Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beyond Solitaire Podcast 70: Mary Flanagan on Games that Change Minds

Transcript 47:44

hey gamer's quick add break as you probably know by now the beyond solitaire podcast is proudly sponsored by central michigan university's center for learning through games and simulations and that is a project that i'm super excited about because i believe that learning through play is the best way to do it and the clgs is making it happen in college classrooms and hopefully high school ones part of that initiative is a games press if you want to back their first successful kickstarter project pre-orders for monumental consequence by dr marybeth looney are open now and keep an eye out for rising waters designed by dr scout bloom this is an upcoming game about the mississippi flood of 1927 one of the worst natural disasters in american history and i will be interviewing dr bloom about it on this podcast in the coming weeks thanks so much and let's get started with the show hey gamers this is liz davidson from beyond solitaire and this week on the pod i have a very special guest i have mary flanagan she is a gamer extraordinaire she's a professor of digital humanities at dartmouth and uh i'm delighted to have you how are you doing today mary i am great thank you thank you so much liz so why don't you give us just the overview of the many gaming projects that you are currently involved in oh wow wow the key points well i i just submitted a book manuscript so that is a studies of games a book manuscript with my colleague at mit michael jacobson and it's called

playing oppression board games and colonialism so we did a deep dive into contemporary games and also historic games that have colonialist themes and also mechanics and that's where things get kind of interesting if you're um into uh game studies in general like unpacking the history of certain kinds of game mechanics is not something that's done that often and so we we do some of that in that book so that was just hot off the hands into the editor's hands and so um that's that's just recently finished um i'm running a kickstarter right now um it's uh for a game called retrograde which is a real-time roland right uh in an 80s arcade theme so you're like you have these like little droid creatures on dye and you're kind of trying to uh blast your little arcade looking cabinet filled with droids and there's a lot of there's strategy and other stuff going on in there so it may be one of the first if not the first um real-time role in rights which is interesting um it's uh anyway you never want to claim absolutely because there's always something that we don't know um anyway we're in development for a couple other games this year um and uh so i'm doing a lot of board game stuff right now uh which is great with my company called resinim yes so you have been involved in both board and video games oh yeah extensively so is wrestling focused specifically on

board games yes resident resident is focused specifically on board games i started off as a digital game designer and ended up at around in the 1990s and so i ended up around 2010 doing a board game with some of my students in my research lab and that ended up kind of spawning this whole new um new area of of work in my life so i i've done like one two three we're also oh we also have a game called phantom inc which is a party game based on spiritualists and spirits and mediums which is awesome um it is a great fun to play and that one's just being uh released to retail right now so so there's so we're quite busy quite active with with the company i also recently because it was during the pandemic last year slash this year released a game called surrealist dinner party and you play real world surrealists at dinner table and they at a dinner table and they're like having drama or giving compliments and you have to feed them their wine or their desserts or whatever and meet their needs and send them home and um send them back to the dinner party so it's there's a kind of a dinner party simulation with surrealists oh my goodness and uh and uh you also are you still doing work with tilt factor oh yes yes i i founded tilt factor in 2003 believe it or not so it's like wow i've been doing that a long time and yeah it's uh you know the pandemic has slowed down some of my research teamwork uh and my boardgame company's been very

busy but we are working with the national academy of sciences on a game to promote scientific thinking um and especially evidence gathering and so we're doing a board game with them so that's cool too yeah so there's all kinds of research going on we just finished a vr project too that is released on steam for free uh through so if you look for tilt factor on there um you can find our vr escape the room game that we did a research study on and you can read about the research study on our website so yeah lots of stuff lots you know what i think being busy is a good thing uh so you know your research you mentioned gaming and research together obviously you're a professor this is what you study but um your underlying driving force seems to be that games can affect social change uh is that still the purpose behind all of these newer releases as well yeah so so more or less um certainly at the the i founded resinim as a way to kind of commercialize some of the things that were going on in my research lab and didn't have any any output for so you know as soon as publishers would hear oh a game that you know possibly might make you less racist oh gosh you know that's controversial which is too bad um so we ended up kind of getting banding together you

