Is Arcs by Leder Games the BEST GAME of 2024 . . . as Shut up & Sit Down claims? | Unboxing & Chat
Transcript
hello welcome to quacko thank you for being here today I am finally opening up my pledged copy of arcs from leader gains now I like you have watched a pile of reviews come in specifically of course the most recent shut up and sit down review saying and declaring that arcs is the best game of 2024 I have a few questions and a few concerns regarding that review and my relationship to it but one thing is undeniable I have to get this game played and we host a Tuesday night game night here at the calop studio and so uh tomorrow seems like the perfect chance for me to review the rule book get this game set up and finally get it to the table it plays two to four players it looks like which means we'll have a full cast and crew who knows we might even get multiple plays in depending on how quick it plays and how many people show up and want to give it a swing why am I skeptical though and what is arcs for any of you that don't know ARS was one of the last kickstarters done by leader games the uh creators of a lovely game called root which I am sure you all at this point are very familiar with root is one of the 10 games that I want to obsess over that I'm diving into it is the next game that Dennis and I will be featuring here on the channel when he comes back up to film now I pledged for for the entirety of this Kickstarter but
I was even skeptical at the time I mean the TTS and the print and play were available I'm not sure if it was on TTS I know the print and play was available at the time and even back then arcs was compelling to me but was confusing in a few ways it deals with a space area control style system with asymmetric player Powers being driven from the cards that you've actually built up and the Hand of cards that you've drafted in order to take your actions it has dual action cards that not only give you uh the power or the uh strength of the action you're going to be taking but also determine the number of actions you're going to take in a round and granted I haven't played this yet but the trick taking combined with area control combined with Space theme and the uh kind of oath style campaign mechanic that was introduced here with the little additional expansion made me cautious of the game to say the least I didn't love the final version of oath even though the Prototype was in my mind awesome but when it came to the actual gameplay experience at least the three-player game plays that we played it didn't seem to fit with my game group same thing's been true for a lot of leader games properties I've loved them but they haven't stuck around vast is one of those that is really cool to explore and play but hasn't had the staying power in my collection that I would have liked to see it have had or that I would have predicted it would have had back when we were first exploring it root is really the only one
that has yet to be challenged that has a lot of games that have been compared to it but hasn't really uh came off or fallen off of that hierarchy that it built it kind of in a lot of ways is a definer of a genre of asymmetric games and player Powers now arcs comes in as a challenger to that and shens sit down presented it as the the best of all of these versions without the compromises that games like oath made meaning that even average Gamers Gamers that aren't looking for theme and integration could get a lot out of this whereas oath was maybe more for a niche Community let's read the flavor text let's dive into the game a little bit let's go ahead and open it up here on camera and let me tell you about why I don't think or I don't know based off of uh what previous knowledge of how I respond and how I engage with games and how I engage with other reviewers in the community why I don't know that this will be a game that fits me very well chaos rains movements Bloom loud like desert flowers promising safety Liberation communion or simply the honor of Glorious deaths in the struggle what will you promise the blight reach expansion adds an innovation Innovative campaign to arcs over three game trill over a three Game tril trilogy players will guide their factions through the Epic science fiction Saga where every choice matters is this an
expansion really wait so this is the expansion I didn't even look at the front of it conflict and collapse in the rig wow okay so this is arcs and this is the expansion I thought this was the core game but I guess it makes sense for the size of the game boxes that exist but that's actually really interesting and really compelling I'm surprised they went with such a big box expansion I understand I mean I guess it fits the profile that oath did as well but um this sitting on this shelf or sitting in the store next to root well has them naturally match up that seems like a big bite to chew and maybe a big box to sell I wonder if I would have preferred to see maybe two smaller boxes like this like they've done for root but I'm not sure wait before I pop this off I do want to read the flavor text anyway conflict and collapse in the reach long ago the reach thrived but our ancestors failed us and I fear we're no better as we wrestle over the Galaxy's Edge can we break the cycle can we build something new it's a sharp sci-fi strategy G strategy game for two to four players set in a dark yet silly Universe ready yourselves for dramatic twists and turns as you launch into the galactic struggle seize the initiative declare Ambitions crush your foes each game contains hundreds of Wooden Ships and agents 18 custom engraved dice a beautiful six panel board and tons of cards with over 60 pieces of unique art
