A Buyer's Guide For The Iron Rail Series: Irish Gauge, Ride the Rails & Iberian Gauge Review!
Transcript
hello everyone tally and farrell here from bolivia and welcome to our review of the beautiful iron rails series this is a series of three train games all about building railways in various geographical locations whilst incorporating high player interaction stock investment and route building in order you have irish gauge ride the rails and iberia engage now these games all existed in some form or other previously but capstone games have republished them with gorgeous new artwork from eno tool and new components as the iron rails series yep and we're immensely fond of this series but why do we love it so much well it has high interactivity they all have interesting unique mechanisms and to be honest they give you a full game experience in under an hour with a very simple rule teach as in each of the rules for each of these games is on a single a4 sheet of paper and they all play in under an hour so what you should know is that each of these games is for three to five players and in each game you will win by ending the game with the most money or the most money and the most valuable stocks now the reason we're doing this is because these are well received but there's three of them so it can be tough to know which should you get or if you have one you love it you want to get another one which one should you get do you need all three so we're going to go through we're going to review each
one quickly and then we're going to compare and contrast and hopefully find the right iron rails game for you in irish gauge you'll be auctioning for stock in the different companies and if you win an auction that stock will allow you to build track for the matching company you'll be aiming to build a railway network that connects to as many towns and cities as possible because eventually a player will call for dividends that player will draw three cubes out of a bag and the cities that have the matching colored cube will pay out if they have the proper connections but the problem is that on their turn a player can start an auction for a remaining stock in any company and companies pay out during dividends per share so if at the start of the game which is likely you're the only share in a company all the profits go to you but maybe you made that company a bit too profitable purple's looking good and now someone else buys a share or wins an auction for a share in your company now you get half as much money and they get the other half for doing none of the work so what are you gonna do to make up that loss well maybe you'll just buy in another company and you can see how this goes and how it gets more and more
savage as the game goes on the first word that comes to mind when we think about irish gauge is fun it's arguably the lightest of all three as there's much less mass and brain burn in the late game it's a great game to get out if you just want a bit of silly fun but also to have a tense and tight experience out of all three is also going to provide new players with the best experience in their first game the state of the board and which companies are profitable is fairly visual so any player can have a quick glance over the board and understand and know how to react there's a high level of player interactivity and the auction mechanic is a real highlight here as you get these wild bidding wars and a lot of tension ensues you'll be laughing and shouting because it's so cut throat but also kind of light and breezy at the same time but what might be our favorite part of irish gauge is how much of a sandbox it is despite a simple rule set i'm genuinely surprised by how much you can do within these rules and four actions for example it's incredibly funny to start an auction for a stock in a rival company with no intention of actually wanting that stock just to arbitrarily drive the price up so that person scared of losing their monopoly will overpay thus costing them more money than they would have got just not doing it that's devious but i also particularly love where you take cubes out of the bag and you make towns into cities
and if you do this at the right moment with the cube that maybe there's only two maybe there's only three left in the bag you can completely tank their railway because those cubes aren't going to be drawn anymore and there'll be no payout for them and when i first did that i did not make any friends classic pharaoh so well as well as fun the one word that also comes to mind when we think of irish gauge is dynamic and honestly we don't really have any criticisms the only thing that maybe people might not like is the fact that drawing dividend cubes is random so it could be that one player benefits more or it hurts another player disproportionately but honestly because you have this auction element and the fact that you're all in bidding wars and people are over bidding or under bidding we've never ever felt like it's affected the game in terms of who's won so with that we 100 recommend irish gauge and personally for me i think it's honestly one of my favorite games of all time of all time wow wow they're being high on the list i think yeah fair it's a good one the second game in the series which is ride the rouse is the odd one out
because it's by a different designer to the other two and as such it feels quite distinct here you have six rounds and at the beginning of each round each player will pick a stock in the available companies then everyone can lay tracks in the companies that they have stock of once the building phase is over everyone will get a chance to take a passenger to ride the rails and they'll move that passenger across the cities using any tracks they wish and your score for the amount of cities that the passenger passes through but any tracks that were used are going to pay out to anyone that has a share in that company now before we get on to some of the issues that we have with this game we'd firstly like to say that the theme is excellent and it really makes the mechanics pop it's really fun to take the little passengers and take them on a little trip and while the other players around the table are shouting ride the rails ride the rails it's also really satisfying to watch the progression as you collaboratively build these monster transcontinental rail networks with different loops and offshoots from small beginnings it's also particularly addictive and we really feel the urge to get it out again and again although perhaps that is just the drive to try and beat the game at its own game and what we mean by this is that you're going to have to overcome elements of the game to win it so when you do win it doesn't just feel like you beat the other players it feels like you beat the game itself and it's that much
sweeter to win and our biggest problem with this game is there's a lack of player agency because the decisions you make they aren't good or bad depending on you and what you do they're only good or bad depending on what the other players pick because the entire game is driven by the whims of other players and this means that you could be in a position where you're probably not going to win very early on through no fall of your own and not due to maliciousness of the other players either although that can happen as one example in the very first round you're given an arbitrary position a decision pick red or pick blue both the same doesn't matter but if you go first you pick blue the next three players pick red you're already screwed because what that means is that with three of them in red they're going to build a longer railway which means they're going to get more base money for moving the passengers further than you can and they're going to move passengers more times on the road railway which means more payouts because they all have shares in red so you're going to end the first round here on points they're going to end around here on points and there's already a big goal and it wasn't your fault and what is so frustrating is that picking these stocks is such a vital vital important decision in the game but there's no
