Skip to main content
Loading video...

When Do You Sell An Out of Print Game?

Transcript 18:29

Hey, I'm Alex from Board Game Co, and today I'm going to be talking about whether I'm selling my Marvel Champions collection. Or to be more specific, whether I'm selling particular parts of my Marvel Champions collection. There's a lot to go ahead and get in here. Let's start off with just some background over here. Right now, I'm currently at UKGE, UK Games Expo. I'm sitting here in my hotel room trying to set up the light as best as possible. Hopefully the mic and audio are pretty decent. We shall see. But I try to put up a bunch of videos on the channel on a regular basis, which means if I'm gone for a week and a half, which I am gone. I you know, this travel time, there's UKGE, I'm going to a Gamefound to Poland shortly after, then back home. So I'm going to be gone for a while, which means you can expect some videos on the road. Also, the fun fact of the way I run my channel means you may not know when those videos show up. They might show up 17 months in the future or 2 months in the future or a week from now. I don't really know. I just film them and they go up when they go up. Well, unless they're time sensitive, then they go up sooner than they go up. Well, they don't go up sooner than they go up. That'd be crazy.

They go up shortly after they go up. Well, they go up when they go up, but they go up shortly after I film them, which is what I mean to say. Anyways, by the way, if you're new to the channel, this is the kind of craziness and chaos you can expect to see. And if you're not new to the channel, thanks for joining us in this um on the on the go video. But anyways, Marvel Champions. Marvel Champions is a phenomenal game. I love Marvel Champions. I have no intention of getting rid of my entire collection, but I found myself the other day tempted to sell a few particular games from my collection. Because I happen to be browsing Facebook and I saw a conversation around I believe it was Sinister Motives if I'm not mistaken. Somebody was saying, "Hey, does anyone know anyone selling their copy of Sinister Motives?" Apparently it's incredibly expensive and rare and out of print and they don't want to shell out an arm and a leg for it. Curious person that I am, first I went and checked my shelf because I particularly I have a lot of Marvel Champions. I have nearly everything Marvel Champions because I keep buying Marvel Champions because I love Marvel Champions. I've also said many times in the channel that for every four expansions I buy, I probably play it once. I pull it out every few months and the expansions come out faster than that, which means I I keep spending more on a a than I should, but I keep doing so because of the fact that I do know that something that gets harder to get these expansions, so it's worth getting them now while I can. And I don't usually sell things. In fact, very, very, very rarely have I I mean and I when I say very rarely, I don't know if I've ever done it. I'd have to look through like my history. I don't think I've ever sold something because it was rare. I sell things when I'm ready to move on from them. Sometimes they're rare, sometimes they're not, but I don't sell things when they just because they're rare, just because they're expensive. I have always said to myself

I've always justified this with the logic that to me, my board game collection is the one leeway I give myself in life. I don't spend money on a ton of fancy things. I don't have fancy cars. I don't have fancy watches. I don't have What are other fancy things people do? I don't know. I don't know. I don't do drugs. I I don't drink a lot. I I have very few vices in life. I have I have my board games. That's my single biggest vice. My entire video collection on Steam, my entire video game collection, I buy nearly everything when it's on sale for like seven bucks. I I mean, the amount I spend on board games in my most expensive year is probably more than I spent on video games in my entire life. My single greatest vice is board games. But that means that I also allow myself the leeway of I don't try to min-max board games the way I min-max everything. Well, it's not entirely true. I do try to min-max board games the way I min-max everything in my life, but I but I don't min-max the justification of can I own that board game. And this also applies to out of print things.

Just because something is expensive doesn't mean I turn around and sell it. I want board games in my life. I don't try to sit there and say, "Should I sell this because it's a $400 out of print game and I need to go ahead and get it?" But then I checked up the price for Sinister Motives. And here's the problem. There's two problems, a combination of twofold that that work together, threefold actually, technically. First is that all those Marvel Champions games that I have, most of the time they integrate into my collection. I say most of the time cuz I do have a few I have a few unopened packs here and there, but the general packs, if I buy Doctor Strange, Captain America, whatever particular pack there is, it usually gets opened and put into the rest of my collection. Some of them I've played with, some of them I haven't, but it gets put into the big box of cards. Uh again, aside from a few packs here and there, which I I do have to go through and see which ones are the rare ones. But the ones that I haven't are the bigger boxes. Those bigger boxes, those campaign expansions, those are for the most part in shrink. I haven't really played with a lot of those cuz I haven't really incorporated the campaign expansions for Marvel Champions. And so my Sinister Motives is in shrink.