now of course Arts by Kyle faren here the classic leader games art they really have uh set the standard for maybe that style we have the rule book here they usually do a very good job with their rule book they usually are are built out well even though their games are complex and uh sometimes a little bit hard to table and can be confusing um they do a very good job with player AIDS and with graphics and with design we have our punch board here good punch board thick cardboard very happy with all of that we have our main map board this is going to be the game board that we're going to be playing on uh and you can go ahead and see kind of how it's built out this is going to be the main kind of central zone and then outside here all the planets that will'll be able to conquer control possibly exploit for resource and harvest we're going to be playing cards in order to build our infrastructure to move around these areas and to surpass other players this is a victory Point driven and scoring game uh which I believe the core system being do as good as you can that's usually how a lot of these work we have our player boards we have the three players blue red yellow and white and of course course piles and piles of very nice stuff so we have all of our ships that are going to be going out with these very unique design for the ships they look uh kind of like big Freighters big
freight ships but they also have this galaxy kind of Star Wars Cruiser usage to them we have piles of dice which dice is a uh conflicting item in many board games but um we see it in play both in oath and in root and I don't think many people have found that the luck involved in dice takes away from the Strategic gameplay in a lot of leader games games we have oh I don't I think this might be the first player Mark some tracking cubes to uh Orient us on the game board for our scoring and for our positioning we have all of our little characters our little meeples although that's now a licensed word apparently so I can't claim that leader games is calling their pieces meeples and we have a pack of cards a pretty light haul overall for the core game so these are going to be the cards that drive uh not only your actions uh but also your strength of your actions these are going to be the trick- taking cards and they have two corresponding locations on them you have the number and you have the actions underneath so a very very strong card but with a limited number of actions that you can take um again I think you'll be getting a wide mix of these you might be even creating a can we have our starting setup here and we have all of our player powers and abilities now unlike root you're not going to be playing various different uh factions it's going to be a little bit closer to oath where um as you play the
game the different powers and abilities and characters that you've recruited Into Your Arsenal are going to be the things that change up and make your gameplay experience more uh varied and more asymmetric I do think it's a small it's kind of a narrow amount of cards we have events that can happen here and uh more technology more powers and more abilities I would like I would like to see a bigger deck but then again that's kind of what the expansion is for I am sure and then I believe these are our leaders um they're also going to have their own buildout which is going to show kind of their starting power starting cards factions that they're uh you know good with I think that's how this works I'm not entirely sure I should do a bit more research and we can tell by opening this up and seeing what the game says yeah leader cards action cards Guild Vox and lore initiative marker so that big towering device is going to be initiative marker and we have our main game board I'm not seeing a lot of lore built out through this which isn't uncommon for leader games I mean typically there isn't so much lore built into games it's usually more of an experiential play however I do like the little bits of flavor text that you find every now and then like for instance I would like to see each one of these have like their artwork on the back or a little bit of flavor text on the back or something giving me uh a better sense a better theme of who we are and the game that we're actually playing that might be something we'll find over here in the
expansion let's go ahead and pop open the expansion because I'm absolutely going to be playing with it now leave a comment down below should I play core game and not the expansion to start or should I start by integrating the blighted reach expansion now the game might also have its own suggestions as to the correct way to play so we'll look into them well lots of different tile trays meaning the game is going to be changing as you play it the blighted reach expansion we have additional rules here so little player aids for people to reference uh looks like we have a campaign log and campaign cards we have various different looks like tracking boards Flagship boards lots and lots of punch board and I don't want to pull all of these out cuz I don't know what they do so I don't know that it matters looks like we're introducing flagships which are going to be big ones and castles or keep so that means our location on the board just like an oath might change from game to game and as we establish dominance in area will'll either start off stronger or weaker depending on how we flow into the next game cycle we have lots and lots of cards and again I don't want to open all of these because I don't want to you know throw off the flow of the game I'll pop them after I've read the rule book and get a sense of exactly how they play looks like we have room for seved cards in here um but we don't have sleeves I don't know if I failed to order sleeves or I missed out on that somewhere and it looks like we have a way I'm getting a call from my wife
looks like we have a way to save our cards I'll go ahead and answer Shar you're on speaker phone on camera I'm currently filming what's up oh I'm sorry I didn't really you were filming I'm opening up arcs all right a good unboxing okay my my Bose my Bose speaker interrupted it said call from Shira Anderson I'm sorry okay I'll call you back in a second yep bye bye all right that's her see okay looks like we have trays that can save the game from from game state to game State I don't know it says that it's played over a three campaign or a three three story arc I'm not sure if that's intended to be three separate gaming sessions or if this would be something you'd prefer to play with one longer sitdown kind of like a Twilight Imperium style night where you just committed to playing the blighted reach and that's kind of the approach you're taking I find in terms of my preference would be that longer big dedicated game gaming session cuzz how often is it that you're going to be able to get people back consistently then again keep in mind if you have a consistent game group it is also hard to get people arranged and organized for a long extended game session as well looks like there's a story that we go through here there's a campaign there's the Empire events it so
