How to design a worker placement game with Shem Phillips & Sam Macdonald
Transcript
what's up my friends welcome to the board game Design Lab today today we're going to play some workers we're going to talk about what it looks like to design a worker placement game and we're talking to shim Phillips and Sam McDonald from garfi games gentlemen welcome to the show hey thanks for having us hello yeah really excited to have you guys here you two have put together just some of the best worker placement games in the industry uh over and over again You' come out with with new mechanisms new way of placing workers New Way ways of scoring points and so I'm just really excited to kind of get y'all's perspectives on how to design these games you know how to come up with new ideas how to make things Innovative how to make things different and shiny and new and do well and Kickstarter and all that good stuff but before we get into it who are you how'd you get in game design all that kind of thing shim where'd you go first yeah so I've been uh been doing this for about 12 or 13 years now I think um I actually got into designing games before I even knew anything about the modern board game hobby at all um so uh would have been I think I I wanted to make a little like family roller move game um way back in early 20s um so I went about designing that and um made all of the bits um like Source bits from different places so tiles from Germany got the robw books made locally and we make these almost like kit set style um games which I could sell to my friends basically just making them for um as cheap as possible and selling them at at cost price um and then after doing that first game G um I then got introduced to
a local board game convention started learning more about these new modern board games um and was really on this kind of Journey of learning what makes what how to make great games but I was kind of learning as I was still trying to produce these games um so I always s refer to as I was learning on the job quite a bit so I've learned a lot and my my games have changed a lot over those years gotcha and Sam what brought you into the industry well it was kind of a bit of a happy accident really uh I always loved playing games but I wasn't much of a collector up until maybe 3 or 4 years ago shim uh was a bandmate so I played drums and shim play guitar in a band that we were in so we knew that we could sort of work together creatively uh I used to test a lot of shim's games he he introduced me to pandemic and citadels and you know one day when I was at work on my lunch break this idea for a game came to me I scribbled a few ideas down on pieces of paper I got home to my flat that night I drew it up on a whiteboard cut out some pieces of paper and I raided all my other games like Cosmic Encounter for pieces and yeah shim doesn't love Cosmic Encounter but anyway we'll continue uh and then I decided I'd contact shim just to see what he thought of this game you know just because he he knows a lot about games he produces them and I just wanted advice from a friend you know could this be something and about after two or three three plays with him shim was like yep let's do this together and
that ended up being architects of the West Kingdom so yeah I haven't really looked back from there yeah I'd say that game uh it did pretty well I think that was a a pretty good pretty good choice there now shim tell me about the development of Garfield games as as a company where you know when did that happen how did the idea come along what made you want to get into the publishing side of things well back then um for me to actually get a game published based in New Zealand would have been extremely hard um it would have involved going to conventions overseas which for me was a lot of money at the time still there's a lot of money and a lot of time um so it never really dawned on me to even attempt that um the first people I know of that actually achieved it well were um Jarrett and Carl who got Endeavor picked up by zman um but I don't believe that was done in person though so it's quite rare for a New Zealander back then um so my solution was just to make the game myself um so I never really set out to be a publisher I suppose I just wanted to make a game and then after doing that game I thought hey can I do another one you know is is this my one game or can I make more so I just kept for I guess for five or six years just kept going can I make another one and for me I I enjoy production I enjoy creating the entire the entire thing the the visuals and everything so I just kept making games how I knew how to do it um and then when when Kickstarter came to New Zeal that's when it kind of changed a lot for me yeah for sure now what have been some of the bigger obstacles in New Zealand
obviously you know shipping out of New Zealand other parts of the world super expensive but what else have you run into as far as you know being kind of on an island isolated yeah so I me back then I didn't know anyone else locally that was probably the biggest part of it um until I put games up on Kickstarter um I didn't really have much of a network in New Zealand as far as designers go um so I felt quite isolated as a designer um until until I started networking with more people in New Zealand we now have like a Facebook group of a couple hundred people that are involved um like a little Design Group we meet up every six or eight weeks locally with people to test games but before before that happened it was very isolating um I found channels like the MEAP syrup show in Canada so should chewed into these like YouTube live streams to kind of in a way get that Community feel from other designers um and I really believe and honestly would say that until I did meet designers my games weren't as good um because I wasn't getting that really good feedback from people so that's probably the biggest challenge gotcha all right well let's jump into the topic for this episode talking about worker placement so let's get a good working definition Sam why don't you go first kind of what what are your thoughts if somebody says worker placement what does that mean what do you think that is just personally yeah so there's kind of the the broad definition is if anyone's placing workers to take actions that's kind of the broad running definition some other people like to specify a little bit more they would say that you're drafting actions with these
workers so that would mean that your workers block other people um from taking those actions but I think it's probably better if we just say that we are selecting actions with workers that are available to us yeah and typically these workers are ponds or meeples or yeah could be dice I guess people might want to you know say oh that's dice placement I guess but I guess dice placement is just a subset subcategory of work replacement uh shim do you have any kind of differing definition or is that what you feel as well yeah I think it's I agree with Sam completely um it's also just it's like a general feel as well I think that worker placements have they are very um like ex usually quite accessible Euro game um obviously you got to have the mechanisms to support that it's a work placement but um they yeah I think worker placement as a genre has a very similar feel to it so Raiders Raiders nor SE is kind of work placement game because of how it feels to play it more than strictly what you're doing on your turn or that kind of thing um so it's I don't know it's it's it's like a rough thing like it's like we kind and categorize movies into like comedy and drama but there's always these mish mash and blending that happens yeah and at the end of the day the definitions are there to help us you know what I mean they're they're words that we use to help us to kind of narrow things down so that we can understand kind of what we're getting into you mean they're not reasons for us to argue and hate each other on the internet I thought that was the whole point of that's the main
that's the main reason yeah that that's it all right so why do you think these games are so popular shim you mentioned just a moment ago that that people you know just kind of drawn to these games as zero games are very accessible they do very well on Kickstarter you know a lot of the top 100 and 200 on Board Game Geek rankwise are worker placement games uh Sam why do you think these games do so well one of the reasons I think is they just often look quite pretty you've got a really big board with all these different locations that they'll make the locations look and feel different um and they'll feel thematic another reason I would say shim kind of hit on it with the the complexity it kind of sits in that often will sit in that midweight Euro so you can pick it up but there's enough depth there and then a final thing that I'd add is that there's just the right amount of interaction so there's blocking and you kind of you really are interacting with the players and watching what they're doing but they never do anything that feels really really bad you know there's not really take that um inherently involved in work of placement just minor blocking gotcha and then shim from the publishing side of things I mean you you keep putting these games out so obviously they're doing well you know if they weren't making you any money you you'd publish something else and so tell me from the publishing side of things you know what you've seen as as far as the marketplace being drawn to these games and why do you think that is I would i' argue that like say 20 30 years ago that dice rolling was like the thing in games so if you played a game with a