know i was like i'm going to start a publishing company and we're going to publish this stuff so we started with publishing our well-researched games sometimes now we use some of the same principles but we're not necessarily doing full-blown research studies in part because they're very expensive they're very expensive and time-consuming especially when you are at a small liberal arts college in the northeast um if you're trying to do research with students and stuff that we just don't have a critical mass so getting enough data takes a long time and often involves multiple institutions um so it's it's it's it's an interesting uh context in which to do studies especially when you're looking at social psychological social psychology aspects of of uh gaming yeah but this does lead to the question of how could a game make a person less racist how does it work okay so there's no like one oh i have an answer you know it's not like one answer right but certainly we have found for example in this game we have a game called buffalo and um it it gives you unexpected combinations so you might of a of a of a person and a a descriptor for example so you might pull up a card it says wizard and then it says british and you might say oh uh you know harry potter you know okay that's not rocket science right but once you say harry potter you can never use harry potter again in the game and then you might have something else that's like chemist

woman and you're like ah i have to name a female chemist do i know a female chemist does marie curie count because she's always the person that everyone says anytime there's anything about women in sciences like marie curie and uh you know so so but one of the theories behind this is even if you can't come up with um uh uh in iranian video game designer off the top of your head depending on your context because of course if you were in a red you might actually come up with the the answer but in in another context you might not but just the idea of of being confronted with a combination that you don't you like that does not compute is actually really helpful because it it in theory i mean we have no evidence to look at our we haven't done mri studies on this but in theory it kind of disrupts your the pattern of stereotypes right it it it it's kind of oh when i think of a novelist you know i have an unconscious bias in my head um and now that bias is a little bit shaken up even if i can't name another person there's this idea that on a subconscious level you're breaking up that stereotyping process um at least that's one hypothesis to our data um but the data did show we used um different measures that are vetted for measuring discrimination and this idea of social identity complexity which is how complex you kind of can't accept or see the

world like as a set of contradictions so instead so social identity complexity i could say oh i'm a scientist and you might have an idea in your head but if you say oh i'm a scientist i also uh am a i sing opera at night and i play ping pong uh competitively uh that though that's a more complex identity and um so it kind of expands how we see the world a little bit and kind of makes us a little more accepting right it's like oh yeah sure of course you're blah blah blah blah right so expanding the world and expanding this idea of social identity complexity is a really good thing when you're thinking about ideas about uh uh racism um bias in general uh we you know if you're if you're trying to address those issues you want to expand how we think about other people and not reduce people to caricatures and stereotypes so in other words board games are a way to create exposure to new ideas to new types of people to potential identities even if it's not anybody in particular and that's what you are taking advantage of when you are creating games that are supposed to be change agents that's one aspect um thinking about identity thinking about representation that's that's only one aspect sometimes we stop there when we think about diversity and and inclusion and social justice or whatever sometimes we think we stop at you know

like a kind of certain kind of identity but there are other kinds of thinking that also help expand the way we see the world and so that it's really i games i mean a lot of the his historians and anthropologists about games have looked at them as ways that humans rehearse themselves in the world right so they're rehearsal sites it doesn't mean that they're actually training you to be one way or another but after gosh you know almost 20 years of research in the field i have to say that i am surprised how malleable we are at you know before and after an intervention when you see the kind of you know statistically significant changes you're like wow everything we're experiencing is kind of you know moving us around a little bit and and and that's that's kind of that's kind of surprising actually so essentially increasing exposure to new ideas through games does in fact work in the sense that it has an impact on how people see the world after play according to what i've studied yes oh i like it so i guess my next question then is so i'm a teacher i think about this all the time when i'm trying to do fun stuff with my students in the classroom but also get them to learn at the same time it's like having to be really careful about how i set up my fun because the more i guess hand-fisted it is the

