Skip to main content
Loading video...

Every day, rulebooks destroy my soul a bit more

Transcript 10:14

I HATE IT. I hate it. I hate it. Hate it. I hate it when I can't play game. I want to play a game, but I can't play a game because the rulebook is in the way. And trust me, the team is reading like two rulebooks a week minimum, like minimum. We go through so many rules here. So, yeah, the anger has just been boiling up and now it's time to rant about it and maybe this can help publishers or people that are going through rulebooks. Like these aren't even just for prototypes. There's normal games where I read the rulebook and I'm still not even sure how to play, so I'm forced to take the pieces out and try to do a normal turn. But games shouldn't have a required solo session before gaming. So yes, I'm ranting, but hopefully people can get something out of this again. Cuz the hobby should be about, you know, playing the game, not buying the game and being wowed by the components as you open it up and then putting it away and not playing the game cuz the rulebook sucks. Like yeah, it kind of does feel like I need a bachelor of arts degrees and Google Board Game Geek to play the game. Like why is it so much work to play the game? Like the amount of times here even for us that we try to play a game and we get through like one round and then have to go get dinner, so we didn't really play the game. Okay, one final thing. Maybe people use AI to help them go through rulebooks or make the rulebooks, but we won't be discussing AI in this video. And this video will all be about structural issues too with rulebooks, no grammar nitpicking, so let's get into that.

This just makes the rules needlessly long. Like sure, it's good to have some flavor text at the beginning of the rulebook to set the tone of why you're playing the game. So for example, if you're playing Star Wars Rebellion, yes, explain this rebel versus Empire conflict. And then after that, then you can explain the how to win and the mechanical overview, like how it does worker placement and how you move ships. I've gone through so many rulebooks where every chapter has multiple paragraphs of just useless flavor text really. It's just there to sound cool. Not only do I not care about the flavor text while trying to read rules, it'll often end up confusing the message.

Let's say for example, the rulebook doesn't technically say you win even though it seems like you win, rather it'll say that you were crowned the magical ruler and now get special resources called shekels. If you want flavor text in your rulebook, yes, I get it. I get it. It's fun to have. It's fun to build out this world. So, just put in sidebars like how Brass: Birmingham does it.

So, you have a game with a bunch of pieces and maybe your rulebook even has a component list and then will tell you to start setting up the game with very specific instructions and maybe drafting cards or using them ways and it's like, well, we don't even know what these cards do. How can we even draft them? Sometimes I've even seen that the cards are explained halfway through the rulebook. Like, it's not even what the cards do, it's what are their costs or benefits? What's the timing to playing a card? I haven't played the Stardew Valley board game, but apparently it's huge in doing this thing. It explains all the win conditions without knowing the component list. Like, if we're learning how to write emails in class, the teacher would say, "Okay, first we're learning what an email is and the purpose of it. Then we're learning the tone of emails. Then lastly, we're learning how to conclude, maybe write in some calls to actions so the other person knows how to respond." But rulebooks are doing the equivalent of starting the class with sometimes no lesson plan because there's no table of contents, sometimes, then jumping right into why subject line matters before you even know why you're writing an email. Like, who am I sending email to? The longer I live, the more I realize that middle school journalism class had it so correct. To explain things, you need to know who, what, where, when, why, how. I'll say it again. Who, what, where, when, why, how.

And so, if I do not know what am I supposed to be modifying in your game, that is, I do not know what the cards do, then you jump ahead to how I'm supposed to use the cards, even though I don't know what the cards mean, then I'm going to be very confused. So, your game is pretty big, right? You spent many years making it. There's a lot of components. There's a lot of terms. There's a lot of cool mechanics that go together well, and yeah, why why is there no index or glossary? Again, if you spent so much time making your game, like even years, wouldn't it take like three to four hours about to make a quick glossary or a quick index? Maybe even AI could help you with this. So, there is a defense that, "Oh my gosh, no, I don't want to have this in my rule book because it's going to make the rule book too big. Maybe the manufacturer can't do it, or maybe I just don't want to intimidate people." Then I would just say put it in a separate booklet, like come on. The only reason why you shouldn't have at least some index or glossary is because your game is so so simple with few keywords, like coup or last word. Yeah, these are like party games. So, additional pages would be too redundant or serve to confuse its target audience.

Yes, even Grim Covenant has a glossary and index called keywords and glossary, but it's not perfect. But hey, at least they're trying, right? Some games don't even try. Ever been listening to a friend talk about their story and they'll go, "Oh wait, wait, did you know about that? Joe? Yeah, Joe walked up and oh gosh, Joe is my best friend. Do you know Joe? Yeah, he was wearing that shirt I gave him." And you're internally screaming, "Just get back to the story about the car accident so I can actually help you." So, yes, even rules explanations that are written are subject to this. This point is related to number two, that is the rule book will have things in the wrong order. This is it's interrupting itself. This is more like sections are getting combined in annoying ways rather than there being completely out of order. Again, very similar, but still worth pointing out.

