this one did a good job of relaying a strong foundation for this Yahtzee variant roll and write genre of games and this one still holds up remarkably well you know you are probably aware that maybe three four years ago there were so many roll and right style games coming

out and they still are um there really is a huge saturation of them and in fact this one was one of the earliest and it is still one of the best ones really does speak highly of its quality so yeah like all these additional little twists that again that idea of the game fighting against you it almost feels like one of those Stefan Feld um games where there's always something to you know just to have in the back of your mind to try and counter reaction you're always under a bit of pressure not to lose those additional oh not to lose um victory points that's pretty much the gist of the game yeah the smoke special special puzzle a bit of drafting a bit of dice rolling and it's just a really nice game that I would recommend picking up if you like that genre so that is Saint Marlo so let's go back 20 years and talk about our Hambra so this was a spilled jealous winner back in 2003 uh two to six players can play this one and it takes 45 to 60 Minutes to play on average now this was one of the kind of old classic Euros it's kind of one of the original tile placement games as well and I do like how the tile placement of this game is simple but there are a few extra little restrictions that I do like so for example whenever you place a new tile you always have to be able to trace the roots back to your starting starting Fountain here and that's not always easy because if

you notice here each tile or most of the tiles have kind of a black border on them and the those are walls that you are trying to construct in the basically the longer your wall is around the parameter of your town square or your Alhambra means that there's more points available to you so it's another scoring mechanism but it can actually hurt you if you don't place it too optimally because it could end up creating a border or a barricade and tracing back to the Fountain so a nice little puzzle there to overcome uh the what the reason you're trying to collect these tiles is based on these colors so basically um every so often in the game there will be a scoring phase anyway Whoever has the majority in each of the different colors will score more points or secondaries will get fewer points third place fewer points again and so on and that's not where the twists on this game end because the way you draft the tiles in the first place is quite novel as you have this board here where the tiles will be dished out randomly but you can see that each towel has an Associated currency to it so you can see that now this tile has a blue currency in order to buy it and what you're doing is you're collecting these currency cards which come in four different colors and basically then you are cashing those cards in to get the relevant tiles but of course sometimes there's going to be more or you know fewer available options of a certain currency meaning that certain tiles might be more rare or harder to get hold of

and on top of that if you end up spending the exact amount of change on buying a tile like you know if you spent six to get the six then you get an additional turn and you can actually string multiple turns together if you map out your currency very carefully so it does have a nice pacing to this one just constantly picking up cards buying tiles smashing a bunch down as you charge up all your currency cards and um hopefully by the time a scoring comes around you have the majorities um again I love that additional spatial puzzle of the Border of the um you know of the Alhambra that's a really nice touch and I actually think that makes the game so much better than if it didn't have that so that's pretty much the gist of the game it's very simple very straightforward but those extra little twists do make it quite captivating for me it can be quite interesting as you are trying to collect a certain type of currency you know your opponent is doing the same thing because you both want that tile I mean maybe you overspend and don't get those extra turns but it was worth it because you got the exact time you wanted to give you the majorities or to extend your Alhambra um Alpha wall there that's where the game ends I think this one does a great job of editing everything that didn't need to be in this game out of it keeps it very straightforward I know there is a ton of expansion material to this game and I've only played the base game and base game alone and as it is I think it is very impressive and it's very um he's very minimalist and it's quite refreshing to see that now I understand this game is

you know 20 years old now and but I do think it is very it has an evergreen feel to it it feels almost Timeless um almost like a game like carcasson or something but a more urified version of that so at the moment I'm loving this one I think the two-player variant of the game is a little bit clunky so be wary of that because in two players you basically use a proxy player to compete with the majorities and by drawing randomly from the tile bag that is a little bit you know it's a little bit clunky it isn't the most um the most satisfying way to win or lose a game um by interacting with that proxy player so I think it definitely does Peak at three or four players but that is a nitpick then it's still worth playing it too because you know mapping out your own grid is always quite fun anyway so this one again held up remarkably well I'm really enjoying it and it's gone straight into my collection and I'm very excited to play some more of this one a nice quick teach but there's again there's additional little twists just keep it coming back to the table so that is Alhambra by Dirk hen and the final game we're talking about today is Manhattan by Andrea safarth this is another spilled Jazz winner back in 1994 so almost 30 years ago now this is a two to four player game that takes around 40 minutes to play and it is an area majority or area control Style game

as you are trying to build these skyscrapers in these different cities and this game has one of the simplest scoring systems out there where you are going to score points based on who's got the majority in each of the cities are you also going to score points based on who has the highest or the tallest skyscraper on the entire board and then you're going to score an additional point for every building you have of your color on display now the actual Action System in this game is super simple as you have this hand of cards which will show a grid on it and if you notice each of these grids shows where you can deploy one or your buildings and depending on where you're sat on the table that location will change because say I'm facing this way my top left hand corner is going to be here where if I sat facing this way my top left hand corner is going to be here so every card is going to mean something else or something different to each player now there are some additional twists to this game as you can actually build on top of other players skyscrapers and clean that building for your own as long as you have an equal amount or more amount of your player pieces in that particular skyscraper so there definitely is some confrontation here it can be a little bit spiteful at times and even feel a little bit mean but I always felt that it came through in quite a jovial and fun and almost light-hearted way so I think you've got to be prepared to be in for a bit of a knife fight in this game um you know be you know be conscious of the fact that you are going to get

attacked and have your buildings conquered by other players but it you know it can it never feels nasty because you are always just reacting to the cards available to you I think it does a great job of having you or giving you a limited hand size so your options aren't overwhelming but you have enough to decide for yourself and I like the fact that you know each round you have to decide which buildings you're going to take to be able to be to be deployed are you going to go straight in with your huge um Stacks are you going to put your small ones down just to build a foundation um it's just yeah it's just a very Dynamic um a quick Breezy game with a lot of player interaction simple scoring very accessible um you know scales well at three or four players and I just think this game is has been a bit of a grow up for me at first I was a little bit underwhelmed by it because it is so minimalistic um but I think that really does play to its strengths and more and more I've played this one you know you can get this played in around 30 minutes um which is I think is a really good time stamp for a game uh with this much going on now I'm not saying it's it's huge it is you know family weight but it does feel like you're getting a good amount of game for that amount of time so this is very Bare Bones stuff but it does stay true to that area control and majority feed of the game um and it does I feel like there's a good degree of play interaction which is what you want for a game like this so I'm pretty sure this is going to go down well with most um most game groups maybe if you like really complex games this might feel a

little bit might leave you feeling a little bit wanting um but I like it you know considering this is from the designer of um Puerto Rico which is like a heavier Euro game um this one does definitely pulls apart to a game like that so it's definitely a shows the um the the depth of this guy's mind and what the kind of games that he puts out there but yeah this one has gone straight to strength for me um I found its way into my collection and I love putting this one out and getting it to the table because it always puts smiles on people's faces even if it is in a somewhat confrontational way so that is Manhattan by Andreas safarth so that we have it that concludes the video hopefully you have enjoyed it as much as I have because it's always nice to talk about these older games with so many people talking about the new hotness um I don't think that's always necessary sometimes these old games are just as good if not better than the new stuff coming out if you have enjoyed the video please be sure to hit like And subscribe to my channel and for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye

Progress saved