less it works you have to make sure that the fun part happens and that they don't feel preached to so how do you manage that in games that you know you are explicitly designing as a study of how of how mindsets change liz that's a very that's a very astute um uh observation we play has to be free right it's one of the definitions of play by anthropologists like brian sutton smith or johann hoisingha you you have to enter into it voluntarily you have to be free you have to be able to make meaningful choices right um all of these things if you're saying okay i'm gonna make you play this game that's teaching you this it's not really embodying any of those values right so you have so it's really difficult that's why a lot of people do it because um you know to do it well it's really really difficult i've had 20 years 30 years or whatever a lot of years of trying to figure this out and it's there's no one easy uh solution you know it's not a pattern that you can follow but what i can say is that sometimes and that that that feeling that you're getting um like the resistance it's called psychological reactants it's like okay no that's like you're causing you know i'm shutting that down too much i'm not doing that no way like there's this kind of uh refusal happening and so what you're trying to

do is get around psychological reactants right and that happens also by the way not just in games but let's say let's say for example um you have uh a documentary film and it's about it's featuring poor people in a faraway place and and and it's really difficult and life is really challenging and you might be like wow wow that's really you know how can we help what can we do i mean we see you know we could also talk about current events and feel that same oh my gosh what can we do but you might have a documentary and it's showing your neighbor next door or people on your street having the same kind of problems or someone who's homeless and uh is you know right next door and you might be like well you know they should get a job or they should you know sometimes people react to things that are too close by shutting it down because it's too close and you it's like an overload and that that's where this whole theory of i'm simplifying this for all of you psychologists out there but i apologize but but it it is a it is a way in which you know we react and we are open to things literally psychological distance literally further away or further away in terms of fiction right so we did this one set of studies with this game called pox and it was a board game it was an app a digital game and we did a version that was a board game that was zombie themed okay

so we've got this like spread of disease on the board you're trying to contain the disease it's it's um it actually came out right around the time that pandemic came out but it's a super simplified version of of of of of a pandemic and we studied this game in a variety of contexts and um with pairs of players who were randomly assigned another and it was very systematic throughout the different conditions and it was really wild because when people had the digital game in between them and they were playing the digital game people spoke less to each other they lost the game more often significantly and they um and they actually had lower scores on some of these things like would you you know like a like a survey would you give money to a you know a public health group or something like this so so so we had different kinds of measures and they did not perform very strongly and the group that performed the strongest was the zombie group okay so we learned a lot through that we actually learned a lot sometimes being open to a zombie apocalypse actually opened people's minds to thinking about well how would i sell public health it wasn't threatening you know to to think about it because it's fiction no one employed any of this kind of research in the handling of the pandemic um which is a bummer because

you know everyone's like how do we get people to wear masks how do we get people to think about getting vaccinated and no one really used psychological um uh principles uh to the extent that we we know about we know a lot about how we react to narratives first-person versus third-person narratives you know there's different ways to tell stories that are more or less effective and we we actually know a lot about that as a society but very little of that of that research actually translated into the way in which um for example our public health messaging happened so there's a lot of lost opportunities where research doesn't actually get into the hands of people making decisions uh and and um you know people's lives are at stake sometimes and it's really quite disturbing so that involves games but it also involves other kind of messaging as well yeah i'm interested also that story has come into this so what i'm hearing from what you said is that um people do have the ability to change their minds about things or open up their mindset but being very blatant about what exactly you're asking like you need to go outside and wear a mask you need to go and get a shot that's not going to be as effective as let me tell you this story about zombies that you really identify with and get into and then let's see how you feel about taking a measure you know in our world now i mean is that what i'm hearing that people actually

respond better when they've had time to think away from the reality of the problem but like something that's adjacent yeah people's minds can change when they when they consider some of these some of these like fictional stories for example um also if uh i mean there are also other things like you know policies that require something you know i mean there are other ways you know but we because we've you know the united states has done that in the past we've actually had you know required vaccinations but but if you're really trying to deal with motivation um then we do have to think about what are ways that we could approach so yes having stories my um uh my collaborator jeff kaufman who's now at carnegie mellon has he did this really great research about voting and he had students read you know like short stories about why someone really couldn't get to vote they couldn't get to out there but then finally they did and whoever read different stories that the conditions were quite interesting and he was actually able to track who voted because the voting records were open in that um in that jurisdiction that he was doing the research study and he was able to find that people who read a story first person about overcoming the difficulties who was like them who was more like the students and that's very interesting so someone like you who you can identify with making decisions um