So, let's say the rule book is bringing up all the actions you can do on a turn, and one of the actions is combat. So, instead of continuing with the rest of the actions or maybe the rest of the turn structure because you're mentally in that frame of what do I do on a turn, it will just start going down this tangent of oh, this is all the combat steps. It might say, "Oh, combat requires you to grab dice, check these numbers on the board, check if your opponent has the right dice, Roll the dice. Check the strength numbers. But really, you don't care about that at the moment. You just want to know how the turn works. This is why in all of our how to play videos, I'll always say, "Yes, you can do combat as part of your turn." But I'll never explain it in the part where we're talking about a turn. I'll just say, "Yes, as an action, you can move to another player and you can attack them and we'll talk about that later." So, the rulebook is trying to be more like an almanac or like an encyclopedia of being so comprehensive, but there's a big difference between something being a good reference book and being a good tutorial book. One is trying to explain to you when you know nothing and the other is a reference that you can go back and reference once you already know about said thing.

Yes, your rulebook can look really pretty with nice cover art. It can have things on the margins. It can have colored fancy paper. But if I don't know what you're talking about with your writing, I don't know what you're talking about. I find many games where it would just say, "Oh, find the asset card." And I go, "Okay, the asset card. I don't know what that is." All right, so what am I doing now? Well, then I'm flipping all the way to the start of the rulebook. I have to find where they define asset card on their component list and then flip back to the middle of the rulebook where they actually talk about asset card. It's just a pain in the butt. Imagine doing this for many, many components. A way to help this is to have symbols on the cards. Seen this in a lot of games. Then put these symbols next to the words in the rulebook. So, maybe asset cards have a briefcase. Every time you see the term asset card, at least early on, you see the briefcase. Also, this would really help with piece identification of when you punch out the game because again, punching out the game and playing it should be an exercise of getting to play the game, not this Sherlock Holmes detective thing where you're putting pieces in the right category cuz you're not really sure because the rulebook is unclear. Here, let's do a little exercise in clarity. I can say, "Go to the top row of the central player board, then find the star action."

Or I can just circle it in a picture. Huh. Oh, bonus points if you have a rulebook have numbered steps right next to the setup. That's pretty perfect. A picture tells a thousand words. That is just how it is. Like rule book reading actually reminds me of being forced to read in college for classes and just being kind of burned out of reading. And now I know why people hate reading cuz yeah, a lot of reading is just boring. Like technical writing by its nature is not fun for most people. So, why make people go through that? Like look at what happens when you buy any product in the world you need a tutorial to use. Electronics or furniture. They have a diagram, a very simple diagram because why say a bunch of word when quick DIAGRAM DO TRICK?

[screaming]

RULE BOOKS ARE TRYING TO TEACH YOU THE GAME in a wide way. It makes sense, right? It needs to be everything. The rules are kind of the soul of the product, the game. They need to hype you up for the game. They need to explain the game. Need to be a reference. But being so wide just doesn't really work for the human brain on a first impression. Especially when you factor in that when you play on game night, someone else is reading the rule book and then teaching you the game. So, there's another layer of muddiness. With most things in life, you just want to do it, right? You just want to get going. And you should be playing games as quickly as possible and a lot of rule books unfortunately just don't facilitate that. Like if I was teaching you a game that I think is interesting, well maybe I'd start out with the core mechanic, right? Like, "Oh, Star Wars Rebellion not only has area control but has a really cool twist on worker placement." But a rule book wouldn't really explain that. They would just say, "Oh, here are all the phases that make up the game." Smaller publishers don't have anyone to help blind play test the rule book because they can't afford it. And honestly, their friends are probably not up to the task because going through rule books is not fun. But then big publishers also have rule book problems, too. But they're not as bad. But yeah, the whole premise, the whole the whole state of it is just sad even from decades of modern board gaming. those of you who still are okay with reading, I'm going to link a BGG article in the description below that inspired me to make this video and I didn't read through all of it. I just kind of skimmed through it, so yeah. Guilty if it ends up sucking, but it definitely inspired me and it has some really cool It has some really cool quotes. Okay, yeah.

That's it. Thank you to our patrons. Hope this rant can help someone. Yeah, cuz there's a lot of games that are unreleased and we have to go through the rules and it's just Yeah, thank you to our patrons making videos like this possible over here. Also remember that's cardboard and we have a lot of big content hitting soon. Hopefully I get out sooner rather than later. And again, these all would be faster if the rule books were more clear and better to go through. Okay, bye-bye.

Progress saved