And so then I went and looked at the price, and the price is like $400. They go for like roughly $400 for an in-shrink Sinister Motives. The price point on it seems insane, and still that wouldn't be enough to tempt me, except I've had it for years and I've never opened it. This is a unpay un- unplayed cardboard box on my shelf with a bunch of cards in it that is apparently worth $400. And that that tempted me. And it also is the reason for this video. Because I think it's an interesting conversation. What's the price point at which you choose to get rid of something you like because it's worth it, because there's a demand for it. Also, so at this point in the video, I should warn you that there's a random pause in the video, it might be because my roommate walks in, and so if I pause it at some point, it's because uh he interrupted my video. How dare he? He should have known I was filming. We'll see if that happens. If there's no cut, then that didn't happen. But anyways, what is the price point for you personally? What is the price point at which you get rid of something because the amount of money it's worth is so tempting? Because I've had to ask myself that question, and it kind of led into a little bit of game theory as far as the way I tend to approach these conversations. And honestly, the very nature of why FOMO exists in our industry, because FOMO FOMO exists in our industry. It is a key word terminology we all grow to love, hate, more hate than love, but we recognize its presence in the space we're in, particularly in crowdfunding, but honestly in all aspects of the board game industry. Heck, I'm at a convention right now. When you go to a convention and you buy the newest, latest, hottest, greatest, and you pay a premium and stand in line for 3 hours, it's often, not always, driven partially by FOMO, fear of missing out. And so here is my

game theory calculator that I apply to a lot of areas in my life, and I don't know how common this is. I'm sure there's I'm sure true game theory experts I'm sure if I spent 2 minutes Googling this I could tell you the actual terminologies here, but I tend to focus on loss aversion above all. What do I mean by that? I mean that when I'm looking at the variable outcomes that are in life, I tend to try to pursue the outcomes that are the least likely to have the worst outcome that I'm trying to avoid. In other words, I am not seeking the best outcome. I don't look at a bunch of options and choices and how things can play out and say, "What is the best possible option? Let me pursue that." Instead, I look at what is the worst possible option? How can I avoid that? Now, sometimes this is a conscious thought process that I go through. Other times it's subliminal. It's in the back of my head. It's subconscious. Uh conscious versus subconscious. Sometimes it's subconscious in the way I just approach something and then choose, and then later if I'm thinking through how I got there, I'll realize that it is loss aversion. Other times, I just know this.

A great example of loss aversion is exactly what I talked about, FOMO. When we approach things from a FOMO perspective, a fear of missing out. When you back that game on crowdfunding that you know is probably going to be cheaper down the road. You can probably get that exact same thing either used from somebody at a good price point or just most if not all of the extras and all that just by paying for it down the road. Why do we not do that? Sometimes we do, sometimes we don't. Sometimes we can hold back, sometimes we can't. And a good deal of that does come that come down to that loss aversion. When you're looking at the variable outcomes in front of you, when there's that game, let's call it I'm looking for random word in this hotel and we have the word hopeless, okay? That's the way it should have begun, but it's hopeless. It's a quote on a picture. I don't know why. But, hopeless. There's a cool game that just came out. It's on crowdfunding. It's called hopeless. It's a journey about despair, obviously. It's called hopeless. You go ahead and you back it even though you know there's a decent chance it'll show up at retail. And the reason you and and at a better price point or whatever, insert all the various usual things. And a big part of the reason you do so is because when you're weighing up your possible outcomes, one possible outcome is you buy the game now on crowdfunding and it is slightly cheaper down the road. That is a possible outcome. When you're looking at those, you're like, "Okay, I The outcome in question is that I bought it and I paid more than I should have."

But the other possible outcome is I don't buy it because I'm hoping to get it cheaper and it's not available and I can't get my hands on it. For many people, that is the worst possible outcome and it's the loss aversion that you are seeking to, well, avert. Hence, the terminology. You're looking at the possible outcomes on the table and you're trying to figure out what is the worst possible scenario. Scenario one, I buy it on crowdfunding and it's the best price point. That's a great scenario. But are you seeking that price point? Are you seeking that that that scenario? Scenario two, you buy it on crowdfunding and it's not the best price point. You could have got it cheaper down the road. Scenario three, you get it on crowdfunding and you could get it down the road but slightly more expensive. Scenario four, you get it on crowdfunding and it turns out you can't get it down the road at all. Crowdfunding was your only option the here and now. You are trying to avoid scenario four, the worst possible option, and so you pay a bit of a premium even though it's not always worth it. And you'll notice that this makes sense with the way we pursue our actions because very often we don't make that choice. We decide to wait for it to be cheaper because that scenario four might not be as big a deal. This particular game, let's choose another word, the word begun. The begun, okay, it's another game. It's called begun. It's about beginnings, hence the name. That other game, the begun, you choose not to buy on crowdfunding because you'd rather get it cheaper at retail. Because in that particular scenario, the potential option in which you never get it at all is not the end of the world. You are not as invested in begun as you are in Hopeless. And so, begun, you're willing to have that option occur. So, paying more for the game than you should have is the loss aversion scenario. It's the scenario you