family and you pass the person the dice they know to roll those dice on their turn it's just like the thing you do on your turn I think it has that same Simplicity of worker placement where it's like I've got my worker it's my T I put my worker down it's just so simple to grasp which I think is why it's it's a great a great tool to use um for those those yeah those mediumweight games from a pishing point of view um it's quite funny I never actually set out to make worker placement games I'm not like trying to reinvent anything or or do that it's just when we go to create some of these games it feels like the most natural mechanism to use often gotcha and so Sam why design one of these what what made you want to create one of these you know create multiple of these at this point what kind of Drew you in as far as a design stpoint uh in a sense I didn't have much control over it it's just the idea that came to me you know uh I had I had kind of two ideas about a game which was which ended up being Architects the first one was Hey what if we had a worker placement game where we could capture other people's workers and I thought that could be quite fun you round them up and send them to prison instead of workers blocking actions they um they can be taken away and then I thought that could work really well if you had a what I call a worker investment mechanism so you're only placing one worker on your turn but the more workers that you have on a spot the more rewards you get and so those two
mechanisms actually work really really nicely together because as players get more and more workers on a spot they get more resources and then other players want to prevent them from getting that big um Hall of resources so they come in and they capture them and and so it's quite Dynamic and that was kind of the uh the idea behind Architects gotcha and then what kind of Drew you in like you said you weren't necessar setting out to design a bunch of worker placement games so what is it about this mechanism that really kind of gets you excited and you keep designing more games I think the first one I played would have been Stone Age um which really captivated me back then just going back quite a few years I actually designed a it was a challenge for a design competition to put this little game in a tin almost like the MW Works kind of ones now um but I own this little card-based and dice placement Style game um and that was my first first attempt at it and I quite enjoyed making that game it was a very small print run um and then I think I'd already designed ships was my first Viking game at that point um but when that came out people were saying hey it's let's do some raiding in this in this kind of Series so I set out to make Raiders um I had never really done a proper worker placement I guess um Tanzania was that kind of dice rolling style one um so it was I guess for that one particularly I was trying to make work placement although I spent a lot of time in the early development or design phase um attempting to make the game
feel like you were raing that was the main goal so I always knew you want to have some crew in front of you um and I think I had a few versions where it was just dice chucking I had some that was very Stone Age style worker placement and about like the seventh or eth iteration I kind of stumbled on this idea of placing a worker and picking up a worker and we don't have that kind of oh there's something unique there's something I can work with that's when I started running with it so I don't I think it's you just keep playing with the ideas until something fresh kind of Sparks and you don't know what that's going to be so it's not like you really oh I'm going to go out there and make a real fresh work placement game you just kind of go out there and try things until something really jumps at you and then you run with that yeah that makes sense you I've heard a lot of designers talk about letting the game be what it wants to be and as you play it and play test it and design it and kind of let it do its own thing and you obviously you're the designer you have control over it but if it wants to be a worker placement game then then let it let it run free let it run wild right yeah and so all right let's talk about some of y'all's favorites I want to obviously talk about your games the ones that you've designed have done really really well but before we get into that what are some of the the favorites that stick out to you like what are some of the games that have inspired you or kind of helped you become better at designing worker placement games Sam what are what are some of your favorites Ah that's a really really good question I quite like keylow and assara they both do some interesting things with with colored workers and how that affects other players and what they can do on
their turns underwater cities also I've been playing that recently with shim and that is an amazing design and it makes me um it inspires me I guess with some new mechanism ideas as well very cool now what is it about those games you mentioned colors what else kind of gets you excited like what what are some of the things that listeners can can take away like why should listeners this if they want to be good at designing these games why should they play those games so if we if we take a game like keylow where the first uh worker that you place on an action spot determines the color that all other workers uh all other players must use to take that action that's just so crunchy and you're hiding these workers behind your uh screen so players can't see necessarily what colors you have stacked up uh so there's a lot of Mind Games going on there and I love that that mechanism there gotcha and then Jim what are some of your favorites um so early on I you know Stone Age and Water Deep was some the ones I played I think Pillars of the Earth was the first one that really grabbed me quite a bit um simply because I had kind of two levels of worker placement you had your your little dudes which act almost like a resource really to kind claim um cards at the start and then you use your um big Builder workers to actually take the actions and I liked how how it was resolved how you kind of bid for early placement um and then more recently well not too recent but Village was one that stood out to me as almost a worker removals to style game and yeah more
recently it's underwater cities genes um yeah quite a few I really like Lewis and Clark as well that's got a good mix of worker placement and um that kind of card playay deck building style stuff as well so really a lot of influences I just enjoy stuff when it's kind of fresh and someone's done something new with it yeah very cool now of the earth that was one where you would place a whole bunch of workers at one time right that one yeah that's that's like the um kind of the resource spending for cards at the start of the round um so those were your little workers you did you can even spend money I think at that point for some cards or you can place your workers which yeah we're multiple ones like four for this card five for that and then once everyone's done that you would then go around you draw out of the bag a I think they're called Master work Master Builders or something and they get placed on this kind of uh this re uh this gold track so if you get your one join on the bag first um it's like five coins or something to place place that on the board for the action that you want or you can pass and then they'll go around this kind track of maybe I think it's seven or eight spots and the money gets lower and lower and lower and once everyone's done that you wrap around and then place them for free after that so you can spend money to place um ahead of time and then they resolve the entire board in a in a cycle so that was quite cool quite unique yeah definitely and then you mentioned Village that's one of my favorites I love that one because your workers have a limited amount of time that you can use them and you're actually you know spending their lives so to speak and