uh as even as a fictional thing was very very interesting so there's a lot we don't know about for example games help us be like a lot of people talk about oh vr it makes us more empathetic you get to stand in someone's shoes not necessarily we don't have a whole ton of evidence that that is always the case when you when you are in vr you might feel reactants you might feel forced to look at something that you didn't want to look at you might we don't know so so i think we have to just you know assume very little and approach these things with open minds and say wow you know and and do the research specifically about storytelling and narrative as it relates to psychological change it's really fascinating stuff my my collaborator melanie green also works in this area and it's it's amazing stuff she's at university of buffalo oh my god this has so many implications for everything i'm just faster yes yes it does the other thing that makes me sad about this actually is that you know the emphasis on story and fiction and it actually having impact it's something that i feel the loss of in our day-to-day conversations about what is important um you know i'm really big on reading novels and on playing games and i feel that in a way a lot of those things are kind of downgraded in our culture in favor of facts and just give me the facts and i can do my research but it seems to me that that's actually not necessarily the thing that's going to have the most impact on what you

choose to do do you face pushback as a researcher because of that and how do you know because we we have facts about the fiction so we spell the facts true if we just hypothesize yes we would people would just be very upset but um yes we actually have research studies where we can actually show these things but of course you know that's also just to play devil's advocate on research right like that's social science how social science measures things humanities folks measure things in a very different way it's about argument it's about you know perspective it's about even the language you use and the analysis and the close reading and semiotics and marxist feminists queer you know like we could we have totally different ways of analyzing right and coming up with facts so that's also very interesting as uh someone who sits between creative fields scientific fields and humanities like there's a they're very different kind of ways that that uh information is valid um yeah but that takes us right back to the idea of stories as inherently true in a way that other things don't strike us as true so how very translated very powerful how do you translate all this into a classroom i mean you've got this whole you've got this amazing research life

um yeah how do games make it into your classes well i'm i'm fortunate enough to teach um at dartmouth college where i i'm able to design my classes the way the way i'd like and so i often teach my game design class as almost a rapid prototyping um you know i don't want to say boot camp because it's militaristic and it's not really the way it is but it's like a kind of a rapid fire uh prototyping lab where every week i assign a new problem for example design a game that tackles uh anxiety what you know really hard things you know or like uh yeah it's some of them are very hard so um or bullying how do you reduce bullying with a game could you could you do that is that possible how could we um uh promote reproductive rights in the game how could one you know so so students have to prototype something and they and it often is kind of a rough prototype because they have a week and in a week you learn a lot about what works and what doesn't you what i'm trying to do is almost have people learn to fail because part of any kind of change and being able to do this stuff well is to be able to throw things out it's it's just as valuable to see what doesn't work as what does work

right like so so all of that is very important so you know sometimes people get really um really uh stuck on an idea and it's like ah this will be my magnum opus and i will have this my vision is for and it's like let's just make a little thing let's just let's just get it like just get it try it try stuff try stuff low investment because that that you can let it go when it doesn't work and that it's much better to have like this kind of iterative um pattern uh pattern language develop so yeah that's how i i teach i you know and we read studies but but i often just bring in researchers to talk about it because really if you hand out all of these scientific papers some students are really going to bond with that and other students will be like i have no idea what this does how this relates to world of warcraft i cannot make that leap i am not you know i i you know you just can't you know and or or i'll have the like the one student who's like a dwarf fortress person you know none of this relates to dwarf fortress you know so how do you so yeah we have to kind of be uh it's it's it's more like a taste of of iteration and rapid prototyping but certainly certainly you can use games as a way to explore you know life and and and playing them and even