you know it's not the decision isn't yours to stand by or regret it's the other players it's not down to you it doesn't matter what you do and that's really frustrating situation to be in and this kind of lack of agency also extends to other aspects because there are spaces that will give you payouts if you're the first person to put a train there or if you're the first to connect transcontinental railway you get payout as well but often who does these it isn't down to tactical acumen or strategic planning it's simple turn order it's who when their turn comes around is in the position to reach there you know and these are things that can literally be the difference between someone winning losing the game so with all that said ride the rails is our least favorite of the series and there are certainly things that we're not fans of here but we do still really enjoy playing this game like we're not going to get rid of our copy and for sure it's going to make it to the table many many more times but we'd recommend one of the other two over this one unless you already have one of the other two and you're looking for something that's more different but is still within the same world
now we come to the third game in the series iberian gauge and here the name of the game is cooperation so like any of these games you're going to start by buying stock but if you're the first person to buy stock in a company you get set its share price then other players can buy into it but they have to pay the price you've set or the current price because it will move up and down after everyone's happy or run out of money you will then lay track but the twist is you can only lay track as many times as there is shares in your company and each player who has that share controls where it goes so for example in orange you'd only be able to put down one from the starting position but the problem is you need to work together and have multiple people in companies because each round you really want your railway to be reaching a town or a city because if you don't the stock price starts full because you're building a route to nowhere thus you have to strike a balance between sharing stock in a company to allow you to build further with not allowing another player to get the majority of stocks in a shared company because for each share the value of it will be added to your final score and what makes things interesting is each company has funds they have to use in order to build track but you can also lease track from the other companies by paying them a fee in order to reach towns and cities that are further away so you can shuffle money between companies that you have a stake in in
order to bankroll your expansion iberian gauge is just as wonderful as irish gauge but this is more of a gamers game whereas irish gauge is almost approaching party game levels iberian is much more studious and mathematical and perhaps has the more interesting mechanisms setting a stock price for a company that you've set up and then trying to persuade others to invest with you is terrifically thematic and a cooperative aspect of working together especially when you co-own a company makes for some really great table talk you also get a really great sense of progression as you watch the share price in the companies that you've invested in go up and up over the course of the game so you're in the game feeling fulfilled no matter what happens and generally because of this cooperation iberian gage is the least harsh of the three here there aren't really any direct ways to hurt other players so it's one to get if you want the most friendly experience now the money is a big part of this game and another thing that we really love is the transfer of money between the companies it's loud obviously but somehow it's just hilarious because it feels naughty and illegal so you just have this edge to it and you can also just be rewarded for doing it or get a feeling of reward because if you can combo together different companies you have shares in you can feed them money to build longer tracks and then you're boosting the stock price up of all these companies
so it's good fun but the money is also pretty much our only criticism of the game because in this game all you're going to be doing is exchanging money between you and the bank you and the companies the companies and the companies and it's incredibly tedious and honestly i don't know if we'd get this to the table as often as the other ones if we weren't playing with our iron clays and using the paper money and the iron clay is still tedious but a little bit less tedious than the paper money but with that out of the way not being our only criticism we again 100 100 recommend iberian gauge and i think this is again a great pick there's not i think you prefer iberian gauge i prefer irish gauge yeah but there's really not much in it they're both excellent i can't really put my finger on why i prefer this one i just i just do but it is teeny tiny amounts in it full recommendation yeah why do we like these games so much well the first reason is that they occupy a novel space in our collection we really don't have anything that's quite like these games second is that they're just excellent examples of game design the short are simple they're easy to teach but they also provide a really full gaming experience very intense and interactive one and if we go through them irish gauge is the lightest probably the easiest to grasp on first play most party s because
of the auction mechanics but it's also quite harsh because you're usually undercutting the other players whatever you do ride the rails is the most straightforward in the terms of your goal but the complexity does spiral out as the game goes on and the decisions are quite difficult to make and it can be ap inducing right um iberian gauge is the most cooperative and friendly of all three but you're going to be collaborating a lot while trying to just get that edge over the other players we have no doubt that different people are going to like these games in these series for different reasons but honestly we don't think you could go wrong with any of them these are games that we intend to play over and over again with all different types of people that said farrell's favorite is irish gauge and for me i've been engaged just pips irish gauge as my favorite but not by much and maybe it's because it's the newest game in our collection so maybe it's just a bit more novel and time will tell if it still is my favorite ride the rails is the least favorite of both of us and it's probably the one we've seen generally the most negativity about but do you need all three well if you buy one and you really like it we do feel like they are different enough but kind of maintain that same feel to own them all so we don't think you'll regret it we obviously have all three and we're very very happy to do so and
we genuinely look forward to playing them all and best of all then you can have an iron rails night where you play them all together and we're definitely going to do that soon yeah so if you enjoyed this video we'd really really appreciate it if you could give us a thumbs up subscribe to our channel if you haven't done so already and please feel free to ask us any questions about the games in the comments or if you've played all three let us know what your favorite is and what you think of them all yeah and we better wrap this up because meg's not here because she's rebelling and now svensson's rebellion she's rebelling for she's really annoying all right all right well thank you for watching and we hope it was helpful see you bye