then eventually they're going to die and they get to go on these kind of places on the board where they get to be remembered by the local community and you g gain points and things like that it's cool how you you want to use your workers but you also want to remove them from the game because you score other points and things like that uh you mentioned Stone Age what is it about that one that uh why should people play it I think that one a classic so that's like one of the first ones um it's just a very easy to learn solid um clean design there's not much going on but it's just what it does it does well um and that's yeah I think it's if you've never played a work placement that's a great one to start with because it'll kind of teach you the the very simple basics of how the mechanism works all right let's talk about y's games uh so you've designed quite a few and you've kind of got two different uh tracks or or different universes or are they maybe even in the same univers I'm not sure but you have the Western kingdoms and you have the North Sea lines of games and so shim real quick tell me why you chose to kind of have these two different tracks are they all in the same world so we might see some kind of intermingling of things you know Raiders of the West Kingdom or something like that one day down the road like tell me tell me more so they are they are the same world um the in paladins which is the second game in the west Kingdom that brings in that kind of ties them together you start seeing the Vikings coming to attack and that kind of stuff um so they're definitely the same I just I changed the Box colors to make the trilogies kind of stand apart so you know that the West kingdom is all red boxes the north is all blue um that's
the only reason and also because having that many games in a series can get confusing even just one Trilogy um but that started out with the kick my first Kickstarter um I had this game on my shelf for like two years that I designed I knew I couldn't produce by my usual methods of kind of in a way homemade games um so when Kickstarter came to New Zealand I thought hey it's a great chance to um to make this game I finally want to make it needs a lot of art it needs a big bigger box than I'm used to um so I st out to do that I honestly went into it thinking I might make 500 and maybe sell half of I'm lucky and that might be my last game because it's it's been a fun fun Journey but I might just stop here um and then I was just overwhelmed by the attention that I got on Kickstarter I had no idea at that point that people go there to buy games I thought it was just a crowdfunding site um so yeah that I end up printing I think it was 1, 1600 copies or something like that in China um lost a lot of money as you do when you first do your Kickstarter um but then after that um people were saying on the comments and on emails saying that they enjoyed they enjoyed the look of the game the game itself they like the idea of building your ships in the in the North Sea but why can't we use these ships to go and raid um and that kind of sparked for me hey maybe I should do a second game in this series um so that year I worked on Raiders and then in my mind it just makes more sense to do a Trilogy rather than just two games that don't they connect but don't really have any kind of finality or kind of roundness to them
um so I just thought well let's make three games and for me in my mind it made sense to do explorers because you've built your ships you've gone raiding now you're going out further abroad um and when I got to the end of that one um from a marketing point of view it made a lot of sense to continue with um the same art style and everything um and I because that was the North Sea I thought well I could do a south or an East or a West um and at that point I was considering like maybe a South Pacific um so actually changing the time period completely maybe changing the art style I was had a lot of things in my mind to think about and I had a few ideas working away but that was when Sam basically showed me his um early prototype for Architects um and I was this is actually this is pretty good this is quite a unique mechanism I can't think I've ever seen that kind of work investment before um and it just made sense Sam at that point had set it in like a citadels kind of fantasy medieval setting and it just made sense like this should be the West Kingdom this should be a French game about building buildings because the French are known for their fancy architecture um and that's just kind of where it went so we've got plans like the South and the East um as well so we'll see what that happens anyway sorry Sam I was just going to say how original it was that there was a game set in France about building a cathedral original but it works and it works yeah definely we actually toy that a lot we're like that's not unique enough we
need to change it somehow like we're trying to do Squires like you're training kns but then in the end we just said this makes sense like it's not very unique and not very original but it's just building building seems to make sense so sometimes you you can try and fight it as much as you like but it just like you're saying before the game wants to be what it is yeah and I guess the biggest thing is make a really good game and you know if the theme just kind of goes along with it and that's just going to enhance it and just let it be what it wants you know and I love how the games have kind of they've taken on this emergent story right and so we we go from here and then we go to there and then we're going to do this we're g to explore we're gonna raid it's very very cool from a a just publishing standpoint you kind of step back and and you can look at the trajectory of your narrative so to speak just with your different games it's it's really cool all right so let's talk about these uh your games more individually just kind of the design process the challenges you ran into the main three I want to talk about are Raiders paladins and Architects and so Sam let's let's start off with you you you had talked in a while and so let's let's get like tell me your design process kind of you already told a little bit about you had this idea for worker investment but give me more give me more behind the scenes about architects of the West Kingdom and how it came to be and then we'll talk you know challenges and that kind of thing right yeah so I'm very much a mechanism kind of guy so if there's a really good mechanic meical hook that is fun that makes you want to come back and play it I I'm stoked and so that's really what I want to work on to start with so I've explained the worker investment mechanism but that's just a mechanism what was the the game going to be uh surrounding it and shim has mentioned
that it was kind of building buildings in the in the medieval times so the workers Gathering resources was the thing that made sense and so we needed to have a fair amount of resources uh so that you have this tension about where you want to put your workers do you want to just invest in one spot and get all the wood in the world cut down all the forests but then you don't have any stone then you don't have any clay and so yeah there there's a tension between spreading out your workers and going hard on one spot and getting more benefit from that one spot then we started to um add in other ideas about could we have this kind of good verse Evil theme running through it this kind of corruption vers virtue kind of thing and that's where we added in the The Virtue track and then there's the black market and the cathedral and so how the virtue track works is throughout the game the decisions that you make you might be doing good things like giving resources to the king at the king Storehouse or you might be working on the cathedral if you make those good decisions you're going to be moving up The Virtue track if you make more kind of uh dodgy decisions if you're playing a little bit more evil then you're going to be dropping down the virtue track so things like robbing the tax stand things like uh going to the black market and the game is going to be played differently for you based on those decisions that you've made so if you've made too many evil decisions now you are locked out of the cathedral they won't accept you there anymore they just won't