looking at their development practices and looking globally right because what we're lucky enough right now to be having a a a global uh connection with so many people through crowdfunding and through um through you know steam being so available and other places we can get digital games you know further and faster than ever before and we can also find all of these you know unique developers with unique points of view uh coming out of like kickstarter and these uh these other communities um that's great we we wouldn't have had those games uh you know 10 years ago so i'm very excited about the state of games and play right now yes there's actually a couple directions i could take this but i'm going to start here which is i think it's really interesting you're mentioning you know kickstarter crowdfunding you know i think a lot of academics see their work as within the university setting and within academic circles how do you think that your work is impacted by the fact that you're clearly very much between worlds you're you're doing work and you're taking information and you're marketing your work in in spheres that are not considered traditionally academic does that change the way that you approach your work and the impact that you think it's going to have wow um that's a great question i um i always try to contribute to academic learning and growth with scholarly articles reviewing scholarly

articles giving presentations about the work you know uh writing both from this more scientific points of view and from the humanities points of view about games and play and and um inclusivity and this kind of stuff i try to contribute there but it's never been enough for me to stay within academia because i um i make things also as an artist right so i i show things in art galleries and then in museums around the world and so i i end up with a totally different group of people like i go to gen con and that is of not and then i'm like at the museum of contemporary art in barcelona okay and they're like okay you know like these are very different worlds i like that continuity continuity though because it means that people are engaging with ideas in different ways and they're all equally valid and unique and interesting ways but they're different audiences and so sometimes my work this is a question i got recently at a talk i gave is like a student was like how do you decide whether an idea is art or whether it's a game or whether it's a research project and i was like wow wow yeah that's a good question i don't have like a chart you know where i'm like looking it up they're like okay well that idea it's just kind of how my brain works like for example i have these here i'll show you i have these here's something you know like here

here's two here are two things i have visual aids for you all right so i have these like rubik's cubes that i've been making let's say yes so for those of you listening that was a rubik's cube with letters on the faces that said we in right and then this one try to describe that so now we are looking at a rubik's cube where the letters it's not one letter per cube they're like bunched up at weird angles and sometimes like cross cubes yeah like jumbled jumbled uh and this it all says we and various things okay so that is that a game is that art um you know i i don't really think about that i i just make it you know what are games aren't really separate well in some ways they are um well in the sense of in the sense of is it a visual art piece and only only generally through audience um and um since you like ancient history i'm gonna even go back way before um ancient christianity and we're going back okay we humans you know and proto-humans right not just humans cro-magnon whatever created artworks right like people like it's not just humans who created artwork artwork was created by all kinds of humanoid um uh folks but we also played games and sang music right so so i think of games and play as

kind of in this er form like we have visual art you have sound and music we have story and narrative and we have game it's kind of in that cloud right it's that level game and play because playfulness can can you know can be gamey and and so i think sometimes we forget that like it's like oh well it's i'm playing this video game it's media it's pictures it's moving it's animation it's this and and no it's actually an er art form it's referring it's not you know medium specific but the art form about a system with rules that there's a winner or a loser or as a tie or there's a negotiation of power or there's a you know like that's an abstract space that is um really interesting and i wish we had more artifacts that were ancient to be able to explore this stuff um further but you know when i think about these cards i've developed right like i have this artificial intelligence that i trained on the work of women artists so it only produces work from this kind of point of view of women artists that's a another long story but um i so then i start printing out some of these um these images of these artificial intelligence generated clouds right so i have these i have this card deck of clouds and i'm like this is a game is this an

artwork like i don't know what this is yet so this is just like a prototype of something i know i wanted it to be like a physical object but where it goes from there it you know it could go in either direction of being something more conceptual and open-ended um which i would say something like the jumbled rubik's cube would be right that's kind of not really it is solvable but is that the point um or is it asking a set of open-ended questions or troubling or or being critical about or reflecting on what a what a game or play space is so yeah really really oh here's another you know you asked me a recent thing and i totally forgot this book that i that i um i just put out last year and we had a book launch in berlin and then omicron and pandemic went really deep deep out so we weren't able to do very many events but it's a a book of my hopscotches that i've been creating for 20 years possibly over 20 years and it's in three languages and it and i describe their instructions for various hopscotches and they start off very kind of poetic and and um uh what do you want to call it like kind of abstract and poetic and then they go into kind of critical stuff um things about um uh