it looks like this is going to be kind of a expansive experiential storytelling game we have our Miniatures pack and we have our leaders and lore pack so this might be what I'm looking for when it comes to a little bit more flavor text so let me talk a little bit about why I'm skeptical based on the reviews that have come out I mean lots of people have been talking about this game lots of people have been saying it is excellent I believe them I believe that this game is fantastic I mean leader games has consistently put out solid playable well recognized games in the space However the fact that shut up and sit down has put out a glowing review of arcs does make me more skeptical as to whether or not this game is going to fit my personal gaming tastes historically from the point I entered the hobby before I even started quackalope I made a lot of purchasing decisions based off of shut up and sit down and I found consistently that the games that they liked the most I tended to disagree with and the games that they kind of panned in their reviews root being one of those initial games that they said was wonderful and magical but didn't have the staying power without more uh faction being introduced constantly I tend to disagree with I mean Kingdom Death they didn't get into the depth and the meat of the game that I would have liked to see same thing again with root but arcs they're saying is a masterpiece is a magnific magnificent game is the best game to come out in 2024 and we're halfway
through 2024 so there's been a chance to explore quite a few titles so far I'm just not sure I don't typically agree with their verdict and it's not that I think ARS is going to be a bad game I'm just curious as to the gaming group and the gaming environment I have now and the way that I tend to explore games if this will be one that will actually fit and stay in my collection or one that we play we do a review of and we end up moving on fast going back to the Classic route which we love and adore it's a challenge it's definitely a a big question it's a big puzzle that we need to approach they did say this plays excellently at two-player which for me might be the Saving Grace because rout at two- player hasn't always been the most compelling puzzle I certainly like it more at four five and six players okay we have more leaders here which is fine I'm just going to mix these into the core main game I'm not seeing a lot of War though I mean this expansion is supposed to be the leaders and lore pack explore unique tricky strategies with the base game with these new leaders and add a twist with both base game and campaign game with new lore I guess these are called Lore cards there story cards that get mixed into the core game but again I would have liked to see a bit more flavor text A A bit more expansion on the world that we're exploring not just based off the Sci-Fi knowledge that I have and the art the beautiful art that Kyle faren has done would have liked to see a little bit more of an in-depth lore dive similar to what mine clash games does
for well all of their titles being said I do get it if you leave things as an open mystery without defining and uh diagnosing all the lore you might uh give people a more an experience that fits their tastes a little bit better finally we have the Miniatures pack so I am never a big fan of Miniatures over the actual wooden meele pieces I backed everything I just did the full pledge I do like these castles quite a lot the wash is the wash needs to be redone um especially on the yellow here the blue looks okay it could have a little bit more depth in the creases and the red is it's just very very messy I'm not impressed at all with the wash on this but I do like these Miniatures I don't think though that I like them more than I like the abstract nles the ships look very nice the wash is is again it's very splotchy it's very splotchy and very messy purple stands out well uh these little figurines the little meeples that we have they look good I don't think the Miniatures pack is going to be for me I would love to hear your opinions for me I like wood I like the bright vibrant colors I like how clean and pristine they make the board game and unless we're doing something like a Dungeon Crawl a Gloom Haven style game a oathsworn I don't
find that adding Miniatures especially like washed Miniatures change or enhance the game experience more than adding wooden components in fact more often than not I will go for really nice well-made wooden components with bright vibrant colors over something like this little Miniatures pack so this would be something that I'm not interested in probably didn't need to purchase fairly disappointed by when it comes to the wash the models look decent but I think they should really probably be stripped and rewashed to make them less blotchy uh and the game overall I'm compelled by I'm going to be playing it tomorrow so hopefully this week I'll have a little quick First Impressions dive into it maybe do some game play uh I do wish there was a solo mode available there isn't so if this is big on our list maybe we split our time next time Dennis comes up with a three-part campaign of the blighted reach and a lot of game plays of root maybe we'll just make it a leader game Extravaganza we'll see either way thank you for watching thank you for being here let me know have you did you buy arcs did you back it did you back it with the expansion have you played it yet do you like it do you agree with SH it down or like me do you find that your taste in your gaming group often times while their reviews are excellent and very entertaining I usually use them as a reference for what I won't like more than what I will either way whatever the case whatever you do remember to do the important thing drink drink more tea drink in just in general it's good for you hydrates you a little bit of caffeine has a calming
effect good either way we'll see you next time bye