let you work on the church and if you're too much of a goodie two shoes you're not allowed into the black market because they think that you might snitch on them so uh this allows for so many different ways of playing people really do feel like they're being a more evil people do feel like they're being the police if they're rounding up everyone else's workers or some people love sitting at the top of the virtue track and just being a goody two shoes always getting their workers out of prison so that was the one of the things and then the final thing we wanted to add was engine building I guess there was a little bit of innate engine building in where your workers are invested but once they're captured you've kind of lost all that progress so that's where we added in the apprentices and these allow for uh more kind of Divergent strategies um and in some play groups they'll be watching that Workshop there's a kind of an area of eight cards and when one of their favorite cards comes into the workshop they all go o ah and they want to rush to grab that that Prince before the others so yeah that's part of the process I'd say yeah the biggest challenge I think for that one for me because I did a lot of the the number crunching behind it all like say with with Raiders it was quite simple because um we we know that at the end of a game a piece of gold in your supply is worth a point so you've got this like kind of um Plum line I guess of what things are worth so I know that if I give up I think there's an action where you can discard two cards to get a gold like oh that means that a card is half a point so you can kind of math it out as I think a lot of designers would
understand that you do this a lot for Euro starle games with Architects it was a real challenge for me because you place a worker which has some kind of value to placing workers like the value of a turn I guess um you place worker at the stone at the Quarry you get a stone your second worker you get two Stone and three stone so had this like how the heck can I balance this game this is bizarre I have to I have to figure out what is the value of a turn um and that was the big challenge I had to run this like um my spreadsheet kind of like well you might get to about three or four on a spot before someone captures you so I had to like get a kind of average of what you're getting on your tun at the spot so I had to I had to figure out what is Stone worth what is wood with and then this additional challenge um on top of that there were things like The Virtue track as well but the other challenge was like the the thing about how Sam's talking about when you spam one location you get lots of wood or lots of stone there has to be some kind of reward or extra cost involved in going to different locations so some cards might require two resources um which is quite easy to get whereas one might require five different resources which spends a lot of different time investing in different spots where to calculate like what is the value of having different resources in cards so that was a that was a big challenge um from a a number crunching side of things for me and Architects yeah now do you normally just use spreadsheets for all your games when you're trying to balance things yeah to to an extent I think we often start just by feel um and then we will really once
we know the game's working we'll then spend some time like crunching the numbers and then playing it a lot more again and then still go by fi at the end of the day gotcha and so when do you really try to balance it I've talked to some designers that that right from the beginning they're trying to Crunch the numbers and make it balance early on some weight to the middle some weight to the end until you know blind play testing basically to worry about balance when do you do it I'd say in the middle um so like I think VI counts which is our latest one that was on Kickstarter recently that has three very different kind of strategic paths you can take and they you blend them together to form your strategy in the game um but that was like there was so many variables in the game that it was hard to balance um so we did a lot of just play it play it play it oh Nobles feel strong let's tweaked them down a bit oh buildings feel weak let bring them up lot of that and then I think once we felt like it was balanced we actually Dove right in and did the math and figured out is it actually balanced and then with that in mind went back into it played it more tweaked it some more and just yeah we that was much more um what's the word kind of organic for us I guess whereas a game like Raiders which is very very simple and contained in its mechanism is so easy to balance just on the on the spreadsheet yeah and there's another issue as well with games like not paladins but with games like Architects and vicant where they've got a variable length of time so the game will end faster depending on how people are playing how that's really hard to balance you know so if everyone and
Architects for example is building the cathedral it's going to be a really really fast game and so the players that play the evil strategy are often not going to do well depending on on how the others are playing if they're playing it quickly but if you play a really long game of people are hoarding their resources and building bigger buildings then the evil player does a lot lot better so yeah I I I like the variable end um the variable end like timer but it does add a few headaches for sure yeah for those who haven't played that game I think a good um example is like aul so in the zul the game triggers when someone finishes a row I think so it's funny you see comments online saying oh I got my I got 110 points well that's very relative to the entire game so like everyone probably scored high in that game whereas you could win with like 45 points if everyone if the game was really short so it makes scorers quite strange because you can't really say oh that's the best score ever because it was variable whereas in paladins which is set to a number of rounds then the scores are like very definitive yeah it could also make your play testing kind of interesting because if you have player scoring 40 points in one game and 110 in the next one it might make you think wow my game must be broken but maybe not maybe it's just the way the end game is structured I say for Architects we had to we had to like check the like how much they won by it was all relative to other players yeah makes a lot of sense now shim tell me about the design process for Raiders of the North Sea tell me about kind of how you came up with the the idea for the the worker placement
and displacement mechanism I don't know if you have a better I call it the up and down system you know I put one down I pick one up every time and so tell me about that game yeah I I like I like the term place and pick think it's quite a good one um yeah so that one was definitely from a I started with the setting first the kind of overall story was that we wanted to go raing so the name was already set before I started designing it basically um so that went through I think it was about eight different game versions uh one of them was like very heavy on your collecting resources um like almost like for SE collecting in the village itself which is more like like stone age or Water Deep um and I think some of the play testing comments I got um well this is winding forward a bit but were like oh I feel like I just want to go out and grab tons of stuff when a raid like I want to go out there and pick up all the stuff off the board and Chuck it in front of me so it was It was kind of inspired by more the feel um the mechanism um so the mean the the place one pick one mechanism was very much like just a spark of an idea that worked um so it wasn't like I was spending tons of time thinking about it just like that that could work but then adding the layers of the different colored workers that can be it kind of add a bit of progression to the game um were were the was one of the other things but the biggest challenge for me in that game was actually does this feel like raing and some people would probably say no it doesn't that's fine because it's a Euro game but like for me it kind of ticks
the boxes as far as how I feel about the game so it's yeah you you spend only a bit of time in the village mainly kind of getting money getting Provisions getting your crew and then it's all about going out and grabbing stuff off the board that's the kind of feel you want um in the game and the last challenge I think in the game for me was the the valkyrie mechanism so in the game there are little tokens on the plunder spots if you take them your crew will die certain number of crew will die one for each um and I think I it's hard to remember I think I had it in the game quite early on but there was no other purpose to it it was just like you died that's it um so I think in very late in the play testing like even after like a bit of public testing I started thinking about hey maybe you can get points for this like the just a a natural ramp of the more you do the more you get kind of thing and I think I try one or two different ideas and landed on the one that was like just a simple track just that you move up and you get more points the higher you go and I think that in the game really helps to reinforce the theme as well of kind of this glory and battle and death and all that kind of stuff um so I guess for me as a designer the biggest challenge for that game was actually coming at it from more of a theme point of view rather than just a mechanisms point of view because I was always about mechanisms leading up to that and always start with hey how can I use this dice differently how can I use cards differently whereas with that game it was my first attempt to go all right the name is Raiders we're going to be raiding what are the mechanisms yeah definitely I want to talk more about theme in just a minute let's uh break down your other game paladins of the West Kingdom this is a