income uh inequality uh uh state violence this kind of thing so an early version of this would be city scotch draw rooms on top of rooms on top of rooms so that's an instruction and people are given chalk and they do something with it and um think about it what it what it means and so this is a little handbook for these kind of abstract um abstract hopscotches and i'm bringing that up because again is that it's not really even medium specific it's a conceptual space of using a game as a conceptual space and that um that really interests me no matter how it comes out i find this really fascinating it seems like in your own art it's it's very exploratory like you have an instinct maybe and you follow it and kind of see what happens uh whereas you know i mean and this is obviously gonna have to happen you know in a self-contained class uh you're asking your students to design games that have specific purposes reducing anxiety fix bullying make people open to vaccines i don't know if you've actually done so how do you i guess reconcile making a game with a specific social purpose with games in that more artistic exploratory space well this goes back i think it's a really great question and some schools of thought

really separate ideas of art from ideas of design right and a shorthand for this and most many people might not agree with this but a shorthand for this has been designers solve problems artists cause problems right designers are thinking here's the problem here's here's how i'm going to move around in that space um artists might think uh here's where i'm you know it's like a top-down bottom up maybe kind of kind of uh approach but that's really a rough rough rough way of thinking about it and probably in practice most designers and most artists probably don't do that so so it's it's these are real weird generalities but certainly if you were going to an industrial design firm and you said i need a you know a chair that's like going to do this and it helps me stand up and i you know if i like want to have a chair designed for a particular ability you know that's a there's a problem to solve right and when i'm saying oh gosh uh we we want to have a game that tries to uh make people more open-minded yeah that's a problem to solve but how we get there and maybe this is why it works so well how we get there might not be a direct oh i have an answer for this you know because some of our problems are very difficult and very intractable

so so i think you need a little bit of both you need to be able to go well i don't know how about we try this you know experiential thing how about we we do something um you know uh that's kind of out there and um yeah i don't know i don't know if i would have gotten to some of the quote data that we had talked about earlier without having that sense of exploratory stuff um yeah i don't know if i would have gotten there interesting so i i've i feel like i'm just fascinated by this idea of like research showing that games and stories can really impact outcomes and it seems like in your classes right you're teaching students to do that deliberately i'm gonna make a game about reproductive rights i'm gonna make a game um you know that impacts you know x thing in a person a lot of hobby games and hobby gamers will say that games are just for fun oh i just had a really good idea for a mechanism and i you know popped the theme on there and it's there for my relaxation and enjoyment um so i think a lot of games claim to not be there for any particular purpose other than to be enjoyed do they still say something yes can there ever be a game that is just a game no games carry games carry meaning in them whether the designer intends that meaning or not right that that is the responsibility of a designer to look at it with open eyes um let's just talk

about chess okay everybody that's something that everybody's seen played or whatever right okay chess oh it's just a game it's like two sides it's like a war game whatever i'm gonna win a strategy yeah okay well let's unpack it some more right chess has a social hierarchy built into it it has a royal family it has servants of the royal family and advisors right it has the plebeians the everyday people the pawns and they're less valued right there's a lot of them and they're less valued they're expendable um in and the the most important thing is to save the the ruler and not the people um conflicts have two sides and one side um uh is oh there's only one winner there's only going to be one winner one outcome and um that total annihilation is fine uh i mean there's a lot of stuff packed into that game if you just unpack it you know um it's easier to do because psychological distance it's easy to do because it's an old game and it's like oh yeah and i didn't make it so can you do that with your own games can you look at a game that you've made or you love to play and can you pull out its values and