are trying to avoid. Again, thinking through these hypothetical scenarios, are you trying to avoid a scenario or are you trying to seek a scenario? That's kind of the question you want to ask yourself. Seeking a scenario is figuring out which opportunity is the one you want to happen, and avoiding scenario is trying to figure out what decisions you have to make to avoid the worst possible scenario. Going back to Marvel Champions, by the way. Going back over here to this to this thing about Marvel Champions, and also what decision I'm going to end up making around my Marvel Champions collection. There's different options on the table here. There's a lot. I'm not going to try to play out every single option, but I'll play out the main options that I thought of. Scenario one. Scenario one is that I hold onto Marvel Champions. Let's just use In this example, we'll just use Sinister Motives. We won't talk about the rest of them, but this applies to any of the rare out of print content that I have in my collection. And again, I should note, as a background to all this decision space, I love Marvel Champions. I am not getting rid of the bulk of my Marvel Champions, but the question is specifically around specific rare packs, in which getting rid of those rare packs wouldn't negatively impact my overall gameplay experience.

It would negatively impact my sense of completionist that I want to have it. That I just want to have that thing. So, going back to the scenarios, the hypothetical scenario. Scenario one, I hold onto Sinister Motives, and it stays as a rare out of print option. That is option one. Okay, I can always sell it down the road if that's the case. That's a possibility. But, if it just stays at its current value. Scenario two, I hold onto Marvel Champions, and it actually goes up in value. That's probably the scenario that I want the most. In theory, in theory I think it's the one I want the most. It's a little hard to think it through, but if I could hold onto Marvel Champions, and it turns out that 3 years from now it's actually going to be going for $800 because people want it all, and they never reprinted and it's $800, just goes up in value. That is the most sought-after scenario. Keep in mind that when I go through my options, I don't think I'll be picking based on the sought-after scenario.

Scenario three, I get rid of Marvel Champions, and then I can go ahead and get back if they reprint it down the road. Okay, so scenario three is I sell my Marvel Champions, I sell it for $400, whatever it's going for, and then eventually, hopefully, Fantasy Flight, because of the demand, they hopefully reprint it and I get it back. Okay? Then I can go ahead and buy it for 30 bucks, 40 bucks, whatever it was, and I go ahead and add it back to my collection. I made $360. That also That's probably the most the the the scenario I want the most actually when I think about it, because the chances of going up in value is tempting. I also am a completionist at heart, and I want Sinister Motives in my collection. I've heard good things about it. I heard it's a really good expansion. I haven't been playing it, but I heard it's a really good expansion. So, that would really be an ideal scenario. Scenario four, I sell Marvel Champions: Sinister Motives, and it never goes down in price. I can always buy it down the road for $400. I will never do that, by the way, which is part of my logic, as well, where I would never buy it for $400. So, why shouldn't I sell it for $400? Completionist or not, I think there's like three Marvel Champions packs I don't have. I have not paid the premium to get those. I've always been like, "Hey, I'll check, and if they're ever in print, I'll buy them.

I'll add them. But if they're out of print, they're out of print. It is what it is. I'm not going on eBay and paying through the nose to get them." So, again, scenario four is I sell it. It doesn't go down in price. And here's scenario five. Here's the kicker and the reason for why I decided that I will, in fact, be selling the expensive stuff in my Marvel Champions collection. Scenario five is I hold onto it. I do not sell it and it goes down in price. They reprint it. It's now back to being $40, and I never sold that $400 box of cards while I could have, even though I would have been then able to get it back anyway at a lower price point. When I think of loss aversion, when I think of the idea of the the the angle I want to most avoid, the situation I want the least to happen, that is the situation I want the least to happen.