codesign for both of you and so Sam tell me about that one tell me kind of your process there and then sham I'll get your thoughts yeah so again we kind of knew uh sort of vaguely what the theme was going to be we knew that it was going to be the West Kingdom hey look we've built the city now let's defend it you know and this was going to be a great way of tying in potentially the other trilogies shim said to me early on in the piece that hey Raiders was probably the heaviest game in the North Sea game two so how about we make game two a little bit heavier and Architects probably arguably is heavier than uh Raiders so knew that we were going to go quite heavy so that was all the license that we needed uh we were playing around with lots and lots of different ideas but this one that sticked was an idea of having different colored workers not for each player but everyone gets the different colored workers and they're using these workers on their player board to take actions um I found out later that o on kind of had already done that but um so we did a little bit of tweaking just to make sure it didn't feel exactly the same and it doesn't feel exactly the same we've got a draft of workers at the start of each round and then there are there are multiple ideas but one of them was that these Outsiders are coming into the city and so you can either attack them or you can convert them and we just we love multi-use cards so you get an immediate benefit if you attack them and you'll get an a long-term endgame benefit if
you convert them and and what also that does is it adds interaction so let's say that there's a card that would really really benefit shim if he converts it I don't have the faith to be able to convert that person but I could still attack it and make sure that shim can't get that card he would do that too that's pretty much Sam right gotcha now this is the second game that we've talked about so Raiders and paladins both have you know different colored workers that allow you to do different things so shim tell me about that like why is that an interesting mechanism why is that an interesting way to do it you know tell me about the the different colors and what they mean in different games all that I just like that in games I like when the the kind of the the placement mechanism of work placement game is like a shared resource um so Raiders was my first attempt at that you don't really own the workers you share them um it just makes quite a unique feel in a game I guess rather than just like I've got my three guys and I can get two more later on if I try hard um so just changes it up um for us the there was there was a bit of theme behind them they've got like the red so like your Knights your Fighters the greens or your Scouts that kind of stuff um but helped us inform our decisions about what the actions are so to go commission a monk you need like a scout and a cleric U whereas to go and attack you'd need a um I think it's a merchant and a a merchant Trader where they are and like a fighter um so we we we kind of we create this triangle thing in the game which is the whole story in a way
but where um we had to kind of assign workers and resources to the different actions in the game um but the the the colored workers really just they create like a an interesting decision space I guess is what they do if they're all just the same color and they didn't matter then the decisions would be quite boring in the game you just go well I've got three dudes I put the three dudes on the three spot or this spot or that spot whereas now you've got two Reds a blue and a green you want to do two actions that require green but you got one green so which one do you do and what do you do the blue guys for so that creates those interesting decisions which which is really the Crux of what makes Paladin Squad a crunchy game is that it's a really hard puzzle to figure out because there's always multiple things you want to do but you can't do everything but you might if you do something else so it kind of has that that fun puzzle to it yeah definitely I think one of the things going back to the to why people are drawn to these games is that you have actions that I guess you have you have more more to do than you have time to do right and and there's always cool things going on there's always cool choices and even if you get blocked you know even if you're playing a game where you know if you put your guy in that space I really want to go to and I can't go there anymore but there's still two or three other options where I can still keep going so I don't necessarily feel like it doesn't feel like a take that mechanism necessarily it still feels like okay you block me there but I'm going to do this I'm gonna change my strategy a little bit I'm GNA get these resources this turn I'll do that other thing next turn and I feel like it's just a cool way to do it and so when you have a game like like y'all where you have different colors you have different things to think about it's like okay here's some really cool choices and I'm
kind of P puzzling out how I'm going to do and oh you're doing that over there okay in that case I'll do this over here and it's just a really cool decision space for these games Sam would you say that that that's accurate would you say that that is one of the things that draws people in is that something you like about these games yeah absolutely yeah another thing that we we like to add is yeah that kind of multiple paths to Victory you know we you go into Paladin saying maybe I'll try something different this time maybe I'll go down the attack convert sort of path or maybe I'll just go all out commissioning and and the game allows you to do that and you can get points from multiple different areas and I guess you would call it a point salad but people like Point salad for that reason that they've got a lot of agency a lot of choice uh with what they can do yeah now when it comes to a point salid game you know shim a lot of times people get upset because they can't really figure out what they need to do it's like everything scores points and then you know they get to the end of the game and they lose they're like well I don't really know why I lost I did all these things and gained points you you did other things and you gained more points I don't know how that happened and so how do you you know make sure there's lots of pass to Victory lots of different things people can do at the same time players feel like they can create a strategy that they can say okay I won or Lost based on these things I was doing versus just I don't I don't even know where to where to look I've definitely been in that position where I've played a game and just at the end gone why did I lose by like 40 points like you know I kind as even as a designer myself I can't figure out why that's really frustrating and I can understand that people if they don't know their game well enough they will feel that frustration so I totally get
there um and I think as designers we need to be aware of that um so for paladins um that was an issue for us that we had to try and overcome we had it was all working that the puzzle was working really well but we had there was no in a way diversity between players there was no like oh I want to go this strategy or was you want to go this one um the first thing we tried was like hidden agenda cards or hidden goal cards um but that actually made the puzzle worse because you were then there was an Optimum thing you should be doing on your turn but the you should always do this um which actually ruined the game it made it solvable um so we added in there's two things they said two things to to changed it up one thing was that we brought out these public goal cards so in the first round one gets revealed which might be let's say absolve so if you absolve five is it five times in that in that game total game you'll get an extra four points so that gave new players especially something to aim towards um and then the second and third rounds other goals come out you don't have to go for all of them it's quite hard to achieve all of them um but it gave players some kind of Direction they're not forced down that path but they could go down that path and the other thing that we bought them was along with those cards in the later rounds come out these um King's favor cards which become like public worker placement spots um so that was like we're trying to add in tension we're trying to add in Direction and add in a little bit more interaction we kind of solved all those things by adding this like kind of shared line of cards that