can you can you it doesn't mean you have to throw all you have to burn all your games or anything if they have a problematic thing in them but it's good to know um with open eyes about the kind of structures and assumptions made around you so that we can actually be aware of them we can talk about them and we can change them yeah i think that also takes away the opportunity to say well i just wasn't thinking about it i didn't think it was a big deal i just did what i felt like doing is that so wrong and i mean it's not wrong i guess but you should be thinking about everything that you say has i mean everything that you make says something about you and and what you think and how you see the world right right and also i mean you don't i i don't think anyone uh well i shouldn't say that but i a majority of designers would would not want their work to do harm right so i think that um that that's something we just have to kind of look at and and and educate designers to to to be to have a critical eye yes and i guess my uh my last hard question it's not really hard uh is that um in i guess in a world where we know that games could do harm and where we can deliberately design them in an attempt to do good um you know is that is there anything about that that is manipulative

especially if you're taking something like your zombie game right that you want to have outcomes you want to create outcomes that impact how people understand disease and make them want to do certain things and you knew that when you made the game is there anything about that that is i guess taking away somebody else's consent or that is it's an interesting question yeah what's the ethical line between what you know about the thing that you're sharing and how much you share about that it is an ethical question and it comes up of course beyond games that's coming up right now and all the fake news stuff like like and all the you know um there's just so many sources that are that are uh questionable you know like the whole idea that the butterfly preserve in texas had to be shut down because of um conspiracy theories about a butterfly preserve is a very sad very sad thing you know so um so yes i it's it's an interesting question you know at what point is something propaganda and kind of manipulative and at one point is it um is it uh kind of doing good as a kind of wholesome thing in the world right and who gets to decide that those are open questions you know i don't think there's any we we haven't had cultural conversations about that you know they're in motion pictures they

used to have these committees you know where they would do something rated r and what but they didn't talk about you know political propaganda or ideology or these kind of like um and then increasingly increasingly polarized world we probably need to have more conversations and limitations about about that kind of stuff but there's a other side to this right if people are consciously designing games to you know make people open-minded and and you know who who am i to actually think that that's a good thing and and what is my definition of open-minded and my science behind it and so therefore should i not do it and therefore we have no social like none of us are really allowed to engage in social change because we would be presuming that other people um would benefit or share from us so these are it's you know they're in a time when we kind of want an answer and we want to say yes that's good no that's good you have no right to do this you have the right to do this this is this is a very difficult kind of conversation because we don't really have um a consensus about about that now we're totally fine with buying a whole bunch of stuff from commercial companies that are intentionally designed to have us buy more and use more resources and materials and forced obsolescence so we have to buy another one and we're you know we don't we don't really protest that stuff as much as we might want to

yeah and then we eat food that is designed to be addictive and to make us want more food yes and video games um you know there have been plenty of examples of video game designers having to work with um uh gambling uh experts to keep people hooked on games longer i mean it's a huge controversy and behind the scenes and some of the big game companies about um keeping people hooked on your game and and uh gaming and addiction and you know it's i've had friends you know put something out and then they're like is it ethical that this person just spent 62 hours non-stop playing and spent uh 200 000 in my game like i don't feel good about that even though it's great that they spent a lot of money i don't feel good about what i just put out in the world you know like there are lots of lots of questions that that we um have to have conversations about which is why it's great to have um one with you yes and i very much appreciated this conversation so a couple fun softies towards the end what are you playing right now for fun hardest question of the interview actually i've been playing our own my phantom ink i kind of can't get enough of that game it's you know it's great if you make a game that you love so much you just want to play it a lot so in fact every party i'm playing that and i normally don't force my games upon other people unwillingly phantom inc totally no problem and of course because we're running a

kickstarter campaign i've been playing retrograde die on tabletopia like virtual hands shaking those virtual die left and right so i've been playing a lot of that um so it's for fun too so it's good that you like what you make it's good definitely and then uh for people who are curious about your work where can you be found online and don't worry i'll be putting some links in the show notes oh yeah well so the my game companies resinim.com uh my research lab where you can find some of the research studies behind some of this conversation is at tilt factor.org and my general website for all things marry is maryflanigan.com i'm also on instagram critical play and twitter critical play excellent and i those of you here listening probably know this can be found anywhere as beyond solitaire thank you so much for watching or listening everybody leave us some likes some comments some questions and most of all happy gaming so

you

Progress saved