Keeping in mind, I don't have control over the various variables here. Well, I have control over one variable. Do I sell it? Do I not? The market price for it, I don't have control over. Fantasy Flight's decision to reprint it or not, I don't have control over. I only have control whether I sell it or don't sell it. And in all those scenarios, if I want to avoid the scenario I dislike the most, which again is that I hold on to it, I don't sell it while people want it for $400, and then a month from now, or heck, a year from now, 2 years from now, whenever it is, they reprint it and I could have bought it back, that's the one where I'm kicking myself thinking, "Why couldn't you just hopped on eBay, taken the 10 minutes, and gone ahead and sold it, only to get it back?" And that's why I'll be selling Marvel Champions Sinister Motives and the other rare stuff, because I tend to operate from a place of loss aversion.

Look through all the scenarios that can possibly happen to a thing, and try to avoid the worst possible outcome. Now, life is not always so simple. It's not always as cut and dry in that. Very often you have to even weigh the differences between those versions. There's also statistics and odds and all these other things. If loss aversion, if the thing you're trying to avoid the most is very, very unlikely to happen, you have to factor those things into your decision trees. All the decision trees we make, subconscious and conscious, we do have to think through all the things. What outcomes do we have control over? What are the statistical likelihood of different options? How far is the gap from the worst option to the second worst option? What is the spread of positive outcomes versus negative outcomes? We do have to look at everything holistically. And the goal of this video is not to do a what are every single nooks and crannies of every single decision you'd ever encounter.

The goal of this video is I thought it was an interesting conversation. I think it is interesting what prompts you to let go of something. I also should note, by the way, that part of my decision tree, a huge part of it, and the reason this is possibly the first time I'm considering selling something that is out of print, even though I want it, is because I haven't opened the box in 4 years, or whenever I got Sinister Motives. I got it whenever it came out, I don't know, I'd have to go check it out, but I haven't opened the box. I've played Marvel Champions, I haven't played those specific expansions. A good example of this is Doctor Strange is apparently also a very sought out after rare pack. I've played Doctor Strange multiple times. I like him as a hero. I am not going to get rid of him. All of those outcomes and those loss versions and all those decision bases, they all play into how do I go from decisions to making decisions. And for me, I'm still going to give myself that leeway that if something is part of my board game collection, I'm not going to try to min-max the hell out of every single aspect of value added and how to get the most money out of something.

Life is about more than money, which is always a privileged thing to say and usually people who aren't having trouble paying the bills are able to say that the most. But thankfully, I don't have a problem paying the bills. This is not a question of having to sell my board game collection to pay for a car repair, which is something that I've I've seen people have to do. I know people who have anything from Magic the Gathering rare cards, Pokémon rare cards, entire board game collections worth tons of money and I've seen people have to go through the process of choosing to sell those things because a rainy day finally happened. Part of the justification of why I haven't sold things like this in the past is that hey, my board game collection to a certain extent is an asset. It's a part of my rainy day fund. If things go south, if I lose all jobs, if YouTube shuts down, if the various things happen in life that shouldn't happen, I I or just if enough expenses accumulate that I just have to make hard decisions, I've also justified it that way. I shouldn't sell it today. I'll keep it for the future so I can sell it one other day.

But looking at this particular scenario, when I look up at all the factors, the the tolerance between different options, the likelihood of different options, uh how much I want to avoid one versus pursue another, and again, the biggest thing for me, the background of it all is that this is a game that I'm not playing anyway, or at least this expansion is an expansion I'm not playing anyway. All of that leads me to the decision. And so my question to you, what's your line in the sand? What's a game or something like let's focus on games, but honestly, if you want to add any hobby that you're passionate about in any way, what is something that you have either sold because the value is high enough that you sold it despite wanting it? This is specifically about something you want. If you sold it because you didn't care or it's always about prospecting and all that, I don't care. I've I've sold things that were worth stuff because I was getting rid of it. This is specifically about what is something that you have wanted for yourself but you sold because the value was high enough. And or what is something that you have not done so but been tempted to do so and why not? I'd love to hear from you. This is a good time to remember that this channel is sponsored by All Play. If you want to go ahead and uh put all that money that you're getting from selling those incredibly rare things towards a board game table which will add daily value to your life. If you don't already have one, I do recommend board game tables by the way. Whether you get it from All Play or anyone else, I think a board game table is a worthwhile investment for those of us who can justify that investment of course, but it's something that can add value to your day-to-day play. Yes, it's more expensive than any one board game, but it's also something that enhances every single board game that you try to table. All Play is a channel sponsor. You can go to allplay.com and find a variety of board

game tables at a variety of price points depending on what you're looking for. In any case, until next time, I'm Alex Radcliffe from Board Game Co talking to you from UKGE which also means you know when this is filmed because I have no idea when this video goes up. And as always, I hope you have a good one.

Progress saved