get red throughout the game and that seemed to for us at least seemed to fix a lot of the things we had that weren't quite working with the game yeah very cool all right let's uh let's go back to theme just a minute ago shim you mentioned you know trying to add more theme in the games and really trying to bring the Viking theme to life uh Sam what are your ideas on theme because a lot of times Euro games they they get kind of put into the the genre as oh it's just another soulless Euro it's just another you know themeless they just pce it on trading in the Mediterranean this is really a mechanism with some art and that's it so how do you avoid that how do you really bring a theme to life yeah I like to make players feel like they are taking on a certain role and that can be within the game and that can be within the group like just at the table so in Architects there's the capturing mechanism and the the theme kind of almost comes out of the game and it kind of becomes this thing between the players and and so someone takes on the role of being the police but I think it's it's almost comedic in Architects and I think that really suits the the um the art style as well because you've got these characters with these big long noses and bald heads and massive ears and you know everything is kind of disproportionate and and that's kind of yeah it is comedic as I said and and players can do that in the game so they really feel like they are being the policemen or they really feel like they're being the goody Tes um and then you can add that to the medieval setting
which I think it just sort of feels right um yeah so that's kind of my theme contribution is how a players feeling can they take on different roles not necessarily do they feel like a builder but do they feel like they're a part of this world that they're in now gotcha and then shim do you have any other thoughts on bringing the theme to life oh man I get so many comments on this it's it's funny I amount times that I get a comment that says no theme and that's it that's the other comment they'll post about the whole game thank you for the criticism very helpful apprciate feedack so I think it's important well I've kind of discovered over time that for me I like to separate it a bit so I like you have the setting right and then you have your Mech your me mechanisms then you have your theme um so I I'm quite heavy on I guess setting with a underlying story which I think for a lot of people doesn't actually equate to theme um because theme when they're talking about theme often they're talking about immersion so like are you feeling like you're actually in the world doing the stuff whereas for me I it's it's just a personal preference I don't need that in a game I suppose um whereas I like to have an underlying story a setting a good example I guess I talk with my brother uh two days ago about Star Wars right he did not like the latest Star Wars movie at all he he said the story was so weak it was horrible whereas I was like I love that world I love being in that world just the imagery the characters I don't need a really strong
uh connecting story and I think it's just a difference of people um so I think an important thing to remember as a designer you need to design games that you want to play um but also know that you can't please everyone um I Heard a really good podcast that you did um we we had a road trip up north a few uh months back one of the I can't remember which one it was but you had someone on talking about there's like four aspects of a player it was like um play and tactile stuff and other things that was a really good episode um talking about how different players need different things from games and it's important to try and meet those if you can but you can't always meet all four so yeah I think if you're going to make Euro games like we kind of do just know that people who love chucking Dice and you know playing the villain or or whatever they they might they probably never going to like your game at all so you just have to accept that and make games that you love to make um but I think you still need need to serve them as much as you can so there is a lot of theme put behind our games but that is often more story uh more sorry more setting and more kind of purpose and reason for mechanisms uh less than it is like that kind of immersion into the theme itself yeah definitely and that episode is four types of gamer experiences with Ian Zang and so yeah it's such a great episode if you're trying to get into your your players heads so to speak and really trying understand how people work why they are drawn to different games
different things happening in games that's a really good episode as far as like player psychology and so I definitely recommend people checking that one out all right let's switch gears let's talk a little bit about victory points so I mean the vast majority of of worker placement games uh require victory points they that's how you win that's what you're trying to do during the game you're trying to do different things in order to gain victory points so you can beat everybody else and so how do you figure out victory points how do you figure out how much things are worth how do you figure out kind of the the scales of different things you know if I have one of this it's worth one point if I get two it's worth three you know how do you how do you figure those things out so Sam what what's kind of your process for for determining how much things are worth how people win that kind of thing yeah I um I just start by obsessing over it and thinking about it in my head like crazy and then later on Chim will go to the spreadsheet but I I kind of want every single strategy to be viable and I know that actually many game designers don't do that for example with ag gria I might be wrong I haven't played it enough but I don't think you can afford to not feed your family I think you have to feed your family you can't you can't take all those negative points see I want to play a game when I can play a strategy without feeding my family that sounds horrible but I there has to be a risk to that but I want to be able to do that and so that's how we look at things like The Virtue track and and architect where it says hey hey don't go down here too
far it's trouble but you can actually come out of it so yeah I think it starts for me with a lot of obsessing and then we hit the spreadsheets and then we play and play and play and and when I play test I don't just try and win I it's like I heard someone say this analogy it's like when you're going to look at a house if you're looking to by the house you walk up to all the walls and all the and all the doors and you're you're checking everything out to to really fine details if you're going to a friend's house you'll just have a look around and say this is a nice house so when we play test we want to you know try everything out things that shouldn't work things that might work things that other people would think of that you might not normally think of and we'll just test those and then after the game we'll we'll be like did I deserve to win I won that game but did I deserve to win or I thought I should have scored higher than what I did CU I felt like I played well and then we'll tweak um the games based on that as well based on feel very cool and so shim tell me your side of thing especially with the spreadsheets and and you figuring out how much things are worth tell me about victory points yeah I mean what Sam said there at the very was like exactly how we do test we we get the end of our games and we go do I feel like I did well do I feel like I deserve to win that's actually a really good thing to ask yourself you testing games I think um because often you might get to game and go I feel like I should have won that everyone felt at the table I was winning you know and why didn't I um or you get to the game in the game and you
go oh I won really I felt like I was doing really bad and so that's a good thing to dive into um the other side that the spreadsheets I don't know I feel like that's the easy part and unless it's game Architects where there's this like Dynamic scale of numbers just figuring out what things are worth is quite easy and if you don't know how basically find something that's you already have a point assigned to in a game like I was saying in Raiders one gold is worth a point so you've got this Plum line and then base everything around off that so if you like an arch R sorry if you have an action that says discard two cars to get a gold which you know is a point then you now know that a card is half a point so there's really easy ways to figure out around that I mean there are yeah there are games that are harder to figure out but if it's a simple kind of resource conversion Style game then that's a really simple way of doing it gotcha and now shim what are your thoughts as far as open scoring versus closed scoring you know some games you can look around the table and you know exactly how many points people have you might to do a little math in your head but you can still figure out okay I'm 10 points down whereas other games a lot of it's closed you're like okay I think I'm winning or I might be looting you're not entirely sure until the endgame scoring tell me your thoughts as far as open vers closed yeah so personally I prefer right in the middle um or more towards mainly clo mainly open sorry um so Dominion is what I would say is almost 100% closed which I can't stand because you get to the end the game and go all right who won oh you did oh well done like no one really knew who was winning there's no track there's
no way of knowing um whereas other games where it's all public information you suddenly realize in the last round oh I can't win there's no way I can win I know everything that's available why do we bother with the last round and that's just not fun so I think you need a bit of both to make a game really work all right so Sam let's keep talking about Victor points let's talk about endgame as far as like how the Game ending gets triggered how do you how do you figure that out what makes sense based on the different theme different game all those kind of things what what are you thinking about when you're designing a game as far as like how is this game going to end I mean you could do a certain number of rounds you could do a you know it's almost like a race to get to a certain endgame Trier whatever tell me your your process yeah so we actually often start uh when we design we don't design the end game straight away we'll just be testing this game and we'll just go an arbitrary number of rounds or however it works and decide okay we've we we know enough now and so it's something that we do a little bit later on in the piece my preference is that the the um the game time can vary and that like a game like Scythe for example that that can vary because what I like is for players to adapt to how others are playing so then they can't calculate in round one two and three I always do this rounds four five six I must do this and then round seven and eight I always do this it's a little bit more Dynamic if you can make it like that um and also the the other benefit to not having rounds is that it generally will flow faster if you don't have a sort of a
reset phase so if the game is going to vary then you kind of look at what are some of the big actions that players do and we we'll have a set number of those actions so in Raiders I know I didn't design it but in Raiders it makes sense that the game is got going to end either by number of raids um I think it's on the fortresses or number of offering tiles that have been taken um those are kind of the big Point scoring actions so we'll give players a certain number of those and then we'll end the game after that that many so that allows players to actually go out for it and to rush and to apply pressure on others but they can also take it slow and they can s kind of handshake on it a little bit oh you're not going to build a building in architects in the Guild Hall I won't build a building either and we'll both just slowly gather up our resources um and then there'll be a bit of a mad rush towards the end and a attention there and um and wanting to kind of maximize your last few actions yeah gotcha shim what are your thoughts yeah I think that's that's exactly it um I do know that with Architects like Sam said we didn't actually have the end game planned um there was nothing that we designed early on so that was like oh how do we finish this game um when you've played games like S one or citadels it's always about having a certain number of buildings in your Tableau um and so we kind of like that idea in Architects so there is there's like building cards but then there's a public Cathedral that you can all contribute if you want to so we thought well we can't
have like a game where once someone gets to the top of the cathedral the game ends because no one might do that so we ended up creating this Guild Hall area in the game where every time you do either a building or a cathedral action you place a worker and then we're like well there's our timer it's a certain number of workers placed in the guild wall yeah I've got one more thing to add also about um ingame is that you kind of want it to be that players can do almost almost everything that they wanted to do and maybe maybe about 5% of the time they actually can do everything that they wanted to do so that it's kind of it's possible but it's just Out Of Reach and so then they say okay I'm going to try that strategy again and if I just do this little action earlier then I might be able to get everything done that I wanted to um by the time the game ends it's all about T CH yeah yeah yeah I've heard other designers talk about how they want their game to end right before the people at the table want it to end so it doesn't overstay it's welcome and then it also a lot of times leads people into wanting to play it play it again they want to say okay what if I do this strategy a little bit differently or or change it up because they weren't able to kind of fully complete it the way they wanted to yeah now you've mentioned play testing a little bit let's go a little bit deeper into your specific play testing process shim what are some of you're looking for how do you know that one of these games is really working the way that you wanted to what what are you writing down in your notes as you're watching play testers that kind of thing so we're it's funny I
think it's part of being in New Zealand Sam and I are quite different I think to a lot of other sort of uh what do you say like the the norm I guess so a lot of our testing is actually just us um so just two of us in a room playing our game over and over again making small tweaks um we won't even show it to people for for months probably um so that's I know that's very different than what most people tell you it just depends on your situation I suppose if you've got access to a lot of people which no one does currently um then you can you can quite easily like play the game on a weekly basis with different people and that's that's great one one thing that I do find about that though is that you're going to get a lot of strange weird wonderful suggestions which can be good but it can be hard to filter whereas for us um I think when it's just us we can bounce back quite fast ideas and spit stuff quite quickly and make changes a lot faster um I think a lot of that though um is a little bit of it sounds arrogant so I'll just say it but um it's kind of like a maturity as a designer so you start to really it's not just that it's confidence as well but knowing that you are capable of making a good game um and it's hard for like the first five or 10 years a designer you're always questioning yourself if I if you should be doing this or not but eventually it does get easier and you start to really trust your own gut quite a bit um so we do a lot of internal testing um and then once we're ready once we feel like we need more players then we'll expand it out and then um we'll do a lot more public testing but to be honest we actually
don't do that much public testing um we show it to a lot of designers that we know locally and then we'll just have our own kind of bubbles of friends that will play the game um yeah so a little bit different to be honest samim do you have anything to add as far as your thoughts on play testing I just I totally agree with shim that's just what works for us it might not work for some of you listeners but it works for us that we kind of obsess over it and I'm thinking about our games all the time I think it helps to really really try and this is hard to do as a human but to not be biased to almost take off your own lenses and say if this was someone else's game would I like it is this a good game if this was anyone's design not my design if this was anyone's designed would I like it and if you can be honest with yourself and say no this is actually bad it's not that good or yeah this has got potential that that'll help you a lot if you can do that and then you start to kind of figure out what's missing what do I need to fix what doesn't need to be there um and just be really critical kind of with your own designs um then you don't need other people to be as critical because you're the first person to do that yeah now let's talk player count real quick so some of your games go 2 to four some 1 to four some 1 to five so shim tell me about you know figuring out the the best player count tell me about solo modes you know trying to make your game accessible for just one player tell me about that I think if I could for like at least for this like medieval kind of sitting of games I would probably make
them one to four um simply because now that we've been doing it a while we realize that solo is really important but also great for testing purposes but um with with a four Max then you can easily do like a a five player expansion if you want to down the line and it keeps the game length often at a at a shorter period for four players whereas like like shipes back then I was like yeah let's make it five players but now looking back I go well that's a really long game so it kind of it can ruin some people's experiences if they play at the full player count when it shouldn't really be at the full player count um but uh was I going to say um with Architects that was a bit of a real one because we actually felt the game shined at five and six players so that was like well I don't want to do six players in the box cuz that's going to make the game really expensive and not probably not fit too well in the Box um so we kept it at five with the hope that we'd be a to do a six expansion at some point um but that's just for any game you kind of figure out what is the the ideal Play account um can you make it solo if you can you should probably do it if you've got the time and the energy to do it but then that that high limit I think a lot of that comes in from a publishing point of view like what is the price point of the game what is the the market of the you know the what is the target for the game but also um it comes down to that player experience so I mean an example say citadels that plays I think it's 3 to seven in the Box I think eight with the expansion that game varies heavily
on play count so you're going to get a very different experience in different play counts and I think I don't know I think in today's market you got to be a bit wary of that you want to give a very similar um I guess experience at different play accounts very similar across all play accounts whereas back in the day Pro wasn't much of an issue as much um that's just something to be aware of as a designer is go what where does this game shine um and then and then like yeah highlight on that I suppose so we we probably could have almost capped Architects at like a three to five if we wanted to but we knew that we could Implement a good solo mode so we went right down to solo for that one yeah and tell me more about creating a solo mode for a worker placement game because I feel like it's going to be a little bit different than you know an action game an adventure game or something Sam that's probably more you yeah um we love we love designing solo modes it's super fun and this actually ties back into the testing question as well I'll just add this first is that we design a solo mode now quite early on in the piece and that allows us to do a lot of testing and a lot of different strategies as well so for Vi counts what we did is we designed four different AIS um and each of them did a kind of a different strategy in the game and we got to see if they were balanced when playing them against each other so that was helpful but if you're wanting to design a solo mode in your game first off you need to ask this question where are the points of interaction in the game so write down a
little list so start off with maybe blocking with workers it start off with um you know if there's cards drafting those cards uh always there's always going to be victory points as well that's a point of interaction can you win can you lose that sort of thing and so you want to write down all of those points and if possible your AI needs to be able to do all of those things and do them cleverly do them like how a human would do them so that the the AI can really get in your way that they can feel like a player that is blocking you that is taking the actions that you're wanting to do so you write those down first uh with with worker placement it's actually easier than than some games cuz you can create a little uh deck of cards we call them scheme cards and those cards can tell you where the AI is going to place their worker or where they're going to block or those sorts of things and then the other thing I like to do is to let the AI ramp up over time because normally human players will ramp up they'll get stronger and stronger over time so the AI usually will need a way of doing that and so we kind of often will make it deck build so it's got another uh deck of cards that are better and over time it's adding those into its deck of scheme cards to get stronger and stronger definitely well gentlemen this has been awesome do you have any closing thoughts shim anything that you want to leave listeners with as far as designing worker placement games you know especially if someone they're sitting there they're listening to this they're thinking gosh I want to design one of these or maybe I've been working on one
I'm stuck you know what would you tell somebody kind of as a closing thought I think just try something fresh like I'm I often if I get stuck with stuff I'll just grab out a bunch of components on my desk and just look at them and just move them around and just kind of think just stare at them for like an hour or something and just think how could they use these differently and um I think it's just trying to find those Sparks so I think just yeah just try and think look look at games you like ones that do things differently and go okay they did that differently uh can I do something like that can I do something different uh and just really try and find that that freshness in the mechanism rather than just trying to do what someone else has already done try and find something new and unique yeah you and I are very similar in our design process I feel like half of my design time is just staring ing at stuff sitting on the table not moving maybe not even blinking barely breathing you know my wife has walked in she's hey hey she snap her fingers you know do you have a stroke are you okay no I'm fine I'm just I'm figuring out something leave me alone you know so I'm a big fan of just staring at stuff until the the idea comes out Sam what about you you get any closing thoughts I love talking to people so I've got shim and I've got another friend where I'll just talk about ideas like would this work would would there be a game where you use dice that that um the number means you go a different direction on a hexagon say I use that in cadians and just talk it through because the the person might then say oh yeah yeah but what if you did this and you can kind of bounce off each other so I find that really really
helpful if you've got fellow nerds that love to just talk mechanisms you know talk novel kind of ideas because the combination of ideas will make something unique I think because it can be quite hard just going at it alone so yep find some fellow nerds that love talking game design with you and and you can do it online you can do it on messenger if you're stuck at home that's like it's like two months of our development okay Sam like before we even play a game we spend about two months just split balling ideas yeah awesome well sham you got a game on Kickstarter right now it's actually from a different company than your own publishing company and so tell me a little bit about that one yeah so shelfie stacker is a little dice abstract game that I created um which I knew didn't really fit the GLE games brand so I had some it's quite funny I had these friends I had pitched the game to a couple Publishers um with no luck with different theme and different kind of things going on and then I had these friends that are creating this new Publishing Company who are all well one of them still at where to Workshop one's exw to Workshop um and I thought hey hang on I've got this game that might actually fit your brand quite well because they want to do fairly um easy access kind of games with really incredible artwork um and and fun themes so I took this game to them they really enjoyed it they played around a lot with the theme um and they end uping this game game where it's basically about trying to fit your board games onto your shelf um so it's a really fun meta kind of game but it's it's uh the game itself is like a a seven round game where you play cards to determine turn order they give you powers for the game and you're trying to fit these dice with different
Pips into that your shelf with certain uh rules around colors and numbers and that kind of stuff so it's a really fun crunchy little game very cool and like I said it's on Kickstarter right now well gentlemen really appreciate your time really appreciate you coming on the show good luck with all the the the more worker placement games I know you have in the works and everything else you got going on right now thank you thanks for having us thanks so much it's been a
privilege